State of Rajasthan v. Asharam @ Ashumal
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 383; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 1
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice M.M. Sundresh Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice Directing Summoning and Recording of Evidence of One Dcp
- Decided
- 17 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1156/2023
- Sections
- 391, 311, 1, 161, 164, 162
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1[2023] 4 S.C.R. 1
STATE OF RAJASTHAN
v.
ASHARAM @ ASHUMAL (Criminal Appeal No. 1156 of 2023)
APRIL 17, 2023
[SANJIV KHANNA AND M. M. SUNDRESH, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.391 – High Court allowed the application filed by the respondent u/s.391 of Cr.P.C., directing summoning and recording of evidence of one DCP, who wrote a book “Gunning for the Godman:The True story behind Asaram Bapu’s conviction” – In the said book, DCP disclosed that he had recorded a video of the scene of the crime (i.e. Kutiya) on his mobile phone on 21.08.2013, which is the day prior to the drawing of the site maps on 22.08.2013 – It was alleged that the victim was tutored based on the videography of the scene of the crime a day prior to the preparation of the spot panchnama and site maps on 22.08.2013 – Therefore, assertions were made that site maps (Exhibits P-13 and P-14) were false and ought to be discarded – On appeal, held: It is not the prosecution’s case and version that police team/officers had not visited the place of occurrence or scene of crime on 21.08.2013 – Presence of police team on 21.08.2013 is not disputed and it is an accepted position – The findings recorded by the trial Court is based on detailed examination of the evidence of the victim and investigating officer – Whether finding is correct will be tested in the appeal – When the prosecution states that on 21.08.2013 the police team had visited the scene of the crime, that is, the ‘Kutiya’, the plea to examine DCP on the ground that he had purportedly recorded a video of the ‘Kutiya’ on his mobile phone is completely inconsequential and irrelevant – The impugned judgment is unsustainable and mistaken in both facts and law and the reasoning is based upon mere conjectures, and that too without appreciating the scope and object of s. 391 Cr.P.C.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 391 – Additional evidence at appellate stage – The touchstone of when the additional evidence at the appellate stage may be taken on record is not the A B C D E F G H 2 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
impossibility or inability to pronounce the judgment in its absence, but whether there would be a failure of justice without such additional evidence – This discretion is not to be exercised lightly but requires caution and care.
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss. 311, 391 – Comparative analysis – Both s. 311 and 391 relate to power of the court to take additional evidence; the former at the stage of trial and before the judgment is pronounced; and the latter at the appellate stage after judgment by the trial court has been pronounced – The discretion u/s. 391 should be read as somewhat more restricted in comparison to s. 311 as the appellate court is dealing with an appeal, after the trial court has come to the conclusion with regard to the guilt or otherwise of the person being prosecuted – Further, the appellate court can examine the evidence in depth and in detail, yet it does not possess all the powers of the trial court as it deals with cases wherein the decision has already been pronounced.
Trial – Right to speedy trial – Additional evidence at appellate stage – Appellate court must be equally, if not more cautious, of the desire to delay the hearing of the appeal, or the attempt to lead additional evidence to explore a chance of contradictory evidence – The prayer for leading additional evidence should be permitted to correct a bona fide error or otherwise, and a party may be entitled to further opportunity without any fault on the part of the opposite party, the request for recall should be bona fide and is to be balanced carefully with relevant considerations, including hardship to the witness and delay of the proceedings – Also, Right to speedy trial, including speedy disposal of an appeal, is not the exclusive right of an accused, but an obligation of the court towards the society in general, and the victim in particular.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1. The case of the prosecution, as held by the trial court in paragraphs 298 to 303, as quoted above, is that the victim (PW-5) was not tutored and, therefore, her version as to the details of the ‘Kutiya’ were narrated by her to the police without being taken inside the room or the bathroom. This version and stand of the prosecution, as accepted by the trial court, is not on the ground and reason that the police team had not gone inside the A B C D E F G H room or the bathroom on 21.08.2013, but by rejecting the argument that a police officer or the Investigating Officer had prompted or tutored the victim (PW-5) to give the description and details of the room and bathroom. This finding recorded by the trial court is based on the detailed examination of the evidence of the victim (PW-5), as well as the Investigating Officer (PW- 43). Whether this finding is correct will be tested in the appeal, albeit the reasoning given in the impugned judgment to summon and examine DCP as a court witness cannot be sustained on the ground that DCP had purportedly recorded a video on his mobile phone. The statement made by DCP in the Book, which statement is heavily relied upon by the learned Senior Advocate for the respondent, nowhere mentions that the video, which he had purportedly recorded on his mobile phone, was handed over, given or transferred by him to the Investigating Officer (PW-43), or that it was shown by him to the victim (PW-5). When the prosecution states that on 21.08.2013 the police team had visited the scene of the crime, that is, the ‘Kutiya’, the plea to examine DCP on the ground that he had purportedly recorded a video of the ‘Kutiya’ on his mobile phone is completely inconsequential and irrelevant to the factual matrix of the present case. [Para 11][13-A-G]
2. The touchstone of when the additional evidence at the appellate stage may be taken on record is not the impossibility or inability to pronounce the judgment in its absence, but whether there would be a failure of justice without such additional evidence. This discretion is not to be exercised lightly but requires caution and care as it is to be exercised only in cases when the appellate court finds, on good and justifiable grounds, that there would be a failure of justice without the additional evidence being taken on record. However, once this condition is satisfied, there is no restriction on the kind of evidence received, which may be formal or substantial. The right to fair hearing is inherent to the concept of due process of law and ascertainment of truth. Equally, there can be failure of justice if this discretion to allow additional evidence at the appellate stage is exercised in a routine and liberal manner, without the court being satisfied that the prayer has imprints of reasonableness and genuineness to at least consider STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. ASHARAM @ ASHUMAL A B C D E F G H 4 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
the worth, credibility and acceptability of the material sought to be brought on record. [Paras 14, 15][14-C-F]
3. Both Sections 311 and 391 of the Cr.P.C. relate to power of the court to take additional evidence; the former at the stage of trial and before the judgment is pronounced; and the latter at the appellate stage after judgment by the trial court has been pronounced. It may not be totally correct to state that the same considerations would apply to both situations as there is a difference in the stages. Section 311 of the Cr.P.C. consists of two parts; the first gives power to the court to summon any witness at any stage of inquiry, trial or other proceedings, whether the person is listed as a witness, or is in attendance though not summoned as a witness. Secondly, the trial court has the power to recall and re-examine any person already examined if his evidence appears to be essential to the just decision of the case. On the other hand, the discretion under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C. should be read as somewhat more restricted in comparison to Section 311 of the Cr.P.C., as the appellate court is dealing with an appeal, after the trial court has come to the conclusion with regard to the guilt or otherwise of the person being prosecuted. The appellate court can examine the evidence in depth and in detail, yet it does not possess all the powers of the trial court as it deals with cases wherein the decision has already been pronounced. [Para 16][14-G; 15-A-C]
4. The appellate court must be equally, if not more cautious, of the desire to delay the hearing of the appeal, or the attempt to lead additional evidence to explore a chance of contradictory evidence. While the prayer for leading additional evidence should be permitted to correct a bona fide error or otherwise, and a party may be entitled to further opportunity without any fault on the part of the opposite party, the request for recall should be bona fide and is to be balanced carefully w ith relevant considerations, including hardship to the witness and delay of the proceedings. Right to speedy trial, including speedy disposal of an appeal, is not the exclusive right of an accused, but an obligation of the court towards the society in general, and the A B C D E F G H victim in particular. The process of ascertaining the truth requires compliance of procedures and rules of evidence. In a welldesigned system, judicial findings of formal legal truth should coincide with substantive truth. This happens when the facts contested are skillfully explored in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law. Further, in a criminal trial, burden of proof to establish the fact, which has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt, is on the prosecution. The power to take additional evidence in an appeal is to be exercised to prevent injustice and failure of justice, and thus, must be exercised for good and valid reasons necessitating the acceptance of the prayer. [Para 17][15- F-G; 16-A-D] Rajeswar Prasad Misra v. State of West Bengal and Another [1966] 1 SCR 178; Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh and Another v. State of Gujarat and Others (2004) 4 SCC 158 : [2004] 3 SCR 1050 ; State (NCT of Delhi)
v. Shiv Kumar Yadav and Another (2016) 2 SCC 402 :
[2015] 10 SCR 455; Girish Kumar Suneja v. Central Bureau of Investigation (2017) 14 SCC 809 ; P.
Ponnusamy v. State of Tamil Nadu 2022 SCC Online SC 1543; State of West Bengal v. Amiya Kumar Biswas (2004) 13 SCC 671 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1966] 1 SCR 178 referred to Para 14 [2004] 3 SCR 1050 referred to Para 15 [2015] 10 SCR 455 referred to Para 17 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
1156 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 10.02.2022 of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur in DBCRA No. 123 of 2018. Dr. Manish Singhvi, Devadatt Kamat, Sr. Advs., Ashok Basoya, Sandeep Kumar Jha, Arpit Prakash, Vikalp Sharma, Anish R. Shah, Rajesh Inamdar, Revanta Solanki, Abhiyudaya Vats, Advs. for the appearing parties.
STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. ASHARAM @ ASHUMAL A B C D E F G H 6 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
SANJIV KHANNA, J.
Leave granted.
2. The present appeal preferred by the State of Rajasthan takes exception to the judgment dated 10.02.2022 passed by the High Court of Rajasthan at Jodhpur1, allowing the application2 filed by the respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal under Section 391 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19733, and directing summoning and recording of evidence of Ajay Pal Lamba, who was posted as Deputy Commissioner of Police (West), Jodhpur, Rajasthan in August 2013 and has written a book “Gunning For The Godman: The True Story Behind Asaram Bapu’s Conviction”4.
3. The respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal was charge-sheeted on 06.11.2013, and after a trial lasting almost five years, vide judgment dated 25.04.2018 passed by the Magistrate, Special Court, Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 20125, Jodhpur, Rajasthan, he has been convicted for the offences under Sections 370(4), 342, 354-A, 376(2)(f), 376-D, 506, 509/34 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, Sections 23 and 26 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 20006, and Sections 5(f)/6, 5(g)/6, and 8 of the POCSO Act. He stands sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for different periods, and life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life, with fine and default stipulations.
4. Earlier, the victim had given a handwritten complaint (Exhibit P-4) on the intervening night of 19/20.08.2013 at 11:55 p.m., pursuant to which ‘Zero’ F.I.R. dated 20.08.2013(Exhibit P-11) was registered at Police Station Kamla Market, Central District, Delhi at 2:50 a.m. The victim was spoken to and had interacted with a Non-Governmental Organization7, and a report dated 20.08.2013 (Exhibit D-4) was prepared by the N.G.O. On the same day, the victim had appeared before the Metropolitan Magistrate in New Delhi, and her statement under Section 1 For short, ‘the High Court’.
2 D.B. Criminal Misc. Application No. 1 of 2021 in D.B. Criminal Appeal No. 123 of 2018. 3 For short, ‘Cr.P.C.’.
4 For short ‘the Book’.
5 For short, ‘POCSO Act’.
6 For short, ‘JJ Act’.
7 For short, ‘N.G.O.’.
A B C D E F G H 164 of the Cr.P.C. (Exhibit P-7) was recorded. As the offence was committed in Jodhpur, the investigation was transferred to the Police Station of competent jurisdiction and, consequently, F.I.R. No. 122 of 2013 (Exhibit P-106) was registered at Police Station Mahila Pashchim, Jodhpur District, Rajasthan on 21.08.2013 at 6:15 p.m.
5. The investigation in the case was conducted by Chanchal Mishra, the then Assistant Commissioner of Police8, (West), Jodhpur, Rajasthan, who has deposed as PW-43. As per the prosecution’s version, the Investigating Officer – Chanchal Mishra (PW-43) had recorded the statement of the victim under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. on 21.08.2013. For some reason, the entire statement of the victim under Section 161 the Cr.P.C. recorded on 21.08.2013 has been marked as Exhibit D-29. The Investigating Officer – Chanchal Mishra (PW-43) was examined and cross-examined on as many as eleven dates between 09.07.2015 and 03.03.2016. The victim, who has deposed as PW-5, was examined and cross-examined on eleven dates between 11.04.2014 and 13.06.2014.
6. As a limited issue arises for our consideration, and keeping in mind that the appeal preferred by the respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal is pending adjudication before the High Court, we would refrain from referring to the evidence in detail, and avoid expressing any opinion on merits, albeit we would confine ourselves to the record on the issue raised before us.
7. In 202110, the respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal filed an application under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C.11, in which the impugned judgment has been passed, alleging that the victim (PW-5) had never been inside the house described as ‘Kutiya’ and therefore, the entire case against the respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal that he had sexually abused and raped the victim (PW-5), is false and concocted. The application asserts that the victim (PW-5) was brought to the ‘Kutiya’ for the first time by the police for the spot panchnama/Mauka Naksha on 22.08.2013, which visit was duly video-graphed (Exhibit P-70) and after that, a transcription vide compact disc (Article-16) was prepared, 8 For short, ‘ACP’.
9 Whether the entire statement recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. can be exhibited, and canbe read in evidence is not the subject matter of the present appeal and we make no comments and observations on this aspect.
10 The exact date of filing the application is not available on record. 11 For short, ‘the application’.
STATE OF RAJASTHAN v. ASHARAM @ ASHUMAL [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] A B C D E F G H 8 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
and the site maps (Exhibits P-13 and P-14), were drawn. It is alleged that the victim (PW-5) was tutored based on the videography of the scene of the crime shown to the victim a day prior to the preparation of the spot panchnama/Mauka Naksha and site maps on 22.08.2013. In this context, the application records that Ajay Pal Lamba, who was the then Deputy Commissioner of Police (West), Jodhpur, Rajasthan, in the Book, has disclosed having recorded a video of the scene of the crime on his mobile phone on his first visit to the ‘Kutyia’ on 21.08.2013, which is a day prior to the drawing of the site maps (Exhibits P-13 and P-14) on 22.08.2013. The assertion in the application is that the site maps (Exhibits P-13 and P-14) are false and ought to be discarded. It is alleged that there is a discrepancy between video recording (Article-15) and statement of the victim (PW-5) recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. dated 21.08.2013 (Exhibit D-2). If the description of the ‘Kutiya’, as given by the victim (PW-5), which, as per prosecution’s case, was made in her statement under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. for the first time on 21.08.2013 (Exhibit D-2), is falsified and rejected, the prosecution’s case wouldnot be able to link the victim (PW-5)’s presence with the respondent – Asharam @ Ashumal at the scene of the crime on 15.08.2013, the date when the offences were allegedly committed.
8. The impugned judgment refers to quotes from a portion of the Book, wherein Ajay Pal Lamba has stated that on learning about the offence, he had swung into action and had sent a police team to scan and examine the location. Ajay Pal Lamba had asked Sub-Inspector Madan Beniwal to seal and secure the entire campus until the investigation was completed. The impugned judgment dated 10.02.2022, at the sametime, quotes Ajay Pal Lamba’s assertion in the Book – “In any case, one would not be very wrong to assume that not much of the forensic evidence would be found at the [scene of the crime] because of...the sheer delay in filing the FIR...”, as the offence was stated to have occurred on 15.08.2013, while the F.I.R. No. 122 of 2013 (Exhibit P-106) was registered on 21.08.2013. Nevertheless, the application under Section 391 of the Cr.P.C. for summoning and recording evidence of Ajay Pal Lamba has been allowed primarily relying on the following statement by Ajay Pal Lamba in the Book:
“….. While I was there, I thought it would be prudent to film a video of the place on my mobile phone, should I need to refer to it at some point during the course of the investigation. And so, I did.”
A B C D E F G H
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.