Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1322; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 221
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 17 Nov 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 4895/2025
- Sections
- 302, 147, 148, 144, 145, 34, 207, 313, 161, 27
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 221 : 2025 INSC 1322 Raj Kumar @ Bheema v.
State of NCT of Delhi (Criminal Appeal No. 4895 of 2025)
17 November 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Appellant-accused was convicted for the offence punishable u/s.302 IPC. The High Court further affirmed the order on sentence dated 20.02.2021, whereby the accused-appellant was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 – Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999 – u/ss.3, 3(1)(i), 3(1)(ii), 3(2), and 3(4) – Prosecution case that accused-appellant along with others did house breaking by night and allegedly assaulted occupants of the premises – Upon entering the premises, the police found the house ransacked, and the household articles scattered – In lobby, a dead body of an elderly male was found – In the adjoining room, an elderly lady-PW-18 was found lying injured – Accused was apprehended based on description given by PW-18 – Accused gave disclosure statement – In furtherance thereof, a blood-stained pant and one chheni were recovered – Primarily three circumstances have been relied upon by the prosecution to bring home its case against the appellant: i) The identification of the appellant in Court by the prosecution witness PW-18 during her sworn testimony; (ii) The refusal of the appellant to participate in the TIP, leading to an adverse inference being drawn against him; (iii) Recovery of weapon of offence stained with human blood – Trial Court convicted accused-appellant u/s.302 of IPC and remaining co-accused were acquitted – The High Court affirmed the conviction – Correctness:
Held: The identification of appellant was done by PW-18 while being examined through video conferencing, nearly eight and a half years after the incident – PW-18 used to wear spectacles as her * Author 222 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports distance vision was weak – At the time of dock identification, the witness was not wearing spectacles – Not even a bare suggestion was put to her by the Public Prosecutor that she had been taken to the police station or jail for TIP proceedings – The witness emphatically denied the suggestion of the Public Prosecutor that she had gone to the Court on 26.12.2008, and identified the assailants – The possibility of identification of the accused-appellant by PW-18 in Court, after a lapse of nearly eight and a half years from the incident, is extremely unlikely – PW-18 was not wearing spectacles at the time of her deposition via video conferencing – In this background, her purported identification does not inspire confidence – In her cross-examination, the witness (PW-18) stated that the accused was wearing a black coloured shirt, which is an improvement introduced for the first time after nearly eight and a half years – In view of the aforesaid glaring facts, it would be unsafe to place reliance on her evidence regarding the identification of the accused – Further, the very sanctity of the TIP stands under a serious cloud of doubt when it is manifest that PW-18 did not go for participating in any such identification parade – When it stands established from the record that the TIP attempted by the prosecution was fundamentally flawed, and a doubt is created that the identifying witness herself may not even have been present to participate therein, the very foundation of the identification proceedings falls flat to the ground – As far as recovery of articles looted is concerned, PW-18 was not made to identify the said articles during her testimony and son of PW-18, who is stated to have identified the articles in the TIP, was not examined during the trial – Thus, there is no credible proof that they are the looted articles – The blood stains on the pant could not be matched with the blood sample lifted from the scene of occurrence or with the blood group of the deceased or the injured victim – On this count alone, guilt cannot be fastened upon the appellant, as the recovery by itself is not sufficient to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt – Therefore, the judgment passed by the High Court as well as trial Court is set aside and the accused-appellant is acquitted of the charges. [Paras 50, 52, 54, 56, 57, 65, 67, 68, 71] Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.144, 145 – Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 – ss.147, 148 – When evidence of witness is recorded over video conferencing:
Held: A plain reading of the above provisions would make it clear that wherever questions are required to be put as to the matters [2025] 12 S.C.R. 223Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi in writing/previous statements in writing, the attention of the witness must be drawn to the document/statement itself – Thus, a question would arise as to how this procedure would be followed in cases where the evidence of the witness is being recorded over video conferencing – In this age of advancement of technology, instances are galore where, the evidence of witnesses are being recorded over video conferencing – In such circumstances, none of the parties should be put to a dis-advantage merely because the witness is not in attendance before the Court, and the document/ previous statement in writing with which such witness is sought to be confronted, cannot be shown/put to him – Therefore, this Court hereby clarifies and directs that in every case where, it is proposed to record the statement of a witness over video conferencing and any previous written statement of such witness or a matter in writing is available and the party concerned is desirous of confronting the witness with such previous statement/matter in writing, the trial Court shall ensure that a copy of the statement/document is transmitted to the witness through electronic transmission mode and the procedure provided u/s.147 and s.148 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (corresponding s.144 and s.145 of the Evidence Act) is followed in the letter and spirit, so as to safeguard the fairness and integrity of the trial. [Paras 46-48] Evidence Act, 1872 – Test Identification Parade (TIP) – Where the witnesses have had an opportunity to see the accused prior to the holding of the TIP:
Held: It is trite that where the witnesses have had an opportunity to see the accused prior to the holding of the TIP, the evidentiary worth of such proceedings stands considerably diminished – It is the duty of the prosecution to establish beyond doubt that right from the time of arrest, the accused was kept baparda to rule out the possibility of his face being seen before the identification proceedings are conducted – If the witnesses have had any opportunity to see the accused before the TIP–whether physically or through photographs–the credibility and sanctity of the identification proceedings would stand seriously compromised. [Para 62] Case Law Cited Koppula Jagdish v. State of Andhra Pradesh (2005) 12 SCC 425; Mekala Sivaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh [2022] 6 SCR 989 : (2022) 8 SCC 253 – referred to.
224 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Evidence Act, 1872; Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023; Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999.
List of Keywords Test Identification Parade; Identification by the Sole Eye-Witness; Evidence as to matters in writing; Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing; Technology; Video conferencing; Section 147 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023; Section 148 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023; Identification in Court after delay; Recoveries and Non-identification of Articles; Evidentiary worth. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
4895 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.09.2022 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLA No. 218 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ajay Marwah, Swaroopanand Mishra, Mrigank Bhardwaj, Parkhar Singh.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Vikramjeet Banerjee, A.S.G., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Shubhendu Anand, Ms. Priyanka Das, Ms. Dacchita Shahi, Ms. Arushi Singh, Ms. Sunanda Shukla.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. The instant appeal is directed against the final judgment and order dated 29 th September, 2022, passed by the Division Bench of the [2025] 12 S.C.R. 225Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi High Court of Delhi at New Delhi 1 in Criminal Appeal No. 218 # of 2021, whereby the appeal preferred by the appellant Raj Kumar @ Bheema 2 came to be dismissed, affirming the judgment dated 12 th February, 2021, rendered by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, South East, Saket Courts, New Delhi 3 . By the said judgment, while the accused-appellant was acquitted of the charges under Sections 3, 3(1)(i), 3(1)(ii), 3(2), and 3(4) of the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 19994 , and Sections 396, 307, 397, 412 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 5 , he was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC, whereas the remaining co-accused were acquitted. The High Court further affirmed the order on sentence dated 20 th February, 2021, whereby the accused-appellant was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs.5,000/-, and in default whereof, to further undergo simple imprisonment for a period of one month.
PROSECUTION CASE
4. On the intervening night of 2 nd /3rd November, 2008, at about 1:50 a.m., an information was received at Police Station, New Friends Colony through wireless operator, regarding an incident of house breaking by night at House No. 81, Sukhdev Vihar, near Escort Hospital, where the intruders were allegedly assaulting the occupants of the premises. At about 2:00 a.m., further information was received at the said Police Station, which was reduced into writing vide DD No. 29A, as per which, Head Constable Bhagirath (PW-7) informed that SI Sanjeev Solanki (PW-17) may be sent to the spot.
5. Pursuant thereto, SI Sanjeev Solanki (PW-17), accompanied by Constable Ashok Kumar (PW-9), proceeded to the place of occurrence and apprised the Additional S.H.O., who arrived there shortly thereafter. Upon entering the premises, they found the sliding door of the drawing room broken, the side grill bent, the house ransacked, and the household articles scattered. A large pool of 1 Hereinafter, referred to as the “High Court”.
2 Hereinafter, referred to as the “accused-appellant”.
3 Hereinafter, referred to as the “trial Court”.
4 For short, ‘MCOCA’.
5 For short, ‘IPC’.
# Ed. Note: “Criminal Appeal No. 218” instead of “Criminal Appeal No. 281” in terms of subsequent corrigendum. 226 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports blood was noticed in the lobby, where the dead body of an elderly male (deceased-Madan Mohan Gulati) was lying, alongside certain articles. Bloodstains and articles in disarray were also observed in the adjoining bedroom.
6. On hearing faint cries emanating from the adjoining bedroom, the police officials rushed inside and found an elderly lady, later identified as Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18), lying in an injured condition. She was immediately shifted to AIIMS Hospital by the PCR. Thereafter, SI Sanjeev Solanki (PW-17), accompanied by Inspector S.K. Sharma (PW-15), proceeded to the Trauma Centre, AIIMS, where Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) was under treatment. Medico-Legal Certificate (MLC)6 of the injured, Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) was prepared on 3 rd November, 2008, by Dr. Sharwan. The MLC recorded that the injured was fit for statement and noted multiple grievous stab injuries, including blood clots around the nether region, scalp-deep wounds, and a lacerated wound near the right eyebrow. The nature of the weapon used to cause the injuries was opined to be sharp.
7. Upon being declared fit, the statement (Fard bayan)7 of Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) was recorded by SI Sanjeev Solanki (PW-17) and based on the said statement, Inspector S.K. Sharma (PW-15) prepared a rukka and handed it over to SI Sanjeev Solanki (PW-17), pursuant to which an FIR8 came to be registered at Police Station, New Friends Colony, for the offences punishable under Sections 394/397/302/307/34 of IPC.
8. On 5th November, 2008, body of the deceased Madan Mohan Gulati was identified by his son-Vivek Gulati, and by his nephew-Servesh Gulati (son of the deceased’s younger brother). The post-mortem examination of the deceased was thereafter carried out, and the postmortem report was issued wherein the cause of death was opined to be shock and haemorrhage on account of multiple antemortem injuries. The opinion on the weapon of offence (knife/chheni) was also obtained from the doctor.
9. The accused-appellant was apprehended on 21 st November, 2008, based on the description allegedly provided by the injured 6 Exh. 21/A.
7 Exh. PW-17/A.
8 FIR No. 601/2018 dated 3 rd November, 2008.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 227Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi eye-witness, Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18). It is alleged that the accused-appellant gave a disclosure statement 9 , and in furtherance thereof, he led the police party to an open area near bushes situated at Pul Prahladpur, from where a blood-stained Eagle brand pant was recovered from a pit. The pant was duly seized and sealed. On the following day, while the appellant was on police remand, his disclosure led to the arrest of the co-accused persons.
10. On 25th November, 2008, pursuant to a supplementary disclosure statement 10 , the appellant purportedly led the police party to the bushes near the railway track behind Priyanka Camp, from where one chheni was recovered. The same was also seized and sealed. Thereafter, the accused-appellant also facilitated the recovery of the robbed articles, namely, one idol of Lord Ganesha and a Panasonic CD player, from his Jhuggi.
11. Shri Vivek Kumar Gulati, son of the deceased and Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) identified the case property in the Test Identification Parade 11 conducted on 6 th December, 2008. The proceedings12 of the TIP were conducted by Shri Devendra Kumar Jangala (PW-16), learned Additional District Judge, West, Tis Hazari Courts.
12. On 24th December, 2008, TIP was organized in respect of the accused Raj Kumar @ Bheema, Jawahar, Ranbir @ Sintu, and Naeem @ Mota; however, they refused to participate in the same. Upon comparison, the fingerprints of the accused Jawahar and Ranbir @ Sintu were found to tally with the chance prints lifted from the spot. The site inspection plan was prepared, and the material exhibits were forwarded to the Forensic Science Laboratory13 on 22nd January, 2009. Upon completion of the investigation, chargesheet in connection with the said FIR came to be filed on 2nd February, 2002, against the accused, namely, Raj Kumar @ Bheema, Ramesh Kumar @ Shankar, Naeem Khan @ Mota, Jawahar, and Ranbir @ Sintu, in the Court of the learned ACMM, for offences punishable under Sections 3, 3(1)(i), 3(1)(ii), 3(2), and 3(4) of the MCOCA, and Sections 396, 307, 397, 412 read with Section 34 of IPC. One of the accused, namely, Kastoori, 9 Exh. PW 14/A.
10 Exh. PW-14/N.
11 For short, ‘TIP’.
12 Exh. PW16/B.
13 For short, ‘FSL’.
228 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports could not be traced out despite best efforts, and proceedings under Sections 82 and 83 of the Code of Criminal procedure, 1973 14 were initiated against him and his name was placed in Column No. 2 of the chargesheet. Since the offences were triable exclusively by the Court of Sessions, the learned ACMM, after compliance with the provisions of Section 207 CrPC, committed the case to the Court of Sessions for trial, where charges were framed against the accused. They abjured their guilt and claimed trial.
13. During the course of trial, the prosecution examined 27 witnesses and exhibited 25 documents in consolidated form to prove the guilt of the accused. The accused Ramesh @ Shankar examined one witness in defence. Upon closure of prosecution evidence, statements of the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 CrPC affording them an opportunity to explain the incriminating material appearing against them. The accused-appellant, in answer to Question No. 82, categorically stated, “I am innocent and have been falsely implicated in the present case. PW-17 Inspector Sanjeev Solanki was known to me prior to the present case, and he has falsely implicated me in this case.”
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
14. Upon consideration of the arguments advanced by the prosecution and the defence, and after appreciating the evidence available on record, the trial Court, vide judgment dated 12 th February, 2021, acquitted the accused persons other than the appellant Raj Kumar @ Bheema, holding that the case against him stood proved beyond reasonable doubt only for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. He was acquitted of the remaining charges. The conviction was primarily based on the testimony of the eye-witness, Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18), who identified the appellant during her testimony (recorded over video conferencing) while failing to identify the remaining accused, coupled with the purported recovery of weapon of offence at the instance of the accused-appellant.
15. Further, the trial Court, vide order dated 20 th February, 2021, directed the accused-appellant to undergo sentence as mentioned hereinabove. 15 14 For short, ‘CrPC’.
15 Supra para 3.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 229Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi
FINDINGS OF THE HIGH COURT
16. In appeal by the accused-appellant, the High Court affirmed the findings of the trial Court vide judgment 16 dated 22 nd September, 2022, finding no infirmity in the judgment and order passed by the trial Court, holding that the prosecution case essentially rested upon the identification of the accused-appellant by the injured witness and the recoveries effected at his instance. The High Court rejected the submission advanced on behalf of the appellant that the identification of the appellant by Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) was doubtful as she failed to identify the other accused, on the ground that, insofar as the present accused-appellant was concerned, she was categorical in her testimony that he was one of the assailants.
17. The High Court observed that non-recovery of the appellant’s finger prints from the place of incident would not absolve him of participation in the offence, which stood established by the identification made by the injured victim, Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18). It was further noted that pursuant to the disclosure made by the appellant, the pant allegedly worn by him at the time of incident was recovered, on which human blood was detected, and no plausible explanation was forthcoming from the appellant as to the presence of human blood on his wearing apparel. The Court also held that merely because the son of the deceased and the injured victim, who had identified the robbed articles in TIP, did not appear in the witness box to identify the recovered articles, would not discredit the rest of the evidence led by the prosecution, which was sufficient to prove the guilt of the appellant for the offence alleged, beyond reasonable doubt.
18. Aggrieved, the accused-appellant is before us in the present appeal by way of special leave.
Submissions on behalf of accused-appellant
19. Learned counsel for the appellant, vehemently and fervently urged that the High Court fell in grave error in affirming the conviction of the accused-appellant recorded by the trial Court, which is wholly unsustainable in law. It was contended that the prosecution case rests entirely upon the testimony of the old and infirm witness Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18), who was admittedly suffering from weak 16 Crl.A. 218/2021.
230 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports eyesight. Accordingly, her testimony is riddled with inconsistencies and is far too unconvincing so as to form the sole basis for upholding a conviction for an offence punishable with capital punishment.
20. It was further contended that Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) identified the appellant in Court through video conferencing on 8 th May, 2017, after an inordinate delay of nearly eight and a half years from the incident dated 2nd November, 2008, while notably failing to identify any of the other accused. It was urged that in his statement under Section 313 CrPC, the accused-appellant specifically alleged that PW-18 had been tutored, as his photographs had already been shown to the witness prior to her deposition.
21. It was averred that there were material contradictions and improvements in the testimony of PW-18. In her initial statement under Section 161 CrPC, she mentioned that the assailants were armed with “knives, screwdriver, and rods,” but made no reference to a “chheni.” The introduction of the “chheni” for the first time during her sworn testimony recorded after a lapse of more than eight years was a material improvement, evidently tailored to align with the alleged recovery. Moreover, she failed to identify any of the co-accused, all of whom were acquitted, rendering her solitary identification of the appellant highly doubtful.
22. Learned counsel urged that the prosecution placed reliance upon the alleged recoveries of a blood-stained pant, a “chheni,” and articles such as a Ganesh idol/CD player at the instance of the accusedappellant. The first recovery attributed to the accused-appellant was allegedly made pursuant to his disclosure statement from an open area near bushes at Pul Prahladpur, wherefrom a blood-stained pant was recovered. The prosecution alleged that the said pant had been worn by the appellant at the time of the incident. However, the bloodstains detected on the garment did not test positive for the blood group lifted from the scene of occurrence. It was thus contended that the said article could not be connected with the present case, even after forensic examination17 .
23. It was further urged that the said recovery cannot be read in evidence under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, 1872 inasmuch as in his 17 Ex. PW-24/B read with Ex. PW-24/A.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 231Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi disclosure statement 18 dated 21 st November, 2008, the accusedappellant did not state that he could get the article recovered from an open place near Pul Prahladpur, which, in any event, was accessible to all and sundry. The learned counsel urged that all the recoveries were made without any independent witness being associated to corroborate the same. It was further averred that the alleged weapon of offence, namely the “chheni,” was shown to have been recovered after a lapse of 22 days from bushes near a railway track. The said article was never shown to Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) for identification, no photographs were taken at the time of recovery, and no independent witness was associated in the process.
24. Placing reliance on the judgment of this Court in Koppula Jagdish v. State of Andhra Pradesh19, learned counsel further urged that the High Court failed to appreciate that the appellant was wrongly convicted for the offence under Section 302 IPC simpliciter, inasmuch as no separate charge under Section 302 IPC was framed against him. It was pointed out that in the present case, all the accused were charged under Sections 394, 397, 302, 307, read with 34 IPC, and except for the appellant, all other co-accused have been acquitted.
25. It was also urged that Shri Vivek Gulati, son of the deceased, who had identified the robbed articles during the TIP, did not appear in the witness box during the trial to prove and identify the articles allegedly recovered at the instance of the accused-appellant, and hence, no adverse inference ought to be drawn against the appellant on this count.
26. He, thus, implored the Court to accept the appeal and set aside the impugned judgment(s).
Submissions on behalf of respondent-State
27. Per contra, Shri Vikramjeet Banerjee, learned Additional Solicitor General, supported the impugned judgment and urged that the appellant Raj Kumar @ Bheema was correctly identified by the injured eye-witness, Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18), in her examinationin-chief as well as in her cross-examination, as the person armed 18 Exhibit PW 14/A.
19 (2005) 12 SCC 425.
232 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports with a “chheni” and a rod, who inflicted blows upon her and her husband, resulting in the death of the latter. It was further submitted that the said weapons were recovered from the appellant pursuant to his disclosure statement, thereby corroborating the version of the injured witness Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18).
28. It was further contended that, as per the opinion rendered by Dr. Arvind Kumar (PW-1) with regard to the weapon of offence, Exhibit V, i.e., the recovered “chheni,” could be one of the weapons used in the offence and that injuries marked B, C, and D on the person of injured Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) were possible by the said weapon.
29. The conduct and antecedents of the appellant, including his status as a history-sheeter, repeated involvement in criminal cases, and acts of misconduct during incarceration, clearly reflect a persistent pattern of unlawful behaviour. Considering the heinous nature of the offence, being the murder (for gain) of a senior citizen, the accusedappellant does not deserve any indulgence, and the gravity of the crime and the attendant circumstances warrant dismissal of the appeal filed on his behalf.
30. He thus implored the Court to dismiss the appeal, urging that the High Court had rightly affirmed the conviction of the accused-appellant and the sentence awarded to him by the trial Court. It was further urged that upon an independent and comprehensive appraisal of the evidence on record, including the consistent testimonies of Investigating Officer Shri S.K. Sharma (PW-15) and Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18), both the trial Court and the High Court had recorded concurrent findings that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt, and hence no interference is warranted in the impugned judgment.
Discussion and Analysis
31. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have carefully gone through the impugned judgments, the material available on record, as well as the written submissions filed on behalf of both sides.
32. Since the appellant seeks reversal of concurrent findings of fact recorded by the trial Court as well as the High Court, this Court is required to tread with circumspection. It has been consistently held [2025] 12 S.C.R. 233Raj Kumar @ Bheema v. State of NCT of Delhi by this Court in a catena of decisions that unless the findings are shown to be perverse or rendered in disregard of material evidence, this Court would be slow in interfering with concurrent conclusions of the Courts below. Reference in this regard may be made to the decision of this Court in the case of Mekala Sivaiah v. State of Andhra Pradesh20 , the relevant para of which is quoted hereinbelow:
“15. It is well settled by judicial pronouncements that Article 136 is worded in wide terms and powers conferred under the said Article are not hedged by any technical hurdles. This overriding and exceptional power is, however, to be exercised sparingly and only in furtherance of cause of justice. Thus, when the judgment under appeal has resulted in grave miscarriage of justice by some misapprehension or misreading of evidence or by ignoring material evidence then this Court is not only empowered but is well expected to interfere to promote the cause of justice.”
(Emphasis is supplied)
33. Keeping the aforesaid principle in mind, this Court would proceed to consider the appeal at hand to examine whether there is some manifest error or illegality in the impugned judgment, and if any grave and serious miscarriage of justice has been occasioned on account of misreading or ignoring of material evidence in the present case.
34. Evidently, on a perusal of the judgments under challenge and upon considering the submissions advanced by learned Standing Counsel for the State, it emerges that primarily three circumstances have been relied upon by the prosecution to bring home its case against the appellant:
i. The identification of the appellant in Court by the prosecution witness Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18) during her sworn testimony.
ii. The refusal of the appellant to participate in the TIP, leading to an adverse inference being drawn against him.
iii. Recovery of weapon of offence stained with human blood.
20 (2022) 8 SCC 253.
234 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports A. Identification by the Sole Eye-Witness
35. It is undisputed that the fulcrum of the prosecution case is based on the testimony of Smt. Indra Prabha Gulati (PW-18). Thus, for the sake of ready reference, we quote the entire deposition of the said witness below: - “ON S.A.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.