Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1399; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 560
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 8 Dec 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5315/2025
- Sections
- 302, 34, 3(2), 161, 460, 313, 11, 324
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 560 : 2025 INSC 1399 Govind Mandavi v.
State of Chattisgarh (Criminal Appeal No. 5315 of 2025)
08 December 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the trial Court as well as the High Court committed grave errors in facts as well as in law while appreciating the evidence available on record and convicting the accused-appellant for the offences alleged u/s.302 r/w. s.34 IPC.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 r/w. s.34 – Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 – s.3(2)
(v) – One B was killed by masked persons – FIR was registered – A perusal of FIR makes it clear that informant-PW-1 was not an eye-witness to the incident; rather, his knowledge of the occurrence was entirely based on the information furnished to him by PW-2, his daughter-in-law and wife of the deceased B – After four days of the incident, PW-2 recorded her statement u/s.161 CrPC and for the first time it was alleged by her that that during the assault being made on her husband, the mask of one of the assailants came off and thus, she was able to identify the said assailant as being the appellant – The Investigating Officer, PW-14, apprehended the accused-appellant as well as the two co-accused – Recoveries were effected based on their disclosure/memorandum statements – Accused-appellant was subjected to TIP and allegedly identified by PW-2 – The trial Judge proceeded to convict and sentence all the three accused persons – The High Court affirmed the conviction of the accused-appellant while setting aside the conviction of the remaining two co-accused – Correctness:
Held: A very significant fact which remains undisputed is regarding the prior enmity between the prosecution witnesses (PW-1 and PW-2) and the accused-appellant herein – It is an admitted position * Author [2025] 12 S.C.R. 561Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh that during the subsisting marriage of PW-2 with the deceased-B, he married PW-6, the sister of the present accused-appellant, and serious differences had arisen between the parties owing to this relationship – In FIR, there is a material omission of a known accused’s name in the FIR despite the eyewitness having allegedly identified him and same is a fatal flaw as it goes to the very root of the matter – The belated introduction of the accused appellant’s name in PW-2’s 161 CrPC statement appears to be a clear manipulation – PW-2 had, actually, named the accusedappellant in that statement, there was absolutely no justification for conducting a TIP of the accused-appellant at her instance, particularly as she admittedly knew the accused from earlier, the accused-appellant being the brother of PW-6 – Once the fact of identification of the accused-appellant by the witness PW-2 is eschewed from consideration, there remains no credible evidence on record to connect the appellant with the crime – None of the recovered articles tested positive for any particular blood group, and hence, the same cannot be connected with the crime – Thus, the accused appellant is acquitted of the charges. [Paras 28, 43, 45, 46, 47, 48] Case Law Cited Ram Kumar Pandey v. State of M.P. [1975] 3 SCR 519 : AIR 1975 SC 1026 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. List of Keywords Murder; FIR; Test Identification Parade; Recovery of articles; Material omission; Manipulation; Belated improvements; Assailant’s name; Prior enmity; Vital Omission; Disclosure statements; Memorandum statements; Blood stained articles; Credible evidence. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5315 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 14.01.2025 of the High Court of Chattisgarh at Bilaspur in CRA No. 1298 of 2023 562 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant(s):
Mrs. Pragya Baghel, Azad Bansala.
Advs. for the Respondent(s):
Abhishek Pandey, Prashant Kumar Umrao.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. The appellant-Govind Mandavi1 , along with co-accused Narender Nag and Mansingh Nureti (both of whom stand acquitted by the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur 2 ), were put to trial before the learned Special Judge, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, North Bastar, Kanker 3 , in Special Penal Case No. 65 of 2021. Upon conclusion of the trial, vide judgment and order dated 28 th January, 2023, the accused-appellant and coaccused Mansingh Nureti were convicted for the offences punishable under Sections 302/34 and 460 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 4 , and were sentenced in the following manner:
Sections Sentence Penalty/Fine Sentence in default of payment of fine Section 302 r/w 34 IPC.
Life Imprisonment Rs.10,000/- Six months RI Section 460
IPC.
Ten Years RI Rs.5000/- Three months RI 1 Hereinafter, referred to as the “accused-appellant”. 2 Hereinafter, referred to as the “High Court”.
3 Hereinafter, referred to as the “trial Court”.
4 For short, ‘IPC’.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 563Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh
4. Accused Narender Nag was held guilty of the offences punishable under Section 302/34 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 5 , and was sentenced as follows:
Sections Sentence Penalty/Fine Sentence in default of payment of fine Section 302 r/w 34 IPC.
Life Imprisonment Rs.10,000/- Six months RI Section 3(2)(v)
of SC/ST Act.
Life Imprisonment Rs.10,000/- Six months RI
5. In appeal, the High Court set aside the conviction of the two coaccused, Narender Nag and Mansingh Nureti, whilst upholding the conviction and sentence of the present accused-appellant, vide the common judgment and order dated 14 th January, 2025, passed in the clubbed criminal appeals, including Criminal Appeal No. 1298 of 2023 preferred by the accused-appellant.
Factual Background
6. Succinctly stated, facts germane for adjudication of the present appeal are set out hereinbelow.
7. Heeralal Hidko (PW-1) submitted a merg intimation6 (oral report) to the SHO, Police Station Bhanupratappur, District Kanker, Chhattisgarh, on 18 th April, 2021, at about 7:25 a.m., alleging inter alia: - “I am a Native resident of Village Iragaon, Durgupara, I work in Farming sector. Like every day routine, on 17/04/2021, my son Bivan and daughter-in-law Sukmai Hidko both (sic) were sleeping inside the Farm hut around 11:30 my daughter-in-law Sukmai came home and told me that “2 unknown masked persons came at around 11:00 one of whom was tall and another was short-heighted and thin and held sickle In his hand. They called and woke up my husband Bivan and took him away from the farm hut, I 5 For short, ‘SC/ST Act’.
6 (Exh P/1).
564 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports followed them and stood on the door. After a while, my husband screamed “Aye Daayi! O Daayii” I got scared and ran away.” As soon as I got this news, I took Sahdev Kadiyam, Kushal Kawde and Dhannaram Anchala, and others with me to my field and in the light of my torch, I found my son Bivan lying dead, soaked in blood. My son is dead, some unknown person has killed my son with a sharp weapon. Due to the midnight and it being a forest area, I took care of the dead body of my son, and in the morning, I came here to report.”
8. On the basis of the aforesaid statement, First Information Report 7 No. 106 of 2021, dated 18 th April, 2021, came to be registered at the Police Station for the offence punishable under Sections 302/34 IPC against unknown assailants.
9. Evidently, a perusal of the FIR (Exh. P/2) makes it clear that the informant Heeralal Hidko (PW-1) was not an eyewitness to the incident; rather, his knowledge of the occurrence was entirely based on the information furnished to him by Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), his daughter-in-law and wife of the deceased Bivan Hidko.
10. The statement of Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), wife of the deceased and daughter-in-law of Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 8 came to be recorded on 21 st April, 2021, i.e., after four days of the incident and at that point of time, for the first time, it was alleged by the lady that during the assault being made on her husband, the mask of one of the assailants came off and thus, she was able to identify the said assailant as being the appellant-Govind Mandavi.
11. Acting upon the material collected during the course of investigation, the Investigating Officer, Shri Damon Lal Bhuarya (PW-14), apprehended the accused-appellant as well as the two co-accused on 22 nd April, 2021, as per duly prepared arrest memoranda 9 . Acting in furtherance of the respective disclosure/memorandum statements 10 furnished by all the three accused, the police effected the recoveries attributed to them as per the following table: - 7 For short, ‘FIR’; Exh. P/2.
8 For short, ‘CrPC’.
9 Exh. P/21-23.
10 Exh. P/14, 16, and 18.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 565Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh Accused Exhibit(s) Description of Articles Govind Mandavi (accused appellant)
P/15 1. One Mobile Phone.
2. One Axe, which has been used in the commission of the offence having blood-like stains.
3. One half T-shirt having blood-like stains.
4. One lower having blood-like stains.
5. One black towel having blood-like stains.
6. One pair of shoes having blood-like stains.
7. Rs.500/- cash.
Mansingh Nureti P/17 1. One motorcycle, which is used in the offence.
2. One T-shirt having blood like stains.
3. One towel having blood-like stains.
4. Rs.200 cash.
Narendra Nag P/19 1. One full shirt having blood like stains.
2. One half jeans pant having blood-like stains.
3. One towel having blood-like stains.
4. Rs.500/- cash.
12. The prosecution alleged that all recovered articles were forwarded to the Regional Forensic Science Laboratory, Jagdalpur (Bastar), for 566 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports chemical and serological examination. As per the FSL report11 , human blood was detected on the axe recovered from the accused-appellant (Article-C), the shoes seized from him (Article-E), the T-shirt and full pant of co-accused Mansingh Nureti (Articles F-1 and F-2), the full pant and towel attributed to co-accused Narender Nag (Articles G-1 and G-3), as well as the shirt and half-pant of the deceased (Articles H-1 and H-2). However, the blood group could not be determined as the serology report noted that the samples had disintegrated and the result was, therefore, inconclusive.
13. The accused–appellant was subjected to a Test Identification Parade12 conducted by Moksha Dewangan, Tahsildar (PW-16), on 22 nd April, 2021, during which he is alleged to have been identified by the purported eyewitness, Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2).
14. Pursuant to the filing of the chargesheet, the trial Court proceeded to frame charges against all the three charge-sheeted accused.
15. The accused denied the charges and claimed trial.
16. To bring home the charge against the accused persons, the prosecution examined as many as sixteen witnesses and exhibited certain documents and material objects. The incriminating material emerging from the prosecution evidence was put to the accused persons in their examination under Section 313 CrPC, wherein they denied the allegations in toto, asserting that they had been falsely implicated. No evidence was adduced in defence.
17. Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence brought on record, and after considering the submissions advanced on behalf of the prosecution and the defence, the learned trial Judge proceeded to convict and sentence all the three accused persons as aforesaid, vide judgment dated 28 th January, 2023.
18. In appeal, the High Court affirmed the conviction of the accusedappellant while setting aside the conviction of the remaining two co-accused, vide judgment dated 14 th January, 2025. The High Court principally relied upon the testimony of Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2); her identification of the accused-appellant in the TIP, which was 11 Exh. P/40.
12 For short, ‘TIP’.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 567Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh proved by the Executive Magistrate (Tahsildar) Moksha Dewangan (PW-16) and the dock identification. The Court further drew support from the FSL report, noting that human blood was detected on the axe and shoes recovered pursuant to the memorandum statement of the accused-appellant, duly proved through the testimony of Sahdev Kadyam (PW-7).
19. The High Court additionally held that the motive attributed to the accused-appellant stood firmly established on the basis of the evidence of PW-1, PW-2, PW-4, PW-6, PW-7, PW-8, and PW-9, who consistently deposed that the accused-appellant is the brother of Binda Bai (PW-6), the second wife of the deceased. The record reflected that the deceased had contracted a second marriage with Binda Bai (PW-6), as his first wife, Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), was unable to conceive. A son was born from the second wedlock, giving rise to frequent quarrels between the two wives over taking the child in the lap. Owing to these disputes, Binda Bai (PW-6) began residing at her parental home, and community panchayat meetings were convened on multiple occasions, during which altercations also ensued. The High Court concluded that, as the accused-appellant supported his sister and shared her grievances against the deceased and his family, a strong motive existed for him to commit the offence.
20. The said judgment now forms the subject matter of challenge in the present appeal by special leave.
Submissions on behalf of the accused-appellant
21. Learned counsel appearing for the accused-appellant advanced the following submissions in assailing the conviction recorded by the trial Court and consequently affirmed by the High Court:
(i) That the accused-appellant was not named in the FIR13 (Exh. P/2) lodged by Heeralal Hidko (PW-1). It stands admitted that PW-1 lodged the report purely on the basis of the information furnished to him by the alleged eye-witness Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2). Thus, omission to mention the name of the accused in the very first version, despite such claimed knowledge, is a material lacuna which, according to learned counsel, goes to 13 Exh. P/2.
568 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the root of the matter and gravely undermines the credibility of the prosecution case.
(ii) That the explanation tendered by the prosecution for the omission of identity of the accused in the FIR (Exh. P/2), that the informant, Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), was not an eye-witness, and that Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) allegedly fell ill upon witnessing the assault, is wholly implausible. Learned counsel submitted that in the earliest version narrated by Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) to her father-in-law immediately after the incident, it was pertinently stated that the assailants had covered their faces with masks. However, in stark contrast, her statements recorded after significant gap, under Sections 161 CrPC and 164 CrPC on 21 st April, 2021 and 21 st April, 2024 respectively, contain substantial and material improvements, including her claim of having identified the accused-appellant as his mask moved during the incident. Such embellished version, introduced after an unexplained delay, is inherently unreliable and wholly unworthy of credence.
(iii) That the conduct of the witness belies the prosecution story. Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) was indeed conscious and capable of narrating the incident, as is evident from the fact that the informant Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), could lodge the merg intimation (Exh P/1) on the basis of her version; thus, there was no reason for her to omit the names of the assailants at that very earliest point of time. Learned counsel submitted that the contents of the merg intimation (Exh P/1) unmistakably demonstrate that Smt. Sukami Hidko (PW-2) had provided a detailed information of the incident to her father-in-law; hence, had she actually identified any of the perpetrators, she would not have omitted to disclose their names to him. Consequently, the absence of the name of the accused-appellant in the merg intimation (Exh. P/1) strikes at the root of the prosecution case.
(iv) That the prosecution’s attempt to justify the delayed disclosure of the names of the assailant on the pretext of the illness of Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) is wholly unconvincing. There is no such corroborative evidence in form of any medical report etc. to support the assertion that Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) was in such a debilitated state as to be incapable of naming [2025] 12 S.C.R. 569Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh her husband’s assailant for three consecutive days. It stands admitted on record that the accused-appellant is the brother of Smt. Binda Bai (PW-6), the second wife of the deceased- Bivan Hidko, and that there existed palpable animosity between the two branches of the family, an aspect borne out from the testimonies of Heeralal Hidko (PW-1) and Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2). In this backdrop, the assertion made by Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), that the accused-appellant’s mask purportedly fell off during the assault, enabling her to identify him, at a belated point in time when her statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC were recorded, is a clear embellishment. This belated story, according to learned counsel, reflects a deliberate attempt by the witness to falsely implicate the appellant owing to the pre-existing enmity.
(v) That as the accused-appellant was well known to Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) from the prosecution’s attempt to establish his complicity by conducting a TIP indicates that Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) could not identify any of the assailants at the time of the incident. Once the accused had been named by the witness, there would be no rationale for holding a TIP of the same accused.
(vi) That the recoveries on which the trial Court as well as the High Court relied heavily are inconsequential, because mere detection of human blood on the articles does not, by itself, provide any corroboration to the otherwise flimsy evidence of the witnesses. The prosecution has neither proved the blood group on the articles allegedly recovered at the instance of the accused nor the blood group of the deceased, and hence, the recoveries are rendered inconsequential. Furthermore, the link evidence essential to prove the sanctity of the material objects was not proved by leading credible evidence.
On these grounds, learned counsel implored the Court to accept the appeal, set aside the conviction of the accused-appellant, and direct his release from prison.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent-State
22. Per contra, learned standing counsel for the State of Chhattisgarh supported the impugned judgment. He submitted that the accused- 570 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports appellant was named in the first statement under section 161 CrPC of the wife of the deceased, Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), which was recorded immediately after she regained strength. He urged that it was entirely natural for a woman from a rural background, having witnessed a brutal assault on her husband, to be in a state of deep shock, and hence, her inability to immediately disclose the names of the assailants to her father-in-law, Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), was not unusual or unnatural. He further urged that the accused-appellant, having been named and identified by the eyewitness Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) in her sworn testimony, coupled with her identification of the accused-appellant in the TIP and the plausible explanation furnished for the delayed disclosure, renders her testimony wholly reliable.
23. Thus, learned counsel urged that the conviction of the accusedappellant as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court based on concurrent findings of fact does not warrant any interference.
Discussion and Analysis
24. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the parties and have carefully reanalysed the evidence available on record.
25. At the outset, we may observe that the factum of the death of Bivan Hidko being homicidal is not in dispute, which stands established from the testimony of the medical jurist Dr. A.K. Dhruw (PW-11). Hence, we need not burden the judgment by dwelling further on this aspect of the prosecution case.
26. It is also undisputed that the FIR (Exh. P/2) was lodged on the basis of the merg statement (Exh. P/1) of Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), given at Police Station Bhanupratappur, District Kanker, Chhattisgarh on 18 th April, 2021 at 7:25 a.m., wherein he categorically stated that his daughter-in-law came to him at about 11:30 p.m. and informed him that two unknown masked persons came at around 11:00 p.m., one of whom was tall, while the other was short-heighted and lean, and was holding a sickle in his hand. They called out to Bivan, woke him up, and took him away from the farm hut. Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) followed them and stood at the door, and upon hearing her husband scream, she got scared, and ran away.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 571Govind Mandavi v. State of Chattisgarh
27. On receiving this information, the informant Heeralal Hidko (PW-1), accompanied by Sahdev Kadiyam (PW-7), Kushal Kawde (PW-3), Ramprasad Netam, and Ghana Anchala, proceeded to the field where, in the light of a torch, they found Bivan Hidko lying dead in a pool of blood. It was specifically alleged in the merg information (Exh P/1) that some unknown persons had assaulted and killed Bivan with a sharp-edged weapon.
28. A very significant fact which remains undisputed is regarding the prior enmity between the prosecution witnesses (PW-1 and PW-2) and the accused-appellant herein. It is an admitted position that during the subsisting marriage of Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2) with the deceased Bivan Hidko, he married Smt. Binda Bai (PW-6), the sister of the present accused-appellant, and serious differences had arisen between the parties owing to this relationship. Panchayats were convened, wherein quarrels flared up between them. It is in this backdrop of prior enmity that we shall proceed to appreciate the evidence of the two star witnesses, Heeralal Hidko (PW-1) and Smt. Sukmai Hidko (PW-2), on whose testimony the entire prosecution case hinges.
29. Heeralal Hidko (PW-1) testified as below: - “(1) I know the three accused (Govind Mandavi, Narendra Nag, Mansingh Nureti) in the Court. Bivan Hidko was my son who has died. Our caste is Gond.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.