Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v. The State of West Bengal
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1373; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 258
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice N Kotiswar Singh, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 2 Dec 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5146/2025
- Sections
- 354C, 341, 506, 354, 41A, 161, 164, 227, 227CR, 339
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 258 : 2025 INSC 1373 Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v.
The State of West Bengal (Criminal Appeal No. 5146 of 2025)
02 December 2025 [Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh and Manmohan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The Revision Petition filed by the Appellant-accused against the order dismissing the discharge application filed by the Appellant in FIR No.50/2020 dated 19.03.2020 lodged with police station Bidhannagar North, was dismissed by the High Court. Whether there are sufficient grounds for proceeding against the Appellantaccused for the offences alleged in the FIR.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.341, 354C, 506 – The complainant, an alleged tenant of A, one of the co-owners of the property filed a complaint/FIR u/ss.341, 354C, 506 of IPC – It was alleged that when the complainant along with her friend and workmen tried to enter the property, the Appellant-accused intimidated them and restrained them from entering the property – The complainant further alleged that the Appellant-accused intimidated the complainant by clicking her pictures and making her videos on his mobile without her consent and by doing so, he intruded upon her privacy and outraged her modesty – Chargesheet was filed – Application for discharge filed by the accused was dismissed by the Trial Court – Revision Petition against the order of the Trial Court was dismissed by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: At the stage of discharge, a strong suspicion suffices – However, a strong suspicion must be found on some material which can be translated into evidence at the stage of trial – FIR and chargesheet do not disclose an offence u/s.354C of IPC – Upon a perusal of the FIR and chargesheet on record, this Court is unable to conclude an offence u/s.354C of the IPC since there is no allegation in the FIR and chargesheet that the complainant * Author [2025] 12 S.C.R. 259Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v. The State of West Bengal was watched or captured by the appellant-accused while she was engaging in a ‘private act’ – Further, ingredients of criminal intimidation are not attracted – Except for the bald allegation that the Appellant-accused intimidated the complainant by clicking her photographs, the FIR and chargesheet are completely silent about the manner in which the complainant was threatened with any injury to her person or her property – Also, offence of wrongful restraint is not made out – In the present case, the right of the complainant to enter the property stems from the virtue of being a purported tenant of A – However, no material has been placed on record along with the chargesheet which indicates that the complainant was a tenant in the property at any point of time – In fact, the induction of the complainant as tenant in the property would have been in violation of the injunction passed by the Trial Court – This Court is of the opinion that all that the Appellant-accused did was to enforce what he bonafidely thought was his lawful right over the property in terms of the injunction order passed by the Trial Court – Consequently, this Court is of the view that criminal proceedings against the Appellant-accused for offences punishable u/ss.341, 354C, 506 of IPC cannot be permitted to continue. [Paras 17, 19, 20, 22, 25-27] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Chargesheets – Framing of charges – Tendency of filing chargesheets and framing charges in matters where no strong suspicion is made out clogs the Judicial system:
Held: This Court would like to emphasise that where there is a pending civil dispute between the parties, the Police and the Criminal Courts must be circumspect in filing a chargesheet and framing charges respectively – In a society governed by rule of law, the decision to file a chargesheet should be based on the Investigating Officer’s determination of whether the evidence collected provides a reasonable prospect of conviction – The Police at the stage of filing of Chargesheet and the Criminal Court at the stage of framing of Charge must act as initial filters ensuring that only cases with a strong suspicion should proceed to the formal trial stage to maintain the efficiency and integrity of the judicial system – The tendency of filing chargesheets in matters where no strong suspicion is made out clogs the judicial system – It forces Judges, court staff, and prosecutors to spend time on trials that are likely to result in an acquittal – This diverts limited judicial 260 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports resources from handling stronger, more serious cases, contributing to massive case backlogs – Undoubtedly, there can be no analysis at the charge framing stage as to whether the case would end in conviction or acquittal, but the fundamental principle is that the State should not prosecute citizens without a reasonable prospect of conviction, as it compromises the right to a fair process. [Para 28] Case Law Cited Ram Prakash Chadha v. State of UP [2024] 7 SCR 1155 : (2024) 10 SCC 651; M.E. Shivalingamurthy v. Central Bureau of Investigation Bengaluru [2020] 1 SCR 794 : (2020) 2 SCC 768 – relied on. Stree Atyachar Virodhi Parishad v. Dilip Nathumal Chordia [1989] 1 SCR 560 : (1989) 1 SCC 715; P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala [2010] 2 SCR 78 : (2010) 2 SCC 398; Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal [1979] 2 SCR 229 : (1979) 3 SCC 4 – referred to. List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Chargesheet; Framing charges; Civil Dispute; Pending civil dispute; Integrity of Judicial system; Conviction; Acquittal; Wrongul restraint; Section 341 of IPC; Criminal Intimidation; Section 506 of IPC; Section 354 of IPC; Voyeurism; Private Act; Privacy; Modesty; Stage of discharge; Injunction; Violation of injunction. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5146 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 30.01.2024 of the High Court at Calcutta in CRR No. 3443 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
V. Somnath Ghoshal, Anupama Chakraborty, Sahid Uddin Ahmed, Towseef Ahmad Dar, Ms. Zinat Sultana.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Kunal Mimani, Prashant Alai.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 261Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v. The State of West Bengal Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manmohan, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The present Appeal has been filed challenging the judgment dated 30 th January 2024 passed by the Calcutta High Court, whereby the revision petition filed by the Appellant-accused against the order dismissing the discharge application filed by the Appellant in FIR No.50/2020 dated 19 th March 2020 lodged with police station Bidhannagar North, was dismissed.
FACTS
3. On 19th March 2020, the complainant-Ms. Mamta Agarwal, an alleged tenant of Mr. Amalendu Biswas, one of the co-owners of the property at CF-231, Sector I, Salt Lake, Kolkata 700064 (“the property”) filed a complaint/FIR under Sections 341, 354C, 506 of Indian Penal Code (‘IPC’). The complainant alleged that on 18 th March 2020, when the complainant along with her friend and workmen tried to enter the property, the Appellant-accused intimidated them and restrained them from entering the property. The complainant further alleged that the Appellant-accused intimidated the complainant by clicking her pictures and making her videos on his mobile without her consent and by doing so, he intruded upon her privacy and outraged her modesty.
4. Upon completion of investigation, a chargesheet dated 16 th August 2020 was presented against the Appellant-accused for offences punishable under Sections 341, 354C and 506 of IPC. It is stated in the chargesheet that the complainant expressed her unwillingness to make a judicial statement. The relevant portion of the chargesheet in question is reproduced hereinbelow:- “17. Brief facts of case: Bidhannagar North P.S. Case No:50/2020 Dated 19.03.2020 U/S 341/354C/506 IPC has been started on the basis of written Complaint of one Mamta Agarwal of I/B, Kustia Road, Kolkata – 700039. The fact in brief is that on 19.03.2020 at about 15.00 hrs. while she along with her friend were entering into the premise, 262 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports located at CF-231, Sector-1, Salt Lake, Kolkata-700 064, PS BDN(N), they were restrained by one Tuhin Kr. Biswas @ Bumba. Some argument took place between them.
Said Tuhin Kr. Biswas snapped some photographs and recorded video, which caused outrage of female modesty of the complainant. Being endorsed by IC, Bidhannagar North PS, I took up its investigation.
During investigation all follow-up actions were taken.
Notice u/s 41A Cr.P.C. was complied with by the accused but he didn’t surrender before Ld. Court. The complainant expressed her unwillingness to make judicial statement. Discussed with IC, Bidhannagar North PS and considering all aspects, he opined to submit Charge Sheet in this case. Hence, I do submit Charge sheet vide BDN(N) PS CS No.128/2020 Dated 16.08.2020 u/s 341/354C/506 IPC against accused Tuhin Kr. Biswas @ Bumba S/O Bimanlendu Biswas of CF-231, Sector-1, Salt Lake Kolkata-700 064, PS-BDN(N) to stand his trial in the open Court of law.
The witnesses, noted in Col. No.14, will prove the charge during trial. They may kindly be summoned. Kept the complainant informed about the result of investigation.”
5. Thereafter, the Appellant-accused, who is son of one of the co-owners of the property in question filed an application seeking discharge, which was dismissed by the Trial Court vide order dated 29 th August 2023. The revision petition against the order dated 29 th August 2023 was dismissed by the learned Single Judge vide the impugned judgment.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
6. Learned counsel for the Appellant-accused stated that the two brothers (Mr. Bimalendu Biswas and Mr. Amalendu Biswas) are the joint owners of the property in question and one of the brothers, being Mr. Amalendu Biswas, had tried to dispossess the other brother without due process of law. He stated that said other brother, being father of the Appellant-accused, filed a civil suit being Title Suit No. 20 of 2018 with respect to the property in question against Mr. Amalendu [2025] 12 S.C.R. 263Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v. The State of West Bengal Biswas. He pointed out that vide order dated 29th November 2018, the learned Civil Judge directed the parties to maintain joint possession of the property as well as not to alienate the property and/or not to create any third-party interest in the property. He emphasized that the said injunction was prevalent on the date of the incident which led to filing of the FIR. The relevant portion of the injunction order dated 29th November 2018 is reproduced hereinbelow:- “….Both the parties should maintain a joint possession in the suit property. Both parties are hereby restrained from disturbing the joint possession of the other in the suit property and from alienating the suit property or creating 3rd party interest in the suit property till disposal of the suit…”
7. He alleged that the FIR in question had been registered at the behest of Mr.Amalendu Biswas, who attempted to dispossess the Appellant-accused and his father from the property in violation of the injunction order passed by the Trial Court.
8. He contended that on the date of the incident, the complainant had entered the property with anti-social elements in a bid to dispossess the Appellant-accused’s father. He pointed out that the complainant- Ms. Mamta Agarwal is a habitual offender and has been charged with offences under Sections 302 & 307 of IPC in one case, and offences under Sections 323, 341, 506(II) & 114 of IPC in another case. He emphasised that the complainant is not a tenant in the property. He further stated that in the chargesheet, the investigating agency has not adduced any document pertaining to tenancy of the complainant.
9. He alleged that the other side, i.e., Mr. Amalendu Biswas was in the process of creating third-party rights in violation of the injunction and mere protest against creation of such third-party rights by the other litigant over the property did not attract Section 341 or 506 of IPC.
10. He stated that the allegations in the FIR did not disclose the commission of an offence under Section 354C of IPC. He stated that no photographs or seizure had been placed on record to substantiate the allegations of voyeurism. He submitted that despite the finding given by the learned Single Judge that the allegation in the FIR did not disclose any offence under Section 354C of IPC, the learned Single Judge did not quash the FIR or discharge the Appellant qua the said offence. He stated that the complaint was 264 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports silent with respect to the threatening language allegedly uttered by the Appellant-accused.
11. He stated that there are no statements under Section 161 of Code of Criminal Procedure (‘Cr.P.C’). of the alleged friend accompanying the complainant or her workmen. He further stated that the complainant had also expressed her unwillingness to get her statement recorded under Section 164 of Cr.P.C., thereby indicating the falsity of her allegations in the FIR.
12. He contended that the allegations in the FIR are false and even if they are accepted at face value, no case is made out against the Appellant-accused.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT-STATE
13. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the Respondent-State stated that the complainant was only a prospective tenant. He pointed out that in his statement, the other co-owner of the property, being Mr. Amalendu Biswas had stated that the complainant had come to see the ground floor of the property. He emphasized that there was sufficient material on record which made out a prima facie case against the Appellant-accused for offences punishable under Sections 341 and 506 of IPC. He relied upon the following observations and findings of the High Court in the impugned Judgment:- “14. With regard to truthfulness, sufficiency or admissibility of the charge under Section 341/506 of the IPC made in the FIR, it cannot be said to be a matter falling within the domain of exercising jurisdiction under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure at the time of consideration of a prayer for discharge.
15. On careful scrutiny of the order impugned, I find no reason to interfere with the order whereby Ld. Magistrate refused to discharge the accused and fixed a date for framing of charge and hearing of the petition.
16. Thus, the revision application being no. CRR 3443 of 2023 is hereby dismissed. Ld. Trial Court is directed to frame charge, keeping an eye on the observation made by this Court after giving an opportunity of hearing to both the parties.”
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 265Tuhin Kumar Biswas @ Bumba v. The State of West Bengal
REASONING
ABSENT A STRONG SUSPICION, AN ACCUSED CAN BE
DISCHARGED
14. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, this Court is of the view that before proceeding with the matter, it is essential to outline the legal principles to be kept in mind by the Court while deciding an application seeking discharge.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.