Surendra Koli v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1308; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 152
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Surya Kant, Justice Vikram Nath
- Decided
- 11 Nov 2025
- Case number
- CURATIVE PETITION (CRL) No. 60/2025
- Sections
- 164, 27, 24
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 152 : 2025 INSC 1308 Surendra Koli v.
The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
(Curative Petition (Crl.) No. 60 of 2025)
In (R.P. (Crl.) No. 395 of 2014)
In (Crl. A. No. 2227 of 2010)
11 November 2025 [Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, CJI, Surya Kant and Vikram Nath,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the present case meets the exacting threshold for the exercise of the curative jurisdiction of this Court and; whether two sets of outcomes of this Court can stand together when they rest on an identical evidentiary foundation; whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the curative petition ought to be allowed and the petitioner be acquitted of the charges u/ss.302, 364, 376 and 201, IPC.
Headnotes† Curative Petition – Nithari Case – Two sets of outcomes resting on an identical evidentiary foundation – Impermissibility – Exercise of curative jurisdiction – In Criminal Appeal No. 2227 of 2010 decided on 15.02.2011, Supreme Court affirmed the petitioner’s conviction and sentence of death in the Rimpa Haldar case on the strength of a s.164, CrPC confession and supposed discoveries u/s.27, Evidence Act – Review petition against this order was dismissed – However, in twelve companion prosecutions founded on the same confession and recoveries, the High Court acquitted the petitioner on 16.10.2023, and vide order dtd. 30.07.2025, Supreme Court dismissed the State appeals and affirmed those acquittals rejecting the very same confession and the very same class of s.27 material as legally unreliable – Present petition filed * Author [2025] 12 S.C.R. 153Surendra Koli v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. by the petitioner on the ground that irreconcilable outcomes have arisen on an identical evidentiary framework and that a manifest miscarriage of justice remains despite the dismissal of review:
Held: The present case meets the exacting threshold for the exercise of the curative jurisdiction – Petitioner has established a fundamental defect that impeaches the integrity of the adjudicatory process and that relief is warranted ex debito justitiae within the parameters of Rupa Ashok Hurra case – The confession that anchored the conviction is legally tainted on grounds already accepted by this Court in the companion matters – The supposed discoveries do not satisfy the statutory preconditions for admissibility – The forensic and investigative record does not supply the missing links – Once those keystones are removed, the circumstantial chain no longer holds – Art.21 of the Constitution insists on a fair, just and reasonable procedure – That insistence is at its acutest where capital punishment is imposed – Although the petitioner’s death sentence in this case was commuted to imprisonment for life on 28.01.2015 by the High Court in writ proceedings challenging the rejection of his mercy petition, the conviction continues to carry the gravest consequences – To allow a conviction to stand on evidentiary basis that this Court has since rejected as involuntary or inadmissible in the very same fact-matrix offends Art.21 – It also violates Art.14 since like cases must be treated alike – Arbitrary disparity in outcomes on an identical record is inimical to equality before the law – Curative petition allowed – Judgment dtd. 15.02.2011 in Criminal Appeal No. 2227 of 2010 and the order in Review Petition are recalled and set aside – Petitioner acquitted – Constitution of India – Arts.21, 14. [Paras 9, 15, 16, 19-22] Curative Petition – Curative jurisdiction – Threshold for exercise of, stated. [Paras 2-4] Case Law Cited Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra [2002] 2 SCR 1006 : (2002) 4 SCC 388 – followed.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Constitution of India; Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Supreme Court Rules, 2013. 154 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Curative petition; Curative jurisdiction; Threshold for invoking curative jurisdiction; Threshold for exercise of curative jurisdiction; Manifest miscarriage of justice; Grave miscarriage of justice; Exacting threshold; Nithari Case; Two sets of outcomes; Identical Evidentiary foundation; ex debito justitiae; Rupa Ashok Hurra case; Like cases must be treated alike.
Case Arising From INHERENT JURISDICTION: Curative Petition (Crl.) No. 60 of 2025 In R.P. (Crl.) No. 395 of 2014 In Crl. A. No. 2227 of 2010 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.10.2014 of the Supreme Court at Delhi in RR No. 395 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioner:
Yug Mohit Chaudhary, Ms. Payoshi Roy, Siddhartha Sharma, Prabhu Ramasubramaniam, N. Sai Vinod, Bharatimohan M, Ms. Kanu Garg.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Raja Thakare, A.S.G., Nachiketa Joshi, Sr. Adv., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, K. Parameshwar, Praneet Pranav, Rajendra Singh Rana, Ms. Vaishali Verma, Rohit Khare, Ms. Astha Singh, Rishikesh Haridas, Kritagya Kumar Kait.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. Delay condoned.
This curative petition presents an exceptional case for the exercise of our curative jurisdiction. The petitioner shows that a manifest [2025] 12 S.C.R. 155Surendra Koli v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. miscarriage of justice endures and that two sets of outcomes resting on the same evidentiary foundation cannot lawfully coexist. When final orders of this Court speak with discordant voices on an identical record, the integrity of adjudication is imperilled, and public confidence is shaken. In such a situation, intervention ex debito justitiae is not an act of discretion but a constitutional duty. We therefore entertain this petition to preserve the purity of this Court’s process and to vindicate the rule of law.
2. The curative jurisdiction of this Court exists to prevent abuse of process and to cure a gross miscarriage of justice. In Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra 1, the Constitution Bench of this Court recognised that this power flows from the inherent authority of this Court to do complete justice and to protect the integrity of its judgments. However, the constitutional source of this power is coherent and limited. Article 129 of the Constitution of India (hereinafter “The Constitution”) declares this Court to be a court of record with inherent powers to preserve the purity of its process. Article 142 of the Constitution empowers this Court to make such orders as are necessary for doing complete justice. Article 137 of the Constitution recognises the power of review and marks its limits. Article 145 of the Constitution of India authorises the framing of rules. Order XLVIII of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013, titled “Curative Petition” prescribes the filing requirements, the certification by a Senior Advocate, and the preliminary circulation to a bench as indicated in Rupa Ashok Hurra (Supra). These provisions together sustain a narrow jurisdiction that may be invoked only after review has failed to correct a grave defect.
3. Moreover, we must emphasize that Rupa Ashok Hurra (Supra) makes it clear that a curative petition is not a second review. Finality remains the rule and intervention is reserved only for very strong reasons that strike at the legitimacy of the adjudicatory process. The court has stated that only certain foundational circumstances demand relief as a matter of justice. One is a violation of natural justice where a person is adversely affected without being heard or without proper notice. Another is a case where a Judge failed to disclose a connection with the subject matter or with a party which gives rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The instances are illustrative
1 (2002) 4 SCC 388
156 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and not exhaustive. The guiding principle for the exercise of curative jurisdiction is the duty of this Court to avert manifest injustice.
4. The controlling test is whether the earlier decision produces a result that offends the conscience of this Court because of a fundamental defect in process or because of a grave miscarriage of justice. Such defects may appear where outcomes are irreconcilably inconsistent on the same substratum of facts and evidence or where material circumstances bearing on fairness and reliability were overlooked or where the guarantees of equality and due process under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution stand compromised. Even when leave to proceed is granted, the inquiry remains narrow. This Court does not sit in appeal over its own final judgment and does not reappraise evidence as if in a second appeal. The question is whether intervention is necessary to vindicate the rule of law and to restore confidence in the administration of justice. With these principles in view we shall now examine whether the present case meets the exacting threshold for the exercise of the curative jurisdiction of this Court.
5. This curative petition arises from Criminal Appeal No. 2227 of 2010 decided on 15.02.2011, by which this Court affirmed the petitioner’s conviction and sentence of death in the Rimpa Haldar case. The review petition against this order was dismissed on 28.10.2014 in Review Petition (Crl.) No. 395 of 2014. On 28.01.2015, the High Court commuted the death sentence to imprisonment for life. In twelve companion prosecutions founded on the same confession and recoveries, the High Court acquitted the petitioner on 16.10.2023, and on 30.07.2025, this Court dismissed the State appeals and affirmed those acquittals. The present petition filed by the petitioner on the ground that irreconcilable outcomes have arisen on an identical evidentiary framework and that a manifest miscarriage of justice remains despite the dismissal of review.
6. The Nithari Case Background:
6.1. Surendra Koli, the petitioner herein, was employed as a domestic help at House D5, Sector 31, Noida. The house was owned and occupied by one Moninder Singh Pandher, the employer of the petitioner. From early 2005 residents of Nithari began reporting that women and children were missing. In March 2005, children in the neighbourhood playing cricket noticed a human hand in [2025] 12 S.C.R. 157Surendra Koli v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. the narrow open strip between Houses D5 and D6 and the Jal Board residential quarters. On 03.12.2006, a human hand was again noticed during drain cleaning on the main road in front of the row of bungalows D1 to D6.
6.2. On 29.12.2006, the local police took the petitioner into custody in connection with FIR No. 838 of 2006 concerning the disappearance of Payal, one of the victims. On the same day Pandher was detained outside D5. When the police and panch witnesses reached D5, a large crowd had already gathered and digging was underway in the open strip between D5, D6 and the Jal Board compound. Multiple skulls and bones with footwear and clothes were recovered from that strip on 29.12.2006. A knife was recovered from beneath the terrace water tank of D5. On 31.12.2006 further human remains and articles were taken out from the covered storm water drain in front of Houses D1 to D6. Multiple FIRs were registered on 30.12.2006 for different missing persons.
6.3. On 09.01.2007, the State transferred investigation to the Central Bureau of Investigation under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946. A team from the Forensic Science Laboratory at Agra examined D5 between 04.01.2007 and 06.01.2007. Teams from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences and the Central Forensic Science Laboratory assisted the CBI in searches at and around D5 through mid-January 2007.
6.4. Thirteen trials followed. Each proceeded on a common evidentiary foundation that comprised the alleged disclosure leading to recoveries and the confessional statement under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19732 . The present matter concerns the case relating to Rimpa Haldar, a minor who went missing in 2005.
7. First round of litigation (Rimpa Haldar case)
7.1. By judgment dated 13.02.2009 in Sessions Trial No. 611 of 2007, the Trial Court convicted the petitioner for the death of Rimpa Haldar under Sections 302, 364, 376 and 201 of the 2 CrPC 158 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Indian Penal Code, 18603 and imposed the death sentence. The Trial Court relied on a confession recorded on 01.03.2007 under Section 164 of the CrPC, on recoveries said to have been made at the petitioner’s instance from House No. D-5, Sector 31, Noida, and on a chain of circumstantial facts. The confession runs to several pages and states that the petitioner lured the victim Rimpa Haldar into D-5, strangled her with a chunni, engaged in sexual assault after death, dismembered the body, and disposed parts in the rear gallery and in the stormwater drain. The Magistrate recorded preliminary questions on voluntariness. The Trial Court treated the confession as voluntary and truthful and found corroboration in the recovery of skulls and bones from the rear gallery and drain, in the identification of the victim’s clothing by relatives, and in DNA profiling reported by the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, Hyderabad, which matched remains with the blood samples of the victim’s parents.
7.2. On 11.09.2009, the High Court affirmed the conviction and sentence of death of the Petitioner and acquitted the coaccused, Moninder Singh Pandher, in this case. The High Court treated the confession under Section 164 CrPC as voluntary and reliable. It also found corroboration in material particulars. It relied on recoveries of skulls, bones, clothing and footwear from the enclosed gallery behind D-5 and from the adjacent drain, identification of articles by relatives of victims including Payal, one of the victims, and the testimony of two young girls, PW-27 Pratibha and PW-28 Purnima, who described attempts by the petitioner to lure them towards D-5, which the High Court viewed as revealing the Petitioner’s modus operandi. The High Court also noted forensic linkage through DNA analysis and held that the circumstantial chain was complete. In acquitting Moninder Singh Pandher, the High Court recorded that there was no substantive evidence connecting him with the crime, that the petitioner’s confession was not admissible against a co-accused, that recoveries were pursuant to the petitioner’s disclosure, and that no overt act or presence of Pandher was proved in relation to this offence.
3 In short “IPC”
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 159Surendra Koli v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr.
7.3. On 15.02.2011, a two-Judge Bench of this Court dismissed Criminal Appeal No. 2227 of 2010 and affirmed the conviction and sentence of death. This Court recorded that the confession under Section 164 CrPC was voluntary and that statutory safeguards were observed. It noted the petitioner’s detailed admissions and his leading of the police to the place where multiple skulls and bones were recovered, as well as the seizure of a knife from D-5. It referred to the evidence of PW-27 and PW-28 as indicative of the petitioner’s modus operandi. It relied on DNA analysis by the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics matching remains to the blood samples of Rimpa Haldar’s parents and brother, and on the role of doctors from the All India Institute of Medical Sciences in assembling recovered parts. The recoveries were treated as admissible under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 4 . Characterising the petitioner as a serial killer, this Court held that the case fell within the “rarest of rare” category and upheld the sentence of death.
7.4. On 28.10.2014, after an open-court hearing, this Court dismissed Review Petition (Crl.) No. 395 of 2014. The Court reiterated the narrow compass of review under Article 137 of the Constitution, found no error apparent on the face of the record, and declined to revisit findings on voluntariness or evidentiary appreciation. The submission regarding ineffective assistance at trial was rejected at the review stage.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.