Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1160; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1575
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kumar
- Decided
- 25 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6581/2025
- Sections
- 125, 86(1), 73
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1575 : 2025 INSC 1160 Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v.
Essar Power Limited and Another (Civil Appeal No(s). 6581-6582 of 2025)
25 September 2025 [Sanjay Kumar* and Alok Aradhe, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the appellant-GUVNL is entitled to reimbursement of the fixed charges, in relation to the diverted electricity from out of its allocated share by Essar Power Limited (EPL) to its sister company-Essar Steel Limited (ESL), in addition to the compensation payable for such wrongful diversion.
Headnotes† Electricity – Proportionate principle of allocation – Reimbursement of fixed charges in relation to the diverted electricity – Predecessor-in-interest of GUVNL-Gujarat Electricity Board (GEB), entered into a PPA with EPL for purchase of the electricity generated by EPL – Total installed capacity of EPL’s plant was 515 MW and 300 MW thereof was to be supplied to GEB under the PPA – EPL entered into a separate PPA with its sister company-ESL, for sale and supply of the remaining 215 MW – However, in breach of the agreed proportionate shares in the electricity generated by it, EPL started supplying more power to its sister company-ESL, from out of the allocated share of GEB – In earlier rounds of litigation, issue of diversion of its allocated electricity along with the consequences thereof was raised by GUVNL in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited [2016] 5 SCR 101 (relied on by both the parties herein) wherein interpreting the PPA to determine whether there was obligation to declare availability of power in a particular proportion, this Court inter alia held that EPL was under obligation as per PPA to declare weekly schedule of capacity available and that it shall not divert any power to its sister concern in a manner contrary to the proportionate principle; and that GERC was * Author 1576 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports right in holding that once the entire capacity was allocated in two parts in a particular proportion, EPL was not right in selling power to its sister concern beyond the allocated capacity; APTEL’s judgment was set aside and GERC’s order was restored – As GERC had left the actual working out of the loss suffered by GUVNL to be worked out separately and, on that basis, GUVNL had already filed a petition, it was directed that the same could be revived and considered in the light of its findings – Petition was disposed of by GERC vide order dtd.27.12.2019 – GUVNL and EPL assailed GERC’s order before APTEL, which was disposed of by the impugned order dtd.21.03.2025 – Finding of GERC and the APTEL that GUVNL is not entitled to reimbursement of fixed charges, if, sustainable – GUVNL, if entitled to reimbursement of the fixed charges, in relation to the diverted electricity from out of its allocated share, in addition to the compensation payable for such wrongful diversion – Total amount that can be claimed by GUVNL for the electricity diverted by EPL to ESL from out of its allocated share, that is, 58% of the available electricity for the entire plant declared on a weekly basis:
Held: 1.1 Disjointed reading of specific paragraphs or even sentences of Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited [2016] 5 SCR 101, out of context, would not be the proper approach to understand the import of the decision – It must be read as a whole and in its entirety to glean the findings and ratio decidendi laid down therein. [Paras 12, 14-16, 20-23] 1.2 In the light of para 9.13 in GERC’s order dated 18.02.2009 which was affirmed by this Court in the earlier round, it is not open to GUVNL to agitate its claim for compensation beyond what was determined as just and acceptable in the said para and was accepted and confirmed by this Court, while restoring the order of GERC. [Para 29] 1.3 The issue before this Court is as to the total amount that can be claimed by GUVNL for the electricity diverted by EPL to ESL from out of its allocated share, that is, 58% of the available electricity for the entire plant declared on a weekly basis – ‘Compensation’ could only be claimed by GUVNL for such wrongful diversion by EPL on the basis of HTP–1 Tariff Energy Charge, as this was what was found to be an appropriate method for computing compensation on the basis of the earlier settlement arrived at by and between the [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1577Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another parties for the period April, 1998 to September, 2004 – However, neither GERC nor the APTEL took note of what was stated earlier by this Court and GERC with regard to ‘reimbursement’ of fixed charges. [Para 31] 1.4 The finding of GERC and the APTEL that GUVNL is not entitled to reimbursement of fixed charges is unsustainable – Once GUVNL did not receive the electricity for which such fixed charges had been computed and paid on a monthly basis, it was entitled to reimbursement thereof, not as compensation, but on the principle of restitution as such payment was not at all due from it – GUVNL was entitled to reimbursement of the fixed charges, in relation to the diverted electricity from out of its allocated share, in addition to the compensation payable for such wrongful diversion, computed on the basis of HTP-1 Tariff Energy Charge. [Para 38] 1.5 As regards the computation of the electricity diversion being made on hourly or half-hourly basis, the PPA dated 30.05.1996 executed by and between GEB and EPL provided u/Art.1 thereof that ‘Availability Period’ would mean ‘each of the 24 consecutive periods of 60 minutes in each day’ – Similarly, the PPA dated 29.06.1996 between EPL and ESL provided u/Art.1 that the ‘Availability Period’ would mean ‘each of the 24 consecutive periods of 60 minutes in each day’ – Therefore, there was no difference in the two PPAs as to the computation methodology. [Para 39] 1.6 Further, as the power diversion, for which GUVNL has to be paid compensation, is for the supply made by EPL to ESL, over and above its allocated share, and as it was at the behest of EPL itself that this half-hourly computation methodology was adopted, pursuant to the recommendation of the Central Electricity Authority (CEA), there is no reason why the very same methodology should not be used for computing the electricity diversion so as to quantify the compensation payable to GUVNL for the excess power supply made to ESL by EPL from out of GUVNL’s allocated share. [Para 40] 1.7 Order dtd.27.12.2019 passed by GERC and the judgment dtd.21.03.2025 passed by the APTEL modified to the extent indicated. [Para 42] Words and Phrases – ‘compensation’ vis-à-vis ‘reimbursement’: Held: ‘Compensation’ imply the payment to be made to one party to make good the loss or damage suffered by it owing to a breach 1578 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports or violation of an obligation by the other – Reimbursement of fixed charges flowed from the provisions of the PPA itself and was not traceable only to the breach by EPL, in terms of the diverted capacity which fell to GUVNL’s share. [Para 35] Case Law Cited Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited [2016] 5 SCR 101 : (2016) 9 SCC 103 – explained.
List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; Contract Act, 1872.
List of Keywords Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited (GUVNL); Gujarat Electricity Board (GEB); Essar Power Limited (EPL); Essar Steel Limited (ESL); Electricity diversion; Electricity diverted from allocated share; Power diversion; Proportionate principle of allocation; Reimbursement of fixed charges; ‘Compensation’; Computation of electricity diversion; Hourly or half-hourly basis; Computation methodology; Power Purchase Agreement (PPA); Principle of restitution.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 6581-6582 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.03.2025 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi in AN No. 138 of 2021 and AN No. 201 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
C.A. Sundaram, M.G. Ramachandran, Sr. Advs., Ms. Hemantika Wahi, Anand Ganesan, Ms. Ranjitha Ramachandran, Ms. Jesal Wahi, Ms. Srishti Khindaria, Utkarsh Singh.
Advs. for the Respondents:
C.S. Vaidyanathan, Buddy Ranganatdhan, Sr. Advs., Mahesh Agarwal, Rohan Talwar, E. C. Agrawala, Shashwat Singh, Naman Agarwal, Ms. Shefail Tripathi.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1579Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Kumar, J.
1. A tortuous litigative journey since the year 2005, notwithstanding, the matter is before this Court yet again.
2. By way of these appeals filed under Section 125 of the Electricity Act, 2003, Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited (GUVNL) assails the common judgment dated 21.03.2025 passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi (APTEL) in Appeal Nos. 138 of 2021 and 201 of 2023. Appeal No. 138 of 2021 was preferred by GUVNL while Appeal No. 201 of 2023 was filed by Essar Power Limited (EPL). These appeals were directed against the order dated 27.12.2019 passed by Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission, Gandhi Nagar (GERC), in Petition No. 972 of 2009 filed by GUVNL.
3. Before considering the impact and effect of the past litigation between the parties and the orders passed therein, including by this Court, it would be apposite to note the factual narrative.
4. Shorn of unnecessary detail, relevant facts unfold thus: Gujarat Electricity Board (GEB), the predecessor-in-interest of GUVNL, entered into a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) with EPL on 30.05.1996 for purchase of the electricity generated by EPL from its plant at Hazira for a period of 20 years. The total installed capacity of EPL’s plant was 515 MW and 300 MW thereof was to be supplied to GEB under the above PPA. EPL entered into a separate PPA with Essar Steel Limited (ESL), its sister company, on 29.06.1996 for sale and supply of the remaining 215 MW. In effect, the proportionate share of GEB and ESL in the electricity generated by EPL was in the ratio of 58.25:41.75, rounded off to 58:42.
5. The cause for grievance, laying foundation for the inception of this litigation in the year 2005, dates back long prior thereto. In breach of the agreed proportionate shares in the electricity generated by it, EPL started supplying more power to its sister company, ESL, from out of the allocated share of GEB. This issue was raised by GEB, contending that EPL had supplied over its proportionate share of electricity to ESL which should be treated as deemed 1580 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports supply of electricity by GEB itself and it should be compensated. EPL addressed letter dated 17.02.2000 to GEB, wherein it stated that if ESL drew more power than its allocated capacity, then GEB should charge ESL for the excess power drawn, as EPL’s deemed power supply to GEB, but in that case no deemed non-generation penalty should be imposed upon EPL. Eventually, GEB addressed letter dated 29.07.2004 to EPL about under-allocation of power to it and proposed recovery, on monthly basis, in terms of EPL’s letter dated 17.02.2000. GEB asked EPL to confirm the same to enable it to process the bill for the month of June, 2004 after adjusting the proposed recovery. There was further correspondence on the issue and GEB finally addressed letter dated 30.10.2004 to EPL, stating that a sum of ₹64 Crores would be recovered from EPL’s pending monthly invoices for diverting GEB’s allocated share from EPL’s 515 MW plant to its sister company, ESL, by treating the same as deemed supply by GEB from April, 1998 till September, 2004. GEB further stated that recovery in respect of such diversion of energy from its allocated share to ESL from October, 2004 onwards would also be effected from the monthly invoices.
6. This was followed up by GEB’s letter dated 11.11.2004 informing EPL of how the sum of ₹64 Crores was computed. The tabular statement in this letter set out the details of the energy diversion to ESL from 1998 till September, 2004. The amount recoverable was worked out, on the basis of HTP-1 Tariff Energy Charge @ ₹04.10 per kWh, and after adjusting reimbursement of variable charges, the total recovery to be made for that period was quantified at ₹64 Crores. It was made clear that this recovery had been worked out without applying electricity duty and that EPL would be informed about the amount recoverable on that count after receipt of legal opinion. Notably, the letter ended with the caveat that it was without prejudice to GEB’s rights under the provisions of the PPA.
7. In response, EPL addressed letter dated 30.11.2004 to GEB stating that, with a view to close the discussion on the supply of power to ESL in excess of allocated capacity, it accepted GEB’s claim for ₹64 Crores. EPL thanked GEB officials for having closed the matter that was under discussion for the past few years and concluded by stating that it trusted that the methodology that had been finalized would be the basis adopted for the future. However, by letter dated 31.12.2004, GEB informed EPL that the amount of ₹64 Crores was [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1581Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another not in final settlement of the issue nor was the methodology final for charging for the energy diverted in excess of the proportionate principle. GEB further stated that electricity duty was chargeable on such recovery and it would work out the final recovery amount and inform EPL accordingly.
8. Thereafter, GUVNL came into existence on 01.04.2005 upon the unbundling of GEB. On 14.09.2005, GUVNL filed a claim before GERC under Section 86(1)(f) of the Electricity Act, 2003, which came to be numbered as Petition No. 873 of 2006, seeking a declaration that it was entitled to adjust from the tariff payable by it to EPL all such amounts that were received by EPL as a result of wrongful allocation of electricity. This petition was disposed of by GERC, vide order dated 18.02.2009, concluding thus:
1) that, EPL was obligated at all times under the PPA dated 30.05.1996 to declare the capacity from its entire generating station, as provided in Schedule VI of the PPA; 2) that, once such declared availability was made known, GUVNL was entitled to issue dispatch instructions in accordance with the terms of the PPA;
3) that, supply of electricity was to be made by EPL in proportion to the allocated capacity of 300 MW:215 MW, in accordance with the dispatch instructions;
4) that, the claims of GUVNL prior to 14.09.2002, on account of adjustment of Deemed Generation Incentive and diversion of allocated electricity (except to the extent of settlement of ₹64 Crores for diversion of electricity by EPL to ESL, in excess of 215 MW, from 1998 to September, 2004), was barred by limitation;
5) that, for the period after 14.09.2002, whenever EPL failed to declare the entire capacity of the plant, the supplies made by it to ESL in excess of the proportionate principle, as set out, was liable to be held as supply of electricity by GUVNL to ESL and GUVNL was entitled to be compensated for such supply at the prevailing HTP-1 Tariff, less variable costs, as was previously accepted by the parties for the diversion of electricity in excess of 215 MW;
1582 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 6) that, after 14.09.2002, if GUVNL did not schedule energy to the extent allocated under the proportionate principle, even though EPL had declared the capacity for the entire generating station in terms of Schedule VI of the PPA, then EPL was entitled to supply the additional power that was available to ESL upon reimbursing the proportionate annual fixed charges to GUVNL;
7) that, GUVNL was entitled to recover Deemed Generation Incentive from EPL for the period 14.09.2002 to 29.05.2006.
9. Aggrieved by this order, both GUVNL and EPL preferred appeals before the APTEL. Appeal No. 77 of 2009 was GUVNL’s appeal while Appeal No. 86 of 2009 was filed by EPL. By judgment dated 22.02.2010, the APTEL reversed in part the order dated 18.02.2009. The appeal filed by GUVNL was dismissed and the appeal of EPL was partly allowed. The APTEL held that EPL was not required to declare the capacity of the entire plant of 515 MW. It further held that non-declaration of available capacity on proportionate basis was not shown to have resulted in any loss to GUVNL and it was, therefore, not entitled to any compensation on that score. Lastly, the direction of GERC for reimbursement of annual fixed charges, whenever GUVNL did not secure electricity to the extent allocated under the proportionate principle, was held to be incorrect and the APTEL opined that no such refund was liable to be made.
10. This common judgment was subjected to appeal before this Court by GUVNL. Civil Appeal No. 3454 of 2010 was filed by it in relation to the APTEL’s confirmation of GERC’s finding on limitation, restricting its claims to three years prior to the filing of its petition on 14.09.2005. However, the said appeal was dismissed by this Court on 02.09.2011. The more substantial issue of diversion of its allocated electricity along with the consequences thereof was raised by GUVNL in Civil Appeal No. 3455 of 2010. The decision of this Court in the said appeal, delivered on 09.08.2016, is reported in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited vs. Essar Power Limited 1. Thereby, this Court set aside the judgment passed by the APTEL and restored GERC’s order dated 18.02.2009. However, as the actual working out, based on the said order, was to be made by the GERC
1 (2016) 9 SCC 103
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1583Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another and GUVNL had already filed its claim in relation thereto in Petition No. 972 of 2009, this Court left it open to GERC to proceed in the light of the findings recorded in its decision. Petition No.972 of 2009 was decided by GERC on 27.12.2019. That order was challenged by both sides by way of separate appeals. APTEL’s judgment dated 21.03.2025 in those appeals forms the fulcrum for the present set of appeals by GUVNL. GERC’s order dated 27.12.2019 and the APTEL’s appellate judgment dated 21.03.2025 will be analysed and discussed hereinafter.
11. At this stage, it may be noted that in this round of litigation, leading to the filing of the present appeals, GERC as well as the APTEL proceeded on the premise that the decision of this Court in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited (supra) settled most of the issues. These appeals, therefore, turn upon what was held by this Court in the aforestated decision. Surprisingly, GUVNL and EPL place strong reliance on the said decision and both assert that the findings therein are in its favour. Correct understanding and application of that decision is, therefore, called for. Such hermeneutics would raise a substantial legal question, as rival interpretations are sought to be placed by both parties on the aforestated decision. The maintainability of these appeals, therefore, stands settled.
12. Though both sides have taken us through the aforestated decision and relied upon particular paragraphs therein to assert a claim that this Court had decided the issues, presently under consideration, in its favour, we are of the opinion that such disjointed reading of specific paragraphs or even sentences, out of context, would not be the proper approach to understand the import of the decision. It must, necessarily, be read as a whole and in its entirety to glean the findings and ratio decidendi laid down therein.
13. The question of law framed by this Court in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited (supra) was whether the APTEL had correctly interpreted the terms of the PPA dated 30.05.1996 and was justified in reversing the findings of GERC, based on the interpretation of the PPA and other documents. This Court, then, noted the underlying facts and, in particular, the prayer of GUVNL in its Petition No. 873 of 2006, which reads as under:
“(a) hold that the petitioner is entitled to adjust in the tariff payable by the petitioner to the respondent for purchase 1584 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of electricity all amounts received by the respondent as a result of wrong allocation of electricity; and deemed generation incentive when naphtha is proposed to be used as fuel;
(b) award cost of the proceedings in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent; and
(c) pass such other or further orders as may be deemed proper to give relief to the petitioner;
(d) continue to raise bills on Essar Group of Companies based on proportionate methodology.”
14. This Court then noted the observation of GERC in its order dated 18.02.2009 that GUVNL had an obligation, under the PPA dated 30.05.1996, to pay annual fixed charges for the allocated capacity, i.e., 300 MW, and upon paying such annual fixed charges for the said capacity, GUVNL had a right to an equivalent amount of electrical output. GERC had observed that the purpose of paying such annual fixed charges was to ensure that GUVNL alone had the right to the said capacity and that no part of the same could be sold to any other party. This Court also noted the conclusion of GERC, upon a reading of Article 3.1 of the PPA dated 30.05.1996, that the entire capacity of the generating plant of EPL was to be shared only by the two beneficiaries, i.e., GUVNL and ESL. Noting that EPL’s PPA dated 29.06.1996 with ESL also recorded the allocation of electricity to GUVNL, GERC had held that the allocation was intended to be on a proportionate basis only between these two parties and, therefore, EPL could not argue that the PPAs did not recognize the proportionate principle. GERC’s finding, which is of significance presently, was that, if the proportionate principle was acceptable for recovery of fixed charges, it could not be abandoned for allocation of supply. This finding would have to be kept in mind as the claim of GUVNL before us is with regard to reimbursement of such fixed charges.
15. GERC had held, in no uncertain terms, that once the entire capacity was allocated between the two parties in a particular proportion, EPL could not violate the proportionate allocation for the benefit of any one party. Having sold 300 MW to GUVNL and 215 MW to ESL, for which fixed charges were paid by them in the said proportion, GERC opined that EPL could not argue that it could sell power to ESL beyond the capacity allocated to it. The obligation of EPL, as [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1585Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another per GERC, was to clearly declare the capacity of the generating plant as a whole on a weekly schedule and, once the declared availability for the entire plant was made known, the two beneficiaries were to issue dispatch instructions in accordance with the terms of their PPAs. The argument of EPL that it did not have any obligation to declare the capacity for the entire plant was, therefore, rejected by GERC.
16. Further, GERC observed that once the capacity of the generating plant as a whole was made available, the allocation of such capacity has to take place in the proportion that is contracted, i.e., the electrical output will be allocated and supplied between the two beneficiaries on proportionate basis, in accordance with the dispatch instructions. GERC noted that the obligation of EPL was to supply electrical output to GUVNL up to the allocated capacity of 300 MW and it also had an obligation to make payment of Deemed Non-generation Incentive and reduce annual fixed charges on a pro rata basis. This, as per GERC, however, did not negate the proportionate principle of allocation when EPL declared availability less than the allocated capacity.
17. It was further held by GERC that if GUVNL did not take the power declared available by EPL in terms of the aforesaid ratio, EPL would then have the right to sell that power to ESL, its sister company, subject to reimbursement of the proportionate annual fixed charges. In effect, if GUVNL did not schedule the power to the extent of availability declared by EPL of the entire plant, in terms of the PPA, it could not complain if that power was sold to EPL’s sister company and the proportionate annual fixed charges were reimbursed to it.
18. GERC further held that GUVNL would be entitled to claim compensation for the electricity wrongly diverted to ESL from the capacity allocated to GUVNL under the PPA dated 30.05.1996. The diversion, in the circumstance, was directed to be computed on an hourly basis. As regards the quantum of compensation payable on account of such diversion, GERC noted that the PPA was silent. It then referred to the settlement between the parties on account of such diversion between 1998 and September, 2004, by agreeing upon a particular methodology for determining the compensation. The methodology adopted was that GUVNL would be entitled to HTP-1 Tariff Energy Charge for such diverted power, after excluding the variable costs. Observing that this appeared to be a fair manner of determining the compensation that was to be paid for the period after September, 2004 also, the GERC directed the parties to reconcile 1586 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the generation data and make a final calculation on the basis of the said principle. As regards the remaining period of the PPA, GERC observed that EPL had a legal obligation to declare availability for the entire capacity and was not to divert any power to ESL, contrary to the proportionate principle but, if GUVNL declined to purchase the power allocated on proportionate basis, GERC held that EPL would have the right to sell that power to ESL, subject to reimbursement of the proportionate fixed charges.
19. This Court then noted the findings of the APTEL in its judgment disposing of the appeals filed against GERC’s order dated 18.02.2009. Having set out those observations and findings, this Court held that the APTEL had committed an error in observing that GUVNL had not proved suffering of any damage, as paragraph 23 of its petition expressly demonstrated such damage. This Court also disagreed with the APTEL on its finding that there was no obligation on EPL to declare the availability of generated power for the entire plant, whereupon dispatch instructions could be issued by both the beneficiaries. This Court categorically held that the finding of the APTEL that GUVNL had accepted ₹64 Crores by way of settlement was against the record. The points for consideration were framed by this Court as under: - “…..Points for consideration
20. The points which arise for consideration are:
20.1. (i) True interpretation of PPA to determine whether there is any obligation to declare availability of power in the ratio of 300:215;
20.2. (ii) Effect of letters dated 17-2-2000,4-3-2000 and 4-10-2001 on the rights of the parties;
20.3. (iii) Interpretation of Schedule VI to determine whether the obligation to issue dispatch instructions arose before declaration of availability.
20.4. (iv) Relief to which the appellant may be entitled to.”
20. On the first issue as to the true interpretation of the PPA, this Court held that it clearly contemplated the proportion of allocation of capacity between the two beneficiaries and EPL, necessarily, had to operate its generating plant to meet the requirement of electrical output that [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1587Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited v. Essar Power Limited and Another could be generated corresponding to the allocated capacity. This Court noted that GUVNL had to pay annual fixed charges as determined in terms of Article 7.1.1 of Schedule VII of the PPA dated 30.05.1996 and EPL was under an obligation to declare the weekly schedule of the capacity available so that dispatch instructions could be issued on the basis of the said declaration. The contrary view of the APTEL was held to be erroneous and GERC’s finding was consequently held to be the correct interpretation of the PPA.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.