M/S Kkk Hydro Power Limited v. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1057; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2350
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kumar
- Decided
- 29 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3005/2015
- Sections
- 86(1), 125, 86
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2350 : 2025 INSC 1057 M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others (Civil Appeal No. 3005 of 2015)
29 August 2025 [Sanjay Kumar* and N.V. Anjaria, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Commission) rejected the appellant’s petition for payment of arrears at an enhanced tariff for the electricity supplied by it to the Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited (HPSEB). APTEL allowed the appellant’s appeal in part and inter alia held that the tariff for its 3 MW hydel power plant under the PPA dated 30.03.2000 required no redetermination but, the tariff for its additional 1.90 MW hydel power plant required to be redetermined as per the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Power Procurement from Renewable Sources and Cogeneration by Distribution Licensee) Regulations, 2007; and the Commission was directed to pass a consequential order. Whether the appellant and HPSEB were bound to approach the Commission for its approval before effecting enhancement of the tariff stipulated in the PPA dated 11.03.2008.
Headnotes† Electricity Act, 2003 – s.86(1)(b) – Mandate of, binding – Appellant was to establish a Hydro Electric Power Project of 3 MW capacity (revised capacity of 4.90 MW) – PPA fixed the price to be paid by the HPSEB to the appellant at a fixed rate of 2.50/- per kWh – Under their supplementary PPA dtd. 10.09.2010, the appellant and HPSEB enhanced the tariff from ₹2.50/- per kWh to ₹2.95/- per kWh without the Commission’s review and approval – Appellant and the HPSEB, if were bound to approach the Commission for its approval before effecting enhancement of the tariff stipulated in the PPA dtd. 11.03.2008: * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2351M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others Held: 1.1 Yes – Fixing of the price for the purchase of electricity is not a matter of private negotiation and agreement between a generating company and a distribution licensee – The price as well as the agreement, i.e., PPA, incorporating such price and providing for purchase of electricity at that price necessarily have to be reviewed and approved by the State Commission u/s.86(1) (b). [Para 26] 1.2 A generating company and a distribution licensee cannot, by private agreement, execute a PPA on their own or stipulate tariff therein as per their choice, for supply of electricity within a State, without seeking the review and approval of the Electricity Regulatory Commission u/s.86(1) (b). [Para 31] 1.3 The order dated 09.02.2010 passed by the Commission, without reference to the appellant’s case, required only those existing PPAs which stipulated the tariff of ₹2.87/- per kWh to be amended so as to give effect to the enhancement of tariff from ₹2.87/- per kWh to ₹2.95/- per kWh – This order had no application at all to the case of the appellant as its PPA dated 11.03.2008 did not stipulate the tariff of ₹2.87/- per kWh. [Para 26] 1.4 Thus, the appellant and the HPSEB were bound to approach the Commission to secure its approval before they could effect any enhancement of the tariff stipulated in the PPA dated 11.03.2008 – Without doing so, the appellant and the HPSEB on their own and without the Commission’s review and approval, enhanced the tariff from ₹2.50/- per kWh to ₹2.95/- per kWh under their supplementary PPA dated 10.09.2010. [Para 26] 1.5 Thus, the Commission was fully justified in ignoring the supplementary PPA dated 10.09.2010 and asserting that it could not enforce it – However, the APTEL overlooked this crucial aspect and held that, insofar as the additional 1.90 MW plant was concerned, the supplementary PPA dated 10.09.2010 can be given effect to, by applying to it the tariff of 2.95/- stipulated therein. [Para 27] 1.6 The observation of the APTEL that no adverse inference could be drawn against the appellant for not obtaining the approval of the Commission for the tariff agreed to by the parties under this supplementary PPA 10.09.2010 overlooked the binding mandate of s.86(1)(b). [Para 27] 1.7 Appellant was granted relief by the APTEL, ignoring the mandate of s.86(1)(b) but the HPSEB allowed the same to attain finality 2352 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports by not filing an appeal – No interference at this late stage – Plea of the appellant that it should be extended the enhanced tariff of ₹2.95/- per kWh for the entire project, including the 3 MW plant covered by the PPA dated 30.03.2000, is bereft of merit. [Paras 26, 27, 31] List of Acts Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Power Procurement from Renewable Sources and Cogeneration by Distribution Licensee) Regulations, 2007; Electricity Act, 2003; Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998.
List of Keywords Section 86(1)(b) of the Electricity Act, 2003; Fixing of price for purchase of electricity not a matter of private negotiation; Private negotiation; Enhancement of tariff in PPA; Review and approval of Electricity Regulatory Commission under Section 86(1) (b) under Section 86(1)(b) of the Electricity Act, 2003; Generating company; Distribution licensee; Payment of arrears at an enhanced tariff; Tariff; Power Purchase Agreement (PPA); Supplementary PPA; Baragran Hydro Electric Power Project; 3 MW hydel power plant; Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited (HPSEB); Redetermination of tariff; Enhanced capacity; Private agreement; Royalty for water usage.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 3005 of 2015 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.10.2014 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi in AN No. 198 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
M.G. Ramachandran, Sr. Adv., Raj Kumar Mehta, Ms. Himanshi Andley, Ms. Srishti Khindaria.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Pradeep Misra, Daleep Dhyani, Suraj Singh, Anand K. Ganesan, Nikunj Dayal, Amal Nair, Ms. Shivani Verma, Pramod Dayal. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2353M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Kumar, J.
1. By way of this appeal filed under Section 125 of the Electricity Act, 2003 1 , M/s. KKK Hydro Power Limited, Faridabad, Haryana, calls in question the judgment dated 17.10.2014 passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, New Delhi 2 , in Appeal No. 198 of 2013. In turn, Appeal No. 198 of 2013 was also filed by M/s. KKK Hydro Power Limited, the appellant herein, against the order dated 05.07.2013 of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission 3 , rejecting its petition for payment of arrears at an enhanced tariff for the electricity supplied by it to the Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited 4 .
2. IA No. 4 of 2016 filed by the Commission seeking to be impleaded as a party respondent in this appeal is allowed and the Commission is brought on record as respondent No. 4.
3. By the impugned judgment dated 17.10.2014, the APTEL allowed the appellant’s appeal in part and held that the tariff for its 3 MW hydel power plant under the Power Purchase Agreement5 dated 30.03.2000 required no redetermination but the tariff for its additional 1.90 MW hydel power plant, commissioned on 10.07.2008, required to be redetermined as per the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Power Procurement from Renewable Sources and Cogeneration by Distribution Licensee) Regulations, 2007 6 . The APTEL further directed that, as the entire capacity of the appellant’s power project was to be injected and evacuated from the same bus bars, a common tariff had to be determined for the power project as a whole and held that the common tariff would be the weighted average of the respective tariffs for the 3 MW and 1.90 MW plants. 1 for short, ‘the Act of 2003’ 2 for short, ‘the APTEL’ 3 for short, ‘the Commission’ 4 for short, ‘the HPSEB’ 5 for short, ‘the PPA’ 6 for short, ‘the Regulations of 2007’ 2354 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The appellant was held entitled to arrears on account of the difference in tariff for the period for which payment had already been made as per the existing tariff. The Commission’s order dated 05.07.2013 was set aside to that extent and the Commission was directed to pass a consequential order within a timeframe.
4. Pursuant to the above direction, the Commission determined the tariff as per the weighted average and quantified it at ₹2.60/- per Kilowatt hour (kWh), vide order dated 11.06.2015. In accordance therewith, the appellant and the HPSEB filed a joint petition, bearing No. 106 of 2015, seeking approval of the supplementary PPA dated 03.11.2015 entered into by and between them, stipulating the new tariff as per the weighted average. Reference was made therein to the orders of the Commission and the APTEL dated 11.06.2015 and 17.10.2014 respectively and the tariff of ₹2.60/- per kWh was incorporated for the entire project of 4.90 MW capacity with effect from 14.07.2008. Be that as it may.
5. The factual narrative needs recounting from scratch to properly gauge the issues raised in this appeal. The Government of Himachal Pradesh 7 and the appellant executed Implementation Agreement 8 dated 30.03.2000, whereby the appellant was to establish Baragran Hydro Electric Power Project of 3 MW capacity on Sanjoin Nallah, a tributary of River Beas, in District Kullu. Pursuant to this IA, the appellant and the GoHP executed a PPA on the same day, i.e., 30.03.2000. Clause 6.2 of the said PPA, titled ‘Tariff for Net Saleable Energy’, fixed the price to be paid by the HPSEB to the appellant at a fixed rate of ₹2.50/- per kWh. It was stated therein that ‘this rate is firm and fixed and shall not be changed due to any reason whatsoever’. The PPA was to be in force for a period of 40 years from the synchronization date of the first unit of the project.
6. It was only thereafter, i.e., on 30.12.2000, that the Commission came to be constituted under the Electricity Regulatory Commissions Act, 1998. The 3 MW hydel power project was commissioned by the appellant on 05.08.2004. While so, on 05.02.2005, the appellant sought the approval of the GoHP to augment the capacity of its power project by increasing it to 4.90 MW. Accepting its request, the GoHP 7 for short, ‘the GoHP’ 8 for short, ‘the IA’ [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2355M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others forwarded a draft IA to the appellant under letter dated 06.09.2006, wherein it proposed that royalty for water usage, in the shape of free power to be given to GoHP, would continue as per the IA for the existing 3 MW plant, but it would be waived for the upgraded 1.90 MW plant for 12 years, reckoned from the Commercial Operation Date of the third turbine, and beyond the period of 12 years, the royalty would be 12% for the next 18 years and beyond that, 18%. This proposal was in modification of clause 13.1 of the earlier IA dated 30.03.2000, which stated that royalty for water usage, in the shape of free power @ 10% of deliverable energy, would be leviable but it would be waived for 15 years from the Commercial Operation Date.
7. A supplementary IA was then executed by the GoHP and the appellant on 05.07.2007, wherein both parties agreed that the project for the revised capacity of 4.90 MW should be implemented, subject to the terms and conditions mentioned therein. Clauses 13 and 13.1 of this supplementary IA dealt with the GoHP’s rights on water and stated that royalty for water usage, in the shape of free power, from the appellant’s 4.90 MW power project would be waived for 12 years, reckoned after 30 months from the date of signing of the supplementary IA and beyond the period of 12 years, the royalty would be @ 12% for the next 18 years and beyond that, @ 18%. This was in alteration of the earlier understanding.
8. Thereafter, on 04.12.2007, on the joint petition of the HPSEB and the appellant, the Commission conditionally approved the draft PPA submitted by them in accordance with the supplementary IA dated 05.07.2007 for the revised capacity of 4.90 MW. The relevant portion of the order reads as follows:
‘The Commission under sub-section (1)(b) of Section 86 of Electricity Act, 2003 grants consent to the said PPA, subject to the following observations: i) The Model PPA approved by the Commission vide its order dated 24 th March, 2003 provides for Government Guarantee and the same can only be omitted from the PPA with the approval of the Commission for which purpose the parties need to file a joint application within one month of the date of issue of this order.
2356 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ii) The approved model PPA provides that the Company shall provide to the Board, free of cost, 10% of the energy generated by the project as measured at the interconnection point commencing from the date falling 15 years from the date on which the Company synchronizes the first unit of the project. The stipulation made in this regard in the PPA submitted for approval is however on the basis of “Hydro Power Policy 2006” notified subsequently by the GoHP in December, 2006. The deviation can only be allowed after the parties file a joint application for necessary approval in this regard with the Commission.
iii) Construction Schedule attached to the Implementation Agreement PPA needs to be got approved as Appendix-B from the competent authority as per the standard Implementation Agreement and attached as such with the PPA.
iv) Page 2 of the Implementation Agreement is missing.
v) Tariff and other terms and conditions of the PPA shall be subject to the provisions of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Power Procurement from Renewable Sources and Cogeneration by Distribution Licensee)
Regulations, 2007.’ (emphasis is ours)
9. Pursuant to the conditional approval granted by the Commission, vide order dated 04.12.2007, the appellant and HPSEB executed PPA dated 11.03.2008. ‘Project’ was defined therein under clause 2.2.56 to mean Baragran Hydro Electric Project of 4.90 MW (revised) capacity. Clause 6.2 dealt with the ‘Tariff for the Net Saleable Energy’ and stated that the HPSEB would pay for the net saleable energy delivered to it by the appellant at a fixed rate of ₹2.50/- per kWh. It was further stated that ‘this rate is firm and fixed without indexation and escalation and shall not be changed due to any [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2357M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others reason whatsoever’. However, another clause was added thereunder which reads as follows:
‘Further, the tariff as per clause 6.2 above and other terms & conditions of the PPA shall be subject to the provisions of the Himachal Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (Power Procurement from Renewable Sources and Cogeneration by Distribution Licensee) Regulations, 2007 and when such regulations are framed as per the HPERC order dated 04.12.2007 incase no. 241/2007 (Annexure-IV).’
10. Pursuant to the Regulations of 2007, the Commission issued the Tariff Order for ‘Small Hydel Power Projects not exceeding 5 MW’ on 18.12.2007. Clause 5.35 thereof stated that it would be applicable to all PPAs (not exceeding 5 MW) already approved by the Commission, with a specific clause that the tariff and other terms and conditions of the PPA shall be subject to the provisions of the Regulations of 2007, and also to the PPAs to be approved by the Commission thereafter. The tariff fixed by the Commission under this Tariff Order is ₹2.87/- per kWh.
11. Thereafter, the APTEL adjudicated two appeals filed against this tariff of ₹2.87/- per kWh for small hydel power projects of upto 5 MW and, by order dated 18.09.2009, the APTEL remanded the matter to the Commission to redetermine the tariff for such projects. Pursuant thereto, the Commission issued orders dated 09/10.02.2010, enhancing the tariff to ₹2.95/- per kWh.
12. On the strength of the Commission’s orders dated 09/10.02.2010, the appellant approached the HPSEB on 01.04.2010 to execute a supplementary PPA with the enhanced tariff of ₹2.95/- per kWh. Aggrieved by the lack of response, the appellant filed Petition No. 94 of 2010 before the Commission seeking a direction to the HPSEB to act upon its plea and execute a supplementary PPA, incorporating the tariff of ₹2.95/- per kWh. However, supplementary PPA dated 10.09.2010 came to be executed by the appellant and the HPSEB, without the intervention of the Commission, modifying the tariff from ₹2.50/- per kWh to ₹2.95/- per kWh. Pertinent to note, a caveat was added therein by the HPSEB that such enhancement would be without prejudice to its rights as available under law. 2358 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
13. Pursuant to this supplementary PPA, the HPSEB started paying the appellant the higher tariff of ₹2.95/- per kWh. As arrears of payment at this enhanced tariff from April, 2008 to August, 2010 were not made and payments for that period had only been made at the initial tariff of ₹2.50/- per kWh, the appellant filed Petition No. 6 of 2011 before the Commission. Its prayer therein was to direct the HPSEB to pay the arrears of ₹2,77,50,960/- for the period in question. During the pendency of this petition, the HPSEB cleared the bill for the aforestated amount and stated that the same would be released in 5 installments of ₹55,50,192/- each. The first installment of ₹55,50,192/- was released by the HPSEB on 26.02.2011. According to the appellant, the only issue that survived thereafter in Petition No. 6 of 2011 was as to the interest payable on the arrears from 11.03.2008 to 10.09.2010. While so, the HPSEB filed Petition No. 118 of 2012 before the Commission, seeking recall/modification/ clarification of its earlier conditional approval order dated 04.12.2007.
14. By common order dated 05.07.2013, the Commission dismissed Petition No. 6 of 2011 filed by the appellant for payment of arrears and also dismissed Petition No. 118 of 2012 filed by the HPSEB. Perusal of the order reflects that the following issues were framed for consideration:
1. Whether the Commission has the power to look into the agreement entered into or concluded prior to its existence?
2. Whether the observation No. (v) of the Commission’s consent letter on PPA is relevant in the present case and if it is relevant what is the import of the regulations and the orders issued thereunder on tariff and other conditions?
3. Whether the provisions in the Model PPA have the binding force?
4. Whether the parties to the PPA have the power to amend/ modify the PPA and if so does it require Commission’s approval?
5. Whether the parties have executed the PPA, including the Supplementary PPA, in conformity with the approval accorded by the Commission?
6. Whether the petitioner is entitled to seek directions as prayed for in the petition?
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2359M/s KKK Hydro Power Limited v.
Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board Limited and Others
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.