Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1187; [2025] 11 S.C.R. 1
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 7 Oct 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 12512/2025
- Sections
- 73, 50, 3, 60, 129, 123
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 1 : 2025 INSC 1187 Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v.
Syeda Arifa Parveen (Civil Appeal No. 12512 of 2025)
07 October 2025 [Ahsanuddin Amanullah and S.V.N. Bhatti,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the impugned judgments suffer from perversity and misreading of evidence, warranting re-appreciation of evidence under Article 136 of the Constitution of India; whether the High Court is correct in reversing the finding of the Trial Court on the Oral Gift without an appeal/cross-appeal by the Plaintiff; whether the Plaintiff established her claim as the daughter of K and A; whether the claim of the Plaintiff under oral gift/Hiba is validly proved, and the title is derived to an extent of 10 acres; whether the suit for declaratory relief is barred by limitation. Headnotes† Constitution of India – Art.136 – Re-appreciation of evidence under – Whether the impugned judgments suffer from perversity and misreading of evidence, warranting re-appreciation of evidence u/Art.136:
Held: Though, re-appreciation of evidence is normally not undertaken by this Court u/Art.136 however, in a given case, the re-appreciation of evidence is not barred u/Art.136 – Incorrect appreciation of evidence and few inconsistent findings in the impugned judgments, warrant re-appreciation of evidence to appreciate the real issue between the parties – Re-appreciation undertaken primarily to examine whether the Trial Court and the High Court have accurately recorded the findings – Objection of the respondent-plaintiff that the re-appreciation of oral and documentary evidence is not warranted in the facts and circumstances of this case, rejected – Impugned Judgments set aside – Plaintiff’s suit is dismissed. [Paras 14, 15] Appellate court – Power of, to modify decree – Suit filed by the respondent-plaintiff for declaration that she is the owner of the * Author 2 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Suit Property – Trial Court decreed the suit, in part, granting a decree of title and permanent injunction to an extent of 18 acres and 21 guntas of the Suit Property, however, disbelieved the case of the plaintiff on oral gift/hiba – Appeal filed by the defendants – High Court recognised the oral gift; modified the decree and enhanced the plaintiff’s share by including the 10 acres allegedly gifted by her mother through oral gift and 3/4th share in the balance of extent in the suit property – Whether the High Court was correct in reversing the finding of the Trial Court on the Oral Gift without an appeal/crossappeal by the Plaintiff:
Held: Impugned judgment did not consider whether a ground is made out for modifying a decree or not – High Court disturbed a finding of fact, leading to modifying the decree of the Trial Court in the suit without there being an appeal/cross-appeal – Thus, to this extent, the findings of the High Court are not tenable. [Para 21] Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.50, 60, 73 – Whether the Plaintiff established her claim as the daughter of ‘K’ and ‘A’:
Held: 1.1 Plaintiff claimed the status of the only daughter of ‘K’ and ‘A’ – Trial Court exercised its jurisdiction u/s.73, referred to s.50, and, without testing the credibility, relevancy, admissibility and competence of the witnesses, in an abstract way, held that the Plaintiff is the daughter of ‘K’ – It further found that the mere suggestion to these witnesses does not discredit the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 – Trial Court failed to note that the Plaintiff and the witnesses, going by their evidence, were withholding the documents in their possession, namely, school-leaving records, ration card, etc – The perversity in appreciation is evident from the improvements in the evidence of PWs 1 to 3 on all material aspects – Whereas, the High Court accepted the evidence of PWs 2 and 3 as the witnesses having special means of knowledge of the Plaintiff with ‘K’. [Paras 32, 33] 1.2 The appreciation failing to adhere to the standard tests in appreciating oral evidence, and abstract findings have been recorded on the status of the Plaintiff vis-à-vis ‘K’ – Emphasis is on relevant facts admissible in evidence – Assuming the evidence is admissible, the same must conform to the triple test – The proof of status or relationship need not always necessarily be through documentary evidence, but, when oral evidence is the basis on [2025] 11 S.C.R. 3Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen which the opinion is required to be formed by a Court, the Courts are allowed to treat an opinion on conduct about a relationship as only a relevant fact – This should not be confused with ‘as factum probandum’ – Impugned judgments are liberal in their approach to accepting the status claimed by the Plaintiff as the daughter of ‘K’. [Para 33] Oral gift/Hiba – Claim under – When not proved – Suit filed by the respondent-plaintiff for declaration that she is the owner of the Suit Property – Trial Court decreed the suit, in part, granting a decree of title and permanent injunction to an extent of 18 acres and 21 guntas of the Suit Property, however, disbelieved the case of the plaintiff on oral gift/ hiba – High Court recognised the oral gift; modified the decree and enhanced her share by including the 10 acres allegedly gifted by her mother through oral gift and 3/4th share in the balance of extent in the suit property – Whether the claim of the Plaintiff under oral gift/Hiba is validly proved, and the title is derived to an extent of 10 acres:
Held: 1.1 No – The claim of the Plaintiff under oral gift/Hiba and Ex. P-8 (Memorandum of Gift executed in her favour), for want of evidence on possession, fails, and the issue is answered in favour of the Defendants – Impugned judgments presume possession in favour of Plaintiff on ipse dixit statements, and the courts below fell in grave error in not appreciating the long lapse of years and continued silence of Plaintiff vis-à-vis the Suit Property. [Para 39] 1.2 To constitute a valid conveyance through an oral gift, the three contemporaneous conditions of declaration by donor, acceptance by donee, possession by donee and to continue to establish possession through contemporaneous evidence to show that Hiba is acted upon. [Para 39] 1.3 Possession is one of the important conditions to constitute a valid oral gift – The courts presume possession of a party from the circumstances pleaded and proved – The evidence of acting under the gift (e.g., collecting rent, holding title, mutation) is essential to substantiate the claim of possession – While Mohammedan Law allows for a gift to be made orally without a written document, the validity of such a gift is contingent on the demonstration of all three essential elements, particularly the delivery of possession – The courts will scrutinise “contemporaneous” and “continuous” evidence 4 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the donee’s actions and control over the property to determine if possession was indeed transferred – The lack of evidence (e.g., failure to collect rent, donor’s continued control, lack of mutation) will lead to proving that a gift was never completed, regardless of any written declaration. [Paras 38, 39] 1.4 In the case at hand, there is a consistent revenue record, Ex. P-2, Ex. P-3, Ex. P-4, Ex. P-5 and Exs. D-9 to D-43 showing in the revenue records that the names of Defendants were entered in Record of Rights (ROR) and their predecessors in interest, both in the title and possession columns – The Plaintiff placed oral evidence, however, in the circumstances of the case, it cannot be accepted that there was a valid oral gift in favour of Plaintiff in any capacity, i.e., as a daughter or otherwise – Impugned Judgments set aside – Plaintiff’s suit is dismissed. [Paras 39, 49] Limitation Act, 1963 – Arts.58, 59 – Transfer of Property Act – s.3 – Whether the suit for declaratory relief was barred by limitation:
Held: The suit filed on 28.10.2013 is barred by limitation – The earliest cause of action to the Plaintiff in the case on hand was when Ex. P-2, dated 06.06.1989, was brought into existence at the instance of ‘K’ and the cause of action again arose when Ex. P-3 was brought into existence, denying the claim of the Plaintiff by Late ‘AB’ – ‘AB’ is said to have executed instruments of sale (Exs. D-3 to D-7) on 02.05.1995 – The names of vendees have been mutated, and the continued negligence would result in constructive notice of transactions covered by Exs. D-3 to D-7 – The Plaintiff had opportunities to mutate the Suit Property in her name on 05.01.1989, 29.11.1990, 25.02.1995, and 09.09.2001 – Furthermore, the Respondent did not file the suit until 2013, which, in any case, exceeds the three-year limitation period – Therefore, knowledge is imputed through constructive notice, and consequently, it cannot be stated that there was a continuing cause of action – Moreover, to set aside instruments of sale (Exs. D-3 to D-7), the muster u/ Art.59, Limitation Act must be met – It is axiomatic that there is a presumption that a registered document is validly executed – A registered document is prima facie valid in law – Thus, the onus of proof would be on a person who leads evidence to rebut the presumption – In the instant case, the Respondent failed to rebut the said presumption – The mutation entry in Exs. P-1 and P-2, coupled with the execution of Exs. D-3 to D-7 are sources of potential [2025] 11 S.C.R. 5Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen mischief to the claim of the Plaintiff to the suit property – Plaintiff has not acted in time in challenging the maintenance of ROR, or registered sale deeds, within the time stipulated by law – The conduct for over a period of 23 years cannot be appreciated as the conduct of a passive observer but amounts to failure to use the care that a reasonably prudent and careful person would use under these circumstances. [Paras 44, 46-48] Mohammedan Law – Valid oral gift under – Essentials of: Held: There are three essential conditions for an oral gift under Mohammedan Law – A clear manifestation of the wish to give on the part of the donor; an acceptance of the gift by the donee, which can be either implied or explicit; taking of possession of the subjectmatter of the gift by the donee, either actually or constructively – A gift under Mohammedan Law does not require a written document to be valid – An oral gift that fulfils the three essential requisites is complete and irrevocable – The mere fact that a gift is reduced to writing does not change its nature or character – A written document recording the gift does not become a formal instrument of gift. [Paras 36.1, 36.2] Mohammedan Law – Gift under – Delivery of possession – How to be made:
Held: Delivery of possession is a critical and necessary element for a valid gift – It can be actual or constructive – Constructive possession can be demonstrated by overt acts by the donor that show a clear intention to transfer control – For example, the donor applies for the mutation of the donee’s name in the revenue records – Continuous evidence of acting under the oral gift is crucial to prove the delivery of possession – The donee must be able to demonstrate “exclusive control” over the property to derive benefit under it, such as by collecting rent, or by the donor performing acts like mutation on behalf of the donee – Conversely, the donor’s continued collection of rent and the donee’s lack of control over title documents or mutation records can be evidence that possession was not transferred. [Paras 36.4, 36.5] Words and Phrases – “when the right to sue first accrues” – Limitation Act, 1963 – Art.58. [Para 42] Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.60, 50 – Opinion on relationship, when relevant – Contours of s.50 – Discussed. [Paras 26, 26.1, 27] 6 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Mahesh Dattaray Thirthakar v. State of Maharashtra [2009] 3 SCR 1122 : (2009) 11 SCC 141; Banarsi and Others v. Ram Phal [2003] 2 SCR 22 : (2003) 9 SCC 606; Dolgobinda Paricha v. Nimai Charan Misra [1959] Supp. 2 SCR 814 : AIR 1959 SC 914; Ramchandra Rambux v. Champabai and Others [1964] 6 SCR 814 : AIR 1965 SC 354; Fakhruddin v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1966 SCC OnLine SC 55; Abdul Rahim v. Sk. Abdul Zabar [2009] 4 SCR 32 : (2009) 6 SCC 160; Rasheeda Khatoon v. Ashiq Ali [2014] 11 SCR 31 : (2014) 10 SCC 459; Hafeeza Bibi v. Sk. Farid [2011] 5 SCR 1155 : 2011 5 SCC 654; Mansoor Saheb v. Salima, 2024 INSC 1006 : [2024] 12 SCR 923; Nikhila Divyang Mehta and Another v. Hitesh P. Sanghvi and Others, 2025 INSC 485; Noorul Hoda v. Bibi Raifunnisa [1995] Supp. 6 SCR 110 : (1996) 7 SCC 767; Prem Singh and Others v. Birbal and Others [2006] Supp. 1 SCR 692 : 2006 AIR SC 3608 – relied on.
Chandu Lal Agarwala v. Khalilar Rahman, ILR (1942) 2 Cal 299, 309; Pottem Subbarayudu and Another v. Kothapalli Gangulu Naidu and Others, 2000 SCC OnLine AP 296;
Mussamut Kamarunnissa Bibi v. Mussamut Husaini Bibi, 1880 UKPC 36 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Al-Marghinani, Burhan al-Din, Al-Hiadaya, Quran Mahal, Karachi Vol. III, p. 283; Mulla, Principles of Mahomedan Law, 20th Edition, Chapter XI (Gifts) – referred to.
List of Acts Transfer of Property Act, 1882; Constitution of India, 1950; Evidence Act, 1872; Limitation Act, 1963.
List of Keywords Mohammedan Law; Oral Gift/Hiba; Mohammedan Law of succession; Delivery of Possession; Constructive possession; Constructive notice; Suit barred by limitation; Section 50 of the Evidence Act; Re-appreciation of evidence under Article 136 of the Constitution of India; Record of Rights (ROR); Mutation; Presumption of possession; Lack of mutation; Registered sale [2025] 11 S.C.R. 7Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen deeds; Cross-appeal/cross-objection; Opinion evidence; Special knowledge of relationship; Declaratory suit; Permanent injunction; Continuing cause of action; Negligence.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 12512 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.07.2022 of the High Court of Karnataka at Kalaburagi in RFA No. 200204 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Rauf Rahim, Sr. Adv., Yash Prashant Sonavane, Gopal Bhosale, Ms. Sangita Bhosale, Ali Rauf Rahim, Ravindra Keshavrao Adsure. Advs. for the Respondent:
Ameet Kr Deshpande, Sr. Adv., Akshat Shrivastava, Vibhor Jain, Mrs. Pooja Shrivastava.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment S.V.N. Bhatti, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The Civil Appeal arises from the judgment and decree dated 06.07.2022 in RFA No. 200204 of 2019 in the High Court of Karnataka, Kalaburagi Bench, Kalaburagi. The Civil Appeal is at the instance of the Defendants in OS No. 212 of 2013 in the Court of Principal Senior Civil Judge at Kalaburagi. The sole Respondent is the Plaintiff.
3. The following chronology is prefaced before adverting to the pleadings, evidence and findings in the impugned judgments.
3.1 Khadijabee w/o Syed Abdul Basit filed OS No. 68 of 1971 against her brother for partition and separate possession of agricultural land in Sy.No. 107 measuring 24 acres and 28 guntas at village Kusnoor, Taluka and District Gulbarga (‘Suit Property’). On 27.10.1987, OS No. 68 of 1971 was decreed (Ex. P-1), declaring that the Suit Property belongs to Khadijabee. It is averred that 8 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports on 05.12.1988, Khadijabee, under an oral gift/Hiba, conveyed to the Plaintiff 10 acres in Sy.No. 107. On 05.01.1989, the Memorandum of Gift (Ex. P-8) is stated to have been executed by Khadijabee in favour of Plaintiff. On 06.06.1989, registration of a change of rights (Ex. P-2) in the Record of Rights (‘ROR’) in favour of Khadijabee was carried out covering the entire extent of 24 acres and 28 guntas. Khadijabee died on 29.11.1990 (Ex. P-3). On 23.05.1991, Abdul Basit, the husband of Late Khadijabee, again got the mutation (Ex. D-2) effected for 24 acres and 28 guntas. On 25.02.1995, Abdul Bas (as set out in the sale deeds) sold, through five sale deeds (Exs. D-3 to D-7), the extent of 24 acres and 28 guntas in favour of Defendant nos. 1 to 5, and through Exs. D-9 to D-43, the Suit Property has been mutated in their names. On 09.09.2001, Abdul Basit died. On 28.10.2013, Syeda Arifa Parveen, w/o Mushtaq Ahmed, filed OS No. 212 of 2013, praying for the reliefs of declaration that the Plaintiff is the owner of the Suit Property and perpetual injunction. The suit property is land Sy.No.107, admeasuring Ac. 24-28 Gts., situated at Village Kusnoor, Taluka and District Gulbarga. The Suit Property is bounded by a Government Road to the East, Sy.No.151 to the West, Sy.No.106 to the North, and Sy.No.119 to the South.
3.2 The Plaintiff, by way of amendment, prayed for a further declaration that the sale deeds alleged to be executed by Abdul Bas, dated 25.02.1995, in favour of Defendants are null and void and not binding on the Plaintiff (Exs. D-3 to D-7).
4. The averments in the plaint in support of the declaratory relief of title and cancellation of Exs. D-3 to D-7 state that Khadijabee died on 29.11.1990, and the Plaintiff is her only daughter and heir. Khadijabee’s husband is also deceased, and she left no other legal heirs. Khadijabee, during her lifetime, made an oral gift/Hiba of 10 Acres of land out of the Suit Property in favour of the Plaintiff on 05.12.1988, and delivered possession, which the Plaintiff accepted. Subsequently, a Memorandum of Gift Deed was executed on 05.01.1989. Based on the oral gift and succession, the Plaintiff claims to be the owner and in possession of the Suit Property. The Plaintiff asserted that the Defendant No. 1 was previously an agricultural servant of Khadijabee (original owner) on a yearly salary basis. The Plaintiff further asserts that the Defendants have no concern with either the ownership or [2025] 11 S.C.R. 9Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen possession of the suit land. Taking advantage of Dussehra Vacation, the plaintiff alleged that on 14.10.2013, the Defendants came to the suit land, tried to dispossess the Plaintiff by force, and asked her to vacate, claiming they had purchased the land. They also tried to stop agricultural operations. The Defendants claimed to have purchased portions of the Suit Property through registered sale deeds dated 25.02.1995, with the alleged vendor being Abdul Bas S/o Syed Hussain Saheb. The purchased portions are as follows: (i) Defendant No.1: 4 Acres 38 Guntas, (ii) Defendant No.2: 5 Acres, (iii) Defendant No.3: 5 Acres, (iv) Defendant No.4: 5 Acres and (v) Defendant No.5: 5 Acres. The Plaintiff contends that “Abdul Bas” S/o Syed Hussain Saheb (executor of the sale deed) does not exist, was never the owner, nor in possession of the suit land. The sale deeds were not executed by Khadijabee or her husband, “Abdul Basit Saheb”. The Plaintiff alleges that the Defendants created these false sale deeds to make a false claim over the Suit Property. Therefore, these sale deeds have not conferred any right, title, and the Defendants have not become owners of the Suit Property. The Plaintiff argues that the entries in the revenue records were entered without following proper procedure. Further, the plaintiff stated that these entries are illegal because notices were not served upon the Plaintiff nor the original owners at the time of mutation of entries. These entries, therefore, do not confer any right, title, or interest on the Defendants.
5. The Defendants resisted the suit on all fours. The Defendants admit that Khadijabee was the original owner of the Suit Property, and she died on 29.11.1990 and her husband has also died. However, they deny that the plaintiff is Khadijabee’s only daughter, that Khadijabee left no other heirs, that Khadijabee made an oral gift of 10 Acres of land to the plaintiff on 05.12.1988, or that possession was delivered. According to Defendants, Khadijabee and her husband died issueless. They further deny that Khadijabee executed a Memorandum of Gift on 05.01.1989, or that the plaintiff became the owner and possessor of 10 Acres of land out of the total extent of the Suit Property. They allege that the plaintiff made up a story to grab their property by illegal means. They highlight that the alleged oral gift has not been heard of for 25 years, and the alleged Memorandum of Gift has not seen the light of day for all these years. The Defendants specifically contest that Defendant No. 1 was Khadijabee’s agricultural servant, or that the 10 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Defendants have no concern with the ownership or possession of the Suit Property. The Defendants deny that on 14.10.2013, they tried to dispossess the plaintiff by force, or that they informed the plaintiff they purchased the lands through various sale deeds. The Defendants assert that during the Dussehra Vacation, they did not attempt to stop agricultural operations or ask the plaintiff to vacate and hand over possession. Further, the Defendants stated that the sale deeds were not executed by the plaintiff or her parents. Defendant Nos. 1 to 5 assert they are bona fide purchasers. They verified revenue and other records and were satisfied with the title of Abdul Bas @ Abdul Basit s/o Syed Hussain Sab as it was duly mutated in their vendor’s name. The Defendants detail their individual purchases of land in Sy.No.107 on 25.02.1995 through registered sale deeds, specifying the document numbers and acreage for each Defendant. They assert that they are in possession of their portions as absolute owners since the date of purchase without any interference. They also mention that Abdul Bas @ Abdul Basit had previously sold house properties to Defendant No. 2’s family in 1981. The Defendants’ names were mutated in the revenue records based on these registered sale deeds after due process and have continued without objections from anyone, particularly the plaintiff. They deny that the said sale deeds did not confer any right, title, or interest on the Defendants, or that the Defendants did not become the owners. They further deny that notices were not served on the plaintiff, Khadijabee, or her husband when entries were made in the ROR, or that such entries are illegal and do not confer any right, title, or interest on the Defendants.
6. The following issues and additional issues were framed by the Trial Court:
“1. Whether the Plaintiff proves that, she is having right, title and ownership over the suit schedule property?
2. Whether the Plaintiff further proves that, she is in lawful possession and enjoyment over the suit schedule property as on the date of filing of this suit?
3. Whether the Plaintiff further proves that, defendants have interfered in the peaceful possession and enjoyment of suit schedule property as alleged in the plaint?
4. What order or decree?
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 11Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen Additional issues:
1. Whether suit of Plaintiff is barred by limitation?
2. Whether suit of the Plaintiff in present form is maintainable?”
7. The Plaintiff examined herself as PW1 and PWs 2 to 4 on her behalf and got marked Exs. P-1 to P-8. The second Defendant was examined as DW1, and the third Defendant was examined as DW2. Exs. D-1 to D-44 have been marked on their behalf.
8. The respective pleadings of the parties are, to the extent needed, adverted to while taking up the contentions by the learned counsel appearing for the parties. The Trial Court, in effect, decreed the suit in part, granting a decree of title and permanent injunction to an extent of 18 acres and 21 guntas of the Suit Property. The Trial Court disbelieved the case of the Plaintiff on Oral Gift, and the view taken by the Trial Court can be summed up as follows.
8.1 Plaintiff was the daughter of Khadijabee and Syed Abdul Basit. This finding was based on the testimony of PW2 and PW3, who had special means of knowledge of the familial relationship. The Court did this by invoking Section 50 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (‘Evidence Act’).
8.2 The Trial Court, by referring to Section 73 of the Evidence Act, compared the disputed signatures and found that the signature of Syed Abdul Basit on Ex. P-8 (Memorandum of Gift) matched his signature on the sale deeds, concluding that they belonged to the same person.
8.3 The Trial Court held that the oral gift was not acted upon because the delivery of possession could not be established. Under Mohammedan Law, delivery of possession is an essential condition. The court also noted a discrepancy in the property’s boundaries, as mentioned in the gift memorandum. This created doubt about the identification of the gifted portion, and it was concluded that a valid gift deed requires handing over of actual possession.
8.4 Trial Court held that as per the Mohammedan Law of succession, the shares of the legal heirs after Khadijabee’s death were to be divided as 3/4th to the daughter and 1/4th to the father. 12 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 8.5 The sale deed was only valid to the extent of 1/4th share (6 acres and 7 guntas). The remaining 3/4th share of 18 acres and 21 guntas was declared void.
9. The Defendants filed RFA No. 200204 of 2019, in the High Court of Karnataka, Kalaburagi Bench and through the impugned judgment, while dismissing the appeal, modified the decree by holding that the Plaintiff is the absolute owner of 10 acres derived through Oral Gift and Ex. D-8, and of a 3/4th share in the balance of extent in the Suit Property, i.e., 14 acres 28 guntas. To conclude the introductory narrative, the High Court, through its findings:
9.1 Upheld the Trial Court findings on the Plaintiff being the daughter of Khadijabee and Abdul Basit.
9.2 It overturned the Trial Court’s findings on the oral gift. The High Court found that the evidence proved the delivery of possession of 10 acres; thereby, completing the oral gift. It also noted that the testimony of witnesses PW2 and PW4 supported the Plaintiff’s claim of possession.
9.3 The High Court modified the decree by noting that the Plaintiff is the absolute owner of the 10 acres gifted by her mother, and the 3/4th share in the remaining 14 acres and 28 guntas.
10. Hence, the civil appeal at the instance of the Defendants.
11. We have heard learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Rauf Rahim, for the Defendants and Mr. Amit Kr Deshpande for the Plaintiff. 11.1 It is argued for the Defendants assailing the findings of the High Court and the Trial Court that they bristle with perversity and suffer from unavailable presumptions and assumptions in law. To wit, it is explained that after the death of Khadijabee in 1990, her husband, Abdul Basit, became the sole heir and had his name recorded in the land records on 23.05.1991. On 25.02.1995, Abdul Basit sold the land to the petitioners through five registered sale deeds. The petitioners’ names have been entered on the ROR and Crop Cultivation Column from 1995 to 2022-2023. They have paid agricultural taxes and obtained crop loans for the land. The respondent has not conclusively proven her relationship as the daughter of Khadijabee and Abdul Basit, and no primary documentary evidence, such as a birth certificate, school records or a marriage certificate, was [2025] 11 S.C.R. 13Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen ever produced to prove her lineage. The Trial Court and High Court relied on Section 50 of the Evidence Act, ipse dixit, and accepted the testimony of three “interested witnesses”. The alleged “Oral Gift” and the “Memorandum of Gift” (Hibanama) dated 05.01.1989, are doubtful and sham transactions. While Khadijabee signed her name in Urdu in the plaint, the gift deed only bears her thumb impression, which was not identified by anyone. Further, the document was never acted upon in the revenue records. The suit filed by the Plaintiff on 28.10.2013 was barred by limitation as it was filed 18 years after the 1995 sale deeds were registered. The High Court had exceeded its appellate jurisdiction by recognising the oral gift and granting 10 acres of the land to the respondent, especially since the trial court had rejected this claim and the respondent had not filed a cross-appeal. While the case was sub judice at the Supreme Court, the respondent forcefully dispossessed them on 02.01.2023 and had her name mutated in the land records without their knowledge.
11.2 Appearing for the Plaintiff, at the outset, it is argued that the reappreciation of oral and documentary evidence is not warranted in the facts and circumstances of this case. The findings recorded are concurrent and conform to section 50 of the Evidence Act, and do not warrant re-appreciation under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. Supporting the impugned judgments, it is argued by the Learned Senior Counsel that Khadijabee, was the owner of the suit land, who made an oral gift of 10 acres to the Plaintiff and later executed a memorandum of gift on 05.01.1989. Following her death, her husband, Abdul Basit and the Plaintiff inherited the Suit Property at the first instance. After Abdul Basit’s death, the Plaintiff became the sole owner. This is supported by the testimony of PW-2, a cousin, and PW-3, a brother-in-law, who had intimate knowledge of the family and testified that the Plaintiff is Khadijabee’s daughter. The memorandum of gift (Ex. P-8) was proven by presenting the original document and through the testimony of attesting witnesses. The suit was filed on 28.10.2013, after the Defendants attempted to dispossess the Plaintiff on 14.10.2013. The suit is within the statutory limitation period. The oral gift’s essential conditions, including 14 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports formal delivery of possession, were met, as confirmed by the deposition of PW-4, a neighbour. Furthermore, the alleged sale deeds were executed by an individual named Abdul Bas, not the deceased Abdul Basit. Even if Abdul Basit executed them, they would only be valid for his 1/4th share of the property.
12. A few citations are relied on by both the counsel, and we may refer to them if, in the analysis, the same is warranted.
13. The above narrative presents the following points for consideration. i. Whether the impugned judgments suffer from perversity and misreading of evidence, warranting re-appreciation of evidence under Article 136 of the Constitution of India?
ii. Whether the High Court is correct in reversing the finding of the Trial Court on the Oral Gift without an appeal/cross-appeal by the Plaintiff?
iii. Whether the Plaintiff established her claim as the daughter of Khadijabee and Abdul Basit?
iv. Whether the claim of the Plaintiff under oral gift/Hiba is validly proved, and the title is derived to an extent of 10 acres? v. Whether the suit for declaratory relief is barred by limitation? Point I
14. Re-appreciation of evidence is normally not undertaken by this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. The learned senior counsel appearing for the parties, in support of their respective arguments, have invited our attention to both the oral and documentary evidence. We have taken note of the incorrect appreciation of evidence and a few inconsistent findings in the impugned judgments. The reappreciation is undertaken primarily to examine whether the Trial Court and the High Court have accurately recorded the available findings. In a given case, the reappreciation of evidence is not barred under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. This principle is elucidated in Mahesh Dattaray Thirthakar v. State of Maharashtra 1, which has helpfully summarised the position of law on appreciation
1 (2009) 11 SCC 141
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 15Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen of evidence under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, and the relevant extracts are as follows:
“34. xxxx this Court does not normally reappreciate evidence under Article 136, but when the High Court has redetermined a fact in issue in a civil appeal, and erred in drawing inferences based on presumptions, the Supreme Court can reappreciate the evidence to prevent further delay instead of remanding the matter. (See N.G. Dastane v. S. Dastane [(1975) 2 SCC 326] at SCC p. 329.]
35. From a close examination of the principles laid down by this Court in the aforesaid series of decisions as referred to hereinabove on the question of exercising power to interfere with findings of fact by this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution, the following principles, therefore, emerge:
• The powers of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution of India are very wide.
• It is open to this Court to interfere with the findings of fact given by the High Court if the High Court has acted perversely or otherwise improperly.
• When the evidence adduced by the parties in support of their respective cases fell short of reliability and acceptability and as such it is highly unsafe and improper to act upon it.
• The appreciation of evidence and finding is vitiated by any error of law of procedure or found contrary to the principles of natural justice, errors of record and misreading of the evidence, or where the conclusions of the High Court are manifestly perverse and unsupportable from the evidence on record.
• The appreciation of evidence and finding results in serious miscarriage of justice or manifest illegality.
• Where findings of subordinate courts are shown to be perverse or based on no evidence or irrelevant evidence or there are material irregularities affecting the said findings or where the court feels that justice 16 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports has failed and the findings are likely to result in unduly excessive hardship.
• When the High Court has redetermined a fact in issue in a civil appeal, and erred in drawing inferences based on presumptions.
• The judgment was not a proper judgment of reversal.”
15. The argument of learned senior counsel for the Plaintiff is noted, and having regard to the ratio in Mahesh Dattaray Thirthakar (supra), we are of the view that, to appreciate the real issue between the parties, the objection is rejected.
Point II
16. The Plaintiff categorically claimed that she is the only daughter and heir to Khadijabee. On 29.11.1990, Khadijabee died, and on 09.09.2001, Abdul Basit died. According to Plaintiff, as noted supra, Khadijabee, during her lifetime, made an oral gift/hiba for 10 acres of agricultural land in the Suit Property and delivered possession, which was said to have been accepted by the Plaintiff. Ex. P-8 memorandum of gift deed dated 05.01.1989 is produced to evidence the factum of oral gift. The Plaintiff claims, through the oral gift, an extent of 10 acres. With the demise of Khadijabee on 29.11.1990, it is stated that the Plaintiff and Abdul Basit are the heirs entitled to the property. Since Abdul Basit died on 09.09.2001, the Plaintiff claims a declaration of title to the entire Suit Property.
17. The Defendants admit the demise of Khadijabee on 29.11.1990. They categorically deny that (a) Plaintiff is the daughter of Khadijabee,
(b) Khadijabee executed an oral gift for 10 acres of land in the Suit Property and (c) possession according to Defendants was with their predecessors-in-interest and is presently with the Defendants pursuant to Exs. D-3 to D-7. The claim is based on the oral gift being a concocted version to grab the Suit Property.
18. The party to a lis is not under a legal obligation to file an appeal against mere findings recorded by the Court. Let us examine if the finding on oral gift by the Trial Court is a mere finding, and whether the High Court has substantially altered the relief without there being an appeal or cross-appeal. The Trial Court, while rejecting the oral gift, accepted the case of the Plaintiff over 18 acres and [2025] 11 S.C.R. 17Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen 21 guntas (3/4 th share). The high court, while reversing the finding, has substantially altered the relief by increasing the extent to which the Plaintiff is entitled to a declaration. To wit, the trial court granted the relief of permanent injunction and held that her ownership of 3/4 th share in Khadijabee’s property of 18 acres and 21 guntas was established. The Appellate Court enhanced her share by including the 10 acres allegedly gifted by her mother through hiba and 3/4 th share in the remaining 14 acres and 28 guntas; thus, totalling 24 acres and 28 guntas. Now, let us refer to the power of the appellate court in modifying the decree.
19. In Banarsi and others v. Ram Phal,2 this Court held that: “8. Sections 96 and 100 of the CPC make provision for an appeal being preferred from every original decree or from every decree passed in appeal respectively; none of the provisions enumerates the person who can file an appeal. However, it is settled by a long catena of decisions that to be entitled to file an appeal the person must be one aggrieved by the decree. Unless a person is prejudicially or adversely affected by the decree he is not entitled to file an appeal (See Phoolchand and Anr. v. Gopal Lal, [1967] 3 SCR 153; Smt. Jatan Kanwar Golcha v. M/s Golcha Properties (P) Ltd., [1970] 3 SCC 573; Smt. Ganga Bai v. Vijay Kumar and Ors., [1974] 2 SCC 393. No appeal lies against a mere finding. It is significant to note that both Sections 96 and 100 of the CPC provide for an appeal against decree and not against judgment.
13. We are, therefore, of the opinion that in the absence of cross appeal preferred or cross objection taken by the plaintiff-respondent the First Appellate Court did not have jurisdiction to modify the decree in the manner in which it has done. Within the scope of appeals preferred by the appellants the First Appellate Court could have either allowed the appeals and dismissed the suit filed by the respondent in its entirety or could have deleted the latter part of the decree which granted the decree for specific
2 (2003) 9 SCC 606
18 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports performance conditional upon failure of the defendant to deposit the money in terms of the decree or could have maintained the decree as it was passed by dismissing the appeals. What the First Appellate Court has done is not only to set aside the decree to the extent to which it was in favour of the appellants but also granted an absolute and out and out decree for specific performance of agreement to sell which is to the prejudice of the appellants and to the advantage of the respondent who has neither filed an appeal nor taken any cross objection.”
(emphasis supplied)
20. Juxtaposition of the view taken by the Trial Court and the High Court on the oral gift/Hiba would explain the infirmity pointed out by the Defendants against the impugned judgment.
Issue TrIal C ourT reasonIng HIgH C ourT reasonIng Validity of Hiba under Mohammedan Law Disbelieved the theory of the oral gift dated 05.12.1988, because o f d o u b t r e g a r d i n g the identification of 10 acres due to boundary discrepancies in Ex. P-8.
The Trial Court concluded that no actual possession was handed over.
Reversed the Trial Court finding and stated that the finding that the gift deed has not been acted upon cannot be accepted. The evidence discloses delivery of possession and thereby the gift became complete and the Plaintiff held its possession.
To r e b u t t h e f i n d i n g o f boundary discrepancies, the High Court attributed it to poor drafting and that the crossexamination was lacking.
Possession of the suit property The Trial Court accepted the Plaintiff’s case of possession to the extent of the share inherited.
Possession of the Plaintiff can be said to have continued on the remaining extent of her share in the suit property after the death of her mother.
It also inferred delivery of possession for the gifted land due to the mother-daughter relationship.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 19Dharmrao Sharanappa Shabadi and Others v. Syeda Arifa Parveen
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.