Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1292; [2025] 11 S.C.R. 448
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Joymalya Bagchi
- Decided
- 7 Nov 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13429/2025
- Sections
- 69(1), 69, 21, 22, 52, 52(1), 55, 35, 34, 25, 73, 36
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 448 : 2025 INSC 1292 Samiullah v.
The State of Bihar & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 13429 of 2025)
07 November 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Joymalya Bagchi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regard the sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) to r.19 of the Bihar Registration Rules, 2008 empowering registering authorities to refuse registration of documents, if proof of mutation of the property under sale in favour of the vendor not produced along with the registering document if ultra vires the Act.
Headnotes† Bihar Registration Rules, 2008 – r.19 (xvii) and (xviii) – Refusal of duly presented document – Sub-rules (xvii) and
(xviii) introduced by way of amendments to r.19 empowering registering authorities to refuse registration of documents, if proof of mutation of the property under sale in favour of the vendor is not produced along with the registering document – Effect of the amended sub-rules that registering authorities can refuse registration of an otherwise validly presented document on the ground that it did not mention and carry the proof of jamabandi allotment or holding allotment in favour of the seller, it is now a condition precedent to get jamabandi or holding allotment certificate under the Bihar Land Mutation Act, 2011 or allied laws for sale or transfer of immovable property – Writ petition by the appellants challenging the vires of sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) of r.19 on the ground that the addition of sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) ultra vires the Act and beyond the scope of s.69(1)(a)(aa) – Dismissed by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: : Impugned sub-rules are ultra vires the rule making power u/s.69 of the Act – As the said sub-rules tilt the balance and empower the registering authorities to produce collateral evidence of title to the property as a pre-condition for registration, such a measure, through subordinate legislation, is against the purpose and object of the Act – Requirement under the impugned sub-rules is arbitrary as [2025] 11 S.C.R. 449Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. the process of mutation and its certification is uncertain and virtually unavailable in near future, as the Bihar Mutation Act, 2011 and the Bihar Special Survey and Settlement Act, 2011 are said to be nowhere near implementation – Intention of the State to synchronize the registrable document with real time land holding is appreciated, there is a big missing link given that the process of mutation and the process of survey and settlement are nowhere near completion – Under these circumstances and considering the nascent stage at which the empirical data is translated as mutation into the relevant records and the fact that for this purpose survey and settlement are to be conducted, interlinking and restraining registration till the jamabandi or holding allotment is effected would be illegal, as it has a direct impact on the right and freedom to purchase and sell property – Requirement of rules, regulations or even law that impedes or restrains easy and effective transfer of property will be illegal as it has the direct effect of ‘depriving of property’ to that extent, and such delays, caused due to unreasonable and arbitrary restrictions, impinge the right to hold and dispose of property – Thus, the prescription of mentioning and production of jamabandi allotment or holding allotment as a pre-condition for registration of a legally presented document under impugned sub-rules 19 (xvii) and
(xviii) is arbitrary and illegal and as such, liable to be set aside – Judgment and order passed by the High Court set aside and the Notification introducing r.19 (xvii) and (xviii) quashed – Registration Act, 1908 – s.69(1)(a)(aa). [Paras 2, 25, 29, 38] Bihar Registration Rules, 2008 – r.19 (xvii) and (xviii) – Distinction between the sub-rules (i) to (xvi) and the subrules
(xvii) and (xviii) of r.19 of the 2008 Rules – Explained. [Paras 9-13] Registration Act, 1908 – s.69 – Scope of rule-making power u/s.69 – Sourcing the rule-making power under other provisions of the Registration Act – Stated. [Paras 14-25] Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – Registration Act, 1908 – Stamp Act, 1899 – Dichotomy between registration and title – Existing legal structure – Problems relating to the legal structure – Explained. [Paras 30-33] Property laws – Dichotomy between registration and ownership – Inefficiencies and vulnerabilities in recording the real-estate transactions – Measures adopted by the Government:
450 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: To modernize these transactions, the government adopted certain measures-Digital India Land Records Modernization Programme (DILRMP); National Generic Document Registration System (NGDRS) – However, if the original record is inaccurate, incomplete or subject to dispute, the digital version will simply perpetuate the flaw – Process of digitization does not by itself resolve the underlining title disputes or correct inaccuracies – Adoption of Blockchain technology would ensure immutability, transparency and traceability, thereby minimizing fraud and unauthorized alterations – Blockchain technology offers an alternative paradigm by encoding land titles, ownership histories, encumbrances, and by recording transfers on a Distributed Ledger in an immutable and time stamped form – Blockchain design could integrate cadastral maps, survey data, and revenue records into single verifiable framework, which, while maintaining a transparent audit trail, is accessible to multiple departments and the public – Registration of deeds being a concurrent list subject, Government of India must take lead in constituting a body, with the participation of the States, to examine the issue in light of the technological advancement for integrating the property registration regime with conclusive titling – Process may involve restructuring and reviewing the existing laws-Transfer of Property Act, 1882, Registration Act, 1908, Stamp Act, 1899, Evidence Act, 1872, Information Technology Act, 2000, Data Protection Act, 2023 and may require introduction of new laws for incorporating Blockchain technology – This will necessarily require establishing regulatory framework which institutionalizes processes with integrity and efficiency – Thus, Law Commission to examine the issue, consult the Union, the States and all other stakeholders as well as experts in the field of information and technology, and prepare report on the issue. [Paras 34-37] Case Law Cited K. Gopi v. Sub-Registrar and Others, 2025 INSC 462 : [2025] 5 SCR 47 – referred to.
List of Acts Bihar Registration Rules, 2008; Bihar Land Mutation Act, 2011; Bihar Special Survey and Settlement Act, 2011; Transfer of Property Act, 1882; Registration Act, 1908; Stamp Act, 1899; Evidence Act, 1872; Information Technology Act, 2000; Data Protection Act, 2023. [2025] 11 S.C.R. 451Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. List of Keywords Registering authorities; Registration of documents; Proof of mutation of the property; Registering document; Proof of jamabandi; Sale or transfer of immovable property; Land surveys; Ultra vires; Rulemaking power; Dichotomy between registration and title; Property laws; Dichotomy between registration and ownership; Digital India Land Records Modernization Programme (DILRMP); National Generic Document Registration System (NGDRS); Process of digitization; Blockchain technology; Distributed Ledger; Registration of deeds; Technological advancement; Law Commission.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 13429 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 09.02.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Patna at Nagpur in CWJ No. 21386 of 2019 With Civil Appeal No. 13430 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Manan Kumar Mishra, Sr. Adv., A Velan, Ms. Navpreet Kaur, Prince Singh, Nilay Rai, Ms. Anjul Dwivedi, Dr. Ram Sankar, Mrs. Harini Ramsankar, Ram Sankar & Co.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ranjit Kumar, Sr. Adv., Manish Kumar, Divyansh Mishra.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Contents*
1. Introduction .......................................................................... 2
2. Facts .................................................................................... 4
3. Submissions ........................................................................ 8 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
452 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. Distinction between the existing sub-rules (i) to (xvi) and the impugned sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) of Rule 19 ............ 9
5. Scope of rule-making power under Section 69 .................. 14
6. Sourcing the rule-making power under other provisions of the Registration Act ............................................................. 17
7. Concerns arising out of Bihar Land Mutation Act, 2011 ...... 24
8. Dichotomy between registration and title ............................ 28 8.1 Existing legal structure ................................................ 28 8.2 The problems relating to the legal structure ............... 28 8.3 Technological possibilities ............................................. 30 8.4 Reformation of Land Registration processes and to eschew “fraudulent/multiple registrations” ................... 32 8.5 Suggestions and Direction to constitute a committee ... 33
9. Conclusion ........................................................................... 34
1. Introduction.
1. Delay condoned. Leave granted.
2. The constitutionally protected right to own immovable property inherently includes the freedom to freely acquire, possess and dispose it at will. The efficiency and transparency with which immovable property is bought and sold is demonstrative of a nation’s institutional maturity and a testament of the confidence and trust its citizens repose in the integrity of its legal and transactional framework. 2.1 Rather curiously, our property laws have long sustained a dichotomy between registration and ownership. The Registration Act, 19081 mandates the registration of documents, not titles, and this distinction forms the cornerstone of our country’s presumptive titling system. Since this presumption is rebuttable in a court of law, a substantial burden rests on the prospective buyer, who must undertake a painstaking search of title.
1 Hereinafter referred to as “the Act”.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 453Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. There is no doubt that this uncertainty has been distressing for those seeking to purchase property. Property disputes, in fact, constitute nearly sixty six percent of all civil litigation. It is therefore fair to ask whether the time has come to move towards a system in which the sale and purchase of immovable property becomes simpler, and registration serves as a conclusive proof of ownership guaranteed by the State. We have explored this possibility and found promise in emerging technologies such as Blockchain, which we have directed the government to examine. Until the convergence of conclusive titling with registration is achieved, constitutional courts must balance the freedom to buy and sell property with the Governmental duty to ensure integrity in transactions. Guided by this principle, we have examined the present case and found that the measure adopted by the State has unduly restricted the freedom to sell property. These perspectives gain relevance in the following context.
2.2 Sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) were introduced by way of amendments to Rule 19 of the Bihar Registration Rules, 2008 2 , empowering registering authorities to refuse registration of documents, if proof of mutation of the property under sale in favour of the vendor is not produced along with the registering document. These sub-rules were challenged unsuccessfully before the High Court of Patna. In these Civil Appeals, we have accepted the submissions and allowed the appeals on the ground that the impugned sub-rules are ultra vires the rule making power under Section 69 of the Act. We have also come to the conclusion that, as the said sub-rules tilt the balance and empower the registering authorities to produce collateral evidence of title to the property as a pre-condition for registration, such a measure, through subordinate legislation, is also against the purpose and object of the Act. Further, the requirement under the impugned sub-rules is arbitrary as the process of mutation and its certification is uncertain and virtually unavailable in near future, as the Bihar Mutation Act, 2011 and the Bihar Special Survey and Settlement Act, 2011 are said to be nowhere near implementation.
2 Hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”.
454 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. Facts.
3. These appeals arise out of the judgment of the High Court of Patna dismissing writ petition3 filed by the appellants herein, challenging the vires of sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) of Rule 19, introduced through the 2019 amendment to the Rules on 10.10.2019.
4. The Rules, as well as the amendment in 2019, were made in exercise of the rule making power of the Inspector General of Registration under Section 69 of the Act. The newly added sub-rules empowering the registering authority to refuse registration of a duly presented document in circumstances as indicated therein are as follows; “Rule 19 Refusal of duly presented document – A duly represented document may be refused for registration under following circumstances – …
(xvii) If a document is related to sale/gift of property, in which Jamabandi allotment to seller/donor is not mention in the deed and no proof is produced about the Jamabandi allotment to the seller/donor.
Provided that, it will have no effect on the document related to the transfer of flat/apartment.
(xviii) If a document is related to sale/gift of property, in which holding allotment to seller/donor of the flat/apartment in urban region is not mentioned in the deed and no proof is produced about the holding allotment to the seller/donor. Provided that, it will have no effect on the document related to the first transfer of flat/apartment.”
5. The effect of the amended sub-rules is simply that the registering authorities can refuse registration of an otherwise validly presented document on the ground that it did not mention and carry the proof of jamabandi allotment or holding allotment in favour of the seller. In other words, it is now a condition precedent to get jamabandi or 3 CWJ No. 21386/2019 dated 09.02.2024.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 455Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. holding allotment certificate under the Bihar Land Mutation Act, 2011 or allied laws for sale or transfer of immovable property.
6. Aggrieved by the additional requirement, introduced by way of the amended sub-rules, several writ petitions came to be filed before the High Court of Patna on two grounds; (i) that the addition of sub-rules
(xvii) and (xviii) to Rule 19 is ultra vires the Act and beyond the scope of Section 69(1)(a)(aa), (ii) that it is an admitted fact that the process of land surveys is yet incomplete in Bihar, making it impossible for owners to obtain jamabandi or holding allotment in order to be able to freely deal with their properties, (iii) that it is a settled position of the law that mutation does not create title and therefore, making it mandatory for purpose of registration is arbitrary, and (iv) enquiry into title falls within the jurisdiction of civil courts and the registering authorities have no jurisdiction to refuse registration on the ground of defective title.
7. The Division Bench of the High Court, by the judgment impugned before us, dismissed the writ petitions on the grounds;
(i) That jamabandi or holding allotment does not necessarily confer title on the person whose name is entered in the register, however it is indeed a compelling, although rebuttable, evidence in favour of title.4
(ii) That arguments of the writ petitioners are mutually destructive, wherein on the one hand it is contended that revenue entries confer no title and yet on the other hand, their grievance is that the amendment empowers the registering authorities to adjudicate on question of title. 5 4 “9. We have to immediately observe and affirm the trite principle, as argued by the learned counsel for petitioners and not disputed by the State, that the ‘Holding’ or ‘Jamabandi’ recorded in a register maintained by the State or its authorities, does not necessarily confer title on the person whose name is entered in the register; on which if a dispute arises will have to be adjudicated by a court of law. However, it is also a trite principle that the entry in the register maintained by the State would be compelling evidence in favour of title, which could be displaced by more persuasive evidence, unsettling even a claim based on that entry.
5 10. Having said that, we have to notice that the arguments raised by the petitioners are conflicting and mutually destructive. It is argued that title cannot be decided on the mere entries made in the revenue register; which, as we noticed, is the established principle. But it was also argued that if the entry in the register is insisted upon, then it will be requiring the Sub- Registrar to adjudicate on the title of the land. The arguments, so addressed, are mutually destructive and going by the established principle, based on which the first argument is addressed, even if a registration is carried out of a document where the ‘Jamabandi’ or ‘Holding’ is specified, there is no bar from the Civil Court considering a dispute on title, in a properly instituted suit.”
456 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(iii) That if there is an absence of jamabandi or holding allotment by reason of an ongoing survey process in the State, then it is for the individual owners to approach the appropriate forum for the same.6
(iv) That the provisions of the Act taken together mandate a clear description of the property for purpose of registration and the impugned amendments fall right within the ambit of this requirement. 7
(v) That clause (a) and (aa) of Section 69(1) indeed do not empower the Inspector General to make the impugned sub-rules, however, merely mentioning the wrong provision won’t vitiate the general rule-making power vested in him. 8
(vi) That public policy considerations behind the impugned amendment do not impair the prescription in the amended 6 “12. Section 21 of the Registration Act speaks of description of property and maps or plans. Subsection (1) specifically provides that a non-testamentary document relating to immovable property shall be accepted for registration only if it contains a description of such property, sufficient to identify the same. Section 22 is complementary to Section 21 and explains what, a description of a house and land can be, with reference to Government maps or surveys. Sub-section (1) empowers the State Government to prescribe by way of rules that a land or house should be described with reference to a Government map or survey, if it is practicable so to do. This puts to rest any objection with respect to the hardship of the owners of land, since if there is absence of a ‘Jamabandi’ or ‘Holding’ by reason of no survey being conducted by the State, then it is for such individual owners to approach appropriate forum for relief, pointing out the absence of the entry, by reason of the survey not having been carried out. None can be heard to raise a claim of hardship only for reason of there being a necessity to approach a court of law.” 7 “14. Section 52 is not to be read as an obligation of the Registering Officer, on presentation of a document, to enter the same on the mere requirement under Section 52 being satisfied. No provision in the statute can be read in isolation and the provisions read together, would take in the other requirements also, which mandates a clear description of the property; within which ambit would lie the present amendments too.
15. We also have to emphasize that Section 52(1)(c) requires such entry to be made of a document presented, only if that document is ‘admitted’ to registration; obliging the Registering Officer to look at the other provisions of the statute so as to find the document to be capable of being admitted to registration. Section 55, in relation to the indexes made by the Registering Officer and their contents, also does not militate against the requirement of ‘Jamabandi/Holding’ being mandatory in a document presented for registration.”
8 “16. Now, we have to deal with Section 69, which empowers the Inspector-General to supervise registration offices and make rules. The registration rules have been made under Section 69. The present amendment specifically refers to Clause (a) and Clause (aa) of Section 69(1). We are clear in our minds that the said sub-clauses would not empower the Inspector General to make the subject amendments, but we have to pertinently observe that the mere mentioning of a wrong provision would not vitiate the subordinate legislation; if power can be found under the provision enabling such prescription.
17. Section 69 enables Inspector General to make a prescription by rules, consistent with the Act and Clause (j) permits general regulation of proceedings under Registrars and Sub-Registrars. Clause (h) also requires the particulars to be contained in Indexes Nos. I, II, III and IV respectively, which deal with “description of property….A reading of Section 69, as a whole, along with Sections 21, 22 & 55, does not persuade us to find an absence of power to make the subject amendment. The impugned prescription is one, which is enjoined under Section 69.”
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 457Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. Rules, given the identification of the source of power to validly do so under section 69.9
3. Submissions.
8. On behalf of the appellants, we heard Mr. Manan Kumar Mishra, Senior Advocate and Mr. A. Velan, AOR. They made detailed submissions on the impugned amendments and have also brought to our notice certain precedents that have a direct bearing on the issue arising for consideration, including the recent decision of this Court in K. Gopi v. Sub-Registrar and Others10 . On behalf of the State, Mr. Ranjit Kumar, Senior Advocate, assisted by Mr. Manish Kumar, AOR, has brought to our notice the purpose and object of the amendment, intending to subserve integrity in sale transactions. They have submitted that the impugned sub-rules are in consonance with Section 69 of the Act and are not arbitrary.
4. Distinction between the existing sub-rules (i) to (xvi) and the impugned sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii) of Rule 19.
9. Rule 19 in its entirety is extracted hereinbelow for ready reference and this includes the newly introduced sub-rules (xvii) and (xviii). “Rule 19. Refusal of duly presented document – A duly presented document may be refused for registration under following circumstances –
(i) If the description of identification of the property as defined in Rule-5 has not been given as required under the Act and Rules.
(ii) If the executant denies execution. (Section 35)
9 “21. The learned Advocate General only pointed out the rising criminal tendencies, by reason of land disputes and the requirement by amendment having aimed at curbing such multiplicity of claims being raised on an identical piece of land. The requirements brought in only describe the property by way of the entries in the Register of Raiyats, which is permissible under the Registration Act. The intention of the Legislature or the State Government or the rule making authority, however laudable, cannot be upheld unless the source of power to make such prescription is well defined. As a corollary, if the source is clear and there is power on the rule making authority then merely based on intentions, unless it shocks the conscious or is arbitrary and perverse, valid prescriptions cannot be unsettled. The source we have found clearly under Section 69 of the Registration Act and the argument advanced of an attempt to curb the menace of rising criminal activities, does not make the amendment invalid. Merely because public policy having weighed with the rule making authority, would not impair the prescription, since the power can be easily found under Section 69.”
10 2025 INSC 462.
458 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(iii) If the executant fails to appear and admit execution. (Section 34)
(iv) If the person by whom the document purported to have been executed were dead and his representative or assign deny execution. (Section 35)
(v) If the person purporting to have executed the document appear to be a minor an idiot or a lunatic. (Section 35)
(vi) If the Registering Officer is not satisfied by the identity of the person appearing before him claiming that he has executed the document. (Section 35)
Provided that a document shall not be refused under this clause unless the party fails to prove this identity within the time allowed under Section 34.
(vii) If the Registering Officer is not satisfied of the truth of the allegation that person who executed the document is dead. (Section 35)
Provided that a document shall not be refused for registration under this clause unless the party fails to prove the death of the executant within the time allowed in Section 34.
(viii) If the admitting agent’s power-of-attorney has not been made in accordance with the Act or if any alleged representative or assign has failed to prove his status.
(Section 35)
(ix) If the partes fail or refuse to mention the additions of executants and claimants.
(x) If the prescribed fee or fine has not been paid under Section 25, 34 and 80 of the Act.
(xi) If a document is said to be executed by a deaf and dumb person who does not understand the transaction nor express himself by signs or in writing.
(xii) Where a person admits his signature to a document but states that he signed the paper when it was blank and no document was written thereon.
[2025] 11 S.C.R. 459Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors.
(xiii) If a deed of surrender of lease which claimed exemption from stamp duty because the original lease was so exempt is presented and the party refuses to produce the original lease or a certified copy of it in order to satisfy the Registering Officer that the document is either properly stamped or not liable for stamp duty.
(xiv) Where any or some of the representatives of a deceased executant deny execution while others admit it registration of the document shall be wholly refused subject to the provisions of Section 73 of the Act.
(xv) On refusal or neglect to appear on an appointed date after services of summons under Section 36 of the Act.
(xvi) [-] [Provided further that it will not affect the registration of units/flats of those multi-storied buildings/apartments of which at least one unit/flat has been registered before the Bihar Registration (Amendment) Rules, 2018 notified on 30.8.2018 came into force.] [(xvii) If a document is related to sale/gift of property, in which Jamabandi allotment to seller/donor is not mentioned in the deed and no proof is produced about the Jamabandi allotment to the seller/donor.
Provided that, it will have no effect on the document related to the transfer of flat/apartment.
(xviii) If a document is related to sale/gift of property, in which holding allotment to seller/donor of the flat/ apartment in urban region is not mentioned in the deed and no proof is produced about the holding allotment to the seller/donor.
Provided that, it will have no effect on the document related to the first transfer of flat/apartment].”
10. Circumstances in which a duly presented document can be refused by registering authority under sub-rules (i) to (xv) of Rule 19 can broadly be divided into following categories.
1. Circumstances where identification of property is uncertain – sub-rule 19(i).
460 [2025] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. Circumstances relating to uncertainty about the executant such as; the executant denying execution – sub-rule 19(ii), the executant failing to appear and to admit execution – sub-rule 19(iii), executant dies – sub-rule 19(iv), executant appears to be a minor, idiot or a lunatic – sub-rule 19(v), parties fail or refuse to mention the addition of executants and claimants sub-rule 19(ix), executant being a deaf and dumb person who does not understand the transaction – sub-rule 19(xi), persons admitting signatures but on a blank paper – sub-rule 19(xii), where some representatives of a deceased executant deny execution while others admit registration - sub-rule 19(xiv) and executants refusing or neglecting to appear – sub-rule 19(xv).
3. Circumstances where the Registering Officer is not satisfied about the identity of person claiming to be executant – sub-rule 19(vi), or about the truth of alleged death of executant – subrule 19(vii). However, the proviso to these sub-rules interestingly mandates registration of the documents, unless the concerned party fails to satisfy the authority within the time allowed under Section 34.
4. Circumstances in which the legal requirements of law are not satisfied, such as the admitting agent’s power of attorney is not legal – sub-rule 19(viii), the prescribed fee or fine under Sections 25, 34 and 80 are not paid – sub-rule 19(x) or that the claim of exemption from stamp duty is not proved - sub-rule 19(xiii).
11. It is evident from the above, that the four categories encompassing the existing sub-rules (i) to (xv) of Rule 19 are relatable either to the identity of the property, of the condition or the conduct of the executant, the registering officer not being satisfied with the identity of the property or the death of the executant and the legal requirements of law with respect to POA, fee, fine or exceptions not being satisfied. It is evident that these circumstances have no relation to proof of title of the property. They are conditions precedent to enable the registering authority to be certain about the identity of the property of the executant.
12. On the other hand, the impugned sub-rules 19 (xvii) and (xviii) are qualitatively distinct from any of the circumstances provided under sub-rules (i) to (xv). Sub-rule 19(xvii) empowers the registering authority to refuse registration of the document if the Jamabandi [2025] 11 S.C.R. 461Samiullah v. The State of Bihar & Ors. allotment of the seller is not mentioned in the deed and also if the proof of such allotment is not produced. For the first time, the sub-rule prescribes ‘mentioning’ with ‘proof’ of the transaction of the registrable property under another statute, namely the Bihar Land Mutation Act, 2011. Similarly, Rule 19(xviii) empowers the registering authority to refuse registration of a legally presented document relatable to a flat or an apartment in an urban region if the holding allotment is not ‘mentioned’ and the ‘proof’ is not produced.
13. The requirement under newly added sub-rules is starkly different from the existing sub-rules.
5. Scope of rule-making power under Section 69.
14. It was argued before the High Court, and likewise before us, that the impugned sub-rules are ultra vires the rule-making power of the Inspector-General of Registration. For this purpose, our attention is drawn to Section 69 of the Act, empowering the Inspector-General to make rules. We will reproduce Section 69 in its entirety to examine if sub-rules 19(xvii) and (xviii) could legally and validly be made in exercise of power under Section 69, which is as follows:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.