Haryana Power Purchase Centre (Hppc) and Others v. Gmr Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1079; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 663
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice * Cji and K. Vinod Chandran, Justice J.]
- Decided
- 8 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1929/2020
- Sections
- 125, 100, 62, 63, 79, 79(1), 3(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 663 : 2025 INSC 1079 Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v.
GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others (Civil Appeal No. 1929 of 2020)
08 September 2025 [B.R. Gavai,* CJI and K. Vinod Chandran, J.] Issue for Consideration The APTEL dismissed the appeals (Appeal no.135 of 2018 along with Appeal no.54 of 2019) and upheld the order dated 20.03.2018 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) in Petition No.105/MP/20173.
Headnotes† Electricity Act, 2003 – Electricity Appeals – When experts bodies like the CERC, the APTEL and the Central Electricity Authority have taken a particular view:
Held: When various expert bodies like the CERC, the APTEL and the Central Electricity Authority after considering the relevant material on record have taken a particular view, the Court should be slow in interfering with the decisions taken by them – Unless the Court finds that the expert bodies have failed to take into consideration the mandatory statutory provisions or if their decisions are based on extraneous considerations or they are ex facie arbitrary and illegal, it will not be appropriate for this Court to substitute its views with that of the expert bodies. [Para 20] Electricity Act, 2003 – s.125 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.100 – Appeal u/s.125, when permissible:
Held: The appeal u/s.125 of the 2003 Act is only permissible on any of the grounds as specified in s.100 of the CPC – As such, it is permissible only on substantial questions of law. [Para 23] Electricity Act, 2003 – ss.79, 125 – The two instant appeals challenge the same judgment and final order of the APTEL – The first appeal being Civil Appeal No. 1929 of 2020 has been * Author 664 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports filed by Haryana Power Purchase Centre and two others (HPPC) whereas the second appeal being Civil Appeal No.3429 of 2020 has been filed by one GRIDCO – Earlier, Petition No.79/2013 came to be filed by GKEL-respondent no.1 before CERC against the Haryana Utilities for compensation due to force majeure events and change in law during the operation period – In the said petition, the GKEL-respondent no.1 sought adjustment of tariff on account of events of Change in Law which affected the power project during the operation period in order to restore GKEL to the same economic position that it would have been in if the concerned events had never occurred – CERC vide order dt. 03.02.2016 disposed of the said petition by allowing all such claims which fell within the parameters of Change in Law events – GKEL had preferred a similar petition being Petition No.112/MP/2015 against Bihar Utilities, the CERC vide order dt. 07.04.2017 disposed of the petition by allowing all such claims – The CERC vide another order dated 20.03.2018 disposed of the Petition No. 105 by directing the Haryana Utilities to pay the supplementary bills raised by GKEL – Appeals before the APTEL – The APTEL vide the common judgment and final order dated 20.12.2019 dismissed both the appeals and upheld the order of the CERC – Correctness:
Held: In the first Appeal No. 1929 of 2020, there are concurrent findings of facts not only in the impugned judgment passed by the APTEL and the order passed by the CERC in Petition No.105, but also in the order dated 03.02.2016 passed by the CERC in Petition No.79 during the first round of litigation – The Court will, therefore, have to be very slow in interfering with the said findings of fact – Unless it is found that the findings are perverse, arbitrary or in violation of the statutory provisions, it will not be permissible for this Court to interfere with the same – Also, this Court does not find any substantial question of law arises for consideration in the present appeal – The petition was filed by GKEL seeking relief on account of Change in Law on various grounds – One of the grounds was with regard to deviations from the New Coal Distribution Policy, 2007 (the NCDP) and changes in coal distribution policy of the Government of India and Coal India Limited – The perusal of paragraphs 54, 55 and 73 of the order passed by the CERC dated 03.02.2016 would reveal that it devised a formula for computing the Energy Charge Rate which required pro rata [2025] 9 S.C.R. 665Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others allocation of coal among all three DISCOMS – It is pertinent to note that the Haryana Utilities did not challenge the said order and paid the amounts due – The perusal of the aforesaid judgment and orders (CERC and APTEL) would reveal that they are based upon interpretation of various documents – Considering the concurrent findings of fact by the CERC on two different occasions and the APTEL in impugned order and also taking into note of the communication dated 02.02.2022 issued by MCL, this Court sees no merit in the appeal of Haryana Utilities – In the second appeal being Civil Appeal No.3429 of 2020 by GRIDCO is concerned, the main contention of GRIDCO is that the order dated 03.02.2016 in Petition No.79 and order dated 20.03.2018 in Petition No.105 were passed without impleading GRIDCO – It will be relevant to note that the PPA with GRIDCO is u/s.62 of the 2003 Act whereas the PPAs with the Haryana Utilities and Bihar Utilities are u/s.63 of the 2003 Act – As such there was no occasion for GKEL to implead GRIDCO as a party to the said petitions – Earlier, while considering the appeal of Haryana Utilities, this Court has already upheld the concurrent findings of the CERC and the APTEL that the coal supply from all the sources has to be apportioned amongst all the three DISCOMS in proportion to the energy supplied to them – None of the DISCOMS can claim a priority for supply of power based either on the prior date of agreement or the recital as to the source of coal – There is no merit in the present appeal as well – Appeals dismissed. [Paras 24, 28, 31, 34, 40, 41, 45] Case Law Cited Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited v. Adani Power Maharashtra Limited and Others [2023] 7 SCR 648 : (2023) 7 SCC 401 – relied on.
GMR Warora Energy Limited v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC) and Others [2023] 8 SCR 183 : (2023) 10 SCC 401; Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. & Another v. Adani Power (Mundra) Limited and Others [2023] 5 SCR 468 : (2023) 14 SCC 736; Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission and Others [2017] 3 SCR 153 : (2017) 14 SCC 80 – referred to.
GMR-Kamalanga Energy Limited v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd., 2016 SCC OnLine CERC 43 – referred to.
666 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Electricity Act, 2003; Finance Act 2010; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; New Coal Distribution Policy, 2007; CERC (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009.
List of Keywords Concurrent findings of CERC and APTEL; Electricity Appeals; Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Priority for supply of power; Force majeure events; Change in law during the operation period; Substantial question of law; Second appeal; Computing the Energy Charge Rate; None of the DISCOMS can claim a priority; Power purchase agreement; Pro rata allocation of coal; Slow in interfering; Expert bodies.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 1929 of 2020 From the Judgment and Order dated 20.12.2019 of the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity at New Delhi in AN No. 135 of 2018 With Civil Appeal No. 3429 of 2020 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
M.G. Ramachandran, C. Aryama Sundaram, Sr. Advs., Ms. Poorva Saigal, Shubham Arya, Nikunj Dayal, Ms. Pallavi Saigal, Abhishek Gupta, Harshwardhan Singh, Raj Kumar Mehta, Ms. Himanshi Andley.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Damma Seshadri Naidu, S.B. Upadhyay, Sr. Advs., Vishrov Mukerjee, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Yashaswi Kant, Ms. Juhi Senguttuvan, Ms. Priyanka Vyas, L. Nidhiram Sharma, Avishkar Singhvi, Karun Sharma, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, Vishrov Mukerjee, Pukhrambam Ramesh Kumar, Yashaswi Kant, Ms. Juhi Senguttuvan, Ms. Priyanka Vyas, L. Nidhiram Sharma, Avishkar Singhvi, Karun Sharma, Ms. Rajkumari Divyasana, Ms. Prerna Singh, Ravi Kishore, Guntur Prabhakar, Raj Kumar Mehta, Ms. Himanshi Andley, Nishant Kumar, Abhinav Kathulia, Ms. Anisha Upadhyay.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 667Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment B.R. Gavai, CJI.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
1. These appeals take exception to the judgment and final order dated 20th December 2019 passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, New Delhi 1 in Appeal No. 135 of 2018 along with Appeal No. 54 of 2019, whereby the learned APTEL dismissed the said appeals and upheld the order dated 20 th March 2018 passed by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, New Delhi 2 in Petition No. 105/ MP/2017 3 .
2. We have two appeals before us, both of which challenge the same judgment and final order of the learned APTEL. The first appeal being Civil Appeal No. 1929 of 2020 has been filed by Haryana Power Purchase Centre and two others 4 whereas the second appeal being Civil Appeal No. 3429 of 2020 has been filed by one GRID Corporation of Orissa Limited5 . For the sake of clarity and to avoid any confusion, the parties will be referred to according to their positions in the first of the two civil appeals.
3. Before we proceed with the facts of the case, it would be apposite to give a brief overview of the parties before us.
3.1 HPCC (Appellant No.1) is the nodal agency for the procurement of power on behalf of the distribution licensees in the State of Haryana, being Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (Appellant No.2) and Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (Appellant No.3). Haryana Power Generation Corporation Limited (Proforma Respondent No.6) is the body corporate that was responsible for the initiation of the competitive bid process on behalf of Appellant Nos. 2 and 3 for procurement 1 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘APTEL’ 2 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘CERC’ 3 Hereinafter referred to as ‘Petition No. 105’ 4 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘HPCC’ 5 Hereinafter referred to as ‘GRIDCO’ 668 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of power in the State of Haryana. Together, the said parties may be referred to as the “Haryana Utilities”.
3.2 GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited 6 (Respondent No.1) is a generating company within the meaning of the Electricity Act, 2003 7 . Notably, GKEL is a special purpose vehicle of GMR Energy Limited 8 which was the predecessor-in-interest of the Respondent No.1.
3.3 PTC India Limited 9 (Respondent No.2) is a trading licensee within the meaning of the 2003 Act. Respondent No. 2 had an arrangement with GKEL for the procurement of power.
3.4 CERC (Respondent No.3) is the regulatory commission under the 2003 Act.
3.5 GRIDCO (Respondent No.4) is a licensee under the 2003 Act which is responsible for procuring power for supply within the State of Odisha.
3.6 Similarly, Bihar State Power (Holding) Company 10 (Respondent No.5) is a licensee under the 2003 Act which is responsible for procuring power for supply within the State of Bihar.
4. Having given a brief overview of the parties in the civil appeals, we may now proceed to examine the facts which lead to the present appeals. The facts are as follows:- 4.1 With the intention to set up a thermal power plant of about 1,000 MW comprising of two units of about 500 MW each at village Kamalanga, Dhenkanal in the State of Odisha, GEL entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Government of Odisha on 9th June 2006. Per the terms of the MoU, the power project as envisaged was to operate with coal as the primary fuel, for which purpose the State of Odisha was to either allot coal blocks upon receipt of sanction from the Government of India or allot long-term coal linkage of such quality and quantity 6 Hereinafter referred to as ‘GKEL’ 7 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘2003 Act’ 8 Hereinafter referred to as ‘GEL’ 9 Hereinafter referred to as ‘PTC’ 10 Hereinafter referred to as ‘Bihar Utilities’ [2025] 9 S.C.R. 669Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others as required for the project. The MoU further necessitated that a nominated agency authorized by the Government of Odisha would have the right to purchase up to 25% of power sent out from the thermal power plants. While initially, the MoU envisaged the setting up of thermal plants with an aggregate capacity of 1,000 MW (500 x 2), by way of alteration carried out subsequently, it was decided that GKEL would develop four power plants each having a capacity of 350 MW. Three out of the four said units have been installed, however, the fourth unit of 350 MW is yet to be installed. Subsequently, this project was accorded the Mega Power Project status by the Ministry of Power, Government of India vide its letter dated 1 st February 2012.
4.2 In terms of the MoU, on 28 th September 2006, GKEL executed a Power Purchase Agreement with GRIDCO (Respondent No.4) being the nominated agency of the State of Odisha for the sale of 25% of the gross power generated by GKEL to GRIDCO, which came to 262.5 MW, upon the installed capacity reaching 1050 MW (350 MW x 3).
4.3 Thereafter, on 5th January 2007, GKEL addressed a letter to the Government of Odisha requesting the State Government for a recommendation to the Ministry of Coal, Government of India for the allotment of long-term coal linkage in favour of GKEL. Accordingly, the Department of Energy, Government of Odisha vide letters dated 19 th December 2005 and 12 th January 2007 pursued the matter with the Government of India.
4.4 While this was underway, on 1 st March 2007, the Haryana Power Generation Corporation (Respondent No.6) issued a Request for Proposal 11 on behalf of the Haryana Utilities for procurement of 2,000 MW power on a long-term basis. The said RfP envisaged the procurement of power by way of a tariff-based bidding process as provided for under Section 63 of the 2003 Act. In order to qualify for the bid, all the bidders were required to submit proof of fuel arrangements in terms of Clauses 2.1.5 and 2.1.5 A of the RfP which read thus: - 11 Hereinafter referred to as ‘RfP’ 670 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “2.1.5 All Bidders are required to submit copies of one or more of the following :-
(a) Linkage letter from the fuel supplier; or
(b) Fuel Supply Agreement between the Bidder and Fuel Supplier; or
(c) Coal Block Allocation letter/In principle approval for allocation of captive block from Ministry of Coal; or
(d) Other details submitted by Bidders subject to acceptance by the Procurer as sufficient proof for demonstration of ability, The above proof of fuel arrangement is not required in case the fuel to be used by the Bidder is imported fuel. 2.1.5 A The Successful Bidder is required to show a firm fuel supply agreement/linkage by the time limit specified for fulfilment of Conditions Subsequent as mentioned in the PPA”
4.5 Subsequently, the Standing Linkage Committee (Long Term)12 of the Government of India in a meeting dated 2nd August 2007 approved a firm coal linkage of 2.14 MTPA 13 for a 500 MW power plant as had been originally envisaged under the 1,000 MW (500 MW x 2) configuration.
4.6 In addition to the said approval, the Ministry of Coal, Government of India intimated its decision to allocate Rampia and Dip Side Rampia coal blocks in Odisha to a consortium of six generating companies including GEL. GEL’s share was 4.6 MTPA which corresponded to the project capacity of 1,000 MW. The approval came to pass when the Ministry of Coal, Government of India confirmed the allotment of the said coal blocks to the aforementioned consortium vide letter dated 17 th January 2008. 4.7 In the meanwhile, on 31 st October 2007, GEL entered into an agreement with PTC in order to enable the latter to participate in the bidding process initiated by Haryana Power Generation 12 Hereinafter referred to as ‘SLC-LT’ 13 Short for ‘million tonnes per annum’ [2025] 9 S.C.R. 671Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others Corporation (Respondent No. 6) by way of the RfP. In pursuit of the same, PTC submitted its bid for sale of 300 MW of power to the Haryana Utilities and the bid was accepted. Thereafter, vide an order dated 31 st July 2008, the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission (HERC) adopted the tariff successful bidders including PTC under Section 63 of the 2003 Act. 4.8 Subsequently, upon the allocation of the Rampia and Dip Side Rampia coal blocks to GEL and the remaining allottees of the consortium, Mahanadi Coalfields Limited 14 issued a Letter of Assurance 15 dated 25 th July 2008 in favour of GEL for providing firm linkage of 2.14 MPTA coal, being the normative requirement of one of the power plants having capacity of 500 MW. 4.9 Thereafter, on 7 th August 2008, PTC executed two separate Power Purchase Agreements 16 with the Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (Appellant No.2) and Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (Appellant No.3) for supply of 150 MW of power to each, aggregating to 300 MW with the Haryana STU-Inter Connection Point being the delivery point. Notably, the fuel type proposed to be utilized was Coal India Limited (CIL) coal linkage and it was proposed to be sourced from the MCL. 4.10 As the captive coal from Rampia and Dip Side Rampia had not become available, on 12th November 2008, the SLC-LT approved the tapering coal linkage of 2.384 MTPA for 550 MW of the power project, against the coal block allocation to the concerned project. In view of the same, on 8 th July 2009, MCL issued a LoA to GEL providing tapering linkage as aforementioned till captive coal blocks became available.
4.11 Subsequently, as aforementioned, GKEL and GRIDCO executed an amended and restated PPA on 4th January 2011 which altered the configuration of the thermal power plants and their output capacity, while keeping intact the entitlement of GRIDCO to 25% gross power generated by GKEL.
4.12 On 9th November 2011, GKEL entered into a PPA with Bihar State Electricity Board, being the predecessor to Bihar Utilities 14 Hereinafter referred to as ‘MCL’ 15 Hereinafter referred to as ‘LoA’ 16 Hereinafter referred to as ‘PPA’ 672 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports for supply of 260 MW of net power/282 MW of gross power. Per the said PPA, the fuel source proposed to be utilized was Coal India Limited (CIL) coal linkage and the coal was proposed to be sourced from MCL and the Rampia and Dip Side Rampia coal blocks allocated to GKEL.
4.13 Thereafter, on 26 th March 2013, MCL signed a Fuel Supply Agreement 17 with GKEL for supply of coal to the power plants (3 x 350 MW) being 500 MW under normal linkage and 425 MW generation capacity covered under long term PPA i.e., an aggregate of 1.819 MTPA/18.19 lakh tonnes. The FSA was amended from time to time, initially to increase the quantum of coal supplied from 1.819 MTPA to 2.0009 MTPA for the same capacity of 425 MW and thereafter, the FSA was further amended on 18 th September 2014 to increase the quantum of coal supplied to 2.14 MTPA on account of operationalization of the PPA with Bihar Utilities.
4.14 Subsequently, on 28 th August 2013, GKEL entered into another independent FSA with MCL for tapering linkage.
4.15 In the meanwhile, on 23rd April 2013, GKEL preferred Petition No. 79/MP/2013 18 before the CERC against Haryana Utilities, being a petition under Section 79 of the 2003 Act read with the statutory framework governing the procurement of power through the competitive bidding process and Articles 12, 13 and 17 of the PPA dated 7 th August 2008 executed between PTC and the Haryana Utilities and the back-to-back PPA dated 12 th March 2009 executed between GEL and PTC for compensation due to force majeure events and Change in Law during the operation period. In the said petition, the GKEL sought adjustment of tariff on account of events of Change in Law which affected the power project during the operation period in order to restore GKEL to the same economic position that it would have been in if the concerned events had never occurred. It is notable that GRIDCO was not made a party to this petition.
4.16 Soon thereafter, Unit I of the power project achieved commercial operation and GKEL began supplying power to GRIDCO w.e.f. 17 Hereinafter referred to as ‘FSA’ 18 Hereinafter referred to as ‘Petition No. 79’ [2025] 9 S.C.R. 673Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others 30 th April 2013. Within a few months, Unit II of the power project achieved commercial operation and GKEL commenced the supply of power to Haryana Utilities w.e.f. 7 th February 2014. Subsequently, Unit III of the power project achieved commercial operation on 25 th March 2014 and thereafter GKEL began supplying power to Bihar Utilities w.e.f. 1 st September 2014. 4.17 At this stage, it would be apposite to run through the quantum of power that was contracted to be delivered under each of the long-term PPAs, which are as follows:-
(a) Supply of 350 MW of gross power (Stage 1: 262.5 MW and Stage 2: 87.5 MW) to GRIDCO in terms of PPA dated 28 th September 2006 (as amended on 4 th January 2011, with delivery point as Odisha STU Interconnection point).
(b) Supply of 350 MW of gross power (300 MW net of transmission losses and auxiliary consumption) to Haryana Utilities based on PPA dated 7th August 2008 and backto-back PPA dated 12 th March 2009 executed between GEL and PTC.
(c) Supply of 282 MW of gross power (260 MW net of auxiliary consumption) to Bihar State Electricity Board in term of PPA dated 9 th November 2011, with delivery point as the Bihar STU Interconnection point.
4.18 The CERC vide order dated 3 rd February 2016 disposed of the Petition No. 79 filed by GKEL in the following terms:-
(i) At the time of bid submission, the notified rate of royalty on coal was Rs. 55+5% of ROM price per tonne. This was subsequently increased to an ad-valorem rate of 14% on price of coal. The CERC held that GKEL would be entitled to compensation for the same from Haryana Utilities.
(ii) At the time of bid submission, there was no clean energy cess on coal. However, this was subsequently introduced by way of the Finance Act 2010 whereby statutory cess of Rs. 100 per tonne had been levied on coal. This was subsequently reduced to Rs. 50 per tonne. The CERC held that GKEL would be entitled to recover clean energy cess from Haryana Utilities in proportion to the coal consumed for generation and supply of electricity to the appellants. 674 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(iii) At the time of bid submission, there was no excise duty on coal. Excise duty @ 6% on the determined sale price of coal was introduced by the Finance Act 2012. The CERC held that GKEL would be entitled to compensation through adjustment in tariff on account of the freshly applicable excise duty on coal.
(iv) Owing to shortfall in the linkage coal and also due to transfer of certain quantum of tapering linkage from MCL to Eastern Coalfields Limited, GKEL had to import coal and also source open market coal. This had led to an additional cost of Rs. 46.10 crores in the generation of power for the Haryana Utilities during the months of February and May to July 2014. The CERC held that GKEL would be entitled to compensation for the same and accordingly set out a mechanism for computing the actual additional cost incurred in a month to mitigate the shortfall in linkage coal. The actual compensation payable was to be calculated and certified by the auditor in terms of the method laid down by the CERC.
(v) At the time of submission of the bid, the pricing of coal was based on the UHV 19 method which was Rs. 400 per tonne for F-grade, run-of-mine coal. Thereafter, the Government of India directed a switchover from UHVbased pricing system to GCV 20 -based pricing system. This led to a significant increase in price. The resultant impact of the change was an increase in cost of Rs. 10.76 crores for a full year. The CERC disallowed this claim, holding that any decision affecting the price of inputs for generating electricity including coal could not be covered under Change in Law.
(vi) GKEL had also raised claims for increase in rail freight charges owing to busy season surcharge and development surcharge. CERC disallowed this claim.
19 Short for ‘Useful Heat Value’ 20 Short for ‘Gross Calorific Value’ [2025] 9 S.C.R. 675Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others
(vii) GKEL also raised claims towards compensation/payment for increase in MAT 21 rate from 11.33% to 20.01% as brought in by the Finance Act, 2012. This claim was also disallowed.
(viii) A claim was raised by GKEL for payment towards the increase in VAT22 from 4% to 5%. This claim was disallowed.
(ix) A claim was also raised for payment/compensation owing to increase in water charges, which was disallowed.
4.19 It is notable that GKEL had preferred a similar petition being Petition No. 112/MP/201523 against the Bihar Utilities with regard to the PPA executed between the said parties for compensation due to Change in Law which impacted revenues and costs during the operating period. Vide order dated 7th April 2017, the CERC disposed of the petition by allowing all such claims which fell within the parameters of Change in Law events. 4.20 Subsequently, in terms of the order dated 3rd February 2016 passed in Petition No. 79, GKEL raised supplementary bills towards compensation for ‘Change in Law’ events as approved by the CERC, by pro-rating coal received from various sources for the period commencing from February 2014 onwards. The bills were accompanied by Form 15, detailed annexures and calculations which clearly showed apportionment of firm linkage coal corresponding to respective PPA capacities.
4.21 Disputing the supplementary bills raised by GKEL, Haryana Utilities wrote to PTC on 22nd September 2016 seeking certain clarifications as to whether the bills were as per the order of the CERC dated 3 rd February 2016. GKEL responded to the letter on 6 th October 2016 wherein it contended that as per CERC’s order, it was entitled to claim additional cost incurred during a month in respect of imported coal, open market coal and tapering coal or any other coal purchased to make up the shortfall in the firm linkage coal supplied by MCL.
21 Short for ‘Minimum alternate tax’ 22 Short for ‘Value added tax’ 23 Hereinafter referred to as ‘Petition No. 112’ 676 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 4.22 Being dissatisfied with the response, Haryana Utilities refused to make payments. To resolve the issue, a meeting was held on 25th January 2017, however, the matter could not be resolved. In light of the same, it was decided by PTC that the supplementary bills raised by GKEL for the period between July 2016 to November 2016 would be considered to be disputed bills.
4.23 In order to resolve the issue, another meeting was convened between the parties on 24 th April 2017 wherein it was jointly agreed that a clarificatory petition/review petition would be filed before the CERC.
4.24 Thereafter, GKEL preferred Petition No. 105 before the CERC under Section 79(1)(b) and (f) of the 2003 Act read with Articles 11.6 and 17 of the PPA dated 7th August 2008 for the recovery of the outstanding amount from the Haryana Utilities raised vide supplementary bills.
4.25 The CERC vide order dated 20 th March 2018 disposed of the said petition by directing the Haryana Utilities to pay the supplementary bills raised by GKEL for the period from July 2016 to March 2017 along with late payment surcharge as per the provisions of the PPA executed between the parties within one month. The CERC held, in terms of the previous order dated 3 rd February 2017 as well as the decision of this Court in Energy Watchdog v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission and Others 24, GKEL would be eligible for relief for any shortfall in the firm linkage and tapering linkage met through import and open market coal. To avoid putting GRIDCO and Bihar Utilities at a disadvantage, the CERC further directed that the firm and tapering linkage coal supplied to GKEL would have to be apportioned on a pro rata basis to all the beneficiaries of the project and the cost of procurement of coal from alternate sources to meet the shortfall would also be apportioned pro rata based on power supplied to beneficiaries.
4.26 Aggrieved thereby, Haryana Utilities preferred Appeal No. 135 of 2018 before the learned APTEL. Subsequently, GRIDCO preferred Appeal No. 54 of 2019 before the learned APTEL.
24 (2017) 14 SCC 80
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 677Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others 4.27 The learned APTEL vide the common judgment and final order dated 20 th December 2019 dismissed both the appeals and upheld the order of the CERC.
4.28 Hence, these civil appeals under Section 125 of the 2003 Act.
SUBMISSIONS
5. We have heard Shri M.G. Ramachandran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned Senior Counsel and Shri Vishrov Mukherjee, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.1, Ms. Prerna Singh, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.2, Shri Raj Kumar Mehta, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No. 4 and Shri S.B. Upadhyay, learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent No.5.
6. Shri Ramchandran, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the Haryana Utilities submitted that from the perusal of the RfP issued by Haryana Utilities in March, 2007 and the bid submitted by GKEL on 23 rd November 2007 through PTC, it is clear that the bidders were required to submit the details with regard to fuel arrangement, source of fuel among other particulars. It is equally clear that while submitting the bid, GKEL had shown the source of fuel to be firm linkage granted by way of SLC-LT meeting held on 2 nd August 2007. It is further submitted that the perusal of PPA dated 7 th August 2008 between Haryana Utilities and PTC would also show that the PPA was based on firm linkage coal from MCL. It is submitted that as against this, the PPA dated 9 th November 2011, entered into by GKEL with Bihar Utilities clearly indicated the sources of fuel as firm linkage as well as Rampia and Dip Side of Rampia coal block allotment (tapering linkage).
7. Shri Ramchandran further submitted that FSA as well as the LoA in favour of GKEL for the first phase was unit specific. It is submitted that FSA becomes operational in proportion to the generation covered under long term PPAs. It is submitted that at the time when the FSA dated 26 th March 2013 was signed, even though the linkage was for 500 MW, only 425 MW was considered as generation capacity. This was so since the PPAs with Haryana Utilities for 300 MW as well as with GRIDCO for 125 MW were the only long term PPAs at that time. Shri Ramchandran further submitted that subsequently, when the Bihar PPA became operational, the capacity under the 678 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports FSA vis-à-vis firm linkage was modified by specific additional 29.55 MW (out of a total Bihar PPA capacity of 260 MW).
8. Shri Ramchandran contended that the Haryana Utilities would be entitled to supply of 300 MW of energy from the firm linkage whereas GRIDCO would be entitled to supply of 125 MW energy produced using the coal available from the firm linkage. It is, therefore, submitted that the Haryana Utilities cannot be burdened with the additional cost incurred on account of production of coal from the MCL tapering linkage. Shri Ramchandran submitted that the difference on account of the use of fuel from tapering linkage will have to be borne only by the GRIDCO and Bihar Utilities inasmuch as the said coal was used for production of power for Unit II of 200 MW and Unit III of 350 MW. It is, therefore, submitted that both the CERC as well as the learned APTEL erred in putting the burden on the Haryana Utilities whereas the same should have been apportioned to Bihar Utilities and GRIDCO.
9. Shri Raj Kumar Mehta, learned counsel appearing on behalf of GRIDCO submitted that it was the PPA with GRIDCO which came to be operationalized first in April 2013. It is submitted that even though GRIDCO’s share in the installed capacity of the thermal station of GKEL was 25%, the order dated 3rd February 2016 in Petition No. 79 and order dated 20th March, 2018 in Petition No. 105 were passed without impleading GRIDCO. It is submitted that GRIDCO was a necessary and proper party as its rights were adversely affected. It is submitted that GRIDCO was also not impleaded in the appeal being Appeal No. 135 of 2018 filed by the Haryana Utilities before the learned APTEL. It is submitted that on account of the order dated 28th November 2018 of the learned APTEL, GRIDCO came to be impleaded in the said appeal.
10. Shri Mehta further submitted that the reasoning given by the learned APTEL that since GRIDCO’s PPA was Cost Plus Tariff PPA under Section 62 of the 2003 Act whereas the proceedings before the CERC and the learned APTEL were initiated seeking compensation on the grounds of Change in Law with regard to Haryana Utilities and Bihar Utilities which fell under Section 63 of the 2003 Act and therefore, GRIDCO was not necessary party, is wholly unsustainable. It is submitted that GKEL had specifically prayed for pro rating of linkage coal amongst all the three utilities namely GRIDCO, Haryana Utilities and Bihar Utilities and as such GRIDCO was a necessary party. [2025] 9 S.C.R. 679Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others
11. It is submitted that the project sought to be installed by GKEL was at the instance of the Government of Odisha. It is submitted that the State of Odisha had provided all the necessary facilities to GKEL to install the project. It is therefore submitted that it is the GRIDCO which had the first right to the power generated from the coal made available from the firm linkage.
12. Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi appearing on behalf of the respondent No. 1 submitted that the appeals are liable to be dismissed on the short ground that they do not raise any substantial question of law as is required under Section 125 of the 2003 Act. It is further submitted that the order dated 20th March 2018 in Petition No. 105 is passed by the CERC on the basis of its earlier order dated 3 rd February, 2016 in Petition No. 79. It is submitted that the CERC in Petition No. 79 had clearly held that coal supplied to GKEL under linkage by Government of India is to be apportioned on pro rata basis to all the three Distribution Companies25 i.e. Haryana Utilities, GRIDCO and Bihar Utilities. It is submitted that since the Haryana Utilities had not challenged the said order, it was not permissible for them to challenge the order passed in Petition No. 105. It is further submitted that supply of coal from all the modes of procurement has to be considered for the power project inasmuch as allocation by Government of India was for the whole project and not specific to any particular DISCOM.
13. Dr. Singhvi further submitted that the concurrent orders passed by the CERC and the learned APTEL are equitable orders inasmuch as it has been held that coal supplied under the linkage is to be apportioned on pro rata basis to all the DISCOMS. However, if the contentions of the Haryana Utilities are accepted, it will amount to burdening the consumers in the State of Odisha and Bihar. It is further submitted that if the contentions of both Haryana Utilities and GRIDCO are accepted, it will amount to putting the total burden on the consumers in the State of Bihar.
14. Dr. Singhvi further contended that the attitude of Haryana Utilities is of approbation and reprobation. It is submitted that in the case of Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. & Another v. Adani 25 Hereinafter referred to as ‘DISCOMS’ 680 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Power (Mundra) Limited and Others26, this Court noted that after accepting before the CERC that they would adopt the methodology as given in the case of GMR-Kamalanga Energy Limited v. Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. 27, Haryana Utilities changed their stand subsequently.
15. In the totality, Dr. Singhvi submitted that the appeals deserve to be dismissed.
16. Shri S.B. Upadhyay, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of respondent No. 5 has supported the concurrent orders of the CERC and the learned APTEL.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
17. At the outset, it can be noticed that all three DISCOMS agree that GKEL is entitled to compensation on account of Change in Law event. However, the Haryana Utilities and GRIDCO argued that the said liability should not come to them but should instead be passed on to the other two. It is only the Bihar Utilities which agrees that the liability has to be equally shared by all three DISCOMS in proportion to the energy supplied to them. We find it appropriate to deal with both the appeals separately.
CIVIL APPEAL NO. 1929 OF 2020
18. Undisputedly, the present appeal filed by Haryana Utilities challenges the impugned judgment and final order passed by learned APTEL whereby the learned APTEL has upheld the order of the CERC. The appeal to this Court has been filed under Section 125 of the 2003 Act. The perusal of Section 125 shows that the appeal is tenable only on the grounds as available under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 28 , as such, it could be seen that appeal would be tenable only on a substantial question of law.
19. One of us (B.R. Gavai, J, as he then was) had an occasion to deal with a large batch of electricity appeals pertaining to Change in Law event. This Court first decided the common issues involved in the
26 (2023) 14 SCC 736
27 (2016) SCC OnLine CERC 43 28 Hereinafter referred to as “CPC”
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 681Haryana Power Purchase Centre (HPPC) and Others v. GMR Kamalanga Energy Limited and Others said batch of appeals in Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited v. Adani Power Maharashtra Limited and Others 29. It would be apposite to refer to following paragraphs of the said judgment:
“118. It could thus be seen that two expert bodies i.e. CERC and the learned APTEL have concurrently held, after examining the material on record, that the factors of SHR and GCV should be considered as per the Regulations or actuals, whichever is lower. CERC as well as the State Regulatory bodies, after extensive consultation with the stakeholders, had specified SHR norms in the respective Tariff Regulations. In addition, insofar as GCV is concerned, the CEA has opined that the margin of 85-100 kcal/kg for a non-pit head station may be considered as a loss of GCV measured at wagon top till the point of firing of coal in boiler.
119. In this respect, we may refer to the following observations of this Court in Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra [ Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, (2019) 3 SCC 352] : (SCC pp. 376-77, paras 38-39)
“38. MERC is an expert body which is entrusted with the duty and function to frame regulations, including the terms and conditions for the determination of tariff. The Court, while exercising its power of judicial review, can step in where a case of manifest unreasonableness or arbitrariness is made out. Similarly, where the delegate of the legislature has failed to follow statutory procedures or to take into account factors which it is mandated by the statute to consider or has founded its determination of tariffs on extraneous considerations, the Court in the exercise of its power of judicial review will ensure that the statute is not breached.
29 (2023) 7 SCC 401, hereafter referred to as MSEDCL 682 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports However, it is no part of the function of the Court to substitute its own determination for a determination which was made by an expert body after due consideration of material circumstances.
39. In Assn. of Industrial Electricity Users v. State of A.P. [Assn. of Industrial Electricity Users v. State of A.P., (2002) 3 SCC 711] a three-Judge Bench of this Court dealt with the fixation of tariffs and held thus : (SCC p. 717, para 11)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.