Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1042; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2108
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 26 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 36/2019
- Sections
- 376(2), 201, 302, 313, 366, 106, 161, 293, 329
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2108 : 2025 INSC 1042 Putai v.
State of Uttar Pradesh (Criminal Appeal No(s). 36-37 of 2019)
26 August 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The accused-appellants were convicted for the offences punishable u/ss.376(2)(g), 201 and 302 of Penal Code, 1860. The High Court dismissed the appeals against conviction preferred by the accused-appellants.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.376(2)(g), 201 and 302 – Allegation against the accused-appellants that they raped and murdered a minor girl – Trial Court convicted the accused-appellants for the offences punishable u/ss.376(2)(g), 201 and 302 of Penal Code, 1860 – Accused no.1 was sentenced rigorous life imprisonment u/s.376(2)(g) of IPC; seven years rigorous imprisonment u/s.201 of IPC and death penalty u/s.302 of IPC – Accused no.2 was sentenced rigorous life imprisonment u/s.376(2)(g) of IPC; seven years rigorous imprisonment u/s.201 of IPC and rigorous life imprisonment u/s.302 of IPC – The High Court answered the death reference in the affirmative, confirming the death penalty awarded to accused no.1 and dismissed the appeals against conviction preferred by the accused-appellants – Correctness:
Held: 1. It is a settled tenet of criminal jurisprudence that in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence, the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt – The incriminating circumstances must be such which point exclusively to the guilt of the accused and are inconsistent with his innocence or the guilt of anyone else – In the instant case, the evidence on the record has fallen woefully short of proving the guilt of the accused-appellants by clinching evidence which can be termed as proving the case beyond all manner of doubt – Hence, appellants are acquitted by giving them the benefit of doubt. [Paras 78-80] * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2109Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh
2. A fact emerging from the statement of PW-1 is that he did not mention that the underwear of the child victim was found in the field of accused no.1 – The only fact in deposition of PW-1 which is alleged as incriminating against accused no.1, was the narrative that his wife (PW-2) saw accused no.1 washing his hands and face and going into his house – This Court finds that there is nothing unnatural or unusual in this conduct of accused no.1 as it is natural to carry out these ablutions upon returning from work etc. – Further, accused no.1 has given an explanation in his s.313 CrPC statement that his parents were ill and were hospitalized on the date of the incident – In this background, the fact that accused no.1 was seen by PW-2 rushing into his house, changing clothes and going away cannot be treated to be a suspicious conduct or a fact which inculpates him in the crime. [Paras 28, 30, 35]
3. So far as the accused no. 2 is concerned, the theory set forth by the prosecution, that the comb used by accused no. 2 was recovered from the field and that the sniffer dog, after sniffing the said comb, led the police team to the house of the accused no. 2 is also shrouded in a cloud of doubt – As there is a significant contradiction regarding the colour of the comb which was recovered by the police – Admittedly, there was no special feature in the recovered comb which was an ordinary plastic comb – Further, the procedure pertaining to the exercise of the sniffer dog and failure to prepare any contemporary document for the search by the dog squad makes the entire procedure doubtful – Hence, the theory propounded by the prosecution that the comb found at the spot, was of accused no. 2 falls flat to the ground and is unworthy of credence. [Paras 36-39]
4. The aspect regarding the recovery of the underwear of the child victim from the field of accused no.1 is concerned, the same seems to be a planted recovery and a creation by the Investigating Officer (PW-9) intended to give succor to the prosecution case – The fact regarding the presence of the underwear would definitely have been mentioned in the complaint (Exhibit K-1) filed by (PW 1) to the police – Omission of the fact is far too significant to be overlooked. [Para 43]
5. PW-7, being the medical jurist did not give any opinion regarding the cause of death of the child victim – She claimed to have taken two vaginal swabs and two vaginal smear slides, which were sent 2110 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports for examination of spermatozoa and gonococci – PW-7 did not state that the vaginal swabs and the slides were sealed – She did not even mention the date on which these vital forensic materials were handed over for onward transmission – The witness (PW- 8-doctor) stated that he collected part of scalp hair with skin for DNA, a piece of sternum bone and eight slides of smear and swabs – Not a single document pertaining to this procedure was proved by the witness – Hence, the entire procedure of collecting forensic samples becomes doubtful. [Paras 49, 51, 52]
6. As per the version of the Investigating Officer (PW-9), he had immediately sealed the comb at the spot – Therefore, the same could not have been available for the sniffer dogs to smell – Evidence of PW-9 is that the personal articles of the child victim, i.e., the frock and the underwear which he seized were never forwarded to the FSL – The very fact that the Investigating Officer (PW-9) did not consider it essential to send the articles to the FSL gives rise to a strong suspicion that the recovery of these articles was a planted recovery. [Paras 55, 56]
7. The DNA reports are totally inadmissible in evidence – There is a total lack of evidence regarding the chain of custody of the blood samples – There is a grave discrepancy in the evidence of the two medical jurists, i.e., PW-7 and PW-8 regarding the number of slides prepared for DNA examination – The conclusions in the first DNA report and the supplementary DNA report are in stark contradiction. [Para 65]
8. The material objects including the clothes of the child victim were exhibited in the evidence of PW-9, but the same were not shown to the parents, i.e., PW-1 and PW-2 for identification when they stepped into the witness box – Hence, a doubt is created as to whether the articles so recovered were actually of the child victim or not – The prosecution has given no explanation whatsoever as to why the clothes of the child victim were not forwarded to the FSL for forensic examination. [Paras 67, 68]
9. In conclusion, there is no hesitation in holding that other than the allegation that the child victim’s chappals, underwear and the water canister were found in the field which was cultivated by accused no.1, the prosecution has failed to lead any credible evidence whatsoever which can be considered to be incriminating the accused-appellants for the crime in question. [Para 77] [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2111Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh Evidence – Circumstantial Evidence – Distance between ‘may be proved’ and ‘must be proved’:
Held: The distance between ‘may be proved’ and ‘must be proved’ is small but has to be travelled before the prosecution can seek conviction of the accused in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence. [Para 69] List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
List of Keywords Evidence; Circumstantial evidence; May be proved and must be proved; Incriminating circumstances; Forensic examination; Credible evidence; DNA report; Plantation of articles; Recovery of articles; Procedure of collecting samples; Benefit of doubt; Beyond reasonable doubt; Rigorous punishment; Death penalty; FSL; Inquest report.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 36-37 of 2019 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.10.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in CCN No. 3 and CRLA No. 444 of 2014 With Criminal Appeal No. 154 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Shadan Farasat, Sr. Adv., Ms. Shreya Rastogi, Ms. Manasa Ramakrishna, Abhishek Babbar, Mangesh Naik, Kabir Dixit, Varinder Kumar Sharma, R. D. Rathore, S. K. Bandyopadhyay, Dhruva Kumar, Rajiv Agnihotri, Jeevan R. Patil.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Shaurya Sahay, Aditya Kumar, Ms. Ruchil Raj.
2112 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Vide judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 14th March, 2014 and 19th March, 2014, passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 13, Lucknow 1 , in Sessions Case No. 61 of 2013, the accused-appellants were convicted for the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(g), 201 and 302 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 2 and were sentenced in the terms below: - Accused Section(s) Sentence awarded Accused No.
1-Putai3 • 376(2)(g) IPC • 201 IPC • 302 IPC • R i g o r o u s l i f e imprisonment along w i t h a f i n e o f R s 40,000/- and in default to undergo an additional one year of rigorous imprisonment.
• Seven years rigorous imprisonment along w i t h a f i n e o f R s 20,000/- and in default to undergo an additional 6 months of rigorous imprisonment.
• Death penalty along w i t h a f i n e o f R s 60,000/- and in default to undergo an additional one and a half year of rigorous imprisonment.
1 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘trial Court’.
2 Hereinafter, being referred to as the ‘IPC’ 3 Appellant in Criminal Appeal Nos. 36-37 of 2019.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2113Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh Accused No.
2-Dileep 4 • 376(2)(G) IPC • 201 IPC • 302 IPC • R i g o r o u s l i f e imprisonment along with a fine of Rs 40,000/and in default to undergo an additional 1 year of rigorous imprisonment.
• 7 y e a r s r i g o r o u s imprisonment along w i t h a f i n e o f R s 20,000/- and in default to undergo an additional 6 months of rigorous imprisonment.
• R i g o r o u s l i f e imprisonment along w i t h a f i n e o f R s 60,000/- and in default to undergo an additional one and a half year of rigorous imprisonment.
3. The trial Court made a reference 5 to the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad6 for confirmation of the death sentence awarded to accused No.1-Putai under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 7 . The accused-appellants also preferred separate appeals 8 for assailing their conviction and the sentences awarded to them by the trial Court. The High Court answered the death reference in the affirmative, confirming the death penalty awarded to accused No.1- Putai and dismissed the appeals against conviction preferred by the accused-appellants vide judgment dated 11 th October, 2018, which is subject matter of challenge in these appeals by special leave. 4 Appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 154 of 2025.
5 Capital Sentence No. 3 of 2014.
6 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘High Court’.
7 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘CrPC’.
8 Accused No.1-Putai preferred Criminal Appeal No. 444 of 2014 and accused No.2-Dileep preferred Crl. Appeal No. 597 of 2014.
2114 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Brief facts: -
4. The facts in nutshell necessary and essential for disposal of these appeals are noted hereinbelow.
5. Mst. S, minor daughter 9 (aged about 12 years) of Munna (PW-1) and Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) had gone out to attend the call of nature in the late evening of 4 th September, 2012. When the girl did not return, the parents got alarmed and a search operation was launched, but to no avail.
6. In the morning of 5 th September, 2012, the child victim’s chappals, water canister, underwear and blood stains were seen spread around in Bhaktisharan’s field which was under cultivation of accused No.1- Putai. The denuded dead body of the child victim was found lying amidst the rice crop growing in Harikrishna Sharma’s field. Munna (PW-1), the father of the child victim submitted a complaint 10 to the Inspector of Police on 5 th September, 2012 at around 08:30 AM alleging that some unknown persons had committed rape and thereafter, murdered his minor daughter. Based on the same, an FIR bearing Case Crime No. 318 of 2012 11 came to be registered at Police Station Mohanlalganj, Lucknow for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201 and 376 of IPC.
7. The investigation commenced and was assigned to Sub-Inspector Narad Muni Singh (PW-9) 12 . He inspected the crime scene; prepared the rough site map 13 and vide seizure memo 14 collected the following articles from the fields of Bhaktisharan and Harikrishna which were taken on rent for cultivation by accused No.1-Putai and Radheyshyam Maurya respectively: i. Plain soil.
ii. Blood-stained soil.
iii. Blood-stained grass.
9 Hereinafter, being referred to as ‘child victim’.
10 Exhibit K-1.
11 Exhibit K-5 12 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘Investigating Officer (PW-9)’ 13 Exhibit K-8.
14 Exhibit K-7.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2115Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh iv. A pair of pink hawaai chappals.
v. Blue colour undergarment.
vi. A water canister.
vii. A sky-blue colour frock.
viii. A small male comb.
8. All these articles were seized and sealed in three separate packets. As per the rough site map, the dead body of the child victim was found in the field of Harikrishna Sharma whereas, the chappals, water canister, and underwear of the child-victim were found in the field of Bhaktisharan. A brick road passed between the aforesaid two fields.
9. The prosecution claims that the dog squad was called to the place of occurrence. The sniffer dog sniffed the small male comb and led the police team to the house of accused No. 2-Dileep.
10. The inquest report of the dead body of the child victim was prepared15 which was then subjected to post mortem by a Medical Board of which, Dr. Geeta Chaudhary (PW-7), Dr. Akhilesh Chandra (PW-8) and Dr. Anant Prakash Mishra were members.
11. The medical board conducted autopsy and issued the postmortem reports16 opining that the child victim had been subjected to grave violence and sexual assault and died as a result of asphyxia due to strangulation. As many as nine ante mortem injuries were noticed on the child victim’s body including numerous on her nether regions.
12. From the statements of various witnesses examined by the Investigating Officer (PW-9), the needle of suspicion turned towards the accused-appellants who were arrested on 7 th September, 2012. However, it may be noted that the prosecution did not exhibit the arrest memos of the accused-appellants.
13. The prosecution claims that the blood samples of the accusedappellants were collected under orders of the Court on 26 th November, 2012 for the purpose of DNA comparison. The DNA report 17 was received as per which, the comparison did not yield any conclusive 15 Exhibit K-9.
16 Exhibit K-5 and K-6.
17 Exhibit K-14.
2116 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports results. After conclusion of investigation, chargesheet was laid against the accused-appellants for the offences punishable under Sections 376(2)(g), 201 and 302 IPC. The offences being sessions triable, the case was committed and made over to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 13, Lucknow, for trial where charges were framed for the above offences against the accused-appellants, who abjured their guilt and claimed trial.
14. The prosecution examined as many as 12 witnesses, exhibited 17 documents and 5 material objects to prove its case. The team leader of the dog squad, namely, Tribhuvan Narayan Jaiswal was examined as Court Witness No.1. Statements of the accused-appellants were recorded under Section 313 CrPC, and they were confronted with the allegations as appearing against them in the prosecution case. They denied the same and claimed to be innocent. Three witnesses were examined in defence.
15. Upon hearing the arguments advanced by the Public Prosecutor and the defence counsel and after appreciating the evidence on record, the trial Court proceeded to convict and sentence the accused-appellants as stated supra. The reference for confirmation of the death sentence awarded to accused No.1-Putai by the trial Court was answered in affirmative by the High Court, whereas the appeals preferred by the accused-appellants were rejected vide common judgment dated 11 th October, 2018, passed by the High Court which is assailed in these appeals by special leave.
Submissions on behalf of accused-appellants.
16. Shri. Shadan Farasat, learned senior counsel appearing for the accused No.1-Putai, and Shri Varinder Kumar Sharma, learned counsel representing the accused No. 2-Dileep, vehemently and fervently contended that the conviction of the accused-appellants by the Trial Court, and affirmed by the High Court, is based purely on conjectures and surmises. The prosecution case is totally based on circumstantial evidence and that the prosecution could not lead proper/ reliable evidence to establish the complete chain of incriminating circumstances establishing the guilt of the accused-appellants beyond all manner of doubt. The testimony of the prosecution witnesses is full of inherent contradictions and improbabilities and does not inspire confidence.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2117Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh
17. It was further submitted that the prosecution has tried to place reliance on the so-called suspicious conduct of accused No.1-Putai in order to draw an inference regarding his culpable state of mind. As per Shri Farasat, the fact that the accused-appellants was seen behaving abnormally was introduced by way of a sheer improvement because, in the complaint filed by Munna (PW-1), no such allegation was levelled.
18. It was further submitted that the blind reliance placed by the trial Court and the High Court upon the DNA report is absolutely unjustified. The prosecution failed to lead proper evidence to establish the sanctity of the samples from the time of seizure till the time the same reached the Forensic Science Laboratory18 .
19. He further contended that the first DNA report dated 18 th January, 2014 did not inculpate the accused-appellants. However, during the pendency of appeals before the High Court, the prosecution produced a supplementary DNA report dated 2 nd December, 2014 by way of an affidavit but the same was never put to the accusedappellants under Section 313 CrPC. Furthermore, the expert witness who conducted the DNA profiling and issued the supplementary DNA report was not examined in evidence and hence, the subsequent DNA report is inconsequential and inadmissible in evidence. It was further contended that since the glaring discrepancies in the two reports of DNA profiling have not been explained by the prosecution, the High Court committed grave error in placing reliance on the same.
20. On these grounds, learned counsel representing the accusedappellants, implored the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the impugned judgments passed by the High Court as well as the trial Court and acquit the accused-appellants of the charges levelled against them.
Submissions on behalf of respondent-State
21. Per contra, learned counsel representing the respondent-State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the counsel appearing for the accused-appellants. It was contended 18 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘FSL’ 2118 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that the material witnesses and the accused-appellants are close neighbours. The material witnesses who hail from a rustic background had no reason whatsoever to falsely implicate the accused-appellants in the case. These witnesses have given natural and truthful evidence regarding the suspicious conduct of the accused-appellants corresponding to the time of the incident. The present case emanates from a gruesome incident wherein the minor daughter of Munna (PW-1) and Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) was raped and murdered in a very brutal manner and thus, trivial inconsistencies in evidence of the witnesses were bound to occur and no advantage thereof can be gained by the accused-appellants. It was submitted that the FIR was lodged without any delay in the morning of the 5th September, 2012, soon after the dead body of the child victim was found and hence, the family members would have been in a deep state of shock. Thus, omission of trivial facts from the FIR cannot be a ground to discard the entire prosecution case.
22. It was further submitted that the underwear and other personal articles i.e., chappals and water canister of the child victim were recovered from the field which accused No.1-Putai was admittedly cultivating. Hence, by virtue of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the burden would shift on to the accused- appellants to explain the circumstances under which, these gravely incriminating articles, were found in his field.
23. It was further submitted that the prosecution witnesses, i.e., Munna (PW1) and Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) have given convincing evidence to prove the suspicious conduct of the accused-appellants corresponding to the time of the incident. Since, there was no animosity whatsoever between these witnesses and the accusedappellants, there could not have been any reason for them to falsely implicate the accused-appellants for the rape and murder of their minor child. They, therefore, urged that the conviction of the accusedappellants as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court is based on apropos appreciation of evidence available on record. The impugned judgments are well reasoned and have been rendered after thorough evaluation of evidence. The same do not suffer from any infirmity or perversity and hence, the appeals being devoid of merit should be dismissed.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2119Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh Analysis: -
24. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have gone through the impugned judgments and material placed on record.
25. The following facts are admitted from the record: i. The child victim went missing on 4th September, 2012 at around 07:00 PM. She had gone out for attending the call of nature and was not found alive thereafter.
ii. The parents and neighbours conducted a search for the child victim throughout the night, but no clue was forthcoming regarding her whereabouts.
iii. As per the FIR 19 , the denuded dead body of the child victim was found in the field of Harikrishna Sharma whereas, some of her personal articles i.e., chappals, water canister and underwear were found in the field of Bhaktisharan. The report is silent regarding any suspicious act/conduct of the accusedappellants which may have been noticed or perceived by any of the prosecution witnesses. Rather, the report does not cast suspicion on anyone.
iv. Both the accused-appellants were arrested on 7th September, 2012 and their blood samples were drawn on 26 th November, 2012, i.e., after a gap of almost two and a half months. v. The first DNA examination report dated 18 th January, 2014 i.e., Exhibit K-14, remained inconclusive. The prosecution produced a supplementary DNA report dated 2nd December, 2014 during pendency of the appeals before the High Court by way of an affidavit dated 12 th April, 2017. However, notably, the first DNA report was totally silent regarding any pending tests or the requirement for re-examination of the samples. The supplementary DNA report was not put to the accusedappellants, and they were denied opportunity to rebut the same. vi. The prosecution did not examine the carrier who transmitted the samples from the police station to the FSL. Not a single 19 Exhibit K-2.
2120 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports document pertaining to safe keeping or transmission of the samples viz. maalkhana register, roznamcha entry, forwarding letter or the receipt issued from the FSL was exhibited or brought on record by the prosecution during the course of the trial.
26. Keeping the above admitted facts in mind, we now proceed to appreciate the evidence of the material prosecution witnesses.
27. Munna (PW-1), the informant, being the father of the child victim, testified that his daughter, Mst. S, informed her mother and went to ease herself in the field at about 07:00 PM. When she did not return for quite some time, the family members got worried and launched a search for her. The child’s mother, Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) kept on waiting at the house. She claims to have seen accused No.1- Putai washing his hands and face and going into his house during this period. The search party claims to have seen stains of blood and marks of dragging in the field of Bhaktisharan which was being cultivated by accused No.1-Putai. The chappals of the child victim were also found in the same field. Likewise, the water canister which the child victim had taken with herself was also found in a culvert near the field which accused No.1-Putai used to cultivate.
28. A very important fact emerging from the statement of Munna (PW- 1) is that he did not mention that the underwear of the child victim was also found in the field of accused No.1-Putai. Furthermore, none of the three incriminating articles, i.e., the chappals, the water canister or the underwear were exhibited during the evidence of Munna (PW-1) and Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) being the parents of the child victim. However, the Investigating Officer (PW-9) claims to have recovered the underwear of the child victim from the field which was under cultivation of accused No.1-Putai. We shall consider the import of this discrepancy later.
29. It is also relevant to mention here that Munna (PW-1) did not utter a single word regarding any procedure of using the dog squad to find out the suspect.
30. Thus, the only fact in deposition of Munna (PW-1) which is alleged as incriminating against accused No.1-Putai, was the narrative that his wife, Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) saw accused No.1-Putai washing his hands and face and going into his house. We find that there is nothing unnatural or unusual in this conduct of accused No.1-Putai. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2121Putai v. State of Uttar Pradesh Any labourer or farmer would be naturally inclined to carry out these ablutions upon returning from work and before entering one’s home. The actions as stated above are absolutely natural and would not raise any suspicion nor could the same be treated as incriminating conduct on the part of accused No.1-Putai.
31. Smt. Chandravati (PW2) being the mother of the child victim also gave evidence almost on the same lines as that of Munna (PW-1). In addition, she stated that she also went to the field in search of her daughter i.e., the child victim. Later, the efforts to search shifted to the homes of the relatives, but the same proved to be futile. She further alleged that she saw accused No.1-Putai who was looking disgruntled. He entered his house, changed his clothes and went away on his cycle. The witness stated that accused No.1-Putai did not make any enquiry whatsoever regarding the reason for the commotion being caused owing to the child victim having gone missing. This indifference shown by accused No.1-Putai has been treated to be an incriminating conduct by the trial Court as well the High Court on the ground that in the natural course of events, accused No.1-Putai should have got concerned and would definitely have enquired as to why the family members of the child victim were acting in a panic mode.
32. Be that as it may, we find that this version as set out in the evidence of Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) that accused No.1-Putai came rushing and he went inside his house, and changed the clothes, in addition to being an exaggeration/improvement from her previous statement under Section 161 CrPC cannot be considered to be an incriminating circumstance against accused No.1-Putai in isolation.
33. All that can be inferred from the statement of Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) is that accused No.1-Putai came to his house, changed his clothes and went away without demonstrating any interest whatsoever regarding the commotion which was prevailing on account of the child victim having gone missing.
34. To reiterate, there was nothing unusual in the conduct of accused No.1-Putai if he entered into his own house, even in haste, washed his face and hands and then, went away.
35. Accused No. 1-Putai has given an explanation in his Section 313 CrPC statement that his parents were ill and were hospitalized on 2122 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the date of the incident. This fact was admitted by Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) in her cross-examination. The accused has taken a specific defence that he was with his parents at the time of the incident. In this background, the fact that accused No.1-Putai was seen by Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) rushing into his house, changing clothes and going away cannot be treated to be a suspicious conduct or a fact which inculpates him in the crime.
36. So far as the accused No. 2-Dileep is concerned, Smt. Chandravati (PW-2) admitted in her cross-examination that accused No. 2-Dileep’s house is at a significant distance from her house. The theory set forth by the prosecution, that the comb used by accused No. 2-Dileep was recovered from the field of Harikrishna Sharma, and that the sniffer dog, after sniffing the said comb, led the police team to the house of the accused No. 2-Dileep is also shrouded in a cloud of doubt and unacceptable on the face of record and we have strong reasons for observing so.
37. Firstly, there is a significant contradiction regarding the colour of the comb which was recovered by the police. Munna (PW-1) stated that the comb was of bluish-green color. Gaya Prasad (PW-3) stated that the comb was dirty and light red coloured. Raushan Lal (PW- 5) stated that the comb was of sky-blue color. Narad Muni Singh (PW-9) stated that the comb was of green colour. These contrasting versions of the witnesses regarding the colour of the comb make the recovery by itself doubtful.
38. Secondly, the theory put forth in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses that they had seen accused No. 2-Dileep using the comb and thus they could identify and link the recovered comb to him is absolutely farfetched and unbelievable. Admittedly, there was no special feature in the recovered comb which was an ordinary plastic comb. Thousands of combs of similar design and colour are readily available in the market. Thus, it is impossible to believe that any person could identify the comb to be that of accused No. 2-Dileep simply on seeing him using the same. The emphatic version of the witnesses that the comb belonged to accused No. 2-Dileep is a strong indicator of the fact that the prosecution was hell bent upon implicating the accused No. 2-Dileep in this case by hook or by crook.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.