Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 842; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 103
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 14 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7706/2025
- Sections
- 145, 5
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 103 : 2025 INSC 842 Binod Pathak & Ors.
v.
Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 7706 of 2025)
14 July 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to the correctness of the order passed by the High Court that as some of the defendants before the first appellate court had passed away and their legal heirs were not brought on record in accordance with the provisions of Or.XXII r.4 CPC, the first appellate court could not have heard the first appeal on merits and decided the same in favour of the plaintiffs as it already stood abated.
Headnotes† Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XXII rr.4(3), 10A – Duty of pleader to communicate to court death of a party – Title suit instituted by appellants-plaintiffs – Dismissed by the trial court, however, allowed by the first appellate court – Second appeal by the respondent-defendant – Allowed by the High Court holding that as some of the defendants before the first appellate court had passed away and their legal heirs were not brought on record, and in absence thereof, the first appellate court could not have heard the first appeal on merits and decided the same in favour of the plaintiffs as it already stood abated – Correctness:
Held: Provisions of Or.XXII r.10A were not complied with by the High Court – While the first appeal was being heard, the defendants could have brought to the notice of the first appellate court that some of the defendants had passed away and the appeal had stood abated – Defendants being fully aware of the death of some of the defendants kept quiet and allowed the first appellate court to proceed with the hearing of the first appeal on merits – When the first appeal came to be allowed and the matter reached the High * Author 104 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Court in Second Appeal the issue as regards the abatement of suit came to be raised by the defendants due to non-substitution of legal heirs by the plaintiff, within the statutorily prescribed period of time – Abatement of suit is not a right that accrues to a party when the other party has failed to substitute legal heirs within the specified period of limitation – Abatement may be disallowed by the court if it has sufficient cause for condoning the delay of the party that ought to have filed for the substitution of legal heirs – u/ Or.XXII r.10A, the duty of a pleader to apprise the court as well as the other parties to the suit or appeal of the death of his client is a duty of candour and propriety as a responsible officer of the court – Failure of a party to perform the duty u/r.10A constitutes a wrongful act and such party must not be allowed to avail the benefit arising therefrom in the form of abatement – High Court erred in holding that Or.XXII r.10A is not mandatory and would not override the mandatory provisions relating to abatement in Or.XXII r.4 – Court should know how to apply the provision in the facts of each case – Line of reasoning adopted by the High Court if upheld would render Or.XXII r.10A otiose – Lawyer appearing for the defendants also kept quiet and proceeded to argue the matter on merits, smacks of lack of good faith – Thus, impugned order set aside – Matter remanded to the High Court. [Paras 23, 24, 58, 59, 65-73] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XXII r.10A – Duty of pleader: Held: Providing merely an information with regard to the fact of death is not sufficient compliance of the r.10A unless and until the counsel furnishes the information with regard to the details of the persons on whom and against whom the right to sue survives and the information u/r.10A and the object behind it would remain incomplete as the parties would still be labouring to inquire who are the legal representatives and find out as to upon whom and against whom the right to sue survives. [Para 63] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XXII r.10A – Duty of pleader to communicate to Court death of a party – Scope, objective and rationale of Or.XXII r. 10A – Nature of salutary provision of Or.XXII r.10A – Stated. [Paras 29-44, 50] Maxims – ‘ex injuria ius non oritur’ and ‘nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propia’ – Distinction between: [2025] 8 S.C.R. 105Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors. Held: Maxim ‘ex injuria ius non oritur’ is a principle that a right cannot emanate or emerge from a wrongful act, and the maxim ‘nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propria’, confirms the general rule of equity and prudence that no one can benefit from their own wrongdoing – Scope of the latter is wider than the former – First maxim explains that the legitimacy of a right stands vitiated if such right, which otherwise would have been legitimately exercisable, accrues from a wrongdoing of the person claiming under or exercising such right – Maxim solidifies the faith in law that no wrong action will be given a legal validity – Maxim, ‘nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propria’, on the other hand, lays itself as a rule of equity – Advantage falling from wrongdoing may be a legal or illegal advantage – Maxim dictates that, no profit or advantage of a person’s wrongful act may be validated by the seal of law – Interpretation of Ord. XXII r.10A is a manifestation of the latter and not the former – Thus, the principle that no party can take advantage of his/her own wrong, ‘nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propria’ is squarely attracted in the event of a failure in complying with the provision of r.10A of Ord. XXII CPC, and any abatement as a result of such wrongdoing or failure ought not to be validated by the courts – Thus, the maxim ‘ex injuria ius non oritur’ is different from the maxim ‘nullus commodum capere potest de inuria sua propria’ for the reason that the former pertains to a ‘right’ that may become available to a wrongdoer due to the wrongful act and the latter relates to an ‘advantage’ or ‘benefit’ that a wrongdoer may derive from his wrongful conduct – Although both are in essence a byproduct of the doctrine of equity and share a common genealogy under the doctrine of clean hands, the field in which they operate are different and distinct. [Paras 45-54] Judicial deprecation – Procedural errors by High Court – Disappointment with the manner in which the High Court dealt with the Second Appeal and its understanding as regards the position of law on provisions of Ord. XXII r.10A CPC – High Court took the view that in the absence of the legal heirs being substituted in accordance with the provisions of Ord. XXII r.4 CPC, the first appellate court could not have heard the first appeal on merits and decided the same in favour of the plaintiffs; and that the first appeal had already stood abated as the decree was joint and indivisible – Such procedural errors not expected at the level of any High Court – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. [Paras 12, 13, 23] 106 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Gangadhar v. Raj Kumar (1984) 1 SCC 121; United Bank of India v. Kanan Bala [1987] 2 SCR 1090 : (1987) 2 SCC 583; Kathpalia v. Lakhmir Singh (1984) 4 SCC 66; Kusheshwar Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar [2007] 4 SCR 95 : (2007) 11 SCC 447; Perumon Bhagvathy Devaswom Perinadu Village v. Bhargavi Amma (Dead) by Lrs. and Others [2008] 11 SCR 1 : (2008) 8 SCC 321; P. Jesaya (dead) by Lrs. v. Sub-collector and Anr. (2004) 13 SCC 431 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Schwebel, Stephen M. “Clean Hands, Principle” Eds., Rüdiger Wolfrum, Oxford University Press, 2009; Aaron X. Fellmeth and Maurice Horwitz “Guide to Latin Maxims in International Law” 1st Ed., Oxford University Press; Niel MacCormick, “Rights in Legislation”; Law, Morality and Society: Essays in Honour of H.L.A. Hart, P.M.S. Hacker, and Joseph Raz (eds). 189-206, Oxford: Clarendon Press (1977) – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Abatement; Duty of pleader; Intimate court about death of client; Doctrine of clean hands; Maxim ‘ex injuria ius non oritur’; Maxim ‘nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propia’; Procedural errors; Non-substitution of legal heirs; Contract between client and pleader; Statement of Objects and Reasons for the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Bill, 1976; First appellate court; Scope, objective and rationale of Or.XXII r.10A CPC; Nature of salutary provision of Or.XXII r.10A CPC; Procedural errors by High Court.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7706 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.10.2014 of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in SA No. 190 of 2008 [2025] 8 S.C.R. 107Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors. Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Gagan Gupta, Sr. Adv., Jayesh Gaurav, Ishwar Chandra Roy, Farrukh Rasheed.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Shantanu Sagar, Anil Kumar, Gunjesh Ranjan, Ms. Tara Chauhan, Manoneet Dwivedi, Gopal Jha, Prem Prakash, Kanhaiya Priyadarshi. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, this judgment is divided in the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX .......................................................................... 2 B. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES ................................................. 9 i. Submissions on behalf of the Appellants / Original Plaintiffs. ................................................................................ 9 ii. Submissions on behalf of the Respondents / Original Defendants. ............................................................................ 12 C. ANALYSIS ........................................................................................ 12 i. Relevant Statutory Provisions. ............................................ 13 ii. Order XXII, Rule 10A of the CPC. ........................................ 16 a. Rationale behind Order XXII Rule 10A. ........................ 20 b. Nature of the salutary provision of Order XXII Rule 10A. ... 21 I. Distinction between the legal maxims ‘ex injuria ius non oritur’ and nullus commodum capere potest de injuria sua propia’. ........................................... 22 II. Duty of Pleader. .................................................... 32 D. CONCLUSION ................................................................................. 38 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
108 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
1. Leave Granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High court of Judicature at Patna dated 22.10.2014 (hereinafter referred to as the “Impugned Order”) in Second Appeal No. 190 of 2008 by which the Second Appeal filed the respondents herein; the original defendants, came to be allowed thereby setting aside the judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court allowing the First Appeal filed by the appellants herein; the original plaintiffs, and decreeing the suit in their favour.
3. For the sake of convenience, the appellants herein shall be referred to as the original plaintiffs and the respondents herein shall be referred to as the original defendants.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
4. The plaintiffs instituted Title Suit No. 106 of 1984 in the Court of the Sub Judge – (I) Gopalganj (hereinafter, the “title suit”) for declaration of title and recovery of possession of suit land bearing Khewat Nos. 11 and 12 respectively, revisional survey Nos. 688, 689 and 690 respectively under Khata Nos. 571 and 574 respectively situated in the Village Harkhauli, P.S. Mirganj, District Gopalganj.
5. We need not go into the details of the nature of the suit instituted by the plaintiffs as we are inclined to dispose of this appeal on a neat question of law and remand the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration on merits.
6. In the aforesaid title suit instituted by the original plaintiffs referred to above, the trial court framed the following issues: -
(i) Is the suit, as framed, maintainable?
(ii) Have the plaintiffs got a valid cause of action or right to sue?
(iii) Whether the ancestors of Defendant nos. 7 to 10 had acquired occupancy right in respect of the suit land?
(iv) Have the plaintiffs got subsisting title and possession over the suit lands at the time of vesting of the intermediary interest in the state of Bihar as also on the date of proceeding under Section 145 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, the “Cr.P.C.”)?
(v) To what relief or reliefs, if any, are the plaintiffs entitled to in the aforesaid suit?
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 109Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
7. Upon appreciation of the oral as well as documentary evidence on record the trial court recorded a finding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish their case and accordingly the suit came to be dismissed vide the judgment and decree dated 05.07.1989.
8. The original plaintiffs being dissatisfied with the judgment and order passed by the trial court dismissing the suit went in First Appeal before the Court of Additional District Judge – (I), Gopalganj. The appeal came to be registered bearing Title Appeal No. 60/1989 renumbered as Title Appeal No. 58 of 2007.
9. The appeal filed by the plaintiffs came to be allowed by the First Appellate Court vide the judgment and order dated 02.06.2009.
10. The First Appellate Court while allowing the First Appeal of the plaintiffs held as under: - “18. In view of aforesaid finding I hold that plaintiffs have title on the suit land and they have been illegally dispossessed by the defendants, so plaintiffs title on suit land mentioned in schedule 2,3 and 4 of plaint is hereby upheld and the plaintiffs are entitled for recovery of possession of suit land. Plaintiffs have claimed mesne profit, but the lower court neither framed issue nor decided the same but in the light of aforesaid finding plaintiffs are entitled to mesne profit from the date of dispossession upto getting possession on the suit land which has to be determined by the lower court in separated proceeding if it will be initiated by the plaintiffs after delivery of possession.
Hence, the appeal is allowed with cost, the judgment and decree of the lower court is hereby set aside and the suit is decreed with cost. The plaintiffs have title and possession on schedule K. 2, 3 and 4 of the plaint and they are entitled for mesne profit from date of dispossession upto the date of getting delivery of possession. Defendants (respondents) are directed to deliver possession of the suit land to the plaintiffs within thirty days from today failing which plaintiffs (appellants) will be entitled to get delivery of possession according to the process of law.
I have already recorded finding that defendants (respondents) have constructed house and structures on 110 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports suit land during pendency of the suit so plaintiffs will have obtain to take delivery of possession either with house or structures by evicting persons residing in it or if they so like they may apply for demotion of house and structures at the cost of the defendants and to take vacant possession of the suit land. Pleaders fee Rs. 1000/- and Pleader’s clerk fee Rs. 250/-.”
11. The original defendants being dissatisfied with the judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court referred to above challenged the same before the High Court by way of Second Appeal. In the Second Appeal, the High Court formulated the following substantial questions of law: i. “Whether the judgment and decree of the appellate court could be said to be illegal in view of the same having been passed against several dead respondents, i.e. respondent nos. 3, 6(gh), 8, 9, 11 and 12?
ii. Whether the entry in the concerned ‘record of right can be presumed to be the entry in favour of the erstwhile intermediary as his private land?
iii. Whether in absence of any finding regarding the method and manner of dispossession as alleged by the plaintiffs, the relief of restoration of possession could have been granted especially when the plaintiffs have not adduced any evidence on this aspect of the matter?
iv. Whether the finding of the appellate Court that in absence of plea taken in the written statement no such plea can be allowed to be taken by the defendants is sustainable in law when both the parties had understood the respective cases and adduce evidence?”
12. It appears from the materials on record that when the aforesaid Second Appeal was taken up for hearing it came to the notice of the High Court that some of the respondents before the First Appellate Court i.e., some of the original defendants had passed away and their legal heirs were not brought on record. The High Court took [2025] 8 S.C.R. 111Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors. the view that in the absence of the legal heirs being substituted in accordance with the provisions of Order XXII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, the “CPC”) the First Appellate Court could not have heard the First Appeal on merits and decided the same in favour of the plaintiffs. The High Court took the view that the First Appeal had already stood abated as the decree was joint and indivisible.
13. The High Court held that in case of joint and indivisible decree the abatement of proceedings in relation to one or more of the appellant(s) or respondent(s) on account of omission or lapse and failure to bring on record his or their legal representatives in time would prove fatal to the entire appeal and the appeal would be liable to be dismissed.
14. The High Court while allowing the Second Appeal filed by the defendants held as under: - “At this juncture, it would be pertinent to mention that the judgment and decree in the suit has been passed on 25.07.1989 and the appeal thereafter came to be decided on 02.06.2008 reversing the judgment and decree in the suit and granting the decree to the plaintiff as prayed. The memo of this second appeal has been filed on 27.06.2008 by the original defendant no. 2 Bihari Choudhary, defendant no. 4 Baijnath Chaudhary and defendant no. 5 Harilal Choudhary along with the substituted heirs of the deceased defendant no. 1 Khobhari Choudhary and deceased defendant no. 6 Yamuna Choudhary. The appellant no. 7 Dhananjay Choudhary in this appeal is the substituted heir of Yadunandan Choudhary who was one of the substituted heirs of deceased defendant no. 6 Jamuna Choudhary in the appellate court below. From the perusal of the memo of the instant appeal, it further transpires that the respondent nos. 10 to 13 in this appeal’ have been impleaded as heirs of deceased defendant no. 3 Sheonath Choudhary.
On behalf of the appellants, it has been emphatically submitted that the defendant no. 3-respondent no. 3 (in the appellate court below) namely Sheonath Choudhary died on 07.05.1997 and similarly the substituted respondent no. 6 (Gha) (one of the substituted heirs of the deceased defendant no. 6 Yamuna Choudhary in the appellate court 112 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports below) died on 29.09.2000 during the pendency of the appeal in the court below. It has been further pointed out that the substituted respondent no. 7 (ka) Most. Dipiya (one of the substituted heirs of the deceased defendant no. 7 Mangaru Bhagat) died on 07.08.1999, the defendant no.
8- respondent no. 8 Bacha Bhagat died on 05.04.2003 and respondent no. 9 Nagina Bhagat also died on 05.11.2005 during the pendency of the appeal in the court below.
From the order dated 14.11.2008 passed in this appeal, it becomes evident that the fact of death of the aforesaid defendant respondents during the pendency of the appeal in the court below has been admitted by the plaintiffrespondents and it has been also admitted that their heirs could not be substituted in the said appeal.
Examined in the backdrop of these facts, it is vivid that the deceased defendant no. 3-respondent no. 3 Sheonath Choudhary was one of the purchasers of the suit land and similarly the deceased respondent no. 6 (Gha) was one of the substituted heirs of the original purchaser (Yamuna Choudhary) of the suit land. The remaining deceased respondent nos. 7(ka), 8 and 9 in the appeal in the court below were the heirs of the vendor of the defendant no. 1 to 6. The impugned judgment and decree by the appellate court below granting the declaration of title and entitlement of recovery of possession in favour of the plaintiffs has been passed against these deceased persons as well, along with the other respondents. In view of the nature of the decree as prayed for and granted by the appellate court below being joint and inseverable, it is evincible therefore that the same has been passed against the defendant no. 3-respondent no. 3 Sheonath Choudhary, respondent no. 6 (gha) Sheonandan Choudhary and some other respondents as abovementioned who were already ‘dead and their interest was not represented.
Tested on the anvil of the aforesaid principle the conclusion is inevitable that the decree dismissing the suit as against the aforesaid deceased respondents had attained finality and could not have been varied or overturned in absence [2025] 8 S.C.R. 113Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors. of their heirs and legal representatives by the appellate court below. In other words, the appeal before the appellate court at the time of passing of the decree had become defective (not properly constituted) as all the necessary parties for the determination of the controversy were not before the court and the non-substitution of the heirs of the deceased respondents was fatal to the entire appeal. The proposition by the learned senior counsel on behalf of the plaintiff-respondents on the strength of the decision of the Apex Court in the case of K. Naina Mohamed (supra), in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case as mentioned, is clearly misplaced. In the said decision the purchaser was already on record to represent the interest of his deceased vendors and, in fact, it was the purchaser who filed the appeal as well as contested the second appeal thereafter. In the present case, one of the purchasers and one of the substituted heirs of another purchaser of the suit land died during the pendency of the appeal and their interest remained unrepresented as no substitution was admittedly done. Similarly, no rule has been laid down in the said decision prescribing that the provision of Order 22 Rule 10 A shall override the mandatory provision relating to abatement as contained in Order 22 Rule 4 C.P.C. for want of substitution of a defendant/respondent who was a necessary party. In this fact situation, this Court is inclined to hold that the impugned judgment and decree passed by the appellate court below cannot be stained in law, and the same is, accordingly, set aside. The substantial question of law, as formulated in this regard, is accordingly answered in favour of the appellants.
In view of the aforesaid conclusions, there remains no necessity for determining the other substantial questions of law as framed/suggested.
In the result, this appeal is allowed. In the facts and circumstances, there shall be no order as to cost.”
15. In such circumstances referred to above, the plaintiffs are here before this Court with the present appeal.
114 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
B. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
i. Submissions on behalf of the Appellants / Original Plaintiffs.
16. Mr. Gagan Gupta, the learned counsel appearing for the plaintiffs vehemently submitted that the High Court committed a serious error in passing the impugned judgment and order. He would submit that the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is in gross violation of the provisions of Order XXII Rule 10A of the CPC. He would submit that respondents / defendants in the First Appeal deliberately omitted to bring it to the notice of the plaintiffs that some of the defendants had passed away. According to the learned counsel, the respondents in the First Appeal not only failed to bring it to the notice of the First Appellate Court about the passing away of some of the defendants but allowed the First Appeal to be heard on merits. The failure on the part of the respondents to bring to the notice of the plaintiffs as well as to the Court concerned the factum of death of some of the defendants could be said to be in gross violation of Order XXII Rule 10A of the CPC.
17. Mr. Gupta submitted that even while conceding to the fact that some of the respondents before the First Appellate Court had passed away and their legal heirs were not brought on record, still the appeal as a whole could not be said to have stood abated. In this regard, Mr. Gupta has given a chart indicating why the First Appeal could not be said to have wholly abated in absence of the legal heirs being brought on record. The chart indicates as follows: - S.N Respondent Position before the Trial Court Position before the High Court Position before this Court Particulars
1. Hari Lal Choudhary (First Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 5 Appellant No. 6 Respondent No. 6 No Dispute w.r.t abatement
2. Yamuna Choudhary (Second Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 6 His LRs were Appellants Nos. 11 & His LRs are Respondents Nos. 8,11 and 12 No Dispute w.r.t abatement [2025] 8 S.C.R. 115Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
3. Khobari Choudhary (Third Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 1 His LRs were Appellants Nos. 1-3 His LRs are Respondents Nos. 1-3 No Dispute w.r.t abatement
4. Bihari Choudhary (Third Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 2 Appellant No. 4 Respondent No. 4 No Dispute w.r.t abatement
5. Sheonath Choudhary (Fourth Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 3 His LRs were Appellants Nos. 10-13 His LRs are Respondents Nos. 30-33 Dispute w.r.t.
abatement (As he died on 07.5.1997 during First Appeal however in the Second Appeal his LRs were Impleaded.
6. Baijnath Choudhary (Fourth Sale Deed)
Defendant No. 4 Appellant No. 5 Respondent No. 5 No Dispute w.r.t abatement
18. Mr. Gupta thereafter, by way of one another chart pointed out that all those respondents who passed away during the pendency of the First Appeal before the district court were only “Performa respondents”. The said chart reads as under: - S.N Respondent Position before the High Court Position before this Court Particulars
1. Sheo Nandan Choudhary (Died on 07.05.1997)
His LRs were Appellant No. 10 & Respondent Nos. 14-20 His LRs are Respondents Nos. 10 and Nos. 36-41 His LRs were not impleaded in First Appeal but he has no connection with the impugned sale deeds and LRs were impleaded in the High Court.
2. Dipiya (Died on 07.08.1999)
Not a Party. Not a Party. No connection with the impugned sale deeds or the proceedings.
116 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3. Bachha Bhagat (Died on 05.04.2003)
Not a Party. Not a Party. No connection with the impugned sale deeds or the proceedings.
4. Nagina Bhagat (Died on 05.11.2005)
Not a Party. Not a Party. No connection with the impugned sale deeds or the proceedings.
5. Md. Islam (Died on 08.03.2001)
His LRs were Respondents Nos. 27 & 28 His LRs are Respondents Nos. 46 & 47 No connection with the impugned sale deeds or the proceedings.
6. Sheo Dhari Bhagat (Died on 08.07.2008 i.e., after the passing of the judgment in First Appeal)
His LRs were Respondents Nos. 29 & 30 His LRs are Respondents Nos. 48 & 49 No connection with the impugned sale deeds or the proceedings.
19. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel appearing for the plaintiffs prayed that there being merit in his appeal the same may be allowed and an appropriate order be passed with a view to do substantial justice between the parties.
ii. Submissions on behalf of the Respondents / Original Defendants.
20. Mr. Shantanu Sagar, the learned counsel appearing for the defendants on the other hand submitted that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned judgment and order. According to the learned counsel the High Court is right in saying that provisions of Order XXII Rule 4 CPC would override the provisions of Order XXII Rule 10A of the CPC.
21. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being no merit in the present appeal, the same may be dismissed.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 117Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
C. ANALYSIS
22. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and order?
23. We regret to state that we are thoroughly disappointed with the manner in which the High Court dealt with the Second Appeal and more particularly the understanding of the High Court as regards the position of law on the issues in question. Such procedural errors are not expected at the level of any High Court. It is not in dispute that the provisions of Order XXII Rule 10A of the CPC were not complied with.
24. While the First Appeal was being heard, the defendants could have brought to the notice of the First Appellate Court that some of the respondents had passed away and the appeal had stood abated. Had the defendants brought this fact to the notice of the First Appellate Court, the Court could have looked into the matter accordingly. It appears that the defendants being fully aware of the death of some of the respondents kept quiet and allowed the First Appellate Court to proceed with the hearing of the First Appeal on merits. When the First Appeal came to be allowed and the matter reached the High Court in Second Appeal that the issue as regards the abatement came to be raised.
i. Relevant Statutory Provisions.
25. Order XXII Rule 1 of the CPC reads thus: - “1. No abatement by party’s death if right to sue survives.— The death of a plaintiff or defendant shall not cause the suit to abate if the right to sue survives.”
26. Order XXII Rule 2 of the CPC reads thus: - “2. Procedure where one of several plaintiffs or defendants dies and right to sue survives.— Where there are more plaintiffs or defendants than one, and any of them dies, and where the right to sue survives 118 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to the surviving plaintiff or plaintiffs alone, or against the surviving defendant or defendants alone, the Court shall cause an entry to the effect to be made on the record,. and the suit shall proceed at the instance of the surviving plaintiff or plaintiffs, or against the surviving defendant or defendants”
27. Order XXII Rule 4 and 4A, of the CPC reads thus: - “4. Procedure in case of death of one of several defendants or of sole defendant.—
(1) Where one of two or more defendants dies and the right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendant or defendants alone or a sole defendant or sole surviving defendant dies and the right to sue survives, the Court, on an application made in that behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendants to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit. (2) Any person so made a party may make any defence appropriate to his character as legal representative of the deceased defendant. (3) Where within the time limited by law no application is made under sub-rule (1), the suit shall abate as against the deceased defendant.
(4) The Court whenever it thinks fit, may exempt the plaintiff from the necessity of substituting the legal representatives of any such defendant who has failed to file a written statement or who, having filed it, has failed to appear and contest the suit at the hearing; and judgment may, in such case, be pronounced against the said defendant notwithstanding the death of such defendant and shall have the same force and effect as if it has been pronounced before death took place. (5) Where— (a) the plaintiff was ignorant of the death of a defendant, and could not, for that reason, make an application for the substitution of the legal representative of the defendant under this rule within the period specified in the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), and the suit has, in consequence, abated, and (b) the plaintiff applies after the expiry of the period specified therefore in the Limitation Act, 1963 (36 of 1963), for setting [2025] 8 S.C.R. 119Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors. aside the abatement and also for the admission of that application under section 5 of that Act on the ground that he had, by reason of such ignorance, sufficient cause for not making the application with the period specified in the said Act, the Court shall, in considering the application under the said section 5, have due regard to the fact of such ignorance, if proved.
4A. Procedure where there is no legal representative.—
(1) If, in any suit, it shall appear to the Court that any party who has died during the pendency of the suit has no legal representative, the Court may, on the application of any party to the suit, proceed in the absence of a person representing the estate of the deceased person, or may be order appoint the Administrator-General, or an officer of the Court or such other person as it thinks fit to represent the estate of the deceased person for the purpose of the suit; and any judgment or order subsequently given or made in the suit shall bind the estate of the deceased person to the same extent as he would have been bound if a personal representative of the deceased person had been a party to the suit. (2) Before making an order under this rule, the Court— (a) may require notice of the application for the order to be given to such (if any) of the persons having an interest in the estate of the deceased person as it thinks fit; and (b) shall as certain that the person proposed to be appointed to represent the estate of the deceased person is willing to be so appointed and has no interest adverse to that of the deceased person.”
28. Rule 1 of Order XXII of the CPC provides that the death of a plaintiff or defendant shall not cause the suit to abate if the right to sue survives. Rule 4, Order XXII of the CPC prescribes that where a defendant dies, on an application made by the plaintiff, the Court shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendant to be made a party and shall proceed with the suit. It cannot be disputed that such an application has to be filed within the time limit prescribed by law; otherwise, the suit would stand abated against the deceased defendant. A clear provision is to be found to that effect in sub-rule (3) of Rule 4. Obviously in case of failure to bring 120 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the legal representative on record within prescribed time, the suit having abated, the plaintiff will have to seek the remedy of setting aside abatement in accordance with the provisions of law. ii. Order XXII, Rule 10A of the CPC.
29. With enforcement of 1976’s amendment to the CPC, once a party to the suit dies, a duty is cast upon the lawyer representing such party, to communicate the fact of death to the opposite party in terms of provisions contain in Rule 10A of Order XXII of the CPC. It is nobody’s case that there was compliance of this rule in the case at hand by the advocate appearing for the defendants. Unless this primary obligation is discharged and it is established with cogent evidence that the opposite party had sufficient opportunity to know and, had, in fact, knowledge of the death of the defendant, the plea of abatement of the suit at the instance of party having failed to comply with the obligation mentioned under Rule 10A of Order XXII of the CPC cannot be entertained. Nobody can be allowed to reap the benefit of his own lapse and to non-suit the plaintiff.
30. Order XXII, Rule 10A reads thus: - “10A. Duty of pleader to communicate to Court death of a party.— Wherever a pleader appearing for a party to the suit comes to know of the death of that party, he shall inform the Court about it, and the Court shall thereupon give notice of such death to the other party, and, for this purpose, the contract between the pleader and the deceased party shall be deemed to subsist.”
31. Rule 10A has been newly inserted by the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1976.
32. Rule 10A is intended to avoid delay in making an application for bringing legal representatives of the deceased party on record. It seeks to mitigate the hardship arising from the fact that a party to a suit may not come to know about the death of the other side during the pendency of the proceedings. In such a situation, it would be appropriate to ask the advocate of the party to give intimation of the death of the party represented by him so as to enable the other side to take appropriate steps.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 121Binod Pathak & Ors. v. Shankar Choudhary & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.