Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 702; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 513
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 6 May 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1954/2022
- Sections
- 363, 161, 27, 164, 293, 329
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 513 : 2025 INSC 702 Ramkirat Munilal Goud v.
State of Maharashtra Etc.
(Criminal Appeal No(s). 1954-1955 of 2022)
07 May 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to the correctness of the order passed by the High Court upholding the conviction and death sentence of the appellant for causing rape and murder of a child aged 3 years and 9 months. Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 363, 376(2), 201 – Rape and murder of a child – Prosecution case that gruesome rape and murder of a child at the tender age of 3 years and 9 months – Dead body of child recovered from pond located at a distance of one kilometer from appellant’s house – Prosecution case based on circumstantial evidence-last seen together circumstance, extra-judicial confession, and FSL report regarding the soil found stuck in the shoes of the appellant, matching with the soil of the pond where the child’s dead body found – Trial court convicted the appellant and sentenced him to death – High Court upheld the order – Correctness:
Held: Flawed and tainted investigation eventually led to the failure of the prosecution case – Evidence of the witnesses of last seen circumstance vacillating, shaky and tainted with wholesale improvements, and thus, unworthy of credence – Conduct of the witnesses of the last seen circumstance in failing to timely step forward to make a disclosure to the Investigating Officer that they had seen the appellant and the child victim together on the date of the incident in spite of the fact that the police officers were regularly visiting the area, clearly indicates that the witnesses were untrustworthy and were created by the investigation agency for ulterior motive – Investigating Officer made no effort to record the statements of the witnesses of last seen circumstance in the spot panchnama, at the earliest available opportunity, rather did not * Author 514 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports record their statements at all, and the witnesses were examined for the first time three days later by the second Investigating Officer, which omission is vital and indicative of gross negligence on the part of the Investigation Officer – Evidence of extra-judicial confession as deposed by one prosecution witness also unacceptable because the said witness too did not step forward to inform the police regarding the fact of the so called extrajudicial confession made by the appellant before him, in spite of being aware that the police was searching for the child – FSL report regarding the similarity of soil samples also inconsequential – Prosecution did not to place on record the reports pertaining to the comparison of the samples taken from the other watchmen – Thus, the prosecution withheld important evidence thereby, compelling the court to draw adverse inference against the prosecution – Despite there being any reliable evidence, the appellant was convicted and sentenced by the courts below and has suffered incarceration for 12 years of which 6 years were under the threat of death penalty – Findings recorded in the impugned judgments holding the appellant guilty, based on conjectures and surmises and thus, both the judgments and the order of sentence unsustainable and quashed and set aside. [Paras 75-79].
Case Law Cited Sharad Birdhichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2013.
List of Keywords Murder; Rape; Child victim; Shabby and perfunctory investigation; Inherent improbability in prosecution case; Test identification; Damocles sword of impending death penalty; Ante mortem injuries; DNA profiling; Links of circumstantial evidence; Death sentence; Unimpeachable evidence; Circumstantial evidence; Forcible sexual assault; Blind murder; Reliable witness; Last seen together; Intensive combing operations; Significant loophole and grave shortcoming of prosecution case; Flawed and tainted investigation; [2025] 6 S.C.R. 515Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. Extra-judicial confession; Blood stained soil; Foundation of arrest lacking; Inconsequential recoveries; FSL report; Physio-chemical characteristics; Spectro-chemical composition; Rape and murder of a child aged 3 years and 9 months; Evidence of the witnesses of last seen circumstance; Conduct of the witnesses; Investigating Officer; Death penalty.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 1954-1955 of 2022 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.11.2021 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in CC No. 1 and CRA No. 661 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
A Raghenth Basant, Sr. Adv., Ms. Fauzia Shakil, Ms. Aathma Sudhir Kumar, Ms. Shreya Rastogi, Ms. Pratiksha Basarkar, Ms. Kaushitaki Sharma, Ms. Hima Bhardwaj.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Ms. Soumya Priyadarshinee, Vinayak Aren, Amlaan Kumar, Jatin Dhamija, Naveen Kumar Bhardwaj.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. The instant case is yet another classic example of shabby and perfunctory investigation leading to failure of the prosecution case involving a gruesome incident of rape and murder of the budding life of a tender young girl 1 aged about 3 years and 9 months.
3. Despite the shabby investigation, the overzealous approach of the Courts below, to impart justice, in a sense that someone must be held 1 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘child’ or ‘child victim’. 516 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports responsible for the crime, has led to the conviction of the appellant herein 2 , who was a young man aged about 25 years at the time of the incident and has remained incarcerated for more than 12 years with the Damocles sword of impending death penalty hanging over his head for more than 6 years.
4. Succinctly stated, the facts relevant and essential for disposal of the appeals may be noted hereinbelow.
5. The complainant, Manoj Bhaskar Sadavarte (PW-1) 3 a painter by profession, used to reside at Old Waghbil Gaon, Banjari Chawl, Laxminagar, Thane(W) along with his mother and daughter, i.e., the deceased child victim. On 30 th September, 2013, at about 10:00 A.M., the complainant’s mother had gone out of the house to fetch water. At about 10:30 A.M., the complainant left his house to attend to some work. The child victim was alone in the house when the complainant went out. She came out of the house to play with the family pet dog. The complainant returned home at about 10:45 A.M. and noticed that his daughter and the pet dog were nowhere to be seen. Initially, he assumed that his child might have gone out in the vicinity to play with the dog and, thus, he set out to look for her in areas near his house. However, he could neither locate the child victim nor the pet dog. When the complainant’s mother came back to the house, he inquired about the whereabouts of the child from her, but she too was unaware about the same. Concerned about the child’s well-being, he and his mother commenced a frantic search for his daughter.
6. The complainant inquired from two persons living in the neighbourhood, who told him that they had seen the child playing with the dog. Thereafter, he went to the watchmen chawl located near his room, where several watchmen used to reside. The pet dog was found in the chawl, but his child was nowhere to be seen. The complainant got suspicious that some unknown person/s might have kidnapped his child. Accordingly, he proceeded to Police Station Kasarvadavali, Thane and lodged a complaint regarding his child, having gone missing. The police registered an FIR, bearing Crime No. I-306 of 2 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘accused appellant’.
3 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘complainant’.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 517Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. 2013, for the offence punishable under Section 363 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.4 Investigation was assigned to the Assistant Police Inspector (API) Vikas Sarjerao Lokre (PW-16) 5 who prepared the spot panchnama6 of the place of the incident on 1 st October, 2013. The panchnama records the place where the child victim was last seen and the place from where she was purportedly kidnapped. The panchnama also gives out the names of the persons who had seen the child and the dog on 30 th September, 2013, in the sequence enumerated below:- Time Person Around 10:45 A.M. Premshankar Jayshankar Gupta Around 11:00 A.M. Raju Pukraj Choudhari (Owner of Ashapura Grocery Shop)
Around 11:15 A.M. Jaybhim Channappa Kamble and some other people.
Around 12:00 P.M. Dipendrakumar Dhirendranath Shukla (PW-9)
Around 12:15 P.M. Pradipkumar Ganesh Rawat (PW-14)
The aforesaid panchnama was drawn up on 1 st October, 2013 between 07:30 A.M. to 08:45 A.M.
7. Vikas Sarjerao Lokre (PW-16), the 1 st Investigating Officer rounded up some 15 to 20 watchmen from the chawl and collected their forensic/blood samples.
8. The dead body of the child victim was recovered on 2 nd October 2013, lying in a muddy water pond at a distance of about one kilometer from the watchmen chawl and the same was forwarded to Civil Hospital, Thane, where the Medical Officer, Dr. Mahendra Vithalrao Kendre (PW-10), examined the same and found it to be in a highly decomposed condition. Thus, the body was forwarded to the J.J. Hospital for an autopsy as no forensic expert was available 4 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘IPC’.
5 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘1st Investigating Officer (PW-16)’. 6 Exhibit No. 30.
518 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports at the Civil Hospital, Thane. At the J.J. Hospital, the dead body of the child victim was subjected to post mortem by a medical board, comprising of Dr. Sadanand Sangram Bhise (PW-11), along with Dr. N.S. Jagtap and Dr. G.D. Niturkar and the post mortem report 7 was issued. The post mortem report refers to numerous injuries on the external and internal genitalia as well as the anus of the child victim. Few contusions were also found over the skull of the child victim. The brain had liquified and was in an advanced stage of decomposition. The medical board opined that the injuries, mentioned in Column No. 17 to 19 of the post mortem report, were ante mortem in nature and the head injury was sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature.
9. On 3 rd October, 2013, the investigation was handed over to Deputy Superintendent of Police, Mandar Vasant Dharmadhikari (PW-18). 8
10. The accused appellant was arrested on 3 rd October 2013, vide arrest panchnama 9 and he was subjected to medical examination. The Medical Officer (PW-10) of the Civil Hospital, Thane, found an abrasion on the foreskin of the penis of the accused appellant. The prosecution has tried to link the said injury with the crime, claiming that the injury may have been received when the accused appellant had sexually assaulted the child victim.
11. On the pointing out of the accused appellant, the Investigating Officer, Mandar Vasant Dharmadhikari (PW-18) claims to have visited room No. 2 (place of incident) and room No. 4 of the watchmen chawl, in which the accused appellant used to reside. A few articles were recovered and seized from room No. 4, to be specific, the lungi, baniyan, the watchman’s dress and the shoes of the accused appellant. Blood stained soil and blood stained stone slabs were recovered from room No. 2.
12. As per the prosecution case, the accused appellant confessed before the Investigating Officer (PW-18) that he had committed the crime with the child victim in the said room. The lungi of the accused appellant was allegedly blood-stained, and the shoes had some soil/ 7 Exhibit No. 58.
8 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘2nd Investigating Officer (PW-18)’. 9 Exh. 82.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 519Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. mud stuck in their sole. The Investigating Officer (PW-18) also claims to have collected blood samples of the accused appellant for DNA profiling. The forensic science laboratory (FSL) report 10 concludes that the source of blood on the lungi could not be identified. The DNA profiling tests, conducted using the blood of the accused appellant and the DNA samples collected from the child’s body, did not lead to any conclusive opinion.
13. The prosecution’s case was entirely based on three links of circumstantial evidence:
(i) Last seen together circumstance;
(ii) Extra-judicial confession; and
(iii) FSL report regarding the mud/soil found stuck in the shoes of the accused appellant, matching with the soil of the pond where the child victim’s dead body was found.
14. The prosecution relied upon the evidence of Dipendrakumar Dhirendranath Shukla (PW-9), Pradipkumar Ganesh Rawat (PW-14) and Sanjay Ganesh Rawat (PW-15) for proving the purported theory of ‘last seen together’ and Anil Mahatam Singh (PW-17), the Supervisor, under whom the accused appellant was working, for proving the so called extra-judicial confession made by the accused appellant. The prosecution also relied upon the FSL report11 as per which the soil/ mud stuck in the sole of the accused appellant’s shoes was opined to be having characteristics as similar to the soil found near the pond from where the child victim’s body was recovered.
15. Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Thane 12 found the prosecution evidence on the aforementioned links of circumstantial evidence to be reliable and credible and by placing reliance thereupon, the trial Court convicted the accused appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 363, 376(2)(i) and 201 of the IPC and Sections 4 and 8 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2013, vide judgment dated 5th March, 2019 and sentenced him vide sentence order dated 8 th March, 2019 in the terms indicated below: - 10 Exh. 99.
11 Exh. 105 12 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘trial Court’.
520 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S. No. Section Sentence Awarded
1. 302 of the
IPC
Sentenced to be Hanged by Neck till Death.
2. 376(2)(i)
of the IPC Sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for Life which shall mean imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only).
In case of default in payment of fine, he shall suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for one year.
3. 363 of the
IPC
Sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment of 5 years and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only). In case of default in payment of fine, he shall suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for six months.
4. 201 of the
IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment of 3 years and to pay a fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees Five Thousand Only). In case of default in payment of fine, he shall suffer Rigorous Imprisonment for six months All the substantive sentences of imprisonment of the accused shall run concurrently. After realization of the fine amount, it shall be given to the parents of the deceased girl.
16. The appeal 13 preferred by the accused appellant and the reference 14 forwarded by the trial Court, were decided by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay 15 vide judgment dated 25 th November, 2021, whereby the conviction of the accused appellant and the death sentence awarded to him have been confirmed and the appeal preferred by the accused appellant has been dismissed. The said judgment dated 25th November, 2021, rendered by the High Court and along with the judgment dated 5 th March, 2019, and the order of sentence dated 8 th March, 2019, rendered by the trial Court, are subject matter of challenge in these appeals by special leave. 13 Criminal Appeal No. 661 of 2019 14 Confirmation Case No. 1 of 2019 15 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘High Court’.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 521Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. Submissions on behalf of accused appellant:
17. Mr. Raghenth Basant, learned senior counsel representing the accused appellant, vehemently and fervently contended that the prosecution has failed to prove even one of the three projected incriminating circumstances relied upon by it so as to bring home the guilt of the accused appellant. The evidence of the witnesses of the last seen circumstance is highly vacillating and self-contradicting and perfunctory and hence, the same deserves to be discarded in toto. All these witnesses were fully aware about the disappearance of the child victim on 30th September, 2013, itself when the police came to the area and started making enquiries. However, none of them stepped forward to inform the 1st Investigating Officer (PW-16) that they had seen the child victim and the accused appellant together. The statements under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 16 of these witnesses were recorded by the 2nd Investigating Officer (PW-18) as late as on 3rd October, 2013. As per learned senior counsel, the conduct of the witnesses, in keeping silent and their failure in making a timely disclosure to the 1 st Investigating Officer (PW-16) about having seen the child victim in the company of the accused appellant on the fateful day, i.e., 30th September, 2013, and even after the dead body was recovered, i.e., on 2nd October, 2013, makes their entire testimony doubtful and unworthy of credence.
18. Learned senior counsel further submitted that, if at all, the witnesses had seen the child victim in the company of the accused appellant on the alleged day, their natural reaction would have been to disclose the said fact, that they had seen the accused appellant along with the child victim, to the father of the girl child who had initiated the search operations in the afternoon of 30 th September, 2013 itself and made enquiries at the watchman chawl as well. He submitted that investigation agency has resorted to padding by creating the evidence of the witnesses of last seen together theory.
19. Shri Basant, further, submitted that the evidence of extra-judicial confession, sought to be proved through Anil Mahatam Singh (PW-17), is also unreliable and unworthy of credence. While deposing on oath, the witness in his examination-in-chief, did not pertinently state that the accused appellant had made any extra-judicial 16 Hereinafter being referred to as the ‘CrPC’.
522 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports confession in his presence. It is only on the leading questions put by the Public Prosecutor, during cross-examination, that the witness tried to impute that the accused appellant had admitted, in his presence, that he had made a mistake.
20. As per Shri Basant, the evidence of extra-judicial confession is even otherwise of very weak nature and thus, the conviction cannot be solely based on such evidence. In addition thereto, his contention was that the version of the witness (PW-17) regarding the so-called extra-judicial confession made by the accused appellant, is very vague and vacillating and hence, no reliance can be placed on his testimony.
21. Learned senior counsel further submitted that, admittedly, the 1 st Investigating Officer (PW-16) collected the forensic samples from numerous watchmen living in the same chawl, where the accused appellant was residing, however, the FSL report pertaining to these samples never saw light of the day. Hence, an adverse inference has to be drawn that these reports were not favouring the prosecution’s story, which is why the same was held back from the Court.
22. Learned senior counsel further submitted that the FSL report 17 indicating a match between the mud/soil found on the shoes of the accused appellant, and the mud/soil found near the pond, from where the dead body of the child victim was recovered, is also vague and inconsequential. Firstly, the very factum of recovery of the soiled shoes at the instance of the accused appellant is dubitable. It is impossible to believe that the accused appellant, who was a free bird till 3 rd October 2013, would meticulously preserve the worthless incriminating articles i.e., his shoes, lungi and the watchman uniform, for the police to recover the same and thereby, face the risk of being incriminated.
23. Secondly, Shri Basant submitted that the FSL report depicting that the soil on the shoes was similar to the mud/soil of the location from where the victim child’s body was recovered is merely suggestive in nature and not conclusive. He urged that, if at all, the prosecution wanted to establish that the soil was from the same source, then a more exhaustive exercise was required to be conducted by collecting soil samples from different surrounding locations thereby, 17 Supra note 11.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 523Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. excluding the possibility of mud/soil found on the shoes being from the locality where the accused appellant resided. He submitted that the prosecution was under a burden to establish that the mud/soil of this kind was not to be found anywhere else except in and around the pond, from where the dead body of child victim was recovered. He thus urged that unless the prosecution excluded this possibility by adducing proper evidence, the FSL report would remain vague and inconclusive.
24. Shri Basant concluded his submissions by urging that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove a complete and unbreached chain of incriminating circumstances, by leading reliable evidence, and hence, the accused appellant is entitled to be acquitted by giving him the benefit of doubt.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent State:
25. Per contra, Ms. Rukhmini Bobde, learned standing counsel for the State of Maharashtra, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by Shri Basant. She urged that the prosecution has established the guilt of the accused appellant by leading unimpeachable and complete chain of circumstantial evidence in the form of motive, last seen together circumstance, extra- judicial confession and the scientific evidence in the form of FSL report, which establishes that the shoes of accused appellant recovered by the 2nd Investigating Officer (PW-18) in furtherance of the information provided by him under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, bore soil matching with that of the pond where the dead body of the child victim had been disposed of by the accused appellant after committing the crime.
26. She urged that neither the witnesses of the circumstance of last seen together and extra-judicial confession had any animosity against the accused appellant, nor the Investigating Officers bore any ill will against the accused appellant so as to falsely implicate him for the crime without any justification.
27. She further urged that the investigation was conducted in a fair, transparent and unbiased manner and without being influenced by any extraneous consideration, the Investigating Officers, being Vikas Sarjerao Lokre (PW-16) and Mandar Vasant Dharmadhikari (PW-18), faithfully collected unimpeachable incriminating evidence against the accused appellant.
524 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
28. She concluded her submissions urging that the finding of guilt of the accused appellant, as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court, are based on unimpeachable and reliable circumstantial evidence led by the prosecution which irrefutably points to the guilt of the accused appellant and is inconsistent with his innocence or the guilt of any other person. Thus, this Court should be loath to interfere with the concurrent findings of facts while exercising jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. She also urged that looking to the heinous nature of the crime, the death sentence awarded to the accused appellant is fit to be confirmed.
29. She implored the Court to dismiss the appeals and confirm the conviction and sentence awarded to the accused appellant. Discussion and Conclusion: -
30. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at the bar and have meticulously perused the impugned judgments. We have also carefully scanned and analysed the evidence led by the prosecution in its endeavour to bring home the charges against the accused appellant.
31. Admittedly, the case of the prosecution is based entirely on circumstantial evidence. The position of law in a case based entirely on circumstantial evidence, is well-settled by a catena of decisions of this Court, wherein this Court has categorically held that the prosecution has to prove the entire chain of incriminating circumstances by adducing unimpeachable evidence, which leads to only one hypothesis that is consistent with the guilt of the accused, inconsistent with his innocence or the guilt of anyone else. The chain of circumstances sought to be relied upon by the prosecution must be complete in all aspects and must unerringly link the accused with the crime. In case of any breach in the chain of incriminating circumstances, the Court would be left with no option but to acquit the accused by giving him the benefit of doubt. The law with regard to conviction based on circumstantial evidence has been crystalized by this Court in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra18, wherein it was held:
18 (1984) 4 SCC 116.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 525Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. “153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned “must or should”
and not “may be” established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793] where the observations were made: [SCC para 19, p. 807] “Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.
(Emphasis Supplied)
32. Having noted the principles governing a case based purely on circumstantial evidence, we now proceed to discuss the evidence 526 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports led by the prosecution in the present case in its endeavour, to bring home the charges against the accused appellant.
33. The theory set out by the prosecution in its case is that the accused appellant had seen the child victim alone, playing with her dog on the morning of 30 th September, 2013. As there was no one else in the vicinity, the accused appellant, driven by lust, took advantage of the situation, kidnapped the child and thereafter took her to room No. 2 of the watchmen chawl where he subjected the child victim to forcible sexual assault. In this process, the child tried to resist and cried out for help, upon which the accused appellant smashed the head of the child victim on the floor tiles, leading to fractures on the skull of the child and ultimately resulting in her death. For establishing the guilt of the accused appellant, the prosecution relied on three circumstances: i. Last seen together circumstance;
ii. Extra-judicial confession; and iii. FSL report indicating presence of soil on the shoes of the accused appellant which tallied with the soil of the pond from where the dead body of the child victim was found.
34. As has been noted above, the case was of a blind murder. The allegations as set out in the complaint 19 filed by the complainant (PW-1) indicate that the complainant and his mother had gone out of the house at 10:30 A.M. in relation to some work, leaving the child victim alone in the house. The complainant returned at about 10:45 A.M. and at that time, neither the child nor the pet dog of the complainant was present in the house. The complainant immediately launched a search for the child, making inquiries from his mother and the people in the vicinity but to no avail.
35. Hence, what can be deduced from the version set out in the complaint is that the child victim went out of the house between 10:30 A.M. to 10:45 A.M. and was not seen by the complainant thereafter. As per the complaint, the complainant came back to the house around 10:45 A.M., and could not find the child, on which he started searching for her.
19 Exh. 61.
[2025] 6 S.C.R. 527Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc.
36. In this process, the complainant (PW-1) visited the watchmen chawl, which is situated in close vicinity to his house. He found his dog in the said chawl, however, the child was nowhere to be seen. Thus, presumably the child victim must have gone missing within the small window of 10:30 A.M. and 10:45 A.M. It is undisputed that the child victim’s body was recovered from a pond, which is around one kilometer away from the purported place of the incident, i.e., room No. 2 of the watchmen chawl, on 2 nd October, 2013. We are of the prima facie opinion that the case of the prosecution, particularly on the aspect of time, manner and place of the incident is doubtful.
37. It is admitted that the complainant had started the search operations around 10:45 A.M. and had also searched in and around the watchmen chawl. As is borne out from the evidence available on record, the area where the complainant resided is thickly populated and inhabited by a large number of persons who work as watchmen. The prosecution claims that the incident took place in broad daylight sometime after 10:30 A.M. Mainfestly thus, there was hardly any possibility that the accused appellant could have carried the child victim’s dead body to the pond, which was located one kilometer away, without being noticed. Hence, two possible scenarios arise: -
(i) That the incident did not take place in the chawl as claimed by the prosecution; and/or
(ii) The incident did not take place at the time or in the manner alleged by the prosecution.
38. Having noted this inherent improbability in the prosecution case, we now proceed to discuss the evidence of the material prosecution witnesses.
39. For the purpose of appreciating the circumstance of last seen together, the relevant witnesses are the complainant, i.e., Manoj Bhaskar Sadavarte [(PW-1), father of the deceased child], Dipendrakumar Dhirendranath Shukla (PW-9), Pradipkumar Ganesh Rawat (PW-14) and Sanjay Ganesh Rawat (PW-15).
40. The complainant, Manoj Bhaskar Sadavarte (PW-1) virtually repeated the story as set out in the complaint 20 . He tried to introduce an 20 Supra note 19.
528 [2025] 6 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports improvement that on the same day, i.e., the day of the incident, at about 2:00 P.M., he went to the watchmen chawl while he was searching for his daughter and saw the accused appellant standing behind his house and his legs were soiled with mud. He was wearing lungi and banyan. The witness enquired from the accused appellant regarding his daughter (child victim), but the accused appellant did not tell him anything.
41. In examination-in-chief, the witness stated that on seeing the accused appellant with his legs soiled with mud/soil, he started suspecting him. He admitted having made inquiries from his neighbour, Devidas Kale, shop owner Raju Pukraj Choudhari and rickshaw driver Jaybhim Channappa Kamble and other female members in the crowd. All these witnesses stated that they had seen the little girl playing with the dog. He proved the spot panchnama. In the cross-examination, he admitted that the name of the accused appellant as a suspect was not mentioned in the complaint. He had gone to the chawl three times on 30 th September, 2013, and his suspicion was on the accused appellant. He made the following important admission in his cross-examination: - “On 03.10.2013 police recorded my supplementary statement in between 11.30 a.m. to 12.00 noon. Till that time nobody has stated that they had seen any person who took my daughter.”
42. Dipendrakumar Dhirendranath Shukla (PW-9) deposed in his evidence that he was working as a watchman and used to reside in a transit camp which was in front of Unnati Woods. At a distance of about 2 to 3 lines from his house, some 15 to 20 watchmen used to reside. The witness admitted that he did not know the accused appellant by name but recognized him by his face as he used to regularly pass through the road in front of the witness’s house. The accused appellant was also residing in the same chawl. The witness stated that on 30th September, 2013, at around 11:30 A.M. to 12:00 P.M., he was taking lunch when he saw a small girl, aged about 2 ½ to 3 years, heading down the road with a dog. He could see the child from the open gate of his house. At about 01:00 P.M., the witness and his father came back to the house for some work, and, at that time, he noticed that the dog he had seen with the child was wandering around on the road, but the child was nowhere to be seen. The witness claims to have seen the accused appellant coming [2025] 6 S.C.R. 529Ramkirat Munilal Goud v. State of Maharashtra Etc. from behind the bushes at around the same point of time. He was wearing a watchman’s uniform. The witness thereafter went back to work. At about 04:00 P.M., when he came back to his house, he noticed that people were searching for a small girl. He was shown the photograph of the missing girl (child victim), which he identified to be the same child whom he had seen earlier in the afternoon. He further stated that the body of the child victim was found in the pond on 2 nd October, 2013, after which he narrated the entire incident, witnessed by him, to the police.
43. In his cross-examination, the witness (PW-9) admitted that on 30 th September, 2013, the police made inquiries from him in relation to the case, but his statement was not recorded on that date. On 2 nd October 2013, the police again visited the crime scene, but his statement was still not recorded. He further stated that some 25 to 30 north Indian people were residing in the transit camp and were working as watchmen. The police summoned all these people for the purposes of inquiry. The witness was confronted with certain improvements vis-à-vis his previous statement recorded under Section 161 of the CrPC. However, these improvements are trivial and inconsequential for our purpose. The witness denied the suggestion given by the defence that he was making a false deposition regarding having seen the accused appellant coming from behind the bushes. However, he admitted that the police did not call him for the test identification of the accused appellant.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.