Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 444; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1482
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 4 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 630/2018
- Sections
- 366, 173(2), 207, 164, 293, 45
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1482 : 2025 INSC 444 Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v.
State of Uttarakhand (Criminal Appeal No(s). 630-631 of 2018)
04 March 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration In a case based on circumstantial evidence, whether the concurrent conviction of the appellant-accused for the kidnapping, rape/sexual assault and murder of a minor is sustainable.
Headnotes† Circumstantial evidence – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.376A, 302, 366, 363, 201 – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – ss.5, 6 – Kidnapping, rape/sexual assault and murder of minor – Case based on circumstantial evidence – Appellant was convicted, death sentence awarded – Sustainability:
Held: Unsustainable – Prosecution relied totally on circumstantial evidence in the form of last seen theory, recoveries, DNA/FSL report and the confession of the appellant – The witnesses remained silent and did not disclose to the police regarding they having seen the appellant taking away the child-victim with himself, thus, the prosecution case regarding the theory of last seen is demolished – Further, non-examination of the scientific expert who carried out the DNA profiling is fatal – DNA report was merely exhibited in evidence by the IO (PW-14) who was not connected with the report in any manner – The procedure of collecting the samples was also tainted on account of non-sealing of the forensic material collected from the appellant – Thus, DNA/FSL reports cannot be read in evidence – Furthermore, the recoveries were planted as the appellant would not keep the clothes with him for almost two days after the incident so as to facilitate the police to recover the same at a later point of time – The confession was also extracted under duress and * Author [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1483Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand was not voluntary and as a matter of fact was not even relied upon by the Courts below – Trial was not conducted fairly and the appellant was not given a reasonable opportunity to defend himself – No evidence to connect the appellant with the crime – Impugned judgments set aside – Appellant acquitted. [Paras 12, 16, 35, 39, 40, 42, 46, 56-58] Circumstantial Evidence – Confession – Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.24, 25, 26 – PW-12 (Sub-Inspector) narrated the entire confession of the appellant-accused in his examination-inchief – Lopsided trial:
Held: The procedure adopted by the trial Court in permitting a police officer to verbatim narrate the confession made by an accused during investigation is grossly illegal and contrary to the mandate of ss.24, 25 and 26 – Trial Court also allowed the confessional statement of the appellant to be exhibited in the evidence of the witness, which further establishes that the trial was conducted in a totally distorted manner. [Paras 16, 47] Circumstantial Evidence – DNA Report – When inadmissible: Held: In order to make the DNA report acceptable, reliable and admissible, the prosecution would first be required to prove the sanctity and chain of custody of the samples/articles right from the time of their preparation/collection till the time they reached the FSL – For this purpose, the link evidence would have to be established by examining the concerned witness – However, in the present case, neither the documents/memorandums pertaining to the proceedings of sealing the samples/articles were exhibited in evidence nor did any of the prosecution witnesses gave evidence for proving the procedure – There is no evidence on record to show that the samples/articles collected from the dead body of the child-victim and those collected from the appellant-accused which were later forwarded to the FSL were properly sealed or that the same remained in a self-same condition right from the time of the seizure till they reached the FSL – No witness from the FSL was examined by the prosecution to prove that the samples/articles were received in a sealed condition – There is every possibility of the samples being tampered/manipulated by the police officers to achieve a favourable result from the FSL, thereby, inculpating the appellant in the crime – DNA/FSL reports cannot be read in evidence. [Paras 51, 54-56] 1484 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Rahul v. State of Delhi, Ministry of Home Affairs & Anr. [2022] 9 SCR 1129 : (2023) 1 SCC 83 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012; Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Circumstantial evidence; Confession; Last seen theory; DNA/ FSL report; DNA profiling; Recoveries; Forcible sexual assault; Child-victim; Confession extracted under duress; Confession not voluntary; Jagran function; Child victim went missing; Death sentence; Non-examination of the scientific expert; Forensic samples/articles; Post-mortem examination; Last seen circumstance; Undue haste; Just and fair manner; Denial of proper opportunity; Procedure of collection and forwarding of DNA samples to the FSL; Non-sealing of the forensic material; Examination-inchief; Police officer verbatim narrated the confession made by accused; Contradiction in the evidence; Incriminating articles; Forensic examination; Chain of custody of the samples/articles; Lopsided trial; Trial not fair; Samples tampered/manipulated by the police officers.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 630-631 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.01.2018 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CRLA No. 156 and CRLR No. 1 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Nishant Sanjay Kumar Singh, Ashish Singh, Sadashiv.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Sumit Kumar, Shubham Arora, Manan Verma, Ms. Anubha Dhulia.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1485Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. The accused-appellant 1 was tried by the Fast Track Court/Additional Sessions Judge/Special POCSO Judge, Rudrapur, Udham Singh Nagar 2 in Special Sessions Trial No. 159 of 2016 for the offences punishable under Sections 376A, 302, 366, 363 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 3 and Sections 5/6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 4 . Vide judgment dated 5th April, 2017 and 6th April, 2017, he was convicted and sentenced in the terms below:
Section Sentence 376A IPC Death Sentence 302 IPC Death Sentence 366 IPC 10 years Rigorous Imprisonment along with fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for 3 months.
363 IPC 3 years Rigorous Imprisonment along with fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for 3 months.
201 IPC 3 years Rigorous Imprisonment along with fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default, to undergo Simple Imprisonment for 3 months.
1 Hereinafter. Referred to as the ‘appellant’.
2 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘trial Court’.
3 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘IPC’.
4 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘POCSO Act’.
1486 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3. The trial Court forwarded a reference 5 under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 6 to the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital 7 , for confirmation of the death sentence. The appellant also preferred an appeal 8 assailing his conviction. The High Court vide judgment dated 5th January, 2018 dismissed the appeal preferred by the appellant and answered the reference in the affirmative thereby confirming the penalty of death sentence awarded to the appellant by the trial Court. The said judgment of the High Court is the subject matter of challenge in these appeals by special leave at the instance of the accused-appellant.
4. The case of the prosecution as unfurling from the record is that the child-victim, i.e., Ms. A 9 went missing from a Jagran function which was organized in the village Fasiyapura on the intervening night of 25 th /26 th June, 2016. The father of the victim(PW-1) 10 lodged an FIR 11 to the effect that his daughter had gone missing from the Jagran function and all their efforts to trace out the girl proved futile. While he was continuing the search operations, someone told him that the body of a girl child was lying in a nearby field. On this, the complainant(PW-1) along with his family members rushed to the location and identified the dead body to be that of his daughter (child-victim). The complainant(PW-1) suspected that the childvictim had been subjected to forcible sexual assault before being killed. On receiving the FIR, Om Prakash Sharma, Investigating Officer(PW-14) commenced investigation. Spot documents were prepared, and an inquest was carried out on the child-victim’s dead body. Statements of witnesses were recorded. The body of the childvictim was sent for post-mortem examination. Dr. Madan Mohan, medical officer(PW-7) conducted autopsy upon the dead body and issued the post-mortem report 12, taking note of multiple injuries on the private parts and the head of the child-victim. He opined that the 5 Criminal Reference No. 1 of 2017.
6 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘CrPC’.
7 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘High Court’.
8 Criminal Appeal No. 156 of 2017.
9 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘child-victim’.
10 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘complainant(PW-1)’. 11 FIR No. 236 of 2016 (Exhibit Ka-1).
12 Exhibit Ka-2.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1487Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand cause of death of the child-victim was asphyxia. Statements of the material witnesses were recorded. The appellant was apprehended on 28 th June, 2016. It is alleged that the Investigating Officer(PW-14) got the confession 13 of the appellant recorded through the Magistrate concerned. After concluding the investigation, a charge-sheet 14 came to be filed against the appellant and he was subjected to trial. Upon completion of trial, the appellant was convicted and sentenced as mentioned above.
5. The appeal filed by the appellant against his conviction also stands rejected and the death sentence awarded to the appellant by the trial Court has been confirmed by the High Court vide judgment dated 5 th January, 2018. Hence, the present appeals by special leave.
6. Learned counsel representing the appellant urged that the entire prosecution case is based on circumstantial evidence which is purely conjectural and untrustworthy. There is no tangible evidence on record to connect the appellant with the crime. The evidence of the witnesses of last seen circumstance, i.e., PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, PW-6, PW-8 and PW-11 is totally unreliable. Further, the DNA report cannot be read in evidence because the expert who conducted the DNA examination was not examined by the prosecution at the trial.
7. Learned counsel further submitted that the confession of the appellant was extracted under threat, duress and coercion and that is why neither the trial Court nor the High Court relied upon the same.
8. On these grounds, learned counsel for the appellant implored the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the conviction of the appellant, and acquit him of the charges levelled against him.
9. Per contra, learned standing counsel appearing for the respondent- State vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant. He urged that the material prosecution witnesses, i.e., PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, PW-6, PW-8 and PW-11, have given unimpeachable testimony alleging that the childvictim was last seen in the company of the appellant on the night of the incident whereafter she was not seen alive.
13 Exhibit Ka-11.
14 Exhibit Ka-17.
1488 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
10. Learned counsel further urged that the DNA expert’s report (Exhibit Ka-8) conclusively established that the DNA obtained from the t-Shirt of the appellant matched with the DNA obtained from the blood sample of the child-victim. Likewise, the DNA obtained from the hair of the suspect, vaginal smear of the child-victim and her clothes were found to be matching with the DNA obtained from the blood sample of the child-victim and the blood sample of the appellant. Learned counsel thus, submitted that the evidence of the witnesses of the last seen circumstance coupled with the DNA/FSL report is sufficient to bring home the guilt of the appellant. On these grounds, learned counsel for the respondent-State sought dismissal of the appeals.
11. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at the Bar and have gone through the impugned judgments and minutely reappraised the evidence available on record.
12. There is no dispute that the case of the prosecution rests totally on circumstantial evidence in the form of ‘last seen’, ‘recoveries’, ‘confession of the appellant’ and the ‘DNA/FSL report’. We may note that the confession of the appellant was exhibited in prosecution evidence but the same was not relied upon by the trial Court or the High Court and thus, the same need to be taken into consideration while appreciating the evidence available on record. Otherwise also, we find that the confession seems to have been extracted under duress and cannot be termed voluntary. The prosecution is, thus, left with the testimony of the witnesses of the last seen theory and the DNA/FSL report in its endeavour to bring home the guilt of the appellant.
13. Before we proceed to discuss the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, we may note that the present case is yet another classic example of undue haste resulting in denial of proper opportunity to the accused to be tried in a just and fair manner.
14. The sequence of events narrated below is sufficient to draw this inference.
15. The incident took place on the intervening night of 25 th /26 th June, 2016. The charge-sheet came to be filed on 24 th September, 2016 and the trial Court took cognizance of the same on the very same day. The matter was deferred to 26 th September, 2016 for providing copies of the documents submitted under Section 173(2) CrPC [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1489Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand to the appellant, as per the mandate of Section 207 CrPC. The matter was then deferred to 5 th October, 2016 for the very same purpose. The order sheets of 5 th October, 2016, 13 th October, 2016, 17th October, 2016, 19th October, 2016 and 1st November, 2016, all indicate that the matter was deferred for providing the copies of the relied upon documents to the accused (appellant herein). It was only on 5th November, 2016 that the trial Court noted that the appellant had been presented from custody and the documents included in the chargesheet as relied upon by the prosecution were being provided to him. It must be emphasized that till this date the appellant was neither represented by a privately engaged defence counsel nor did the trial Court offer him the services of a legal aid counsel. On 5 th November, 2016 itself, the trial Court proceeded to frame charges against the appellant even though he had been provided with the copies of the relied upon documents on that very day. Apparently thus, proper opportunity was not given to the appellant before framing charges against him and sending him for trial. Not only this, the trial Court extensively referred to the confession of the appellant recorded under Section 164 CrPC while framing charges against him. It is a different matter that the said confession was not relied upon either by the trial Court or the High Court, as a reliable piece of evidence against the appellant. On none of the dates fixed by the trial Court right up to the framing of charges and summoning of the witnesses did the Court make any endeavour to provide legal aid counsel to the appellant despite noting the fact that he remained unrepresented throughout the said proceedings.
16. Further, the Forensic Science Laboratory 15 report was presented by the Investigating Officer(PW-14) on 1 st and 3 rd December, 2016 and the trial Court took it on record. However, the order sheets of the trial Court are totally silent on the aspect of whether the copy of the said FSL report was ever provided to the appellant. For the first time on 11 th January, 2017, on the request being made by the appellant, one Shri S.P. Singh, Advocate, was appointed as an amicus curiae to represent him in the trial. It is pertinent to note that the recording of the evidence of prosecution witnesses began on the very same day, i.e., 11 th January, 2017, and the process was concluded within 15 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘FSL’.
1490 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 27 days, i.e., on 6th February, 2017. During this short period, the amicus curiae appointed to defend the appellant was changed on 31 st January, 2017. In view of the above sequence of events, there is no possibility that the defense counsel could have had a reasonable opportunity to prepare the matter and conduct the cross-examination from the witnesses. Thus, it is established beyond the pale of doubt that the trial was not conducted in a fair manner and that the appellant was not provided with a reasonable opportunity to defend himself.
17. Be that as it may, now we shall proceed to discuss the evidence of the prosecution witnesses who testified in the trial.
18. Brajpal Singh(PW-1), being the father of the child-victim gave evidence stating that his daughter (child-victim) went missing from a Jagran function. The dead body of the child-victim was recovered from a nearby field, whereby, he lodged the FIR 16 at the Police Station Kashipur. This report came to be filed around 10:00 AM on 26th June, 2016. However, what is most significant to note is that, although the witnesses of last seen circumstance claim in their depositions that they were present at the crime scene when the dead body of the child-victim was found, and police had arrived. Surprisingly, the FIR gives no indication whatsoever that anyone had seen the child-victim in the company of the appellant, who operated the sound and light at the Jagran function. The witnesses of the last seen theory claim to be present at the spot where the dead body was found but none of them divulged to the police officials who reached the spot that he/she had seen the child-victim and the accused-appellant moving together.
19. Jasweer Singh(PW-2) stated that he had come to the village Dhakiya Gulabo to meet his relatives. He also went to the Jagran function. The incident took place on the night of 25 th June, 2016. In the morning of 26 th June, 2016, at about 6:15 AM-6:30 AM, he came to know that the dead body of a girl child was lying in the nearby field. Out of curiosity, he also went there. He claimed that the dead body which he saw was of the same girl, whom he had seen in the night time accompanying a person who was doing the work of sound and light in the Jagran function and was being addressed by the name Rajiya @ Raju, by other people. The witness stated that he had seen the 16 Supra note 11.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1491Karandeep Sharma @ Razia @ Raju v. State of Uttarakhand child-victim going with the said person in the middle of the night. In cross-examination, the witness admitted that he did not know the appellant prior to the date of the incident.
20. What is important to note here is that the witness(PW-2) was not made to identify the appellant in the dock as being the person with whom the child-victim was seen going away.
21. Anand Pal Singh(PW-3) also testified almost on the same lines as Jasweer Singh(PW-2). This witness too did not identify the appellant in the dock as being the suspect with whom the child-victim was seen going away. However, both Jasweer Singh(PW-2) and Anand Pal Singh(PW-3) stated that the appellant was wearing spectacles.
22. Sheespal(PW-4) was a formal witness who gave evidence regarding the inquest proceedings and preparation of the inquest memo.
23. Smt. Rashmi Devi(PW-5) also gave evidence of last seen circumstance. She alleged that in the night at about 3 o’clock, she saw the person who was doing the task of sound and light at the Jagran function, talking to the child-victim. Thereafter, both of them were seen going towards Dhakiya Gulabo road. This witness also was not made to identify the appellant in the dock as being the person who was seen going away with the victim. She admitted in her cross-examination that she had never seen the appellant before the incident and that she identified him with the help of a photograph which was published in the newspaper. The witness(PW-5) further admitted that her statement was recorded by the police on the same day on which she saw the photograph in the newspaper. The fact that the photograph of the appellant was published in a newspaper and that this witness of last seen theory got wise about the identity of the assailant thereafter, makes her testimony suspect.
24. Munesh Singh(PW-6) is another witness of last seen circumstance. The testimony of this witness is also on the same lines as that of PW-2, PW-3, and PW-5. This witness also was not made to identify the appellant in the dock as being the suspect with whom the childvictim was seen going away.
25. Dr. Madan Mohan, medical officer(PW-7) conducted the post-mortem examination on the body of the child-victim. He opined that the childvictim had been subjected to forcible sexual assault and that she may have died as a result of asphyxia because of pressure applied 1492 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports during the act of sexual assault. He also conducted the medical examination of the appellant and collected samples of the appellant for serological and DNA examination. The medical officer made a vague assertion in his evidence that all the samples which he had collected were handed over to the policeman who had brought the appellant to the hospital. However, he neither disclosed the name of the policeman to whom the samples were handed over nor did he state that the samples were sealed and were handed over to the policeman in a secure condition. The witness did not refer to any document or receipt under which the samples were handed over to the policeman.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.