Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1203; [2025] 10 S.C.R. 587
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 8 Oct 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3633/2024
- Sections
- 8, 7, 6, 5, 366, 173(2), 193, 209, 232, 165, 168, 363
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 587 : 2025 INSC 1203 Dashwanth v.
State of Tamil Nadu (Criminal Appeal No(s). 3633-3634 of 2024)
08 October 2025 [Vikram Nath, Sanjay Karol and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Trial Court found appellant guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act. An appeal against the said conviction was dismissed by the High Court and confirmed the death sentence awarded to the appellant. Whether the prosecution has proved the vital circumstances, viz., (i) last seen together theory;
(ii) suspicious movement of the appellant captured in the video footage of the CCTV camera installed at a nearby temple; (iii) confessional/disclosure statement made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries/recoveries and (iv) FSL reports establishing the DNA profiling comparison, which constituted the entire edifice of the prosecution case and on which the conviction of the appellant was based.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) – A 7 year old female child went missing – Later, a charred body of the child was recovered in furtherance of the disclosure statement made by the appellant herein – Trial Court found appellant guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act – Appellant was sentenced in each of the aforesaid sections along with a death sentence – The trial Court also forwarded a reference u/s.366 of the CrPC for confirmation of the death sentence – Appeal preferred by the appellant before the High Court was dismissed and death sentence was confirmed – Correctness: Held: 1. The prosecution has miserably failed to prove the vital circumstances, viz., (i) last seen together theory; (ii) suspicious movement of the appellant captured in the video footage of the CCTV * Author 588 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports camera installed at a nearby temple; (iii) confessional/disclosure statement made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries/recoveries and (iv) FSL reports establishing the DNA profiling comparison, which constituted the entire edifice of the prosecution case and on which the conviction of the appellant was based – It would not be safe to uphold the conviction of the appellant as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court – Thus, the conviction of the appellant and the sentences awarded to him, by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court are also set aside. [Paras 81-83] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) – Appellant was found guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act by the Courts below – Whether the prosecution has proved the vital circumstance, viz., last seen together theory:
Held: The first and most critical circumstance on which the prosecution placed reliance was that of last seen together – The witness who gave evidence in support of this circumstance was PW-3, who claimed that on the fateful day, he saw the appellant and the victim playing on the second floor of the building, on the first floor whereof, the complainant (PW-1) being the father of the victim resided with his family – When the frantic process for searching the victim started, PW-3 claims to have informed the complainant (PW-1) that his daughter was not in the house and might be playing upstairs and advised him to go and look for her on the upper floor of the building – Had there been an iota of truth in the version of PW-3, he would definitely have told the complainant (PW-1) that he had seen the victim in the company of the appellant between 6:00 p.m. to 6:15 p.m. on the second floor of the building – The glaring omission on the part of PW-3 in failing to share this vital information is also manifest from the complaint filed by the complainant (PW-1) – The theory put forth in the evidence of (PW-3) that he had seen the victim in the company of the appellant on 05.02.2017 i.e., the date of the incident, is nothing but a sheer concoction, bereft of credibility – The statement of PW-3 that the said witness, for the first time, divulged the information comprising the circumstance of last seen together to the 2nd Investigating Officer (PW-30) only on 24.04.2017, i.e., more than two months and 20 days after the incident – Therefore, the circumstance of last seen together was [2025] 10 S.C.R. 589Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu created by the Investigating Officer (PW-30) through the witness (PW-3) in order to lend credence to the otherwise weak case of the prosecution. [Paras 44-46] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) – Appellant was found appellant guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act by the Courts below – Whether the prosecution has proved the vital circumstance of the video footage of the CCTV camera: Held: The next piece of circumstantial evidence on relied upon was in the form of the video footage of the CCTV camera, the primary evidence of the so-called CCTV footage is not available on record – The oral evidence regarding the CCTV footage was given by PW-6 being the In-charge of the nearby temple – In the absence of the CCTV footage being collected and exhibited as per law, no credence can be given to the evidence of PW-6, more so, when there is grave discrepancy between his version and the version of the complainant (PW-1). [Paras 47, 49, 51] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) – Appellant was found guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act by the Courts below – Whether the prosecution has proved the vital circumstance of the confessional/disclosure statement/s made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries/ recoveries:
Held: The third circumstance on which the prosecution relied upon to bring home the guilt of the appellant was in form of the confessional/disclosure statement/s made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries/recoveries – The fact that the police officers had told the complainant regarding the location where the body of the victim was disposed of, in the morning of 08.02.2017, is itself sufficient to discard the theory of the prosecution that all the incriminating discoveries were made in pursuance of the disclosure statement made by the appellant – It is apparent that the police had already created the entire story and later on, tried to fit the same into a sequence by postponing the formal arrest of the appellant 590 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in order to implicate him in this case – Thus, the claim made by the prosecution that the dead body of the victim was recovered in furtherance of the disclosure statement made by the appellant is belied by cogent material available on record – There is no hesitation in holding that recoveries of the bag, allegedly containing the bottles in which petrol was carried and the undergarment of the victim, were not effected at the instance of the appellant and were planted recoveries – The theory of confessional/disclosure statement of the appellant leading to the discoveries is nothing but a creation of the Investigating Officer (PW-29) and as a matter of fact, all the incriminating facts and circumstances were already in the knowledge of the Investigating Officer (PW-29) and were subsequently woven into a story, projecting a hypothesis that a voluntary confession was made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries of the dead body, the ornaments, etc. – The signatures of appellant were obtained on the confessional statements by detaining him in advance and torturing and beating him and that the appellant was implicated in the case falsely. [Paras 52, 54, 55, 60, 67] Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC – Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 – s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) – Appellant was found guilty for the charges framed u/ss.302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and s.8 r/w. s.7 and s.6 r/w. s.5(m) of the POCSO Act by the Courts below – Whether the prosecution has proved the vital circumstance of the FSL reports establishing the DNA profiling comparison, which constituted the entire edifice of the prosecution case and on which the conviction of the appellant was based:
Held: The testimony of the Investigating Officer (PW-29) confirms that the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the chain of custody of the forensic articles/samples right from the time of seizure till they reached the FSL – The malkhana In-charge of the police station was not examined in evidence – Neither any forwarding documents except for a forwarding letter, authorising the movement of the forensic articles/samples were proved by the Investigation Officer (PW-29) nor any witness who carried these samples from the police station to the Court or the concerned laboratories, was examined in evidence – Since the sanctity of the samples was not proved by proper evidence, as a necessary corollary, the reports of scientific analysis would lose significance [2025] 10 S.C.R. 591Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu and cannot be relied upon – Though the scientific experts concluded that the DNA profile of the semen stain found on the underwear of the victim was matching with the DNA profile of the appellant but as the very factum of recovery of the Material Object, i.e., the undergarment of the victim has not been established beyond doubt, as a consequence, no sanctity whatsoever can be attached to the conclusions drawn in the Expert Report (Exhibit P-32) – A very serious question has to be posed regarding the time of collection of the blood samples of the appellant – There was no reason whatsoever for the Investigating Agency to have waited for four months before collecting the blood samples of the appellant – There is a strong possibility that the delay may have been utilized to manipulate the samples. [Paras 71, 76, 78] Crime – Heinous crime – Punishment cannot be based on moral convictions or conjectures – Prosecution is duty-bound to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt: Held: The present case pertains to the commission of a heinous offence involving a girl of tender age of 7 years, at the same time, this Court cannot ignore or bypass the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that the prosecution is duty-bound to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt – The onus is heavier in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence – However, regrettably, the prosecution has miserably failed to do so in the instant case, leaving the Court with no choice but to acquit the appellant, despite the heinous nature of the crime – While it is acknowledged that the acquittal of an individual involved in a heinous crime can lead to societal distress and cause grave anguish to the victim’s family, the legal framework does not permit the Courts to punish an accused person based merely on moral convictions or conjectures – Each case must be adjudicated by the Courts rigorously on its individual merits and in strict conformity with the law, without yielding to public sentiment and external pressures. [Para 80] Constitution of India – Constitutional right to defend: Held: The constitutional right afforded to an accused charged with an offence to defend himself is not illusory or imaginary – For the trial to be fair and reasonable, an effective opportunity to defend must be provided to the accused and representation by a counsel of choice is an important component of this guarantee – In a 592 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports case where accused is facing charges for offences which carry capital punishment, this constitutional mandate becomes even more sacrosanct, and it is the duty of the Court as well as the State to ensure that the accused is not prejudiced or deprived of a fair opportunity of defending himself in a case where he may be awarded death penalty. [Para 36] Natural Justice – Criminal Law – Trial – Fair opportunity of defending:
Held: Such opportunity would require: (a) Providing copies of all relied upon documents to the accused immediately on submission of report u/s.173(2) CrPC (Section 193 BNSS)/committal of case u/s.209 CrPC (Section 232 BNSS); (b) Ensuring that the accused is represented by a lawyer of his own choice and in case, he/she is not in a position to engage a private counsel then, a legal aid defence counsel having requisite experience must be appointed to represent him at the trial; (c) The legal aid counsel so appointed should be given sufficient opportunity to go through the record and prepare the matter for carrying out effective cross-examination from the witnesses; (d) The Court should not act as a mute spectator during recording of evidence, as provided u/s.165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 168 of the Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023) – The Court must remain vigilant, and in case any important question necessary to arrive at a just decision of the case is omitted to be put to the witnesses either by the defence counsel or the public prosecutor, the Court must not let such lacuna creep into the proceedings, and it must be ensured that Court put questions to the witnesses for ensuring fairness in the proceedings. [Para 37] Case Law Cited Sharad Birdhichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; Prakash Nishad @ Kewat Zinak Nishad v. State of Maharashtra [2023] 8 SCR 152 : 2023 SCC Online SC 666 – relied on.
Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab [1983] 1 SCR 145; Santa Singh v. State of Punjab [1977] 1 SCR 229 : (1976) 4 SCC 190; Allauddin Mian and Ors. v. State of Bihar [1989] 2 SCR 498 : (1989) 3 SCC 5; Malkiat Singh v. State of Punjab [1991] 2 SCR 256 : (1991) 4 SCC 341; Dattaraya v. State of Maharashtra [2019] 11 SCR 295 : (2020) 14 SCC 290; Anokhilal v. State of Madhya [2025] 10 S.C.R. 593Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu Pradesh [2019] 18 SCR 1196 : 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1637; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Deoman Upadhyaya [1961] 1 SCR 14 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 8; Mohmed Inayatullah v. State of Maharashtra [1976] 1 SCR 715 : (1976) 1 SCC 828; Earabhadrappa v. State of Karnataka [1983] 2 SCR 552 : (1983) 2 SCC 330; Bodhraj alias Bodha and Others v. State of Jammu and Kashmir [2002] Supp. 2 SCR 67 : (2002) 8 SCC 45 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Constitution of India; Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
List of Keywords Murder; Child missing; Charred body; Disclosure statement; Confession; Last seen together theory; CCTV footage; Incriminating discoveries; FSL reports; DNA profiling; Circumstantial evidence; Heinous crime; Moral convictions; Conjectures; False implication; Death sentence; Discrepency in versions of witnesses; Constitutional right to defend; Natural Justice; Criminal Law; Trial; Fair opportunity of defending.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 3633-3634 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 10.07.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in CRLA No. 234 of 2018 and RT No. 1 of 2018 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Siddharth Aggarwal, Sr. Adv., Ms. Manasa Ramakrishna, Vishwajeet Singh, Ms. Trisha Chandran, Karan Dhalla, Prashanth Sharmila Prakash, Ms. Shreya Rastogi, Ms. Rajni Gupta, Abhimanue Shrestha, Shivendra Gupta.
Advs. for the Respondent:
V.Krishnamurthy, Sr. Adv./AAG, Sabarish Subramanian, Vishnu Unnikrishnan, Ms. Azka Sheikh Kalia, Ms. Jahnavi Taneja, Danish Saifi.
594 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. The appellant herein was tried by the learned Sessions Judge, Mahila Court, Chengalpet 1 in Special Sessions Case No. 33 of 2017 for the offences punishable under Sections 363, 366, 354-B, 302, and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 2 and Section 8 read with Section 7 and Section 6 read with Section 5(m) of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 3 . The trial Court, vide judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 19 th February, 2018 convicted the accused-appellant 4 for the aforementioned offences and sentenced him in the terms indicated below: - Section Sentence S. 363 IPC 7 years S. 366 IPC 10 years S. 354-B IPC 7 years S. 201 IPC 7 years S. 302 IPC Death Penalty S. 6 r/w S. 5 (m) of POCSO Act 10 years S. 8 r/w S. 7 of POCSO Act 5 years
3. Being aggrieved, the appellant preferred an appeal 5 before the High Court of Judicature at Madras 6 for assailing his conviction and the sentences awarded to him. The trial Court also forwarded a reference7 1 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘trial Court’.
2 For short, ‘IPC’.
3 For short, ‘POCSO Act’.
4 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘appellant’.
5 Criminal Appeal No. 234 of 2018.
6 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘High Court’.
7 Referred Trial No. 1 of 2018.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 595Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 8 for confirmation of the death sentence. The learned Division Bench of the High Court vide common judgment dated 10 th July, 2018, dismissed the appeal preferred by the appellant and answered the reference in the affirmative thereby confirming the death sentence awarded to the appellant by the trial Court. The said judgment of the High Court is the subject matter of challenge in these appeals by special leave.
FACTUAL MATRIX: -
4. In brief, the story of the prosecution is that a seven-year old female child victim 9 , being the daughter of C.S.D. Babu (PW-1) 10 and Sridevi (PW-2), went missing on 5th February, 2017. The parents had gone out shopping, and when they returned at about 7:15 p.m., they did not see their daughter around, upon which a search was made with the help of the neighbours including the appellant. The police were also informed, but the efforts to trace out the child did not yield any results. The hapless father, C.S.D. Babu (PW-1) filed a complaint 11 at Mangadu Police Station at around 10:00 p.m. on 5 th February, 2017 itself and based upon the same, a missing persons’ case was registered. The complainant (PW-1), in his efforts to get clues about the whereabouts of his child, claims to have browsed video footage of a CCTV camera installed at a nearby temple which gave an indication as to the manner in which the child victim might have been kidnapped. The police also followed the lead provided by the complainant (PW-1) and went through the CCTV footage after which the needle of suspicion turned towards the appellant.
5. Based on this suspicion, the appellant was arrested on 8 th February, 2017 at about 9 a.m. He allegedly confessed and made a disclosure statement 12 to N. Ravikumar, 1st Investigation Officer (PW-29) 13 in the presence of Sumathi (PW-7), Village Administrative Officer, Madanandhapuram Village, and Mohandass (PW-8) who is the assistant of PW-7.
8 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘CrPC’.
9 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘victim’ or ‘child victim’. 10 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘complainant (PW-1)’.
11 Exhibit P-1 12 Exhibit P-8.
13 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘Investigation Officer (PW-29)’. 596 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
6. The Investigating Officer (PW-29) claims that the charred body of the child victim was recovered on 8 th February, 2017 in furtherance of the disclosure statement made by the appellant. The body was identified by Muneesekar (PW-14), the Administrative Officer of the school where the victim was studying. Based on the said recovery of the victim’s body, the missing persons’ case was converted to a crime report 14 for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and Section 8 read with Section 7 and Section 6 read with Section 5(m) of the POCSO Act. The disclosure statement of the appellant further led to the recovery of an Apache motorcycle and a Oppo mobile phone. The Investigation Officer (PW-29) prepared an observation mahazar15 and a rough site sketch16 of the place from where the body of the victim was recovered. The appellant also identified the blue-coloured travel bag 17 in which undergarments 18 worn by the victim and two cold drink bottles19 were placed. Forensic material was collected from the dead body of the victim and the crime scene.
7. Thereafter, the appellant allegedly took the police to his flat which was located on the second floor of the very same building in which the complainant (PW-1) also resided and pointed out the place where the victim had been subjected to sexual abuse and later, murdered. The Investigation Officer (PW-29) prepared the observation mahazar20 and site inspection plan 21 of the said flat. The jeans pant 22 and t-shirt23 allegedly worn by the appellant at the time of commission of the offence were recovered from the flat and the earrings 24 and 14 FIR bearing Crime No. 285 of 2017.
15 Exhibit P-4.
16 Exhibit P-35.
17 Material Object No. 6.
18 Material Object No. 1.
19 Material Object No. 11.
20 Exhibit P-6.
21 Exhibit P-36.
22 Material Object No. 12.
23 Material Object No. 13.
24 Material Object No. 2.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 597Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu anklets 25 of the victim along with the ATM card26 , PAN card27 , and identity card 28 of the appellant were also recovered from his purse29 during this sequence. Recovery of a helmet 30 was also effected, based on the interrogation conducted from the appellant.
8. After the completion of the inquest proceedings, the child’s body was forwarded to the Kilpauk Medical College and Hospital, Chennai for post-mortem examination. The body of the victim was subjected to post-mortem by Dr. Karthika Devi (PW-16), medical officer, attached with the Kilpauk Medical College and Hospital, Chennai. The medical officer noticed that the body of the victim was charred and there were bruises over the lower lip. The lower incisor teeth were loosened with bruises around the surrounding area. The thigh bones collected from the dead body were forwarded for DNA analysis, and the skull was forwarded for superimposition so as to ascertain the identity of the victim. Since the body was completely charred, the medical officer expressed inability to give a definite opinion regarding the exact cause of her death. However, on queries raised by the Investigation Officer (PW-29), the medical officer gave an opinion that death by smothering could not be ruled out. The appellant was subjected to medical examination on 13 th February, 2017.
9. The Investigating Officer (PW-29) examined Santosh Kumar (PW-18), who had purportedly sold petrol to the appellant which he carried in the two bottles 31 recovered from the blue bag 32 . The witness provided information regarding the appellant making payment through a credit card and based on the said statement, the credit card slip pertaining to the purchase of petrol by the appellant was also seized.
10. Upon carrying out the scientific procedure of superimposition and DNA examination, it was concluded that the body was of none other than that of the victim, daughter of C.S.D. Babu (PW-1) and Sridevi (PW-2).
25 Material Object No. 3.
26 Material Object No. 16.
27 Material Object No. 17.
28 Material Object No. 18.
29 Material Object No. 14.
30 Material Object No. 19.
31 Supra Note 19.
32 Supra Note 17.
598 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11. The Investigating Officer (PW-29) was transferred and thus further investigation of the case was assigned to R.D. Vivekanandan, 2nd Investigation Officer (PW-30) 33 who completed the investigation and filed a chargesheet against the appellant for the offences punishable under Sections 363, 366, 354-B, 302 and 201 of the IPC and Section 8 read with Section 7 and Section 6 read with Section 5(m) of the POCSO Act in the trial court.
12. The trial Court framed charges against the appellant for the aforementioned offences, to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 30 witnesses and exhibited 45 documents and 19 material objects in order to prove its case.
13. By resorting to the procedure under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant was questioned and confronted with the incriminating circumstances appearing against him in the case put up by the prosecution. He refuted these allegations and claimed to have been falsely implicated. A written statement was filed on behalf of the appellant under Section 315 CrPC. However, neither any oral evidence was led, nor any document was exhibited on his behalf in defence. The plea taken by the appellant in the written statement was that he returned from his office on 7 th February, 2017 at about 5:00 a.m. On the same day, the police officials came to his house at about 7:30 a.m. and questioned him and his family members for about 30 minutes. Thereafter, between 11:00 a.m. and 12 noon, an inspector came to his house and took him to the police station where, he was kept confined and was forced to sign blank papers and was then remanded to judicial custody.
14. The trial Court upon appreciating the arguments advanced by the Public Prosecutor and the defence counsel and upon analysing the oral and documentary evidence available on record, found the appellant guilty for the charges framed under Sections 302, 201, 363, 366 and 354-B of the IPC and Section 8 read with Section 7 and Section 6 read with Section 5(m) of the POCSO Act and sentenced him as noted above, vide judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 19 th February, 2017.
15. Being aggrieved, the appellant preferred an appeal under Section 374(2) CrPC to the High Court challenging his conviction and 33 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘Investigation Officer (PW-30)’. [2025] 10 S.C.R. 599Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu sentences awarded to him whereas, a reference was forwarded by the trial Court under Section 366 CrPC to the High Court, for confirmation of the death sentence awarded to the appellant. The appeal filed by the appellant was rejected and the reference was answered in the affirmative by the High Court vide common judgment dated 10 th July, 2018 which is the subject matter of challenge in the present appeals by special leave.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT: -
16. Learned counsel for the appellant, vehemently and fervently contended that the entire case of the prosecution is false and fabricated. The prosecution story is full of improbabilities and loopholes. The evidence of the material prosecution witnesses is flimsy and does not inspire confidence. The conduct of the witnesses is highly suspicious which makes their testimony doubtful and unworthy of credence. The conduct of Murugan @ Venkata Murugan Guna (PW-3)34 , the alleged witness of the last seen together circumstance, is highly unnatural inasmuch as, in spite of claiming to have seen the victim playing with the appellant on the second floor of the same building where the complainant (PW-1) used to reside, he never divulged the said fact either to the father of the victim or to the police officers, who had reached the area soon after the victim was reported missing. It is the admitted case of the prosecution that after the parents of the victim raised a hue and cry regarding their daughter having gone missing, an extensive search operation was launched. The appellant also participated in the search efforts, and he remained with the search party till 4:00 a.m. in the morning of 6th February, 2017. It was, thus, submitted that the evidence of Murugan (PW-3), the sole witness of the last seen together circumstance cannot be relied upon.
17. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that Murugan (PW-3), the self-proclaimed witness of last seen together circumstance claimed that he had seen the victim playing with the appellant on the second floor of the building. Had there been an iota of truth in this version then in the natural course of events, he would have immediately disclosed this fact to the parents of the victim, and an immediate attempt would have been made to search the second 34 Hereinafter, referred to as ‘Murugan (PW-3)’.
600 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports floor of the building including the flat of the appellant. However, no such effort was made by the search party or the police officers which completely discredits the theory put forth by Murugan (PW-3) that he had seen the victim in the company of the appellant soon before her disappearance.
18. It was further submitted that the recoveries allegedly made at the instance of the appellant were planted and fabricated and hence, unbelievable. The appellant was apprehended by police officials on 7 th February, 2017, and was kept in illegal custody at the police station, where he was forced to sign several blank papers and that, the recoveries were planted to provide padding to the false prosecution narrative.
19. Learned counsel referred to the examination-in-chief of the complainant (PW-1) to urge that the victim was seen playing with her friends, by her mother at 6:00 p.m. on 5 th February, 2017. Immediately thereafter, both the parents left to buy vegetables. They returned home inside of an hour but did not see their child around, on which the search efforts were commenced. Thus, there was only a gap of one hour in which the entire incident is stated to have taken place.
20. Learned counsel submitted that since the search was commenced within an hour of the victim having gone missing, there was practically neither enough time nor any possibility for the appellant to subject the child victim to rape and to have disposed of the dead body of the victim in the time and manner as alleged by the prosecution. He pointed out that the prosecution has surmised that the appellant after committing the ghastly crime, concealed the victim’s body in a bag; carried it down two flights of stairs; took it to the petrol pump on his motorcycle; purchased petrol and then carried the body to a remote location before setting it ablaze. He submitted that this sequence of events put forth by the prosecution is totally unbelievable and could not have been completed in the small window of about an hour. It was emphasised with reference to the evidence of the complainant (PW-1) and Sridevi (PW-2) that right from the inception, the appellant was participating in the search and remained with the search party till 4:00 a.m. in the morning of 6th February, 2017.
21. Attention of the Court was drawn to the version of the complainant (PW-1), i.e., the father of the victim wherein he alleged that previously, the victim had made a complaint to her mother that the appellant [2025] 10 S.C.R. 601Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu indulged in pinching her cheeks and also used to kiss her. It was contended that looking at the said previous conduct, it is impossible to believe that the suspicion of the parents would not have shifted on to the appellant once the information regarding the victim having gone missing was received.
22. Learned counsel further contended that looking at this past history as referred to supra and the fact that Murugan (PW-3), being the member of the search party, claimed to have seen the child victim playing with the appellant on the second floor of the same building, the immediate and natural reaction of the witnesses would have been to make a search on the second floor as well as inside the flat of the appellant. Learned counsel contended that a theory tried to be built up by the prosecution witnesses claiming that the flat of the appellant was found locked and hence, it could not be searched, does not hold water when it is seen that the material prosecution witnesses, namely, the complainant (PW-1) and Sridevi (PW-2) themselves admitted that the appellant was also assisting them in the search till 4:00 a.m. in the morning of 6th February, 2017.
23. He further submitted that if at all, Murugan (PW-3) had actually seen the child playing with the appellant on the second floor and soon thereafter, a hue and cry was raised regarding the child having gone missing, then the said witnesses would have immediately divulged the said information to the complainant (PW-1) being the father of the child victim. In this scenario, the police personnel who arrived at the spot would also have been, instantaneously sounded about the gravely suspicious circumstance thereby putting everyone at guard regarding the conduct of the appellant and the finger of suspicion would have turned towards him at the first instance. Had there been an iota of truth in these allegations, the family members and the police officials would never have permitted the appellant to participate in the search efforts and further they would have immediately proceeded to search the second floor of the building and particularly, the flat of the appellant. If such an exercise had taken place, the same would have immediately exposed the circumstances prevailing at the alleged crime scene and would have provided an important lead for further investigation. It was also submitted that the entire set of incriminating circumstances and recovered articles have been subsequently planted by the police officials for oblique motives.
602 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
24. Learned counsel further urged that the prosecution case regarding the appellant having purchased petrol in the bottles is false and unsubstantiated. The recovery of the blue bag with the undergarment of the victim is clearly planted because when the initial observation mahazar (Exhibit P-4) was prepared by the police officers pursuant to the alleged disclosure statement of the appellant, the presence of the said bag was not mentioned in the memorandum. It was further submitted that the Investigating Officer (PW-29) did not prove the disclosure statements of the appellant as per law and hence the recoveries pale into insignificance.
25. It was also contended that the body of the victim had already been discovered much prior to the disclosure statement of the appellant being recorded which fact is evident from the testimony of the complainant (PW-1), i.e., the father of the victim. Thus, the discovery of the body cannot be treated as having been made in pursuance of the disclosure statement of the appellant.
26. It was also submitted that not only is the recovery of the ornaments suspicious but, in addition thereto, there is a grave doubt in the manner in which the identification proceedings of these articles were held.
27. Learned senior counsel vehemently urged that there has been a failure of a fair trial in this case inasmuch as the appellant was hardly given any opportunity to defend himself in the case. The charge was framed against the appellant on 24 th October, 2017 and the calendar for the summoning of the witnesses was finalised on 20 th November, 2017. However, compliance with the mandatory requirement of Section 207 CrPC, i.e., providing copies of the relied upon documents to the accused, was ensured only on 13 th December, 2017 and just four days thereafter, the prosecution evidence was commenced. Thus, as per the learned counsel, the entire procedure adopted by the trial Court right from the framing of charges to recording of evidence of the prosecution witnesses is hasty and vitiated and tantamounts to denial of fair trial inasmuch as the trial Court proceeded to frame charges against the appellant without providing the relied upon documents to him as mandated by law and thus, the subsequent proceedings would be automatically vitiated.
28. He further contended that the appellant was unrepresented in the trial proceedings and requested for the services of a legal aid counsel. It was, for the first time, on 13 th December, 2017, the trial Court [2025] 10 S.C.R. 603Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu appointed a legal aid counsel to represent the appellant in the trial proceedings. The documents under Section 207 CrPC were supplied on the same day and without giving any time for preparation to the legal aid counsel; the evidence of the prosecution was commenced from 18 th December, 2017, i.e., within 4 days of the legal aid counsel being appointed, and evidence of as many as 30 witnesses was completed within one month and sixteen days. He further submitted that the judgment of conviction was pronounced on 19 th February, 2018 and on the very same day, the trial Court proceeded to pass the sentence of death penalty against the appellant, which is in gross contravention to the tenets of fair trial and the sentencing principles as consistently laid down by this Court. To fortify these assertions, learned counsel placed reliance on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab35, Santa Singh v. State of Punjab36 , Allauddin Mian and Ors. v. State of Bihar37, Malkiat Singh v. State of Punjab38 , and Dattaraya v. State of Maharashtra39.
29. On these grounds, learned counsel for the appellant implored the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the conviction of the appellant, and acquit him of the charges levelled against him.
30. Without prejudice to the above, learned counsel representing the appellant urged that the incident took place way back in the year 2017, and the appellant has already been incarcerated in prison for almost 8 years. Neither the trial Court nor the High Court undertook the mandatory exercise of procuring the report in respect of aggravating and mitigating circumstances; no effort was made to get conducted the psychological evaluation of the appellant; and to get a report about the conduct of the appellant in jail before passing the order of sentence. The entire sentencing exercise was completed by the trial Court on the very same day on which the judgment of conviction was pronounced. Hence, the capital punishment awarded to the appellant is totally vitiated since the sentencing exercise was a mere formality and no proper opportunity was provided to the appellant
35 1983 (1) SCR 145.
36 (1976) 4 SCC 190.
37 (1989) 3 SCC 5.
38 (1991) 4 SCC 341.
39 (2020) 14 SCC 290.
604 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in the said process. He, thus, submitted that in case, the conviction of the appellant is upheld, he deserves leniency on the aspect of the sentence.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT-STATE: -
31. Per contra, learned senior counsel representing the State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the appellant’s counsel. He urged that Murugan (PW-3) had no reason to falsely implicate the appellant. His statement to the effect that the victim was playing with the appellant on the second floor of the building is absolutely truthful and constitutes unimpeachable evidence in support of the circumstance of last seen together which has been established against the appellant beyond all manner of doubt. Immediately thereafter, the child victim went missing. Hence, the onus would shift onto the accused to explain the circumstances under which the child victim was found murdered and her body burnt.
32. He further submitted that the burnt dead body of the victim was recovered in furtherance of the disclosure statement of the appellant for which he has offered no explanation whatsoever. The jewellery articles worn by the victim on the day of the incident were also recovered from the house of the appellant which also gives rise to a presumption under Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The appellant failed to offer any explanation whatsoever for these damning incriminating recoveries, and thus, the trial Court and the High Court were absolutely justified in drawing the presumption of guilt against the appellant. On these grounds, learned senior counsel for the respondent-State sought dismissal of the appeals.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS: -
33. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have gone through the impugned judgments and the material placed on record.
34. First and foremost, we will address the submission advanced by learned counsel for the appellant that there has been a total failure of justice inasmuch as the trial was not conducted in a fair manner and no proper opportunity was provided to the appellant to defend himself. The following chronological list of dates is essential to appreciate the above issue raised by the counsel: - [2025] 10 S.C.R. 605Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu Date Event 17.08.2017 Chargesheet filed by the police.
24.10.2017 Charges were framed against the appellant, who was not represented by a defence counsel and was not provided services of a legal aid defence counsel.
20.11.2017 A calendar was fixed for the trial of the appellant. Schedule for examination of witnesses by the prosecution was fixed and 34 witnesses were sought to be examined in 4 days, commencing from 18th December, 2017.
13.12.2017 Compliance with the mandatory provision of Section 207 CrPC was made. On the same day, for the first time, a legal aid counsel was appointed to represent the appellant, on his request.
18.12.2017 Prosecution evidence was commenced.
30.01.2018 Prosecution evidence completed.
19.02.2018 Judgment of conviction was passed by the trial Court and on the same day, the appellant was awarded death penalty.
35. A bare perusal of the above sequence of events and proceedings makes it clear that right from the stage of framing of the charges, the trial was conducted in a lopsided manner and without due deference to the principles of fair trial. The appellant herein was not represented by a defence counsel, and the services of a free legal aid counsel were provided to him on 13th December, 2017, only after the charges were framed. The documents relied upon by the prosecution were not provided to the appellant and without complying with the mandate of Section 207 CrPC (Section 230 BNSS40 ), the charges were framed against the appellant on 24th October, 2017, who was unrepresented on that date. The schedule for examination of 30 prosecution witnesses was fixed for four days starting from 18th December, 2017 without providing the services of a legal aid counsel to the appellant who was left to face the charges of such grave nature unrepresented by 40 Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
606 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a counsel of his choice or a legal aid counsel in gross disregard to the mandate of Articles 21 and 22(1) of the Constitution of India and the guidelines issued by NALSA 41 . As noted above, copies of the documents relied upon by the prosecution and the services of the legal aid counsel were, for the first time, provided to the appellant only on 13th December, 2017 and the evidence commenced within a period of four days therefrom. Recording of prosecution evidence was concluded within a period of one and a half months. In this background, we are of the firm view that the legal aid counsel appointed to defend the appellant could, by no stretch of imagination, have had a reasonable and effective opportunity to prepare the matter and conduct the cross-examination from the witnesses.
36. The constitutional right afforded to an accused charged with an offence to defend himself is not illusory or imaginary. For the trial to be fair and reasonable, an effective opportunity to defend must be provided to the accused and representation by a counsel of choice is an important component of this guarantee. In a case where accused is facing charges for offences which carry capital punishment, this constitutional mandate becomes even more sacrosanct, and it is the duty of the Court as well as the State to ensure that the accused is not prejudiced or deprived of a fair opportunity of defending himself in a case where he may be awarded death penalty.
37. Such opportunity would unquestionably require: -
(a) Providing copies of all relied upon documents to the accused immediately on submission of report under Section 173(2) CrPC (Section 193 BNSS)/committal of case under Section 209 CrPC (Section 232 BNSS).
(b) Ensuring that the accused is represented by a lawyer of his own choice and in case, he/she is not in a position to engage a private counsel then, a legal aid defence counsel having requisite experience must be appointed to represent him at the trial. As has been laid down by this Court in Anokhilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh42 , in capital punishment offences, a legal aid defense counsel so appointed should preferably have an experience of 10 years at the bar.
41 National Legal Services Authority.
42 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1637.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 607Dashwanth v. State of Tamil Nadu
(c) The legal aid counsel so appointed should be given sufficient opportunity to go through the record and prepare the matter for carrying out effective cross-examination from the witnesses.
(d) The Court should not act as a mute spectator during recording of evidence, as provided under Section 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 168 of the Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023). The Court must remain vigilant, and in case any important question necessary to arrive at a just decision of the case is omitted to be put to the witnesses either by the defence counsel or the public prosecutor, the Court must not let such lacuna creep into the proceedings, and it must be ensured that Court put questions to the witnesses for ensuring fairness in the proceedings.
38. However, the chronological list of events reproduced (paragraph 34 supra) makes it clear that these mandatory requirements were totally bypassed/violated by the trial Court while conducting the proceedings. Hence, prejudice and denial of opportunity of effective defence to the accused are writ large on the face of the record.
39. The conviction of the appellant was recorded on 19 th February, 2018, and on the very same day, the learned trial Judge proceeded to undertake a pretentious exercise of hearing the appellant on the aspect of sentence and awarded the death penalty to him. Evidently, the manner in which the trial Court proceeded to pass the sentencing order indicates hot haste leaving much to be desired and would vitiate the death sentence awarded to the appellant. Neither the trial Court nor the High Court undertook the mandatory exercise of seeking a report of mitigating and aggravating circumstances; the psychological examination report of the appellant and a report concerning the conduct of the appellant in jail, before passing the order of sentence and confirming the same. Thus, the sentencing procedure is in direct conflict with the judgments of this Court in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab43 , Santa Singh v. State of Punjab44 , Allauddin Mian 43 Supra Note 35.
44 Supra Note 36.
608 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and Ors. v. State of Bihar45, Malkiat Singh v. State of Punjab46, and Dattaraya v. State of Maharashtra47.
40. In view of the facts and circumstances indicated above, we would have been persuaded to set aside the impugned judgment and could have remanded the matter to the trial Court for fresh adjudication. However, considering the fact that almost eight years have elapsed since the incident took place, and considering the fact that the appellant has already suffered protracted proceedings of trial and appeal, while being incarcerated in custody, we deem it fit to examine the case on merits.
41. At the outset, it may be noted that the case of the prosecution is based purely on circumstantial evidence, in the form of: i. last seen together theory;
ii. suspicious movement of the appellant captured in the video footage of the CCTV camera installed at a nearby temple; iii. confessional/disclosure statement/s made by the appellant leading to the incriminating discoveries/recoveries of: -
(a) body of the victim;
(b) the undergarments of the victim;
(c) the bottles in which the appellant procured petrol for burning the body of the victim;
(d) ornaments of the victim.
iv. Forensic Science Laboratory 48 reports establishing the DNA profiling comparison.
42. It is trite law that in a case based purely on circumstantial evidence, the onus is upon the prosecution to prove the chain of unbroken circumstances beyond all manner of doubt. The chain of incriminating circumstances must be complete, conclusive and should exclude every hypothesis other than the guilt of the accused. In other words, it must be proved from the chain of incriminating circumstances that 45 Supra Note 37.
46 Supra Note 38.
47 Supra Note 39.
48 For short, “FSL”.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.