Somdatt Builders-Ncc-Nec(Jv) v. National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 113; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 203
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 26 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2058/2012
- Sections
- 37, 34, 34(2)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 203 : 2025 INSC 113 Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV)
v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2058 of 2012)
27 January 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards correctness of the judgment of the Division Bench setting aside the arbitral award u/s.37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.
Headnotes† Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – s.34 and 37 – Jurisdiction under – Exercise of – Interference with the decision of the arbitrator – Execution of contract awarded by National Highways Authority of India-NHAI to the appellant regarding construction of lanes on National Highway – Dispute as regards geogrid/geotextile material exceeded the Bill of Quantities-BOQ quantities in the contract, and the power of the Engineer to revise the rates given in the BOQ in the event of increase in actual quantities – Appellant’s case that the Engineer/Employer intending wrongful application of the Conditions of Particular Application for downward revision of rates for BOQ item of geogrid for quantity in excess of BOQ quantity – Recommendation by Dispute Review Board-DRB that quantities of geogrid required limited to facia area provided in the BOQ to be paid as per the BOQ rates – Invocation of arbitration clause by NHAI – Arbitral tribunal holding that the quantity of geogrid given at the tender stage by NHAI was wrong, there was no change in the design but mere increase in the quantity beyond the BOQ quantity, directed NHAI to pay the appellant for the actual quantity of geogrid required to be executed to complete the work as per the approved design at the BOQ rate – Application by NHAI u/s.34 – Single Judge of the High Court upheld the arbitral award – However, the Division Bench set aside the same – Sustainability:
* Author 204 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Held: Not sustainable – Great deal of restraint is required to be shown by the Courts while examining the validity of an arbitral award when such an award has been upheld, wholly or substantially, u/s.34 – Court cannot undertake an independent assessment of the merits of the award and must only ascertain that the exercise of power by the court u/s. 34 has not exceeded the scope of the provision – View taken by DRB and arbitral tribunal, both comprising of technical experts, that there is no variation either in the form or quality or quantity of the works is the correct one which was acknowledged by the Single Judge – At the time of execution of the contract, the geogrid required turned out to be much more than the estimated figure given in the contract – As such both the fact finding authorities held that there was no variation in terms of Clause 51.1 and the Engineer did not have the competence to renegotiate the price or rate of the geogrid for the excess quantity of geogrid required – This is clearly a plausible view – It is the correct interpretation of Clause 51 made by the DRB and the arbitral tribunal, in a reasonable manner based on the evidence on record – As such, the Single Judge rightly declined to interfere with the award of the arbitral tribunal u/s.34, affirming the decision of the DRB – Division Bench of the High Court not at all justified in setting aside the arbitral award exercising extremely limited jurisdiction u/s.37 by merely using expressions like ‘opposed to the public policy of India’, ‘patent illegality’ and ‘shocking the conscience of the court’ – Thus, the judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court is set aside and the arbitral award is restored. [Paras 27.3, 28, 33, 34, 36, 42, 43] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Arbitral award – Public policy in India – Explanation:
Held: Public policy in India means the fundamental policy of Indian law – Violation of Indian statutes linked to public policy or public interest and disregarding orders of superior courts in India would be regarded as being contrary to the fundamental policy of Indian law – It would also mean that the arbitral award is against basic notions of justice or morality – Arbitral award can be set aside on the ground of patent illegality, where the illegality goes to the root of the matter but reappreciation of evidence cannot be permitted under the ground of patent illegality. [Para 37] [2025] 2 S.C.R. 205Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
Case Law Cited Ssangyong Engineer and Construction Company Ltd. v. NHAI [2019] 7 SCR 522 : (2019) 15 SCC 131; Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. v. State of Goa [2023] 8 SCR 379 : (2024) 1 SCC 479 – relied on.
S.V. Samudram v. State of Karnataka [2024] 1 SCR 281 :
(2024) 3 SCC 623; M/s. Hindustan Construction Company Ltd. v. M/s NHAI [2023] 11 SCR 623 : (2024) 2 SCC 613; Konkan Railway Corporation Limited v. Chenab Bridge Project Undertaking [2023] 11 SCR 215 : (2023) 9 SCC 85; M/s. Larsen Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Company v. Union of India 2023 INSC 708 : [2023] 11 SCR 86; MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Limited [2019] 3 SCR 1023 : (2019) 4 SCC 163; MP Power Generation Company Ltd. v. Ansaldo Energia SPA (2018) 16 SCC 661; Associate Builders v. DDA [2014] 13 SCR 895 : (2015) 3 SCC 49; PSA Sical Terminals Private Ltd. v. Board of Trustees of V.O. Chidambranar Port Trust Tuticorin [2021] 5 SCR 408 : (2023) 15 SCC 781– referred to. Grinaker Construction (TVL) Ltd Vs. Transvaal Provincial Administration, 1982 (1) AD 78 – referred to.
List of Acts Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
List of Keywords Dispute Review Board; Arbitral award; Interference with arbitral award; Public policy; Public policy in India; Patent illegality; Bill of quantities; Geogrid; Geotextile; General Conditions of Contract; National Highway; Variation in quantity; Variation in design; Technical experts; Interference with the decision of arbitrator; Execution of contract awarded by National Highways Authority of India; Construction of lanes on National Highway; Arbitration clause; Court of appeal; Interpretation of contractual terms; Opposed to the public policy of India; Patent illegality; Shocking the conscience of the court; Basic notions of justice or morality.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2058 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.11.2009 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in FAO No. 427 of 2007 206 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Arvind Minocha, Sr. Adv., Rakesh Kharab, Mayank Kshirsagar, Ms. Dhanlaxmi Iyer, Advs. for the Appellant.
Krishnan Venungopal, Sr. Adv., Vikas Goel, Abhishek Kumar, Avinash Mathews, Ms. Garima Kaul, Santosh Kumar - I, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2. This civil appeal by special leave is directed against the judgment and order dated 17.11.2009 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi (‘High Court’) in FAO(OS) No. 427 of 2007 [National Highways Authority of India Vs. Som Datt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV)].
2.1. By the aforesaid judgment, the High Court allowed the appeal of the respondent-National Highways Authority of India (‘respondent’ or ‘NHAI’ hereinafter) under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (briefly ‘the 1996 Act’ hereinafter). It may be mentioned that respondent had challenged, by way of the aforesaid appeal, the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge in OMP No. 316/2005 dated 29.08.2007 whereby the learned Single Judge dismissed the application filed by NHAI under Section 34 of the 1996 Act for setting aside the award dated 03.06.2005 passed by the Arbitral Tribunal.
3. The matter relates to execution of a contract awarded by NHAI to the appellant regarding the work of four laning and strengthening of the existing two lane section between Km. 470.000 and Km. 38.000 on NH-2 (construction package II-B) near Kanpur in the State of Uttar Pradesh under World Bank Loan Assistance.
4. At the outset, it would be apposite to advert to the relevant facts.
5. Following a process of open bid tender, the related contract was allotted by NHAI to the appellant vide the contract agreement dated [2025] 2 S.C.R. 207Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
27.03.2002 who undertook to execute the work at the contract price of Rs. 4,961,183,599.00. Appellant is a joint venture of Somdatt Builders Pvt. Ltd., Nagarjuna Construction Company and Navayug Engineering Company Limited having its principal place of business at East of Kailash, New Delhi.
6. A joint venture between Consulting Engineering Services (I) Ltd. and BECA International Consultants Ltd. was appointed by NHAI as the Engineer of the project in terms of the contract agreement to supervise the construction work.
7. It was a unit rate contract comprising of a detailed Bill of Quantities (BOQ). The BOQ contained description of the items of the work to be executed by the appellant as contractor and the estimated quantity of each item. The rates of each BOQ item were to be filled in by the contractor (appellant).
8. The contract agreement provided for a mechanism of dispute resolution at the first instance through a Dispute Review Board (‘DRB’) prior to the parties availing of their remedy by way of arbitration. A three-member panel of DRB was constituted comprising of one member appointed by each of the two parties and the third member appointed by the aforesaid two members.
9. While executing the contract, a dispute arose between the parties in respect of item No. 7.07 of the BOQ which provided for reinforced earth structure including soil reinforcing geogrid with all fixtures and accessories complete as per approved design and drawing of specialised firm and matters connected therewith. The dispute was not really in respect of the nature of the work to be performed but was the consequence of the geogrid/geotextile material exceeding the BOQ quantities in the contract. In essence, the dispute relates to power of the Engineer to revise the rates given in the BOQ in the event of increase in actual quantities. This was contested by the appellant.
10. Appellant raised the aforesaid dispute before the DRB contending that the Engineer/Employer was intending wrongful application of Clause 52.2 of the Conditions of Particular Application (COPA) for downward revision of rates for BOQ item No. 7.07 (ii) of geogrid for quantity in excess of BOQ quantity. DRB heard both the sides and deliberated upon the issue in detail. DRB vide its decision dated 208 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 15.03.2004 recommended that quantities of geogrid required limited to the facia area provided in the BOQ have to be paid as per the BOQ rates.
11. Respondent NHAI was not satisfied with the aforesaid decision of DRB and invoked the arbitration clause in the contract agreement whereafter the dispute was referred to arbitration before an Arbitral Tribunal comprising of three arbitrators: one arbitrator appointed by each of the two parties and the third arbitrator appointed by the two arbitrators so appointed. It is on record that each of the arbitrators were technical experts conversant with the nature of the contract. Arbitral Tribunal, by a majority of 2:1, passed the award dated 03.06.2005. Arbitral Tribunal held that the quantity of geogrid given at the tender stage by NHAI was wrong. Therefore, the increase in quantity was a mere increase to meet the requirement for completion of the RE wall work which was indicated by the RCC facia quantity at the tender stage. There was no change in the design but mere increase in the quantity beyond the BOQ quantity which did not attract Clause 52.2. In this context, Arbitral Tribunal held that the Engineer does not possess the power to revise the rates for additional quantity of geogrid required for actual execution of work as per the approved design. Upholding the recommendations of DRB, Arbitral Tribunal held that variation in terms of Clause 51.1 was not established and directed NHAI to pay the appellant for the actual quantity of geogrid required to be executed to complete the work of RE wall as per the approved design at the BOQ rate.
12. The aforesaid award dated 03.06.2005 was challenged by the respondent-NHAI under Section 34 of the 1996 Act which was heard and decided by a learned Single Judge of the High Court. Learned Single Judge examined the contours of Clauses 51.1, 51.2, 52.1, 52.2, 52.3 and 55.1 and came to the definite conclusion that there was no change in the design. The BOQ rate would apply since the matter was one of mere change in quantity. By the judgment and order dated 29.08.2007, learned Single Judge of the High Court found no merit in the application filed by NHAI under Section 34 of the 1996 Act and dismissed the same.
13. It was thereafter that NHAI as the appellant preferred the appeal before a Division Bench of the High Court under Section 37 of the 1996 Act. The Division Bench examined the primary contention [2025] 2 S.C.R. 209Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
of NHAI that under the contractual terms, all variations in quantity beyond the tolerance limits set out in the contract, whether arising as a result of issuance of instructions by the Engineer or arising even without the issuance of instructions, were open to renegotiation of the rates by the Engineer. By the judgment and order dated 17.11.2009 (‘impugned judgment’), Division Bench agreed with the contention of NHAI and set aside the award of the Arbitral Tribunal as well as the order of the learned Single Judge.
14. Being aggrieved, the contractor (appellant) preferred the related special leave petition. On 14.12.2009, this Court had issued notice and passed an interim order staying encashment of the bank guarantee subject to the appellant renewing it for a period of one year. Vide order dated 10.02.2012, this Court granted leave and directed continuance of the interim order. Hence the civil appeal.
15. Contention of the appellant is that it is NHAI who had provided the wrong quantity in respect of item No. 7.07 of the BOQ on the basis of which appellant had tendered. Upon approval of the design by the Engineer when the increased quantity became known in April, 2003, the Engineer held that BOQ rate would be payable for the entire quantity which was not acceptable to NHAI. The increase in quantity was not as a result of any change in the design or as a result of any instructions given by the Engineer. The enhancement in the quantity was necessitated because wrong information was furnished by the respondent at the stage of tender itself. On dispute being raised, this position was accepted by the DRB and thereafter by the Arbitral Tribunal. Application filed by the respondent under Section 34 of the 1996 Act for setting aside of the arbitral award was rightly rejected by the learned Single Judge of the High Court. Division Bench of the High Court fell in error and committed a manifest mistake in overturning the technical findings of the three authorities below while exercising limited jurisdiction under Section 37 of the 1996 Act.
16. Counter affidavit has been filed by respondent NHAI. Reliance has been placed on Clauses 51 and 52 of COPA. Clause 51 of COPA has two parts: 51.1 and 51.2. Clause 51.1 covers instructed variations which includes any increase or decrease in the quantity of work. As per Clause 51.2, for increase or decrease in quantity of any material, instructions of the Engineer are not required. A combined reading 210 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of Clauses 51.1 and 51.2 would indicate that though increase or decrease in the quantity of any work may be without instructions but it nonetheless remains a variation. Once it is a variation, Engineer has got the power to fix a new rate. This power is traceable to Clause 52.1, which does not make any distinction between instructed variation or uninstructed variation; on the other hand, it provides that all variations referred to in Clause 51 are to be valued by the Engineer. In case of instructed variation only, notice is required to be given in terms of the second proviso to Clause 52.2. If this be the position, view taken by the Division Bench of the High Court is the correct one and calls for no interference.
17. Mr. Arvind Minocha, learned senior counsel for the appellant, at the outset submits that the core issue involved in this appeal is the justification or otherwise of the decision of the Division Bench of the High Court upsetting concurrent findings of three authorities while exercising jurisdiction under Section 37 of the 1996 Act. He submits that the dispute raised by the appellant was decided in its favour by the DRB comprising wholly of technical experts. Arbitral Tribunal again comprising of technical persons passed the award in favour of the appellant by confirming the decision of the DRB. When the respondent filed application under Section 34 of the 1996 Act for setting aside of the award, learned Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the same and affirmed the award passed by the Arbitral Tribunal.
17.1. Learned senior counsel submits that scope of interference by the appellate court under Section 37 of the 1996 Act is extremely limited. None of the grounds for invocation of jurisdiction under Section 37 of the 1996 Act were satisfied. Learned Single Judge while exercising jurisdiction under Section 34 of the 1996 Act had repelled the challenge of the respondent to the arbitral award. View taken by the learned Single Judge is a plausible view, if not the only possible view. Therefore, Division Bench committed a manifest error in setting aside the arbitral award as well as the order passed by the learned Single Judge affirming the same.
17.2. Adverting to the facts of the case, learned senior counsel submits that the scope of the contract involved construction of 50 Kms. of road, service roads on both sides, drains, [2025] 2 S.C.R. 211Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
17 main bridges, 65 culverts and 20 under-passes. The 51 Kms. stretch of road included raised carriageway of about 22 Kms. having Reinforced Concrete wall (RCC wall) on both sides for 9.5 Kms. and Reinforced Earth wall (RE wall) for about 12 Kms. with concrete facia panels. After the award of work, the design of the wall was to be done by the appellant based on the design criteria given in the contract with the approval of the Engineer appointed by the respondent. The item RE wall is mentioned at item No. 7.07 in the BOQ having three sub-items:
(i) RCC facia wall on both sides,
(ii) filter media,
(iii) geogrid.
17.3. He submits that dispute in the present matter relates to the subitem geogrid as the respondent had given a wrong estimate of the quantity in respect of geogrid while correct quantities were given for the other two sub-items. This mistake was detected when the design was prepared by the appellant and approved by the Engineer. When the quantity of material in respect of geogrid increased, the Engineer decided that the BOQ rate would be applicable for the increased quantity of geogrid.
17.4. After the appellant commenced the work, the respondent was making the monthly payment for the said item as per the BOQ rate. After a new Engineer was appointed by the respondent, it was decided that the rate for the increased quantity of geogrid should be renegotiated.
17.5. Thereafter, the matter was referred by the appellant to the DRB which decided in favour of the appellant. DRB held that variation in terms of Clause 51.1 was not established and recommended payment of geogrid at the BOQ rate for the entire quantity.
17.6. Respondent did not accept the above recommendations of the DRB and invoked the arbitration clause in the contract. Arbitral Tribunal, comprised wholly of technical persons, by a majority of 2:1 held that increase in the quantity of geogrid for erection of the RE wall as per the approved design could 212 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports not be termed as a variation in terms of Clause 51.1. Further holding that the Engineer did not have the power to revise the rate qua the BOQ rate for the additional quantity of geogrid required for execution of the work as per the approved design, Arbitral Tribunal directed payment as per the BOQ rate for the additional quantity.
17.7. In the application filed by the respondent under section 34 of the 1996 Act for setting aside of the arbitral award, the challenge centred around Clauses 51 and 52 only. Learned Single Judge rejected the challenge of the respondent and upheld the arbitral award. After the award was confirmed by the learned Single Judge under Section 34 of the 1996 Act, the Division Bench acting as the appellate court was not at all justified to overturn the concurrent findings of three adjudicating fora while exercising extremely limited jurisdiction under Section 37 of the 1996 Act.
17.8. He further submits that the interpretation given by the Division Bench is not only contrary to Clause 51.1 and the proviso to Clause 52.2 but renders those provisions completely otiose. Division Bench misdirected itself by stretching the meaning of the word variation by referring to dictionary meanings whereas the said expression has to be understood in the context of the relevant clauses of the contract. Division Bench failed to appreciate that in so far automatic increase in the quantity is concerned, the rate which is payable is the one as agreed in the BOQ. If any other rate is to be fixed, the same can be considered only in case of instructed variation provided 14 days prior notice before commencement of the work is given which was admittedly not done in the present case. In this connection he places reliance on a Delhi High Court judgment in the case of NHAI vs. M/s ITD Cementation India Limited. 1
17.9. On the limited scope of interference under Section 37 of the 1996 Act, learned senior counsel for the appellant has placed reliance on the following decisions:
1 (2009) 113 DRJ 176
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 213Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
(i) S.V. Samudram Vs. State of Karnataka,2
(ii) M/s. Hindustan Construction Company Ltd. Vs. M/s NHAI 3
(iii) Reliance Infrastructure Ltd. Vs. State of Goa 4
(iv) Konkan Railway Corporation Limited Vs. Chenab Bridge Project Undertaking 5
(v) M/s Larsen Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Company Vs Union of India 6
(vi) MMTC Ltd. Vs. Vedanta Limited 7
(vii) MP Power Generation Company Ltd. Vs. Ansaldo Energia
SPA8
18. Per contra, Mr. Krishnan Venugopal, learned senior counsel appearing for NHAI submits that Division Bench of the High Court has rightly set aside the arbitral award finding the same to be perverse.
18.1. He submits that the core issue involved in the present appeal is whether the arbitral award dated 03.06.2005 goes contrary to the only interpretation of Clauses 51 and 52 of the General Conditions of Contract (GCC) read with COPA as contained in the contract dated 27.03.2002 executed between the parties.
18.2. Learned senior counsel submits that subject matter of the dispute relates to BOQ item No. 7.07 (II) i.e. geogrid. Due to change in design of the RE wall, quantity of geogrid increased almost by 300 percent during execution. Since the twin conditions contemplated under Clause 52.2 were being fulfilled i.e. overall quantity of geogrid executed by more than 25 percent from the estimated quantity and the cost of geogrid being more than 2 percent of the contract value, the rate for the additional quantity of geogrid was required to be reworked. Therefore, the present case is that of instructed 2 [2024] 1 SCR 281 : (2024) 3 SCC 623 3 [2023] 11 SCR 623 : (2024) 2 SCC 613 4 [2023] 8 SCR 379 : (2024) 1 SCC 479 5 [2023] 11 SCR 215 : (2023) 9 SCC 85 6 [2023] 11 SCR 86 : 2023 INSC 708 7 [2019] 3 SCR 1023 : (2019) 4 SCC 163
8 (2018) 16 SCC 661
214 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports variation under Clause 51.1(a) for which the appellant was also notified on 28.10.2003 fulfilling the requirement of 14 days’ notice contained in Clause 52.2.
18.3. Referring to the arbitral award, Mr. Venugopal submits that contrary to the evidence on record and contrary to the relevant clauses of the contract, Arbitral Tribunal held that it was not a case of instructions issued by the Engineer but a case of automatic increase of quantity. Referring to Clause 51.1(a), he submits that increase or decrease in quantity is also a variation and as per Clause 51.2, no instructions are required for such increase or decrease of quantity though the same continues to be a variation.
18.4. Even assuming but not admitting that the Engineer did not issue any notice to the appellant then also, according to Mr. Venugopal, a bare reading of Clause 52.2 would make it apparent that for a non-instructed variation, the condition of giving 14 days’ notice would not apply.
18.5. Learned senior counsel also submits that the contention of the appellant that the quantity of geogrid had increased due to negligence and wrong mentioning of figures by the respondent is totally fallacious in as much as Clause 55.1 of the contract clarifies that the quantity set out in the contract are the estimated quantities only.
18.6. He would therefore contend that this is not a case of plausible interpretation but a case of adopting an interpretation which is contrary to the only possible interpretation of the contractual clauses. Arbitral Tribunal has rewritten the contract by ignoring the plain and simple language of the relevant clauses and the parties’ intentions besides overlooking the evidence on record which is legally impermissible. All these aspects were raised by the respondent in its application under Section 34 of the 1996 Act but the learned Single Judge failed to consider the same by placing reliance on a South African judgment which is clearly distinguishable in the facts of the present case. Therefore, Division Bench of the High Court acting as the appellate court under Section 37 of the 1996 Act rightly interfered in the matter by setting aside the arbitral award.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 215Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
18.7. Learned senior counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions to buttress his submissions:
(i) Associate Builders Vs. DDA 9
(ii) Ssangyong Engineer and Construction Company Ltd.
Vs. NHAI 10
(iii) PSA Sical Terminals Private Ltd. Vs. Board of Trustees of V.O. Chidambranar Port Trust Tuticorin 11
18.8. Learned senior counsel further submits that the judgment in the case of NHAI Vs. M/s ITD Cementation India Limited, cited and relied upon by the appellant, is not applicable to the facts of the present case. Firstly, the judgment is by a Single Bench whereas the impugned order has been passed by a Division Bench which is also later in point of time. Secondly, the said judgment does not deal with the power of the Engineer to fix a new rate in terms of Clause 52.
18.9. He finally submits that the present appeal is devoid of any merit and the same is therefore liable to be dismissed by this Court.
19. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the court.
20. At the outset, it would be relevant to advert to Clauses 51 and 52 of the GCC read with COPA. Clauses 51 and 52 are as under: Alteration, Additions and Omissions 51.1 Variations (GCC)
The Engineer shall make any variation of the form, quality or quantity of works or any part thereof that may, in his opinion, be necessary and for the purpose, or if for any other reason it shall, in his opinion, be appropriate, he shall have the authority to instruct the Contractor to do and the Contractor shall do any of the following:-
(a) increase or decrease the quantity of any work included in the Contract.
9 [2014] 13 SCR 895 : (2015) 3 SCC 49 10 [2019] 7 SCR 522 : (2019) 15 SCC 131 11 [2021] 5 SCR 408 : (2023) 15 SCC 781 216 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(b) omit any such work (but not if the omitted work is to be carried out by the Employer or by another contractor),
(c) change the character or quality or kind of any such work,
(d) change the levels, lines, position and dimensions of any part of the works,
(e) execute additional work of any kind necessary for the completion of the works, or
(f) change any specified sequence or timing of construction of any part of the works.
No such variation shall in any way vitiate or invalidate the Contract, but the effect, if any, of all such variations shall be valued in accordance with Clause 52.
Provided that where the issue of an instruction to vary the works is necessitated by some default of or breach of contract by the Contractor or for which he is responsible, any additional cost attributable to such default shall be borne by the Contractor.
51.2 Instructions for Variations (GCC)
The Contractor shall not make any such variation without an instruction of the Engineer.
Provided that no instruction shall be required for increase or decrease in the quantity of any work where such increase or decrease is not the result of an instruction given under this Clause, but is the result of the quantities exceeding or being less than those stated in the Bill of Quantities. 52.1 Valuation of Variations (GCC)
All variations referred to in Clause 51 and any additions to be Contract Price which are required to be determined in accordance with Clause 52 (for the purposes of this Clause referred to as “varied work”), shall be valued at the rates and prices set out in the Contract if, in the opinion of the Engineer, the same shall be applicable. If the contract does not contain any rates or prices applicable to the varied work, the rates and prices in the Contract shall be used [2025] 2 S.C.R. 217Somdatt Builders-NCC-NEC(JV) v.
National Highways Authority of India & Ors.
as the basis for valuation so far as may be reasonable, failing which, after due consultation by the Engineer with the Employer and the Contractor, suitable rates or prices shall be agreed upon between the Engineer and the Contractor. In the event of disagreement, the Engineer shall fix such rates or prices as are, in his opinion, appropriate and shall notify the Contractor accordingly, with a copy to the Employer. Until such time as rates or prices are agreed or fixed, the Engineer shall determine provisional rates or prices to enable on-account payments to be included in certificates issued in accordance with Clause 60.
(COPA)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.