Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Bcl Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1401; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 455
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 9 Dec 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14647/2025
- Sections
- 11(4), 9, 21, 11, 16, 7, 37, 8
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 455 : 2025 INSC 1401 Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
v.
BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 14647 of 2025)
09 December 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and K.V. Viswanathan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the High Court, was justified in referring the parties to arbitration by allowing the petition u/s.11(4) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
Headnotes† Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Appointment of arbitrators – Appellant-Corporation floated a tender and issued a purchase order in favour of the contractor-successful tenderer – Tender prohibited sub-letting, sub-contracting without the prior consent of the owner obtained in writing – Appellant issued notice to the contractor with regard to non-functioning and unsatisfactory performance – Later, the respondent informed the appellant that they were working as sub-vendor of the contractor and were entitled to receive 94% of the payment due – Appellant informed respondent that the appellant had not entered into any contract with the respondent and as such no payments due to the respondent from the appellant – Thereafter, series of proceedings between them – Respondent issued notice to the appellant invoking arbitration – Resolution of disputes between the respondent and the contractor, Settlement-cum-Assignment Agreement signed, to assign the receivables of contractor against the appellant to the respondent – Respondent then raised claim which was denied by the appellant – Respondent filed petition u/s.11(4) – High Court allowed application and appointed an arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes and differences between the parties – Justification:
Held: Referral court should be prima facie satisfied that there exists an arbitration agreement and as to whether the non-signatory is a veritable party – Even if the referral court prima facie arrives at the * Author 456 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports satisfaction that the non- signatory is a veritable party, the arbitral tribunal is not denuded of its jurisdiction to decide whether the nonsignatory is indeed a party to the arbitration agreement on the basis of factual evidence and application of legal doctrine – Appellant has no privity at all with the respondent – To the documentation between the contractor and the respondent, the appellant was not a party – Appellant and the respondent have been operating on separate orbits – Not been established even prima facie that there was any intention to bind respondent to the contract between appellant and contractor – Respondent not shown any consent for assignment as required under the clause of the tender document – Nothing even prima facie shown to establish that there was any semblance of an intent to effect legal relationship between the respondent and the party originally granting the contract and/or to indicate that the respondent was a veritable party – Applying the consensual theory or the non-consensual theory, the respondent not established its case to show even prima facie the existence of an arbitration agreement between appellant and the respondent – Settlement-cum-Assignment Agreement between contractor and respondent have been perused and under the clause, the contractor has represented and warranted that any amount/receivables accruing to the contractor as a result of litigation/proceeding initiated by respondent against the appellant was to be transferred to respondent – This does not mean that there is an arbitration agreement existing between the appellant and respondent or that respondent was a veritable party to the agreement between appellant and contractor – Respondent fails the prima facie test of being a veritable party to the arbitration agreement between the appellant and the contractor – Non-existence of an arbitration agreement between the parties – Thus, the judgment and order passed by the High Court set aside. [Paras 24, 30-32, 36, 38, 40, 42, 43] Case Law Cited Cox and Kings Limited v. Sap India Private Limited and Another [2023] 15 SCR 621 : (2024) 4 SCC 1; In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements under Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 & Stamp Act, 1899 [2023] 15 SCR 1081 : (2024) 6 SCC 1; SBI General Insurance Company Limited v. Krish Spinning [2024] 7 SCR 840 : (2024) 12 SCC 1; Ajay Madhusudan Patel and Others v. Jyotrindra S. Patel and Others [2024] 9 SCR 894 : [2025] 12 S.C.R. 457Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
(2025) 2 SCC 147; ASF Buildtech Private Limited v. Shapoorji Pallonji and Company Private Limited (2025) 9 SCC 76; Khardah Company Limited v. Raymon & Co., 1962 INSC 202 : [1963] 3 SCR 183 – referred to.
Pravin Electricals Private Limited v. Galaxy Infra & Engineering Private Limited [2021] 1 SCR 1162 : (2021) 5 SCC 671; Cox & Kings Ltd. (2) v. SAP (India) Pvt. Ltd. [2024] 9 SCR 199 : (2025) 1 SCC 611 – held inapplicable.
Books and Periodicals Cited Illustrated Oxford Dictionary (Revised Edition 2003) – referred to. List of Acts Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
List of Keywords Referring the parties to arbitration; Appointment of arbitrator; Purchase order; Tender; Prohibited sub-letting, sub-contracting without prior consent of owner; Resolution of disputes; Settlementcum-Assignment Agreement; Assign receivables of contractor; Referral court; Arbitration agreement; Non-signatory; Veritable party; Consensual theory; Non-consensual theory.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 14647 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 07.04.2025 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in CAA No. 125 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant(s):
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Sanjay Kapur, Surya Prakash, Ms. Shubhra Kapur, Ms. Mansi Kapur, Abhishek Tiwari.
Advs. for the Respondent(s):
Nalin Kohli, Ms. Aarushi Yadav, Sr. Advs., Chirag Madan, Ravleen Sabharwal, G. Sai Krishna Kumar, Rahul Agarwal, Ronit Bose, Ms. Nimisha Menon, Ayuushman Arora, Randeep Sabharwal, Vijay Pal, Deepankar, Anubhav.
458 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The present appeal calls in question the correctness of the judgment and order dated 07.04.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Comm. Arbitration Application No.125/2025. By the said order, the learned Single Judge allowed the Section 11(4)-Application filed under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short the “A&C Act) of the respondent-BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the “BCL”) and appointed an arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes and differences between the parties herein. Aggrieved, the appellant-Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (for short ‘Corporation’) is in appeal.
3. The facts giving rise to the appeal are as follows:
4. The appellant-Corporation floated a tender for design, supply, installation, integration, testing, commissioning and post-commissioning warranty support services of Tank Truck Locking System (for short the “TTLS”).
5. The tender conditions had a specific clause stating that the contractor shall not be entitled to sublet, transfer or assign, the work under the contract without the prior consent of the owner obtained in writing. The relevant clauses of the tender conditions are set out hereinbelow:- “2.6 The “Contract” between the Owner and the Contractor shall mean and include all documents like enquiry, tender submitted by the contractor and the purchase order issued by the owner and other documents connected with the issue of the purchase order and orders, instruction, drawings, change orders, directions issued by the Owner/Engineerin-Charge/Site-in-Charge for the execution, completion and commissioning of the works and the period of contract mentioned in the Contract including such periods of time extensions as may be granted by the owner at the request of the contractor and such period of time for which the work is continued by the contractor for purposes of completion of the work.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 459Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
3.17 Contractor shall not be entitled to sublet, subcontract or assign; the work under this Contract without the prior consent of the Owner obtained in writing.
5.c SUBLETTING OF WORK 5.c.1 No part of the contract nor any share or interest thereof shall in any manner or degree be transferred, assigned or sublet, by the Contractor, directly or indirectly to any firm or corporation whatsoever without the prior consent in writing of the Owner.
14. ARBITRATION
14.1 All disputes and differences of whatsoever nature, whether existing or which shall at any time arise between the parties hereto touching or concerning the agreement, meaning, operation or effect thereof or to the rights and liabilities of the parties or arising out of or in relation thereto whether during or after completion of the contract or whether before after determination, foreclosure, termination or breach of the agreement (other than those in respect of which the decision of any person is, by the contract, expressed to be final and binding) shall, after written notice by either party to the agreement to the other of them and to the Appointing Authority hereinafter mentioned, be referred for adjudication to the Sole Arbitrator to be appointed as hereinafter provided.
14.9 Subject to the aforesaid, the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 or any statutory modification or re-enactment thereof and the rules made thereunder, shall apply to the Arbitration proceedings under this Clause.
14.10 The Contract shall be governed by and constructed according to the laws in force in India. The parties hereby submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Courts situated at Mumbai for all purposes. The Arbitration shall be held at Mumbai and conducted in English language.”
6. On 20.08.2013, the appellant issued a purchase order in favour of the successful tenderer-M/s AGC Networks Ltd (for short “AGC”) 460 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports (presently known as Black Box Limited) and AGC duly accepted the purchase order by a letter of acceptance on 21/22.08.2013. On 08.09.2016, the appellant issued a notice to AGC with regard to nonfunctioning of Electro Magnetic Locking System [for short ‘EMLS’] at Pilot locations of Vashi and Manmad. Further, on 02.02.2017, the appellant issued a show cause notice to AGC for unsatisfactory performance of EMLS at the said two locations.
7. On 14.06.2018, the respondent-BCL informed the appellant that they were working as sub-vendor of AGC and were entitled to receive 94% of the payment due. On 25.06.2018, appellant informed AGC that since it could not complete the project successfully, no payment was due to them. On 26.06.2018, appellant informed respondent-BCL in reply to BCL’s letter dated 14.06.2018 stating that the appellant had not entered into any contract with BCL and as such no payments are due to BCL from the appellant. Thereafter, a series of proceedings ensued between the respondent-BCL and the AGC.
8. On 27.07.2018, a civil suit came to be filed by BCL against AGC before Patiala House Court at New Delhi seeking injunction against AGC from invoking the bank guarantee submitted by BCL. The appellant was not a party to this suit. Thereafter, a Section 9-Petition under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 was filed by BCL against AGC. The Section 9-Petition came to be rejected on 17.07.2019.
9. In 2020, BCL filed its first claim (No. 1446/2020) with the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) Facilitation Council, Haryana against AGC for the payment of outstanding dues. The matter was referred to arbitration and here again the appellant was not a party. On 20.06.2020, the respondent BCL withdrew the claim from the Arbitral Tribunal in view of the amicable settlement with AGC. On 17.07.2020, respondent-BCL withdrew the civil suit filed against AGC.
10. In 2021, respondent-BCL filed its second claim (No. 2411/2021) against AGC with the MSME Facilitation Council. The matter was referred to arbitration and here again the appellant was not a party.
11. On 25.11.2022, the second claim was rejected by the arbitrator as not maintainable due to relinquishment of rights by BCL under the 20.06.2020 settlement.
12. On 25.03.2023, third claim was filed against AGC by BCL in MSME Facilitation Council, Haryana and this was rejected as not maintainable.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 461Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
13. On 28.08.2024, respondent-BCL issued a notice to the appellant invoking arbitration under Section 21 of the A&C Act, setting out the following:- A. After AGC was awarded a purchase order, AGC entered into an agreement dated 15.01.2014 on back-to-back basis with BCL wherein entire performance concerning the supply of TTLS was to be undertaken by BCL.
B. That as per the said contractual arrangement of 15.01.2014, BCL was obligated to perform the services and AGC was merely an intermediary since 96% of the total amount payable by HPCL was accruing in favour of BCL. The relevant clauses of the contractual arrangement between BCL and AGC are set out hereinbelow:- “And whereas “AGC” wishes to engage “BCL”
and “BCL” has agreed to supply install integrate test commission and warranty and post-warranty support services of HPCL TTLS (Tank Truck Locking System) to “AGC” on a back-to-back basis and more specifically described in the referred Tender as per Annexure - I forming an integral part of this Agreement BCL has reviewed all the annexures, fully understood HPCL’s requirement and has agreed to bear all costs take full responsibility and to Indemnify AGC in case of this Pilot Project not being successful and resultant cancellation of contract by HPCL.
4. OBLIGATIONS OF “BCL”
4.1 “BCL” shall provide a Project Manager at its own cost and towards the successful completion of the entire HPCL TTLS project The Project Manager shall be responsible for the communication and co-ordination between BCL/AGC/HPCL. However, the Project Manager mentioned herein above shall not make any such communication/co-ordination with HPCL without obtaining the prior written approval from AGC.”
462 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11. ARBITRATION
Any and all dispute(s) or difference(s) between the parties hereto arising out of or relating to this agreement and which is not amicably settled between the parties within 60 (Sixty) days from the date of such dispute or difference, the same shall be referred for arbitration to such person as may be appointed by the parties hereto and the same shall be adjudicated in accordance with the Arbitration and Re-Conciliation Act 1996 and its latest amendments.
The cost of any such Arbitration shall be solely borne by the defending party. The place of arbitration shall be jurisdiction of New Delhi/Mumbai Court. The language of the arbitration shall be English. Award of Arbitration shall be final and binding on both the parties.”
(Emphasis supplied)
C. That after the resolution of disputes between BCL and AGC, a Settlement-cum-Assignment Agreement was signed by AGC and BCL on 31.10.2023, to assign the receivables of AGC against HPCL to BCL. Relevant clauses read as under: - “2. ASSIGNMENT OF RECEIVABLES 2.1 The present Agreement further records the existing position that all claims and counter-claims of Parties against each other have been settled, relinquished, closed and Parties are discharged against each other for all future claims and liabilities. However, it is understood that BCL may be desirous of proceeding against HPCL. by filing the necessary application/petition before the competent authority or court for recovery of purported dues arising out of the HPCL PO. It is however agreed by BCL that, Black Box shall not be impleaded or joined as a party to any such legal action or litigation/proceedings that may be initiated by BCL and such actions of BCL shall not result in any adverse action or cause any prejudice to Black Box.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 463Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
2.2 Subject to compliance of the reciprocal obligations under this Agreement by the BCL Black Box hereby represents and warrants that any amount/receivables accruing to Black Box as a result of the litigation/ proceedings initiated by BCL against HPCL shall stand transferred/assigned to, BCL in entirety. Black Box shall not retain any amount/receivable that may accrue to it in terms of the order/direction of the competent authority or court in any such litigation/ proceedings initiated against HPCL.
3.20 GOVERNING LAW, DISPUTE RESOLUTION
AND JURISDICTION:
This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of India and shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the competent courts in New Delhi only.
Both Parties agree that all disputes and/or differences arising out of or relating to or under this Agreement between the Parties shall, unless amicably resolved within 30 days of mutual discussions, be finally settled by reference to arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 read with its subsequent amendments and the Rules framed thereunder. The Arbitration shall be conducted at New Delhi. The Arbitration proceedings shall be conducted in English language. The decision of the arbitral tribunal shall be binding on the Parties.”
D. That BCL has entered into the position of AGC and can agitate all pending claims with the appellant and a claim was raised to the tune of Rs. 3,00,01,810/- along with 18% interest.
14. The Arbitration Clause for Indian Bidders issued in the tender of the appellant was invoked vide legal notice dated 28.08.2024.
15. On 26.09.2024, appellant sent a reply denying the contentions made by BCL setting out the following grounds:- A. There was no privity of contract between the appellant and BCL. 464 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports B. The claim amount and assignment agreement were unfounded, false and denied.
C. That the purported assignment agreement was not valid in law as no prior written consent was obtained from HPCL by AGC. D. There was no valid purchase order between HPCL and BCL.
16. BCL issued another notice dated 12.11.2024 and followed it up with a petition under Section 11(4) of the A&C Act before the High Court of Judicature at Bombay dated 28.02.2025. The appellant-Corporation objected by raising all the contentions set out in their reply along with the additional contention that the application was time-barred.
17. By the judgment dated 07.04.2025, the High Court allowed the Section 11-Application with the following reasoning:- “3. This to my mind raises a clear capacity for the Respondent to file an application under Section 16 of the Act, whereby the arbitral tribunal should decide the arbitrability of the disputes. In the peculiar facts of this case, while allowing this Section 11 Application by making a reference to the arbitral tribunal, it is directed that the arbitrability of the disputes should be decided as preliminary issue upfront by the arbitral tribunal, so that the interests of the parties are well balanced and protected and unnecessary time is not wasted, should the arbitral tribunal reach a conclusion that the arbitration agreement would not bind the Respondent with the assignee of AGC Networks Limited.
4. Being satisfied that an arbitration agreement is in existence but taking into account the objection raised by the Respondent that the Respondent had a right to approve the counter-party prior to the assignment of rights of the Applicant, this aforesaid request to the Arbitral Tribunal, asking for the Section 16 Application to be decided first as a preliminary issue is being made.”
18. Aggrieved, the appellant-Corporation is before us.
19. We have heard Mr. Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General and Mr. Sanjay Kapur, learned counsel for the appellant. We have also heard Mr. Nalin Kohli, learned senior counsel for the respondent. We have perused the records.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 465Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
CONTENTIONS OF THE APPELLANT:-
20. Mr. Tushar Mehta, the learned Solicitor General, appearing for the appellant contends that there is no legal relationship between the appellant and the respondent inasmuch as there was no privity of contract between them. Learned Solicitor General contends that, at no stage, BCL was ever involved either in the preliminary negotiation or at the execution stage. It is further contended that there is no material/document which discloses that the appellant had the knowledge of BCL participating in the performance of the underlying contract. Learned Solicitor General contended that the respondent had entered into series of litigation with AGC, and the court below had not made any reference to it in the impugned order. Learned Solicitor General contends that the claim was also ex facie timebarred and it is manifest from the record. Learned Solicitor General contends that at the Section 11 stage that the court has an obligation to prima facie examine whether the dispute is arbitrable and even applying that limited test, the records reveal that the dispute was not arbitrable. Learned Solicitor General extensively relied on Clauses 3.17 and 5 of the General Terms and Conditions of Works Contract to contend that there was express prohibition to sub-let, sub-contract or assign the work or any share of interest thereof without the prior consent of the owner obtained in writing.
21. Refuting the submissions, Mr. Nalin Kohli, learned Senior Advocate, appearing for the respondent contended that the test whether a non-signatory would be bound by an arbitration agreement entails a fact-intensive inquiry involving a mixed question of fact and law and, therefore, the arbitral tribunal would be the more appropriate forum to carry out the said inquiry. Mr. Kohli, learned Senior Advocate, further contends that the appellant had knowledge of the sub-letting agreement between the respondent and AGC, presently known as Black Box Limited. Mr. Kohli, learned Senior Advocate, referred to the agreement signed between the respondent and the AGC dated 15.01.2014; the purchase orders issued to the respondent by AGC, the escrow account opened by AGC; the monies transferred to the escrow account by the appellant. Mr. Kohli also referred to certain email communications, copies of which are marked to the appellant. Mr. Kohli further referred to the Settlement-cum-Assignment Agreement dated 31.10.2023 assigning the right to receivables and 466 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports AGC giving up its rights and invoked the veritable party doctrine to sustain the impugned order. Mr. Kohli, learned Senior Advocate, prayed for the dismissal of the appeal.
22. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the records of the case.
QUESTION FOR CONSIDERATION: -
23. The question that arises for consideration is whether the High Court, on facts, was justified in referring the parties to arbitration by allowing the Section 11(4) petition filed by the respondent?
24. The scope of jurisdiction of the referral court hearing a Section 11-Petition when faced with an issue of joinder of a non-signatory to the arbitration agreement has been lucidly set out by the five-judge Bench of this Court in Cox and Kings Limited vs. Sap India Private Limited and Another1 . Though said in the context of considering the Group of Companies doctrine, the said judgment has a great bearing for the present case. This Court, speaking through Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, held as under:- “84. It is presumed that the formal signatories to an arbitration agreement are parties who will be bound by it. However, in exceptional cases persons or entities who have not signed or formally assented to a written arbitration agreement or the underlying contract containing the arbitration agreement may be held to be bound by such agreement. As mentioned in the preceding paragraphs, the doctrine of privity limits the imposition of rights and liabilities on third parties to a contract. Generally, only the parties to an arbitration agreement can be subject to the full effects of the agreement in terms of the reliefs and remedies because they consented to be bound by the arbitration agreement. Therefore, the decisive question before the Courts or tribunals is whether a non-signatory consented to be bound by the arbitration agreement.
To determine whether a non-signatory is bound by an arbitration agreement, the Courts and tribunals apply
1 (2024) 4 SCC 1
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 467Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. BCL Secure Premises Pvt. Ltd.
typical principles of contract law and corporate law. The legal doctrines provide a framework for evaluating the specific contractual language and the factual settings to determine the intentions of the parties to be bound by the arbitration agreement. [Gary Born, International Arbitration Law and Practice, (3rd Edn., 2021) at p. 1531.]
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.