Manoj Rameshlal Chhabriya v. Mahesh Prakash Ahuja & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 282; [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1433
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 27 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1048/2017
- Sections
- 378(3), 378, 372, 106, 27
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 2 S.C.R. 1433 : 2025 INSC 282 Manoj Rameshlal Chhabriya v.
Mahesh Prakash Ahuja & Anr.
(Criminal Appeal No. 1048 of 2017)
27 February 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration What are the parameters that a High Court should keep in mind while granting or refusing a leave to appeal filed under Section 378(3) of the Cr.P.C.
Headnotes† Criminal Law – Section 378(3) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Leave to appeal against acquittal order:
Held: High Court should primarily see whether prima facie case is made out based on the materials on record while considering application for grant of leave under sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the Cr.P.C and thereafter should adjudicate the appeal on merits. [Paras 12-13] High Court to apply judicial mind to discern whether arguable points have been raised – No reappreciation of evidence to be done at the stage of Section 378(3) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973:
Held: Court relied on State of Maharashtra v. Sujay Mangesh Poyarekar (2008) 9 SCC 475 wherein it was held that while it cannot be said that all applications seeking grant of appeal must be allowed, the High Court also does not reappreciate the evidence at this stage to ascertain whether the judgment appealed against is perverse or not – It was further held that in cases where leave is refused, High Court must consider all materials on record including witness testimonies and pass a reasoned order reflecting application of mind by High Court so that its order is free from any illegality – At the same time if materials on record reveal any need for reappreciation of evidence to decipher viability of the order sought to be challenged, leave must be granted and appeal must be heard on merits. [Para 7] 1434 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Right to appeal – Life and liberty – Human fallibility: Held: Court relied on Sita Ram v. State of U.P. (1979) 2 SCC 656 which held that at least one right to appeal is imperative so that the guarantee of life and liberty is ensured because humans, including judges, are not infallible – It also held that such a right of appeal ensures that before any irreversible deprivation of life or liberty is done, a given case is relooked into both factually and legally to ensure fairness.
Case Law Cited State of Maharashtra v. Sujay Mangesh Poyarekar [2008] 13 SCR 750 : (2008) 9 SCC 475; Sita Ram v. State of U.P. [1979] 2 SCR 1085 : (1979) 2 SCC 656 – relied on.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 List of Keywords Section 378(3) CrPC; Leave to appeal; Appeal against acquittal order; Circumstantial evidence; Prima facie case; Perverse; Universal application; Application of mind; Relevant material; Speaking order; Reappreciation of evidence; Life and liberty; Human infallibility; Remand; Section 372 CrPC.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 1048 of 2017 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.08.2013 of the High Court of Bombay in CRLA No. 207 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Gaurav Agrawal, Sr. Adv., C. George Thomas, Ms. Kaarunya Lakshmi, Nakul Patwardhan, Ansh Mittal.
Advs. for the Respondents:
R. Basant, Sanjay Kharde, Sr. Advs., Satyajit A. Desai, Pravin V. Khandare, Shubham Singh, Siddharth Gautam, Abhinav K. [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1435Manoj Rameshlal Chhabriya v. Mahesh Prakash Ahuja & Anr. Mutyalwar, Sachin Singh, Ananya Thapliyal, Naman Vashishtha, Akash Rajeev, Ms. Anagha S. Desai, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. This appeal is at the instance of the original first informant brother of the deceased, seeking to challenge the order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in Criminal Application No.207 of 2013, dated 22nd of August 2013, by which the High Court in an appeal filed by the State against the judgment and order of acquittal, declined to grant leave under sub-section (3) of Section 378 of the Criminal Procedure Code (hereinafter referred to as, “Cr.P.C.”).
2. We are conscious of the fact that the acquittal appeal was at the instance of the State. As leave came to be declined, the State could have come before us by way of an appeal. However, the State has though fit not to question the order passed by the High Court, declining to grant leave and in such circumstances, it is the brother of the deceased (original first informant) who has thought fit to question the order passed by the High Court.
3. It appears from the materials on record that the respondent no.1 herein, was put to trial in the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Kalyan in Sessions Case No.132 of 2011 on the charge of having committed murder of his wife i.e. the deceased. It is the case of the prosecution that on the date of the incident i.e., 02.04.2011 India was playing World Cup final against Sri Lanka in Mumbai. After India won the match and the World Cup, the respondent accused started celebrating by firing shots in the air from his licensed pistol. Later, he is alleged to have fired a shot at his wife. The wife succumbed to the firearm injuries. Their fifteen years old son was an eyewitness to the incident.
4. The Trial Court acquitted the respondent no.1 of the charge of murder. The State preferred acquittal appeal before the High Court. The High Court thought fit, not to grant leave to appeal. The High Court has observed thus:- “6. PW.3 - Umesh (son of the deceased), the sole witness with regard to the last seen, was declared hostile as he 1436 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports did not support the prosecution case. PW.3 - Umesh has in his evidence stated, that he was informed by his mother and sister, that the Respondent/accused had gone out of station for show room work, since the morning of 2 nd April, 2011. The said witness has denied the portions marked “A to C” i.e. portion ‘A’ “after India winning the Cricket match, my father took out pistol from the cupboard, put bullets in it, fired in air by going down stairs”; portion ‘B’ i.e. “my father accused Mahesh again came to house and started watching Awards Programme on T.V.; portion ‘C’, i.e. ”that there was quarrel between my mother and father in the bed room, after some time heard noise of firing bullet and my father came from the bedroom in frightened condition. At that time his shirt was soaked with blood and there was blood on his hand”. It has come in the evidence of PW.3- Umesh, that he had seen one person passing near the staircase when he was going towards the lift and when he went to his house he saw that his mother was bleeding. He has further stated, that when police came home, they had taken with them a jean pant and a shirt from the balcony which was exclusively attached to the bedroom where the incident took place. In his cross-examination, he has stated, that Gladish Anthony was his teacher who use to come to their house for teaching him and that she was about 55 years of age. It is pertinent to note that PW.3 – Umesh’s statement came to be recorded on 8 th April, 2011 where as the incident had occurred on the intervening night of 2 nd and 3 rd April, 2011. In fact PW.9 PSI – Ghuge has admitted in his evidence that when he went to the spot immediately after the incident PW.3 – Umesh was present and that he had not recorded the statement of any person in the ADR enquiry.
7. In the light of the evidence, that had come on record, the Trial Court rightly discarded his evidence and put his evidence in the category of neither fully reliable nor wholly unreliable. Although the prosecution examined PW.1- Manoj i.e. brother of the deceased and PW.4 – Dhanwanti Chhabriya, mother of the deceased, the Trial Court found that there were several inconsistencies, material omissions [2025] 2 S.C.R. 1437Manoj Rameshlal Chhabriya v. Mahesh Prakash Ahuja & Anr. and improvements in their evidence and therefore did not think it fit to reply on their testimony, regarding alleged disclosures made by PW.3 – Umesh, to them regarding the presence of the Respondent at the relevant time with the deceased in the bedroom. The Trial Court also found that there was a delay of 3 to 4 days in recording the statement of PW.4- Dhanwanti which is another factor which weighed while evaluating her evidence.
8. The Trial Court did not rely on the testimony of PW.1- Manoj for the following reasons:-i) that the delay in lodging the FIR was not explained by PW.1-Manoj, though the police were present at the scene of incident. It is pertinent to note, that PW.1 – Manoj did not disclose anything to the police on the spot; despite the alleged disclosures made by PW.3-Umesh to PW.1-Manoj soon after the incident, before the police arrived; and despite the fact that he was present at the time of the spot-cum-inquest panchnama prepared by PW.9-PSI Ghuge. Infact, there is reference of suicide having been committed by the deceased Reena/ Bhavana, in the spot cum inquest panchnama, which was recorded in his presence and within the hearing of PW.1- Manoj. In view of the said discrepancies, the Trial Court rightly found the evidence of PW.1 – Manoj, unworthy of credence. The Trial Court also found the evidence of PW.4- Dhanwanti as unsafe to rely upon as there were several material omissions with regard to the disclosures made by PW.3 - Umesh to her, with regard to the incident. The Trial Court observed, that the onus was on the prosecution to lead such evidence, which would show that the Respondent was at his residence at the time of the incident, so as to attract the provisions of Section 106 of the Evidence Act. It was further observed that the evidence on record showed, that in addition to the Respondent, respondent’s father, his wife and brothers of the Respondent and their wives were also residing in the same bungalow and in the absence of any evidence to show that they were not having access to the house of the Respondent, situated on the third floor, Section 106 of the Evidence Act could not be invoked.
1438 [2025] 2 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
9. The Trial Court, has therefore, rightly come to the conclusion, that there was no evidence of last seen against the evidence of PW.9-PSI Ghuge, that ADR no.24 of 2011 came to be registered, on the basis of information received from one Rajkumar Govindram Ahuja, who however has not been examined by the prosecution. It also appears from the evidence of PW.9-PSI Ghuge, that the Control Room had received a call regarding suicide by a girl in the Ahuja Bungalow on 3 rd April, 2011 at 12.45 a.m. The prosecution had also examined PW.6-Dattatraya Ware, a watchman at the Bungalow at the relevant time. The said witness also has not supported the prosecution and has been declared hostile with regard to the evidence of last seen. The Trial Court, therefore, rightly concluded that in the absence of any reliable evidence, the prosecution had failed to prove the last seen theory. The prosecution had also failed to prove as to when the deceased had her last meal and that in the absence of any evidence to show that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the respondent, found it difficult to come to a conclusion that it was the respondent who was the author of the crime.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.