Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand)
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 816; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1932
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Aravind Kumar
- Decided
- 23 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 102/2013
- Sections
- 302, 27, 161
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1932 : 2025 INSC 816 Nimai Ghosh & Ors.
v.
The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand)
(Criminal Appeal No. 102 of 2013)
23 January 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari* and Aravind Kumar, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The instant criminal appeal assails the findings recorded by the High Court, thereby convicting the appellants herein u/s.302/34 of IPC and s.27 of the Arms Act, 1959. Whether the findings recorded by the High Court in the facts and circumstances of the case is sustainable.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – s.302/34 – Arms Act, 1959 – s.27 – P.S. Case No. 127/89 was registered on 09.07.1989 arraying six persons as accused for committing murder of father of the informant (PW-8) – The Trial Court acquitted all the six persons, inter-alia, holding that testimonies of the witnesses cannot be believed – In appeal, the High Court sustained acquittal qua three accused persons, however, the other three accused-appellant herein were convicted for the offences as charged – Correctness: Held: 1. In view of the facts and circumstances of the instant case, in considered opinion of this Court, the prosecution has miserably failed to prove the allegations of the commission of murder by the appellants – Therefore, the findings as recorded by the High Court are not based on due appreciation of records but on misreading of evidence which cannot be sustained and is hereby set aside – Accordingly, the impugned judgment stands set aside – The order of the Trial Court stands restored. [Para 24]
2. The normal conduct of the son (PW-8) and other two nephews (PW-5 and PW-8) should have been to immediately report the incident to the nearest police station, however, in the present case no information was furnished by them for approximately 14 hours – All the eyewitnesses left the place of the occurrence after some time and later came back without intimating the other family * Author [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1933Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand) members and villagers – The conduct raises serious questions, especially considering that PW–8, a key eyewitness, allegedly witnessed the brutal murder of his own father – Given these circumstances, it is perplexing and surprising as to why he refrained from reporting the incident immediately and bringing the deceased to the nearest hospital – Such inaction undermines the credibility of the prosecution’s narrative, as any reasonable person faced with the murder of a close family member would typically inform the police without delay – This kind of passive conduct runs contrary with the natural behavior expected of a prudent person in such grave and distressing circumstances. [Paras 9, 23]
3. All the three eyewitnesses (PW-8, PW-2, PW-5) are unable to say who were the chance witnesses at the time of incident and saw the commission of crime by the accused persons – It is pertinent here to mention that in the present case, neither the pistol nor the knife was recovered or seized – The testimony of first investigating officer (PW–11), wherein he has deposed that information was received through telephonic message, however in the cross-examination of second investigating officer (PW–10) to whom investigation was later carried forward to, he has specifically mentioned that no telephone was installed in the police station – Also, the witnesses’ testimony remains completely silent on why the deceased’s body was not taken to the nearest hospital and why it was kept at the site overnight – In view of the foregoing facts, the prosecution has failed to prove the allegations of the commission of murder by the appellants. [Paras 20-24] Evidence – Unnatural beaviour of witness – Discussed.
[Paras 10-15] Evidence – Eye-witnesses – Quality of evidence – Conduct of witness:
Held: As a general rule, to prove the case of the prosecution, the testimony of eyewitness primarily ought to be considered and be relied upon to prove the guilt of the accused – It is trite to say that the testimony of the eyewitness must be trustworthy, free from any kind of blemish and of sterling character to prove the incident, whereby the case of the prosecution may be proved beyond reasonable doubt – It is also settled that the quality of evidence brought to prove the guilt is a relevant factor and not the quality of the witnesses – The testimony of those witnesses either proves 1934 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the case as alleged by the prosecution or otherwise – Sometimes, the testimony of the eyewitness is found unbelievable and can be discarded – To adjudge the credibility of the said testimony, relevant factor would be the conduct of the witness indicating the natural reaction comparable to a prudent man, making the conduct of witness realistic. [Para 16] Evidence – Relative or friend of accompanying deceased – Furnishing information to police or relative – Relevant factor:
Held: If a friend or relative is accompanying the deceased at the time of incident, action taken by the witness is a relevant factor to save him – Moreover, in addition, at the time of incident and immediately after commission of the offence, what steps were taken by the eyewitness to save the life of the deceased – Whether the eyewitness left the place of occurrence and returned the place of incident simpliciter without furnishing information to the police or intimating the relatives/friends/near dear ones becomes relevant – In case, the eyewitness does not convey any information about the incident to anyone which is not expected from a prudent man, his conduct does not appear to be natural of a human being – The time of furnishing information to the police at the earliest by eyewitness is one of the relevant factors to dislodge the plea of belated FIR, therefore, the conduct of an eyewitness should be reflected like a real image in a mirror, thereby making his testimony reliable to prove the guilt of the accused. [Para 17] Case Law Cited Alil Mollah and Anr. v. State of West Bengal [1996] Supp. 3 SCR 666 : (1996) 5 SCC 369; Gopal Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2010] 6 SCR 1062 : (2010) 6 SCC 407; Shivasharanappa and Others v. State of Karnataka [2013] 5 SCR 1104 : (2013) 5 SCC 705; Lahu Kamlakar Patil and Another v. State of Maharashtra [2012] 9 SCR 1173 : (2013) 6 SCC 417; Amar Singh v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2020] 8 SCR 751 : (2020) 19 SCC 165; Narendrasinh Keshubhai Zala v. State of Gujarat [2023] 2 SCR 746 : (2023) 18 SCC 783 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Arms Act, 1959.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1935Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand) List of Keywords Evidence; Eye-witness; Relative or friend of accompanying deceased; Furnishing information to police or relative; Quality of evidence; Conduct of witness; Unnatural behaviour of witness; Testimony of eyewitness; Delay in lodging the FIR; Chance witnesses.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
102 of 2013 From the Judgment and Order dated 02.08.2012 of the High Court of Judicature at Jharkhand at Ranchi in GA No. 31 of 1998 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Jayesh Gaurav, Ishwar Chandra Roy, T. Mahipal.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Ms. Pallavi Langar, Sujeet Kumar Chaubey.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.K. Maheshwari, J.
1. Challenging the findings recorded by High Court of Jharkhand in judgment dated 02.08.2012 passed in Government Appeal (DB) No. 31 of 1998, convicting the appellants for the charges under Section 302/34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short ‘IPC’) and Section 27 of the Arms Act, 1959, by setting-aside the judgment of acquittal dated 02.04.1998 of Additional Sessions Judge, Pakur, in Sessions Trial No. 148 of 1990, the present appeal has been preferred by the accused-appellants.
2. The necessary facts in brief are, P.S. Case No. 127/89 was registered by Shyama Ram, A.S.I., the Investigating Officer (PW–11) on the basis of fardbeyan of Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8, informant and son of deceased) on 09.07.1989 at 05.30 a.m. The incident allegedly took place on 08.07.1989 at around 4 p.m., in which one Manmohan 1936 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Ghosh (father of the informant) was murdered. The P.S. Case was registered against six accused persons namely (i) Nimai Ghosh; (ii) Sonachand Ghosh; (iii) Sambal Ghosh; (iv) Gaya Nath Ghosh; (v) Shridhar Ghosh and (vi) Sachin Ghosh. After investigation, challan was filed against all accused persons. The prosecution was unable to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt leading to acquittal of all the accused persons. On filing appeal by the State, the High Court dismissed the same qua three accused persons sustaining their acquittal, however, by partly allowing the appeal qua other three accused persons namely (i) Nimai Ghosh; (ii) Sonachand Ghosh and (iii) Sambal Ghosh, they have been convicted for the offences as charged, hence, this appeal.
3. As per case of prosecution, on 08.07.1989 at about 3 p.m., the deceased Manmohan Ghosh accompanied with his son Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8), Megh Nath Ghosh (PW–5, nephew of deceased on maternal side) and Shankar Ghosh (PW–2, nephew of deceased on paternal side), started on bicycles from village Malaypur to visit Pakur, where the house of the deceased was under construction. Around 4 p.m., when they reached the railway bridge near village Dadpur, Janmejay Ghosh saw Nimai Ghosh and Sonachand Ghosh (appellants–accused) came from eastern side of the railway under bridge. Co-accused Gaya Nath Ghosh, Shridhar Ghosh, Sachin Ghosh and Sambal Ghosh also came from the western side of the bridge. Accused Nimai Ghosh and Sonachand Ghosh were armed with pistol and they forcibly dragged the deceased under the railway track, where Nimai Ghosh fired on the back of the deceased, as a result of which deceased fell down and started bleeding. Co-accused Sonachand Ghosh shot second fire with intention to kill him. In the meantime, while the deceased was bleeding and withering, Sambal Ghosh assailed him by means of knife, as such the deceased succumbed to the injuries. As further alleged, the entire incident was witnessed by Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8), Megh Nath Ghosh (PW–5) and Shankar Ghosh (PW–2) and when alarm was raised by them, accused persons threatened to kill them. Fearing the same, they could not save the deceased. Thereafter, the accused persons left the place and moved towards Purab Jheel. The motive for the incident attributed in the fardbeyan is of previous enmity and prior litigation of deceased with accused Gaya Nath.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1937Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand)
4. On 09.07.1989, the next day of incident, at around 5.30 a.m., the Investigating Officer (PW–11) reached the place of scene and recorded the statement of Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8). Later, the investigation was carried out by Dinanath Ram (PW–10).The post-mortem was conducted by Dr. S.K. Gupta (PW–1) on 09.07.1989,wherein following injuries were found –
(i) One injury having one inch diameter round shape with burnt periphery on the angle of left scapula entrance wound;
(ii) One injury to the continuation of injury no. 01 on the left side of the chest, triangular shaped 4" above medial 5" lateral 6’ forming a cavity fracturing a bone spanding ribs and puncturing the lungs, aorta, heart and surrounding structure exit;
(iii) One injury on the back by the X ride of the vertible columns 2" above the waist 1/2" x 1/2"with lacerated margins;
(iv) One incised wound on the left side on neck 2" x 1/4" x muscle deep;
(v) One incised wound on the face by the right side of the nose 1/2" x 1/6";
(vi) One incised wound on left iliac crest 1 and 1/2" x 1/4" x skin deep.
Out of these, injury nos. 1 and 2 were of firearms and other injuries except injury no. 3 were incised. Injury No. 3 was a lacerated wound on the left side of the vertical column above neck. As opined, the cause of death was due to injury no. 1 and 2 leading to massive intra thorax hemorrhage and shock. After completion of investigation, the charge-sheet was filed, and the case was committed to the Court of Sessions for trial.
5. The charges for offence under Section 302/34 of IPC read with Section 27 of the Arms Act were framed. The accused persons abjured the guilt and demanded trial taking defence of false implication because of previous enmity and pending litigation. The prosecution examined Shankar Ghosh (PW–2), Megh Nath Ghosh (PW–5) and Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8) as eyewitnesses. The prosecution further examined Manjur Rahman (PW–4), Mahadev Ghosh (PW–6), Saidul Rahman (PW–9) as chance witnesses. On due appreciation of material placed on record, the trial Court was of the opinion that in 1938 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the facts of the case, testimonies of the witnesses cannot be believed and moreover, material contradictions qua injuries and the weapon possessed by the accused persons are there. Neither the recovery of the weapon has been made out, nor any ballistic or scientific evidence connecting overt act of the accused persons is on record. The trial Court also found that the conduct of the eyewitnesses is absolutely doubtful as none of them intimated the police about the incident that took place at about 4 p.m. on 08.07.1989. PW–11 stated that he got intimation about the occurrence over phone by someone, however, no clear proof has come in this regard in the testimony. In such situation, the trial Court was of the opinion that the testimonies of eyewitnesses or chance witnesses are not worthy to be relied upon for proving the guilt of the accused persons,in particular looking to the previous enmity and the litigation pending between deceased and co-accused Gaya Nath Ghosh. As such, all the accused persons were acquitted from the charges because the prosecution failed to prove the case against them.
6. On filing appeal before the High Court, it was partly allowed qua Nimai Ghosh, Sonachand Ghosh and Sambal Ghosh. The High Court by the impugned judgment convicted all the appellants for the charges under Sections 302/34 of IPC and further convicted accused Nimai Ghosh and Sonachand Ghosh for charge under Section 27 of the Arms Act, inter-alia observing that the defence to disprove the charge cannot be believed when the testimonies of the eyewitnesses are consistent with respect to the incident, corroborated by the statements of chance witnesses. The High Court, believing the testimonies of those witnesses, set-aside the judgment of acquittal of trial Court so far as the appellants are concerned,noting that active role of the appellants in commission of offence by shooting from the firearm namely pistol and other weapon, i.e., knife has been specifically proved and corroborated by medical evidence. Challenging the said findings as recorded by the High Court, the appellants have preferred this appeal.
7. Mr. Jayesh Gaurav, learned counsel appearing on behalf of appellants submits that the incident took place on 8 th July 1989, at around 4 p.m. in an open place where the deceased accompanying his son, maternal nephew and paternal nephew were going towards village Pakur on bicycles. The other three persons were following the deceased from behind. It is surprising that at the first instance, when [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1939Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand) only two persons came at the place of the incident who dragged off the deceased, the alleged eyewitness who were deceased’s own son and close relatives were not in a position to stop two persons and save the deceased. The other four accused persons later came from another direction. Therefore, the testimonies of those witnesses were not worthy to be relied upon for conviction of accused persons, in particular when there has been no recovery of the weapon from them. It is also not on record that the weapon (pistol) allegedly used by two accused persons, namely, Nimai Ghosh and Sonachand Ghosh was the same and the third accused Sambal Ghosh used knife. In absence of recovery of those weapons, the incident itself is doubtful, and the charges as alleged under Section 27 of the Arms Act cannot be proved. It is further contended that in absence of recovery, no scientific/ballistic investigation has been carried out and trial Court in such absence has rightly disbelieved the testimonies of those witnesses and recorded the finding that in absence of recovery of weapon and ballistic report,recovered empty bullet cover cannot be connected with the incident and the guilt of the appellants cannot be proved, in particular, when there is a previous enmity and litigation pending between them. It is said that the High Court committed grave error in setting aside those findings without any plausible reasons and grounds, therefore, the judgment of conviction by the High Court deserves to be set-aside.
8. Per contra, learned counsel Mr. Sujeet Kumar Chaubey representing the State has strenuously argued in support of the findings of the High Court, inter-alia stating that the testimonies by the eyewitnesses have been fully corroborated by chance witnesses and the entire incident cannot be disbelieved on the testimony of the defence witnesses who merely heard the gun shot and arrived at the place of incident. It was further urged that the High Court has rightly set-aside the judgment of acquittal so far as the appellants are concerned, therefore, the interference in this appeal is not warranted.
9. After having considered the submissions made and on perusal of the material placed on record, it emerges that Janmejay Ghosh (PW–8) is the son of the deceased, Shankar Ghosh (PW–2) is the paternal nephew and Megh Nath Ghosh (PW–5) is the maternal nephew of the deceased. All three along with the deceased were going to Pakur on bicycles. On reaching the place of occurrence, deceased was dragged off by accused Nimai Ghosh and Sonachand Ghosh and 1940 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports was shot by firearm from the backside by Nimai Ghosh. It is further submitted that another shot thereafter was fired Sonachand Ghosh. However, as per the testimony of doctor S.K. Gupta (PW–1), out of the six injuries, only one firearm injury was found with an entry and exit wound. Therefore, the allegation in the testimonies of eyewitnesses of having taken two shots of firearm on the body of the deceased is suspicious. The deceased was going along with his son and two other relatives and these three persons, who were eyewitnesses, were frightened because of the incident and threatening by the accused person. The said conduct of the witnesses has been questioned in the facts of the case. In addition, the place of incident is not a place where the deceased/accused were residing, though 5-6 kms (as deposed by PW–11) far from village Malaypur, i.e., from where they started. The normal conduct of the son and other two nephews should have been to immediately report the incident to the nearest police station, however, in the present case no information was furnished by them for approximately 14 hours. All the eyewitnesses left the place of the occurrence after some time and later came back without intimating the other family members and villagers.
10. Given the circumstances, before assessing the witnesses’ testimony to determine the appellants’ guilt, it is imperative to consider as to how and in what manner a witness’s testimony may be deemed credible or otherwise in support of the prosecution’s case. In this regard, reference is made judgment of this Court in case of ‘Alil Mollah and Anr. Vs. State of West Bengal’ 1 , wherein this Court while allowing the appeal against concurrent conviction for offence under Section 302/24 of IPC based on testimony of solitary eyewitness, observed in paragraph 7 as thus: - “7. On his own showing PW 3 was an employee of the deceased. He was present, according to his testimony, when the deceased was assaulted by the appellants. He admits that after committing the crime the appellants and their associates fled away. The witness, however, not only did not raise any alarm when his master was being assaulted, he did not go near his employer even after the assailants had fled away to see the condition in which the
1 (1996) 5 SCC 369
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1941Nimai Ghosh & Ors. v. The State of Bihar (Now Jharkhand) employer was after having suffered the assault. According to him he got frightened and fled away to his home. He also admitted in his cross-examination that neither at his home nor in the village did he disclose what he had seen in the evening of 4-2-1982 to anyone. Though in the morning of the following day, the witness went to the brick-fields of the deceased-employer and many of his co-employees were also present there, he admitted that he did not disclose the occurrence to anyone of them and went on to concede that even to the Manager of the brick-fields he gave the information about the occurrence only 2-3 days after the occurrence. His statement was recorded by the police on the next day in the afternoon. This conduct of the witness that he did not tell anyone about the occurrence till the next day appears to be rather unnatural and creates an impression that he had not witnessed the occurrence. The witness however tried to take shelter on the plea that he was ‘frightened’ and therefore till he appeared before the police, he did not pick up courage to inform anyone either in the village or in the brick-fields regarding the occurrence. This plea does not impress us. ………”
As noted, this Court disbelieved the evidence of this eyewitness due to his unnatural conduct who did not tell about occurrence to anyone despite his presence at the place of occurrence. His plea of fear was also discarded.
11. In the case of ‘Gopal Singh Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh’2 , relating to double murder, this Court allowed the appeal against conviction by High Court, which had set-aside the judgment of acquittal by trial Court for offences under Section 302/34 of IPC, and disbelieved the testimony of eyewitness Feran Singh (PW–5) noting as thus:- “25. We also find that the High Court has accepted the statement of Feran Singh, PW 5 as the eyewitness of the incident ignoring the fact that his behaviour was unnatural as he claimed to have rushed to the village but had still not conveyed the information about the incident to his parents and others present there and had chosen to disappear for
2 (2010) 6 SCC 407
1942 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a couple of hours on the specious and unacceptable plea that he feared for his own safety.”
In the above case also, this Court observed that behaviour of the eyewitness is unnatural since after the incident, he rushed to the village,however, did not convey any information either to the villagers or his parents and other persons present. He disappeared from the spot merely on the pretext of fear and to save himself.
12. Similarly, in ‘Shivasharanappa and Others Vs. State of Karnataka3 ’, this Court in an appeal against conviction by the High Court, which had set-aside the judgment of acquittal by the trial Court primarily for offences under Section 302/149 of IPC, while allowing the appeal, disbelieved the testimony of the daughter (PW–9) who is said to be eyewitness and inter-alia observed as thus:- “22. Thus, the behaviour of the witnesses or their reactions would differ from situation to situation and individual to individual. Expectation of uniformity in the reaction of witnesses would be unrealistic but the court cannot be oblivious of the fact that even taking into account the unpredictability of human conduct and lack of uniformity in human reaction, whether in the circumstances of the case, the behaviour is acceptably natural allowing the variations. If the behaviour is absolutely unnatural, the testimony of the witness may not deserve credence and acceptance.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.