Bidyut Sarkar & Anr. v. Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through LRs. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 704; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 984
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 28 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10509/2013
- Sections
- 36, 35, 144(2), 16, 96, 40, 32, 61, 33, 38, 13, 14
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 984 : 2024 INSC 704 Bidyut Sarkar & Anr.
v.
Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 10509-10510 of 2013)
28 August 2024 [Vikram Nath and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards admissibility of the insufficiently stamped agreement to sell.
Headnotes† Stamp Act, 1899 – ss.35, 36, 40 and 42 – Instruments not duly stamped inadmissible in evidence, etc. – Suit for specific performance of contract based on agreement to sell, filed by the respondent no. 1 against the defendant no. 1-owner of the property – Trial court dismissed the suit on the finding that the agreement to sell not admissible in evidence being insufficiently stamped – Appeal thereagainst by the respondent no. 1 allowed by the High Court – Appellants, in whose favour the defendant no. 1 had executed the sale deed filed cross objections against the findings of the trial court recorded against them, dismissed by the High Court – However, as regards admissibility of the agreement to sell it was held that as the respondent no. 1 had accepted that he would pay the deficient stamp duty and penalty as assessed by the collector, the trial court erred in dismissing the suit on the ground that the agreement to sell, could not be enforced being executed on insufficiently stamped paper – Correctness:
Held: No reason to disagree with the findings of the trial court regarding the inadmissibility of the agreement to sell – Document, being insufficiently stamped, was rightfully barred from being admitted as evidence in the absence of the requisite stamp duty and penalty being paid and certified by the Collector – As the document was found to be insufficiently stamped and was marked as exhibit with objection and that objection having not been removed or cured, no benefit of s.36 could be extended to the respondent no.1 – High Court did not consider the statutory provisions and only proceeded to rely upon the statement of the respondent [2024] 8 S.C.R. 985Bidyut Sarkar & Anr. v. Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. no.1 that he had accepted to deposit the deficiency in stamp duty and penalty, if any, imposed by the Collector – Even till date, the respondent no.1 has not made any efforts before the Collector to get the deficiency and penalty determined on the impounded document and to clear the same – As a result, the document remains inadmissible in evidence under the express bar imposed by s.35 – Failure to resolve the deficiency in stamp duty prevents the document from being considered as admissible and valid in evidence – Thus, until the necessary stamp duty and penalty are duly paid and endorsed by the Collector, the instrument remains legally barred from being admitted in evidence – High Court failed to recognize that an insufficiently stamped document can only be admitted into evidence after the deficiency in stamp duty and any applicable penalty has been duly paid and cleared – This lapse of procedure not properly addressed by the High Court – As the document is foundational to the suit, the failure to comply with the statutory requirements renders the entire claim unenforceable – Respondent no. 1 cannot claim relief on the basis of a document that has not satisfied the legal requirements for admissibility – Thus, the impugned order of the High Court set aside and that of the trial court dismissing the suit restored. [Paras 21-27, 30, 32, 33] Case Law Cited Ram Rattan (dead) by L.Rs. v. Bajrang Lal and Others, AIR 1978 SC 1393; Javer Chand and others v. Pukhraj Surana, AIR 1961 SC 1655 – referred to.
List of Acts Stamp Act, 1899.
List of Keywords Instruments not duly stamped; Admissible in evidence; Suit for specific performance of contract; Agreement to sell; Insufficiently stamped; Cross objections; Deficient stamp duty and penalty. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 10509-10510 of 2013 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.12.2008 of the High Court of Calcutta in FA No. 282 of 2006 and COT No. 2304 of 2005 986 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Subrata Dutt, Ms. Shipra Ghose, Advs. for the Appellants. Shubhayu Roy, Rohit Dutta, Ms. Shalini Kaul, Ms. Priyata Chakraborty, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. These appeals, by defendant nos.2 and 3, have been filed assailing the correctness of the judgment and order dated 05.12.2008 whereby the Division Bench of Calcutta High Court allowed the First Appeal No.282 of 2006, titled Kanchilal Pal vs. Sashti Charan Banerjee & Others, and after setting aside the judgment of the Trial Court dismissing the suit of the respondent no.1, proceeded to decree the suit for specific performance of the contract in favour of plaintiff-respondent no.1. Hereinafter will deal with the parties as they have been referred in the Trial Court.
2. Relevant facts giving rise to the present appeals are as follows:
2.1. Sashti Charan Banerjee-respondent no.2, was admittedly the owner of the property in dispute. According to the appellants, respondent no.1 filed a suit for specific performance registered as Title Suit No.123 of 1999, Kanchilal Pal vs. Sashti Charan Banerjee and two others in the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Barasat, for a decree of specific performance of contract dated 29.03.1999. The plaint allegations are as follows: a) Defendant no.1 is the owner of property in question being Premises No.126, Rajkumar Mukherjee Road, Calcutta, 700035, within the JL No.5, Paragana Calcutta, Khatian No.2292 bearing Plot Nos. 2477 and 2478 measuring about 7 cottahs, 7 1/2 Chittack of land, including the structures thereon.
b) Defendant no.1 intended to sell the premises in question for which the plaintiff agreed to purchase the same for a consideration of Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakhs only). The plaintiff was required to develop the property/premises in question while dividing into plots and to sell the same to different persons within the period of one year and, [2024] 8 S.C.R. 987Bidyut Sarkar & Anr. v. Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. after realizing sale consideration from the proposed purchasers, shall pay the balance amount of Rs.2,90,000/- (Rupees two lakhs ninety thousand only) whereupon defendant no.1 would transfer the land in favour of the plaintiff or his nominees, as the case would be.
c) An advance amount of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) is said to have been paid in cash to defendant no.1. The plaintiff was also empowered to make a settlement for ejectment of the tenants residing in the premises in question and take possession from them. The plaintiff was also authorized to carry out development work and to make construction of common passage, drain, etc. in the meantime and to collect money from the proposed buyers of the plots to be developed.
2.2. In due course, a sale deed would be executed by defendant no.1 in favour of the nominees or the plaintiff and in such sales, the plaintiff would be a confirming party. The said exercise was to be completed within one year. In case defendant no.1 fails to execute the sale deed, the plaintiff or his nominees would be at liberty to file a suit for specific performance.
2.3. It was further provided in the agreement that, in case the plaintiff fails to pay the amount as agreed within the time stipulated i.e. one year, the agreement to sell would be treated as cancelled.
2.4. Further, according to the plaint, the plaintiff has spent an amount of Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees two lakhs only) for construction of common passage, drain, etc. and has also contacted with the tenants to purchase part of the property in question measuring three cottahs and that they would pay an amount of Rs.1,20,000/- (Rupees one lakh twenty thousand only), out of which the plaintiff had received Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty thousand only) from one of the tenants. The plaintiff also claimed to be in possession. He also requested defendant no.1 to deliver the original title deeds, which defendant no.1 did not oblige.
2.5. The tenants, on 20.05.1999, came to the plaintiff and showed him letter of an advocate and, after going through the same, the plaintiff learnt that defendant no.1 had already transferred the property in question vide sale deed dated 03.05.1999 in favour of defendant nos.2 and 3 (appellants). The plaintiff thereafter 988 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports made inquiries and again approached defendant nos.1 to 3 to execute the sale deed in his favour but as they declined, he was compelled to institute the suit on 21.05.1999.
2.6. It is also averred in the plaint in paragraph 10 that the plaintiff was always ready and willing to perform his part of the contract.
3. Defendant no.1 filed his written statement denying the plaint allegations. A separate written statement was filed by defendant nos.2 and 3. Defendant no.1 in his written statement stated that he had entered into an agreement to sell dated 10.03.1999 in favour of defendant nos.2 and 3 and had also executed a registered deed of conveyance on 03.05.1999 in favour of defendant nos.2 and 3 for valuable consideration received by him and, also handed over possession to them. Thereafter, a letter of atonement dated 18.05.1999 was served on the tenant of the premises in question on behalf of all the three defendants through their advocates which was duly received by them informing them about the transfer of title from defendant no.1 to defendant nos.2 and 3.
4. It is further stated in the written statement of defendant no.1 that plaintiff approached him on 24.03.1999 with a proposal to purchase the said property, however, defendant no.1 declined the said proposal informing him that he had already entered into an agreement to sell with defendant nos.2 and 3. The plaintiff, however, continued with his insistence to purchase the property and in that respect on 29.03.1999 at about 04:30 PM, the plaintiff compelled defendant no.1 to accompany him to the machine shop of Ajit Bhattacharjee, where under threat and pressure and surrounded by about ten persons, he was compelled to sign some papers against his will. He was not even allowed to read the papers, and he was threatened not to disclose such incident to any person, including police. Despite the same, defendant no.1 reported the matter to the police on the basis of which G.D. Entry no.713 was made at the Talatola Police Station on 07.04.1999. The plaintiff, along with his men and agents, tried to cut the trees over the property in question on 03.04.1999, which being illegal and unlawful, was again reported to the police station at Baranagar and registered vide G.D. Entry no.496 dated 04.09.1999.
5. Defendant no.1 also moved an application under section 144(2) Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, before the Executive Magistrate at Barrackpore, which was registered as M.P. Case No.894 of 1999. [2024] 8 S.C.R. 989Bidyut Sarkar & Anr. v. Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr. The defendant also informed the Chairperson, Baranagar Municipality, through advocates’ letter dated 12.04.1999, against the illegal acts of the plaintiff over the suit property.
6. Further, defendant no.1 also lodged a criminal case no. C/1335 of 1999 before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate under sections 384/341/34 Indian Penal Code, 1860 which was still pending at the time of filing of the written statement. It was further stated in the written statement of defendant no.1 that on 23.04.1999, the plaintiff came to his house and threw some xerox copies of papers with a bundle of currency notes of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) and threatened him with dire consequences if he discloses anything to the police. It was only then that defendant no.1 came to know of the alleged agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999, which he was compelled to sign under circumstances already stated above.
7. It is also averred in the written statement that defendant no.1 tried to return the amount of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) to the plaintiff by way of cheque which he received but later returned. Despite best efforts, defendant no.1 could not return the amount of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) to the plaintiff.
8. It was further averred that plaintiff was land speculator and promoter. He wanted to grab the suit property by hook or crook. The plaintiff joined hands with the tenants and tried to create obstructions from inspecting the premises in question by defendant nos. 2 and 3. Defendant nos.2 and 3 also lodged a complaint in that regard, being G.D. entry no.1434 dated 03.04.1999 at the Baranagar Police Station.
9. In para-wise reply, defendant no.1 denied the plaint allegations, however, accepted the execution of sale deed dated 03.05.1999 in favour of defendant nos.2 and 3. On such averments defendant no.1 sought that suit deserves to be dismissed.
10. Defendant nos. 2 and 3 in their written statement also denied the plaint allegations and more or less reiterated the same facts as pleaded in the written statement of defendant no.1. In addition, it was stated that defendant nos. 2 and 3 filed Title suit No.235 of 1999 in the Court of Civil Judge (Junior Division), Sealdah, against the plaintiff of which the plaintiff had full knowledge.
11. Based upon the pleadings of the parties, the Trial Court framed the following issues:
990 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “ISSUES 1) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and law? 2) Has the plaintiff any cause of action to file this suit? 3) Is the suit barred by limitation?
4) Was there any concluded contract in between the plaintiff and the defendant no.1 on 29.03.1999 regarding sale of the ‘A’ schedule property by defendant no.1 in favour of the plaintiff?
5) Was the defendant no.1 compelled to put signature under threat and compulsion by the plaintiff and his associates at Dharamtala Street, Kolkata?
6) Are the defendant nos. 2 & 3 bonafide purchasers for value of the suit premises without notice?
7) Is the agreement of sale dated 29.03.1999 which has marked as Exbt.1 with objection be admitted in evidence?
8) Is the plaintiff entitled to get the benefit of section 36 of the Indian Stamp Act?
9) Is the plaintiff ready and willing to perform his part of the contract inviting Section 16(c) of the specific Relief Act?
10) Was there any part performance of the said contract? 11) Is the plaintiff entitled to get relief as prayed for? 12) To what other relief/reliefs, if any, is the plaintiff entitled?”
12. The parties led evidence, both documentary and oral. The plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and proved the agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999 which was although marked as Exhibit-1 but with objections, as defendant no.1 had raised an objection regarding the said agreement to sell being not properly stamped. On behalf of the defendants, defendant no.1 examined himself as DW-1, whereas on behalf of defendant nos.2 and 3, their father entered the witness box as DW-2. Various documents on behalf of the defendants were proved by the respective witnesses.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 991Bidyut Sarkar & Anr. v. Kanchilal Pal (Dead) Through Lrs. & Anr.
13. The Trial Court decided all the issues relating to maintainability of the suit, cause of action, limitation, validity of agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999, defendant nos.2 and 3 being bona fide purchasers or not, readiness and willingness of the plaintiff to perform his part of the contract, in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants. However, the Trial Court dealt in detail with regard to the admissibility of the agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999 and whether the plaintiff was entitled to get the benefit of section 36 of Indian Stamp Act, 18991 .
The Trial Court dismissed the suit of the plaintiff on the finding that the agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999 was not admissible in evidence as the defendants had raised objections regarding the same. Once the same was held not admissible, the suit for enforcement of the same was held liable to be dismissed.
14. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiff filed an appeal under section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, registered as Appeal from Original Decree No.282 of 2006. Further, defendant nos.2 and 3 filed crossobjections against the findings of the Trial Court recorded against them, which was registered as COT No.2304 of 2005. The Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court allowed the First Appeal and dismissed the cross-objections. The Division Bench affirmed the findings recorded by the Trial Court on all issues already decided in favour of the plaintiff and accordingly dismissed the cross-objections. However, with regard to issue of admissibility of the agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999, the Division Bench was of the view that as the plaintiff had accepted that he would pay the deficient stamp duty and penalty as may be assessed by the competent authority/collector, the Trial Court had erred in dismissing the suit on the ground that Ex.-1-the agreement to sell, could not be enforced being executed on insufficiently stamped paper.
15. Aggrieved, the present appeals have been preferred by defendant nos.2 and 3 against the judgment of the High Court in allowing the first appeal of the plaintiff and further on dismissing their crossobjections.
16. Learned counsel for the appellants has not only challenged the findings of the High Court on the admissibility of the agreement to sell dated 29.03.1999 but also the concurrent findings of both the 1 The Stamp Act 992 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports courts on other issues regarding the validity of agreement to sell, circumstances under which it was executed and defendants 2 and 3 not being bona fide purchasers for value.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.