Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1372; [2025] 12 S.C.R. 317
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 2 Dec 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14512/2025
- Sections
- 14(1), 14, 3D, 4, 17, 2(19), 40, 3C, 3A, 152, 3B, 2
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 317 : 2025 INSC 1372 Jyoti Builders v.
Chief Executive Officer & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 14512 of 2025)
02 December 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether a mandamus should be issued to the State Government to acquire the subject property in accordance with s.14(1) of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 keeping in mind the order dated 26.02.2015 (2015 order) passed by the Chief Executive Officer-Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA); whether the appellant is entitled to full Occupation Certificate for the final sale building in the slum scheme upon handing over the portion of land admeasuring 2700 sq. mts. meant for Recreational Ground (RG) identified as the dark green portion; whether the appellant has been fully compensated by granting an equivalent and/or adequate area (FSI) for sale by the State Government.
Headnotes† Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment)
Act, 1971 – s.14 r/w s.3D(c)(i) – Under the Development Plan of 1991 for Mumbai, the Subject Property was reserved for Recreational Ground (RG) – In 2015, an order was passed by respondent No.1-SRA after giving notice to and hearing to all the concerned including the respondent No.5 (the then owner) inter alia holding that the Slum Scheme of the appellant-builder had substantially been implemented on the entire area covering the Project Property (including the Subject Property) and the Subject Property was liable to be acquired in the interest of the slum scheme and the slum dwellers on the Subject Property had to be rehabilitated by the appellant – Respondent No.5 transferred her title rights in the subject property in favour of the respondent No.4 who floated its own proposal for implementation of the slum rehabilitation scheme – Writ * Author 318 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports petition filed by the appellant questioning the orders passed by the SRA granting sanction to the respondent No.4 and refusal to implement the 2015 Order and; seeking a mandamus for the acquisition of the subject property relying on the SRA’s 2015 order – Dismissed by High Court – Challenge to:
Held: Power of the State Government u/s.14 r/w s.3D(c)(i), Slum Act is subject to preferential right, if any, of the owner – It is undisputed that when the respondent No.4 submitted its proposal for development of the subject property in 2022, the same was accepted in accordance with law as there was no slum scheme proposal on the subject property – On facts, no case made out by the appellant for a writ of mandamus to be issued to the State Government to acquire the subject property u/s.14, Slum Act – Appellant is entitled to the Occupation Certificate for the Final Sale Building in the slum scheme on the appellant handing over the Dark Green Portion admeasuring 2700 sq. mts. reserved for RG – Further, the appellant has been fully compensated by granting adequate area/FSI for sale – Respondent No. 4, their successors and assigns shall not put up any type of construction on the subject property and the same shall be utilized only as a RG. [Paras 67, 77] Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment)
Act, 1971 – Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act, 1966 – Development Control Regulations, 1991 – Scheme of the Slum Act, 1971. [Paras 60-62] Case Law Cited Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. [2025] 8 SCR 1193 : 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1795; Saldanha Real Estate Pvt. Ltd. v. Bishop John Rodrigues & Ors., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1794 – relied on.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Jogendra Singh [1964] 2 SCR 197 : 1963 SCC OnLine SC 96; State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu & Anr. [2025] 4 SCR 985 : 2025 SCC OnLine SC 770 – referred to.
Citispace & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra, Order passed by the Bombay High Court dated 31.07.2002 in Writ Petition No. 1152 of 2002 – referred to.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 319Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. List of Acts Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act, 1966; Development Control Regulations, 1991.
List of Keywords Section 14, Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; No mandamus can be issued to State Government to acquire property under Section 14, Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Recreational Ground; Slum rehabilitation scheme; Slum redevelopment scheme; Owner possesses a preferential right to redevelop the Slum Rehabilitation Area; Preferential right to redevelop; Redevelopment of slum dwellers; Mandamus to State Government to acquire property; Redevelopment; Recreational ground; Occupation certificate; Occupation Certificate for the final sale; Slum scheme; Dark green portion; Rehabilitation and redevelopment of slum dwellers; Slum Rehabilitation Authority; Development Plan of 1991 for Mumbai.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 14512 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.12.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WPL No. 31702 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant(s):
Shyam Divan, Kavin Gulati, Sr. Advs., Anish Agarwal, Yogesh Adhia, Pratik Chakma, Ms. Natasha Bagga, Abhinav Maurya, Ms. Pooja Kane, Jitendra Jain, Yashvardhan Singh.
Advs. for the Respondent(s):
Vikas Singh, Vinay Navare, K. Parameshwar, Sr. Advs., Ms. Pallavi Sharma, Shubhranshu Padhi, Bharat Jain, Purvesh Buttan, Karan Batura, Prateek Narwar, Nikhil Vijay Adkine, Ms. Tuhina Kakkar, Himanshu Buttan, Ms. Prachi Bhutani, Abhikalp Pratap Singh, Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, B. Dhananjay, Ms. Srishty Pandey, Palash Singhai, Harshal Sareen, Pragya Prakash Upadhyaya. 320 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay (Original Ordinary Civil Jurisdiction) dated 18.12.2024 by which the writ petition filed by the appellant herein seeking to challenge the orders passed by the respondent No. 1 herein dated 03.10.2022 and respondent No. 3 herein dated 07.10.2024 respectively came to be dismissed.
3. Over and above the challenge to the two orders referred to above, the appellant also prayed before the High Court for a writ of mandamus directing the respondent Nos. 1 and 3 herein respectively to implement the order dated 26.02.2015 passed by the respondent No. 1 herein i.e. the Chief Executive Officer, Slum Rehabilitation Authority (CEO-SRA).
4. This litigation has a chequered history. The facts are quite complicated. In such circumstances, we need to give a fair idea about this litigation which, according to the High Court, was a third round of litigation between the parties.
FACTUAL MATRIX
5. The dispute in the present case relates to a parcel of land admeasuring 2,005 sq. mts. bearing CTS No.620/A/1A/1(Part) (now renumbered as CTS No. 620/A/1A/1B/1 and 620/A/1A/1B/2) of Village Malad in Taluka Borivali, Mumbai Suburban District (“Subject Property”).
6. The Subject Property was originally owned by F.E. Dinshaw Trust. Since there were hutments on the Subject Property and the same had no proper hygiene and sanitation, it was declared as a slum on 26 th November, 1987 under Section 4 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (for short “Slum Act”).
7. On 25 th March, 1991, the Development Plan of 1991 for Mumbai was published, wherein the Subject Property was reserved for Recreational Ground (“RG”). The Subject Property even today is reserved for RG. [2025] 12 S.C.R. 321Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors.
8. The respondent No. 5, i.e., Phuldai R. Yadav claims to have purchased the Subject Property from the Trust on 18 th September, 1991 under a distressed sale for an amount of Rs. 1,06,000/-. Within a period of 6 months from the date of purchase, the respondent No. 5 is said to have entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) dated 9 th February, 1992 (“1992 MOU”) for sale of the Subject Property with the appellant’s predecessor in interest viz. Harishree Enterprises (“Harishree Enterprises”). The respondent No. 5 is said to have granted her consent to Harishree Enterprises for redevelopment. It is the case of the appellant that such act on the part the respondent No. 5 is a pointer that she was not interested in developing the property herself or in any case, had waived her preferential right, if any, to redevelop the slum land i.e. the Subject Property way back in the year 1992.
9. Initially, Harishree Enterprises propounded the slum scheme on a larger property consisting of seven plots of land, admeasuring 19456.7 sq. mts. (“Larger Property”). The Subject Property is one of the said seven plots. The 1992 MOU was considered as grant of consent by the owner for the proposed redevelopment as per the prevailing law. The other six plots of land are either owned by the appellant’s predecessor (and thereafter the appellant) or the development rights/ consent for the slum scheme had been given for the same.
10. Accordingly, a survey was undertaken to identify the number of slum dwellers. As per the survey, 34 slum dwellers were found to be residing on the Subject Property.
11. On 30 th January 1997, Certified Annexure-II (“Annexure II”) was issued by the SRA in respect of the slum dwellers of the Larger Property including the Subject Property. Annexure II contains a plan on which slum scheme is to be implemented. The plan annexed to Annexure II includes the Subject Property and contain names/details of 34 slum dwellers who had their hutments on the Subject Property.
12. On 3 rd September, 1997, a Letter of Intent (“1997 LOI ”) was issued in favour of Harishree Enterprises for implementation of the Slum Scheme on Larger Property, which includes the Subject Property.
13. In the meantime, there was an agreement between Harishree Enterprises and one M/s. Vikas Housing Ltd. (“Vikas Housing”) for joint development. This led to a dispute, which, in turn, was 322 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ultimately resolved through Consent Terms dated 3 rd August, 2000. In accordance with the consent terms, Vikas Housing became entitled to develop 12606.7 sq. mts. (“Project Property ”), which includes the Subject Property. The said Consent Terms came to be subsequently registered. In the present appeal we are not concerned with the balance portion of the Larger Property which came to Harishree Enterprises’s share as per the Consent Terms.
14. The appellant claims to have acquired its rights from Vikas Housing for Project Property. On 9 th August, 2005, a revised LOI came to be issued in favour of the appellant thereby sanctioning slum scheme on Project Property and Annexure II was certified. The plan includes the Subject Property. The 34 slum dwellers whose hutments were on the Subject Property were included in the Annexure II issued to the appellant.
15. A Public Notice dated 8th June, 2004 was issued by the SRA intimating the public at large that a Letter of Intent with respect to the Project Property including the Subject Property had been issued to Harishree Enterprises for rehabilitation and redevelopment of slum dwellers.
16. Thereafter four Rehabilitation Buildings were constructed between the year 2005 and 2011 and the Occupation Certificate (OC) for the fifth Rehabilitation building was issued by the SRA in the year 2022.
17. On 26 th February, 2015 (“2015 Order”), a detailed order came to be passed by the CEO-SRA after giving notice to and hearing to all the concerned including the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai, the then owner) inter alia holding that the Slum Scheme of the appellant had substantially been implemented on the entire area covering the Project Property admeasuring 12,606 sq. mts. (including the Subject Property) and that a substantial number of slum dwellers had already been accommodated and in furtherance of the slum scheme, the Subject Property was liable to be acquired in the interest of the slum scheme and the slum dwellers on the Subject Property had to be rehabilitated by the appellant. It further states that the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) would be entitled to monetary compensation amount after acquisition. The 2015 Order never came to be challenged by the respondent No.5 (Phuldai) and thus, has attained finality.
18. Accordingly, on the application filed by the society of the slum dwellers, a survey for demarcation of the Subject Property was carried out by [2025] 12 S.C.R. 323Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. the Officers of SRA and requests were made by the Slum Societies for acquisition of the Subject Property from time to time as per the 2015 Order. It is the case of the appellant that the Full Occupation Certificate for the sale building in favour of the appellant was not granted on the ground that the Subject Property of the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) was yet to be acquired under Section 14 of the Slum Act and handed over to MCGM.
19. On 26 th March, 2022, the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) sold the Subject Property to the respondent No. 4 (“Alchemi Developers”). According to the appellant, it was sold on the pretext that there are slum dwellers on the Subject Property who are required to be rehabilitated. It is alleged by the appellant that the subject property was sold with the knowledge that the slum scheme had already been implemented. However, the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) has now floated its own scheme giving a list of 34 persons, most of whom, according to the appellant, have already been rehabilitated.
20. The subject matter of the present dispute is only to the extent of 2005 sq. mts. i.e. the Subject Property which was owned by the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) and which has belatedly been acquired by another builder, i.e. respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) on 26 th March, 2022 with knowledge that the Slum Scheme on the area of 12606.7 sq. mts., i.e. the Project Property, including Subject Property, had fully been implemented by rehabilitating 498 slum dwellers. It is the case of the appellant that the SRA has changed its earlier consistent stand till the issuance of letter dated 14 th March, 2022 only after the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) acquired rights from the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai), i.e. after March 2022.
21. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant invoked the writ jurisdiction of the High Court and questioned the legality and validity of the orders passed by the respondent No. 1 (CEO-SRA) granting sanction to the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) and refusal to implement the 2015 Order referred to above.
JUDGMENT OF THE HIGH COURT
22. The High Court first looked into Section 14(1) of the Slum Act. Section 14 relates to the power of State Government to acquire land. Section 14 of the Slum Act reads thus:- 324 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “14. Power of State Government to acquire land
(1) Where on any representation from the Competent Authority it appears to the State Government that, in order to enable the Authority to execute any work of improvement or to redevelop any slum area or any structure in such area, it is necessary that such area, or any land within adjoining or surrounded by any such area should be acquired the State Government may acquire the land by publishing in the Official Gazette, a notice to the effect that the State Government had decided to acquire the land in pursuance of this section:
Provided that, before publishing such notice, the State Government, or as the case may be, the Competent Authority may call upon by notice the owner of, or any other person who, in its or his opinion may be interested in, such land to show cause in writing why the land should not be acquired with reasons therefor, to the Competent Authority shall, with all reasonable despatch, forward any objections so submitted together with his report in respect thereof to the State Government and on considering the report and the objections, if any, the State Government may pass such order as it deems fit.
1(A) The acquisition of land for any purpose mentioned in sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be a public purpose.
(2) When a notice as aforesaid is published in the Official Gazette, the land shall, on and from the date on which the notice is so published, vest absolutely in the State Government free from all encumbrances.”
23. The High Court took notice of the proviso to Section 14 of the Slum Act which imposes an obligation on the State Government to consider the SRA’s report as well as the objections that might have been raised by the owner as regards the acquisition. Based on such material, the State Government would thereafter proceed to pass an appropriate order as it may deem fit. The High Court observed that the State could have proceeded with the acquisition subject to the conditions prescribed in the proviso contained under Section 14 of the Slum Act referred to above. The High Court recorded that indisputably [2025] 12 S.C.R. 325Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. the State Government had failed to take steps contemplated under Section 14(1) referred to above despite the order dated 26.02.2015. However, according to the High Court, it was too late in the day now for Jyoti Builders (appellant herein) to assert that the State Government should be directed to acquire the subject property. In other words, the finding returned by the High Court is that the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) was never called upon to develop the subject property in accordance with Section 14 of the Slum Act. The High Court noted that Jyoti Builders (appellant herein) had failed to take necessary steps for a period of seven years i.e. between 2015 and 2022. The High Court had also returned the finding that the attempt now being made by Jyoti Builders is to acquire the subject property by back door entry. If Jyoti Builders at all intended to acquire the subject property, it could have purchased it. It is when Jyoti Builders failed to purchase the subject property, then respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers purchased it.
24. The High Court thereafter considered the question whether the respondent No. 4 herein (Alchemi Developers) had submitted a scheme for the subject property. According to the appellant herein, the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) is responsible for dragging one and all to this litigation. The appellant has levelled serious allegations against the respondent No. 4 alleging that it managed with the authority concerned. However, the High Court returned the finding that since the rights of respondent No. 5 (Phuldai), the owner of the subject property, were yet to be adjudicated upon, the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) would be entitled to submit its scheme for redevelopment.
25. The third issue that the High Court addressed itself was whether the subject property was included in the slum scheme. In this regard, the High Court returned the finding that subject property is not included in the slum redevelopment scheme.
26. In such circumstances referred to above, the final conclusion arrived at by the High Court reads thus:- “14) Additionally, even as per Jyoti the benefits of subject property were excluded. Furthermore, in light of Citispace vs. State of Maharashtra (“Citispace”) Order dated 31” July 2002 in Writ Petition No 1152 of 2002 read together with the Order dated 25 th July 2014, no new scheme could be 326 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports implemented on the land reserved for garden. This was the view of the CEO SRA in Order dated 26th February 2015 where he noted the following:
“Further with regard to the land owned by Respondent No. 2 viz. Shrimati Phuldai R Yadav, the record shows that the said land is reserved for recreation ground and therefore the same cannot be developed in view of the order dated 31-7-2002 passed by the Honourable High Court at Bombay in Writ Petition No. 1152 of 2002 [Citispace v State of Maharashtra]. However since the land is occupied and encroached by the Slum Dwellers, they are required to be rehabilitated as Project Affected Persons and it is the responsibility of the developer to handover the RG plot of land to MCGM.”
It was only after 1st March 2022 that an owner could propose a scheme for such property. Therefore, the question of Phuldai attempting to propound a scheme post SRA’s order of 26th February 2015 does not arise.
15) Regarding the contention of Mr. Kadam that, the CEO SRA whilst passing the Order dated 3 rd October 2022 had reviewed the Order dated 26 th February 2015, - we reject it outrightly. We clarify that the CEO SRA acted solely in compliance with the Court’s directive to examine the contentions raised by Jyoti and Alchemi in Jyoti’s Petition itself, which opposed the implementation of S R Scheme on the subject property by Alchemi. The CEO SRA’s role was limited to addressing the rival contentions and did not involve reopening or reconsidering the earlier decision. Therefore Mr Kadam’s claim that the CEO SRA “reviewed” the matter is unfounded and is hereby rejected. Consequently, the judgements of Kapra Mazdoor Ekta Union (supra), Deoki Nandan Parashar (supra) and Chiranjilal Shrilal Goenka (supra) cited by Mr. Kadam will render no assistance to the Petitioner.
16) We agree with Mr. Chinoy’s argument that Jyoti has already benefitted from accommodating the slum dwellers [2025] 12 S.C.R. 327Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. under the scheme by receiving necessary FSI under the Rules. Therefore, the cost of relocation has effectively been compensated to Jyoti.
17) The AGRC has rightly asked the SRA to ‘look into’ the matter. We now expect that the SRA will not adopt a contrary stance, especially after recording that the slum dwellers on Phuldai’s plot have been already allocated apartments.
18) Considering the case from another perspective, in our view, first Harishree and now Jyoti’s intent appears on usurping Phuldai’s land in some form or manner and to deprive her of her legitimate benefit under the law.
18.1) It is undisputed that prior to the slum scheme proposed by Harishree, a MoU was entered into between Phuldai and Harishree with the intent to purchase Phuldai’s land for consideration. For reasons unknown, that MOU failed. However, Harishree proceeded with the slum scheme, assuming they would acquire Phuldai’s land at a later stage. A significant portion of the plot (approximately 1905 sq. mtrs.) remained vacant, as evidenced by the MOU. The LoI’s issued from time-to-time further confirm this fact. 19) A comparison of LoI dated 4 th June 2004 and 9 th August 2005 reveals that not only was the area of the plot reduced, but the number of slum dwellers slated for rehabilitation was also reduced from 574 to 472. It is undisputed that the conditions outlined in the LoIs required Harishree - and later Vikas - to produce title documents and clear the land concerning Phuldai Yadav’s plot. Since this was not accomplished, the utilization of the FSI was kept in abeyance.
20) Pausing here for a moment, we ask ourselves: what remained on the plot apart from FSI? There were only 34 slum dwellers on a specific portion of the subject property that needed rehabilitation. It is undisputed that this plot was reserved for garden and HD purposes, meaning that the land had to remain open and vacant. The FSI was, therefore, the only component to be utilised - either on the same plot or elsewhere.
328 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 21) As the FSI of the said plot was kept in abeyance, it raised a significant question about the land’s inclusion in the scheme. The LoIs clearly demonstrate that the SRA was not convinced about Harishree’s or Jyoti’s title to the subject property. Even the CEO SRA’s order dated 26th February 2015 noted that Jyoti will have to give clear title to MCGM. In our view it meant that Jyoti was required to acquire it and that which its predecessors had intended and based on which proposed the scheme.
22) We believe that Harishree and now Jyoti, assumed they would purchase the land from Phuldai and, in anticipation relocated the slum dwellers. However, the critical question is, if someone decides to relocate and clear the slum dwellers from someone else’s plot, can they subsequently claim beneficial rights of the plot? In our view, the answer is in the negative. Notably, Phuldai was never called upon to develop the subject property as per Section 14(1) of the Slums Act. There is an inexplicable delay in enforcing the 26 th February 2015 Order.
23) What Jyoti did during seven years between 2015 to 2022? In our opinion, seeking acquisition now appears to be an attempt at a backdoor entry. If Jyoti intended to acquire the property, they could have purchased it. They did not and Alchemi did. Therefore, any benefit or loss concerning the property rightfully belongs to Alchemi alone. 24) Jyoti cannot claim a right over the property simply because they rehabilitated the slum dwellers. At best, they are entitled to compensation, which, in our view, has already been provided by granting them an equivalent and/ or adequate area for sale.
25) We reiterate that we find no error or illegality in the AGRC’s findings that would warrant setting them aside. We thus concur with the findings of the AGRC. In view of the above deliberation, we find no merits in the Petition and therefore dismiss it.”
27. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant is here before this Court.
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 329Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
28. Mr. Shyam Divan, the learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant, broadly submitted the following:-
(a) Subject Property is not excluded from the appellant’s predecessor’s slum scheme of 1997 and the same continues to be an integral part of the appellant’s slum scheme till date.
(b) No new slum scheme could have been propounded and/ or sanctioned in favour of the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) as there are no slum dwellers to be rehabilitated.
(c) The SRA does not have jurisdiction to entertain or approve the respondent No. 4’s scheme.
(d) As per the appellant’s scheme, the entire subject property is required to be handed over to the MCGM as a Recreational Ground (i.e. open green land), whereas the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) has applied for slum rehabilitation scheme under DCPR 2034 and, if the same is approved, then the respondent No. 4 would construct upon 65% of the RG area and would keep only 35% vacant as RG. As per the learned senior counsel, this would lead to reduction of RG in the city of Mumbai which already has been very low per capita green spaces. In such circumstances, the respondent No. 4’s scheme ought not to have been accepted.
(e) A slum scheme in Mumbai was implemented as per Regulation 33(10) of DCR 1991 till 2018 and thereafter as per Regulation 33(10) of DCPR 2034 (both provisions are in pari materia). Appendix (IV) of DCR 1991 and DCPR 2034 allows redevelopment of slum properties by slum dwellers (self-redevelopment), through a developer, owner, public authorities or NGOs. Thus, consent of owner is not mandatory for implementation of slum scheme. In the event the owner does not consent or redevelop the property, it can be acquired by the State Government on the recommendation of the SRA. The owner gets compensation as per Section 17 of the Slum Act.
(f) By 2015 Order, the CEO-SRA could be said to have adjudicated the lis between the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) and the appellant. After hearing the respondent No. 5 (who belatedly objected to the continuation of implementation of slum scheme), and 330 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports considering the rival contentions between the parties, by the 2015 Order, the CEO-SRA held that the slum scheme of appellant has progressed substantially and therefore the Subject Property cannot be excluded from the scheme. The CEO-SRA saying so issued directions to the Dy. Collector SRA to take steps for acquiring the Subject Property under Section 14 of the Slum Act for the effective implementation of the appellant’s slum scheme. There was no challenge to the 2015 Order; the same attained finality; and as such, could not have been revisited either by the parties or slum authorities respectively. The respondent Nos. 4 (Alchemi Developers) and 5 (Phuldai) respectively were aware that the 2015 Order is binding on them. To overcome this, they have gone to the extent of misinterpreting the 2015 Order by misconstruing the words ‘carve out’. The words ‘carve out’ have to be read in the context of the finding and conclusion of the 2015 Order, which is to include the same and not exclude from the slum scheme. As such, the purport of 2015 Order is that the property should be “demarcated” i.e. carved out for the purpose of acquisition and handing over the same to BMC. The demarcation was already undertaken on 6 th October, 2016. The 2015 Order does not in any manner suggest “taking out” the Subject Property out of the appellant’s scheme.
(g) In such circumstances referred to above, the power of the SRA under Section 14 of the acquisition is also coupled with duty to acquire the Subject Property. Such a duty has been recognized by this Court in the case of (i) State of Uttar Pradesh v. Jogendra Singh, 1963 SCC OnLine SC 96, and (ii) State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu & Anr., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 770.
29. Mr. Divan, the learned senior counsel further highlighted the SRA’s diametrically opposite stance before and after the respondent No. 4 proposed its alleged illegal scheme which, according to him, is evident from the following:-
(a) From the year 1997 to 2022:
The SRA’s stand prior to Alchemi Developers coming in picture is as follows:
[2025] 12 S.C.R. 331Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors.
(i) All the LOIs issued by the SRA clearly show that the Subject Property is part of the appellant’s slum scheme.
(ii) The SRA included 34 slum dwellers on the Subject Property in the Annexure II of the appellant’s slum scheme.
(iii) The SRA directed rehabilitation of the said 34 slum dwellers in the rehab component of the appellant’s slum scheme.
(iv) By an Order dated 26 th February, 2015, the SRA directed acquisition of the Subject Property and stated that the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) would be entitled to monetary compensation after the acquisition.
(v) In pursuance of 2015 Order, the Subject Property was demarcated by CTS Officer on 6th June, 2015.
(vi) When the appellant requested for grant of Occupation Certificate in respect of the Sale Building No. 4, the SRA (respondent No.1) vide its letter dated 14 th March ,2022 stated that the request for Occupation Certificate cannot be granted as RG is not handed over and that the Subject Property is yet to be acquired under Section 14(1) of the Slum Act.
(vii) On 20 th April, 2022 the Tehsildar from the office of SRA gave an opinion stating that necessary steps towards acquisition should be taken with respect to the Subject Property as per 2015 Order and in fact enclosed a draft Notice to be issued under Section 14 (1) of the Slum Act and sent the same to the CEO-SRA for further process.
(viii) On 27 th May, 2022 the Chief Legal Consultant of SRA gave his opinion and stated that the Subject Property be acquired as per 2015 Order.
(ix) From 2015 till 2022, it was a consistent stand of the SRA that the Subject Property forms part of the appellant’s scheme and thus was required to be acquired under Section 14(1) of the Slum Act for the benefit of the Slum Scheme of the appellant.
332 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(b) Events post Alchemi Developers – respondent No. 4 coming into picture:-
30. According to Mr. Divan, the moment another builder i.e. respondent No. 4 came into picture and started pursing its slum scheme on the Subject Property, the office of SRA made a complete volte face which can be seen from the following:
(i) On 26th March, 2022 the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) sold the Subject Property to the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers).
(ii) Thereafter, in March-April 2022, the respondent No. 5 applied for implementation of the Slum Scheme on the Subject Property based on fraudulent list of slum dwellers (persons who were already rehabilitated by the appellant). The true and correct status of list of the slum dwellers submitted by the respondent No. 5 in its scheme is set out by the appellant. This list, relied upon by the appellant at every stage, from CEO-SRA to this Court, has not been denied by the respondent No. 4.
(iii) After respondent No. 4 started pursuing its slum scheme, the SRA made a complete volte face and started contending that the Subject Property is excluded from the slum scheme and 2015 Order need not be implemented, and the Subject Property should form part of the respondent No. 5’s scheme, despite holding that all the slum dwellers had already been rehabilitated.
(iv) After the new developer came into picture, the respondent No. 1 (SRA) has taken a stance which is contradictory to the order dated 26 th February, 2015 and the same amounts to review of its own order i.e. order of his predecessor.
31. According to Mr. Divan, the CEO-SRA (respondent No. 1) could not have taken the orders passed by his predecessor in review as no such power is provided under the statute. He would submit that the order dated 03.10.2022 passed by the CEO-SRA holding that acquisition of the Subject Property as per the 2015 Order need not be undertaken amounts to review of the 2015 Order directing acquisition of the Subject Property.
32. He would thereafter contend that the findings returned by the High Court to the effect that the appellant had already availed the FSI benefit insofar as rehabilitation of 34 slum dwellers is concerned [2025] 12 S.C.R. 333Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. could be said to be perverse. In this regard, he submitted that a perusal of the LOI would indicate that the entire FSI benefit arising out of the Subject Property is kept in abeyance. He would submit that the slum scheme is implemented by the developer under the Slum Act. The developer gets dual benefit - first rehabilitating the slum dwellers and secondly entitlement to FSI for implementation of slum scheme. He strongly contended that the entire FSI for the Subject Property has been kept in abeyance. He asserted that, on the other hand, the respondent No. 4 (Alchemi Developers) seeks benefit of the entire FSI without implementing the slum scheme or the clearing slum. According to Mr. Divan, this is something absolutely illegal.
33. In the last, Mr. Divan contended that the respondent Nos. 4 and 5 respectively have misled this Court by submitting that 34 slum dwellers on the subject property have been rehabilitated as Project Affected Persons i.e. PAPs. According to him, the slum dwellers of the subject property are part of Annexure II issued to the appellant and therefore they have been rehabilitated in rehab component under the slum scheme and cannot be rehabilitated as PAPs as per the orders and directions of the respondent No. 1.
34. In such circumstances referred to above, Mr. Divan, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant herein submitted that there being merit in his appeal, the same may be allowed and appropriate relief may be granted.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT NOS. 1 and 2
35. Mr. Siddharth Dharmadhikari, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 respectively vehemently submitted that no error, not to speak of any error of law, could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned judgment and order.
36. It was submitted that the subject property does not form part of the appellant’s slum scheme. As per Regulation 33(10) of DCR 1991 and Guidelines issued in the year 1997, a slum scheme could have been submitted only with the consent of the “owner” or after acquiring the same in accordance with Section 14(1) of the Slum Act.
37. It was argued that indisputably the true and correct position in tabular format is as under:- 334 [2025] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Sr.
No.
Plot No. Map @ pg. 1004 Area Sq. m.
Purpose
1. CTS No. 620/A/1A/1A/3 Dark Green 2700 Owned by appellant & included in Scheme.
Satisfies the RG requirement.
2. CTS No. 620/A/1A/1B/1 CTS No. 620/A/1A/1B/2 Light Green 2005 Owned by R4 and excluded from scheme on 04.04.2000 on request of predecessor of appellant
38. It was argued that indisputably the respondent No. 5 namely Phuldai was the owner of the subject property. According to the learned counsel, the predecessor in title of the appellant had misrepresented to have obtained the consent from the owner i.e. Phuldai on the basis of an unregistered MOU between the appellant’s predecessor (Harishree Enterprises) and the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai). It was pointed out that the records reveal that the respondent No. 5 (Phuldai) had terminated the unregistered MOU in 1995 itself. Such termination was challenged by Harishree Enterprises before the Civil Court by filing Civil Suit No. 1514 of 1995 which later came to be dismissed.
39. In so far as obtaining occupation certificate for the Final Sale Building in Slum Scheme is concerned, the learned counsel submitted that the appellant is not required to hand over the subject property. It was submitted that it is absolutely incorrect on the part of the appellant to say that the appellant has been put to a specific condition to acquire or hand over the Light Green portion i.e. subject property (2005 sq. m.) for further compliance of Full Occupation Certificate.
40. It was vehemently submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 respectively that since the subject property stood excluded from its Slum Scheme, the respondent No. 1 could not have insisted on any such condition for the purpose of issuing [2025] 12 S.C.R. 335Jyoti Builders v. Chief Executive Officer & Ors. the occupation certificate. However, it was clarified that the appellant was liable to hand over the Dark Green Portion admeasuring 2700 sq. mts. as Recreational Ground (RG).
41. It was argued that in accordance with the direction issued by the respondent No. 1 vide order dated 26.02.2015 the appellant had declared the 34 slum dwellers residing on the subject property as Project Affected Persons (PAPs). In lieu of the appellant handing over PAP’s to SRA, the appellant has been compensated in accordance with the policy with equivalent FSI for Sale Component. The appellant had already utilised such FSI generated against PAP and had constructed its Final Sale Building.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.