Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 590; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 345
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 8 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2828/2023
- Sections
- 302, 120B, 161, 162, 26, 21, 27, 323, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 345 : 2024 INSC 590 Allarakha Habib Memon Etc.
v.
State of Gujarat (Criminal Appeal Nos. 2828-2829 of 2023)
08 August 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration As per the FIR (Exhibit-79) there were two eyewitnesses to the incident, PW-12-Police Constable and PW-11-the first informant who was deceased’s cousin brother. PW-12 claiming to be an eyewitness to the incident had reported at the police station with the crime weapons however, he did not lodge any complaint of the incident. FIR was registered on the basis of the oral statement of PW-11. Testimony of the aforesaid witnesses, if was trustworthy and reliable. In view of inconsistencies and contradictions in the evidences, whether the conviction of the accused-appellants under Section 302 read with Section 120B, Penal Code, 1860 and their sentence was justified.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302 r/w s.120B – Concurrent conviction of the accused-appellants – Various inconsistencies and contradictions in evidences – Guilt of the accused appellants if proved beyond doubt:
Held: No – First informant-PW-11 was not present at the crime scene – Evidence of PW-12-an independent witness makes the very presence of PW-11 at the crime scene doubtful – Testimony of PW-11, the star witness of prosecution is thus, not trustworthy and reliable as the same was contradicted on material aspects by numerous material facts and circumstances – Testimony of the Police Constable-PW-12 also does not help the prosecution in linking the accused-appellant with the crime – It is improbable and totally unacceptable that a police constable had seen the incident and also brought the crime weapons to the police station and yet his statement would not be recorded and the factum of presentation of weapons would not be entered in the daily diary (roznamcha) of the police station – Non-production of the daily * Author 346 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports diary is a serious omission on part of the prosecution – Further, on facts, identification of the accused by PW-12 for the first time in the dock is unbelievable and unacceptable – Also, on a careful perusal of the complaint (Exhibit P-79) filed by PW-11 which was subsequently registered as the FIR, it is manifest that no time of recording was mentioned thereupon – There was no endorsement as to the date and time on which the said FIR reached the Court concerned – Going by the testimony of PW-11, the actual complaint filed by him at the police station seems to have been withheld and the FIR was a post investigation document and seems to have been created at a later point of time – Furthermore, neither the disclosure statements made by the accused were proved as per law nor the same resulted into any discovery which could be accepted as incriminating inasmuch as the requisite link evidence was never presented by the prosecution so as to establish that the recovered articles remained in the self-safe condition from the date of the seizure till the same reached the FSL – Prosecution failed to lead convincing evidence establishing the guilt of the accused appellants beyond doubt so as to hold the appellants responsible for the crime – Impugned judgments quashed and set aside – Appellants acquitted by giving them the benefit of doubt. [Paras 19, 20, 22, 23, 25, 28, 31, 36-38, 46, 48] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss.161, 162 – Police Constable-PW-12 claiming to be an eyewitness to the incident reported at the police station with the crime weapons however, he did not submit any report/complaint of the incident – Complaint lodged by PW-11-first informant who was deceased’s cousin brother came to be registered as FIR – Impermissibility:
Held: First version of the incident as narrated by the PW-12 would be required to be treated as the FIR and the complaint lodged by PW-11 would be relegated to the category of a statement u/s.161, CrPC and nothing beyond that – The same could not have been treated to be the FIR as it would be hit by s.162 CrPC – Prosecution is thus, guilty of concealing the initial version from the Court and hence, an adverse inference is drawn against the prosecution on this count. [Para 21] Evidence Act, 1872 – ss.26, 21 – Confessions of the accusedappellants recorded by PW-2-Medical Officer while preparing their injury reports of the accused – Admissibility:
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 347Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat Held: The so-called confessions are ex-facie inadmissible in evidence as the accused persons were presented at the hospital by the police officers after having been arrested in the present case – As such, the notings made by PW-2 in the injury reports of the accused would be clearly hit by s.26 – Therefore, the said admissions of the accused not accepted as incriminating pieces of evidence relevant u/s.21. [Para 41] Evidence – Seizure panchnama, FSL Reports – Reliance upon – When not proper – Seizure panchnama recorded that the accused threw away their weapons and fled away from the crime scene and that all the weapons were brought to the police station by police personnel – Reliance placed by Courts below on FSL reports to hold that blood group found on the crime weapons incriminated the accused for the crime as the same matched with the blood group of the deceased – Correctness:
Held: Various infirmities create a doubt on the very process of seizure of the weapons – Seizure panchnama (Exhibit -38) does not bear the signatures of PW-12-police constable who admittedly collected the weapons from the crime scene and presented them to the police station – Thus, no credence can be given to seizure panchnama because it was not attested by the witness who had actually presented the weapons at the police station – Trial Court as well as the High Court heavily relied upon the FSL reports (Exhibits 111-115) for finding corroboration to the evidence of the eyewitnesses and in drawing a conclusion regarding culpability of the appellants for the crime however, the testimony of the so-called eyewitnesses is discarded being doubtful – Thus, even presuming that the FSL reports conclude that the blood group found on the weapons recovered at the instance of the accused matched with the blood group of the deceased, this circumstance in isolation, cannot be considered sufficient so as to link the accused with the crime – Further, the IO-PW18’s evidence on the aspect of disclosure statements made by the accused-appellant leading to the recoveries is perfunctory and unacceptable – The witness did not elaborate upon the words spoken by the accused-appellant at the time of making the disclosure statements. [Paras 42-44] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.27 – Disclosure as regards the place of incident irrelevant when crime scene was already known to police:
348 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Held: In the present case, the circumstance regarding identification of place of incident at the instance of the accused was inadmissible because the crime scene was already known to the police and no new fact was discovered in pursuance of the disclosure statements – Thus, since the place of incident was known to police, this disclosure was irrelevant. [Paras 41, 45] Constitution of India – Article 136 – Concurrent findings by courts below – Exercise of jurisdiction u/Article 136: Held: While exercising jurisdiction under Article 136 this Court will not interfere with the concurrent findings recorded by the courts below – However, where the evidence has not been properly appreciated, material aspects have been ignored and the findings are perverse, this Court would certainly interfere with the findings of the courts below though concurrent. [Para 47] Case Law Cited State of A.P. v. Punati Ramulu and Others (1994) Supp 1 SCC 590; Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar and Others v. State of Karnataka [2024] 5 SCR 174 : (2024) OnLine SC 561; Mustkeem alias Sirajudeen v. State of Rajasthan [2011] 9 SCR 101 : (2011) 11 SCC 724 – relied on.
Tomaso Bruno & Anr. v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2015] 1 SCR 721 : (2015) 7 SCC 178; Amrik Singh v. State of Punjab [2022] 7 SCR 451 : (2022) 9 SCC 402; Animireddy Venkata Ramana & Ors. v. Public Prosecutor, High Court of Andhra Pradesh [2008] 3 SCR 1078 : (2008) 5 SCC 368 – referred to.
List of Acts Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Eyewitnesses; So-called eyewitnesses; Projected eyewitness; Concurrent findings by courts below; Concurrent conviction; Crime weapons; Weapons of offence; Identification of the accused; Test Identification Parade; FIR was a post investigation document; Disclosure statements made by the accused not proved; Admissions of the accused not incriminating pieces of evidence; Guilt of the accused not proved beyond doubt; Seizure panchnama, FSL Reports;Confessions of the accused; Confessions ex-facie [2024] 8 S.C.R. 349Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat inadmissible in evidence; No new fact discovered in pursuance of disclosure statements; Identification of place of incident at the instance of accused inadmissible; Crime scene already known to police.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos. 2828- 2829 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.02.2019 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in CRLAP Nos.450 and 563 of 2015 With Criminal Appeal No. 112 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Divyesh Pratap Singh, Ms. Shivangi Singh, Amit Sangwan, Rishi Malhotra, Utkarsh Singh, Praveen Chaturvedi, Advs. for the Appellants.
Ms. Deepanwita Priyanka, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. The instant criminal appeals have been filed by the appellants namely, Allarakha Habib Memon, Amin @ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon and Mohmedfaruk @ Palak Safibhai Memon, for assailing the common judgment dated 18th February, 2019, passed by the Division Bench of High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad dismissing the Criminal Appeal Nos. 94 of 2015, 450 of 2015 and 563 of 2015, preferred by the accused appellants and affirming the judgment and order dated 13 th October, 2014 passed by the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Anand, in Sessions Case No. 84 of 2011 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’). The trial Court had convicted the appellants for offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter, referred to as ‘IPC’) and sentenced them to imprisonment for life with fine of Rs. 1,000/- each, 350 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in default whereof, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of three months. At the same time, the appellants were acquitted of the charge for the offence punishable under Section 323 IPC. Brief facts: -
3. The accused appellants are the residents of New Memon Colony, Bhalej Road, Anand. There was some issue regarding the supply of water in the residential blocks where the accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak was residing. On 3 rd May 2011, a meeting was convened in this regard wherein, an altercation flared up between the accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak and Mohammad Sohail. It is alleged that Mohmedfaruk @ Palak hurled abuses and used foul language against Mohammad Sohail, who in turn intimated the society members that he may be relieved from the duty of supplying water in the society. A meeting with respect to the intimation given by Mohammad Sohail was convened by the members of the society, wherein Mohammad Sohail insulted accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak, who started carrying a grudge against Mohammad Sohail on this account. Resultantly, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak conspired with the accused Amin @ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon and Allarakha Habib Memon and hatched a plan to eliminate Mohammad Sohail. As per the prosecution, acting in furtherance of the above conspiracy, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak collected arms like gupti, daggers etc., and concealed the same in the dicky of his scooter. On 4 th May, 2011 at around 8:00 pm, Mohammad Sohail, along with his first cousin namely, Mohammad Arif Memon (the first informant), had proceeded to Shah petrol pump on a two wheeler, where they got the vehicle refuelled, and then both proceeded towards their residence, by taking a turn towards Bhalej overbridge. On the way, the accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak stopped them on the pretext of asking mobile number of one Mohammad Hussain. Taking advantage of the situation, the accused appellants launched an indiscriminate assault upon Mohammad Sohail with sharp edged weapons, causing injuries on his head and chest regions. Mohammad Arif Memon tried to intervene, upon which he was given a push by Mohmedfaruk @ Palak and fell down. Mohmedfaruk @ Palak took out a big knife and inflicted a blow with a sharp weapon on the back of Mohammad Sohail. Upon hearing the noise of the commotion, people from nearby gathered at the place of occurrence whereupon the accused appellants fled away, abandoning their weapons at [2024] 8 S.C.R. 351Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat the crime scene. Mohammad Sohail having been severely injured was shifted to a hospital, where he was declared dead.
4. Incorporating the above allegations, the first informant Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11), first cousin of Mohammed Sohail (deceased) lodged a complaint (Exhibit P-79) being CR No. 141 of 2011 on 4 th May, 2011 which came to be registered as FIR at Anand Town Police Station for the offences punishable under Sections 302 and 323 IPC read with Section 120B IPC. The investigation of the case was assigned to Dhananjaysinh Surendrasinh Waghela, Police Inspector (PW-18) (hereinafter being referred to as ‘Investigating Officer’).
5. Inquest panchnama (Exhibit P-25) was prepared and the dead body of Mohammad Sohail was sent for postmortem. Dr. Swapnil (PW-1) conducted autopsy taking note of 29 injuries all over the body of the deceased-Mohammad Sohail. He issued the post-mortem report (Exhibit P-12) opining that the cause of death of Mohammad Sohail was due to shock attributed to multiple injuries all over the body. The first informant-Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) was medically examined by the Medical Officer, Dr. Arvindbhai (PW-2) who after examining him, issued a medical certificate (Exhibit P-17).
6. The Investigating Officer (PW-18) carried out the usual investigation and prepared a site plan (Exhibit P-27) of the place of occurrence. The accused appellants were arrested after about five days from the date of incident. Clothes worn by the accused appellants were collected by drawing panchnama (Exhibit P-40). The Investigating Officer (PW-18) reconstructed the crime scene at the instance of all accused-appellants and drew demonstration panchnama (Exhibit P-50). The effected recovery of one big knife at the instance of accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak; the blood-stained clothes of the deceased and the recovered weapons were forwarded to the Forensic Science Laboratory (in short ‘FSL’) for chemical analysis. The Investigating Officer (PW-18) also collected call detail records from service provider i.e. Vodafone. After conclusion of the investigation, a charge was filed against the accused appellants for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 323 and 120B IPC.
7. The offence under Section 302 IPC being exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, the case was committed and made over for trial to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Anand, where it came 352 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to be registered as Sessions Case No. 84 of 2011. Charges were framed against the accused appellants for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 323 and 120B IPC. The accused-appellants pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 18 witnesses and exhibited 131 documents in order to bring home the charges. On being questioned under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘CrPC’) and upon being confronted with the allegations as appearing in the prosecution case, the accused appellants denied the same and took a categorical stance that they had been falsely implicated in the case. However, no evidence was led in defence.
8. After hearing the arguments put forth by the prosecution and the defence counsel and upon appreciating the evidence available on record, the trial Court, vide judgement and order dated 13 th October, 2014 convicted and sentenced the accused appellants as mentioned above. The judgment of conviction and the order of sentence was challenged by the accused appellants before the Division Bench of Gujarat High Court by filing separate criminal appeals, which came to be rejected vide a common judgment dated 18 th February, 2019, which has been subjected to challenge in the instant batch of appeals by special leave.
9. Since the appeals arise out of a common judgement, the same were heard and are being decided by this judgement.
Submissions on behalf of the accused-appellants:-
10. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the accused appellants advanced the following submissions beseeching the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the impugned judgments and acquit the accused appellants of the charges: - 10.1 Demistalkumar, Police Constable (PW-12), projected to be an eyewitness of the incident, was admittedly the first to reach the police station with two weapons collected from the crime scene at 9:15 pm. However, surprisingly, his statement was either not recorded or if recorded, the same never saw the light of the day. The FIR (Exhibit P-79) which ought to have been registered on the earliest version of Demistalkumar (PW-12) was lodged at a much later point of time on the basis of a statement given by the first informant, Mohammad [2024] 8 S.C.R. 353Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat Arif Memon (PW-11) to S.N. Ghori, Police Sub-Inspector (PW-17) at 11:00 pm. The fact that Demistalkumar (PW-12) had reached the police station at the earliest point of time along with the weapons used in the crime is admitted by the prosecution and is fortified by the evidence of panch witness, Mohammad Hussain (PW-5), who stated that he was informed by the police that a person named Demistalkumar (PW-12) had produced the weapons at 9:15 pm.
10.2 Demistalkumar (PW-12) admitted in his cross-examination that after reaching the police station, an enquiry was made from him by the higher officials. As Demistalkumar (PW-12) is projected to be an eyewitness who had produced the weapons used in commission of the crime and had also been questioned about the incident at the police station at the earliest point of time, his statement which presumably was the first detailed disclosure about the incident, would have assumed the character of an FIR. However, his statement was never brought on record, which tantamounted to deliberate concealment by the prosecution. These proceedings which took place at the police station would definitely have been recorded in the daily diary (roznamcha) maintained at the police station. However, these vital aspects of the case have been intentionally withheld by the prosecution who failed to produce the corresponding daily diary entry before the Court, warranting an adverse inference to be drawn. In support of this contention, learned counsel placed reliance on a judgment rendered by this Court in the case of Tomaso Bruno & Anr. v. State of Uttar Pradesh. 1 It was urged that the statement of Demistalkumar (PW-12) was legally required to be treated as the first and foremost information.
10.3 That the explanation offered by Demistalkumar (PW-12), for not lodging the FIR of the incident, stating that an another person was already present there at the police station at 9:15 pm for giving the complaint, is falsified by the testimony of S.N. Ghori, Police Sub-Inspector (PW-17), who testified on oath that the statement of first informant, Mohammad Arif 1 [2015] 1 SCR 721 : (2015) 7 SCC 178 354 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Memon (PW-11) was reduced into writing by him at Krishna Medical Hospital, Karamsad at 11:00 pm.
10.4 That the evidence of Demistalkumar (PW-12) also creates grave doubt about the very presence of the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) at the place of incident, as the witness clearly stated in his evidence that he saw only the injured lying at the crime scene in a profusely bleeding condition.
10.5 That Demistalkumar (PW-12) made gross improvements in his evidence while identifying the three appellants in the dock for the first time after a span of more than two and a half years. The witness admitted in his cross-examination that he had not provided any details in his statement, recorded under Section 161 CrPC, about the identity of assailants. The identification in the dock without any Test Identification Parade (TIP) is a weak and unreliable piece of evidence. In support of this submission, learned counsel placed reliance on the judgment rendered by this Court in the case of Amrik Singh v. State of Punjab. 2 10.6 That K.N. Waghela, Head Constable (PW-16), posted at the Anand Town Police Station admitted in his cross-examination that a telephonic wardhi about the incident was noted down by him. However, the witness was not in a position to recollect the exact time of recording of the telephonic wardhi. The witness stated that it was mentioned in the telephonic wardhi, that an indiscriminate assault with sword and other sharp weapons had been made upon Mohammad Sohail (deceased). It was admitted by the witness in his cross-examination, that no reference of a sword was made in the FIR. It was also admitted that there was no reference of dagger and gupti in the telephonic wardhi. It was contended that the daily dairy entry pertaining to the recording of the telephonic wardhi was also not produced on record by the prosecution which tantamounts to concealment of vital facts requiring adverse inference to be drawn against the prosecution.
2 [2022] 7 SCR 451 : (2022) 9 SCC 402 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 355Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat 10.7 That the information about the commission of crime had been received at the police station at 9:15 pm, is clear from the evidence of Demistalkumar (PW-12) and therefore, the statement of the first informant (PW-11) recorded by S.N. Ghori, PSI (PW-17) at a later point of time, would tantamount to a statement under Section 161 CrPC and resultantly, it will be hit by Section 162 CrPC. In support of this contention, learned counsel placed reliance on a judgment rendered by this Court in the case of Animireddy Venkata Ramana & Ors. v. Public Prosecutor, High Court of Andhra Pradesh.3 10.8 Mustaq (PW-13), another projected eyewitness to the incident, deposed that he was also present at the place of occurrence and had seen the accused appellants assaulting the deceased. The witness, while deposing on oath, made grave improvements in his testimony inasmuch as in his previous statement under Section 161 CrPC, he had clearly stated that he was at his house at the time of alleged incident and that he received a call from the father of the deceased, Mohammad Iqbal Memon (PW-14), about the attack made on the deceased. Thus, Mustaq (PW-13) spoke a blatant lie in his deposition while trying to assume the status of an eyewitness without actually being present at the crime scene. His claim in this regard is further belied by the testimony of Mohammad Iqbal Memon (PW-14), who stated on oath that it was he who had informed Mustaq (PW-13) about the incident. It was contended that if at all Mustaq (PW-13) was present at the place of incident, then he would have been the one to inform the father of the deceased, Mohammad Iqbal Memon (PW-14) about the incident and not the other way around. 10.9 That the evidence of Demistalkumar (PW-12) and K.N. Waghela, Head Constable (PW-16) completely contradicts the evidence of the so-called eyewitnesses Mustaq (PW-13) and first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) and brings their presence at the crime scene under a grave shadow of doubt. 10.10 That the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11), stated on oath that two other persons, namely, Mehboob Abdul 3 [2008] 3 SCR 1078 : (2008) 5 SCC 368 356 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Rehman Memon and Irfanbhai Memon, being the colleagues of the deceased were also present at the spot. However, these two persons were not examined in evidence for reasons best known to the prosecution.
10.11 That the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) did not make any claim in the FIR that he too had sustained an injury in the alleged incident. However, he later claimed that he was also injured in the incident, upon which he was medically examined on the next day of the incident by Dr. Arvindbhai (PW-2). The doctor (PW-2) admitted in his cross-examination that the injury No.2 could be the result of itching and scratching. 10.12 That the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) claimed in his evidence that he lifted the victim and placed him in a rickshaw, after he had been indiscriminately assaulted by the accused appellants using sharp weapons. However, he admitted not having received any blood stains either on his person or on his clothes, which was bound to happen if he had actually assisted in boarding the profusely bleeding victim on to the rickshaw.
10.13 That none of the so-called eyewitnesses were actually present at the crime scene; they never saw the incident and a case of blind murder had been foisted upon the accused appellants because of prior enmity.
10.14 That the trial Court and the High Court heavily relied on the circumstance that the accused appellants had collected weapons in the dicky of the scooter. However, neither any scooter was recovered by the police nor did any witness gave evidence in support of the above allegation. This circumstance which the prosecution banked upon heavily in order to bring home the charge of criminal conspiracy against the accusedappellant was not substantiated by any tangible evidence. 10.15 That as per the prosecution, the accused appellants were arrested by the police on 9 th May, 2011 i.e. after 5 days from the date of alleged incident at a short distance from Memon Colony, where the accused-appellants reside, while they were trying to flee away on a motorcycle. It is highly improbable that the accused-appellants, after committing such a grave [2024] 8 S.C.R. 357Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat crime would continue to reside in close vicinity of the crime scene. Had there been any iota of truth in the prosecution case, the police would have arrested the accused immediately after the incident because they were all along available at their respective homes which are located just nearby to the place of incident.
10.16 That the recoveries/discoveries made at the instance of the accused-appellants are fabricated and were not proved by convincing/tangible evidence.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent-State: -
11. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the accused-appellants. Learned counsel for the respondent-State advanced the following submissions craving dismissals of the appeals:- 11.1 That the prosecution case is based on clinching testimony of eyewitnesses which is corroborated in material particulars by the evidence of Dr. Swapnil (PW-1) and so also the incriminating recoveries effected by the Investigating Officer (PW-18).
11.2 That the FIR (Exhibit P-79) was lodged with utmost promptitude i.e. within two and a half hours of the incident. The accused appellants were named in the FIR. The first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) had no motive whatsoever to falsely implicate the accused appellants for the crime. The promptitude in lodging of the FIR lends succour to the prosecution case.
11.3 That it is an admitted case that a day before the incident, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak and Mohammad Sohail (deceased)
had indulged in a quarrel during a meeting owing to the issue of shortage of water in the colony. Being enraged by this controversy, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak conspired with Amin @ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon and Allarakha Habib Memon and launched the pre-planned indiscriminate attack upon Mohammad Sohail, causing fatal injuries, leading to his death, and causing injuries to the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11).
358 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 11.4 That the attack on the deceased was pre-mediated and gruesome, inasmuch as, 29 injuries were caused to the deceased by sharp and blunt weapons and no part of his body was spared. The injuries so inflicted upon Mohammed Sohail (deceased) proved instantaneously fatal which fact was duly proved by Dr. Swapnil (PW-1).
11.5 That Dr. Arvindbhai, Medical Officer (PW-2) proved the injuries of the first informant Mohammad Arif Memon (PW- 11) which corroborates the presence of the witness (PW-11) with the deceased at the crime scene. In addition, thereto, Dr. Arvindbhai (PW-2) also examined and proved the injuries sustained by the accused appellants during the incident which again corroborates the prosecution case regarding active participation of the accused appellants in the incident. 11.6 That the prosecution led clinching evidence to establish the guilt of the accused and therefore, the trial Court was justified in convicting the accused-appellants as above. The High Court too did not commit any error while affirming the judgment of the trial Court and upholding the conviction of the appellants herein.
11.7 That two competent Courts sifted and made detailed analysis of the entire evidence and thereafter, have recorded concurrent findings of facts, holding the accused appellants guilty of the charges, and thus, this Court should not feel persuaded to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, so as to interfere in the well-reasoned judgments rendered by the trial Court and the High Court.
12. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have perused the impugned judgments. We have minutely scanned the record with the assistance of the learned counsels representing the parties.
Discussion and Conclusions: -
13. As per the prosecution case, the FIR (Exhibit-79) was registered on 4 th May, 2011 at 11:00 pm on the basis of the oral statement given by the first informant Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) to S.N. Ghori, PSI (PW-17) at Krishna Medical Hospital, Karamsad. The first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11) deposed in [2024] 8 S.C.R. 359Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat his testimony that an incident had taken place on 3 rd May, 2011 in their colony wherein, allegedly Mohammad Sohail (deceased) made some imputations against Mohmedfaruk, thereby annoying the accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak. On the next day, i.e., on 4th May, 2011 at about 8:30 pm, the first informant (PW-11) along with his cousin Mohammad Sohail (deceased) had gone to Shah petrol pump, near Bhalej Road overbridge for filling petrol in their scooter. Having refuelled the scooter, they proceeded towards the Bhalej overbridge for going home. At that point of time, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak came around and asked for the mobile number of Mohammad Hussain, a friend of the first informant (PW-11) who used to reside at Bangalore. The first informant (PW-11) stopped the vehicle and was trying to look for the number of Mohammad Hussain saved in his mobile at which point of time, the accused Amin@ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon and Allarakha Habib Memom also reached there. Accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak insinuated as to why Mohammad Sohail had insulted him in the meeting convened earlier in the Memon colony to discuss the issue of water. Amin@ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon suddenly took out a big knife concealed on his person and inflicted a blow thereof on the head of Mohammad Sohail (deceased). Allarakha Habib Memon took out a gupti and after removing the cover thereof, inflicted a blow on the head of Mohammad Sohail who started running towards the petrol pump in order to escape. Mohmedfaruk @ Palak also chased Mohammad Sohail, whereupon, the first informant (PW- 11) tried to intervene, but he was given a push by Mohmedfaruk @ Palak and fell down as a result. Accused Mohmedfaruk @ Palak also took out a big knife being carried by him and inflicted a blow thereof on the back of Mohammad Sohail after chasing him down. Having received multiple injuries in the assault laid by the accused appellants, Mohammad Sohail fell down on the road just outside the petrol pump. A policeman was present near the petrol pump who came running towards Mohammad Sohail and on seeing him, the three assailants started running away with their weapons. In the intervening period, Mehboob Abdul Rehman Memon and Irfanbhai Memon, colleagues of Mohammad Sohail also arrived at the spot. Accused Allarakha Habib Memon and Amin @ Lalo Aarifbhai Memon threw down their weapons whereas, Mohmedfaruk @ Palak ran away carrying the knife held by him. The first informant (PW-11) noticed large number of injuries on the body of Mohammad Sohail. Someone stopped a rickshaw wherein; Mohammad Sohail was boarded, and 360 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports he was taken to Anand Nagar Palika Hospital for treatment. On reaching the hospital, they came to know that the doctor was on leave on which, the first informant (PW-11) gave a call to his uncle Mohammed Iqbal Memon (father of the deceased) who came to the Anand Nagar Palika Hospital with a Maruti van. Mohammad Sohail was placed in the van and was taken to Krishna Medical Hospital, Karamsad for treatment where the duty Doctor examined him and declared that he had expired. The first informant (PW-11) stated that when Mohammad Sohail was being taken in the van, at that time, he, Mohammad Sohail’s father Mohammed Iqbal Memon, Sikander Abdul Karim Chokshi, Munafbhai Farooqbhai Memon and Mustaq Mohammad Siddiqbhai Memon were also present in the vehicle. The aforesaid oral statement was treated to be the complaint (Exhibit P-79) and came to be registered as the formal FIR.
14. Apparently, going by the allegations made in the FIR (Exhibit P-79), there were two eyewitnesses to the incident, namely, the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11), and the Police Constable, Demistalkumar (PW-12) who were present at the petrol pump.
15. Before dealing with the evidence of the first informant, Mohammad Arif Memon (PW-11), we would like to allude to the testimony of the Police Constable, Demistalkumar (PW-12) who is indisputably an independent witness having no interest either in the complainant party or the accused party. The relevant extracts from the evidence of Demistalkumar (PW-12) are reproduced hereinbelow for the sake of ready reference: - Examination-in-Chief:
“Since last 3 years I am discharging duty at Anand Town Police Station at L.R. Police constable.
On 4/5/11, I was having my duty at Shah Petrol Pump which is situated towards Anand at Bhalej bridge between morning hours 10 to 2400 (sic). At 8:30 o’ clock in the night, I came to know that some scuffle has taken place opposite Radhaswami Chamber. Hence I came on road from Shah Petrol Pump. Once person was found lying there in bleeding condition. He had fallen down at small garden near Mahendra Shah Petrol Pump and 3 persons were running towards him to beat him. They were having weapons like knife and Gupti. Upon seeing me, 2 persons [2024] 8 S.C.R. 361Allarakha Habib Memon Etc. v. State of Gujarat out of the 3 had thrown away their weapons and 3 rd person ran away towards the bridge. Thereafter the person who was having bleeding was made to sit in the rickshaw and was sent for treatment. His relative came and the weapons were deposited at police station. I came to know that the person who was having bleeding had passed away at Shri Krusna hospital. Police had taken my statement once only. I had presented one big knife and Gupti at police station and I can recognise those weapons if I am shown those weapons.”
… “I can identify 3 persons which I have mentioned. Upon being asked to 1 st identified 2 accused out of the persons present in the court today, he identifies 2 accused. One of them is Amin Arif Memon and another one is Farooq Safi Memon.”
Cross-examination:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.