Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 488; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 333
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 9 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 696/2010
- Sections
- 452, 311, 165, 364A, 392, 120B, 161, 27, 313, 106, 114, 173
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 333 : 2024 INSC 488 Gaurav Maini v.
The State of Haryana (Criminal Appeal No(S). 696 of 2010)
09 July 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Courts below, if justified in convicting and sentencing the appellants for the offences punishable u/ss. 364A, 392 and 120B IPC. Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 364A, 392 and 120B – Kidnapping for ransom – Robbery – Prosecution case that the appellants kidnapped a minor boy for ransom and robbed him, and on payment of ransom of Rs. One crore, the boy was released – FIR was registered by police on the basis of the secret information received by them while patrolling about such offences – Pursuant thereto, first disclosure of the incident made by the grandfather to the Investigating Officer, however, FIR was not registered regarding the alleged kidnapping of the boy – Conviction and sentence of the appellants for the offences punishable u/ss. 364A, 392 and 120B by the trial court – Upheld by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: Entire prosecution story totally concocted and does not inspire confidence – Inherent improbabilities in the versions of the two star prosecution witnesses-father of the kidnapped boy and the kidnapped boy – Prosecution failed to examine the most relevant witness-grandfather which compels the Court to draw an adverse inference against the prosecution – No convincing evidence led by the prosecution to connect the accused persons with the suspected mobile numbers – FIR could not have been registered on the basis of the secret information received by SI because the said information did not disclose the commission of any cognizable offence – If at all, the FIR had to be registered, on the basis of the statement of grandfather recorded by the police officials – However, no such steps taken by the police officials, thus, creates doubt on the bona fides of the actions of the Investigating Agency – Complainant party * Author 334 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports failed to offer logical explanation for failing to file an FIR even after the kidnapped boy had returned home – Delay in taking legal action creates a grave doubt on the truthfulness of the entire prosecution case – Kidnapped boy though knew accused A2 from before and claims to have identified him at the time of the incident however did not disclose his name to the police officials till the statement was recorded by the investigating officer – Also omission of the names of the accused persons in the special report – Furthermore, identification of the accused by the boy not free from doubt – Prosecution case failed to led trustworthy evidence to establish the recovery of the currency notes at the instance of the accused because the disclosure statements were not proved as per law – Currency notes were handed back to father without any order of the Court which is an act of gross misconduct on the part of the Investigating Officer – High Court as well as the trial court failed to advert to these important loopholes and shortcomings in the evidence available on record which are fatal to the prosecution case – Prosecution case is fabricated and the accused were framed in the case for ulterior motive – No iota of truth in the prosecution story – Thus, conviction of the accused appellants by the trial court and as affirmed by the High Court cannot be sustained – Judgment passed by the courts below quashed and set aside – Evidence. [Paras 30, 31, 51-55] FIR – Registration by police officials merely based on source information – Effect:
Held: Police officials could not register the FIR merely on the basis of such source information without even verifying the fact as to whether any such incident had actually occurred – Very fact that the said FIR was registered by referring to an incident without making any verification from the aggrieved persons clearly shows that the Investigating Agency right from inception had started plotting that the case should proceed in a particular direction – This is a very suspicious circumstance which creates a grave doubt on the conduct of the Investigating Agency. [Para 34] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss. 451, 452 and 457 – Disposal of property – Action of the Investigating Officer in returning the mudammal currency notes to the complainant without any order of the Court – Effect:
Held: Disposal of the case property could only have been done by taking recourse to the procedure contained u/ss. 451, 452 and 457 as the case may be – Investigation Officer had no authority to release [2024] 7 S.C.R. 335Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana the currency notes without an order of the Court and his action to the contrary tantamounts to grave misconduct – Trial court causally brushed aside the plea regarding the non-production of the currency notes in the Court observing that the recovered currency notes were released on superdari by the Magistrate – However, the trial court went on to note that the currency notes were never seen after the recovery and were not produced in the Court when the prosecution witnesses were examined – No order for final disposal of the currency notes was passed by the trial court u/s. 452 which is a mandatory requirement – Sheer indifference exhibited by the courts below is shocking, to say the least – Thus, the entire process of recovery of the currency notes is clearly flawed, marked by procedural errors – Courts below erred by not pulling up the prosecution for flagrant disregard of legal procedures and failure to document key details which undermines the prosecution’s case. [Para 42] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 311 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s. 165 – Power to summon material witness, or examine person present – Power to put questions or order production – Ambit of:
Held: Conjoint reading of s. 311 CrPC and s. 165 of the Evidence Act makes it clear that the trial court is under an obligation not to act as a mere spectator and should proactively participate in the trial proceedings, so as to ensure that neither any extraneous material is permitted to be brought on record nor any relevant fact is left out – It is the duty of the trial court to ensure that all such evidence which is essential for the just decision of the case is brought on record irrespective of the fact that the party concerned omits to do so – On facts, grandfather of the kidnapped boy was the first person who came into contact of the police officials and he admittedly disclosed about the incident to Investigating Officer, thus, the grandfather would have been the most vital witness to unfurl the truth of the matter, however, for the reasons best known to the prosecution, he was not examined as a witness in the case – Trial court should have remained vigilant and it was absolutely essential for the Court to have exercised powers u/s. 311 CrPC read with s. 165 of the Evidence Act so as to summon and examine the grandfather in evidence because his evidence was essential for a just decision of the case – Non-examination of the said witness at the trial is a fatal lacuna to draw an adverse inference against the prosecution. [Paras 47, 48, 50] 336 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Witness – Non-examination of the most relevant witness at the trial – Effect:
Held: Trial court failed to perform its lawful obligation u/s. 311 CrPC rw s. 165 of the Evidence Act – Most vital witness whose deposition was imperative for arriving at the truth of the matter not produced by the prosecution and the trial court took no steps whatsoever to summon him by exercising its powers u/s. 311 CrPC and s.165 of the Evidence Act – Non-examination of the said witness at the trial is a fatal lacuna leading to an adverse inference against the prosecution – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 311 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s. 165. [Paras 47] Case Law Cited Pooja Pal v. Union of India and Others [2016] 11 SCR 560 : (2016) 3 SCC 135; Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and Ors. [2020] 7 SCR 180 : (2020) 3 SCC 216 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Evidence Act, 1872; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Kidnapping for ransom; First disclosure; Inherent improbabilities; Delay; Dock identification; Trustworthy evidence; Disclosure statements; Registration of FIR by police officials based on source information; Aggrieved person; Disposal of property; Non-production of the case property; Recovery of the currency notes; Summon witness; Non-examination of witness.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 696 of 2010 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.01.2009 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRLA No.779-DB of 2005 With Criminal Appeal Nos. 695 and 1724 of 2010 and Criminal Appeal No. 584 of 2013 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 337Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana Appearances for Parties Ms. Kiran Suri, Neeraj Kumar Jain, Sr. Advs., Ms. Bharti Tyagi, Vikash Kumar, T. N. Singh, Vikas Kumar Singh, Ms. Rajshree Singh, T. Mahipal, Advs. for the Appellant.
S. Udaya Kumar Sagar, A.A.G., Ms. Bina Madhavan, Dr. Monika Gusain, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. The appellants were subjected to trial in the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula(hereinafter being referred to as the ‘trial Court’) in Sessions Case No. 11 of 2003 for the offences punishable under Sections 364A, 392 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860(hereinafter being referred to as ‘IPC’). Vide judgment and order dated 26 th September, 2005, the learned trial Court held the appellants guilty for the above mentioned offences and sentenced them as below: - Provision under which convicted Sentence Section 364A IPC Life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default, further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year.
Section 392 IPC Rigorous imprisonment for five years and a fine of Rs. 5,000/- and in default, further undergo rigorous imprisonment for six months.
Section 120B IPC Life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default, further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year.
2. Being aggrieved by the conviction and sentences awarded by the learned trial Court, the appellants preferred separate appeals before the Punjab and Haryana High Court. The Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissed the appeals preferred by the appellants vide common judgment dated 19 th January, 2009 338 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports affirming the judgment passed by the learned trial Court and upholding the conviction and sentences of the appellants.
3. The aforesaid judgment rendered by the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court is subjected to challenge in these four appeals.
4. Since all the appeals arise from common judgment dated 19th January, 2009, the same have been heard and are being decided together by this judgment.
Brief Facts: -
5. On 15 th April, 2003 Jai Singh, SI(PW-27), Police Station, Sector-5, Panchkula, while being present near the market of Sector 16, Panchkula along with the police team in connection with patrol duty and crime checking, claims to have received a secret information to the effect that a gang was operating in Panchkula which was indulged in demanding ransom from parents after kidnapping the children and in case of non-payment of ransom, threats were given to eliminate the kidnapped children. It was further divulged in the information that such type of incident had already occurred in Kothi No. 81-A, Sector 17, Panchkula.
6. A ruqa(Exhibit-PAA) with these allegations was sent to the police station by Jai Singh, SI(PW-27) based whereupon a formal FIR No. 283 of 2003(Exhibit-PAAA/1) dated 15 th April, 2003 came to be registered by Jai Raj, ASI(PW-25) for the offences punishable under Sections 387 and 507 IPC at Police Station, Sector-5, Panchkula. Investigation of the case was assigned to Surjit Kumar(Investigating Officer)(PW-37), Sub-Inspector, CIA, Panchkula. He proceeded to Kothi No. 81-A on 15 th April, 2003 where one Shamlal Garg met him and informed that his grandson namely, Sachin Garg(PW-2) had been kidnapped. Shamlal Garg also alleged that they had received ransom calls from two mobile phones bearing Nos. 9815XXXXXX and 9815XXXXXX. Both the numbers were found to be of service provider Bharti Airtel Company. The Investigating Officer(PW-37) made enquires from the office of Bharti Airtel Company and received information that these mobile SIMs had been sold to Kohli Traders, Sector 26, Chandigarh. The Senior Manager of Bharti Airtel Company, Shri Rakesh Michael provided the call detail records of both the mobile [2024] 7 S.C.R. 339Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana numbers from 28 th March, 2003 to 3 rd April, 2003. On an inquiry made from Kohli Traders, it came to light that both the SIM cards had been sold to one Singla Traders, Sector-7, Chandigarh on 24 th February, 2003. On an enquiry from the shop of Singla Traders, the Investigation Officer(PW-37) was provided information that these SIM cards had been purchased by two boys from Reena Singla, sister of the owner of Singla Traders. Based on the call data of the mobile numbers as provided by Bharti Airtel Company, it was found that mobile sets bearing IMEI(International Mobile Equipment Identity) Nos. 350179626659830, 350019563917100 and 350609807685060 had been used for operating these SIM cards. The statements of Sachin Garg[kidnapped boy(PW-2)] and Mahesh Garg[(Father of the kidnapped boy(PW-1)] were recorded by Investigating Officer(PW-37) on 20 th April, 2003.
7. Mahesh Garg(PW-1) stated that on 2nd April 2003, his son Sachin Garg had gone to play badminton at the playground of Sector 7, Panchkula, in a car, but he did not return till 9:00 pm. Thereupon, he along with his family members made efforts to trace Sachin Garg out. He received calls from Mobile Nos. 9815XXXXXX and 9815XXXXXX and the caller(s) informed them that Sachin Garg(PW-2) was in their custody and demanded ransom to the tune of Rs. 1 crore for his release. The caller(s) also threatened that in case, the ransom demand was not satisfied, Sachin Garg would be eliminated. A threat was also given to eliminate the entire family in case any intimation was given to the police.
8. Fearing for the life of his son, Mahesh Garg(PW-1) arranged money from his relatives, friends and his own bank accounts. He again received calls on 3 rd April, 2003 threatening him not to inform the police. He was further directed to reach a designated place with the ransom amount and to wait for further instructions. Accordingly, he took the ransom amount to the address given by the miscreants i.e. Sector 17, Chandigarh, thereafter, to Sector 8, Chandigarh and ultimately to PGI hospital. On reaching there, he received another call and was directed to leave the bag with the ransom amount in his car and to proceed to the emergency ward of the hospital and wait for further instructions. Accordingly, he left the briefcase containing the money in the car and proceeded to the emergency ward of PGI hospital. However, he did not find anyone present there. After some time, he received another call 340 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports asking him to leave the place and wait for another call with the assurance that his son would be released along with the car after the cash amount had been counted and verified. He received another call by which he was informed that his car was parked near the chowk of Sector 11/15, Chandigarh. Accordingly, he took the car and proceeded to his house. At about 10:30 pm, another call was received informing him that his son Sachin Garg(PW-2) was standing near the chowk of Sector 20, Panchkula. He brought Sachin Garg(PW-2) back home from that place. He again received a call threatening that if any attempt was made to inform the police, then the entire family would be eliminated. Thus, out of fear, they did not approach the police.
9. Sachin Garg(PW-2) in his statement(Exhibit-DB) recorded by the Investigating Officer (PW-37) on 20 th April, 2003 under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973(hereinafter being after referred to as ‘CrPC’) stated that on 2 nd April, 2003, he had gone to Sector 7, Panchkula in his car for playing badminton. While he was returning home, and had reached near Sector 17, Panchkula, a Maruti car obstructed his path. Three persons came out of the car from which one was carrying a pistol. The said assailant placed the pistol against his head and asked him to shift to the adjoining seat. The second assailant armed with a knife occupied the rear seat. He was then directed to shift to the rear seat. His wrist watch, ATM card, school card, gold chain and some money lying in his pocket were robbed at pistol and knife point. In the meantime, the third assailant who was also armed with a knife took the driver’s seat and his car was driven towards the pulia where Sachin Garg(PW-2) was blindfolded and shifted into the Maruti car and was taken away to some unknown location. He was kept confined in a room during the intervening night of 2 nd and 3 rd April, 2003. A person named Gaurav Bhalla was present in the room and he was calling out names of the other accused as Sanjay, Mintu and Gaurav. He was again blindfolded in the evening and was taken in a car and was dropped off at the market of Sector 20, Panchkula with the instruction to remove the blindfold(patti) after 10 minutes and stand there and wait for his father. The accused threatened to eliminate his entire family in case intimation of the incident was given to the police. On returning home, he came to know that his father had paid an amount of Rs. 1 crore for securing his release.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 341Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana
10. Further investigation revealed that Gaurav Maini was using Mobile No. 9814XXXXXX, Gaurav Bhalla was using Mobile No. 9814XXXXXX and Sanjay @ Sanju was using Mobile No. 9814XXXXXX.
11. Based on the statements of Mahesh Garg(PW-1) and Sachin Garg(PW-2), offences punishable under Sections 392, 342, 364A and 506 IPC were added to the case on 20th April, 2003.
12. The accused Pankaj Bansal, Gobind, Amit Verma and Gaurav Maini were arrested on 29 th April, 2003. It is alleged that Gaurav Maini suffered a disclosure statement under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872(hereinafter being referred to as ‘Evidence Act’) divulging that he, along with Gaurav Bhalla, Sanjay @ Sanju and Munish Bhalla had kidnapped Sachin Garg(PW-2), who was released after collecting an amount of Rs.1 crore as ransom. The accused Gaurav Bhalla was arrested on 1st May, 2003 and he too suffered a disclosure statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Likewise, the accused Munish Bhalla and Sanjay @ Sanju also made disclosures to the Investigating Officer(PW-37) under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.
13. Following items were allegedly recovered at the instance and in furtherance of the disclosures made by the accused appellants being Gaurav Maini(A1), Gaurav Bhalla(A2), Munish Bhalla(A3) and Sanjay @ Sanju(A4): - Name of Accused Recovered Articles Gaurav Maini
(i) A wristwatch of Sachin.
(ii) Currency notes to the tune of Rs. 17,00,000/-
(iii) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 3,50,000/from his house
(iv) A motorcycle along with papers.
(v) One mobile phone marked Digital worth Rs.
7500/-
(vi) One gold kara
(vii) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 3,72,500/from his house
(viii) One mobile phone Panasonic bearing IMEI No. 350179626659830 342 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Gaurav Bhalla
(i) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 18,50,000/from his locker at Central Bank of India, Sector 10, Panchkula.
(ii) Receipt worth Rs. 27,300/- regarding the purchase of a Mobile phone.
(iii) A mobile phone worth Rs. 27,000/-
(iv) One L.G. Air Conditioner worth Rs. 23,500/from Cabin No. 20, SCO No. 37, Sector 11, Panchkula
(v) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 5,80,000/from Cabin No. 20, SCO No. 37, Sector 11, Panchkula Munish Bhalla
(i) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 20,00,000/from his locker at Ambala Central Cooperative Bank, Ambala.
(ii) An ATM card and school card of Sachin.
(iii) One Motorcycle bearing registration No.
HR01E-4113 (Bullet) worth Rs. 35,000/-
(iv) One Panasonic mobile
(v) Cash amount to the tune of Rs. 4,55,500/from his Battery shop in Mohar Market Ambala City.
(vi) His Maruti Car bearing No. HR 35A-0012 used in Kidnapping.
Sanjay @ Sanju
(i) Rs. 22,000/- during his personal search.
(ii) Rs.20,50,000/- currency notes in denomination of Rs. 500/- from the Almirah of his house.
(iii) Rs. 1,28,000/- from a shop
(iv) An Air pistol used in the offence.
(v) One mobile phone marked Samsung IMEI No. 350019563917100
(vi) A gold chain of Sachin
(vii) Amount to the tune of Rs. 40,000/- deposited in his bank account at HDFC bank, Sector 11, Panchkula.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 343Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana
14. Upon completion of the investigation, a charge sheet came to be filed against seven accused persons in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, 1 st Class, Panchkula. The offence under Section 364A IPC being exclusively sessions triable, the case was committed to the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, Panchkula for trial. The learned trial Court framed charges against the accused Gaurav Maini(A1), Gaurav Bhalla(A2), Munish Bhalla(A3) and Sanjay @ Sanju(A4) for offences punishable under Sections 364A, 392 and 120B IPC. They denied the charges and claimed trial. The remaining three accused namely Pankaj Bansal, Gobind and Amit Verma were discharged.
15. The prosecution examined 37 witnesses and exhibited 125 documents in order to bring home the charges. The accused were questioned under Section 313 CrPC. They denied the prosecution allegations and claimed to be innocent. Gaurav Maini(A1) made a pertinent assertion that he had no concern whatsoever with the alleged crime and the case was totally cooked up. Gaurav Bhalla(A2) stated that he was involved in a love affair with Shivani @ Kaku, daughter of Mahesh Garg(PW-1) since 3 to 4 years prior to the occurrence. Shivani @ Kaku used to send him greeting cards as an expression of love. She often used to ring him up from her mobile phone and landline numbers. On 1 st April, 2003, Shivani @ Kaku approached him and pressurized him to elope with her. He tried to reason with her that it was not the right step and advised her to return home. Since, she was pressurizing him for marriage, he assured her that they would marry. He was illegally detained by the CIA officials on 26 th April, 2003 and was kept confined and tortured in custody. No recovery was effected from him and all the recoveries were manipulated. The other accused also denied the prosecution allegations and claimed to be innocent. Four witnesses were examined in defence.
16. After hearing the arguments of both the sides and analysing the evidence, the learned trial Court proceeded to convict and sentence the accused appellants(A1, A2, A3 and A4) as above vide judgment and order dated 26th September, 2005. The appeals preferred by the appellants against the judgment rendered by the trial Court were rejected by the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court vide judgment dated 19 th , January, 2009 which is subjected to challenge in these four appeals by special leave.
344 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Submissions of learned counsel for the appellants:-
17. Ms. Kiran Suri, learned senior counsel representing the accused appellant Gaurav Bhalla(A-2), vehemently and fervently contended that the entire case setup by the prosecution is false and fabricated. For assailing the impugned judgments, learned senior counsel advanced the following pertinent submissions: -
(i) That the alleged incident of kidnapping and demand of ransom took place on 2 nd April, 2003. Even though the kidnapped boy, i.e., Sachin Garg(PW-2) had been released on 3 rd April, 2003, the family members took no steps whatsoever to report the matter to the police. This rank silence of the family members and their utter failure to report the matter to the police or the authorities casts a grave doubt on the truthfulness of the entire prosecution case.
(ii) That the Investigating Officer(PW-37) went to the house of the kidnapped boy on 15 th April, 2023, and recorded the statement of his grandfather Shamlal Garg on the very same day. However, no effort was made by the Investigating Officer(PW-37) to record the statement of Sachin Garg(PW-2) on the same day despite he being available in the house. Sachin Garg(PW-2), categorically stated to the Investigation Officer(PW-37) on 20 th April, 2003 that he had identified Gaurav Bhalla(A2) at the time of the incident. Had there been an iota of truth in the prosecution case, identity of Gaurav Bhalla(A2) would definitely have been disclosed by Shamlal Garg to the Investigating Officer(PW-37), when his statement was recorded on 15 th April, 2003.
(iii) That the entire process of recovery of money and other articles at the instance of the accused is totally fabricated and remained unsubstantiated because the arrest memos of the accused were never proved by the prosecution. The accused made pertinent assertion that the police had kept them illegally confined for almost seven days and thus proving of the arrest documents was imperative to arrive at the truth of the case.
(iv) That the prosecution, did not tender any evidence regarding the fate of the currency notes allegedly recovered at the instance of the accused. The Investigating Officer(PW-37) candidly admitted that he handed back the currency notes to Mahesh Garg(PW-1) [2024] 7 S.C.R. 345Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana of his own accord. As per the learned senior counsel, this action of the Investigating Officer in returning the mudammal currency notes to the complainant(PW-1) without any order of the Court, throws grave doubt on the truthfulness of the entire process of disclosures and discovery.
(v) That the SIM cards in question were not issued in the name of the accused. The prosecution did not lead any evidence whatsoever to show that the accused had ever acquired or were using the mobile numbers from which the ransom calls were allegedly made.
(vi) That the secret information based whereupon FIR No. 283 of 2003(Exhibit-PAA/1) was registered was not brought on record and thus it is a clear case of concealment of vital evidence warranting adverse inference against the prosecution.
(vii) That there is no material to show as to when the special report reached the Magistrate concerned pursuant to the registration of the formal FIR No. 283 of 2003(Exhibit- PAA/1).
(viii) That the accused other than Gaurav Bhalla(A2) were not known to the victim Sachin Garg(PW-2) from before. The Investigation Officer(PW-37) made no effort whatsoever to subject these accused to the Test Identification Parade(TIP) and thus, the dock identification of the accused namely Gaurav Maini(A1), Munish Bhalla(A3) and Sanjay @ Sanju(A4) for the first time in the Court by Sachin Garg(PW-2) is of no value whatsoever. Attention of the Court in this regard was drawn to the deposition of Mahesh Garg(PW-1) who stated that his son was never asked to identify the accused by the police in any identification parade. Learned senior counsel also referred to the cross-examination of Sachin Garg(PW-2) wherein, he stated that once he had gone to CIA with his father and there, he saw the accused from some distance. The police did not record his statement regarding the identification of the accused. Sachin Garg(PW-2) also admitted that he had told his father Mahesh Garg(PW-1) and his grandfather Shamlal Garg that one of the accused was Gaurav Bhalla (A2) and that the other accused were calling out the names of each other. Thus, as per the learned senior counsel, the omission regarding the names of these accused in the previous statement of Sachin 346 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Garg(PW-2) recorded under Section 161 CrPC is fatal to the prosecution case.
(ix) That the so-called disclosure statements of the accused as recorded by Munish Kumar, Sub-Inspector(PW-33) and Surjit Kumar, Investigating Officer(PW-37) were not proved as per law. The prosecution failed to prove that the recovered mudammal articles including the currency notes were kept securely at the malkhana of the police station. In this regard, attention of the Court was drawn to the statement of Investigating Officer(PW-37), highlighting the fact that the said witnesses did not utter a single word regarding the fate of the currency notes after the purported seizure and his failure to explain as to how the same were dealt with after the seizures were allegedly made at the instance of the accused.
(x) That the learned trial Court as well as the High Court failed to give due credence to the evidence of the defence witnesses. Stress was laid by the learned senior counsel to the deposition of Manav Malhotra(DW-4) who stated that he often saw Gaurav Bhalla(A2) and Shivani @ Kaku, sister of the kidnapped boy-Sachin Garg(PW-2) together. It was contended that, as a matter of fact, the family members were aware about the ongoing affair between Gaurav Bhalla(A2) and Shivani @ Kaku and were opposed to it and hence, the case of kidnapping for demand of ransom was cooked up so as to put Gaurav Bhalla(A2) and his companions behind bars and sever the relationship.
(xi) It was further contended that the defence witnesses, gave affirmative evidence for proving the plea of alibi raised by the accused. However, neither the trial Court nor the High Court gave due consideration to the evidence of the defence witnesses and brushed their testimonies aside in a totally perfunctory manner.
18. The learned counsel representing the remaining accused appellants adopted the submissions of learned senior counsel Ms. Kiran Suri.
19. The court was apprised that accused Gaurav Maini(A1), Gaurav Bhalla(A2), Munish Bhalla(A3) and Sanjay @ Sanju(A4) were in custody for 10 years 11 months(approx.); 9 years(approx.); 7 years 2 months; 10 years 10 months(approx.), respectively.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 347Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana
20. On these grounds, learned counsel for the appellants implored the Court to accept the appeals, set aside the impugned judgments, and acquit the accused appellants of the charges.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent-State: -
21. Per contra, learned counsel for the State, vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by learned senior counsel for the accused appellants. It was contended that the prosecution case is founded on unimpeachable testimony of the minor boy Sachin Garg(PW-2) who was kidnapped by the accused appellants for demand of ransom. The witness gave clinching evidence identifying and implicating the accused appellants for his kidnapping and release after payment of ransom. The trivial contradictions appearing in the evidence of the witness rather establish that he is a truthful witness and has given a true picture of the incident. The evidence of Sachin Garg(PW-2) finds due corroboration from the testimony of Mahesh Garg(PW-1), 161 CrPC statement of Shamlal Garg recorded by Investigating Officer(PW-37) and the incriminating recoveries effected at the instance of the accused appellants.
22. He contended that the recoveries having been effected proximate to the incident of kidnapping for ransom, the burden of explaining, as to how the incriminating articles including the huge sums of money came into their possession shifted on to the accused appellant by virtue of the presumption provided under Section 106 read with Section 114(a) of the Evidence Act. Since, the accused failed to offer any plausible explanation in this regard the prosecution is entitled to raise the statutory presumption against them.
23. Learned counsel further urged that since the accused appellants had given a grave threat of evil consequences to Mahesh Garg(PW-1), he was justified in not approaching the police for reporting the matter and his silence cannot be treated as an unnatural conduct.
24. He further urged that the trivial contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses cannot be considered sufficient so as to discard the entire prosecution case which is based on unimpeachable direct as well as circumstantial evidence. He further contended that the trial Court and the High Court have recorded concurrent findings of facts in the impugned judgments after appreciating the evidence available on record and thus this Court should not feel persuaded 348 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to interfere in the conviction of the accused while exercising the jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. On these grounds, he implored the Court to dismiss the appeals and affirm the impugned judgments.
25. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have gone through the impugned judgments and the evidence placed on record.
Discussion and Conclusion: -
26. At the outset, we are of the opinion that the very inception of the prosecution case is shrouded under a grave cloud of doubt and we shall record our reasons for the above conclusion while discussing the prosecution evidence. It is undisputed that neither the victim Sachin Garg nor his family members ever reported the incident to the police. Sachin Garg(PW-2) deposed that when he was driving on the road dividing Sectors 17 and 18, three miscreants obstructed his path. They had come in a Maruti car. One of them placed a pistol against the head of Sachin Garg and asked him to shift to the adjoining seat. The other assailant was armed with a knife and he directed Sachin Garg to shift to the rear seat of the car and snatched away his gold chain. The person holding the pistol came and sat beside him. The third assailant who too was armed with a knife, occupied the driver’s seat and extended a threat. His wrist watch, ATM card, identity card and some cash amount were also snatched away by the same person who had taken the gold chain. The miscreants then put a blindfold on his eyes and drove away the car. Sachin Garg(PW-2) admitted that while being blindfolded, he could identify the driver as Gaurav Bhalla(A2). He was taken to an unknown location where they reached after driving for 45 minutes. He was kept confined in a room for the entire night with the blind-fold. He overheard the accused appellants talking to each other and, thus, he managed to catch their names. Then, he was taken in a car and accused appellants told him that they would be releasing him at a place from where, his father would pick him up. He was extended a threat that in case he disclosed about the occurrence to anyone, his entire family would be eliminated. He was dropped off after some time. He opened the blind-fold(patti) and found himself standing in Sector 20, Panchkula. Ten to fifteen minutes later, his father arrived and took him home. Thereafter, [2024] 7 S.C.R. 349Gaurav Maini v. The State of Haryana he came to know that his father had paid a sum of Rs. 1 crore as ransom for securing his release.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.