Sukhpal Singh v. NCT of Delhi
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 385; [2024] 6 S.C.R. 315
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 7 May 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 55/2015
- Sections
- 302, 299, 33, 106, 313, 82, 83, 161, 3
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 6 S.C.R. 315 : 2024 INSC 385 Sukhpal Singh v.
NCT of Delhi (Criminal Appeal No. 55 of 2015)
07 May 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Appellant was convicted u/s.302, Penal Code, 1860 for the murder of his wife. Courts below whether justified in holding that the statement of Complainant-PW-1 recorded in proceedings u/s.299, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 could be read as a piece of substantive evidence; whether the prosecution could establish the links in the chain of incriminating circumstantial evidence. Headnotes Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.299 – Record of evidence in absence of accused – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.33 – Appellant murdered his wife owing to her suspected infidelity however, fled away from the crime scene and remained absconding for nearly 10 years – Charge sheet was filed u/s.299 showing him to be an absconder – Complainant (PW-1) was examined on oath in proceedings u/s.299 where he gave detailed account of the sequence of events witnessed by him – However, he could not be produced for deposition in the trial which resumed after the arrest of the appellant, as he could not be found at the address given in the FIR despite all sincere efforts – Statement of PW-1 recorded during proceedings u/s.299 was relied upon as a piece of incriminating evidence against the appellant, apart from other incriminating circumstantial evidences and appellant was convicted u/s.302 – Conviction and sentence affirmed by High Court – Sustainability:
Held: s.299 (1) is in two parts, the first part provides for proof of jurisdictional fact in respect of abscondence of an accused person and the second that there was no immediate prospect of arresting him – In the event, an order under the said provision is passed, deposition of any witness taken in the absence of an accused may be used against him if the deponent is dead or incapable of giving evidence or cannot be found or his presence 316 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports cannot be procured without any amount of delay, expense or inconvenience which, under the circumstances of the case, would be unreasonable – In the present case, circumstances of motive, last seen, confession and abscondence from the crime scene after committing the crime etc. were all spoken by the witness (PW-1) in his statement recorded on sworn affirmation during the proceedings u/s.299 – His statement by itself provides a complete chain of circumstantial evidence sufficient to establish the guilt of the appellant – Thus, in light of the provisions of s.299 r/w s.33 of the Evidence Act, 1872, the trial Court and High Court were justified in holding that the statement of PW-1 recorded in these proceedings was fit to be read as a piece of substantive evidence – Prosecution established a clinching and complete chain of incriminating circumstantial evidence pointing exclusively towards the guilt of the appellant and totally inconsistent with his innocence or the involvement of any other person in the crime – Impugned judgments not interfered with. [Paras 31, 36, 38, 39, 47, 48, 50] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.106 – Burden of proving fact especially within knowledge – Appellant failed to offer explanation for the homicidal death of his wife in the house during night time when only him and deceased were present, leading to interference of guilt by virtue of s.106:
Held: The circumstances leading to murder of appellant’s wife were in his exclusive knowledge – He offered no explanation as to the manner in which she was strangled to death within the confines of the room where only he and the deceased were present – The bald plea of denial offered by the appellant by way of an explanation to this gravely incriminating circumstance is not sufficient to absolve him of the burden cast upon him by virtue of s.106. [Para 46] Case Law Cited Nirmal Singh v. State of Haryana [2000] 2 SCR 807 :
(2000) 4 SCC 41; Jayendra Vishnu Thakur v. State of Maharashtra & Another [2009] 8 SCR 591 : (2009) 7 SCC 104 – relied on.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872; Penal Code, 1860.
[2024] 6 S.C.R. 317Sukhpal Singh v . NCT o f D e l h i List of Keywords Section 299 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Record of evidence in absence of accused; Piece of substantive evidence; Incriminating evidence; Links in the chain of incriminating circumstantial evidence; Burden of proving fact especially within knowledge; Suspected infidelity; Absconder; Abscondence of accused; No immediate prospect of arrest; Motive; Last seen together; Homicidal death; Wrong explanation by accused in statement under Section 313 Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Section 106 of Evidence Act, 1872; Circumstantial evidence; Complete chain of circumstances; Murder inside the house.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 55 of From the Judgment and Order dated 07.01.2010 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLA No. 296 of 2003 Appearances for Parties Ambreesh Kumar Aggarwal, Adv. for the Appellant.
Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Ms. Seksha, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. The instant appeal is directed against the judgment dated 7th January, 2010 passed by the High Court of Delhi in Criminal Appeal No. 296 of 2003 whereby the appeal filed by the appellant against the judgment and order of conviction and sentence dated 6 th March, 2003 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘trial Court’) was rejected.
2. By the said judgment, the trial Court convicted the accused appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘IPC’) and sentenced him to life imprisonment and fine of Rs.2000/- (in default further rigorous imprisonment for six months).
318 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
3. Leave was granted by this Court in this matter on 8 th January, 2015 and the accused appellant was released on bail on furnishing bail bonds to the satisfaction of the trial Court.
Brief facts:-
4. The accused appellant was married to Usha and three children were born out of the wedlock. However, the spouses got embroiled in a matrimonial strife and thus the appellant left company of his wife Usha and started residing at his village Khatta, U.P.
5. The officers of Police Station Bhajan Pura received a wireless message on 20 th May, 1990 from the PCR regarding an incident which had taken place outside the shops of Rori and Badarpur. Acting on the said information, Head Constable Mohan Lal, Constables Jai Pal, Bhagwan Dass and Ramesh Chand along with Inspector Ishwar Singh reached House no. J-387, Gali No. 14, Kartar Nagar, Delhi where Usha w/o Sukhpal (the appellant herein) was found lying dead on a cot in a room of the said house. On cursory inspection, abrasions, scratches and other injury marks associated with bleeding were noticed on the neck, mouth, shoulder and private parts of the deceased Usha. Marks of dragging were also found on the right leg below the knee. Strips of tablets were found scattered around the cot on which the dead body was lying. The police officials claim to have recovered a handwritten note (Exhibit PW-12/E) from the crime scene bearing a recital indicating that the scribe was the killer of Usha. The prosecution alleges that the said note was written by the accused appellant.
6. Statement (Exhibit PW-1/A) of Ashok Kumar Pathak, resident of House No. J-386, Gali No. 14, Kartar Nagar, Delhi was recorded by the police officials on 20 th May, 1990 wherein he stated that he was residing in the immediate vicinity of House No. J-387, Gali No. 14, Kartar Nagar, Delhi, where Usha with her husband Sukhpal (accused appellant) and three children had been residing for the last 3-4 years. Ashok Kumar Pathak was serving with M/s. R.P. Associates and that he had got Sukhpal employed in that very firm. Sukhpal suspected his wife Usha of infidelity which often led to quarrels between them and, therefore, Sukhpal left his wife and children and started residing in village Khatta, U.P. He used to commute from the village for attending to his job. Sometimes, he would also come and stay with Usha. Four days prior to the alleged occurrence, Sukhpal had [2024] 6 S.C.R. 319Sukhpal Singh v. NCT of Delhi visited Usha and on that day, Usha’s sister (Sudha) had also come there. Sukhpal quarrelled with Usha and went away. On the next day, Usha’s sister, Sudha (PW-10) took the three children of Usha and went to her house. On the day prior to incident, i.e., on 19th May, 1990, in the evening when Ashok Kumar Pathak had returned from duty and got free after having his meals, at about 9.30 p.m., he saw that Sukhpal had come to visit Usha on his cycle. The spouses were talking while sitting on a cot in the courtyard. He went to the terrace for sleeping and after some time, it started raining so he came downstairs and saw that Sukhpal and Usha had also gone inside their room. The next morning i.e. 20 th May, 1990, while he was carrying out his daily chores, he saw Sukhpal’s cycle parked in the courtyard and presumed that he and Usha were inside the house. He did not see any movement in the house for the entire day and even at about 5.30 p.m., he saw the cycle of Sukhpal parked at the same place but neither Sukhpal nor Usha were to be seen. So, he called out from outside, but nobody responded, on which he went into the room and found Usha lying dead on a cot. Sukhpal was not present there. He informed the neighbours who, in turn, called the police. He bore a suspicion that Sukhpal (appellant herein) might have killed Usha sometime during the night and had fled away. This statement was taken as a complaint and based thereupon, FIR No. 213 of 1990 (Exhibit PW-13/F) came to be registered at P.S. Bhajanpura for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC.
7. The dead body of Usha was subjected to autopsy and the post mortem report (Exhibit PW-15/A) was received with a pertinent opinion that cause of death was “Asphyxia resulting from manual strangulation”. A confession letter/note (Exhibit PW-12/E) was found below the cot where the dead body was lying and it was seized vide memorandum (Exhibit PW-13/B) and spot inspection memo (Exhibit PW-12/B) was prepared.
8. The Investigating Officer (PW-13) collected two letters (Exhibit PW- 12/C and PW-12/D) purportedly written by the accused appellant from the employer namely Sanjiv Jain (PW-8). Specimen Pad (Exhibit PW-13/O) of the employer was also collected and seized vide memorandum (Exhibit P-13/N).
9. The prosecution alleges that the accused appellant fled away from the crime scene. Efforts were made to trace him out without any 320 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports success and thus proceedings under Section 82 and Section 83 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as ‘CrPC’) were initiated against him. The accused appellant was declared to be a proclaimed offender and a charge sheet came to be filed against him under Section 299 CrPC by showing him to be an absconder. As per the prosecution case, the complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak, Head Constables Mohan Lal and Surender Kumar and Inspector Bal Kishan were examined on oath in proceedings under Section 299 CrPC and the file was consigned to the record room.
10. The accused appellant could be apprehended on 9th August, 2000 i.e. nearly after ten years of the incident. He gave a disclosure statement pointing out the place of incident. His specimen handwritings (Exhibits PW-5/D, 5/E and 5/F) were obtained while he was in police custody. Thereafter, the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E), the specimen handwritings (Exhibits PW-5/D, PW-5/E and PW-5/F) along with admitted handwritings (Exhibits PW-12/C and PW-12/D) (collected from the employer of accused appellant) were sent to FSL for comparison. The handwriting expert (PW-24) issued a report (Exhibit PW-12/F) opining that the confession letter/note (recovered from the crime scene) was in the handwriting of the accused appellant.
11. A supplementary charge sheet came to be filed against the accused appellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. The trial Court framed charge against the accused appellant for the said offence. He pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution examined 24 witnesses and exhibited 48 documents to support its case.
12. It is relevant to mention here that the complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak, was not produced for deposition in the trial which resumed after the arrest of the accused appellant. The trial Court held that the non-examination of complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak was not a deliberate act of the prosecution and rather the same was beyond the control of prosecution. The trial Court further found that complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak was examined on oath on 17th July, 1991 in proceedings under Section 299 CrPC. In this sworn statement, Ashok Kumar Pathak proved his signature on the statement[Exhibit PW-1/A (which led to registration of FIR)] made by him to the police on 20 th May, 1990 and gave a detailed account of the sequence of events witnessed by him. The complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak could not [2024] 6 S.C.R. 321Sukhpal Singh v . NCT o f D e l h i be examined in the trial proceedings post arrest of the accused as he could not be found at the address given in the FIR despite all sincere efforts.
13. The trial Court held that since Ashok Kumar Pathak could not be located despite genuine efforts, his sworn deposition recorded in absence of the accused appellant was liable to be read in evidence as per the provisions of Section 299 CrPC. Accordingly, the said statement was relied upon as a piece of incriminating evidence against the accused appellant.
14. The trial Court also placed reliance on the confession note/letter (Exhibit PW-12/E) holding that the same was found to be in the handwriting of the accused appellant by the handwriting expert (PW- 24) vide report (Exhibit PW-12/F). The said confession was treated to be an admission and a strong link of incriminating circumstantial evidence against the appellant.
15. Placing reliance upon the evidence of Ashok Kumar Pathak recorded in proceedings under Section 299 CrPC and the evidence of the handwriting expert (PW-24), the trial Court held the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E) to be an unimpeachable piece of evidence sealing the fate of the accused. Corroboration thereto was sought from the evidence of Sudha (PW-10), sister of the deceased Usha. By relying on these incriminating links of circumstantial evidence, the trial Court proceeded to convict and sentenced the accused appellant as above vide judgment dated 6 th March, 2003.
16. The appeal preferred by the accused appellant in the High Court of Delhi was rejected by learned Division Bench of High Court vide judgment dated 7 th January, 2010 holding that the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E) written by the accused appellant proved his culpability in the crime. The prosecution had established that the accused appellant was in company of the deceased Usha at her house where she was murdered in the intervening night of 19 th and 20th May, 1990. The prosecution also established that the deceased was done to death by violence in the said intervening night and that the accused appellant had absconded to flee from justice which established his guilty conduct.
17. The accused appellant has challenged the above judgment affirming his conviction and sentence through this appeal by special leave. 322 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Submissions on behalf of the appellant: -
18. Learned legal aid counsel appointed by Supreme Court Legal Services Committee (SCLSC) for representing the appellant advanced extensive submissions to assail the impugned judgment. He urged that:-
(i) The trial Court as well as the High Court committed grave factual error in holding that complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak was examined on oath in proceedings under Section 299 CrPC. As per learned counsel, this finding is totally contrary to the record because the statement of complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak relied upon by the trial Court and the High Court is actually the statement of the said witness recorded by the SHO, PS Bhajan Pura under Section 161 CrPC which was proved by the Investigating Officer (PW-13) in proceedings under Section 299 CrPC.
(ii) The confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E) is a fabricated piece of evidence because the prosecution did not make any endeavour to get the two admitted documents (Exhibit PW-12/C and PW- 12/D) collected from the employer of the accused appellant, i.e., Sanjiv Jain (PW-8) compared with the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E). This contention was made without prejudice to the plea that the very process of collecting these documents is under a cloud of doubt because the Investigating Officer (PW- 13) could not have had any idea that the accused had worked in M/s. R.P. Associates.
(iii) The handwriting expert’s report (Exhibit PW-12/F) and the testimony of the handwriting expert (PW-24) is not reliable, since the expert did not give any opinion after comparing the admitted writings (Exhibit PW-12/C and PW-12/D) (seized from the employer of the accused appellant) with the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E).
(iv) Without prejudice to the above, learned counsel submitted that from a visual comparison of the confession note (PW-12/E) and the specimen handwritings of the accused (Exhibit PW-5/D, PW-5/E and PW-5/F), it would become clear that there is no similarity whatsoever in the two sets of handwritings so as to conclude with any degree of certainty that the scribe of these [2024] 6 S.C.R. 323Sukhpal Singh v . NCT o f D e l h i documents was one and the same. He thus urged that the report (Exhibit PW-12/F) of the handwriting expert (PW-24) is unreliable and cannot be pressed into service for affirming the guilt of the accused.
(v) He urged that the evidence of Sudha (PW-10) is totally unreliable and not trustworthy and deserves to be discarded. It was admitted by the prosecution that the accused appellant and Usha had divorced each other and thus it is totally unbelievable that the accused appellant had come and stayed with Usha, few days before the incident as claimed by Sudha (PW-10). He urged that the evidence of Sudha (PW-10) is not trustworthy and deserves to be discarded.
(vi) The claim of the prosecution that the accused appellant was absconding is totally unfounded because in the FIR, it was clearly mentioned that the accused appellant after divorcing deceased Usha had started residing in his village Khatta, U.P. However, the Investigating Officer (PW-13) made no effort whatsoever to apprehend the accused appellant from his village.
(vii) It has been admitted by material prosecution witnesses that deceased Usha was indulged in sex trade and that Sandeep Kumar used to solicit her services. Sandeep Kumar and Rajbir Singh (PW-14) were apprehended by the police on suspicion of the death of Usha, however, proper investigation was not made on this aspect. As per him, the possibility of Usha having been murdered by some other person cannot be ruled out.
19. Learned counsel concluded his submissions urging that the case is based purely on circumstantial evidence. The entire chain of incriminating circumstances has to be established leading to the only conclusion consistent with the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with the guilt of anyone else. As per the learned counsel, this chain was not established conclusively by cogent and clinching evidence and hence conviction of the accused appellant as recorded by the trial Court and affirmed by the High Court is unsustainable and should be set aside.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent-State:-
20. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent State fervently and vehemently opposed the submissions advanced by learned counsel 324 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports for the appellant and contended that the chain of incriminating circumstances is complete in all aspects exclusively pointing out towards the guilt of the accused. The learned counsel made the following pertinent submissions imploring the Court to dismiss the appeal and upheld the conviction of the accused appellant: -
(i) That the statement of Ashok Kumar Pathak recorded as PW-1 during proceedings under Section 299 CrPC was rightly relied upon as admissible and reliable piece of evidence. The non-examination of Ashok Kumar Pathak during trial is not a deliberate act of prosecution, rather, the witness could not be examined during regular trial after apprehension of the accused appellant. The witness could not be traced by the prosecuting agency inspite of best efforts. The prolonged abscondence of the accused is primarily the reason for non-examination of Ashok Kumar Pathak.
(ii) That the complainant Ashok Kumar Pathak in his evidence as PW-1 during proceedings under Section 299 CrPC has admitted his signature on his statement[Exhibit PW-1/A (based upon which FIR was registered)] and also elaborated about the averments made therein which he had witnessed with his own eyes.
(iii) That the evidence of Ashok Kumar Pathak clearly establishes the presence of accused appellant with Usha on intervening night of 19 th /20 th May, 1990, whereafter, the lady was found murdered and the accused was found absconding from the crime scene leaving behind a confessional note. Ashok Kumar Pathak also proved about the motive of the appellant to commit the crime.
(iv) The testimony of Usha’s sister Sudha (PW-10) establishes that the accused appellant used to quarrel with Usha suspecting her infidelity and there were repeated altercations between the spouses. They had indulged in a fight just four days prior to the incident. This also establishes the motive attributed to the appellant to commit the offence.
(v) That there is no evidence on record to show that accused appellant and Usha were divorced except a bald statement made in this regard in the confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E).
(vi) That the report (Exhibit PW-12/F) submitted by the handwriting expert, Deepa Verma (PW-24) proves that the handwriting on the [2024] 6 S.C.R. 325Sukhpal Singh v . NCT o f D e l h i confession note (Exhibit PW-12/E) which was recovered from the crime scene matched with the handwriting on the two admitted documents (Exhibits PW-12/C and PW-12/D) collected from the employer of the accused appellant and specimen handwritings (Exhibits PW-5/D, PW-5/E and PW-5/F) given by the accused appellant to the police which in turn concludes the fact that the confession note is in the handwriting of the accused.
21. He urged that the prosecution has proved the case against the accused appellant by leading cogent and convincing chain of incriminating circumstantial evidence and implored the court to dismiss the appeal.
22. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the judgments of the trial Court and the High Court as well as the evidence available on record.
Discussion and Conclusion: -
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.