Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand)
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 143; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 776
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.M. Sundresh, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 26 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 684/2012
- Sections
- 172, 145, 161, 162, 172(3), 165, 302, 313, 299, 300, 172(2), 173(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 776 : 2024 INSC 143 Shailesh Kumar v.
State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand)
(Criminal Appeal No. 684 of 2012)
26 February 2024 [M. M. Sundresh* and S.V.N. Bhatti, JJ.] Issue for Consideration What is the goal of investigation and what is the role of investigating officer; Are s.172 CrPC and ss. 145 & 161 of the Evidence Act to be read in consonance with each other; Can a General Diary entry precede the registration of FIR.
Headnotes Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Goal of investigation and the role of investigating officer:
Held: An investigation of a crime is a lawful search of men and materials relevant in reconstructing and recreating the circumstances of an offence said to have been committed – With the evidence in possession, an Investigating Officer shall travel back in time and, therefore tick off the time zone to reach the exact time and date of the occurrence of the incident under investigation – The goal of investigation is to determine the truth which would help the Investigating Officer to form a correct opinion on the culpability of the named accused or suspect – Once such an opinion is formed on a fair assessment of the evidence collected in the investigation, the role of the court comes into play when the evidence i.e. oral, documentary, circumstantial, scientific, electronic, etc. is presented for and on behalf of the prosecution – During the entire play, the rules of evidence ought to be honoured, sprinkled with the element of fairness through due procedure – Adequate opportunities would have to be given to challenge every assumption – Administration of criminal justice lies in determining the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt – The power of the State to prosecute an accused commences with investigation, collection of evidence and presentation before the Court for acceptance. [Para 17] [2024] 2 S.C.R. 777Shailesh K u m a r v . State o f U .P. ( Now State o f U t t a r a k h a n d ) Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Evidence Act, 1872 – Maintenance of case diary u/s. 172 CrPC and application of s. 145 and s. 161 of the Evidence Act – S.172 CrPC and ss. 145 & 161 of the Evidence Act are to be read in consonance with each other subject to the limited right conferred under sub-section (3) of s.172 of CrPC:
Held: A case diary is maintained by an Investigating Officer during his investigation for the purpose of entering the day-to-day proceedings of the investigation – While doing so, the Investigating Officer should mandatorily record the necessary particulars gathered in the course of investigation with the relevant date, time and place – Under sub-section (1-A) and (1-B) of s.172 of CrPC, the Investigating Officer has to mention, in his case diary, the statement of witnesses recorded during investigation with due pagination – The object of these sub-sections is to facilitate a fair investigation since a statement made u/s. 161 of CrPC is not expected to be signed as mandated by s.162 of CrPC – When a police officer uses case diary for refreshing his memory, an accused automatically gets a right to peruse that part of the prior statement as recorded in the police officer’s diary by taking recourse to s.145 or s.161, as the case may be, of the Evidence Act – S.172(3) of CrPC makes a specific reference to s.145 and s.161 of the Evidence Act – Therefore, whenever a case is made out either u/s.145 or u/s. 161 of the Evidence Act, the benefit conferred thereunder along with the benefit of s.172(3) of CrPC has to be extended to an accused – Thus, the accused has a right to cross-examine a police officer as to the recording made in the case diary whenever the police officer uses it to refresh his memory – Though s.161 of the Evidence Act does not restrict itself to a case of refreshing memory by perusing a case diary alone, there is no exclusion for doing so – Similarly, in a case where the court uses a case diary for the purpose of contradicting a police officer, then an accused is entitled to peruse the said statement so recorded which is relevant, and cross-examine the police officer on that count – What is relevant in such a case is the process of using it for the purpose of contradiction and not the conclusion – To make the position clear, though s.145 r/w. s.161 of the Evidence Act deals with the right of a party including an accused, such a right is limited and restrictive when it is applied to s.172 of CrPC – Suffice it is to state,that the said right cannot be declined when the author of a case diary uses it to refresh 778 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports his memory or the court uses it for the purpose of contradiction – Therefore, there is no hesitation in holding that s.145 and s.161 of the Evidence Act on the one hand and s.172(3) of CrPC on the other are to be read in consonance with each other, subject to the limited right conferred under sub-section (3) of s.172 of CrPC. [Paras 20, 26, 27] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – First Information Report vis-a-vis Case Diary:
Held: In Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh & Others, the Supreme Court held that an Information disclosing commission of a cognizable offence shall first be entered in a book kept by the officer in charge of police station and not in the General Diary – A General Diary entry cannot precede the registration of FIR, except in cases where preliminary inquiry is needed – While an FIR is to be registered on an information disclosing the commission of a cognizable offence, so also a recording is thereafter required to be made in the case diary. [Para 28] Evidence Act, 1872 – s. 165 – Judge’s power to put questions or order production:
Held: S.165 of the Evidence Act speaks of the power of the court to put questions and order production of documents in the course of trial – This is a general and omnibus power given to the court when in search of the truth – Such a power is to be exercised against any witness before it, both in a civil as well as a criminal case – The object is to discover adequate proof of a relevant fact and, therefore, for that purpose, the Judge is authorised and empowered to ask any question of his choice – When such a power is exercised by the court, there is no corresponding right that can be extended to a party to cross-examine any witness on an answer given in reply to a question put forth by it, except with its leave. [Para 29] Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 – Prosecution case that victimdeceased went to picnic along with PW-2 and PW-3 – On their return, they were intercepted by appellant with a knife, who inflicted two fatal blows on the chest and stomach of the victim – Prosecution sought to bring home the guilt of the appellant primarily in the form of: (a) dying declaration, (b) eye witnesses, (c) recovery and (d) alleged arrest of the appellant nearer to the scene of the offence – Trial Court convicted [2024] 2 S.C.R. 779Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) appellant u/s. 302 IPC and sentenced him to imprisonment for life – High Court confirmed the conviction – Propriety: Held: The victim-deceased was first examined by the PW-5 (who was working in the hospital) – The presence of PW-1 (father of deceased) before PW-5 is extremely doubtful – His presence was not spoken to at all by PW-5 – The evidence of PW-1 is quite unnatural as he has neither spoken about the motive in his statement recorded u/s. 161 of CrPC, nor about the so-called dying declaration which was not even witnessed by PW-5 – PW-5 has clearly stated that the deceased was in a very serious condition, blood was oozing out and, therefore, he could not give adequate treatment – The deceased was immediately referred to the second hospital – The testimony of PW-1 is also contradictory to PW-3 and PW-8 (doctor who examined deceased in the second hospital) – Similarly, evidences of PW-2 and PW-3 cannot be relied upon, PW-2 admittedly was not examined by PW-11 (investigating officer) for over 2 weeks, for which no explanation was given – This witness also stated that he was not the friend of the deceased, therefore, his presence at the place of occurrence creates a serious doubt as to how he happened to accompany the deceased to the picnic spot – PW-3, though accompanied the deceased, was not present thereafter, as deposed by PW-5 and did not admit the deceased to the second hospital as deposed by PW-8 – The prosecution has not chosen to examine the driver of the vehicle i.e the tempo in which the deceased was taken to the hospital – There is no explanation as to how PW-9-another police officer from different jurisdiction authored the inquest report – Also, it is totally unbelievable for PW-6 to reach the place of occurrence out of inquisitiveness – The arrest of the accused at the instance of PW-7 is yet another instance of the prosecution trying to make out a case – It is incomprehensible that the appellant would be present at the place of the occurrence when he is attempting to flee – Similar logic goes to the recovery of the knife, it was found in an open place – On perusal of the case diary, it was found various corrections had been made, while some pages were even missing – A clear attempt is made to correct the dates – When the trial court perused the case diary for the purpose of contradicting the statement of a police officer, it ought not to have fixed the onus on the appellant – It has failed to discharge its duty enshrined u/s. 172(3) of CrPC r/w. s. 145 or s.161, as the case may be, of the Evidence Act – These aspects as discussed were not looked 780 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports into in a proper perspective – Thus, the appellant has made out a case for acquittal. [Paras 32-39] Case Law Cited Lalita Kumari v. Government of Uttar Pradesh & Others, [2013] 14 SCR 713 : (2014) 2 SCC 1 – followed.
Arvind Kumar @ Nemichand & Ors. v. State of Rajasthan, [2021] 11 SCR 237; Common Cause and Others v. Union of India, [2015] 6 SCR 731 : (2015) 6 SCC 332; Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, [1983] 3 SCR 109 : (1983) 3 SCC 344; Baleshwar Mandal v. State of Bihar, (1997) 7 SCC 219; Balakram v. State of Uttarakhand and Others, [2017] 5 SCR 367 : (2017) 7 SCC 668; Ram Chander v. State of Haryana, [1981] 3 SCR 12 : (1981) 3 SCC 191 – relied on.
Manoj and Others v. State of Madhya Pradesh, [2022] 9 SCR 452 : (2023) 2 SCC 353 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Law Commission of India’s One Hundred and Fifty Fourth Report (154th).
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860, Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Investigation; Goal of investigation; Role of investigating officer; Case Diary; Maintenance of case diary; Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing; Right of the accused to crossexamine as to case diary used to refresh memory; Refreshing of memory perusing case diary; Contradiction of police officer using case diary; FIR vis-à-vis case diary; Power of Judge to put questions.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.684 of 2012.
From the Judgment and Order dated 15.11.2010 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CRLA No.888 of 2001 [2024] 2 S.C.R. 781Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) Appearances for Parties D. P. Singh, Vikram Singh, Amit Gupta, Archit Singh, Manu Mishra, Ms. Shreya Dutt for M/s. Mitter & Mitter Co., Advs. for the Appellant. Saurabh Trivedi, Ashutosh Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Respondent. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment M. M. Sundresh, J.
1. The appellant convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge, Anti-Corruption U.P (East) Dehradun in ST 166/1992 under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as “IPC”) for life imprisonment, as confirmed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Criminal Appeal No. 888 of 2001 seeks acquittal.
2. Heard learned counsel Mr. D.P Singh appearing for the appellant and the learned counsel Mr. Saurabh Trivedi appearing for the respondent. We have perused the entire records placed before us, and taken due note of the synopsis notes submitted.
BRIEF FACTS
3. The deceased, Gajendra Singh went to a picnic along with two friends, Suresh (PW-2) and Sunil Mandal (PW-3) at about 11 a.m. on the fateful day – 21.06.1992. On their return, they were intercepted by the appellant riding on a motorcycle. The appellant by uttering the words “Today I shall pay all your dues”, attacked the deceased Gajendra Singh with a knife inflicting two fatal blows on the chest and stomach respectively. The motive of the attack appears to be the failure of the appellant in completing the work for which the deceased gave a sum of Rs.500/-.
4. PW-2 and PW-3 took the deceased, who was bleeding profusely on a tempo whose driver has not been examined, to the hospital in which PW-5 was working. After admitting the deceased in the hospital, PW-2 went to the house of the deceased by travelling, which took him 15 minutes, and passed on the information of attack on deceased, to his father, PW-1. On examination, PW-5 found that the deceased was in a serious condition and, therefore, merely gave first aid and referred the deceased to a hospital in 782 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Dehradun. After reaching the hospital, PW-1 made an enquiry with the deceased who gave a dying declaration narrating the incident. PW-5 did not speak about the presence of any of the witnesses except the fact that the deceased was admitted by PW-3 and, therefore, did not refer to the said dying declaration given to PW-1. PW-1 dictated the complaint to one Mr. Inder Singh (not examined) and went to the police station situated just opposite to the hospital. Prior to the aforesaid action on the part of PW-1, PW-5 has made an entry in the emergency medical register which was subsequently filled up by another person named Dr. B.V. Sharma (not examined). Dr. B.V. Sharma sent report immediately to the police station.
5. Before PW-1 could reach the police station, the report from the hospital had reached and, therefore, investigation was triggered. However, neither First Information Report (FIR) had been registered nor noting had been made in the general diary. In fact, the available noting on the general diary did not disclose any offence committed on 21.06.1992, as per the statement of PW-13, who produced the same before the court.
6. PW-2 and PW-3 took the deceased to the nearby hospital at Dehradun as per the version of PW-1 and PW-2, while PW-3 said it was himself and PW-1 who undertook the said exercise. As per the version of PW-8, the doctor who attended the deceased at the Dehradun hospital, the deceased was brought to the hospital by his brother Mr. Bhupender Singh (not examined).
7. PW-11 took up the investigation. He went to the place of occurrence, drew the sketch and prepared the site plan. While returning, he was informed by PW-7, another brother of the deceased that he received information that the appellant was trying to escape to Dehradun. PW- 6, who heard about the occurrence, went to the place of occurrence out of curiosity. The appellant was found and arrested at about 50- 60 yards from the place of occurrence by PW-11 in the presence of PW-6, PW-7 and one Mr. Sanjeev Saini (not examined). The knife that was said to have been used for committing the offence was recovered from an open place at about 50 steps near the place of occurrence. No arrest memo has been prepared though an entry was made in the general diary. Recovery memo was signed by PW-6 and PW-7 alone.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 783Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand)
8. The post-mortem was conducted by PW-4, Dr. Jaideep Dutta, which indicated two major injuries, in tune with the case of the prosecution. PW-9, being the police officer of a different jurisdiction, prepared the inquest report, presumably on the ground that the ultimate death happened there, as the second hospital was situated within his jurisdiction.
9. After the initial investigation by PW-11, PW-12 took over the further investigation, but did not take adequate care to check and verify the earlier statements given by the witnesses. Some of the witnesses have been examined at the earliest while the others like PW-2, PW-6 and PW-7 were examined 2 weeks thereafter. The FIR was curiously sent by post and, therefore, reached the jurisdictional magistrate days thereafter.
10. During the course of trial, the prosecution examined 13 witnesses. In the questioning made under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as “CrPC”), the appellant clearly denied all the charges levelled against him. On a request made on behalf of the appellant, the general diary was summoned and perused by the trial court. This was done as a question was raised on the story propounded by the prosecution which goes to the date and time of the occurrence. On perusal, the trial court found out that there were certain interpolations with specific reference to the dates and certain pages were missing and jumbled. While giving a finding that the noting of the date as 22.06.1992 and thereafter striking it off to 21.06.1992 as a clerical mistake, the trial court went on to put the blame on the appellant that he maneuvered to do so in connivance with somebody, though the said correction could only help the case of the prosecution.
11. While convicting the appellant, the trial court placed heavy reliance upon the evidence of PW-1 to PW-3. The discrepancies qua the emergency medical register and amongst the statements of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were brushed aside as minor and natural or ignorable discrepancies due to the passage of time. Much reliance has been placed on the recovery of the two-wheeler, though not mentioned in the site plan. The delay in recording the statement of the witnesses were also taken lightly. The so-called dying declaration given before PW-1 was accepted, despite a clear statement made by PW-5 that none was present during the stay of the deceased with him till he was sent to the other hospital.
784 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
12. The High Court concurred with the decision of the trial court by placing reliance upon the post-mortem report and the testimony of PW-1 to PW-3.
SUBMISSION OF THE APPELLANT
13. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the evidence of PW-1 ought not to have been accepted by both the courts. The report from the hospital had reached the police station much before. The person to whom PW-1 dictated the complaint has not been examined. There is no material for motive and the testimony of PW-1 is contrary to the one given by PW-3, PW-5 and PW-8. Similarly, the presence of PW-2 is extremely doubtful as his evidence was recorded weeks thereafter. He was also not found to be present by PW-3 in the second hospital, though PW-3 deposed otherwise. Therefore, evidence of PW-2 also ought to have been eschewed. His statement that it is PW-1 and himself who took the deceased to the second hospital is found to be incorrect in view of the testimony of PW-8. The courts below ought to have placed adequate reliance upon the evidence of PW-5 and PW-8, the doctors, who were admittedly working in the hospital at the relevant point of time. The fact that the FIR was not registered immediately after the information was received clearly indicates that it was ante-dated. This contention is also strengthened by the inquest report prepared by the police officer of a different police station i.e. by PW-9.
14. Learned counsel vehemently contended that the trial court has committed grave error in not noting the fact that no time, date and adequate particulars were mentioned in the case diary. The object and rationale behind Section 172 of CrPC coupled with Sections 145, 161 and 165 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter referred to as “Evidence Act”) have been clearly overlooked by both the courts. The motive has not been proved as witnesses have not spoken about it in their statements under Section 161 of CrPC. It is a case of completely botched up investigation and, therefore, the appellant deserves acquittal.
SUBMISSION OF THE RESPONDENT
15. Learned counsel for the State placed substantial reliance upon the recovery of the vehicle. It is stated that admittedly the vehicle belonged to the father of the appellant. That is the reason why [2024] 2 S.C.R. 785Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) an application was filed seeking its custody, which came to be allowed. Both the courts have rightly held that the discrepancies are bound to happen in view of the passage of time from the date of incident till the deposition is recorded in the Court. PW-2 and PW-3 did not have any ulterior motive or reason to implicate the appellant. PW-3’s statement has been recorded at the earliest. There is nothing wrong in the inquest report submitted by PW-9. As there is no perversity, appreciation by both the courts of the evidence available on record for coming to their conclusion does not warrant any interference.
DISCUSSION
16. Before considering the factual submissions of both sides, we shall first deal with the position of law which is relevant for deciding the appeal.
Investigation and the Role of Investigating Officer
17. An investigation of a crime is a lawful search of men and materials relevant in reconstructing and recreating the circumstances of an offence said to have been committed. With the evidence in possession, an Investigating Officer shall travel back in time and, therefore tick off the time zone to reach the exact time and date of the occurrence of the incident under investigation. The goal of investigation is to determine the truth which would help the Investigating Officer to form a correct opinion on the culpability of the named accused or suspect. Once such an opinion is formed on a fair assessment of the evidence collected in the investigation, the role of the court comes into play when the evidence i.e. oral, documentary, circumstantial, scientific, electronic, etc. is presented for and on behalf of the prosecution. In its journey towards determining the truth, a court shall play an active role while acknowledging the respective roles meant to be played by the prosecution and the defence. During the entire play, the rules of evidence ought to be honoured, sprinkled with the element of fairness through due procedure. Adequate opportunities would have to be given to challenge every assumption. Administration of criminal justice lies in determining the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The power of the State to prosecute an accused commences with investigation, collection of evidence and presentation before the Court for acceptance.
786 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
18. The investigating agency, the prosecutor and the defence are expected to lend ample assistance to the court in order to decipher the truth. As the investigating agency is supposed to investigate a crime, its primary duty is to find out the plausible offender through the materials collected. It may or may not be possible for the said agency to collect every material, but it has to form its opinion with the available material. There is no need for such an agency to fix someone as an accused at any cost. It is ultimately for the court to decide who the culprit is. Arvind Kumar @ Nemichand & Ors. v. State of Rajasthan, [2021] 11 SCR 237, “Fair, Defective, Colourable Investigation
40. An Investigating Officer being a public servant is expected to conduct the investigation fairly. While doing so, he is expected to look for materials available for coming to a correct conclusion. He is concerned with the offense as against an offender. It is the offense that he investigates. Whenever a homicide happens, an investigating officer is expected to cover all the aspects and, in the process, shall always keep in mind as to whether the offence would come under Section 299 IPC sans Section 300 IPC. In other words, it is his primary duty to satisfy that a case would fall under culpable homicide not amounting to murder and then a murder. When there are adequate materials available, he shall not be overzealous in preparing a case for an offense punishable under Section 302 IPC. We believe that a pliable change is required in the mind of the Investigating Officer. After all, such an officer is an officer of the court also and his duty is to find out the truth and help the court in coming to the correct conclusion. He does not know sides, either of the victim or the accused but shall only be guided by law and be an epitome of fairness in his investigation.
41. There is a subtle difference between a defective investigation, and one brought forth by a calculated and deliberate action or inaction. A defective investigation per se would not enure to the benefit of the accused, unless it goes into the root of the very case of the [2024] 2 S.C.R. 787Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) prosecution being fundamental in nature. While dealing with a defective investigation, a court of law is expected to sift the evidence available and find out the truth on the principle that every case involves a journey towards truth. There shall not be any pedantic approach either by the prosecution or by the court as a case involves an element of law rather than morality. xxx xxx xxx
44. We would only reiterate the aforesaid principle qua a fair investigation through the following judgment of Kumar v. State, (2018) 7 SCC 536:
“27. The action of investigating authority in pursuing the case in the manner in which they have done must be rebuked. The High Court on this aspect, correctly notices that the police authorities have botched up the arrest for reasons best known to them. Although we are aware of the ratio laid down in Parbhu v. King Emperor [Parbhu v. King Emperor, AIR 1944 PC 73], wherein the Court had ruled that irregularity and illegality of arrest would not affect the culpability of the offence if the same is proved by cogent evidence, yet in this case at hand, such irregularity should be shown deference as the investigating authorities are responsible for suppression of facts.
28. The criminal justice must be above reproach. It is irrelevant whether the falsity lie in the statement of witnesses or the guilt of the accused. The investigative authority has a responsibility to investigate in a fair manner and elicit truth. At the cost of repetition, I must remind the authorities concerned to take up the investigation in a neutral manner, without having regard to the ultimate result.
In this case at hand, we cannot close our eyes to what has happened; regardless of guilt or the asserted persuasiveness of the evidence, the 788 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports aspect wherein the police has actively connived to suppress the facts, cannot be ignored or overlooked.”
45. A fair investigation would become a colourable one when there involves a suppression. Suppressing the motive, injuries and other existing factors which will have the effect of modifying or altering the charge would amount to a perfunctory investigation and, therefore, become a false narrative. If the courts find that the foundation of the prosecution case is false and would not conform to the doctrine of fairness as against a conscious suppression, then the very case of the prosecution falls to the ground unless there are unimpeachable evidence to come to a conclusion for awarding a punishment on a different charge.”
(emphasis supplied)
19. Common Cause and Others v. Union of India, (2015) 6 SCC 332, “31. There is a very high degree of responsibility placed on an investigating agency to ensure that an innocent person is not subjected to a criminal trial. This responsibility is coupled with an equally high degree of ethical rectitude required of an investigating officer or an investigating agency to ensure that the investigations are carried out without any bias and are conducted in all fairness not only to the accused person but also to the victim of any crime, whether the victim is an individual or the State.”
Case Diary Section 172 of CrPC “172. Diary of proceedings in investigation.—(1) Every police officer making an investigation under this Chapter shall day by day enter his proceedings in the investigation in a dairy, setting forth the time at which the information reached him, the time at which he began and closed his investigation, the place or places visited by him, and a statement of the circumstances ascertained through his investigation.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 789Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) (1-A) The statements of witnesses recorded during the course of investigation under section 161 shall be inserted in the case diary.
(1-B) The diary referred to in sub-section (1) shall be a volume and duly paginated.
(2) Any Criminal Court may send for the police diaries of a case under inquiry or trial in such Court, and may use such diaries, not as evidence in the case, but to aid it in such inquiry or trial.
(3) Neither the accused nor his agents shall be entitled to call for such diaries, nor shall he or they be entitled to see them merely because they are referred to by the Court; but, if they are used by the police officer who made them to refresh his memory, or if the Court uses them for the purpose of contradicting such police officer, the provisions of section 161 or section 145, as the case may be, of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872), shall apply.”
Section 145 of the Evidence Act “145. Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing.—A witness may be cross-examined as to previous statements made by him in writing or reduced into writing, and relevant to matters in question, without such writing being shown to him, or being proved; but, if it is intended to contradict him by the writing, his attention must, before the writing can be proved, be called to those parts of it which are to be used for the purpose of contradicting him.” Section 161 of the Evidence Act “161. Right of adverse party as to writing used to refresh memory.—Any writing referred to under the provisions of the two last preceding sections must be produced and shown to the adverse party if he requires it; such party may, if he pleases, cross-examine the witness thereupon.”
20. A case diary is maintained by an Investigating Officer during his investigation for the purpose of entering the day-to-day proceedings of the investigation. While doing so, the Investigating Officer should 790 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports mandatorily record the necessary particulars gathered in the course of investigation with the relevant date, time and place. Under subsection (1-A) and (1-B) of Section 172 of CrPC, the Investigating Officer has to mention, in his case diary, the statement of witnesses recorded during investigation with due pagination. Sub-section (1-A) and (1-B) were inserted by Act 5 of 2009 with effect from 31/12/2009. The object of these sub-sections is to facilitate a fair investigation since a statement made under Section 161 of CrPC is not expected to be signed as mandated by Section 162 of CrPC. To highlight the importance of adhering to the requirements of these sub-sections, we rely upon the Law Commission of India’s One Hundred and Fifty Fourth Report (154 th ) on Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, Chapter IX, “7. After giving our earnest consideration and in view of the fact that there is unanimity in respect of the need for making substantial changes in the law, we propose that there should be changes on the following lines :
…The signature of the witness on the statement thus recorded need not be obtained. But, if the witness so examined desires a copy of such statement so recorded shall be handed over to him under acknowledgement.
To reflect the shift in emphasis, a corresponding amendment to Section 172 should also be made to the effect that the Investigating Officer maintaining the case diary should mention about the statement of the circumstances thus ascertained, and also attach to the diary for each day, copies of the statement of facts thus recorded under Section 161 CrPC.
Neither the accused nor his agent shall be entitled to call for such diaries which can be put to a limited use as provided under Section 172 CrPC. Under the existing provisions of the Code, the preparation of the earliest record of the statement of witness is left in the hands of Investigating Officer and as the mode of recording as provided in section 162 does not ensure the accuracy of the record (It is well known that many good cases are spoiled by insidious incorrect entries at the instance of the accused and it is also well known that many innocent persons [2024] 2 S.C.R. 791Shailesh Kumar v. State of U.P. (Now State of Uttarakhand) are sent up along with the guilty at the instance of informant’s party),…”
(emphasis supplied)
21. In furtherance of the above suggestion, the Law Commission of India accordingly provided a draft amendment to Section 172 of CrPC for the consideration of the Parliament, “… On the above mentioned lines, the relevant Sections can be amended as follows:
xxxx 172(1) Every police officer making an investigation under this chapter shall day by day enter his proceedings in the investigation in a diary, setting forth the time at which the information reached him, the time at which he began and closed his investigation, the place or places visited by him and a statement if the circumstances ascertained through his investigation; and also attach to the diary for each day copies of statement of facts, if any, recorded under Section 161 in respect of the person or persons whose examination was completed that day.
(2) Any criminal Court may send for the police diaries of a case under inquiry or trial in such court, and may use such diaries, not as evidence in the case, but to aid it in such inquiry or trial.
(3) Neither the accused nor his agents shall be entitled to call for such diaries, nor shall he or they be entitled to see them merely because they are referred (to) by this Court.” (emphasis supplied)
22. While it is the responsibility and duty of the Investigating Officer to make a due recording in his case diary, there is no corresponding right under sub-section (3) of Section 172 of CrPC for accused to seek production of such diaries, or to peruse them, except in a case where they are used by a police officer maintaining them to refresh his memory, or in a case where the court uses them for the purpose of contradicting the police officer. In such a case, the provision of Section 145 or Section 161, as the case may be, of the Evidence Act, shall apply.
792 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
23. Law is quite settled that an improper maintenance of a case diary by the Investigating Officer will not enure to the benefit of the accused. Prejudice has to be shown and proved by the accused despite non-compliance of Section 172 of CrPC in a given case. However, this does not take away the mandatory duty of the police officer to maintain it properly. As the court is the guardian of truth, it is the duty of the Investigating Officer to satisfy the court when it seeks to contradict him. The right of the accused is, therefore, very restrictive and limited. Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, (1983)
3 SCC 344,
“17. The other inference which disturbs us is that the entries in the police case diary (set forth in the annexure to the counter-affidavit on the record) do not appear to have been entered with the scrupulous completeness and efficiency which the law requires of such a document. The haphazard maintenance of a document of that status not only does no credit to those responsible for maintaining it but defeats the very purpose for which it is required to be maintained. We think it to be of the utmost importance that the entries in a police case diary should be made with promptness, in sufficient detail, mentioning all significant facts, in careful chronological order and with complete objectivity.”
(emphasis supplied)
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.