M/S Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 53; [2024] 1 S.C.R. 642
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 23 Jan 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8580/2011
- Sections
- 147, 148, 139, 139(9), 260A, 143, 143(3), 144, 282(2), 132, 145, 149
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 1 S.C.R. 642 : 2024 INSC 53 M/s Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v.
Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam (Civil Appeal Nos. 8580-8582 of 2011)
23 January 2024 [B. V. Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan*, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Reopening of a concluded assessment-reassessment u/s. 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 following issuance of notice u/s. 148 of the Act, legally sustainable or bad in law.
Headnotes Income Tax Act, 1961 – ss. 147 and 148 – Reopening of a concluded assessment-reassessment u/s. 147 following issuance of notice u/s. 148 – Sustainability:
Held: On the basis of the balance sheet submitted by the assessee before the Bank for obtaining credit, the assessing officer upon a comparison of the same with a subsequent balance sheet filed by the assessee for the assessment year 1993-94 concluded that there was escapement of income and initiated reassessment proceedings – Dehors such balance sheet, there were no other material in the possession of the assessing officer to hold that income of the assessee for the assessment years had escaped assessment – When the assessee had not made any false declaration, it was nothing but a subsequent subjective analysis of the assessing officer that income of the assessee for the assessment years was much higher than what was assessed and thus, had escaped assessment – This was a mere change of opinion which cannot be a ground for reopening of assessment – Returns for the assessment years were not accompanied by the regular books of account – Such return may be a defective one but certainly not invalid return – Furthermore, in none of the assessment years, the assessing officer had issued any declaration that the returns were defective – Assessee asserted both in the pleadings and in the oral hearing that though it could not file regular books of account along with the returns for the assessment years because of seizure by the department, nonetheless the returns [2024] 1 S.C.R. 643M/S M a n g a l a m P u b l i c a t i o n s , K o t t a y a m v . Commissioner o f Income T a x , K o t t a y a m of income were accompanied by tentative profit and loss account and other details of income which were duly enquired into by the assessing officer in the assessment proceedings – Thus, the tribunal justified in holding that the reassessments for the assessment years not justified – High Court erred in reversing the findings of the tribunal – Order of the High Court set aside and that of the tribunal restored. [Paras 41-45] Income Tax Act, 1961 – s. 147 – Income escaping assessment – ‘Full and true disclosure’ – Meaning of:
Held: Word ‘disclosure’ means to disclose, reveal, unravel or bring to notice –Word ‘true’ qualifies a fact or averment as correct, exact, actual, genuine or honest – Word ‘full’ means complete – True disclosure of concealed income must relate to the assessee concerned – Full disclosure, in the context of financial documents, means that all material or significant information should be disclosed – Thus, the meaning of ‘full and true disclosure’ is the voluntary filing of a return of income that the assessee earnestly believes to be true – Production of books of accounts or other material evidence that could ordinarily be discovered by the assessing officer does not amount to a true and full disclosure. [Para 31] Income Tax Act, 1961 – s. 147 – Income escaping assessment – Expression “change of opinion” in terms of assessment proceedings:
Held: Expression “change of opinion” would imply formulation of opinion and then a change thereof – In terms of assessment proceedings, it means formulation of belief by the assessing officer resulting from what he thinks on a particular question – Thus, before interfering with the proposed reopening of the assessment on the ground that the same is based only on a change of opinion, the court ought to verify whether the assessment earlier made has either expressly or by necessary implication expressed an opinion on a matter which is the basis of the alleged escapement of income that was taxable – If the assessment order is non-speaking, cryptic or perfunctory in nature, it may be difficult to attribute to the assessing officer any opinion on the questions that are raised in the proposed reassessment proceedings. [Para 36] Income Tax Act, 1961 – s. 139 – Return of income – Obligation on assessee to disclose all material facts necessary for his assessment:
644 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Held: s.139 places an obligation upon every person to furnish voluntarily a return of his total income if such income during the previous year exceeded the maximum amount which is not chargeable to income tax – Assessee is under further obligation to disclose all material facts necessary for his assessment for that year fully and truly – While the duty of the assessee is to disclose fully and truly all primary and relevant facts necessary for assessment, it does not extend beyond this – Once the primary facts are disclosed by the assessee, the burden shifts onto the assessing officer. [Para 41] s. 139 – Return of income – When to be treated as invalid return: Held: U/s. 139(9), where the assessing officer considers that the return of income furnished by the assessee is defective, he may intimate the defect to the assessee and give him an opportunity to rectify the defect within fifteen days from the date of such intimation or within such further period, the assessing officer may in his discretion allow – Burden is on the assessing officer – If he does not exercise the discretion, the return of income cannot be construed as a defective return – If the defect is not rectified within the specified period or within the further period as may be allowed, the return shall be treated as an invalid return – In such an eventuality, it would be construed that the assessee had failed to furnish the return. [Para 24.1-24.2] Case Law Cited Calcutta Discount Company Limited v. Income Tax Officer, [1961] 2 SCR 241 : (1961) 41 ITR 1991 – followed.
M/s Phool Chand Bajrang Lal v. Income Tax Officer, [1993] 1 Suppl. SCR 28 : (1993) 4 SCC 77; Srikrishna Private Limited v. ITO, Calcutta, [1996] 3 Suppl. SCR 627 : (1996) 9 SCC 534; CIT, Delhi v. Kelvinator of India Limited, [2010] 1 SCR 768 : (2010) 2 SCC 723; CIT v.
Bimal Kumar Damani, (2003) 261 ITR 87 (Cal); Income Tax Officer v. Lakhmani Mewal Das, [1976] 3 SCR 956 :
1976 (3) SCC 757 : 1976 (103) ITR 437 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals cited P. Ramanatha Aiyar, Advanced Law Lexicon, Volume 2, Edition 6 – referred to.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 645M/S M a n g a l a m P u b l i c a t i o n s , K o t t a y a m v . Commissioner o f Income T a x , K o t t a y a m List of Acts Income Tax Act, 1961; Direct Tax Laws (Amendment) Act, 1987 List of Keywords Income Tax Jurisprudence; Concluded assessment; Reassessment; Search and seizure operations; Disclosed income; Limitation period; Reopening the assessment; Omission; Reason to believe; Time limit; Full and true disclosure; Production of books of accounts; Change of opinion.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 8580-8582 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 12.10.2009 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in ITA Nos.400 and 557 of 2009.
With Civil Appeal Nos.8599-8603, 8604, 8593-8598, 8583-8587 and 8588- 8592 of 2011.
Appearances for Parties Raghenth Basant, Ms. Kaushitaki Sharma, Ms. Liz Mathew, Advs. for the Appellant.
N. Venkataraman, ASG, Shyam Gopal, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Prahlad Singh, Shashank Bajpai, Suyash Pandey, Prashant Singh Ii, T. S. Sabarish, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
The perennial question in income tax jurisprudence, whether reopening of a concluded assessment i.e. reassessment under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (briefly “the Act” hereinafter) following issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act is legally sustainable or is bad in law, is again confronting us in the present batch of appeals. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, Cochin (‘Tribunal’ hereinafter) had decided in favour of the assessee 646 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports by setting aside the orders of reassessment. However, the High Court of Kerala in appeals filed by the revenue under Section 260A of the Act has reversed the findings of the Tribunal by deciding the appeals preferred by the revenue in its favour.
2. Aggrieved by the aforesaid orders passed by the High Court of Kerala (briefly “the High Court” hereinafter), the assessee had preferred special leave petitions to appeal before this Court and on leave being granted, civil appeals have been registered.
3. We have heard Mr. Raghenth Basant, learned counsel for the appellant/assessee (which would be referred to either as the appellant or as the assessee) and Mr. Shyam Gopal, learned counsel for the respondent/revenue (again, would be referred to either as the respondent or as the revenue).
4. A brief narration of facts is necessary.
5. For the sake of convenience, we may refer to civil appeal Nos. 8580, 8581 and 8582 of 2011 (M/s Mangalam Publications, Kottayam Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam).
6. The above three civil appeals pertain to assessment years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93.
7. The assessee was a partnership firm at the relevant point of time though it got itself registered as a company since the assessment year 1994-95. The assessee is carrying on the business of publishing newspaper, weeklies and other periodicals in several languages under the brand name “Mangalam”. Prior to the assessment year 1994-95 including the assessment years under consideration, the status of the assessee was that of a firm, being regularly assessed to income tax.
8. For the assessment year 1990-91, assessee filed return of income on 22.10.1991 showing loss of Rs.5,99,390.00. Subsequently, the assessee filed a revised computation showing income at Rs.5,63,920.00. Assessee did not file any balance sheet alongwith the return of income on the ground that books of account were seized by the income tax department (department) in the course of search and seizure operations on 03.12.1995 and that those books of account were not yet returned. In the assessment proceedings, the assessing officer did not accept the contention of the assessee and [2024] 1 S.C.R. 647M/S Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam made an analysis of the incomings and outgoings of the assessee for the previous year under consideration. After considering various heads of income and sale of publications, the assessing officer made a lumpsum addition of Rs. 1 lakh to the disclosed income vide the assessment order dated 29.01.1992 passed under Section 143 (3) of the Act.
9. Likewise, for the assessment year 1991-1992, the assessee did not file any balance sheet along with the return of income for the same reason mentioned for the assessment year 1990-1991. The return of income was filed on 22.10.1991 showing a loss of Rs.21,66,760.00. As per the revised profit and loss account, the sale proceeds of the publications were shown at Rs.8,21,24,873.00. Assessing officer scrutinised the net sale proceeds as per the Audit Bureau of Circulation figure and the certified Performance Audit Report. On that basis assessing officer accepted the sale proceeds of Rs.8,21,24,873.00 as correct being in conformity with the facts and figures available in the Audit Bureau of Circulation report and the Performance Audit Report. After considering the incomings and outgoings of the relevant previous year assessing officer reworked the aforesaid figures but found that there was a deficiency of Rs.29,17,931.00 in the incoming and outgoing statement which the assessee could not explain. Accordingly, this amount was added to the total income of the assessee. Further, the assessee could not produce proper vouchers in respect of a number of items of expenditure. Accordingly, an addition of Rs.1,50,000.00 was made to the total income of the assessee vide the assessment order dated 29.01.2022 passed under Section 143 (3) of the Act.
10. For the assessment year 1992-1993 also, the assessee filed the return of income on 07.12.1992 showing a loss of Rs.10,50,000.00. However, a revised return was filed subsequently on 28.01.1993 showing loss of Rs.44,75,212.00. Like the earlier years, assessee did not maintain books of account and did not file the balance sheet for the same reason. However, the assessee disclosed total sale proceeds of the weeklies at Rs.7,16,95,530.00 and also advertisement receipts to the extent of Rs.40 lakhs. The profit was estimated at Rs.41,63,500.00 before allowing depreciation.
10.1. On scrutiny of the performance certificate issued by the Audit Bureau of Circulation, the assessing officer observed that total sale proceeds of the weeklies after allowing sale commission 648 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports came to Rs.7,22,94,757.00. Following the profit percentage adopted in earlier years, the assessing officer estimated the income from the weeklies and other periodicals at 7.50% before depreciation, adding the estimated advertisement receipts of Rs.40 lakhs to the total sale receipts of Rs.7,22,94,757.00. The assessing officer held that the total receipt from sale of weeklies and periodicals came to Rs.7,62,94,757.00. The profit earned before depreciation at the rate of 7.50% on the turnover came to Rs.57,22,106.00. In respect of the daily newspaper, the assessing officer worked out the loss at Rs.22,95,872.00 as against the loss of Rs.41,23,500.00 claimed by the assessee. Taking an overall view of the matter, the assessing officer estimated the business income of the assessee during the assessment year 1992-1993 at Rs.10,00,000.00 vide the assessment order dated 26.03.1993 passed under Section 143(3) of the Act.
11. It may be mentioned that for the assessment year 1993-1994, the assessee had submitted the profit and loss account as well as the balance sheet along with the return of income. While examining the balance sheet, the assessing officer noticed that the balance in the capital account of all the partners of the assessee firm together was Rs.1,85,75,455.00 as on 31.03.1993 whereas the capital of the partners as on 31.12.1985 was only Rs.2,55,117.00. According to the assessing officer, none of the partners had any other source of income apart from one of the partners, Smt. Cleramma Vargese, who had a business under the name and style of “Mangalam Finance”. As the income assessed for all the years was found to be not commensurate with the increase in the capital by Rs.1,83,20,338.00 (Rs.1,85,75,455.00 – Rs.2,55,117.00) from 1985 to 1993, it was considered necessary to reassess the income of the assessee as well as that of the partners for the assessment years 1988-1989 to 1993-1994. After obtaining the approval of the Commissioner of Income Tax, Trivandrum, notice under Section 148 of the Act was issued and served upon the assessee on 29.03.2000.
12. In respect of the assessment year 1990-1991, the assessee informed the assessing officer that the return of income filed which culminated in the assessment order dated 29.01.1992 may be considered as the return in the reassessment proceedings. The assessing officer took cognizance of the profit and loss account and the balance sheet filed [2024] 1 S.C.R. 649M/S Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam by the assessee before the South Indian Bank on the basis of which assessment of income for the assessment years 1988 - 1989 and 1989 - 1990 were completed. Objection of the assessee that the aforesaid balance sheet was prepared only for the purpose of obtaining loan from the South Indian Bank and therefore could not be relied upon for income tax assessment was brushed aside. The reassessment was made on the basis of the accounts submitted to the South Indian Bank. By the reassessment order dated 21.03.2002 passed under Section 144/147 of the Act, the assessing officer quantified the total income of the assessee at Rs.29,66,910.00 whereafter order was passed allocating income among the partners.
13. Likewise, for the assessment year 1991-1992, the assessing officer passed reassessment order dated 21.03.2002 under Section 144/147 of the Act determining total income at Rs.13,91,700.00. Following the same, allocation of income was also made amongst the partners.
14. In so far assessment year 1992-1993 is concerned, the assessing officer passed the reassessment order also on 21.03.2002 under Section 144/147 of the Act determining the total income of the assessee at Rs.25,06,660.00. Thereafter allocation of income was made amongst the partners in the manner indicated in the order of reassessment.
15. At this stage, we may mention that the assessing officer had worked out the escaped income for the three assessment years of 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 at Rs.50,96,041.00. This amount was further apportioned between the three assessment years in proportion to the sales declared by the assessee in the aforesaid assessment years as under:
Sr. No. Assessment year Amount
1. 1990-91 Rs.19,05,476.00
2. 1991-92 Rs.16,83,910.00
3. 1992-93 Rs.15,06,655.00 Total Rs.50,96,041.00 rounded off to Rs.50,96,040.00
16. Against the aforesaid three reassessment orders for the assessment years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93, assessee preferred three 650 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports appeals before the first appellate authority i.e. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), IV Cochin (briefly “the CIT(A)” hereinafter). Assessee raised the ground that it had disclosed all material facts necessary for completing the assessments. The assessments having been completed under Section 143(3) of the Act, the assessments could not have been reopened after expiry of four years from the end of the relevant assessment year as per the proviso to Section 147 of the Act. It was pointed out that the limitation period for the last of the three assessment years i.e. 1992-93, had expired on 31.03.1997 whereas the notices under Section 148 of the Act were issued and served on the assessee only on 29.03.2000. Therefore, all the three reassessment proceedings were barred by limitation. The assessee also argued that the alleged income escaping assessment could not be computed on an estimate basis. In the present case, the assessing officer had allocated the alleged escaped income for the three assessment years in proportion to the corresponding sales turnover. It was further argued that as per Section 282(2), notice under Section 148 of the Act in the case of a partnership firm was required to be made to a member of the firm. In the present case, the notices were issued to the partnership firm. Therefore, such notices could not be treated as valid.
16.1. CIT(A) rejected all the above contentions urged by the assessee. CIT(A) relied on Section 139(9)(f) of the Act and thereafter held that the assessee had not furnished the details as per the aforesaid provisions and therefore fell short of the requirements specified therein. Vide the common appellate order dated 26.02.2004, CIT(A) held that, as the assessee had failed to disclose all material facts necessary to make assessments, therefore it could not be said that the reassessment proceedings were barred by limitation in terms of the proviso to Section 147. The other two grounds raised by the assessee were also repelled by the first appellate authority. Thereafter, CIT(A) made a detailed examination of the factual aspect whereafter it proposed enhancement of the quantum of escaped income. Following the same, CIT(A) enhanced the assessment by fixing the unexplained income at Rs.1,44,02,560.00 for the assessment years 1987-88 to 1993-94 which was thereafter apportioned in respect of the relevant three assessment years. The pro-rata allotment of [2024] 1 S.C.R. 651M/S M a n g a l a m P u b l i c a t i o n s , K o t t a y a m v . Commissioner o f Income T a x , K o t t a y a m escaped income for the three assessment years as directed by CIT(A) are as follows:
Sr. No. Assessment year Escaped income
1. 1990-91 Rs.24,98,755.00
2. 1991-92 Rs.23,01,204.00
3. 1992-93 Rs.20,20,895.00 Total Rs.68,20,854.00
16.2. Thus, as against the total escaped income of Rs.50,96,040.00 for the above three assessment years as quantified by the assessing officer, CIT(A) enhanced and redetermined such income at Rs.68,20,854.00.
16.3. However, it would be relevant to mention that CIT(A) in the appellate order had noted that the assessee had filed its balance sheet as on 31.12.1985 while filing the return of income for the assessment year 1986-87. The next balance sheet was filed as on 31.03.1993. No balance sheet was filed in the interregnum on the ground that it could not maintain proper books of accounts as the relevant materials were seized by the department in the course of a search and seizure operation and not yet returned. CIT(A) further noted that the assessing officer had taken the balance sheet as on 31.03.1989 filed by the assessee before the South Indian Bank as the base for reconciling the accounts of the partners. It was noticed that CIT(A) in an earlier appellate order dated 26.03.2002 for the assessment year 1989-90 in the assessee’s own case had held that the profit and loss account and the balance sheet furnished to the South Indian Bank were not reliable. CIT(A) in the present proceedings agreed with such finding of his predecessor and held that the unexplained portion, if any, of the increase in capital and current account balance with the assessee had to be analysed on the basis of the balance sheet filed before the assessing officer as on 31.12.1985 and as on 31.03.1993.
17. Aggrieved by the common appellate order passed by the CIT(A) dated 26.02.2004, assessee preferred three separate appeals before the Tribunal which were registered as under:
652 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(i) ITA No. 282(Coch)/2004 for the assessment year 1990-91.
(ii) ITA No. 283(Coch)/2004 for the assessment year 1991-92.
(iii) ITA No. 284(Coch)/2004 for the assessment year 1992-93.
17.1. In the three appeals filed by the assessee, revenue also filed cross objections.
17.2. By the common order dated 29.10.2004, the Tribunal allowed the appeals filed by the assessee and set aside the orders of reassessment for the three assessment years as affirmed and enhanced by the CIT(A). Tribunal held that the re-examination carried out by the assessing officer was not based on any fresh material or evidence. The reassessment orders could not be sustained on the basis of the balance sheet filed by the assessee before the South Indian Bank because in an earlier appeal of the assessee itself, CIT(A) had held that such balance sheet and profit and loss account furnished to the bank were not reliable. The original assessments were completed under Section 143(3) of the Act. Therefore, it was not possible to hold that the assessee had not furnished necessary details for completing the assessments at the time of original assessment. In such circumstances, Tribunal held that the case of the assessee squarely fell within the four corners of the proviso to Section 147. Consequently, the reassessments were held to be barred by limitation, thus without jurisdiction. While allowing the appeals of the assessee, Tribunal dismissed the cross objections filed by the revenue.
18. Against the aforesaid common order of the Tribunal, the respondent preferred three appeals before the High Court under Section 260A of the Act, being IT Appeal Nos. 400, 557 and 558 of 2009 for the assessment years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 respectively. All the three appeals were allowed by the High Court vide the common order dated 12.10.2009. According to the High Court, the finding of the Tribunal that the assessee had disclosed fully and truly all material facts necessary for completion of the original assessments was not tenable. Holding that there was no material before the Tribunal to come to the conclusion that the assessee had disclosed fully and truly all material facts required for completion of original assessments, [2024] 1 S.C.R. 653M/S M a n g a l a m P u b l i c a t i o n s , K o t t a y a m v . Commissioner o f Income T a x , K o t t a y a m the High Court set aside the order of the Tribunal and remanded the appeals back to the Tribunal to consider the appeals on merit after issuing notice to the parties.
19. It is against this order that the assessee had filed the special leave petitions which on leave being granted have been registered as civil appeals. The related civil appeals have been filed by the partners of the assessee firm which would be dependent on the outcome of the present set of civil appeals.
20. Respondent has filed counter affidavit supporting the judgment under appeal. It is contended that the High Court has correctly appreciated the facts and the law and thereafter given a reasoned order as to why the reopening of assessment is valid. High Court has correctly held that the assessee had not disclosed fully and truly all the material facts necessary for completion of the assessments. Adverting to Section 139 (9) of the Act, it is submitted that, it is not mandatory for the assessing officer to treat a return as invalid even if the return is defective under any of the sub-clauses of Section 139 (9). It is the discretion of the assessing officer to issue notice. Since no notice was issued, the return and the assessment made thereon would be valid.
20.1. It is submitted that the assessee had not even had accounts pertaining to the advertisement receipts which is a major source of income of a publication entity; as a matter of fact, the assessee had shown the income from advertisements on estimation basis.
20.2. Though the assessee had been claiming that it did not maintain any books of account from the assessment years 1989- 1990 onwards, an audited balance sheet and profit and loss account submitted to the South Indian Bank were traced out and used as evidence against the assessee for reopening the assessment for the assessment year 1989- 1990. In the first appellate proceedings, CIT(A) took the view that the profit shown in the statement was for availing credit facility only and therefore set aside the reopening of assessment. Though the Tribunal concurred with the view of CIT(A), the department filed an appeal before the High Court. The assessing officer had compared the balance of the partners in their capital account in the firm in the said balance sheet (filed before the 654 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports bank) with capital in the balance sheet filed for the assessment year 1993 – 1994 and thereafter determined the probable escapement of income which is fully justified and rightly upheld by the High Court.
20.3. Respondent has contended that in the original assessments the assessing officer had made the assessments on the basis of limited information furnished by the assessee. The assessing officer made the reassessments on the basis of the increase in the capital in the balance sheets between the years ending 31.03.1989 and 31.03.1993. Respondent has denied that the reassessments were made on the basis of change of opinion. An audited balance sheet for the period ending 31.12.1984 was available with the department. Thereafter, no audited or unaudited balance sheets were furnished on the ground that books of account could not be maintained. However, an audited balance sheet for the period ending 31.03.1993 was furnished in the course of the assessment proceedings for the assessment year 1993 – 1994. Another balance sheet for the period ending 31.03.1989 which was claimed by the assessee to be an account prepared only for submission before the South Indian Bank for availing loan could be traced out. A perusal of the balance sheet for the assessment year 1993-1994 revealed that the increase in capital was not commensurate with the income assessed on estimation basis by the assessing officer for the assessment years 1989 – 1990 to 1992-1993. It was in view of such changed circumstances that notices under Section 148 were issued. The original assessments for the assessment years 1990 – 1991, 1991 – 1992 and 1992 – 1993 were completed on 29.01.1992, 29.01.1992 and 26.03.1993 respectively. The balance sheet for the assessment year 1993 – 1994 which was used as the basis for reassessment was not available with the assessing officer when the original assessments were made. Facts available with the assessing officer in the original assessments and in the reassessments were different. Since facts were different, question of any change in the opinion did not arise. In the circumstances respondent sought for dismissal of the special leave petitions since registered as civil appeals.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 655M/S M a n g a l a m P u b l i c a t i o n s , K o t t a y a m v . Commissioner o f Income T a x , K o t t a y a m
21. Mr. Raghenth Basant, learned counsel for the appellant at the outset submits that the High Court fell in error while setting aside the wellreasoned and correct order of the Tribunal. Order of the High Court should be set aside and the order of the Tribunal restored.
21.1. He submits that the appellant is a partnership firm engaged in the business of publication of newspaper, weeklies and other periodicals under the brand name “Mangalam”. Being an assessee under the Act it was maintaining proper books of accounts and had filed profit and loss accounts as well as balance sheets along with the returns of income till the assessment year 1985 – 1986. A search operation was carried out by officials of the department under Section 132 of the Act in the business premises of the appellant on 31.12.1985. In the said search operation, books of account, registers and ledgers of the appellant were seized. Because of the aforesaid, the appellant was unable to maintain proper books of account as it was not possible for it to obtain ledger balances to be brought down for the succeeding accounting years. Nonetheless, appellant maintained primary books of account and used to prepare profit and loss accounts. It also used to prepare a statement of source and application of funds in support of the income returned by it in the returns of income. Being a member of the Audit Bureau of Circulation, appellant was also required to maintain exhaustive details regarding printing and sale of newspaper and other periodicals published by it.
21.2. Learned counsel submits that returns were filed by the appellant for the three assessment years in question. Those returns were supported by profit and loss accounts and statements showing the source and application of funds. Assessments for the three assessment years were carried out and completed under Section 143 (3) of the Act after making additions and providing for certain disallowances. He submits that for the assessment year 1993–1994, the appellant had maintained complete set of books of account, audited profit and loss account and balance sheet which were duly filed before the assessing officer. Following assessment proceedings, assessing officer passed the assessment order for the assessment year 1993 – 1994 on 27.01.1994 under Section 143 (3) of the Act.
656 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
21.3. More than eight to ten years after expiry of the relevant assessment years, appellant was served with notices dated 29.03.2000 issued under Section 148 of the Act for the assessment years 1990 – 1991, 1991 – 1992 and 1992 – 1993. He submits that the basis for reassessment was purportedly comparison of the current and capital accounts of the partners of the assessee firm in the balance sheet filed along with the return for the assessment year 1993 – 1994 with the capital and current accounts of the partners as on 31.12.1985, which showed unexplained increase. The revenue also sought to rely upon the balance sheet for the assessment year 1988 – 1989 obtained by the assessing officer from the South Indian Bank which was submitted by the assessee to the said bank to avail credit facility. He submits that on such comparison the assessing officer came to an erroneous conclusion that the profits for the assessment years 1990 – 1991, 1991 – 1992 and 1992 -1993 would be Rs.1,86,57,246.00 and as the assessment for the said years came to Rs.16,64,518.00 only, there was an under assessment of income to the tune of Rs.1,69,92,728.00.
21.4. Learned counsel submits that during the reassessment proceedings assessee sought for return of the books seized by the department. Though some books were returned, the entire seized materials were not returned. As it was an old matter assessee had sought for time to look into the old records and to consult its representative. However, the assessing officer declined to grant time and went ahead and passed the reassessment orders ex parte under Section 144/147 of the Act. He submits that the assessing officer made the reassessment on a comparison of the increase in the capital and current accounts of the partners for the period from 1986 to 1993. According to him, the assessing officer could not have done that because the balance sheet for the assessment year 1989 – 1990, which was obtained by the assessing officer from the South Indian Bank, was not prepared on actual and current accounts; that was prepared on provisional and estimate basis in the absence of the account books which were seized by the department, that too, only for the purpose of obtaining credit facilities from the bank.
[2024] 1 S.C.R. 657M/S Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam
21.5. It is the submission of learned counsel for the assessee that the High Court has erred in holding that even in the absence of the entire books of accounts, the assessee had not furnished the documents and particulars required under Section 139 (9) (f) of the Act. According to the High Court since the original assessment was completed without the books of account and the details under Section 139 (9) (f) being furnished, therefore, the assessee had not disclosed fully and truly all material facts necessary for completion of assessment. Learned counsel submits that for non-furnishing of particulars under Section 139 (9) (f) the original assessment would be rendered invalid. However, the assessing officer did not adopt the aforesaid course of action but instead proceeded to complete the assessments under Section 143 (3) of the Act. In the circumstances, he submits that non furnishing of details under Section 139 (9) (f) cannot lead to any inference that material facts had not been disclosed so as to justify reopening of assessments that too eight to ten years after expiry of the relevant assessment years.
21.6. Learned counsel asserts that even though the assessee was not maintaining regular books of accounts, all relevant details necessary for making the assessments were furnished before the assessing officer. These included detailed cash flow statements, profit and loss accounts, statements showing the source and application of funds reflecting the increase in the capital and current accounts of the partners of the assessee firm etc. It was thereafter that assessments were completed not only in respect of the assessee for the above three assessment years but also for the partners as well under Section 143(3) of the Act.
21.7. It is contended by learned counsel for the assessee that there was no specific information before the assessing officer wherefrom he could form a reason to believe that income exigible to income tax had escaped assessment for the three assessment years. The only reason for initiating reassessment proceedings was the impression of the assessing officer that there was an increase in the capital and current accounts of the partners upon a comparison of the balance sheets for the assessment year 1985 – 1986 and for the assessment year 1993 – 1994 which could not be properly explained. The 658 [2024] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports assessing officer also formed the above belief on the basis of the balance sheet for the assessment year 1989 – 1990 which was obtained from the South Indian Bank. According to him, on both counts, the revenue could not have initiated proceedings for reopening of concluded assessments that too under Section 143 (3) of the Act. He submits that CIT(A), in the appeal of the assessee for the assessment year 1989 -1990, had clearly held that such a balance sheet submitted before the bank was not reliable. Learned counsel asserts that an assessing officer would get the jurisdiction to reopen an assessment only on the basis of specific, reliable and relevant information coming to his possession subsequent to the original assessment and not otherwise. In support of such submission learned counsel has relied upon the decisions of this Court in:
(i) M/s Phool Chand Bajrang Lal Vs. Income Tax Officer,
(1993) 4 SCC 77.
(ii) Srikrishna Private Limited Vs. ITO, Calcutta,
(1996) 9 SCC 534.
21.8. Summing up his submissions, learned counsel submits that as rightly held by the Tribunal, it was the change of view of the assessing officer upon assessing the comparative accounts of the partners which led to the reassessments which is not based on any fresh material or evidence. It is evident that the assessing officer had only reviewed the original assessments on the basis of a fresh application of mind to the same set of facts. Therefore, it is a clear case of change of opinion leading to reassessment proceedings which is not permissible in law as held by this Court in CIT, Delhi Vs. Kelvinator of India Limited, (2010) 2 SCC 723. He therefore submits that the order of the High Court is liable to be set aside and that of the Tribunal restored.
22. Mr. Shyam Gopal, learned counsel for the respondent at the outset submits that there is no merit at all in the civil appeals, and therefore, the civil appeals should be dismissed.
22.1. Adverting to Section 145 (1) of the Act, he submits that income from the profits of business shall be computed in accordance with the cash or mercantile or any other system of accounting regularly employed by the assessee. Since the business income [2024] 1 S.C.R. 659M/S Mangalam Publications, Kottayam v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam had to be computed by following the method of accounting adopted by the assessee and based on the books of accounts so maintained, the assessee was required to produce the books of accounts but when the books of accounts were not available, at least to furnish the particulars in terms of Section 139 (9) (f) of the Act.
22.2. Referring to Section 139 (9) (f) of the Act, he submits that even in the absence of regular books of accounts, the assessee is bound to provide the information required under the aforesaid provision. An assessee who does not disclose the above information and instead submits returns on estimation basis cannot claim that it has fully and truly disclosed all material facts required for assessment.
22.3. According to Mr. Gopal, Tribunal erred in holding that the assessee had disclosed fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment. In fact, Tribunal did not go into the merit of the case. Rather, Tribunal held that there were no materials before the assessing officer to take the view that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.