Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By LRs. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1006; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 923
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice C.T. Ravikumar, Justice Sanjay Karol
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4211/2009
- Sections
- 129, 17
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 923 : 2024 INSC 1006 Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors.
v.
Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 4211 of 2009)
19 December 2024 [C.T. Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Under Mohammedan law, whether an owner of property can, in his lifetime, transfer said property to his heirs by way of partition; whether, in the facts of this case, the requisites of a valid gift were met and also whether nomenclature employed in Mutation Entry can be said to be indicative of intentions.
Headnotes† Mohammedan law – Partition under, during the lifetime of the owner – If permissible:
Held: No – Under Mohammedan Law, partition while a person is alive between him and his heirs is impermissible – Under the Mohammedan Law, the right of an heir-apparent comes into existence for the first time on the death of the ancestor, and he is not entitled until then to any interest in the property to which he would succeed as an heir if he survived the ancestor – Thus, in the present case, ‘SS’ during his lifetime could not have partitioned his property, giving two parts thereof to his sons (appellants). [Paras 20, 21] Mohammedan law – Oral gift made by ‘SS’ in favour of his sons, if was a valid gift – Plea of the appellants that even though the Mutation entry used the word ‘partition’, it should be read as ‘gift’ – Nomenclature employed in Mutation Entry, if indicative of intentions:
Held: Only the substance, not the form or nomenclature, is pertinent to determine the nature of the transaction – ‘Partition’ and ‘gift’ are two terms that have different requisites, require different circumstances, and bear different consequences – Partition, is the division of property among co-owners, whereas gift is a voluntary transfer of existing property made voluntarily *Author 924 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports without consideration – The legal necessities of both these modes of conveyance are quite different and, thus, cannot be liberally interpreted – What is required to be considered is the intention as shown by the words written in a document – Further, the words used in a document have to be understood in their natural meaning with reference to the language employed – While interpreting any document, common or usual meaning is ascribed to the words unless that leads to absurdity – A perusal of the Mutation Entry No.8258 (Ex.P1) shows that ‘SS’ got the ‘partition’ done in favour of his sons – The words “partition of the property done by SAKS” clearly indicate his intention to divide the property into three parts without any indication of his intent to gift the property to his sons – Had ‘SS’ intended to gift the property, it ought to have been recorded as a gift in the Mutation Entry – Even though the other two requisites, i.e. acceptance and possession, may have been proved, the essential requirement of the declaration made with clear and unequivocal intention remains unfulfilled – When neither the words of the Mutation Entry nor the Entry itself support the claim of the appellants-original defendants in any manner, for neither can it be a gift nor does the Mutation Entry mean that any title rests with them, the oral gift made by ‘SS’ in favour of his sons cannot be held to be a valid gift – No fault with the reasoning of the Trial Court and the High Court qua the questions of gift and partition – Order of the Trial Court concurred by the High Court is confirmed. [Paras 31-34, 36, 38] Mohammedan Law – Gift deed – Requisites of a valid gift deed – Enumerated.
Islamic Personal Law – Sources – Discussed.
Mohammedan Law – Gift – Registration:
Held: Registration of gift is not required under Mohammedan Law – An unwritten and unregistered gift executed by the donor in favour of donees is valid. [Para 27] Words and Phrases – ‘Partition’; Gift (Hiba) – Meaning – Discussed.
Case Law Cited Hafeeza Bibi v. S.K. Farid [2011] 5 SCR 1155 : (2011) 5 SCC 654; N.Mani v. Sangeetha Theatre & Ors. (2004) 12 SCC 278; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 925Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors. Mathai Samuel v. Eapen Eapen [2012] 10 SCR 1098 : (2012)13 SCC 80; B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Srinivasamurthy [2010] 11 SCR 784 : (2010) 12 SCC 530; Abdul Rahim & Ors. v. Sk. Abdul Zabar [2009] 4 SCR 32 : (2009) 6 SCC 160; K. Mahammad Ghouse Sahib v. Jamila Bi & Ors., 1949 SCC OnLine Mad 433; Shayara Bano v. Union of India [2017] 9 SCR 797 : (2017) 9 SCC 1; Shub Karan Bubna v. Sita Saran Bubna [2009] 14 SCR 40 : (2009) 9 SCC 689; Abdul Wahid Khan v. Mussumat Noran Bibi & Ors., 1885 SCC OnLine PC 4; Gulam Abbas v. Haji Kayyum Ali & Ors. [1973] 2 SCR 300 : (1973) 1 SCC 1; Syed Shah Ghulam Ghouse Mohiuddin v. Syed Shah Ahmed Mohiuddin Kamisul Quadri [1971] 3 SCR 734 : (1971) 1 SCC 597; Outlines of Mohammadan Law (2009) 6 SCC 160; Mohd. Abdul Ghani v. Fakhr Jahan Begam, 1922 SCC OnLine PC 18; Jamila Begum v. Shami Mohd [2018] 13 SCR 1253 : (2019) 2 SCC 727; Rasheeda Khatoon v. Ashiq Ali [2014] 11 SCR 31 : (2014) 10 SCC 459; Hafeeza Bibi v. Sk. Farid [2011] 5 SCR 1155 : (2011) 5 SCC 654; D.N. Joshi v. D.C. Harris [2017] 7 SCR 326 : (2017) 12 SCC 624; Sawarni v. Inder Kaur [1996] Supp. 5 SCR 165 : (1996) 6 SCC 223; Jitendra Singh v. State of M.P. & Ors. 2021 SCC OnLine SC 802; P. Kishore Kumar v. Vittal K. Patkar [2023] 14 SCR 796 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1483 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited ‘The Muslim Law of India’, 2nd Edition, Chapter 12 (Law of Inheritance) by Tahir Mahmood; Mulla on Mohammedan Law 5th Edition; Advanced Law Lexicon P Ramanatha Aiyar 3rd Edition Reprint 2009; Mulla Principles of Mahomedan Law, 22nd Edition; Mohammedan Law, by Syed Ameer Ali 4th ed., vol.i – referred to. List of Keywords Mohammedan law; ‘Partition’; Gift (hiba); Partition while a person is alive; Oral gift; Valid gift; Mutation Entry; Nomenclature; Transfer of property during the lifetime of a person; Acceptance; Possession; Declaration made with clear and unequivocal intention; Requisites of a valid gift; Registration of gift; Unwritten gift; Unregistered gift; Donor; Donees; ‘leave’, ‘leaves’; ‘man dies’; Division of property is only possible upon the death of a person; Inheritance; Nature of the transaction; Words used in a document; Natural meaning; Language employed; Common or usual meaning.
926 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 4211 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.01.2006 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in RFA No. 469 of 1998 With Civil Appeal No.4213 of 2009 Appearances for Parties Basava Prabhu S. Patil, S N Bhat, Sr. Advs., Samarth Kashyap, V. N. Raghupathy, Radhakrishna S Hegde, Rajeev Singh, Tarun Kumar Thakur, Ms. Parvati Bhat, Abhay Choudhary M, Vivek Ram R, Ms. Anuradha Mutatkar, Advs. for the appearing parties Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Karol J.
1. The instant appeals, preferred by the original defendants, arise out of the judgment and order dated 13.01.2006 passed by the High Court of Karnataka whereby it dismissed the appeals filed by the original-defendants, confirming the decree passed by the Court of the Principal Civil Judge (Sr. Dn.),1 Bijapur in O.S. No.140 of 1988 in favour of the original plaintiffs (Respondents herein).
2. Admittedly, the parties are governed by Mohammedan law. The following questions arise for our consideration:-
(a) Whether an owner of property can, in his lifetime, transfer said property to his heirs by way of partition?
(b) Whether, in the facts of this case, the requisites of a valid gift were met and also whether nomenclature employed in Mutation Entry can be said to be indicative of intentions?
FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The brief facts are stated by referring to the parties as per their status in the Trial Court.
1 Hereinafter referred to as ‘Trial Court’ [2024] 12 S.C.R. 927Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors.
4. One Sultan Saheb, the owner of the suit land described in Schedule B and C being agricultural land and house property respectively, of the plaint, died on 09.01.1978. Through his first marriage, he had one daughter namely, Ajamunisa (defendant no.11). With his first wife passing away, he remarried and, from this second marriage, had three children- two sons, namely Mansoorsaheb (defendant no.1), Sikandar (defendant no.9) and daughter namely, Rabiyabi. Plaintiff nos.1 to 9 are the children of Rabiyabi, who had died on 08.06.1985. Defendant no.2 is Mansoorsaheb’s wife, defendant nos. 3 to 7 are his children, defendant no.8 is defendant no.1’s daughter-in-law. Defendant no.10 is the son of defendant no.9.
For ease of understanding, the position of parties is demonstrated through a family tree:
5. The case of the plaintiffs is that Sultan Saheb was the owner and possessor of the suit property. On his death, defendant no.1 got his name, as also the names of defendant no. 9 & 11 mutated in the revenue records to the exclusion of the plaintiffs’ mother, Rabiyabi, also a successor-in-interest. As such, plaintiffs are entitled to 1/6th share in different scheduled properties and sought partition by way of O.S. No.140/1988.
6. In their written statements, the defendants contended that Sultan Saheb himself had divided the property, R.S.No.249/1A/1, into three parts, gifting one part each to his sons and retaining the third remaining part. Subsequently, in September 1980, he partitioned the retained third portion among his four children. Reliance is placed on the Mutation Entry No. 8258 dated 21.01.1973, which is disputed by the plaintiffs.
928 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. The Trial Court framed thirteen issues and held that an oral gift was not made to the sons as the essential requisites were not conclusively proven. It rejected the plea of partition on the ground that under Mohammedan Law, property partitioned during the owner’s lifetime requires a written registered document. After examining witnesses and evidence placed on its record, it held the plaintiffs jointly entitled to 1/6th share, defendant nos.1 and 9 each entitled to 1/3rd share and defendant no.11 to 1/6th share in the suit schedule properties.
8. While dismissing the appeals, the High Court concurred with the Trial Court’s findings on both issues of gift and partition. It reiterated the position under Mohammedan Law that as long as the owner is alive, the partition is unknown to the members governed by Muslim Law. Regarding the gift, it was held that the witnesses’ testimonies failed to substantiate the plea for an oral gift.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
9. Mr. V.N. Raghupathy, learned counsel for the Appellants, submitted that writing is not essential to effectuate the transfer of immovable property by way of gift. Sultan Saheb made a declaration of gift, which was accepted by the donees, and possession was delivered to them, as evidenced by the Mutation Entry No.8258 (Ex. P1). He placed reliance on Section 129 of Transfer of Property Act,1882 and submits that writing is not essential to effectuate transfer of immovable property by way of gift. Further reliance is placed on Hafeeza Bibi v S.K. Farid 2 to describe the three essentials of a gift under Mohammadan Law. It is submitted that Sultan Saheb made a declaration of gift, the same was accepted by the donees and possession was delivered to the donees which is evident from Mutation Entry (Ex.P1).
10. It is submitted that the erroneous description of the transaction as watni/partition instead of an oral gift made the plaintiffs contend that Sultan Saheb and his sons had no right to divide/partition the property, but if the nomenclature ‘partition’ in Mutation Entry (Ex. P1) is replaced by ‘oral gift’, the remaining contents clearly shows that the transaction was an oral gift. Further reliance is placed on 2 [2011] 5 SCR 1155 : (2011) 5 SCC 654 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 929Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors. N.Mani v. Sangeetha Theatre & Ors.3 and Mathai Samuel v. Eapen Eapen.4 It is further submitted that the High Court failed to exercise its jurisdiction as a First Appellate Court depriving appellant his valuable right. In furtherance of the said submission, the learned counsel refers to B.V. Nagesh v. H.V. Srinivasamurthy.5
11. Mr. SN Bhat, learned senior counsel for the Respondents, submitted that the Mutation Entry No.8258 dated 21.01.1973 refers only to an alleged partition, and there is no reference to any gift as alleged by the appellants. It is further submitted that the said Mutation Entry was purported to have been made on the basis of a report (‘wardi’) submitted to the revenue officials, but the appellants-defendants never produced such a report. Further, it is submitted that, unlike Hindu Law, children governed by Mohammedan Law have no pre-existing right; thus, there can be no oral partition of properties during the lifetime of the owner. To buttress his submission the learned senior counsel relies on Abdul Rahim & Ors. v. Sk. Abdul Zabar 6 and K. Mahammad Ghouse Sahib v. Jamila Bi & Ors.7
APPRECIATION OF LAW & ANALYSIS
12. At the outset we may remind ourselves of the observations made in regard to personal laws by J.S. Khehar the then CJI in his dissenting judgment in Shayara Bano v. Union of India 8:
“240 …Reference was also made to the definition of the term Personal Law in Conflict of Laws 188 (7th Edn., 1974) by R.H. Graveson, who defined the term as under: “The idea of the Personal Law is based on the conception of man as a social being, so that those transactions of his daily life which affect him most closely in a personal sense, such as marriage, divorce, legitimacy, many kinds of capacity, and succession, may be governed universally
3 (2004) 12 SCC 278
4 [2012] 10 SCR 1098 : (2012)13 SCC 80 5 [2010] 11 SCR 784 : (2010) 12 SCC 530 6 [2009] 4 SCR 32 : (2009) 6 SCC 160 7 1949 SCC OnLine Mad433 8 [2017] 9 SCR 797 : (2017) 9 SCC 1 930 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports by that system of law deemed most suitable and adequate for the purpose …”
(emphasis in original)
322. “Personal law” has a constitutional protection. This protection is extended to “Personal Law” through Article 25 of the Constitution. It needs to be kept in mind that the stature of “Personal Law” is that of a fundamental right. The elevation of “Personal Law” to this stature came about when the Constitution came into force. This was because Article 25 was included in Part III of the Constitution. Stated differently, “Personal Law” of every religious denomination is protected from invasion and breach, except as provided by and under Article 25.”
(Emphasis supplied)
13. Mohammedan Law, being the personal law, possesses its own legal principles and regulations which govern family relationships in matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, custody and guardianship. Its distinctive feature sets it apart from other personal laws on fundamental issues. It is pertinent to examine the legal principles, if any, governing partition under Mohammedan law.
14. Tahir Mahmood,9 in his book ‘The Muslim Law of India’, 2nd Edition, Chapter 12 (Law of Inheritance) Para II, has provided for various concepts related to succession in Muslim Law which distinguish it from other personal laws:
"1. The Muslim law of succession is basically different from the parallel indigenous systems of India. The doctrine of janmswatvavada (right by birth), which constitutes the foundation of the Mitakshara law of succession, is wholly unknown to Muslim law. The law of inheritance in Islam is relatively close to the classical Dayabhaga law, though it differs also from 9 The author is a recognized expert on Islamic law, having written numerous acclaimed works on the subject. He was a retired professor of law at Delhi University and the founder of Department of Islamic Law at the Indian Institute of Islamic Studies, New Delhi. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 931Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors. that on several fundamental points. The modern Hindu law of succession (as laid down in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956) is, however, much different from both the aforesaid classical systems; it has a remarkable proximity, in certain respects, to the Muslim law of inheritance.
2. The division of heritage (daya) into sapratibandh (‘obstructed’) and apratibandh (‘unobstructed’)-selfacquired and ancestral- is equally foreign to Muslim law. Whatever property one inherits (whether from his ancestors or from others) is, at Muslim law, one’s absolute property- whether that person is a man or a woman.
3. In Muslim law, so long as a person is alive he or she is the absolute owner of his or her property; nobody else (including a son) has any right, whatsoever, in it. It is only when the owner dies- and never beforethat the legal rights of the heirs accrue. There is, therefore, no question of a would-be heir dealing in any way with his future right to inherit.
4. The Indian legal concepts of ‘joint’ or ‘undivided’ family, ‘coparcenary’, karta, ‘survivorship’, and ‘partition’, etc., have no place in the law of Islam. A father and his son living together do not constitute a ‘joint family’; the father is the master of his property; the son (even if a minor) of his, if he has any. The same is the position of brothers or others living together.
5. Unlike the classical Indian law, female sex is no bar to inherit property. No woman is excluded from inheritance only on the basis of sex. Women have, like men, right to inherit property independently, not merely to receive maintenance or hold property ‘in lieu of maintenance’. Moreover, every woman who inherits some property is, like a man, its absolute owner; there is no concept of either stridhan or a woman’s ‘limited estate’ reverting to others upon her death.
932 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
6. The same scheme of succession applies whether the deceased was male or a female. This is one of those salient features of Muslim law of succession which distinguish it from modern Hindu law of inheritance.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15. The position on devolution of property under Mohammedan Law has been succinctly captured in Chapter 22- Law of Succession and Inheritance of Mulla on Mohammedan Law 5th Edition in the following terms: “all properties devolve by succession, so the rights of heirs come into existence only on the death of the ancestor. The whole property vests in them.” The Mohammedan Law has welldefined rules of inheritance that come into effect upon the death of the ancestor, and its policy has been to restrain the owner from interfering in such well-defined rules. Transfer of property if required to be made during the lifetime of a person, they may do so primarily by way of gift (hiba). Other methods include the writing of a will but even therein certain restrictions have been postulated.
16. Prior to looking to the above said sources, a general understanding of partition would also be instructive. Advanced Law Lexicon10 defined partition as a separation between joint owners or tenants in common of their respective interests in land, and setting apart such interest, so that they may enjoy and possess the same in severalty. In Shub Karan Bubna v. Sita Saran Bubna,11 partition was defined as under: “5. “Partition” is a redistribution or adjustment of preexisting rights, among co-owners/coparceners, resulting in a division of lands or other properties jointly held by them into different lots or portions and delivery thereof to the respective allottees. The effect of such division is that the joint ownership is terminated and the respective shares vest in them in severalty.
6. A partition of a property can be only among those having a share or interest in it. A person who does not have a share in such property cannot obviously be a party to a partition. “Separation of share” is a species of “partition”. When all 10 P Ramanatha Aiyar 3rd Edition Reprint 2009 11 [2009] 14 SCR 40 : (2009) 9 SCC 689 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 933Mansoor Saheb (Dead) & Ors. v. Salima (D) By Lrs. & Ors. co-owners get separated, it is a partition. Separation of share(s) refers to a division where only one or only a few among several co-owners/coparceners get separated, and others continue to be joint or continue to hold the remaining property jointly without division by metes and bounds. For example, where four brothers owning a property divide it among themselves by metes and bounds, it is a partition. But if only one brother wants to get his share separated and other three brothers continue to remain joint, there is only a separation of the share of one brother.”
(Emphasis supplied)
17. Let us now turn to the position as it is under Mohammedan Law. The right of an heir-apparent comes into existence for the first time on the death of the ancestor, and he is not entitled until then to any interest in the property to which he would succeed as an heir if he survived the ancestor [See: Mulla Principles of Mahomedan Law, 22nd Edition, Chapter 6; Abdul Wahid Khan v. Mussumat Noran Bibi & Ors.12]. Reference may also be made to the decision of this case in Gulam Abbas v. Haji Kayyum Ali & Ors.13 wherein a bench of three learned judges observed albeit in connection with renunciation of inheritance as under:
“7. Sir Roland Wilson, in his “Anglo Mohamadan Law” (p. 260, para 208) states the position thus:
“For the sake of those readers who are familiar with the joint ownership of father and son according to the most widely prevelant school of Hindu Law, it is perhaps desirable to state explicitly that in Mohammedan, as in Roman and English Law, nemo est heres viventis.........a living person has no heir. An heir apparent or presumptive has no such reversionary interest as would enable him to object to any sale or gift made by the owner in possession; See Abdul Wdhid, L.P. 12 I.A., 91, and 11 Cal 597 (1885)
12 1885 SCCOnLine PC 4 13 [1973] 2 SCR 300 : (1973) 1 SCC 1 934 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports which was followed in Hasan Ali, 11 All 456, (1889). The converse is also true: a renunciation by an exepectant heir in the lifetime of his ancestor is not valid, or enforceable against him after the vesting of the inheritance.””
(Emphasis supplied)
It is also important to note that the doctrine of partial partition does not apply to Mohammedan Law as the heirs therein are tenants-incommon. Succession is to a definite fraction of the estate in question. A.N. Ray, J. as his Lordship then was wrote in Syed Shah Ghulam Ghouse Mohiuddin v. Syed Shah Ahmed Mohiuddin Kamisul Quadri,14 as follows:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.