Prakash and Others v. The State of Maharashtra and Another
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1020; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1160
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5543/2024
- Sections
- 227, 306, 107, 309, 482, 161, 306IP
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1160 : 2024 INSC 1020 Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another (Criminal Appeal No. 5543 of 2024)
20 December 2024 [B.R. Gavai* and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the courts below were justified in accepting the prosecution case that the act of suicide by the victim was a direct result of the words uttered by the appellants at the mahalokadalat when there was a clear gap of over a month between the incident at the mahalokadalat and the commission of suicide.
Headnotes† Penal Code – ss.306, 107 – Abetment of suicide – Disputes between the victim, and her husband-appellant no.1 and in-laws – Victim tortured mentally and physically over demand of money at her matrimonial house – Victim started residing separately, at her paternal house with her child – Subsequently criminal case against the husband and in-laws under the 2005 Act – During pendency, mahalokadalat held during which appellants allegedly refused to cohabitate with the victim or accept her or her child or settle the proceedings initiated by victim – Month later, victim committed suicide – Accidental Death Report by brother of the deceased stating that his sister committed suicide by hanging herself – Five days later, complaint by the mother of deceased against the appellants – On basis thereof, FIR registered u/ss.306 and 34 against the husband and in-laws, and chargesheet filed – Application seeking discharge from case by the appellants – Rejected by the trial court – Said order upheld by the High Court – Correctness:
Held: There must be a close proximity between the positive act of instigation by the accused person and the commission of suicide by the victim – Close proximity should be such as to create a *Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1161Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another clear nexus between the act of instigation and the act of suicide – Such instigation or incitement should reveal a clear mens rea to abet the commission of suicide and should put the victim in such a position that he/she would have no other option but to commit suicide – On facts, clear gap of over a month between the incident at the mahalokadalat and the commission of suicide – Gap of over a month would be sufficient time to dissolve the nexus or the proximate link between the two acts, and render the instigation or incitement by the appellants, nugatory – Courts below erroneously accepted the prosecution story that the act of suicide by the deceased was a direct result of the words uttered by the appellants at the mahalokadalat – In the Accidental Death Report lodged on the day of the incident, no mention about any involvement of the appellants in the suicidal death of the deceased and no mention about the incident that had occurred at the mahalokadalat – These facts alleged for the first time in the FIR lodged five days after the incident – Reasoning given by the High Court for refusal to discharge the appellants completely perfunctory – Prosecution failed to prima facie establish that the appellants had any intention to instigate or aid or abet the deceased to commit suicide – No doubt, a young woman of 25 years lost her life in an unfortunate incident, however, in the absence of sufficient material to show that the appellants had intended by their words to push the deceased to commit suicide, continuation of criminal proceedings would result in an abuse of process of law – Thus, the orders passed by the courts below quashed and set aside – Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.227. [Paras 32-38] Penal Code – ss.306 and 107 – Abetment of suicide – Interpretation of s.306 read with s.107 – Ingredients and principles of s.306 – Elucidated. [Paras 13-28] Case Law Cited Mohit Singhal and Another v. State of Uttarakhand and Others, 2023 INSC 1035 : (2024) 1 SCC 417 : ; Gurjit Singh v. State of Punjab, 2019 INSC 1281 : [2019] 14 SCR 232 : (2020) 14 SCC 264; State of West Bengal v. Indrajit Kundu and Others, 2019 INSC 1164 : [2019] 13 SCR 489 : (2019) 10 SCC 188; Madan Mohan Singh v. State of Gujarat and Another, 2010 INSC 521 : [2010] 10 1162 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports SCR 351 : (2010) 8 SCC 628; Yogesh alias Sachin Jagdish Joshi v. State of Maharashtra, 2008 INSC 534 : [2008] 6 SCR 1116 : (2008) 10 SCC 394 ; Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of M.P., 2002 INSC 250 : [2002] 3 SCR 668 : (2002) 5 SCC 371; S.S. Chheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan and Another, 2010 INSC 506 : [2010] 9 SCR 1111 : (2010) 12 SCC 190; Jayedeepsinh Pravinsinh Chavda and Others v. State of Gujarat, 2024 INSC 960 : [2024] 12 SCR 439 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3679; Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh, 2001 INSC 515 : [2001] Supp. 4 SCR 247 : (2001) 9 SCC 618; Ude Singh and Others v. State of Haryana, 2019 INSC 810 : [2019] 9 SCR 703 : (2019) 17 SCC 301; Naresh Kumar v. State of Haryana, 2024 INSC 149 : [2024] 2 SCR 830 : (2024) 3 SCC 573 – referred to.
List of Acts Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005; Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
List of Keywords Abetment of suicide; Direct or indirect acts of instigation; Clear nexus between suicide and instigation; Proximate to time of suicide; Intention to instigate suicide; Act of suicide; Direct result of the words uttered; Mahalokadalat; Commission of suicide; Tortured mentally and physically over demand of money; Application seeking discharge from case; Close proximity between positive act of instigation by accused person and commission of suicide by victim; Mens rea to abet commission of suicide; Sufficient time to dissolve nexus or proximate link between two acts; Absence of sufficient material; Interpretation of s.306 read with s.107 IPC; Ingredients and principles of s.306 IPC.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
5543 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.10.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay at Aurangabad in CRWP No. 246 of 2021 Appearances for Parties Niteen V. Gaware, Mahesh Prakash Shinde, Vatsalya Vigya, Advs. for the Appellants.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1163Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Sourav Singh, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment B.R. Gavai, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal challenges the judgment and order dated 17th October 2022 passed by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad in Criminal Writ Petition No. 246 of 2021, by which the learned Single Judge dismissed the Writ Petition preferred by the present appellants. The Writ Petition had been filed with the prayer to quash the order dated 24th December 2020 passed by the learned Assistant Sessions Judge, Sangamner, District Ahmednagar wherein the learned Assistant Sessions Judge had rejected the application preferred by the appellants seeking discharge from the charges punishable under Sections 306 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860,1 pending against the appellants before the Court of the Assistant Sessions Judge, Sangamner2 in Sessions Case No. 75 of 2015.
3. The facts which lead to the present appeal are as under:-
3.1. On 20th March 2015, the Police Station, Ashvi, District Ahmednagar, received an Accidental Death Report (Khabar) by one Vikas Bhausaheb Sanap who stated that on the same day at about 10 a.m. his sister Jyoti Nagre,3 aged about 25 years, had committed suicide by hanging herself from the iron pipe situated in the bathroom of her paternal house where she had been residing for the past two years.
3.2. Subsequently, on 25th March 2015, Mrs. Sindhubai Bhausaheb Sanap (Respondent No.2), mother of the deceased, lodged a complaint at the said police station. According to the complaint, 1 For short, ‘the IPC’.
2 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘trial court’.
3 Hereinafter referred to as ‘the deceased’.
1164 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the deceased had been married to Prakash, Appellant No. 1, on 19th November 2009, after which she had given birth to twin sons. After marriage, disputes arose between the deceased and her husband and in-laws from time to time, with the complainant alleging that the deceased had been mentally and physically tortured at her matrimonial house. However, on the intervention of the complainant and her family, the disputes were patched up and the deceased was sent back to her matrimonial home. Soon thereafter, owing to persisting acrimony at her matrimonial home, the deceased and Appellant No.1 started residing separately, away from the matrimonial home, in Lonikand, Pune. It was further alleged that on 8th August 2013, Appellant No.1 had physically abused the deceased over a demand of Rs.20 lakhs for the purchase of a new plot of land. After this incident, the deceased came to reside at her paternal house. Subsequently, a criminal case being Criminal M.A. No. 175 of 2013 came to be filed before the Court of Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Sangamner against the husband and in-laws of the deceased under Sections 12, 18, 20 and 22 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005. During the pendency of the criminal case, a mahalokadalat was held in the court in Sangamner on 17th February 2015, which was attended by the complainant, the deceased and the present appellants, among others. The complainant (Respondent No.2) alleged that on the said day, the present appellants told the deceased that they were not ready to reach a compromise in the matter and further that she would not be allowed to go back to her matrimonial house. The deceased was further advised by Appellant No.1 to re-marry as he would not accept her or her children at the matrimonial house. Subsequent to this incident, the deceased would frequently say that she would commit suicide as her life no longer held any meaning. Thereafter, on 20th March 2015, the deceased committed suicide by hanging herself from an iron pipe with the aid of a saree.
3.3. On the basis of the complaint, a First Information Report4 being Crime No.12 of 2015 was lodged under Sections 306 and 34 of the IPC against Prakash Pandurang Nagare (Appellant No.1), 4 For short, ‘FIR’ [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1165Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another Pandurang Kundlik Nagare (Appellant No.2), the father-in-law of the deceased, and Pradip Pandurang Nagare (Appellant No.3), the brother-in-law of the deceased at the aforementioned police station.
3.4. Upon completion of the investigation, the chargesheet came to be filed on 28th September 2015.
3.5. Being aggrieved thereby, the appellants filed an application under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19735 before the trial court, praying to be discharged from the said case. The trial court, by its order dated 24th December 2020, rejected the aforesaid application on the ground that there was sufficient ground to proceed against the appellants.
3.6. Being aggrieved further, the appellants preferred a Criminal Writ Petition before the High Court for setting aside of the aforesaid order of the trial court. The High Court, vide the impugned judgment and order, dismissed the writ petition finding it to be devoid of merit.
3.7. Being aggrieved thereby, this present appeal.
4. This Court while issuing notice on 30th January 2023 had stayed the criminal proceedings bearing Sessions Case No. 75 of 2015 pending before the trial court, until further orders.
5. We have heard Mr. Niteen V. Gaware, learned counsel appearing for the appellants and Mr. Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, learned counsel and Mr. Siddharth Dharmadhikari, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-State of Maharashtra.
6. Mr. Gaware, learned counsel, submitted that there was a delay of five days in lodging the FIR. He submitted that although an Accidental Death Report (Khabar) had been filed on the day of the incident by the brother of the deceased, there is not a whisper about any harassment caused by the appellants to the deceased. It also did not disclose any involvement of or instigation by the appellants which might have led the deceased to commit suicide. He further submitted that the FIR was an afterthought and no satisfactory explanation has been offered to justify the inordinate delay.
5 For short, ‘Cr.P.C.’ 1166 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. Mr. Gaware further submitted that it is not a case of prosecution that the appellants spoke in such a manner which would amount to abetment of suicide. He further submitted that the appellants met the deceased only on the day of the Mahalokadalat which was held on 17th February 2014 where Appellant No. 1 is alleged to have told her that he did not wish to cohabitate with the deceased any longer and he did not wish to settle the proceedings initiated by her. Merely because the deceased was depressed about her situation, it would not be enough to convict the appellants, particularly since, prima facie, the ingredients of Section 306 IPC are not fulfilled.
8. Mr. Gaware submitted that the deceased had been residing separately from the appellants since 8th August 2013. In the intervening period between the date of separation and the date of the incident, the appellants had interacted with the deceased only on one occasion that is on the date of the Mahalokadalat which was held on 17th February 2014. He submitted that the FIR wrongly mentions the date of the mahalokadalat to be 17th February 2015. It is submitted that the deceased committed suicide after over a year had passed. However, the courts below did not consider this aspect or look into the roznama of court proceedings which clearly showed the date on which the mahalokadalat had been held. Therefore, he submitted that in view of the time gap between the alleged meeting and the date of suicide, there is no immediate instigation or abetment to commit suicide which can be attributed to the appellants.
9. Mr. Gaware placed reliance on the judgments of this Court in the cases of Mohit Singhal and Another v. State of Uttarakhand and Others,6 Gurjit Singh v. State of Punjab,7 State of West Bengal v. Indrajit Kundu and Others,8 Madan Mohan Singh v. State of Gujarat and Another,9 Yogesh alias Sachin Jagdish Joshi v. State of Maharashtra10 and Sanju @ Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of M.P.11. He submitted in view of the material placed on record and
6 2023 INSC 1035 : (2024) 1 SCC 417
7 2019 INSC 1281 : [2019] 14 SCR 232 : (2020) 14 SCC 264 8 2019 INSC 1164 : [2019] 13 SCR 489 : (2019) 10 SCC 188 9 2010 INSC 521 : [2010] 10 SCR 351 : (2010) 8 SCC 628 10 2008 INSC 534 : [2008] 6 SCR 1116 : (2008) 10 SCC 394 11 2002 INSC 250 : [2002] 3 SCR 668 : (2002) 5 SCC 371 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1167Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another the authorities cited, the appeal deserves to be allowed and the appellants deserve to be discharged of all charges.
10. Per contra, Mr. Siddharth Dharmadhikari, learned counsel, submitted that no interference is warranted in the concurrent findings of the trial court and the High Court. He submitted that there is sufficient material against the appellants to proceed against them. He further submitted that in view of the allegations levelled against the appellants and the evidence collected by the investigating agency, it is not a fit case to allow this appeal. Mr. Dharmadhikari, therefore, prayed for the dismissal of this appeal.
11. We have carefully considered the rival submissions and perused the material placed on record.
12. The relevant provisions of the IPC that fall for consideration are as under:
“306. Abetment of suicide.- If any person commits suicide, whoever abets the commission of such suicide, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.
107. Abetment of a thing—A person abets the doing of a thing, who— First.— Instigates any person to do that thing; or Secondly.— Engages with one or more other person or persons in any conspiracy for the doing of that thing, if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance of that conspiracy, and in order to the doing of that thing; or Thirdly.— Intentionally aids, by any act or illegal omission, the doing of that thing.
Explanation 1.— A person who, by wilful misrepresentation, or by wilful concealment of a material fact which he is bound to disclose, voluntarily causes or procures, or attempts to cause or procure, a thing to be done, is said to instigate the doing of that thing.
Explanation 2.— Whoever, either prior to or at the time of the commission of an act, does anything in order to 1168 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports facilitate the commission of that act, and thereby facilitates the commission thereof, is said to aid the doing of that act.”
13. Section 306 of the IPC has two basic ingredients-first, an act of suicide by one person and second, the abetment to the said act by another person(s). In order to sustain a charge under Section 306 of the IPC, it must necessarily be proved that the accused person has contributed to the suicide by the deceased by some direct or indirect act. To prove such contribution or involvement, one of the three conditions outlined in Section 107 of the IPC has to be satisfied.
14. Section 306 read with Section 107 of IPC, has been interpreted, time and again, and its principles are well-established. To attract the offence of abetment to suicide, it is important to establish proof of direct or indirect acts of instigation or incitement of suicide by the accused, which must be in close proximity to the commission of suicide by the deceased. Such instigation or incitement should reveal a clear mens rea to abet the commission of suicide and should put the victim in such a position that he/she would have no other option but to commit suicide.
15. The law on abetment has been crystallised by a plethora of decisions of this Court. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating or intentionally aiding another person to do a particular thing. To bring a charge under Section 306 of the IPC, the act of abetment would require the positive act of instigating or intentionally aiding another person to commit suicide. Without such mens rea on the part of the accused person being apparent from the face of the record, a charge under the aforesaid Section cannot be sustained. Abetment also requires an active act, direct or indirect, on the part of the accused person which left the deceased with no other option but to commit suicide.
16. This Court in the case of S.S. Chheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan and Another,12 had an occasion to consider the scope of Section 306 of the IPC and the ingredients which are essential for abetment, as set out in Section 107 of the IPC. It observed as follows: “16. The word “suicide” in itself is nowhere defined in the Penal Code, however its meaning and import is well known 12 2010 INSC 506 : [2010] 9 SCR 1111 : (2010) 12 SCC 190 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1169Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another and requires no explanation. “Sui” means “self” and “cide” means “killing”, thus implying an act of self-killing. In short, a person committing suicide must commit it by himself, irrespective of the means employed by him in achieving his object of killing himself.
………..
18. In our country, while suicide in itself is not an offence, considering that the successful offender is beyond the reach of law, attempt to suicide is an offence under Section
309 IPC.
……….
21. The learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance on a judgment of this Court in Mahendra Singh v. State of M.P. [1995 Supp (3) SCC 731 : 1995 SCC (Cri)
1157] In Mahendra Singh [1995 Supp (3) SCC 731 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 1157] the allegations levelled were as under: (SCC p. 731, para 1)
“1. … My mother-in-law and husband and sisterin-law (husband’s elder brother’s wife) harassed me. They beat me and abused me. My husband Mahendra wants to marry a second time. He has illicit connections with my sister-in-law. Because of these reasons and being harassed I want to die by burning.”
The Court on the aforementioned allegations came to a definite conclusion that by no stretch the ingredients of abetment are attracted on the statement of the deceased. According to the appellant, the conviction of the appellant under Section 306 IPC merely on the basis of the aforementioned allegation of harassment of the deceased is unsustainable in law.
………..
23. In State of W.B. v. Orilal Jaiswal [(1994) 1 SCC 73 : 1994 SCC (Cri) 107] this Court has cautioned that: (SCC p. 90, para 17)
1170 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “17. … The court should be extremely careful in assessing the facts and circumstances of each case and the evidence adduced in the trial for the purpose of finding whether the cruelty meted out to the victim had in fact induced her to end the life by committing suicide. If it [appears] to the court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and differences in domestic life quite common to the society to which the victim belonged and such petulance, discord and differences were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged of abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty.”
24. This Court in Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) [(2009) 16 SCC 605 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 367] had an occasion to deal with this aspect of abetment. The Court dealt with the dictionary meaning of the words “instigation” and “goading”. The Court opined that there should be intention to provoke, incite or encourage the doing of an act by the latter. Each person’s suicidability pattern is different from the other. Each person has his own idea of self-esteem and self-respect. Therefore, it is impossible to lay down any straitjacket formula in dealing with such cases. Each case has to be decided on the basis of its own facts and circumstances.
25. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. The intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1171Prakash and Others v.
The State of Maharashtra and Another suicide seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide.”
17. This Court held that abetment involves the mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Therefore, without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid a person in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. This Court further observed that the intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 of IPC, there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. Abetment also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no other option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide. However, this Court has cautioned that since each person reacts differently to the same provocation depending on a variety of factors, it is impossible to lay down a straightjacket formula to deal with such cases. Therefore, every such case has to be decided on the basis of its own facts and circumstances.
18. More recently, in the case of Jayedeepsinh Pravinsinh Chavda and Others v. State of Gujarat,13 this Court has relied on S.S. Chheena (supra) to hold that the element of mens rea cannot simply be presumed or inferred, instead it must be evident and explicitly discernible. Without this, the foundational requirement for establishing abetment under the law, that is deliberate and conspicuous intention to provoke or contribute to the act of suicide, would remain unfulfilled. This Court observed as follows:
“18. For a conviction under Section 306 of the IPC, it is a well-established legal principle that the presence of clear mens rea—the intention to abet the act—is essential.
Mere harassment, by itself, is not sufficient to find an accused guilty of abetting suicide. The prosecution must demonstrate an active or direct action by the accused that led the deceased to take his/her own life. The element of mens rea cannot simply be presumed or inferred; it must 13 2024 INSC 960 : [2024] 12 SCR 439 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3679 1172 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports be evident and explicitly discernible. Without this, the foundational requirement for establishing abetment under the law is not satisfied, underscoring the necessity of a deliberate and conspicuous intent to provoke or contribute to the act of suicide.”
19. It is, therefore, evident that the positive act of instigation is a crucial element of abetment. While dealing with an issue of a similar nature, this Court in the case of Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh,14 laid down the parameters of what would be constituted to be an act of instigation. This Court observed as follows:- “20. Instigation is to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite or encourage to do “an act”. To satisfy the requirement of instigation though it is not necessary that actual words must be used to that effect or what constitutes instigation must necessarily and specifically be suggestive of the consequence. Yet a reasonable certainty to incite the consequence must be capable of being spelt out. The present one is not a case where the accused had by his acts or omission or by a continued course of conduct created such circumstances that the deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide in which case an instigation may have been inferred. A word uttered in the fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow cannot be said to be instigation.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.