Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 905; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 906
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bela M. Trivedi, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 25 Nov 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 122/2013
- Sections
- 302, 164, 157, 161, 162, 201, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 906 : 2024 INSC 905 Vijaya Singh & Anr.
v.
State of Uttarakhand (Criminal Appeal No. 122 of 2013)
25 November 2024 [Bela Trivedi and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Criminal Appeal filed by the Appellants challenging the conviction under Section 302/201 IPC can be entertained in the facts and circumstances of the case.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – Section 302 – Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – Section 164 – Principles governing circumstantial evidence reiterated – On facts and circumstances, held that the Trial Court and the High Court have correctly appreciated the evidence, and the conviction of the Appellant upheld: Held: It is a well settled principle of law that when a case is based on circumstantial evidence, the circumstances proved must point unequivocally to the guilt of the accused and must be incompatible with any theory of being innocent – There are no material contradictions in the versions of the witnesses – The evidence of every witness cannot be subject to the same level of scrutiny and the Court must be alive to the social position of the witness – Further, it is trite law that mere presence of minor variations is not fatal to the case of the prosecution – It is so because natural testimony is bound to have variations – The question is whether the variations or contradictions could be termed as fatal to the case of the prosecution – The evidence adduced before the Court is to be examined as a whole and not in isolation – This principle assumes greater importance in cases which are based on circumstantial evidence as in the absence of direct evidence of the offence, the Court is required to analyze the proved circumstances in a collective sense to arrive at a reasonable finding – In such cases, the finding of the Court is essentially an irresistible inference which is drawn from the proved material on record. [Paras 11, 25, 39] *Author [2024] 11 S.C.R. 907Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand Jurisprudence concerning statements under Section 164 CrPC – Discussed:
Held: Statement under Section 164 CrPC is not considered as a substantive piece of evidence, as substantive oral evidence is one which is deposed before the Court and is subjected to cross- examination – However, Section 157 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 makes it clear that a statement under Section 164 CrPC could be used for both corroboration and contradiction – It could be used to corroborate the testimonies of other witnesses – The need for recording the statement of a witness under Section 164 CrPC arises when the witness appears to be connected to the accused and is prone to changing his version at a later stage due to influence – Considering the conceptual requirement of recording a statement before a Judicial Magistrate during the course of investigation and the utility thereof, as prescribed in Section 157 of Evidence Act, it could be observed that a statement under Section 164, although not a substantive piece of evidence, not only meets the test of relevancy but could also be used for the purposes of contradiction and corroboration – A statement recorded under Section 164 CrPC serves a special purpose in a criminal investigation as a greater amount of credibility is attached to it for being recorded by a Judicial Magistrate and not by the Investigating Officer – A statement under Section 164 CrPC is not subjected to the constraints attached with a statement under Section 161 CrPC and the vigour of Section 162 CrPC does not apply to a statement under Section 164 CrPC – Therefore, it must be considered on a better footing – However, relevancy, admissibility and reliability are distinct concepts in the realm of the law of evidence – The weight to be attached to such a statement (reliability thereof) is to be determined by the Court on a case-to-case basis and the same would depend to some extent upon whether the witness has remained true to the statement or has resiled from it, but it would not be a conclusive factor. [Paras 27, 28] List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Criminal Procedure Code, 1973.
List of Keywords Circumstantial evidence; 164 statement.
908 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
122 of 2013 From the Judgment and Order dated 29.08.2012 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CRLA No. 148 of 2004 Appearances for Parties Sachin Patil, Satyajit A Desai, Siddharth Gautam, Abhinav K. Mutyalwar, Sachin Singh, Ms. Anagha S. Desai, Advs. for the Appellants.
Sudarshan Singh Rawat, Ms. Saakshi Singh Rawat, Ms. Rachna Gandhi, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
1. In April, 2002, Devaki got married to Vijaya Singh. More than an year after the wedding, on the fateful day of 14.09.2023, Devaki died an unnatural death at the house of her in-laws. Vijaya Singh, appellant no. 1 herein, was accused of murdering her along with his mother, namely Basanti Devi, appellant no. 2 herein. The case was registered as FIR No. 04/2003 at PS R.P. Jakholi, Rudraprayag, District Garhwal, Uttarakhand. After the conclusion of investigation and trial, the Trial Court found the appellants guilty. In appeal, the High Court of Uttarakhand also found them guilty and upheld the decision of the Trial Court. The appellants, by way of instant appeal, have assailed the Judgment and Order dated 29.08.2012 passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in Criminal Appeal No. 148 of 2004, whereby the said appeal preferred by the appellants was dismissed.
2. The appellant No.1 happened to be the husband and the appellant No.2 happened to be the mother-in-law of the deceased Devaki. After the incident, the FIR was registered at the instance of the complainant Shankar Singh (brother of the deceased Devaki), against the present appellants and Shri. Matbar Singh (father-in-law of the deceased). [2024] 11 S.C.R. 909Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand It was alleged inter alia in the said complaint that on 14.09.2003 at about 9 P.M., he had received one phone call from the in-laws of his sister at Gram Sabha Dangi (Village Hariyali) informing him that his sister had poured kerosene oil over her person at about 6 P.M. and had set herself ablaze. According to the complainant, he along with his two brothers went to the place of occurrence, where they saw that their sister was lying in almost naked condition with green grass having been put over her body and they suspected that their sister was murdered and she had not committed suicide.
3. The Investigating Officer, after completing the investigation, filed the chargesheet against the appellants for the offences under Sections 302 and 201 of Indian Penal Code, 1860. 1 The case was committed for trial to the Sessions Court and the District & Sessions Judge, Rudraprayag, vide the Judgment and Order dated 14.05.2004, convicted both the appellants for the commission of offence under Section 302 of IPC and sentenced them to life imprisonment and fine of Rs.5,000/- each, and in default thereof, to further undergo imprisonment for a period of 6 months. The said Court also convicted them for the offence under Section 201 of IPC and sentenced them to undergo imprisonment for a period of 2 years with payment of fine of Rs. 2000/- each, and in default thereof to further undergo imprisonment for a period of 3 months. Being aggrieved by the said Judgment and Order passed by the Trial Court, the appellants had preferred an appeal being Criminal Appeal No.148 of 2004 before the High Court, which came to be dismissed by the High Court vide the impugned Judgment and Order dated 29.08.2012.
4. The Trial Court acknowledged that the entire case of the prosecution was based on circumstantial evidence and further, that the entire chain of evidence consistently pointed in the direction of guilt of the appellants. It found that the testimonies of the witnesses were credible and the retraction of their statements by PW-3 and PW-4, sisters of appellant no. 1, was a result of tutoring. Thus, the statements of the said witnesses recorded under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 2 were found to be truthful and natural.
5. The decision of the Trial Court was assailed before the High Court and the High Court, in the impugned order/judgment, found that the 1 Hereinafter referred as “IPC”
2 Hereinafter referred as “CrPC”
910 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Trial Court had correctly analyzed the evidence on record and no infirmity was found in the findings of the Trial Court.
6. While assailing the judgement of the High Court, learned counsel for the appellants submitted that there was a delay in the registration of FIR as the same was registered after 24 hours from the incident and the said period led to the fabrication of the entire story by the complainant. It is further submitted that there was no allegation of harassment at the time of registration of FIR and the versions put forth by PW-1, PW-2, PW-5 and PW-6 are inherently contradictory and there is no corroboration between the same. It is further submitted that PW-1 was not the real nephew of the deceased but was a distant relative belonging to the same community and therefore, he could not have possessed any direct knowledge of cruelty or harassment. It is further submitted that the statements of PW-1 and PW-5 appeared to be contrary to each other as PW-5 has not deposed regarding any bodily injury to the deceased at any point of time and has deposed that the relationship between the appellants and the deceased was cordial.
7. It is further submitted that the statements of PW-3 and PW-4 recorded under Section 164 CrPC are liable to be rejected as the said statements were recorded in the presence of the Investigating Officer under threat, and could not be considered as voluntary statements. It is further submitted that the said statements could not be termed as substantive evidence and could only be used to corroborate or contradict the testimony of a witness in the Court. It is further submitted that the primary witness of the prosecution is PW-7/doctor and his testimony is fundamentally flawed. It is submitted that the concerned doctor initially deposed that he could not definitively state whether the death of the deceased was homicidal or suicidal, however, the witness later opined that 100% percent burn injuries were uncommon in suicide cases. It is submitted that in case of suicide, the act of burning is a voluntary act and therefore, 100% burn injuries are completely possible. To buttress, it is contended that the evidence of an expert is not the evidence of fact and is only advisory in nature. It is added that medical jurisprudence is not an exact science and in the expert testimony cannot be considered as a conclusive proof of the fact.
8. Learned counsel has also submitted that the trial court and the High Court have failed to analyze the circumstances of the case in an [2024] 11 S.C.R. 911Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand objective manner and the findings of the said courts are based more on conjectures and less on evidence.
9. Per contra, it has been contended on behalf of the respondent State that the circumstances of the present case have proved the guilt of the appellants beyond reasonable doubt. It has been submitted that the chain of circumstances is complete and falls within the parameters laid down by this Court with respect to circumstantial evidence. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent has placed reliance upon the decision of this Court in Prabhudayal and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra3 to contend that in bride burning cases, the absence of cries or shouts from the victim is suggestive of the fact that it was not a case of suicide. Learned counsel has also laid emphasis on the false plea of alibi taken by appellant no. 2, and has submitted that if a false plea is taken by the accused in the course of a trial, it could be considered as an additional circumstance against the accused.
10. We have heard the respective parties and we may now proceed to answer the seminal issue whether the findings arrived at by the High Court are based on a correct appreciation of the evidence on record and are sustainable in the eyes of law.
DISCUSSION
11. At the outset, it may be noted that the entire case of prosecution hinges on the circumstantial evidence, in as much as there was no eye witness to the incident in question. It is a well settled principle of law that when a case is based on circumstantial evidence, the circumstances proved must point unequivocally to the guilt of the accused and must be incompatible with any theory of his being innocent. The principles governing the appreciation of circumstantial have been laid down by this Court in unequivocal terms in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra.4 The principles, termed as the Panchsheel or five principles of circumstantial evidence, are traceable in the following para:
“153. A close analysis of this decision would show that the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case against an accused can be said to be fully established: 3 [1993] 3 SCR 878 : (1993) 3 SCC 573 4 [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116 912 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(1) the circumstances from which the conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that the circumstances concerned “must or should” and not “may be” established. There is not only a grammatical but a legal distinction between “may be proved” and “must be or should be proved” as was held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra [(1973) 2 SCC 793] where the observations were made:
“Certainly, it is a primary principle that the accused must be and not merely may be guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.”
(2) the facts so established should be consistent only with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to say, they should not be explainable on any other hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3) the circumstances should be of a conclusive nature and tendency,
(4) they should exclude every possible hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence of the accused and must show that in all human probability the act must have been done by the accused.”
12. So far as the facts of the present case are concerned, it is not disputed that deceased Devaki and the Appellant No.1 got married in April, 2002 and the Appellant No.2 happened to be the mother-inlaw of the deceased. It is also not disputed that the tragic incident occurred on 14.09.2003 i.e. within 17 months of the marriage, when deceased Devaki succumbed to the burn injuries at her matrimonial home i.e. at the home of the appellants.
13. The Prosecution had examined as many as 8 witnesses to prove the charges levelled against the appellants, out of whom PW-1 Vinod Singh happened to be the nephew of the deceased who had [2024] 11 S.C.R. 913Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand inter alia stated that he used to go to leave his aunt Devaki at her matrimonial home and used to feel that the behaviour of appellant no. 2 was not good with her. He also stated that in the month of August, 2002 when he had visited the matrimonial home of his aunt to bring her back home, her mother-in-law (appellant no.2) had indulged into a quarrel with him saying that if he wanted to take his aunt with him, then he should keep her permanently with him. He also deposed that the appellant no. 2 had threatened him by saying that he had not seen her anger till that point of time. On that day, PW-1 came back home with his aunt/deceased. He also stated that in the year 2003, when his aunt i.e. the deceased Devaki had visited her parental home, she was found to have an injury on her eye and on his asking about the injury, she had confidentially told him that the said injury was caused by her husband - Vijaya Singh (appellant no.1), however he had not disclosed the same to anyone so that the matter may not aggravate further.
14. In cross-examination, PW-1 deposed that he used to go to his aunt’s matrimonial house frequently as her brothers were not residing in the maternal village. He also deposed that appellant no. 1 was working in Chandigarh and used to come home in 3-4 months. He further deposed that the deceased used to insist for going to Chandigarh and the appellant had promised her that he would take her soon. He further deposed that appellant no. 2 used to quarrel with the deceased regarding household work and about her desire of going to Chandigarh.
15. PW-2 (Shankar Singh), brother of the deceased Devaki had stated before the Court that on 14.09.2003, a call was received at about 12.00 - 1.00 o’clock in the midnight from the village of his sister that his sister had poured kerosene oil on her person and put herself ablaze. He, therefore, managed to go to the village of his sister along with 5-6 people and when he reached the matrimonial home of his sister, the appellants were sitting outside the verandah and he was told that his sister had committed suicide by pouring kerosene oil on herself. He further stated that when he went inside the room, he saw that the dead body of his sister was lying on the floor between two coats in naked condition and green grass was put over her dead body. A quilt was lying there in burnt condition along with water. He further stated that at the time of incident, his sister was pregnant and he had felt that his sister had not committed suicide but she was 914 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports murdered by her in-laws. He deposed that his sister used to tell them about the harassment of her in-laws regarding non-performance of household work. In the cross-examination, he admitted that his sister wanted to accompany her husband Vijaya and stay at Chandigarh instead of staying at village and that prior to the death of his sister, the relationship between his sister and the accused Vijaya Singh was quite cordial.
16. PW-3 Saroj happened to be the sister of the appellant no.1 and daughter of appellant no.2, whose statement was recorded under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. during the course of investigation. She admitted about the recording of her statement before the Magistrate under Section 164 of Cr.P.C and admitted her signatures on the statement. In cross- examination, she stated that she was not present at home at the time of incident and that the relationship between her sister-in-law Devaki and her mother and brother was cordial. She further admitted that when the Patwari brought her to the Magistrate for recording her statement, he had threatened her, and had also remained present before the Magistrate when her statement was being recorded. PW-3 denied any statement regarding quarrel between the deceased and appellant no. 2. PW-4 Preeti is also the sister of appellant no.1 and daughter of appellant no.2, and she also deposed to the same effect as her sister Kumari Saroj/PW-3.
17. PW-5 examined by the prosecution was Kamal Singh, who happened to be the cousin brother of the deceased Devaki. He stated that on receiving the telephone call on 14.09.2003 at 8:00 PM about the incident, he had gone to the house of the deceased and saw that the dead body of his sister Devaki was lying on the floor in naked condition and some green grass was put over her body. One bedding was also lying in the room and water was put all over it. He also stated that on inspection of the room, he felt that Devaki had not committed suicide but her mother-in-law and husband had murdered her by setting her ablaze. He further deposed that quarrels used to take place between the deceased and the appellants over her desire of going to Chandigarh with her husband.
18. During cross-examination, PW-5 deposed that the deceased had told him that her mother-in-law was not allowing her to visit Chandigarh.
19. PW-6 Sunita Devi, was the sister-in-law of the deceased Devaki. She stated that as and when Devaki used to visit her parental [2024] 11 S.C.R. 915Vijaya Singh & Anr. v. State of Uttarakhand home, she used to tell her about the harassment caused by her mother-in-law and husband. She used to tell her that she (Devaki) was kept terrorized and threatened, and was not given proper food at her matrimonial home and that her in-laws would go out locking her in the house.
20. The expert witnesses regarding the cause of death, examined by the prosecution, was PW-7 Dr. Shailendra Kumar, who had carried out post-mortem of the deceased Devaki. He stated that the deceased had sustained 100% burn injuries and the whole body was burnt from top to bottom. The cause of death was ‘Death due to shock’ and semi digested food was found in her stomach. No smell of any kind was felt from her person. He further stated that a male womb measuring 10 cm having weight 200 gm was found in the uterus of the deceased. In the cross-examination, he had stated that it was not possible to give opinion whether the deceased had got herself burnt or somebody had burnt her after pouring kerosene. However, in his opinion, sustaining 100% burn injuries was not possible in case of self-inflicting burns and that some percentage would have been left. In the cross-examination, he had explained that 100% burns would mean the body was lying burnt from top to bottom. He also admitted that if the size of the room was very small, then entering the room from outside would not be probable due to smoke.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.