Pulen Phukan & Ors. v. The State of Assam
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 305; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 616
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sanjay Karol Penal Code, Justice 1860 : Ss. 302, Justice 326, Justice 147, Justice 148, Justice 149, Justice Held: Prosecution Is Not To
- Decided
- 28 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 906/2016
- Sections
- 147, 173(2), 149, 27, 302, 142, 161, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 616 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
[2023] 4 S.C.R. 616
PULEN PHUKAN & ORS.
v.
THE STATE OF ASSAM
(Criminal Appeal No. 906 of 2016)
MARCH 28, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI, VIKRAM NATH AND SANJAY KAROL, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860 : ss. 302, 326, 147, 148, 149, 447 and 34 – Murder – Unlawful Assembly – Complainant-PW 1’s case that 13 persons entered her house and caused grievous injury to her brother-in-law PW 2 and three of them assaulted the victim with sharp cutting weapons resulting in his death – Trial conducted against 11 of them – Courts below convicted them u/s. 147/148/ 447/323/302/149 and sentenced them to imprisonment for life u/ss. 302/149 along with other punishment for the charged offences – On appeal, held: Prosecution is not to accept the complainant’s version as truth but the investigation must be made in a fair and transparent manner and must ascertain the truth – No explanation has come forward to explain the presence of the police personnel throughout the incident – Entire version of the prosecution witnesses that the police personnel accompanied the accused and were standing outside the house of the deceased creates a serious doubt on the very genesis of the prosecution story – Eye-witnesses have not taken names of the 13 accused persons – No statement by the eye-witnesses that all the accused persons had come with a common object of committing murder and assaulting the injured PW-2 – It cannot be said that all members of the unlawful assembly were aware of the common object – It cannot be said that there was unlawful assembly – Furthermore, material inconsistency in the statement of the eye witnesses – No recovery at the instance of any accused – Injuries of PW2 not proved as there was no injury report – Scribe of the FIR also not produced nor the signatures proved – It is quite possible that it was a complete set-up by the police – Although the death was homicidal but the prosecution has not established the case beyond reasonable doubt against the appellants, thus, entitled to benefit of doubt – Order passed by the High Court set aside. A B C D E F G H Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 The prosecution is not to accept the complainant’s version as Gospel Truth and proceed in that direction but the investigation must be made in a fair and transparent manner and must ascertain the truth. The evidence collected during investigation should then be analysed by the Investigating Officer and accordingly a report under Section 173(2) of the CrPC should be submitted. Further, the duty of the trial court is to carefully scrutinise the evidence, try to find out the truth on the basis of evidence led. Wherever necessary the trial court may itself make further inquiry on its own with regard to facts and circumstances which may create doubt in the minds of the Court during trial. If the investigation is unfair and tainted then it is the duty of the trial court to get the clarifications on all the aspects which may surface or may be reflected by the evidence so that it may arrive at a just and fair conclusion. If the trial court fails to exercise this power and discretion vested in it then the judgment of the trial court may be said to be vitiated. [Para 13][628-F-H] 1.2 In the instant case, the informant- PW-1, the injured eye-witness PW-2, eye-witness PW-3 and PW-4 have categorically stated that police personnel had accompanied the accused and they were there throughout the incident. This fact is noticed by the trial court in its judgment but it fails to get this clarification from the prosecution as to what occasioned the presence of the police personnel accompanying the accused and standing outside the house of the deceased to watch the accused assault PW-2 and commit the murder of his brother. The trial court had simply brushed aside the argument of the defence on this count without giving a serious thought. [Para 14][629-A-B] 1.3 If the police personnel were present at the time of commission of the offence, they should have immediately acted upon to set the criminal machinery in motion by first apprehending the accused from the spot itself rather than allowing them to get way by accompanying the police to the Police Station while continuing to assault the injured PW-2 on the way. The entire version of the prosecution witnesses that the police personnel accompanied the accused and were standing outside the house PULEN PHUKAN & ORS. v. THE STATE OF ASSAM A B C D E F G H 618 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
of the deceased creates a serious doubt on the very genesis of the prosecution story. [Para 15][629-C-D] 1.4 According to Section 149 IPC every member of the unlawful assembly must know the common object of their assembly and also the offence likely to be committed in prosecution of the common object. [Para 24][631-D] 1.5 None of the eye-witnesses have taken names of all the accused persons who are said to be 13 in number. Only names of 3-4 accused persons are taken who are said to have assaulted the deceased and the injured PW-2. None of the eye-witnesses have stated that all the accused persons had come with a common object of committing murder and assaulting the injured PW-2. It is also not stated by any of the eye-witnesses that there were any utterances by one or many or all the accused that they must eliminate the deceased and cause injuries to the injured PW-2. There is no evidence to the effect that any of the accused exhorted the others saying that they have to eliminate the deceased and assault the injured (PW-2). Further, it is clearly stated by the eye-witnesses PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 that at least five police personnel were accompanying the accused and that they were standing outside and did not interfere in the commission of the alleged crime. Thus, it is difficult to decipher that all the members of the unlawful assembly were aware of the common object. [Para 25][631-E-H] 1.6 PW-2 and PW-3 have stated that the police along with the accused had come to arrest the deceased and the injured. If that was the object and the police were taking help of the accused persons then also the factum of common object of committing the crime of murdering the deceased is not borne out. It could be that the common object known to the accused was of apprehending the deceased and the injured PW-2 as there was some criminal case registered against them lodged by PP, one of the accused. In view thereof it cannot be held that there was an unlawful assembly and further to uphold the conviction under Section 149 IPC. [Para 26][632-A-C] 1.7 In the FIR, K and PP have not been assigned any role of assault. The role assigned is to MP, DP and HS. PW-1 has A B C D E F G H taken the name of K assaulting on the leg with an iron rod and PP assaulting on the neck. In the cross–examination, she has stated that DP assaulted on the neck. PW-2 has stated that K hit the deceased with a dao then he says that he did not see who assaulted PRP and later on says that it was PP who dealt a blow on the neck. PW-3 has stated that K assaulted with an iron rod and DP assaulted on the neck with an axe. PW-4 has stated that K dealt a blow on the leg with an iron rod and then DP dealt a blow on the neck of the deceased with an axe. There is no recovery at the instance of any accused under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The axe, according to the evidence, was left on the dead–body of the deceased. What is evident is that K’s name was not included in the FIR but his name has been consistently taken by the eyewitnesses of first assaulting the deceased with an iron rod. In so far as PP is concerned, his name has been taken by PW-1 and PW-2 for assaulting on the neck and whereas PW-3 and PW-4 have taken the name of DP striking on the neck. Thus, there is material inconsistency in the statement of the eye-witnesses. [Para 27][632-C-G] 1.8 Another important aspect to be noted from the evidence of PW-1, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 is that after being hit by K with an iron rod, PRP, the deceased struggled to enter the room and there he was assaulted on the neck. When according to the prosecution story itself PRP, the deceased had entered the neighbour’s house it would be very difficult for the eye- witnesses to also have entered the house of PW-4 and PW- 5 and to witness the assault. PW-1 and PW-3 have not stated that they also entered the room where the assault took place. PW-2 has clearly stated that when he tried to follow PRP he was stopped by the accused and the police personnel who were standing outside. [Para 28][632-H; 633-A-B] 1.9 The evidence creates a very serious doubt on the entire prosecution story. It is quite possible that the police personnel of the concerned Police Station were there to arrest the deceased and his brother and in that process some resistance may have resulted into the incident causing the death of the victim. The injuries of PW2 have not been proved as admittedly there was no injury report. Even the scribe of the FIR has not been produced PULEN PHUKAN & ORS. v. THE STATE OF ASSAM A B C D E F G H 620 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
nor the signatures have been proved. It is quite possible that it was a complete set-up by the police. They having committed the murder in the process of arresting the deceased, and thereafter, knowing the enmity between the two parties, set–up a false case against the accused. Apparently, no explanation has come forward to explain the presence of the police personnel of the Police Station throughout the incident. [Para 29][633-C-E] 1.10 The prosecution has not established the place of occurrence by any material exhibit of having collected the bloodstained earth from the place of occurrence. Even the material exhibit, the axe, which is said to have been taken into custody by the police whether on the date of the incident or two days thereafter has also not been produced nor any evidence led to that effect. It is still a mystery as to how the Investigating Officer in his statement has stated that he had filed a charge-sheet against eight accused as five were absconding and there is no further statement regarding three more accused being arrested and put to trial, how the trial court proceeded to convict 11 accused and only two were set to be absconding. Even the scribe of the FIR has not been examined. It was extremely relevant when PW-1 has stated that she had no knowledge of the contents of the FIR. [Para 30][633-E-G] 1.11 Although the death of the victim was homicidal but it is not convincing that the prosecution has established the case beyond reasonable doubt against the accused appellants. The appellants would be entitled to benefit of doubt. The conviction and sentence are set aside. [Para 31][633-H; 634-A] CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.906 of 2016.
From the Judgment and Order dated 21.11.2015 of the High Court of Gauhati at Agarthala in CRLA No.113 of 2014.
Sanjay R. Hegde, Sr. Adv., Azim H. Laskar, Bikas Kar Gutpa, S.K. Biswal, Ms. Debarati Sadhu, Shahrukh Ali, Chandra Bhushan Prasad, Raghav Gupta, Ms. Debanjana Ray Choudhuri, Advs. for the Appellants.
Debojit Borkakati, Adv. for the Respondent.
A B C D E F G H The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
VIKRAM NATH, J.
1. The Appellants have assailed the correctness of judgment and order dated 21.11.2015 passed by Gauhati High Court in Criminal Appeal No.113/2014 – Pulen Phukan and 10 others versus State of Assam whereby the appeal was dismissed confirming the judgment and order of Trial Court i.e. Sessions Judge at Dibrugarh passed in Sessions Case No.27 of 2000 whereby 11 accused were convicted under Sections 147/ 148/447/323/302/149 of Indian Penal Code, 18601 and sentenced to Rigorous Imprisonment for life under Section 302/149 IPC and Rigorous Imprisonment for six months under Sections 147/148/447/323 IPC. Further a fine of Rs.1,000/- was imposed on each of the 11 accused and in default of payment of fine, to undergo further one-month Rigorous Imprisonment.
2. It would be relevant to note here that although trial was conducted against 11 out of 13 accused and all of them were convicted and sentenced as above, all the 11 convicted accused had preferred an appeal before the High Court which had been dismissed. However, before this Court only four of such accused have preferred an appeal, namely, Pulen Phukan (accused no.1), Jiten Phukan (accused no.3), Mridul Saikia @ Midul Saikia (accused no.5) and Mozen Phukan (accused no.2). Two of the thirteen accused namely Dhajen Phukan and Muhiram Phukan remained absconded and there is no material on record regarding their arrest or trial.
3. The prosecution story begins with lodging of a First Information Report2 on 13 June, 1989 at Police Station Chabua, District Dibrugarh, reported by Smt. Nareswari Phukan (PW1). It is a very short and crisp FIR which states that around 12 noon on 13.06.1989, thirteen residents of the village came to her house, cordoned off her house without any reason and caused grievous injury on the head of her brother-in-law Robi Phukan (PW 2) by giving blows with sharp weapons and three of the accused persons, namely, Mozen Phukan, Dulen Phukan and Haren Saikia committed murder of Pradip Phukan by assaulting him with sharp cutting weapons, necessary action may be taken regarding the said incident. This was registered as Chabua Case No.70/89 under Sections
1 IPC
2 FIR
PULEN PHUKAN & ORS. v. THE STATE OF ASSAM A B C D E F G H 622 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
147/148,149,447, 302, 326, 34 IPC. The police came to the spot, made the necessary enquiries and after completing the formalities sent the dead-body of the deceased for post-mortem. They also collected some material from the spot for which recovery memos were prepared and the material taken into custody. After completing the investigation, chargesheet was submitted on 3rd May, 1991 against eight accused, namely, Mozen Phukan, Mridul Saikia, Kuleshwar Chetia, Pulen Phukan, Baren Saikia, Dulen Phukan, Kiran Saikia and Harnath Saikia. Five accused could not be arrested as such they were not sent for trial being absconders, namely, Jiten Phukan, Dhajen Phukan, Muhiram Phukarn, Haren Saikia and Jiban Chetia. It appears that at some stage three more accused were arrested and they were also sent for trial. The two accused who remained absconding are Dhajen Phukan and Muhiram Phukan. The charge-sheet was submitted finding prima facie case for trial under Sections 147, 148, 149, 447, 448, 324, 326 and 302 IPC. The charges were read out to the accused who pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
4. The prosecution examined seven witnesses and also filed four documentary evidences to prove the charges. The seven witnesses are as follows:
i. PW 1- informant and eye-witness: Smt. Nareswari Phukan (sister-in-law of the deceased);
ii. PW2-Eye-witness and injured: Robi Phukan (brother of the deceased);
iii. PW 3 – Eye-witness: Smt. Jogmaya Phukan(sister in law of the deceased) ;
iv. PW 4- Eye-witness: Smt. Anjana Phukan, (relative of the deceased);
v. PW 5 – Bhuban Phukan, relative of the deceased;
vi. PW 6 –Dr. Naleswar Sonowal who conducted the autopsy on the dead-body of the deceased; and vii. PW 7 – Nilo Chiring, the Investigating Officer who submitted the charge-sheet (Ex.-4).
5. The documentary evidence produced and proved by the prosecution are:
A B C D E F G H i. FIR (Ejahar)-Ex.-1;
ii. Seizure of the axe-Ex.-2;
iii. Post-mortem report-Ex.-3;
iv. Charge-sheet-Ex.-4.
6. The Trial Court and the High Court came to the conclusion that the evidence led by the prosecution was unquestionable and have accordingly recorded the conviction and sentence as afore-stated.
7. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material on record.
8. Learned counsel for the appellants made the following submissions:
A. The prosecution has not come forward with fair and honest version for the following reasons:
i. The FIR is very sketchy. The statement of the first informant (PW-1) before the Trial Court is a clear improvement from the version mentioned in the FIR.
ii. PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 have clearly stated that at least five police personnel were present at the time the incident took place. It is also stated that the police personnel had accompanied the accused. There is no explanation given regarding the presence of the police throughout the occurrence.
iii. If the police personnel were present outside the house of the deceased then the matter ought to have been reported by them regarding the incident rather than PW-1 going to the Police Station to lodge the FIR.
iv. The accused accompanied the police to the Police Station along with PW-2 who was throughout assaulted on the way.
v. Why did the police personnel who were five in number not make any attempt to apprehend the accused and not only let them go scot-free but also accompanied them to the Police Station.
B. There is no evidence whatsoever to show that all the accused had come with a common object with regard to the offence to be PULEN PHUKAN & ORS. v. THE STATE OF ASSAM [VIKRAM NATH, J.] A B C D E F G H 624 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
committed and if that be so invoking sections147,148 and 149 IPC would be untenable in law. The ingredients of Section 142 of IPC are not established by any evidence.
C. There is material inconsistency in the evidence of the eyewitnesses PW-1 to PW-4 which completely discredits their testimony not only for the reason that they are interested witnesses being relatives of the deceased but also on careful scrutiny of the evidence, their testimony cannot be regarded as reliable. Further testimonies of PW-1 to PW-4 vis-à-vis their statements under Section 161 Code of Criminal Procedure, 19733 are quite inconsistent.
D. It is a clear case of false implication at the hands of the police inasmuch as:
i. The police were present throughout the incident, which presence has not been explained.
ii. The FIR is written by one Md. Majid Sikdar whose evidence is not only not recorded in the police case diary but also not produced through trial to prove the report.
iii. The first informant has clearly stated that she did not know the contents of the FIR as the same was not read out to her and that she had only put her signatures where she was told to.
9. On the other hand, learned counsel for the State-Respondent submitted that both the Courts below i.e.the Trial Judge as well as the High Court, after considering the material evidence on record, have recorded concurrent findings on conviction and as such the same would not require any interference by this Court.
10. Before proceeding with the analysis of the evidence led by the prosecution, the deposition of each of the seven witnesses is briefly recorded hereunder:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.