Munna Lal v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 78; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 224
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Dipankar Datta Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice Held : Pw-2 Being Inimical to the Appellants, Justice His Testimony to Be Taken Carefully – Pw-3 Was At the Best, Justice A Chance
- Decided
- 24 Jan 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 490/2017
- Sections
- 374(2), 302, 161, 107, 145, 134, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 224 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.[2023] 3 S.C.R. 224
MUNNA LAL
v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal No.490 of 2017)
JANUARY 24, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 : s. 374(2) –Appeal from convictions – Murder of the complainant’s father – Previous enmity between the parties – On the fateful day, the appellants armed with weapons inflicted gun shot injuries and blows to the victim resulting in his death – FIR against the appellants – Surviving appellants convicted u/s. 302 IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment – Upheld by the High Court – On appeal, held : PW-2 being inimical to the appellants, his testimony to be taken carefully – PW-3 was at the best, a chance witness – Circumstances on record do not justify the presence of PW-3 at the place of occurrence – Oral testimony of PW-2 and PW-3, the so-called eye witness, not free from doubt and their evidence not of unimpeachable quality – Rule of prudence demands corroboration of their versions from other witnesses present at the place of occurrence and witnessed the murder of the victim, however, they were not examined – Moreover, non-examination of the investigating officer created reasonable doubt in the prosecution case – On proper evaluation, it has transpired that there were reasons for which PW-2 might have falsely implicated the appellants and also that PW-3 was not a wholly reliable witness – There is a fair degree of uncertainty in the prosecution story and the courts below appear to have somewhat been influenced by the oral testimony of PW-2 and PW-3, without taking into consideration the effect of the other attending circumstances, thereby warranting interference – Charge that the appellants had murdered the victim, not proved beyond reasonable doubt, thus, entitled to benefit of doubt – Order of conviction and sentence passed by the courts below set aside – Evidence Act, 1872.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 By reason of the uncontroverted evidence of a continued enmity existing from 10 (ten) years preceding the A B C D E F G H alleged murder of the victim by and between the two groups, it could be established that PW-2 nurtured personal ill–will towards the appellants and the possibility of PW-2 having acted with intention to keep the appellants away from legal proceedings as well as interference in property rights cannot be totally ruled out; hence, PW-2 being inimical to the appellants, his testimony has to be taken with a pinch of salt and a deeper scrutiny of the other evidence on record is also indeed called for. [Para 31][238- D-F]
1.2. Having found from the oral evidence of PW-2 what transpired on the fateful morning, it is considered necessary to look into the oral testimony of PW-3. There was indeed an attempt on the part of the appellants to establish that PW-3 was a relative of PW-2 and that being an interested witness apart from a ‘chance witness’, his testimony is not wholly reliable. It is not clear from the testimony of PW-3 as to why, so early in the morning, he had the occasion to pass by the place of occurrence. It is found that PW-3 is a resident of place N whereas PW-2 happened to be a resident of place S. The distance between the two places is 1–2 miles. The incident of murder happened within the jurisdictional limits of Police Station T. It has not surfaced from the evidence of PW-3 very early from where he started and where he was headed for. ‘GD’ could be the village, where the matrimonial home of the sister of PW-3 is; but for what purpose he had left is not too clear. It was not said by PW-3 that he was on his way to his sister’s residence. In cross–examination, PW-3 denied having resided in place S. [Para 32][238-F-H; 239-A-B]
1.3. In order to prove the guilt of the appellants beyond reasonable doubt, some more particulars were required given the circumstance that PW-3 was at best a ‘chance witness’. Incidentally, PW-2 had denied being related to PW-3 and it was not elicited by the prosecution from PW-2 as to how he came to know the name of PW-3, given the fact that the latter was a resident of a different village. Similarly, PW-3 too did not say that he knew PW-2 or his father from before. The nature of acquaintance that PW-2 and PW-3 had, ought to have been brought out by the prosecution. That apart, although it is true that PW-3 gave a vivid description of how N was shot by ML, no MUNNA LAL v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 226 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
specific role was attributed insofar as SL is concerned except that all 4 (four) accused were “beating” (as deciphered from the evidence recorded in Hindi) and not “killing” (as available from the translated version in the paper–book) N. Again, in course of cross–examination, PW-3 deposed that ML had shot N without elaborating whether SL also inflicted any injury on N. There is an apparent inconsistency between the versions of PW-2 and PW-3 insofar as the role attributed to SL by PW-2 is concerned, which can hardly be overlooked. [Para 33][239-C-E]
1.4. The circumstances as appearing from the record do not justify the presence of PW-3 at the place of occurrence. The oral testimony of PW-2 and PW-3 is not free from doubt and their evidence not being of unimpeachable quality, the rule of prudence would demand a corroboration of their versions from other witnesses who, according to PW-2 and PW-3, were present at the place of occurrence and witnessed the murder of N. [Para 34][239- F-G]
1.5. As per the evidence of PW-2 and PW-3, there were other eye-witnesses of whom K was a key witness, and CL and KH were independent witnesses. Since it was the version of PW- 2 and PW-3 that K, CL and KH were present at the place of occurrence and had also witnessed, inter alia, the incident of “beating” of N with a ‘kanta’ by SL and firing of a gunshot at him by ML, direct evidence could have been provided by either of the three (K, CL and KH) corroborating the versions of PW-2 and PW-3. For reasons best known to the prosecution, these three individuals, named both by PW-2 and PW-3 as other eye-witnesses, were not examined leading this Court to draw an inference that had they been examined, the prosecution story would not have been supported by them.[Para 35][239-G-H; 240-A-B]
1.6. The statement of PW-3 under section 161, Cr. P.C.
was recorded nearly 24 days after the incident. Since the Investigating Officer did not enter the witness box, the appellants did not have the occasion to cross–examine him and thereby elicit the reason for such delay. Consequently, the delay in recording the statement of PW3 in course of investigation, is not referred to and, therefore, remains unjustified. The possibility of PW-3, A B C D E F G H being fixed up as an eye-witness later during the process of investigation, cannot be totally ruled out. [Para 38][240-F]
1.7. Though PW-4 is said to have reached the place of occurrence at 1.30 p.m. on 5th September, 1985 and recovered a bullet in the blood oozing out from the injury at the hip of the dead body, no effort worthy of consideration appears to have been made to seize the weapons by which the murderous attack was launched. It is true that mere failure/neglect to effect seizure of the weapon(s) cannot be the sole reason for discarding the prosecution case but the same assumes importance on the face of the oral testimony of the so-called eyewitnesses, i.e., PW-2 and PW-3, not being found to be wholly reliable. The missing links could have been provided by the Investigating Officer who, again, did not enter the witness box. Whether or not non– examination of a witness has caused prejudice to the defence is essentially a question of fact and an inference is required to be drawn having regard to the facts and circumstances obtaining in each case. The reason why the Investigating Officer could not depose as a witness, as told by PW-4, is that he had been sent for training. It was not shown that the Investigating Officer under no circumstances could have left the course for recording of his deposition in the trial court. It is worthy of being noted that neither the trial court nor the High Court considered the issue of non– examination of the Investigating Officer. In the facts of the instant case, particularly conspicuous gaps in the prosecution case and the evidence of PW-2 and PW-3 not being wholly reliable, the instant case as one where examination of the Investigating Officer was vital since he could have adduced the expected evidence. His non–examination creates a material lacuna in the effort of the prosecution to nail the appellants, thereby creating reasonable doubt in the prosecution case. [Para 39][240-G-H; 241-A-D] 1.8 As far as non-obtaining of ballistic report is concerned, it is no doubt true that its essentiality would depend upon the circumstances of each case. Since no weapon of offence was seized, no ballistic report was called for and obtained. No evidence has been taced in the records that ML had a licensed gun. However, nothing turns on it. The failure/neglect to seize the weapons of offence, on facts and in the circumstances of the instant case, has MUNNA LAL v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 228 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
the effect of denting the prosecution story so much so that the same, together with non-examination of material witnesses constitutes a vital circumstance amongst others for granting the appellants the benefit of doubt. [Para 40][241-E-F]
1.9. The medical evidence tendered by PW-1, if believed in its entirety, leads to form an opinion that the evidence of PW- 4 of he having recovered a bullet leading to its seizure at the place of occurrence as doubtful.[Para 41][241-G]
1.10. Although, mere defects in the investigative process by itself cannot constitute ground for acquittal, it is the legal obligation of the Court to examine carefully in each case the prosecution evidence de hors the lapses committed by the Investigating Officer to find out whether the evidence brought on record is at all reliable and whether such lapses affect the object of finding out the truth. Being conscious of the above position in law and to avoid erosion of the faith and confidence of the people in the administration of criminal justice, the evidence led by the prosecution is examined threadbare and refrained from giving primacy to the negligence of the Investigating Officer as well as to the omission or lapses resulting from the perfunctory investigation undertaken by him. The endeavour of this Court has been to reach the root of the matter by analysing and assessing the evidence on record and to ascertain whether the appellants were duly found to be guilty as well as to ensure that the guilty does not escape the rigours of law. The disturbing features in the process of investigation, since noticed, have not weighed in the Court’s mind to give the benefit of doubt to the appellants but on proper evaluation of the various facts and circumstances, it has transpired that there were reasons for which PW-2 might have falsely implicated the appellants and also that PW-3 was not a wholly reliable witness. There is a fair degree of uncertainty in the prosecution story and the courts below appear to have somewhat been influenced by the oral testimony of PW-2 and PW-3, without taking into consideration the effect of the other attending circumstances, thereby warranting interference. [Para 42][242-B-F]
1.11. The charge that the appellants had murdered N, cannot be said to have been proved beyond reasonable doubt; hence, A B C D E F G H they are entitled to the benefit of doubt. The trial court’s judgment of conviction and order of sentence being unsustainable, is set aside; consequently, the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, upholding the conviction and sentence, too is set aside. [Para 43][242-G; 243-A] Jarnail Singh vs. State of Punjab (2009) 9 SCC 719 :
[2009] 13 SCR 774 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2009] 13 SCR 774 referred to Para 23 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.490 of 2017.
From the Judgment and Order dated 09.07.2014 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CRLA No.539 of 1986.
With Criminal Appeal No.491 of 2017.
Mukesh K. Giri, Adv. for the Appellant.
Ankur Prakash, Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Prabhat Kumar Rai, Sanjay Kumar, Pawan, Memansak Bhardwaj, Ms. Hardikaa, Advs. for the Respondent.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
THE CHALLENGE
These two criminal appeals, arising out of the same occurrence, call in question the judgment and order of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad dated 9th July, 2014 dismissing Criminal Appeal No.539 of 1986 [being an appeal under section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereafter “Cr. P.C.”, for short)] carried by the appellants from the judgment and order dated 29th January, 1986 of the Court of IInd Additional Sessions Judge, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh, in S.T. No.499 of 1985.
FIRST INFORMATION REPORT (F.I.R.)
2. Narayan, father of Ram Vilas, was murdered in the morning of 5th September, 1985 round about 10.00 hours. A written complaint was MUNNA LAL v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH A B C D E F G H 230 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
lodged soon thereafter, at about 12.10 hours, by Ram Vilas leading to registration of an F.I.R. under section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (hereafter “IPC”, for short). One Dr. Mohd. Hanif Khan was the scribe of the said FIR. Munna Lal, Sheo Lal, Babu Ram, and Kalika were accused of committing such murder.
INQUEST
3. Consequent upon registration of the F.I.R., Shailendra Bahadur Chandra, the Station Police Officer of Police Station Tilhar (who was also the Investigating Officer) proceeded to the place of occurrence, along with Ram Pal Sagar, S.I., and Udham Singh, constable. Inquest had been conducted by Ram Pal Sagar in course whereof a bullet was recovered at the place of occurrence from the blood oozing out from one of the injuries suffered by Narayan.
CHARGE(S)
4. Upon completion of investigation, charge-sheet under section 302 was filed before the concerned court against each of the 4 (four) accused. Kalika had passed away in the meanwhile. Upon committal, the trial court framed the following charges:
“Charge I, Sanwal Singh, II Addl. Sess. Judge, Shahjahanpur, do hereby charge you : -
1. Shiv Lal
2. Munna Lal
3. Babul Ram, as follows:
That you along with Kalika on 05.09.85 at about 10.00 A.M. in village Fatehpur Bujurg alias Mohaddipur, police station Tilhar, District : Shahjahanpur, at the field of Budhu Khan situated in the west of village Abadi did commit murder by intentionally and knowingly causing the death of Narain in that you Munna caused injuries by gunshot, you Babu Ram caused injuries by tamancha and you Shiv Lal caused injuries by Kanta and your associate Kalika deceased caused injuries by lathi and all of you intentionally co-operated in the commission of the said offence and that you thereby committee an offence punishable under section 302 I.P.C. and within the cognizance of this court A B C D E F G H of sessions.
And I hereby direct that you be tried by this court of sessions on the said charge.
TRIAL
5. The prosecution examined 5 (five) witnesses to support its case and more than a dozen of documentary evidence. None was examined on behalf of the defence.
6. PW-1 was Dr. Ramesh, who conducted post-mortem. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on the cadaver of Narayan:
(1) Lacerated wound 2 cm x 1 cm over forehead 3 cm above left eye brow wall maggots present.
(2) Lacerated wound 4 cm x 1 cm over chin 1 cm below lower lip. Maggots were present.
(3) Lacerated wound 3 cm x 1 cm left side face 2 cm left lateral to left side of mouth.
(4) Incised wound 17 cm x 8 cm over front of abdomen cavity deep 5 cm above umbilicus. Visceral organs prolapsing.
(5) Gunshot wound of entry 2 cm x 1 cm over front of abdomen 3 cm right lateral to umbilicus tattooing present. Direction backward downward.
(6) Gunshot wound of exit 6 cm x 5 cm over left side of hip 5 cm below iliac crest.
(7) Gunshot wound of entry 2 cm x 1 cm over front of right thigh 15 cm below ilicae spine (ant) with direction backward lateral.
(8) Gunshot wound of exit 3 cm x 2 cm over lateral side of right thigh 12 cm below iliae crest.”
7. According to PW-1, “death of Narayan occurred due to shock and haemorrhage and much bleedings”; injury nos. 5 and 6 and likewise injury nos.7 and 8 noted above were respectively the entry and exit wounds corresponding with each other, which could be caused by gun and tamancha shots, whereas injury nos. 1, 2, and 3 were possible by lathi and injury no.4 could be caused by “kanta”.
MUNNA LAL v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DIPANKAR DATTA, J. ] A B C D E F G H 232 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
8. Ram Vilas, son of the deceased, while deposing as PW-2 stated that a quarrel had taken place 10 (ten) years before between Narayan and Jaswant (father of Sheo Lal) and Sheo Lal and that Jaswant died in that quarrel. One ‘Aajudhi’, on the side of Sheo Lal, was murdered. Narayan was, however, acquitted. PW-2 identified, inter alia, Munna Lal and Sheo Lal who were present in the Court. According to PW-2, on the date of the fateful incident, he along with his father Narayan after ploughing their field had reached the field of Budhu Khan when the 4 (four) accused persons suddenly came out from the field belonging to Sheo Lal. The said accused viz., Munna Lal, Sheo Lal, Babu Ram and Kalika, were armed with ‘bandook’ (gun), ‘kanta’ (sharp edged weapon), ‘tamancha’ (locally made gun), and ‘lathi’ (stick) respectively. They were hurling abuses, and exhorting to kill Narayan. Narayan received gunshot injuries from Munna Lal and Babu Ram, whereas Sheo Lal and Kalika inflicted blows on him by kanta and lathi, respectively. Such incident was also witnessed by Kedar, Hemraj, Khamkaran and Chhange Lal. Kedar and Hemraj requested not to kill. It was reiterated that Hemraj had come at the time of incident and had seen the incident. After the accused persons fled, other persons had reached there. PW-2 finding that Narayan was dead, reached the shop of Dr. Hanif and narrated the incident to him whereupon Dr. Hanif had written the complaint and read over the contents to PW-2. PW-2 neither signed nor affixed his thumb impression on the report written by Dr. Hanif but when PW-2 took the report to the police station, he had affixed his thumb impression on the report which was written by the ‘munshi’ in the police station.
9. In course of cross-examination, PW-2 disclosed that Narayan had made an application for cancelling the license of the gun of Jaswant and had made ‘pairvi’. Narayan had earlier been tried in a case under section 302, IPC and he also filed a cross-case; further, a case under section 107/116, Cr. P.C. was pending against Narayan; also, a case under section 145, Cr. P.C. was pending wherein PW-2 and his father Narayan were the accused persons. In the latter case, Munna Lal was a witness against them. Since the murder of ‘Aajudhi’, there has been constant enmity with Sheo Lal. However, till the murder of Narayan, there was no ‘marpeet’ or ‘pairokari’ with PW-2 or his father. PW-2 “had not affixed thumb impression on the report at the police station” but had affixed his thumb impression on it at the ‘dukaan’ (shop) of Hanif and handed over the same to the munshi.
A B C D E F G H
10. Hemraj, an eye-witness, deposed as PW-3. Sister of PW-3 resides in Gopalpur Dhadhipura and he is on visiting terms. The distance between Mohaddipur and Gopalpur is 1-2 miles. Whenever PW-3 used to travel to Gopalpur from his village, he used to take the outer road of village Mohaddipur. When he reached near the field of Budhu Khan, the accused persons armed with gun, kanta, tamancha, and lathi, were killing Narayan. PW-2 was present at the place of occurrence. Two passersby viz., Chhange Lal and Khemkaran had reached there. Apart from PW- 3, Kedar who was grazing two buffaloes had also seen the incident. After inflicting blows on Narayan, the accused persons fled towards the southern direction. Narayan had died.
11. In course of cross-examination, PW-3 denied the suggestions that he was related to the family of Narayan. PW-3 reiterated that Kedar was grazing animals near the place of occurrence and Khemkaran and Chhange Lal came there in his (PW-3) presence. By the time PW-3 left the place of occurrence, 20 (twenty) to 25 (twenty-five) persons assembled there of whom one old lady and one girl from the family of Narayan were weeping. Neither could PW-3 identify the wife of Ram Vilas nor did he know the name of villagers who reached there later.
12. Ram Pal Sagar, who conducted inquest, was PW-4. PW-4 deposed that in course of inquest, he found a bullet in the blood oozing out from the injury at the hip of the deceased. He proved the chargesheet and the seizure memo pertaining to the bullet that was recovered. PW-4 also deposed that, among others, he could find Kedar on reaching the place of occurrence.
13. Constable Udham Singh deposed as PW-5. PW-5 had accompanied the Investigating Officer to the place of occurrence, where PW-4 had conducted the inquest.
14. Significantly, Dr. Hanif, Kedar, Chhange Lal, Khemkaran and the Investigating Officer were not examined by the prosecution. Further, neither the gun and the tamancha nor the kanta and lathi were seized. Also, there were no forensic laboratory or ballistic reports.
15. Ultimately, upon consideration of the evidence on record, the Sessions Judge held that the consistent and unimpeachable direct evidence proved the case, which was supported by dependable probabilities, existence of motive, medical evidence and all other circumstances. In so holding, the ocular account of PWs 2 and 3 weighed with the trial MUNNA LAL v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [DIPANKAR DATTA, J. ] A B C D E F G H 234 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
court while holding Munna Lal, Sheo Lal and Babu Ram guilty of the offences with which they were charged. It was also held that the prompt F.I.R. presented a guarantee about the truthfulness of the case. Consequently, by his judgment dated 29th January, 1986, the judge convicted the surviving accused, viz., Munna Lal, Sheo Lal and Babu Ram, and imposed upon them the sentence of life imprisonment.
APPEAL
16. As noted above, the aforesaid judgment and order of the Sessions Judge was carried in appeal before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad by Munna Lal, Sheo Lal and Babu Ram.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.