Royden Harold Buthello & Anr. v. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 180; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 150
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice A.S. Bopanna, Justice Which Was Declined – Revision Petition Filed By The
- Decided
- 28 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 634/2023
- Sections
- 313, 227, 29, 22
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 150 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.[2023] 3 S.C.R. 150
ROYDEN HAROLD BUTHELLO & ANR.
v.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH & ORS.
(Criminal Appeal No.634 of 2023)
FEBRUARY 28, 2023
[A. S. BOPANNA AND AHSANUDDIN AMANULLAH, JJ.] Criminal Law – Investigation by CBI – When cannot be directed – Appellant no.1 accused of indulging in sale of psychotropic NDPS substance – It is the case of the appellant no.1 that while he was travelling with regard to his business, he was illegally abducted, detained and a case under NDPS was foisted on him – Appellant no.1 and his father-appellant no.2 filed writ petition before High Court inter alia seeking direction to transfer the investigation to the CBI, which was declined – Revision petition filed by the appellant against order framing charges was also dismissed – On appeal, held: Power to transfer the investigation is an extraordinary power – It is to be used very sparingly and in an exceptional circumstance where the Court on appreciating the facts and circumstance arrives at the conclusion that there is no other option of securing a fair trial without the intervention and investigation by the CBI or such other specialized investigating agency – In the present case, there is no issue of public importance which requires investigation by the CBI – Contention of the appellant that the offence alleged against him to have been committed on 21.10.2020 could not have been committed by him inasmuch as he was abducted from a different State and was already in illegal detention of the police on 20.10.2020, would be the defence in the criminal trial – Other aspects contended by the appellants could be established through evidence in trial before the competent court – Appellants would have the further remedy of the legal course available to them if they are dissatisfied – Thus, when the issue raised is only a matter of evidence to be considered in the judicial proceedings to arrive at a conclusion, a direction to the CBI to hold an investigation would be unjustified – Impugned orders not interfered with – NDPS Act – ss.29 r/w ss.22(b), (c), 25, 27 – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.313.
A B C D E F G H Dismissing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 Though there is no inflexible guideline or a straightjacket formula laid down, the power to transfer the investigation is an extraordinary power. It is to be used very sparingly and in an exceptional circumstance where the Court on appreciating the facts and circumstance arrives at the conclusion that there is no other option of securing a fair trial without the intervention and investigation by the CBI or such other specialized investigating agency which has the expertise. In that background, there is no issue of public importance which requires to be unearthed by an investigation to be conducted by the CBI. Even from the facts noted and the allegations made against the police, though the Court is sensitive to the sentiment of the appellants herein, the contention ultimately is that the offence alleged against him to have been committed on 21.10.2020 could not have been committed by him inasmuch as he had been abducted from a different State and was already in the illegal detention of the police on 20.10.2020 itself. This essentially would be the defence in the criminal trial. The charges have been framed and the evidence is being tendered. Insofar as the allegation that the said persons namely ‘PB’, ‘S’, ‘S’ and ‘A’ had gone to Odisha and had illegally abducted him, from the very details furnished by the appellants themselves, it is noted that the High Court had through the order dated 17.03.2022 in a collateral proceeding directed that the five officers stated in the said order be called as witnesses for examination and cross-examination. [Paras 19, 20][162-F-H; 163-A-B] 1.2 In that view, even though it is contended that the CCTV footage would be relevant to establish the presence of the said four persons in the hotel at Odisha and the same has not been seized by the police, the fact remains that even from the same what is sought to be established is that the said four persons had abducted the appellant No.1. In the course of trial the five persons specified by the appellants would now be available to be crossexamined and any other orders in that regard can be sought in the pending proceedings. That apart, on the other aspects also since the trial is under progress, the appellant No.1 would be entitled to put forth his case when the statement under Section ROYDEN HAROLD BUTHELLO & ANR. v. STATE OF
CHHATTISGARH & ORS.
A B C D E F G H 152 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
313 of CrPC is recorded and also he would be entitled to tender evidence if necessary. The case of the appellant is clear as to the reason why he contends that the appellant No.1 cannot be held to have committed the offence as registered in FIR No.232/2020 based on which his name has also been included in an earlier FIR No.255/2020. These are matters which could be established through evidence in the trial before the Competent Court in the judicial proceedings wherein all these matters would be appreciated and a conclusion would be reached. In that regard, the appellants in any event would have the further remedy of the legal course which is available to them if they are dissatisfied. Further, insofar as the complaint said to have been lodged by the appellant No.2, from the affidavit as filed by the respondent No.6, the nature of investigation carried out by them has been stated. In that regard also the appellant No.2 would have the legal remedy in accordance with law. In addition, in the said process of the judicial proceedings if the appellants bring out the fact that the appellant No.1 who was not involved, had been framed up and a case was foisted, the appellants would still have the legal remedy to take action for malicious prosecution, loss of reputation, action against involved persons, compensation and for such other relief in that regard. Therefore, when the issue raised is only a matter of evidence to be considered in the judicial proceedings to arrive at a conclusion, this Court is not convinced that in a case of the present nature, a direction to the CBI to hold an investigation would be justified nor is it required at this juncture when the trial in the judicial proceedings has progressed unhindered. Hence to that extent, all contentions of the appellants are kept open. All contentions are left open to be urged before the trial court. No reason to interfere with orders impugned. [Paras 21, 22][163-C- H; 164-A-C] State of West Bengal & Ors. vs. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights, West Bengal & Ors. (2010) 3 SCC 571 : [2010] 2 SCR 979; Mithilesh Kumar Singh vs.
State of Rajasthan & Ors. (2015) 9 SCC 795 : [2014] 13 SCR 1362; Arnab Ranjan Goswami vs. Union of India (2020) 14 SCC 12 : [2020] 8 SCR 222 – relied on.
A B C D E F G H Case Law Reference [2010] 2 SCR 979 relied on Para 17 [2014] 13 SCR 1362 relied on Para 17 [2020] 8 SCR 222 relied on Para 18 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.634 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 10.01.2022 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in WPCR No.686 of 2020.
Shyam Divan, Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Sr. Advs., Adith Deshmukh, D.M. Galani, Ms. Tanya Shrivastava, Neel Kamal Mishra, Jatin Zaveri, Advs. for the Appellants.
Vikramjeet Banerjee, A.S.G., Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Sr. Adv., Sumeer Sodhi, Devashish Tiwari, Shibashish Misra, Mrs. Sairica Raju, Samar Singh Kachwaha, Rahul Mishra, Akshay Nain, Kartik Dey, Ms. Janhvi Prakash, Ms. Shruti Agarwal, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
A. S. BOPANNA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The appellants, as also the respondents are common to these appeals and the subject matter relates to the same issue. Hence, they are taken up together and disposed of through the common judgment. The appeal arising out of SLP Criminal No.2454 of 2022 is filed assailing the order dated 10.01.2022 passed in WPCR No. 686 of 2020. In an appeal arising out of the SLP Criminal No.7306 of 2022, the order dated 15.09.2021 passed in Criminal Revision No.468 of 2021 is assailed. Both the said orders are passed by the High Court of Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur.
3. The said order dated 10.01.2022 is passed in Writ Petition filed under Article 226 wherein the appellant had prayed to direct for investigation under the supervision of the Court, by the Central Bureau of Investigation (for short, ‘CBI’) relating to (i) FIR No. 232/2020 registered at Azad Chowk Police Station, Raipur, (ii) FIR No.255/2020 registered at Kotwali Police Station, Raipur, (iii) Online complaint No. 3334104012000003 dated 27.10.2020 made before the Superintendent ROYDEN HAROLD BUTHELLO & ANR. v. STATE OF
CHHATTISGARH & ORS.
A B C D E F G H 154 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
of Police, Raipur and (iv) Online complaint No. 24488049072000014 dated 06.11.2020 made before the Talcher Police Station, Angul, Odisha. The appellant had also prayed to quash the charge sheet in Special Case No.87/2020 and Special Case No.98/2020 filed by the respondent Azad Chowk Police, Raipur and Kotwali Police, Raipur filed pursuant to the said FIRs No.232/2020 and 255/2020, pending before the learned Special Judge under NDPS Act, Raipur. The further direction which was prayed is for the CBI to submit a periodical progress report of the investigation to the Court and to monitor the same.
4. In the connected appeal, the challenge is to the order dated 15.09.2021 whereby the Criminal Revision Petition filed by the appellant herein, before the High Court assailing the legality and correctness of the order dated 14.07.2021 passed by the Special Judge under NDPS Act at Raipur in Special Case No.98/2020 whereby the appellants application filed under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘CrPC’) was dismissed and charges were framed against the appellant under Section 29 read with Sections 22(b), 22(c), 25 and 27 of the NDPS Act, which was not interfered by the High Court.
5. The brief facts leading to the above appeals are that the appellant No.1 is accused of indulging in sale of psychotropic NDPS substance, due to which the prosecuting agency under the respondent No.1 has registered the FIRs No.232/2020 and 255/2020 and are proceeding in the matter as noted above. The appellant No.1 claims to be innocent, while the appellant No.2 who is his father being agitated by such alleged illegal action by the prosecuting agency under the respondent No.1 had filed the online complaints dated 27.10.2020 and 06.11.2020 raising his concern and sought for action in that regard.
6. The appellants claim that they are residents of Mumbai and the appellant No.1 is a qualified automobile engineer, who is an income tax payee. The appellant No.2 is a businessman carrying on business of logistics, transportation, renting out vehicles etc. for the last 36 years in the name and style, M/s Buthello Travels at R/3, Mathur Estate, Premier Road, Kurla (W), Mumbai. The appellant No.1 was also taking care of the business of his father and as such was visiting the State of Odisha as also the State of Chhattisgarh in respect of contracts relating to the transportation of minerals. It is averred that appellant No.1 had accordingly travelled to Odisha and had booked room no.220 in Hotel Green Park, Talcher, District Angul, Odisha from 15.10.2020 to A B C D E F G H 20.10.2020. It is the case of the appellants that on 20.10.2020 at 13.00 hours, four unknown persons visited the said hotel in a white Innova car with a broken front bumper, impersonating themselves as police officers. They contacted Shri Vijaya who is working as a receptionist and accordingly met the appellant No.1 in room No.220. The appellant No.1 was thereafter abducted and taken into the car and was driven to Raipur.
7. The appellant No.1 claims that while taking dinner at dhaba between Sambalpur and Sonipat he overheard the name of the four persons who had taken him to be, Pramod Behra, Sultan, Santosh and Ali, from their discussion. He also contends that the mobile phone was with the appellant No.1 and he made calls from his cell No. 8249518758. It is averred that after reaching Raipur at about 12:30 AM on 21.10.2020 the said four persons took the appellant No.1 to respondent No.5 where he was detained for some time and his cell phone as also laptop were taken. It is claimed that the appellant No.1 was thereafter kept in the lockup throughout the night without disclosing the reasons for such action and on 21.10.2020 about 19:15 hours, police Sub-inspector Shri Priyesh Mathew John lodged FIR against him, bearing No.232/2020 for an alleged offence under Section 22(b) of the NDPS Act. Thereafter his name was also included in the earlier registered FIR No.255/2020 which is noted above.
8. In that background, the grievance put forth on behalf of the appellants is that the appellant No.1 though being a qualified citizen, who was travelling with regard to his business has been illegally abducted, detained and a case under NDPS has been foisted on him due to which online complaints were lodged by his father- appellant No.2. It is in that light, the appellants are seeking for the directions as prayed and noted above.
9. The respondents have filed their objection statement denying the allegations and also contending with regard to the involvement of the appellant for which he has been apprehended and is proceeded against in accordance with law.
10. In that background, we have heard Shri Shyam Divan and Shri Gopal Sankaranarayanan, learned senior counsel for the appellants, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, learned senior counsel for the State of Chhattisgarh as also the counsel for State of Odisha and perused the appeal papers.
ROYDEN HAROLD BUTHELLO & ANR. v. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH & ORS. [A. S. BOPANNA, J.] A B C D E F G H 156 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
11. At the threshold it is necessary to take note that though initially the petition filed before the High Court had included the relief to quash the charge sheet and the further proceedings, considering that charges have been framed by the trial court and also detailed orders have been passed declining discharge of the appellant No.1, at present, the reliefs sought is essentially limited with regard to the direction to the CBI to conduct an investigation into the issue.
12. In that regard, the contention as noted is that, the FIR No.232/ 2020 is registered on 21.10.2020 alleging that at about 19:15 hours the appellant No.1 was apprehended by the Azad Chowk Police when the appellant No.1 was near Ashram Tiraha in front of Sulabh Complex Police Station, Azad Chowk, Raipur attempting to sell contraband and on apprehending 9.240 grams cocaine was recovered from him. It is contended by the appellants that such offence could not have been alleged against the appellant to have been committed in Raipur on 21.10.2020, when in fact the police personnel named Pramod Behra, Sultan, Santosh and Ali of Chhattisgarh Police had abducted and taken away the appellant No.1 from the hotel in Odisha on 20.10.2020 itself. As such, he was in their illegal custody at the point when it is alleged that he had indulged in committing the offence. The circumstances are referred to claim that there is something more than what meets the eye. The concern expressed is that a citizen who is carrying on his lawful business activities in various states has been ‘framed’ and a case has been foisted, whereby the personal liberty has been taken away, which warrants a detailed investigation. It is contended that the situation which unfolded in Hotel Green Park on 20.10.2020 at about 1 PM would indicate that the said four persons acting on behalf of the Chhattisgarh Police had taken him away from the hotel. Subsequent thereto his name has been included in FIR No.255/2020 as well, though it was an earlier registered case.
13. The learned senior counsel for respondent No.1-State would contend that the allegations are unjustified. Pursuant to the registration of the FIR, an investigation has been conducted and the charge sheet has been filed. The contentions urged by the appellants are available to be put forth in defence, in the proceedings before the trial court where the charges have been framed and the trial is proceeding. Insofar as the allegation that he was abducted and taken away from the hotel, it is denied and contended that even though the police had gone to Odisha in connection with the earlier F.I.R., they were unable to trace the appellant A B C D E F G H No.1 there, but he was subsequently found to be indulging in the illegal activity in Raipur itself when he was apprehended and proceedings have been initiated. It is contended that the claim for investigation by the CBI is without basis and the well laid down guidelines of this Court does not permit referring the investigation to CBI in every case where the accused makes an allegation against the law enforcing authorities.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.