Birbal Nath v. The State of Rajasthan & Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 957; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 85
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice And Convicting Them Only for the Off Ences U/Ss. 147, Justice 148, Justice 323, Justice 324, Justice One Given to Police U/S.161 Cr.Pc., Justice And the Other Given Before the Court, Justice Would Be Suffi Cient to Discredit A Witness. Penal Code, Justice 1870 – Ss. 304 Part I, Justice 308, Justice 147, Justice 148, Justice 323, Justice 324, Justice 325/149 – Culpable Homicide Not
- Decided
- 30 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1587/2008
- Sections
- 161, 149, 300, 302, 304, 307, 308, 145, 162, 313, 1622, 155
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 85 : 2023 INSC 957
CASE DETAILS
BIRBAL NATH
v.
THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ORS
(Criminal Appeal No. 1587 of 2008)
OCTOBER 30, 2023
[SANJAY KISHAN KAUL AND SUDHANSHU DHULIA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the High Court was justified in acquitting the accused for the major offences u/ss. 302 and 307 IPC, and convicting them only for the offences u/ss. 147, 148, 323, 324, 325/149 and reducing their sentences to the period already undergone by them; and whether contractions in the two statements of the injured eye witness, one given to police u/s.161 Cr.PC., and the other given before the court, would be sufficient to discredit a witness.
Penal Code, 1870 – ss. 304 Part I, 308, 147, 148, 323, 324, 325/149 – Culpable homicide not amounting to murder – First Information Report by the complainant that seven armed men assaulted his uncle and aunt while they were working in their agricultural field, causing them grievous injuries, resulting in the death of the uncle – Incident witnessed by several relatives who tried to intervene but failed – Conviction and sentence for the offences u/ss. 302, 307, 323, 324, 325, 447, 147/148 read with s. 149 – However, the High Court acquitted them for the major offences u/ss. 302 and 307, and were convicted only for the offences u/ ss. 147, 148, 323, 324, 325/149 – Correctness:
Held: This case is of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, and not of murder – Injuries sustained by the assailants could not be proved in the trial, defence witness stood thoroughly discredited – There were contradictions in the two statements of an injured eye witness – These contradictions, however, are not enough to completely discredit this witness, she is a reliable witness – Some discrepancies invariably occur in such 86 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
cases taking into account her rural back ground – Reasons assigned for disbelieving the statement of the eye witness by the High Court not correct – Apart from this eye-witness, there were other eyewitnesses as well – Also recovery of the weapons and the blood-stained cloth of the accused – In view of these contradictions, benefit of doubt given to the accused – As regards premeditated attack, the attack would come u/s.300 Exception 4, the attack not being premeditated, but was, “in a sudden fight in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the offender having taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner” – Thus, the approach of the High Court was not correct – Order of the High Court set aside and quashed – Conviction u/s. 302 converted to that of s. 304 Part I and that of s.307 to s. 308 and are sentenced accordingly – Case abates against the accused who expired. [Para 27-32] Witness – Contractions in the two statements, one given to police u/s.161 Cr.PC., and the other given before the court – Credibility: Held: Contractions in the two statements may or may not be sufficient to discredit a witness – s. 145/155 of the 1872 Act, have to be carefully applied in a given case – Purpose of the cross examination of a witness is to bring contradictions in the two statements of the witness – Rural setting, the degree of articulation of such a witness in a court of law are relevant considerations while evaluating the credibility of such witness – Lengthy cross-examination of witness may invariably result in contradictions – However, these contradictions not always sufficient to discredit a witness – Evidence Act, 1872 – ss. 145/155. [Paras 20 and 22] Witness – Injured eye-witness – Evidentiary value:
Held: Statement of an injured eye-witness is an important piece of evidence which cannot be easily discarded by a Court – Minor discrepancies do not matter. [Para 26] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1963 – s. 161 – Statement given to police during investigation under – Evidentiary value:
Held: Cannot be read as an “evidence” – It has limited applicability in a court of law as prescribed u/s. 162 – No doubt statement given before police during investigation u/s. 161 are previous statements u/s 145 of the Evidence Act and thus can be used to cross examine a witness – But only for limited purpose, to “contradict” such witness – Even if the defence is successful in contradicting a witness, it would not always mean that the contradiction in the two statements would result in totally discrediting the witness. [Paras 18 and 19]
LISTS OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Rammi v. State of M.P. (1999) 8 SCC 649: [1999] 3 Suppl. SCR 1; Tahsildar Singh v. State of U.P. AIR 1959 SC 1012: [1959] Suppl. SCR 875; State of M.P. vs. Mansingh and Others (2003) 10 SCC 414: [2003] 2 Suppl. SCR 460 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1587 of 2008.
From the Judgment and Order dated 08.08.2007 of the High Court of Rajasthan at Jodhpur in DBCA No.976 of 2002.
With Criminal Appeal No.1588 of 2008.
Appearances:
Dr. Manish Singhvi, Ramakrishan Veeraraghvan Sr. Advs., Ms.
Shubhangi Agarwal, Apurv S., Milind Kumar, Dr. Charu Mathur, P. D. Sharma, H. D. Thanvi, Nikhil Kumar Singh, Achal Singh Bule, Mahendra Singh, Rishi Matoliya, Advs. for the appearing parties.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.
1. Both the above appeals arise out of the judgment and order dated 08.08.2007 passed by the Rajasthan High Court in Criminal Appeal No.976 of 2002, whereby all the accused who stood convicted by the Trial Court for the offences under Sections 302, 307, 323, 324, 325, 447, 147 /148 read BIRBAL NATH v. THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ORS 88 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
with Section 149 of Indian Penal Code, were acquitted for the major offences under Sections 302 and 307, and were convicted only for the offences under Sections 147, 148, 323, 324, 325/149. Their sentences were also reduced to the period already undergone by them, which roughly varied from two to five years.
2. The complainant as well as the State have approached this Court by way of the above two appeals, which were admitted and leave was granted on 26.09.2008.
3. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant, Dr. Charu Mathur for the victims and Dr. Manish Singhvi, learned senior advocate for State of Rajasthan respectively, as well as senior advocate Mr. Ramakrishan Veeraraghavan on behalf of the accused-respondents.
4. An FIR was lodged on 22.05.2001 at about 3.00 PM by complainant- Birbal Nath at Police Station, Pachori, District Nagaur, Rajasthan which disclosed that at about 1:00 o’clock that afternoon, while the informant’s uncle ‘Chandernath’ and his aunt ‘Rami’ were working in their agricultural field, seven men, armed with weapons approached their field. They were as follows :-
(1) Jethnath having an ‘axe’
(2) Dhurnath having a ‘dang’
(3) Meghnath having a ‘farsi’
(4) Rughnath having Favda (Shovel)
(5) Babunath having a ‘dang’
(6) Malanath having an ‘axe’ and
(7) Devnath having a ‘dang’ All the above named accused, who were armed, started assaulting the aunt and uncle of the complainant-Birbalnath, in which both were grievously injured. Jethnath was the first to assault Chandernath with his axe and the rest joined the attack. Rami was also attacked, by these assailants. This incident was also witnessed by Pratapnath, Ramunath, Dhurnath, their sister-in-law Rampyari, Cheni Devi and Ruparam as they had reached the spot in a few minutes, who tried to intervene in the matter and save their relatives, but in vain. Chandernath died in the ambulance while being taken to the hospital at Jodhpur. Meanwhile the police started its investigation, and filed its chargesheet against all the accused except Devnath in the case. The case was later committed to the Sessions Court where charges were framed under Sections 147, 148, 302, 323/149, 324/149, 325/149, 447, 307/149 of the Indian Penal Code against all the six accused, named in the chargesheet.
5. There were in all 24 witnesses who were examined by the prosecution. The star eye witness being Rami (PW-2) who is the wife of the deceased and was herself grievously hurt in the incident. Apart from her there were other eye witnesses as well such as PW-3, PW-6 and PW-7 i.e., Rampyari, Mohannath, Birbalnath respectively. There was also recovery of clothes and weapons which was made on the disclosure of the accused.
6. In their statement under Section 313 of CrPC, all the accused denied the charges and the evidence against them and also presented defence witnesses in the form of – Birmaram (DW-1), Hanutaram (DW-2), Khemaram (DW-3), Dr. Devkaran (DW-4) and Hukmaram (DW-5).
7. Out of all the prosecution witnesses which were examined by the prosecution, Rami (PW-2) is the most important witness, as she was the wife of the deceased and at the relevant point of time was working in the field, along with her husband. In addition, this witness had sustained grievous injuries in the incident, including a near fatal injury on her head and therefore the testimony of this particular witness is the most credible evidence produced by the prosecution before the Trial Court. The examination-inchief and cross examination of Rami was done before the Trial Court on 27.11.2001. She was cross examined at length by the defence, but nothing has come out in the cross examination, except minor discrepancies. These discrepancies as we shall be examining later do not discredit the witness as has been held by the High Court. The social background and the overall surrounding circumstances of the case are important considerations for the court while examining a witness, which has not been done. The High Court, as we shall see, has relied on these discrepancies, while acquitting the accused of the charges under Sections 302 & 307.
8. In her examination-in-chief PW-2 consistently held the position that she and her husband were working on their field, and each of the accused was armed with either ‘axe’, ‘farsi’ or other weapon and that they were BIRBAL NATH v. THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ORS [SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 90 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
seven in number, who assaulted her and her husband. It was Jethnath who attacked on head with axe, Meghnath with ‘fawda’, Dhurnath with ‘dang’ on the head of her husband, Raghunath assaulted him with ‘fawda’1, Malanath attacked her husband with an axe, as did Raghunath and Babunath. All of them had attacked her as well, and as a result she sustained injuries on her head, left hand, right hand, joints and legs. Her husband too had injuries on his head, hands and legs. His hand and legs were fractured. When she raised an alarm, Pratapnath, Rampyari, Cheni, Ramnath, Birbalnath, Dudhnath, Purkharam and Ruparam came running to the spot and tried to save them. Chandernath her husband died on the way to the hospital at Jodhpur. She (PW-2) was given medical treatment and was examined by a doctor.
9. Rampyari (PW-3) who is again a witness to the incident states that on the fateful day at about 1.00 o’clock in the afternoon she heard someone crying for help. She recognised the voice of Rami and Chandernath and then she immediately ran towards the field. Chena, Birbalnath, Dudhnath and Purkharam were also with her. They saw Jethnath, Dhumnath, Meghnath, Rughnath, Babunath, Malanath and Devnath, all armed with either axe, farsi, dang and “fawda”. They were all attacking Chandernath. On seeing them the accused ran away from the spot. They saw Chandernath lying on his belly and was bleeding, and so was Rami. There were injuries on her head and ear.
10. Dr. Ramvilas who was examined as (PW-4) confirmed that the deceased died due to injuries particularly the injuries sustained on his head. Apart from Rami (PW-2) and Rampyari (PW-3) there are other eye witnesses as well (PW-6 and PW-7), who had reached the spot after they heard an alarm raised by Rami. The ‘site plan’ shows that the “chapper” of these witnesses is nearby and hence the fact that these witnesses were in the neighbourhood was rightly held by the Trial Court, and their presence seemed natural.
11. PW-6 and PW-7 had again made similar depositions as PW-3, being in the neighbourhood at the time of the incident. Though it may be doubtful whether they had witnessed the entire sequence of events, yet they had definitely seen the assailants fleeing from the place of occurrence. 1 Shovel These are also important witnesses though the High Court has said nothing on their deposition.
12. The post mortem of the body was conducted on 23.05.2001. The post mortem report shows the following ante mortem injuries:
“(i): Lacerated wound in the size of 1 ½” X ½” bone deep over the left parietal region of scalp. There is depressed podium of left parietal bone.
(ii): Lacerated wound in the size of 1” X ¼” bone deep over right parietal region of scalp. There is puncture/fracture of right parietal bone.
Pupils = Dilated, haggy.
(iii): Lacerated wound in the size of ¾” X ¼” bone deep over occipital region of scalp. There is puncture of occipital bone on skull. (iv): Lacerated wound in the size of ½” X 1/8” bone deep, huge contusion over upper part of left leg. There is fracture of upper 1/4th portion of tibia and fibula bone.
(v): Lacerated wound in the size of ½” X ¼” deep to bone and quitesome swelling had developed near at the wound. This wound was in the lower left leg. There was fracture in lower end of tibia and fibula bones.
(vi): Swelling in medium size had developed towards the upper side of the right hand and therein there was fracture of first meta-carpal bone.
…..
…..
In my opinion, cause of death of Chander Nath s/o Gopunath is Head- Injury and brian haemorrhage.”
13. The injuries sustained by Rami as per her injury report dated 22.05.2001 is as follows:
1. Incised wound in the size of 2 ½” x ½” x bone deep, deep/over anterior portion of scalp trans-vertically placed, simple in nature; Advised for X-Ray Report, by Sharp weapon.
BIRBAL NATH v. THE STATE OF RAJASTHAN & ORS [SUDHANSHU DHULIA, J.] 92 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
2. As defined swelling on right arm upto shoulder; advised for X-ray, simple in nature, by blunt object.
3. Bruise in the size of 1 ½” x ½” over lower part of left thigh, lower side, simple in nature, by blunt object.
4. Bruise in the size of 1 ½” x ½” on middle of left arm laterally, simple in nature, by blunt object.
5. Bruise in the size of 4” x 1” over lower back, simple in nature, by blunt object.
14. The Trial Court convicted all the accused under Sections 302, 323, 324, 325, 147, 148, 447 read with Section 149 of Indian Penal Code, and sentenced them inter alia for rigorous imprisonment for life. Jethnath, Dhurnath and Meghnath in addition were also convicted under Section 307 of IPC.
15. The accused filed an appeal before the High Court which was partly allowed, as discussed above.
16. The statement given by PW-2 before the Police under Section 161 Cr.PC, during investigation were relied by the defence in order to contradict the witness as to her statement in her examination-in-chief. The witness in her earlier statement before the police, had said that the accused Jethnath was working on his adjacent field and he had some altercation with the deceased regarding their boundary in which heated arguments were exchanged between the two. Jethnath, then, raised an alarm which resulted in his sons and relatives coming to the spot, who were all armed with weapons. It is true that this fact of Jethnath working in the field and the altercation she did not state in her examination-in-chief. The High Court thus finds a discrepancy in the statement of PW-2 made under section 161 Cr.PC and her examination-in-chief, which it believes to be sufficient to discredit this witness.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.