M/S Unibros v. All India Radio
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 931; [2023] 14 S.C.R. 683
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice S. Ravindra Bhat, Justice Attributable to Act, Justice Referred to Arbitrator – Vide First Award, Justice Appellant Was Awarded Sum Towards Loss Of
- Decided
- 19 Oct 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6895/2023
- Sections
- 34(2), 34, 37, 73
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 14 S.C.R. 683 : 2023 INSC 931
CASE DETAILS
M/S UNIBROS v.
ALL INDIA RADIO
(Civil Appeal No. 6895/2023)
OCTOBER 19, 2023
[S. RAVINDRA BHAT AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Arbitral award in question if in conflict with the public policy of India and; whether a claim on account of loss of profit is liable to succeed merely on the ground that there has been delay in the execution of the construction contract, attributable to the employer. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – s.34(2)(b) – “Public policy of India” – Appellant awarded work contract by the respondent – Disputes between the parties owing to the delay in work, referred to Arbitrator – Vide First Award, appellant was awarded sum towards loss of profit (Claim No.12) – Award set aside by High Court, claims remitted to the Arbitrator – Second Award was passed maintaining the award for loss of profit and interest to the appellant vide First Award – Respondent filed petition u/s.34 for setting aside the second Award – Single Judge allowed the objection, rejected the appellant's claim inter alia holding that there was no sufficient evidence presented by the appellant to establish the claimed loss of profit – Order affirmed by Division Bench:
Held: Second Award is equally in conflict with the public policy of India as the First Award – While remitting Claim No.12 for reconsideration, the Arbitrator was warned not to be influenced by the factors that weighed in his mind while making the First Award – Arbitrator was also required to proceed only on the basis of the evidence – However, the Arbitrator went on to ignore the judicial decision of the High Court with impunity – The factors which weighed in the Arbitrator’s mind in the first round and the second round are one and the same – To avoid any charge of being branded 684 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
as a mirror image of the First Award insofar as Claim No.12 is concerned, the Second Award appears to have been expressed in language and form different from the earlier one without, however, there being any change in substance – A judicial decision of a superior court, which is binding on an inferior court, has to be accepted with grace by the inferior court notwithstanding that the decision of the superior court may not be palatable to the inferior court – This principle, ex proprio vigore, would be applicable to an arbitrator and a multi-member arbitral tribunal as well, particularly when it is faced with a judicial decision (either u/s.34 or s.37 of the Act) ordering a limited remand – In the wake of authority of judicial determination made by the Courts of law, any award of an arbitrator or a tribunal that seeks to overreach a binding judicial decision does conflict with the fundamental public policy and thus, cannot be sustained – Further, a claim for damages, whether general or special, cannot as a matter of course result in an award without proof of the claimant having suffered injury – Arbitral award in question is patently illegal in that it is based on no evidence and is, thus, outrightly perverse; therefore, again, it is in conflict with the “public policy of India” as contemplated by s.34(2)(b) – No merit in the appeal. [Paras 13, 14 and 20] Arbitration – Claim for loss of profit arising from a delayed contract or missed opportunities from other available contracts – Claimant to substantiate the presence of a viable opportunity through compelling evidence demonstrating that had the contract been executed promptly, the contractor could have secured supplementary profits utilizing its existing resources elsewhere – Nature and quality of such evidence:
Held: Will be contingent upon the facts and circumstances of each case – However, it may generally include independent contemporaneous evidence such as other potential projects that the contractor had in the pipeline that could have been undertaken if not for the delays, the total number of tendering opportunities that the contractor received and declined owing to the prolongation of the contract, financial statements, or any clauses in the contract related to delays, extensions of time, and compensation for loss of profit – This list is not exhaustive and may include any other piece of evidence that the court may find relevant – In adjudging a claim towards loss of profits, the court may not make a guess in the dark; the credibility of the evidence, therefore, is the evidence of the credibility of such claim – Thus, for claims related to loss of profit, profitability or opportunities to succeed, one would be required to establish that there was a delay in the completion of the contract; that such delay is not attributable to the claimant; that the claimant’s status as an established contractor, handling substantial projects; and credible evidence to substantiate the claim of loss of profitability – In the present case, the fourth condition, namely, the evidence to substantiate the claim of loss of profitability remains unfulfilled. [Paras 17, 19] Arbitration – Contractor's claims for loss of profit – Hudson’s formula:
Held: Hudson’s formula though has attained acceptability and is well understood in trade, however, it does not apply in a vacuum – Hudson’s formula, as well as other methods used to calculate claims for loss of offsite overheads and profit, do not directly measure the contractor's exact costs – Instead, they provide an estimate of the losses the contractor may have suffered – While these formulae are helpful when needed, they alone cannot prove the contractor's loss of profit – They are useful in assessing losses, but only if the contractor has shown with evidence the loss of profits and opportunities it suffered owing to the prolongation. [Para 18]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Associated Builders vs. Delhi Development Authority (2015) 3 SCC 49: 2014 [13] SCR 895; Bharat Cooking Coal Limited vs. L.K. Ahuja (2004) 5 SCC 109: 2004 [3] SCR 1105; The Project Director, NHAI vs. M. Hakeem and Another (2021) 9 SCC 1: M/s AT Brij Paul Singh & Ors. vs. State of Gujarat (1984) 4 SCC 59: McDermott International Inc. vs. Burn Standard Co. Ltd. and Ors (2006) 11 SCC 181: 2006 [2] Suppl. SCR 409; ONGC Ltd. vs. Saw Pipes Ltd (2003) 5 SCC 705: 2003 [3] SCR 69 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.6895 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 09.12.2019 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in FAOOS No.229 of 2010.
M/S UNIBROS v. ALL INDIA RADIO 686 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
Appearances:
Sameer Rohatgi, Jagdish Vats, T.S. Chaudhary, Kartikey Singh, Sachin Gupta, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sanjay Jain, A.S.G., Piyush Beriwal, Sabarish Subramanian, Mrs. Bani Dikshit, Raghav Sharma, Padmesh Mishra, T.S. Sabarish, Ms. Harshita Sukhija, Amrish Kumar, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal, at the instance of M/s Unibros (“appellant”, hereafter), registers a challenge to the judgment and order dated 9th December, 2019 in FAO (OS) 229/2010 passed by the High Court of Delhi (“High Court”, hereafter) dismissing an appeal carried by the appellant under section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“the Act”, hereafter). Vide the impugned judgment, a Division Bench affirmed the judgment and order of a learned Single Judge dated 25th February, 2010 whereby an objection of the All India Radio (“respondent”, hereafter) under section 34 of the Act was allowed resulting in setting aside of an arbitral Award dated 15th July, 2002 to the extent it awarded loss of profit to the appellant.
3. The relevant facts, discerned from the records, reveal that the appellant was awarded a work contract by the respondent to carry out construction of Delhi Doordarshan Bhawan, Mandi House, Phase-II, New Delhi. The work was scheduled to commence on 12th April, 1990 and reach completion on 11th April, 1991; however, it suffered a delay of roughly 42½ months and was finally completed on 30th October, 1994. Disputes and differences emerged between the parties owing to such delay, which were subsequently referred to an Arbitrator (“Arbitrator”, hereafter) for resolution.
4. The trajectory of the case, leading to the present stage, is set out hereunder:
a) Arbitration proceedings having been initiated, the Arbitrator vide award dated 11th February, 1999 (“First Award”, hereafter) decided various claims and counter-claims filed by the parties. Claim Nos. 10, 11, and 12 were collectively addressed under section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (“Contract Act”), as they all centred around the issue of delay and the resultant losses. Vide Claim No. 10, the appellant claimed a sum of Rs. 50,00,000.00 (Rupees fifty lakh) owing to the marked escalation in prices/rates for the work executed beyond the stipulated contract period. Vide Claim No. 11, the appellant implored the Arbitrator to award Rs. 41,00,000.00 (Rupees forty-one lakh) to cover substantial expenses associated with the establishment, machinery, centring/shuttering, and other vital aspects of the project. Additionally, vide Claim No. 12, the appellant urged that a compensation of Rs. 2,00,00,000.00 (Rupees two crore) be granted as redress for the loss of profit endured due to the appellant’s protracted retention on the contract without any corresponding increase in monetary benefits earned. Despite the Arbitrator’s rejection of Claim Nos. 10 and 11, the appellant was awarded a sum of Rs. 1,44,83,830 (Rupees one crore, forty-four lakh, eighty-three thousand, eight hundred and thirty) towards Claim No. 12, along with an interest of 18% per annum under Claim No. 13 from 12th May, 1997 to the date of actual payment. The Arbitrator supported this award based on the undisputed fact that the delay in completing the work beyond the stipulated contract period was caused by the respondent and against the stipulated contract period of 12 months, the appellant was retained by the respondent for the execution of the work for an additional period of 3½ years leading to loss of the appellant’s profit earning capacity during the said extended period. The loss of profit was worked out based on a profit allowance of 7½% per year, which the Arbitrator held to be reasonable in a civil works contract. Applying Hudson’s formula, the Arbitrator arrived at the final compensation for loss of profit, the computation of which is outlined below:
Period of delay 42.5 months Contract value Rs. 5,45,27,386.00 Contract period 12 months M/S UNIBROS v. ALL INDIA RADIO
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
688 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
Contractor’s profit (7 ½ % per year) Rs. 40,89,554.00 Contractor’s expected profit per month Rs. 3,40,796.00 The total amount of loss of profit The total period of delay x Contractor’s expected profit per month Rs. 1,44,83,830.00 b) Aggrieved by the aforesaid First Award, primarily to the extent it awarded Rs.1,44,83,830.00 towards loss of profit to the appellant, the respondent filed an objection under section 34 of the Act before the High Court impugning the decision pertaining to Claim Nos. 12 and 13. Vide judgment and order dated 20th May, 2002, the First Award was set aside and the aforesaid claims were remitted to the Arbitrator for re-consideration and for passing a fresh award. The operative part of the judgment passed by the learned Single Judge reads thus:
“24. *** Except for placing on record the Hudson’s formula and a passage from the book law (sic, Law) on Building and Engineering Contracts, no other evidence is placed on record by the respondent to show that the profit percentage as claimed towards loss of profit was a realistic one at that times and consequently there was no change in the market and also that the work of at least the same general level of profitability would have been available to the respondent at the end of the stipulated contract period. Therefore, evidence in respect of the said claim appears to be definitely not available on record. In absence of any credible evidence and when claims under Claim Nos. 10 & 11 were rejected on the ground that no sufficient evidence had been placed on record by the respondent indicating increase in the prices/ rates for the work executed after the stipulated contract period and also on account of establishment, machinery, centering/shuttering etc., Claim No.12 was allowed by the arbitration (sic, arbitrator) without even considering whether the respondent has placed credible and reliable evidence as required to be proved. ***
25. *** Not only there was lack of credible and required evidence placed on record by the respondent in support of Claim No.12 as set out in the extracts from the book Law of Building and Engineering Contracts, and (sic) the arbitrator also took into consideration such factors which could not and should not be (sic, have) influenced his mind. Therefore, the award was passed by the arbitrator against the fundamental policy of Indian Law attracting the provisions of Section 34 (2)(b) (ii) of the Act. I set aside the award given by the arbitrator against Claim No.12 and remit the same for re-consideration by the arbitrator and to pass a fresh award in respect of the said claim without being in any manner influenced by such factors and on the basis of the evidence available on record. Since the award passed by the arbitrator is set aside to the aforesaid extent, the award of interest in Claim No. 13 in respect of the amount of Claim No. 12 also stands set aside and quashed and the same are remitted for reconsideration and decision. Subject to the aforesaid modifications in the award, the remaining part of the award is upheld.”
(emphasis ours)
c) The Arbitrator passed a fresh award dated 15th July, 2002 (“Second Award”, hereafter) maintaining the award for loss of profit and interest to the appellant vide First Award. By referring to the communications between the parties, the Arbitrator reiterated that the respondent had failed to provide the complete site and drawings within the stipulated contract period, leading to delays. As per established legal principles, the party responsible for the breach of the contract is liable for reasonably foreseeable losses. Considering the appellant’s status as an established contractor, handling substantial projects, the Arbitrator inferred that it was reasonable to assume earning of expected profits elsewhere by the appellant. Employing the doctrine that within a contract, gains M/S UNIBROS v. ALL INDIA RADIO
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
690 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 14 S.C.R.
prevented qualify as loss sustained, the Arbitrator observed that the appellant was not required to establish the exact amount of gain or loss with absolute certainty; instead, presenting fairly persuasive and the best available evidence under the particular circumstances of the case would suffice.
d) The respondent filed a petition under Section 34 of the Act, seeking to set aside the Second Award. The learned Single Judge of the High Court vide judgment and final order dated 25th February 2010 allowed the objection under Section 34 and rejected the appellant’s claim under Claim No. 12 with an observation that there was no sufficient evidence presented by the appellant to establish the claimed loss of profit; the lack of records regarding the alleged utilization of men, material, machinery, overheads, and other resources in the contract performance that could have otherwise been used for other profitable contracts raised doubts about the legitimacy of the claimed losses under Claim No. 12. With an observation that the Union of India was forced into litigation due to the appellant’s misconceived claim, the Single Judge awarded costs of Rs. 50,000.00 (Rupees fifty thousand) in favour of the respondent, payable within four weeks from the date of the final order and interest of 9% per annum in case of non-compliance. Findings returned by the learned Single Judge are extracted below:
“4. I have gone through the entire Award. The Award … as a loss under this Claim 12.
5. In this view of the … in the arbitration proceedings.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.