Batliboi Environmental Engineers Limited v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited and Another
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 850; [2023] 12 S.C.R. 441
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice 1996, Justice And Thereby Setting Aside the and Conciliation Act, Justice And Thereafter
- Decided
- 21 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1968/2012
- Sections
- 37, 34, 31, 30, 55, 73, 75, 81, 33, 34(2), 2A, 31(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 12 S.C.R. 441 : 2023 INSC 850
CASE DETAILS
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LIMITED
v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORPORATION LIMITED AND
ANOTHER
(Civil Appeal No. 1968 of 2012)
SEPTEMBER 21, 2023
[SANJIV KHANNA AND M.M. SUNDRESH, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the Division Bench of the High Court was justified in allowing the appeal filed by the respondents u/s. 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and thereby setting aside the arbitral award.
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – s. 37 – Arbitral award – Interference with – Award of turnkey contract to the appellant by the respondents for a contract value to be completed within stipulated period – Delay in project completion which was extended, and thereafter the appellant abandoned the work, only 80% of the work was completed – Matter proceeded for arbitration – Arbitral award dismissed the respondent’s claim for liquidated damages on the ground that the delay was caused by respondent’s omissions and commissions and its other claim also rejected since they related to future works – Appeal thereagainst allowed by the Division Bench setting aside the arbitral award – Justification of:
Held: Computation depends upon attendant facts and circumstances and methods to compute damages – Determination of the quantum is a matter which would fall within the domain and decision of the arbitrator – However, the computation of damages should not be whimsical and absurd resulting in a windfall and bounty for one party at the expense of the other – Computation of damages should not be disingenuous – Damages should commensurate with the loss sustained – Arbitral tribunal gave a complete go 442 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
by to the principles well in place, overlooked care and caution required and took a one-sided view, grossly and abnormally inflated the damages – No justification for computation of the loss is elucidated or can be expounded – Even if one were to rely upon the chart given by the appellant, and ignore the contradictions in findings, the amount awarded is highly disproportionate and exorbitant – Patent flaws and illegalities emanate from the award, like the manifest lack of reasoning in arriving at the conclusions and the calculation of amounts awarded, which, in fact, amount to double or partdouble payments, besides being contradictory – Thus, the award rightly held to be unsustainable and set aside by the Division Bench of the High Court exercising power and jurisdiction u/s. 37 rw s. 34. [Paras 15, 16, 27 and 45] s. 34 – Post award interference – Scope and ambit of court’s power: Held: Foundation of arbitration is party autonomy – Parties have the freedom to enter into an agreement to settle their disputes/claims by an arbitral tribunal, whose decision is binding on the parties – Court must exercise its powers when the award is unfair, arbitrary, perverse, or otherwise infirm in law – While arbitration is a private form of dispute resolution, the conduct of arbitral proceedings must meet the juristic requirements of due process and procedural fairness and reasonableness, to achieve a ‘judicially’ sound and objective outcome – If these requirements, which are equally fundamental to all forms of adjudication including arbitration, are not sufficiently accommodated in the arbitral proceedings and the outcome is marred, then the award should invite intervention by the court. [Paras 31and 32] Contract – Computation of damages – Method for – Usage of formulae such as Hudson’s, Emden’s, or Eichleay’s formulae to ascertain the loss of overheads and profits:
Held: Three formulae deal with theoretical mathematical equations, but are based on factual assumptions, and thus, can produce three different and unrelated compensation/damages – Thus, while applying a particular equation or method, the assumptions should be examined, and the satisfaction of the assumption(s) ascertained in the facts and circumstances – Hudson’s formula like other formulae, which are only rough approximations of the cost impact of unabsorbed overhead, should be applied with great care and caution to ensure fair and just computation. s. 34 – Public policy test to an arbitral award - Expression ‘public policy’ u/s. 34 – Interpretation of – Elucidated. [Para 21, 25, and 38]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
McDermott International Inc. v. Burn Standard Company Limited and Others (2006) 11 SCC 181:[2006] 2 Suppl. SCR 409; Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority (2015) 3 SCC 49:[2014] 13 SCR 895; A.T Brij Paul Singh and Others v. State of Gujarat (1984) 4 SCC 59; Vidya Drolia and Others v. Durga Trading Corporation and Others, (2021) 2 SCC 1:[2020] 11 SCR 1001; ONGC Limited. v. Saw Pipes Limited. (2003) 5 SCC 705:[2003] 3 SCR 691; Hindustan Zinc Ltd. v. Friends Coal Carbonisation (2006) 4 SCC 445; Centrotrade Minerals and Metals Inc. v. Hindustan Copper Limited (2006) 11 SCC 245; Delhi Development Authority v. R.S. Sharma and Co (2008) 13 SCC 80:[2008] 12 SCR 785; J.G. Engineers (P) Ltd. v. Union of India and Another (2011) 5 SCC 758:[2011] 8 SCR 486; Union of India v. L.S.N. Murthy (2012) 1 SCC 718:[2011] 13 SCR 295; Renusagar Power Co. Limited v. General Electric Co 1994 Supp (1) SCC 644:[1993] 3 Suppl. SCR 22; Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Ltd. v. Dewan Chand Ram Saran (2012) 5 SCC 306:[2012] 4 SCR 1; ONGC Ltd. v. Western Geco International Ltd., (2014) 9 SCC 263:[2014] 12 SCR 1; Excise and Taxation Officer-cum-Assessing Authority v. Gopi Nath & Sons 1992 Supp (2) SCC 312; Kuldeep Singh v. Commissioner of Police (1999) 2 SCC 10:[1998] 3 Suppl. SCR 594; MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd. (2019) 4 SCC 163:[2019] 3 SCR 1023; Ssangyong Engg. & Construction Co. Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India (2019) 15 SCC 131:[2019] 7 SCR 522 – referred to. Robinson v. Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850 at 855; Livingstone v. Rawyards Coal Co (1879-80) L.R. 5880 cases 25; Peak Construction (Liverpool) Ltd v. McKinney Foundations Limited (1970) 1 BLR 114; Whittal Builders v. Chesterle-Street District Council (1987) 40 BLR 82; JF Finnegan Ltd v. Sheffield City Council (1988) 43 BLR 124; Ellis- Don v. Parking Authority of Toronto (1978) 28 BLR 98; Property and Land Contractors Ltd v. Alfred McAlpine Homes North Ltd. (1995) 76 BLR 59; Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v. Wednesbury Corporation., (1948) 1 KB 223: (1947) 2 All ER 680 (CA); Eichleay Corporation case, ASBCA No. 5183, 60-2 BCA – referred to.
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD.
444 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.1968 of 2012.
From the Judgment and Order dated 02.11.2007 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in AN No.227 of 2001 in AP No.280 of 1999. Appearances:
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Amar Dave, Mahesh Agarwal, Ankur Saigal, Aadil Parsurampuria, Ms. S. Lakshmi Iyer, Ms. Tanvi Manchanda, Nishant Rao, E. C. Agrawala, Advs. for the Appellant.
N. Venkataraman, A.S.G., Sanjay Kapur, Ms. Megha Karnwal, Surya Prakash, Arjun Bhatia, Ms. Akshata Joshi, Advs. for the Respondents. JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
SANJIV KHANNA, J.
This appeal by way of special leave by Batliboi Environmental Engineers Limited1 takes exception to the judgment dated 02.11.2007, whereby the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay allowed the appeal2 filed by Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited3 under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 19964, and thereby has set aside the arbitral award dated 23.03.1999.
2. On acceptance of tender and in terms of the letter of intent dated 27.02.1992, HPCL had awarded to BEEL the turnkey contract for detailed engineering including civil and structural design, supply and erection, testing and commissioning of 23 MLD capacity Sewage Water Reclamation Plant in Mahul Refinery area. The contract value was Rs.574.35 lakhs. The contract period was 18 months from the date of letter of intent, and accordingly the 1 For short, BEEL.
2 Appeal No. 227 of 2001 in Arbitration Petition No. 280 of 1999. 3 For short, HPCL.
4 For short, A&C Act.
work was to be completed by 28.08.1993. There was delay in completion. On written requests/applications made by BEEL, the time for completion was extended on two occasions. Three revisions were also issued by HPCL. The last revision dated 20.09.1994 had extended the period for completion from 26.09.1994 by 10 months beginning from the date on which approval of electrical items was accorded by HPCL. BEEL carried on the work till 30.03.1996. Thereafter, BEEL abandoned the work. It is an accepted position that as on 30.03.1996, 80% of the work was complete.
3. On 04.07.1996, BEEL made a formal claim to HPCL for breach of contract on account of delay in execution, causing extra expenses and losses. By the letter dated 16.05.1997, BEEL sought an advance payment of Rs.50 lakhs to enable them to resume work, and simultaneously expressed its desire to resolve the dispute through conciliation. BEEL by the same letter also invoked the arbitration clause in the contract, if the proposal as given by BEEL was unacceptable to HPCL. HPCL by the letter dated 05.05.1997 refused to make payment, and relying on the terms of the contract had impressed upon BEEL to resume and complete the remaining work, even if the matter was to proceed for arbitration. BEEL did not agree and resume work.
4. The General Manager (Project), Mahul Refinery, HPCL, appointed Mr. K. Narayanan as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes and differences in the execution of the contract. Claim was filed by BEEL and reply/counter claim was filed by HPCL, to which rejoinder with supporting documents and sur-rejoinders were filed. In all about 14 hearings were held before the arbitral tribunal between the period 12.03.1998 and 07.01.1999 and oral arguments were addressed. Ocular evidence was not led. The learned arbitrator had conducted a site inspection on 24.12.1997.
5. The arbitral award dated 23.03.1999, substantially allows the Claims Nos. 1,2, and 4 of the BEEL. The relevant portion of the award dealing with the claims of the BEEL, reads:
“A. Claims of the Claimants:
Claim No.1 – Compensation for loss of Overhead and profit and also profitability: Rs.3,38,38,460.00 BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 446 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
The claim is forwards loss of Overheads and profi t/profitability calculated on the basis of 48 months delay as of 27.08.1997. The Claimants have considered 10% of the Contract value towards Overheads and another 10% towards profit/profitability to arrive at the above figure, after taking into account the same percentages from the payments already received by them.
My finding is that the Owner Respondents are fully responsible for the huge delay that occurred by not taking proper and timely action in removing the various impediments and obstacles that stood in the way of completing the project in the given span of 18 months. The party had been tied down to a project, which was allowed to drift aimlessly, with the owner-respondents showing hardly any interest in completing it in time.
Even the basic approval for the Electrical scheme, with numerous revisions was kept pending, till the end without any decision. The Claimants could not have expected to complete the project without these clearances. The Respondents have thus evaded their own responsibilities and committed breach of contractual obligations. As admitted by the Respondents, even the arrangement with MCGB for the supply of Sewage water for purification has not yet been finalised. This, as advised by the Respondents, is awaiting the intervention of the Chief Minister. It is any body’s guess when this arrangement will be firmed up the necessary pumping station and underground pipelines etc. will be ready so that sewage water will flow to the plant being built for purification by the claimant. This is proof that the Respondents were not serious enough in implementing the project.
For reasons given above, I consider that the claimants are legitimately entitled for compensation towards both loss of Overheads and profit/profitability. In arriving at the compensation, the period upto 30.03.1996, when the claimants discontinued the work is being considered. The total period works out to 49 months. The original contract period being 18 months, the extended period comes to 31 months. The claimants had stated in their claim statement that they had provided for 22 months overheads in their estimate. I am allowing 3 months for internal administrative process of the Owner- Respondents and for unforeseen delays such as strike, red alerts etc. I also consider 10% of contract value towards loss of overheads and 10% towards loss of profit/profitability as reasonable. On these (sic) basis, the Compensation works out to Rs.78,68,833.00 towards loss of overheads and an equal amount of Rs.78,68,833.00 towards loss of profit/profitability, the total being Rs.1,57,37,666.00 after taking into account the same percentage from payments already received by them for the work done. I award this amount to the Claimants.
While awarding the above compensation, the existence of the means to mitigate the loss has been considered. According to me, the only means available to the claimants, was to work on Sundays and Holidays, to make up for the lost time to some extent, which was denied by the Respondents except for a brief period at the very end. This brief relaxation was not of much significance in determining the compensation payable to the claimants.
Claim No.2 – Compensation for idle machinery and equipment:
Rs.84,59,615.00 This claim is for machinery and equipment deployed in the execution of this contract, but had to idle for large part of the time, due to extended contract period. I have inspected the site. I am of the opinion that there is substance in the claim. After due consideration of all aspects, I award an amount of Rs.50,000.00 per month for a period of 24 months which comes to Rs.12,00,000.00 Claim No.3 – Compensation for losses incurred due to increased cost of Materials and Labour: Rs.26,89,638.00 Even though the escalation in cost of material and labour is a normal feature when Engineering Contracts such as this gets unduly delayed, since escalation is not permitted as per the contract the claim stands rejected totally.
Claim No.4 – Compensation for carrying out Extra Work:
Rs.19,00,225.00 The claim consists of the following 4 items:
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 448 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
(i) Transportation of excavated earth Rs.12,05,000.00
(ii) Dewatering charges incurred during delayed period Rs.5,62,570.00
(iii) Shifting charges for material Rs.1,01,405.00
(iv) Shifting charges for Filter media Rs.31,250.00 The above jobs have been carried out in relation to the main contract, but have figured as extra items due to certain omissions and commissions by the owner-respondents. The claimants have compelled and produced vouchers and documents in support of their claim. I am not satisfied with all the details furnished. Therefore, against the above claim, I awarded to the extent I am satisfied with the documentation, as under:
Item No.I Rs.1,20,000.00 towards transportation of excavated earth dumped by other contractors in the work site, prior to award of contract but after submission of the offer.
Item No.II Nil amount Item No. III Rs.50,000.00 towards shifting of materials manually because of non-availability of approach to site for vehicle.
Item No.IV Rs.25,000.00 towards charges for shifting the Filter Media Several times for paucity of space.
Total Claim amount awarded: Rs.1,95,000.00 against Rs.19,00,225.00 Claim No.5 – Cost of repair and rectification: Amount to be assessed. No award on this as this refers to future course of action when project work is resumed.
INTEREST: The Claimants are also entitled to 18% interest per annum on all the claims awarded, effective from 16.05.1997, the date on which the notice invoking Arbitration clause was served on the Respondents (date on which cause of action arose) till the date of payment. BANK GUARANTEE: The Claimants have specifically prayed for reduction of the performance Bank Guarantee amount by 50%. In view of the fact that about 80% of the work has been completed, and
(in) view (of) (sic) the huge delay that has occurred the amount shall be reduced by 50%.”
6. The award dated 23.03.1999 dismisses the counter claim of HPCL for liquidated damages of Rs.57.40 lakhs, on the ground that the delay was caused by omissions and commissions of HPCL. Claims by HPCL for rectification/rehabilitation cost of Rs.102.05 lakhs, costs of balance work of Rs.160 lakhs and de-watering cost of Rs.9 lakhs were denied on the ground that they relate to future works and therefore, would not fall within the ambit of arbitration in question.
7. We have intentionally quoted the entire findings and reasoning accorded by the learned arbitrator, while allowing the Claim Nos. 1,2 and 4 of BEEL. The first egregious and obvious flaw in the award is, the omnibus finding and conclusion that HPCL (referred to as the owner and the respondent in the quoted portion of the award) was fully responsible for the inordinate delay that had occurred by not taking proper and timely action in removal of various impediments and obstacles that stood in the way of completing the project within the stipulated period of 18 months. This finding, in our opinion, is bereft of analysis and examination of facts and contentions. The relevant and material facts and the respective stances of the parties are neither decipherable nor evaluated and no reason has been given for arriving at the conclusion. A conclusion without any discussion and reasons, is non-compliant and violates the mandate of sub - section (3) of Section 31 of the A& C Act5, an aspect we would examine subsequently.
8. The second patent error relates to the computation and award of 10% of the contract value towards loss of overheads and another 10% towards loss of profits/profitability. The two amounts have been quantified at Rs.78,68,833/- each. Thus, Rs.1,57,37,666/- has been awarded and held as payable by HPCL to BEEL. The award is deficient being completely silent as to the method and the manner in which the arbitral tribunal has computed the figures. Therefore, it leaves us and the parties to wonder the 5 Section 31 - Form and contents of arbitral award - (3) The arbitral award shall state the reasons upon which it is based, unless—
(a) the parties have agreed that no reasons are to be given, or
(b) the award is an arbitral award on agreed terms under section 30. BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 450 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
basis for awarding and computing the amounts. We are not commenting or examining the merits of the computation, but complete absence of any justification and reason to allow the claim and quantification of the sum awarded. We would subsequently examine the chart furnished by BEEL in support of the said computation, albeit at this stage we would like to highlight the apparent contradiction in the award, which is the third ground to uphold the decision of the Division Bench of the High Court.
9. We begin our substantiation of the third ground, by referring to the first paragraph of the award quoted above, under the heading ‘Claim No. 1 - Compensation for loss of overhead and profit and also profitability’. BEEL had based Claim No.1 for loss on account of overheads and profits/ profitability upon 48 months delay as on 27.08.1997. BEEL for computation had considered 10% of the contract value towards overheads and other 10% towards profits/profitability for arriving at the figure of Rs. 3,38,38,460/-, after taking into “account the same percentages from the payments already received by them”. In the subsequent portion of the award, dealing with Claim No. 1, the learned arbitrator has held that the total contract period was 49 months. The original contract period being 18 months, the extended period being 31 months. However, BEEL in the claim statement had accepted that it had provided for 22 months towards overheads in the estimates. Further, the learned arbitrator has allowed additional 3 months for internal administrative process, and for unforeseen delays, such as strikes, red alerts, and as force majeure events. In other words, the learned arbitrator, for the purpose of default, had excluded the period of 18 months, i.e., the original contract period, plus 4 months as provided by BEEL, and another 3 months on account of internal administrative process and force majeure events. Thus, the default period for which BEEL as per the award is entitled to claim damages/compensation towards overheads and loss of profits/profitability is 24 months.
10. BEEL had, as observed above, accepts the position that the loss towards overheads and profits/profitability has to be arrived at by applying the percentage formula, variant with the execution of the work. Thus, in our opinion, the loss towards overheads and profits/profitability is to be computed on the payments due for the un-executed work, and should exclude the payments received/receivable for the work executed. In other words, based on the value of the work executed by BEEL, the proportionate amount has to be reduced for computing the damage/compensation as a percentage of expenditure on overheads, and damages for loss of profit/ profitability. Damages towards expenditure on overheads and loss of profit are proportionate, and not payable for the work done and paid/payable. Delay in payment on execution of the work has to be compensated separately.
11. It is an accepted position and specifically recorded in the award that the total value of the contract was Rs. 5,74,35,213.00p. In an earlier paragraph of the award, which has been not reproduced, the learned arbitrator has referred to R.A. Bill No.4 dated 31.08.1993, as per which BEEL had completed work of Rs.1,21,95,859.68p. It is also an accepted and admitted position that as on 30.03.1996, the date on which the work stopped, as per R.A. Bill No. 37, work valued at Rs. 2,92,07,619.13p had been executed. In other words, BEEL had executed and received payments of Rs. 2,92,07,619.13/- from HPCL from time to time, between the period 01.09.1993 and 30.03.1996. Eighty percent of the work was complete. BEEL has received total payment of Rs.4,14,03,478.81p in terms of running account bills till R.A. No. 37. The balance work was Rs. 1,14,87,042.00p. Twenty percent of Rs.1,14,03,478.81 is Rs.22,97,408.40p. In addition, BEEL is entitled to compensation for the delay in execution of the work of Rs.2,92,07,619.13/- till the date payments were made, albeit, the award directs payment of Rs. 18% interest per annum on all claims awarded effective from 16.05.1997.
12. The award also reduces the performance bank guarantee amount by 50%, without any discussion, elucidation and reason.
13. In order to justify the computation made in the award and also the principle or the method adopted by the arbitral tribunal, BEEL has referred to the Hudson’s formula and relied upon judgments of this Court in McDermott International Inc. v. Burn Standard Company Limited and Others.6, and Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority7, in addition to an earlier decision of this Court in A.T Brij Paul Singh and Others v. State of Gujarat8, and a few judgments of the High Courts.
6 (2006) 11 SCC 181 (for short, McDermott International Inc.). 7 (2015) 3 SCC 49 (for short, Associate Builders).
8 (1984) 4 SCC 59.
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 452 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
14. In McDermott International Inc. this Court has referred to various methods of computation of damages in paragraphs 102 to 107. In particular, reference has been made to Hudson’s formula, Emden’s formula, and Eichleay’s formula in the following terms:
“Method for computation of damages
102. [Ed.: Para 102 corrected vide Official Corrigendum No. F.3/ Ed.B.J./52/2006 dated 31-7-2006] . What should, however, be the method of computation of damages is a question which now arises for consideration. Before we advert to the rival contentions of the parties in this behalf, we may notice that in M.N. Gangappa v. Atmakur Nagabhushanam Setty & Co. [(1973) 3 SCC 406] this Court held that the method used for computation of damages will depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case.
102-A. In the assessment of damages, the court must consider only strict legal obligations, and not the expectations, however reasonable, of one contractor that the other will do something that he has assumed no legal obligation to do. (See Lavarack v. Woods of Colchester Ltd. [(1967) 1 QB 278 : (1966) 3 All ER 683 : (1966) 3 WLR 706 (CA)] , All ER p. 690 G.)
103. The arbitrator quantified the claim by taking recourse to the Emden Formula. The learned arbitrator also referred to other formulae, but, as noticed hereinbefore, opined that the Emden Formula is a widely accepted one.
104. It is not in dispute that MII had examined one Mr D.J. Parson to prove the said claim. The said witness calculated the increased overheads and loss of profit on the basis of the formula laid down in a manual published by the Mechanical Contractors Association of America entitled “Change Orders, Overtime, Productivity” commonly known as the Emden Formula. The said formula is said to be widely accepted in construction contracts for computing increased overheads and loss of profit. Mr D.J. Parson is said to have brought out the additional project management cost at US$ 1,109,500. We may at this juncture notice the different formulas applicable in this behalf.
(a) Hudson Formula: In Hudson’s Building and Engineering Contracts, Hudson Formula is stated in the following terms:
“Contract head office overhead and profit percentage × Contract sum Contract period × Period of delay”
In the Hudson Formula, the head office overhead percentage is taken from the contract. Although the Hudson Formula has received judicial support in many cases, it has been criticised principally because it adopts the head office overhead percentage from the contract as the factor for calculating the costs, and this may bear little or no relation to the actual head office costs of the contractor.
(b) Emden Formula: In Emden’s Building Contracts and Practice, the Emden Formula is stated in the following terms:
“Head office overhead and profit × Contract sum × Period of delay” 100 Contract period Using the Emden Formula, the head office overhead percentage is arrived at by dividing the total overhead cost and profit of the contractor’s organisation as a whole by the total turnover. This formula has the advantage of using the contractor’s actual head office overhead and profit percentage rather than those contained in the contract. This formula has been widely applied and has received judicial support in a number of cases including Norwest Holst Construction Ltd. v. Coop. Wholesale Society Ltd. [ Decided on 17- 2-1998, [1998] EWHC Technology 339] , Beechwood Development Co. (Scotland) Ltd. v. Mitchell [ Decided on 21-2-2001, (2001) CILL 1727] and Harvey Shopfitters Ltd. v. Adi Ltd. [ Decided on 6-3-2003, (2004) 2 All ER 982 : [2003] EWCA Civ 1757] .
(c) Eichleay Formula: The Eichleay Formula was evolved in America and derives its name from a case heard by the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals, Eichleay Corporation. It is applied in the following manner:
Step 1 BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 454 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Contract billings × To t a l o v e r he a d f o r contract period = Overhead allocable to the contract Total billings for contract period Step 2 Allocable overhead = Daily overhead rate Total days of contract Step 3 Daily contract overhead rate × Number of days of delay = Amount of unabsorbed overhead”
This formula is used where it is not possible to prove loss of opportunity and the claim is based on actual cost. It can be seen from the formula that the total head office overhead during the contract period is first determined by comparing the value of work carried out in the contract period for the project with the value of work carried out by the contractor as a whole for the contract period. A share of head office overheads for the contractor is allocated in the same ratio and expressed as a lump sum to the particular contract. The amount of head office overhead allocated to the particular contract is then expressed as a weekly amount by dividing it by the contract period. The period of delay is then multiplied by the weekly amount to give the total sum claimed. The Eichleay Formula is regarded by the Federal Circuit Courts of America as the exclusive means for compensating a contractor for overhead expenses.
105. Before us several American decisions have been referred to by Mr Dipankar Gupta in aid of his submission that the Emden Formula has since been widely accepted by the American courts being Nicon Inc. v. United States [ Decided on 10-6-2003 (USCA Fed Cir), 331 F. 3d 878 (Fed. Cir. 2003)] , Gladwynne Construction Co. v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore [ Decided on 25-9-2002, 807 A. 2d 1141 (2002) : 147 Md. App. 149] and Charles G. William Construction Inc. v. White [ 271 F 3d 1055 (Fed. Cir. 2001)] .
106. We do not intend to delve deep into the matter as it is an accepted position that different formulae can be applied in different circumstances and the question as to whether damages should be computed by taking recourse to one or the other formula, having regard to the facts and circumstances of a particular case, would eminently fall within the domain of the arbitrator.
107. If the learned arbitrator, therefore, applied the Emden Formula in assessing the amount of damages, he cannot be said to have committed an error warranting interference by this Court.”
15. McDermott International Inc. refers to Sections 559 and 7310 of the Indian Contract Act, 187211, which deal with the effect of failure to perform at 9 Section 55 - Effect of failure to perform at fixed time, in contract in which time is essential - When a party to a contract promises to do a certain thing at or before a specified time, or certain things at or before specified times, and fails to do any such thing at or before the specified time, the contract, or so much of it as has not been performed, becomes voidable at the option of the promisee, if the intention of the parties was that time should be of the essence of the contract.
Effect of such failure when time is not essential.—If it was not the intention of the parties that time should be of the essence of the contract, the contract does not become voidable by the failure to do such thing at or before the specified time; but the promisee is entitled to compensation from the promisor for any loss occasioned to him by such failure. Effect of acceptance of performance at time other than that agreed upon.—If, in case of a contract voidable on account of the promisor’s failure to perform his promise at the time agreed, the promisee accepts performance of such promise at any time other than that agreed, the promisee cannot claim compensation for any loss occasioned by the nonperformance of the promise at the time agreed, unless, at the time of such acceptance, he gives notice to the promisor of his intention to do so.
10 Section 73 - Compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract. - When a contract has been broken, the party who suffers by such breach is entitled to receive, from the party who has broken the contract, compensation for any loss or damage caused to him thereby, which naturally arose in the usual course of things from such breach, or which the parties knew, when they made the contract, to be likely to result from the breach of it. Such compensation is not to be given for any remote and indirect loss or damage sustained by reason of the breach.
Compensation for failure to discharge obligation resembling those created by contract. When an obligation resembling those created by contract has been incurred and has not been discharged, any person injured by the failure to discharge it is entitled to receive the same compensation from the party in default, as if such person had contracted to discharge it and had broken his contract.
Explanation - In estimating the loss or damage arising from a breach of contract, the means which existed of remedying the inconvenience caused by the non-performance of the contract must be taken into account.
11 For short, Contract Act.
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 456 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
fixed time in contracts where time is of essence, and computation of damages caused by breach of contract, respectively, and states that these Sections neither lay down the mode nor how and in what manner computation of damages for compensation has to be made. As computation depends upon attendant facts and circumstances and methods to compute damages, how the quantum thereof should be determined is a matter which would fall within the domain and decision of the arbitrator.
16. This is without doubt, a sound legal and correct proposition. However, the computation of damages should not be whimsical and absurd resulting in a windfall and bounty for one party at the expense of the other. The computation of damages should not be disingenuous. The damages should commensurate with the loss sustained. In a claim for loss on account of delay in work attributable to the employer, the contractor is entitled to the loss sustained by the breach of contract to the extent and so far as money can compensate. The party should to be placed in the same situation, with the damages, as if the contract had been performed. The principle is that the sum of money awarded to the party who has suffered the injury, should be the same quantum as s/he would have earned or made, if s/he had not sustained the wrong for which s/he is getting compensated.12
17. We shall subsequently catechise the Hudson’s formula, suffice at this stage is to notice that the learned arbitrator does not specifically refer to any formula or the method, and the figures to compute damages under the head of loss on account of overheads and profits/profitability. The award, as quoted above, does refer to Sections 55 and 73 of the Contract Act.
18. Having examined the award and the contents, we would now like to refer to the chart produced by BEEL by way of additional or new material, which it is claimed, is drawn on the basis of the statement of claims filed in the arbitration proceedings, to which the column with the heading “explanation” has been added for the benefit of the court. The chart is as under:
12 See - Robinson v. Harman (1848) 1 Ex 850 at 855 and Livingstone v. Rawyards Coal Co (1879-80) L.R. 5880 cases 25 Sr.
No.
Particulars Amount (Rs.) Explanation
1. Contract Sum 5,74,35,213.00 Total Contract Value
2. Overheads (10%) and profits (10%) included in the above sum 1,14,87,042.00 20% of Rs.5,74,35,213.00
(1) i.e. contract value
3. Time limit for completion of the work 22 Months Though the contract was for 18 Months, Petitioner estimated that the site would have to be maintained for 22 Months i.e. 4 months over and above contract term.
4. Overheads and Profits per month [(2) divided by (3)] 5 , 2 2 , 1 3 8 . 2 7 Per month Total Overheads and Profits divided by months of work (22 Months)
5. Value of work done till R.A. Bill No.4 dated 31.08.1993 1,21,95,859.68 Contract period was up to 31.08.1993 i.e. 18 months from 22 February 1992
6. Pro-rata overheads and profits received till 31.08.1993 24,39,171.00 20% of (5). Since the Petitioner received payment of bill at (5), the overheads and profits for the work done covered by bill at (5)
have been deducted by the Arbitrator in (7).
7. Net loss suffered as on 01.09.1993 [(2) – (6)] 90,47,871.00 As above, for 22 months of work, the Petitioner was to get Rs. 1,14,87,042.00/-
(2) towards overheads and profits. However, out of this, the Petitioner received Rs. 24,39,171.00/- (6), the same has been deducted.
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 458 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Sr.
No.
Particulars Amount (Rs.) Explanation Rs.90,47,871.00/- is the outstanding receivable by the Petitioner towards overheads and profits for the contract period.
8. Delay in months 24 months Total time spent was 49 Months (Pg.56 of SLP)
(22 February 1992 to 31 March 1996).
Out of this, since 22 months were contemplated by the Petitioner for the work, th e same have bee n deducted from 49 months by the Arbitrator. (Pg.56 of SLP).
A further period of 3 months on account of Force Majeure has been deducted by the Arbitrator.
Thus 49 – 22 – 3 = 24 Mo nth s e xt ra w or k.
(Pg.56 of SLP).
9. Overheads and profit expected during the extra period [(8) * (4)] 1,25,31,318.48 This is the amount for the extra time spent i.e. 24 Months.
244 Months multiplied by per month overhead and profit.
24 * Rs.5,22,138.27 = Rs. 1,25,31,318.48 Sr.
No.
Particulars Amount (Rs.) Explanation
10. Value of work executed during the extended period upto 30.03.1996 (R.A. Bill No.37)
2,92,07,619.13 This is the amount received for the work done during extended period i.e. August 1993 to March 1996.
11. Pro-rata overheads and profits received during the extended period.
58,41,523.80 This is 20% of 2,92,07,619.13 (10).
Since the petitioner received payment of bill at (10), the overheads and profits for the work done covered by bill at (10), have been deducted by the Arbitrator in (11)
12. Net loss suffered till 27.08.1997 [(9) – (11)] 66,89,791.68 This is loss of overhead and profits for the extra period of 24 Months.
As stated in (9), overheads and profits for extra time of 24 months was Rs.1,25,31,318.48.
Since, the Petitioner received a sum of Rs.58,41,523.80 (11), the same has been deducted by the Arbitrator.
13. Total loss on overheads and profit on this count till 27.08.1997 [(7) – (12)] 1,57,37,665.68 This amount is the sum of overhead and profits due during contract period plus the overhead and profits for the extra period of 24 Months.
Awarded by the Arbitrator (Pg.56 of SLP)
BATLIBOI ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERS LTD v.
HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM CORP. LTD. [SANJIV KHANNA, J.] 460 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
19. The chart and explanations given in the chart, we believe, are an afterthought and futile finagle to work backwards to somehow justify the computation and award of damages. These explanations are ex facie irrational and eristic for the following reasons:
(i) S.No.7 computes the net loss suffered by BEEL as Rs.90,47,871/as on 01.09.1993, that is for the period of 18 months. The computation ignores and does not add the period of 4 months as mentioned by BEEL in the claim statement. Further, the arbitrator had added another period of 3 months for internal administrative process and force majeure events. Thus, the date 01.09.1993 referred to in S.No.7 is incorrect and not the basis of the computation made in the award. S.No.7 fails to taken into consideration the seven-month period, which as per the award has to be added.
(ii) The fi gure of Rs.90,47,871/- would have been relevant, in absence of work done and in fact payments post 01.09.1993.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.