Sunil v. State of NCT of Delhi
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 840; [2023] 12 S.C.R. 381
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hrishikesh Roy
- Decided
- 21 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 688/2011
- Sections
- 34, 307, 313, 302, 300, 27, 342
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 12 S.C.R. 381 : 2023 INSC 840
CASE DETAILS
SUNIL
v.
STATE OF NCT OF DELHI
(Criminal Appeal No.688 of 2011)
SEPTEMBER 21, 2023
[HRISHIKESH ROY AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issues for consideration: (i) Whether based on the evidence led, the appellants could be convicted for the offence of murder of the two deceased with the aid of s.34 IPC or only for the offence punishable u/s. 307 IPC r/w. s. 34 IPC;
(ii) Whether, on account of not putting the incriminating circumstance of exhortation to the appellants while recording their statements u/s. 313 Cr.PC, appellants’ conviction with the aid of s.34 of the IPC stood vitiated. Penal Code, 1860 – Prosecution case that there was an altercation between two families – The main accused went to his house on Street No.400, fetched his gun and fired shots at the public present on Street No.300 from roof of one of the row houses – Gunshots resulted in death of two persons and injuries to twenty-six others – Main accused (nonappellant) was convicted u/s. 302 IPC – Appellants were convicted u/s. 302 r/w. s.34 IPC and s. 307 r/w. s.34 IPC – Propriety:
Held: A close examination of the statement of the prosecution witnesses (regarding role of appellants) would reveal that, though they disclose the presence of the accused-appellants with main accused at the roof-top as also that they were instigating main accused not to spare the supporters of rival faction, they are not specific and consistent to target the said two deceased persons – There is absence of cogent evidence that main accused was instigated/exhorted to fire shots at the two deceased – The evidence, which is consistent, is about exhorting main accused not to spare 382 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
rival faction’s supporters – But there is no evidence that the two deceased were rival faction’s supporters – General exhortation is not sufficient to fasten them with vicarious liability for shots fired by the main accused at the two deceased – The main accused had taken a vow to teach supporters of the other side a lesson – In that kind of a scenario, even if main accused had not been instigated by any of the other accused, he might have fired from his weapon to stamp his authority – Therefore, killing of the two deceased could be his own individual act for which he alone would be liable – The prosecution was required to lead clear and cogent evidence that the shots fired by main accused at the two deceased were in furtherance of common intention of all – In absence whereof, it would be extremely unsafe to convict the appellants with the aid of s.34 of the IPC for the offence of murder. [Paras 26 and 31] Penal Code, 1860 – s. 307 r/w. s.34 IPC – Conviction under:
Held: Evidence is that the appellants were with the main accused, exhorting him not to spare rival faction’s supporters, and pointing at targets – Though, evidence might not be specific as to who in particular was targeted at the behest of the appellants but the very fact that indiscriminate firing continued for long, say 20-25 minutes and the appellants were found present and exhorting main accused to fire, it could be said with certainty that the appellants had knowledge that the act which the main accused was exhorted to commit was so imminently dangerous that it must, in all probability, cause death or such bodily injury as is likely to cause death of a person (Section 300 (Fourthly) of the I.P.C along with illustration (d) thereto) – Therefore, the gunshots fired by the main accused at several by-standers/supporters of rival faction, if not all, could be said to be a criminal act done by several persons in furtherance of the common intention of all – The appellants are liable to be convicted for the offence punishable u/s. 307 with the aid of s.34 of the IPC [Paras 32 and 33] Penal Code, 1860 – s. 34 – Common intention – Necessity:
Held: To fasten liability with the aid of s.34 of the IPC what must necessarily be proved is a common intention to commit the crime actually committed and each accused person can be convicted of that crime, only if it is in furtherance of common intention of all – Common intention pre-supposes a prior concert, though pre-concert in the sense of a distinct previous plan is not necessary as common intention to bring about a particular result may develop on the spot – The question whether there was any common intention or not depends upon the inference to be drawn from the proven facts and circumstances of each case – The totality of the circumstances must be taken into consideration in arriving at the conclusion whether the accused had a common intention to commit an offence with which they could be convicted. [Para 29] Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – Effect of not putting the incriminating circumstance of exhortation to the appellants while recording their statements u/s. 313 of the Cr.PC, 1973:
Held: The legal position that emerges, inter-alia, is that to enable an accused to explain the circumstances appearing in the evidence against him, all the incriminating circumstances appearing against him in the evidence must be put to him – But where there has been a failure in putting those circumstances to the accused, the same would not ipso facto vitiate the trial unless it is shown that its non-compliance has prejudiced the accused – Where there is a delay in raising the plea, or the plea is raised for the first time in this Court, it could be assumed that no prejudice had been felt by the accused – In the instant case, appellants were aware of the prosecution case against them as they were apprised of the FIR lodged by PW-2 which delineated their role as the ones who exhorted the main accused to fire gunshots – Taking the above into account as also that the appellants were throughout represented by their counsel and had cross-examined the prosecution witnesses, yet they raised no such plea, either before the trial court or the High Court, it can safely be assumed that the appellants had suffered no prejudice on that count. [Para 45]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Pandurang, Tukia and Bhillia v. State of Hyderabad AIR 1955 SC 216:[1955] SCR 1083; Balu Alias Bala Subramaniam & Another v. State (UT of Pondicherry) (2016) 15 SCC 471:[2015] 11 SCR 708; Mewa Ram & Another v. State of Rajasthan (2017) 11 SCC 272; Tara Singh v. State AIR 1951 SC 441:1951 SCC Online SC 49:[1951] SCR 729; Alister Anthony SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI 384 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Pareira v. State of Maharashtra (2012) 2 SCC 648:[2012] 1 SCR 145;Nar Singh v. State of Haryana (2015) 1 SCC 496:[2014] 12 SCR 218; Shobhit Chamar & Another v. State of Bihar (1998) 3 SCC 455:[1998] 2 SCR 117;Satyavir Singh Rathi, ACP & Others v. State (2011) 6 SCC 1:[2011] 6 SCR 138 – relied on.
Kulwant Singh alias Kulbansh Singh v. State of Bihar (2007) 15 SCC 670:[2007] 7 SCR 1178; Jainul Haque v. State of Bihar (1974) 3 SCC 543; Hardev Singh & Another v. The State of Punjab (1975) 3 SCC 731; Mohan Singh & Another v. State of M.P. (1999) 2 SCC 428:[1999] 1 SCR 276; Zahoor & Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2011) 15 SCC 218:[2011] 5 SCR 881; Bishnupada Sarkar & Another v. State of West Bengal (2012) 11 SCC 597:[2012] 6 SCR 230; Hate Singh v. State of Madhya Bharat AIR 1953 SC 468; Sujeet Biswas v. State of Assam (2013) 12 SCC 406:[2013] 3 SCR 830; Sharad Birdichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra (1984) 4 SCC 116:[1985] 1 SCR 88; Samsul Haque v. State of Assam (2019) 18 SCC 161; Maheshwar Tigga v. State of Rajasthan (2020) 10 SCC 108:[2020] 9 SCR 482; Gulab v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2022) 12 SCC 677; Sandeep v. State of Haryana 2021 SCC Online SC 642 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.688 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 28.07.2009 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLA No.962 of 2004.
With Criminal Appeal Nos.689 And 785 of 2011.
Appearances:
Sudarshan Rajan, Mahesh Kumar, Hitain Bajaj, Rohit Bhardwaj, Ramesh Rawat, Lakshay Laroiya, Vijay Kumar Sharma, Md. Qamar Ali, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jayant K. Sud, A.S.G., Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, Mukul Singh, Rajesh Singh Chauhan, P. V. Yogeswaran, Rajan Kr Chourasia, Dr. N. Visakamurthy, Kartik Jasra, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. These three appeals are against the judgment and order of the High Court of Delhi (in short “the High Court”) dated 28.07.2009 passed in Criminal Appeal Nos. 962 of 2004; 977 of 2004; 981 of 2004; 14 of 2005; and 61 of 2005, by which Criminal Appeal Nos. 962 of 2004; 977 of 2004; 981 of 2004; and 61 of 2005, preferred by Sunil (appellant in Criminal Appeal No.688 of 2011), Shri Krishna (appellant in Criminal Appeal No.785 of 2011), Ravinder (appellant in Criminal Appeal No.689 of 2011) and Babu Ram @ Fauji (co-accused), respectively, were dismissed whereas Criminal Appeal No.14 of 2005 of co-accused Vijay was allowed. The net result of the impugned judgment and order is that the order of the trial court (i.e., Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Delhi), dated 08.11.2004, in Sessions Trial No.42 of 1999, arising out of FIR No.561 of 1998, P.S. Jahangir Puri, convicting and sentencing Babu Ram @ Fauji, Sunil, Shri Krishan and Ravinder under Sections 302/307/34 of the Indian Penal Code (in short, “the I.P.C.”) has been affirmed whereas conviction of co-accused Vijay has been set aside. It be noted that Babu Ram @ Fauji was also sentenced under Section 27 of the Arms Act, which has also been affirmed by the High Court. The sentence awarded to the appellants, namely, Sunil, Shri Krishan and Ravinder, which is impugned in these appeals, is as under:
(i) Imprisonment for life with fine of Rs. 2000/-, coupled with a default sentence of six months R.I., under Section 302/34 I.P.C.; and
(ii) Five years R.I. with fine of Rs. 1000/-, coupled with a default sentence of three months, under Section 307/34 I.P.C.
Introductory Facts
2. This is a case where, on account of indiscriminate firing by Babu Ram @ Fauji (non-appellant) from his licensed single barrel gun, two persons, namely, Anil Kumar and Vijay, suffered gun-shot injuries and SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI 386 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
died; and 26 others received pellet injuries, some of them being grievous in nature.
3. Babu Ram, who fired the gun shots from his licensed gun, handed over his gun to the police along with 16 used and 4 live cartridges while setting up a plea of self-defence. The appellants before us and Vijay (who has been acquitted by the High Court) were roped in with the aid of Section 34 of the I.P.C. as persons who exhorted Babu Ram to fire gunshots.
4. According to the prosecution case, on 11.11.1998, there was tension in the locality as boys from the accused side had teased daughter of Lala Satpal. Giving vent to that tension, at about 3.00 pm, an altercation took place between Satpal and Shri Krishan whose son Sunil was present. Anil Kumar (one of the two deceased) i.e., brother of Mangat Ram (PW-2) took side of Satpal. Babu Ram (non-appellant) and his son Ravinder joined the altercation taking side of Shri Krishan. Thereafter, Shri Krishan, his son Sunil, Babu Ram and Babu Ram’s son Ravinder left the place while extending threats that they would teach Satpal and his supporters a lesson. Soon thereafter, Babu Ram, Shri Krishan, Ravinder and Sunil appeared on the roof of PW-2’s house and from there, on the instigation of Shri Krishan, Sunil and Ravinder, Babu Ram fired shots at the supporters of Satpal resulting in death of two persons and injuries to as many as 26 persons.
5. As, according to the prosecution, genesis of the incident was a dispute between two families on account of young male members of one family (i.e., of Sri Krishan) teasing female members of the other (i.e., family of Satpal), the relationship of accused persons inter se assumes importance, which is as below:
(i) Shri Krishan is the husband of Babu Ram’s sister;
(ii) Sunil is son of Shri Krishan;
(iii) Ravinder is son of Babu Ram; and
(iv) Vijay (already acquitted) is a distant relative of Shri Krishan.
6. To prove its case, the prosecution examined 56 witnesses. On the other hand, the appellants including Babu Ram examined 15 defence witnesses. As Babu Ram took the plea of self-defence, the trial court as well as the High Court examined his defence plea in detail. The defence plea taken by Babu Ram was that a mob had surrounded his house and threatened to torch it. Therefore, to disburse the mob, shots were fired. This defence was carefully examined by the trial court as well as the High Court with reference to the site plan and the evidence led. After examining the same, it was found that persons who died including those who received injuries were on Street No. 300 whereas the house of Babu Ram had no opening on Street No. 300. Rather, its opening was on Street No. 400. The High Court noticed that even the back wall of the house of Babu Ram did not abut Street No. 300 where the incident occurred. Not only that, the evidence brought on record established that gunshots were fired from the roof-top of Mangat Ram’s house (i.e. House No.354) upon persons who were standing or moving on Street No.300. In this scenario, the defence plea was found unacceptable and was therefore discarded by the trial court as well the High Court. Detailed reasons in that regard can be found in paragraphs 45 to 57 of High Court’s judgment, extracted below:
“45. In our opinion there is hardly much scope for raising a dispute pertaining to the defence of Babu Ram of having acted in self-defence. The defence is a sham.
46. The site plan, Ex.PW-56/A, prepared by Inspector Sajan Singh and the site plan to scale Ex.PVJ-7/A prepared by Tirath Raj Singh PW-7, to which we have made a detailed reference in para 11 above, show that deceased Vijay and Anil were shot dead at street No.300. Mangat Ram PW-2 also was shot at in street No.300. PW-8, PW-9, PW-13, PW-14, PW-15 and PW-27 have categorically stated that they received the gunshot injuries when they were in street No.300. These witnesses may be related to the two young boys who were shot dead as also to Mangat Ram, the complainant, but said fact alone would not render suspect their testimonies. The said six witnesses are all residents of block-D and have their houses on gali No.300 and thus their presence at the spot is natural. That all of them received gunshot wounds itself establishes their presence at the spot. A related witness is not an interested witness on account of being the relation of the complainant. An interested witness is one who has a motive to secure the false conviction of the accused and to achieve the same deposes falsely. As held in the decision reported as State of Rajasthan v. Smt Kalki & Anr (1981) 2 SCC 752:- SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 388 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
“As mentioned above, the High Court has declined to rely on the evidence of P.W.I on two grounds: (1) she was a “highly interested” witness because she “is the wife of the deceased”, and
(2) there were discrepancies in her evidence. With respect, in our opinion, both the grounds are invalid. For, in the circumstances of the case, she was the only and most natural witness; she was the only person present in the hut with the deceased at the time of the occurrence, and the only person who saw the occurrence. True, it is she is the wife of the deceased; but she cannot be called an ‘interested’ witness. She is related to the deceased. ‘Related’ is not equivalent to ‘interested’. A witness may be called ‘interested’ only when he or she derives some benefit from the result of a litigation; in the decree in a civil case, or in seeing an accused person punished. A witness who is a natural one and is the only possible eye witness in the circumstances of a case cannot be said to be ‘interested’. In the instant case P.W. 1 had no interest in protecting the real culprit, and falsely implicating the respondents.”
47. Besides, the other prosecution witnesses namely PW-17, PW-23, PW-29, PW-30, PW-33, PW-34, PW-35, PW-36, PW-37, PW-38, PW-39, PW-40, PW-41. PW-42, PW-43, PW-44 · and PW-46 are not related to the deceased or Mangat Ram. Said witnesses have deposed that they received gunshot wounds on 11.11.1998 at around 3/3:30 PM. Out of said 17 witnesses, PW-23, PW-29, PW-33, PW-37, PW- 38, PW-39, PW-40, PW-41, PW-42, PW-43, PW-44 and PW-46 have categorically deposed that they were present at Gali No.300 when they received the gunshot wounds. The other witnesses have not stated as to where they were standing when they received the gunshot wounds. PW-23, PW-29, PW-33, PW-37, PW-38, PW-39, PW-40, PW-41, PW-42, PW-43, PW-44 and PW-46 are not related to each other or to the deceased or to any other witness of the prosecution, They would have no motive to falsely depose. The testimony of said witnesses establishes that the firing was directed towards people who were on street No.300. The house of Babu Ram is abutting street No.400, which as noted in para 11 above, runs parallel to street No.300 and the two streets are separated by a row of houses constructed back to back. In no way can an unruly crowd which has assembled on street No.300 set on fire any house which is on street No.400. Further, the falsity in the testimony of the defence witnesses who claim that Babu Ram, acting in defence of his house and himself and his family members, fired from the roof of his house is apparent from the fact that standing on the roof of house No.366 which is the house of Babu Ram, it is just not possible to hit anybody standing on street No.300. A little bit of geometry would show the same. Standing on any point at the roof of the house of Babu Ram, the straight line connecting the said spot from any portion of his roof to any spot on street No.300 would pass through the roof· and the walls of house No. D-355, D-356 and D-357 abutting street No.300 on its northern boundary.
48. Besides, there is no evidence of any kerosene oil or petrol being detected outside the house of Babu Ram. This also falsifies the defence version that the riotous mob was threatening to burn down the house of Babu Ram.
49. No doubt, FIR Ex.PW-19/D-3 has indeed been registered at 9:10 PM which evidences rioting in D-Block, Jahangir Puri, but therefrom it does not stand proved that the defence version is correct. It is also true that photographs of the house of Babu Ram show that the door of his house has been broken and brick bats have been thrown towards his house.
50. What has happened is evident. After Babu Ram fired indiscriminately and shot dead two persons on the street and injured 26 more on the street i.e. street No.300, it was apparent that the crowd retaliated. The site plan Ex.PW-7/A shows that the houses on the streets of D-Block Jahangir Puri have a front of 10’ and a depth of 23’.10”. Jahangir Puri is a resettlement colony where slum dwellers have been relocated. Tiny plots ad measuring 10’ x 23’.10” have been allotted to the rehabilitated slum dwellers by the government. The population density in the colony is extremely heavy. Huge crowds can gather in densely populated areas within seconds. It is apparent that the angry crowd sought vengeance against Babu Ram after Babu Ram had created mayhem in the area. That 16 rounds were fired by Babu Ram is not disputed by him. By no stretch of imagination can firing of 16 rounds be belittled. If a man SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 390 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
fires 16 rounds on a crowd causing death of 2 and injuring 26 others, the crowd is bound to retaliate.
51. From the evidence of the witnesses of the prosecution it is apparent that some quarrel regarding eve teasing had taken place on street No.300 involving the families of Satpal and accused Shri Kishan who is the brother-in-law of Babu Ram. Even the defence witnesses have spoken of an ‘eve-teasing incident. The difference is, as per the defence witnesses the victim of the eve teasing incident was Seema, the daughter of Shri Kishan and as per the prosecution witnesses the aggressors were the family members of Shri Kishan. There is commonality in the testimony of both sets of witnesses that Babu Ram left street No.300 taking along with him his sister Sushila and Seema. The difference in the two versions is regarding the presence of the co-accused. As per the witnesses of the prosecution, some of them have spoken of all co-accused being present at street No.300, with some excluding the presence of co-accused Vijay. It is thus apparent that whatever be the cause of the spat on the public street, Babu Ram retrieved himself safely from the street and reached his house.
52. We have already discounted the defence version, in view of evidence on record, of the crowd following Babu Ram and surrounding his house. We have already held that the evidence establishes indiscriminate firing by Babu Ram on the persons in street No.300 and the fact that his house abuts street No.400 evidences that the firing was not to scare the crowd which had surrounded the house of Babu Ram. We have already held that for anyone to be standing on street No.300 it is just not possible to set on fire any house on street No.400. We have already held that by standing on any spot on the roof of Babu Ram’s house it was just not possible to shoot any person on street No.300.
53. The inevitable conclusion is, that as claimed by the witnesses of the prosecution, Babu Ram jumped from the roof of his house on to the roof of House No.D-354 of Mangat Ram and standing at the roof of Mangat Ram’s house at the spot marked ‘4’ on the site plan Ex.PW-7/A, indiscriminately fired 16 shots, all directed downwards on the persons in street No.300, with specific targets being Mangat Ram and his family members against whom Babu Ram had a grievance of being the sympathizers of Lala Satpal.
54. Besides, the right of self-defence is a self-limiting right and authorizes the person acting in self-defence to use only such force which is reasonable and commensurate with the danger to body or to property. No doubt, defence of a dwelling house stands on a different footing and law has always looked with special indulgence on a man who is defending his dwelling against those who try to unlawfully evict him, for: the house of everyone is to him as his castle and fortress.
55. The indiscriminate firing by Babu Ram cannot be justified under any circumstances.
56. The testimony of the witnesses of the prosecution and the defence, though with a difference qua the origin of a spat on the public street, establishes a public spat on a public street involving the families of Sri Krishan and Lala Satpal. The evidence, as held above, establishes that Babu Ram fired from the roof of the house of Mangat Ram and targeted people on street No.300 where the spat between the family members of Shri Krishan and Lala Satpal took place. It is apparent that Babu Ram was led into firing because he learnt of the quarrel going on in street No.300. It is obvious that Babu Ram had come to aid of his sister and his brother-in-law. It is obvious that Babu Ram has acted with vengeance and not to protect himself or his house. It is not the case of Babu Ram that his sister’s house or the family members of his sister who were on street No.300 were in danger and he did the firing to protect them.
57. Looked from any angle whatsoever, Babu Ram cannot escape the consequence of his acts.”
7. As far as co-accused Vijay is concerned, the High Court allowed his appeal by giving him the benefit of doubt as only one witness had alleged about his participation.
8. In respect of the appellants Sunil, Shri Krishan and Ravinder, the High Court observed that Mangat Ram (PW-2), Ashok Kumar (PW-8), Kashmere Lal (PW-9), Darshana (PW-13), Raj Kumar (PW-14) and Sushil SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 392 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Kumar (PW-15), who were all injured in the firing, have categorically deposed that those accused were present with Babu Ram at the time of altercation and they all left simultaneously with Babu Ram and were noticed at the roof top exhorting Babu Ram to fire. The High Court observed that though there had been minor variations in the testimony of witnesses as to which accused did what, but such minor variations were natural as memory fades with passage of time and it is difficult for anyone to remember each and every minute aspect of the incident. Consequently, by relying on their testimony, all appeals were dismissed.
9. We have heard Sri Sudarshan Rajan, learned counsel for the appellants and Shri Jayant K. Sud, learned Additional Solicitor General, for the State (NCT of Delhi).
Submissions on behalf of appellants
10. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that it is a case where the principal accused, namely, Babu Ram, had admitted that he opened fire at the mob from his licensed weapon. Once such is the position, the court was required to carefully consider whether the appellants, who were part of the family, were implicated due to general animosity, by assigning role of exhortation to them. Further, as per prosecution case, gunshots were fired from the roof-top at people who were on the street. It would thus be difficult for the witnesses present on the street to gauge as to who was exhorting and who was not, particularly, when there were more than three persons at the roof-top. Moreover, it is well settled that mere presence with the assailant is not enough to assume that all of them share common intention with the principal accused and that the criminal act has been done in furtherance of the common intention of all. Otherwise also, the prosecution evidence is not clear whether the gunshots fired at the two deceased i.e., Anil and Vijay were in furtherance of the common intention of all the accused. Therefore, even if it is assumed that at some stage the appellants had exhorted Babu Ram to fire shots, in absence of clear and cogent evidence that Babu Ram was instigated/exhorted to fire shots at the two deceased, the appellants cannot be convicted for the offence punishable under Section 302 with the aid of Section 34 of the IPC. Thus, in a worst-case scenario, the appellants can only be convicted under Section 307/34 of the I.P.C. It was argued that since each of the three appellants have already served more than five years of sentence, which they were awarded for offence punishable under Section 307/34 of the I.P.C., their appeals be allowed and their sentence be reduced to the period of sentence already undergone for the offence punishable under Section 307/34 of the I.P.C.
11. In addition to above, the learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the trial of the appellants suffers from a fundamental defect inasmuch as the incriminating circumstance about the appellants exhorting/ instigating Babu Ram to fire shots at the two deceased/public/injured, was never put to the appellants while recording their statements under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short, “the Cr.P.C.”). Hence, the incriminating circumstance appearing in the evidence qua exhortation/ instigation of the main accused by the appellants would have to be eschewed from consideration.
12. The learned counsel for the appellants cited number of decisions on two broad propositions, namely, (A) As to when, based on the role of exhortation, conviction can be sustained with the aid of Section 34 of the I.P.C. The decisions cited were:
(i) Balu Alias Bala Subramaniam & Another v. State (UT of Pondicherry)1;
(ii) Kulwant Singh alias Kulbansh Singh v. State of Bihar2,
(iii) Jainul Haque v. State of Bihar3;
(iv) Hardev Singh & Another v. The State of Punjab4;
(v) Mewa Ram & Another v. State of Rajasthan5;
(vi) Mohan Singh & Another v. State of M.P.6;
1 (2016) 15 SCC 471
2 (2007) 15 SCC 670
3 (1974) 3 SCC 543
4 (1975) 3 SCC 731
5 (2017) 11 SCC 272
6 (1999) 2 SCC 428
SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 394 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
(vii) Zahoor & Others v. State of Uttar Pradesh7;
(viii) Bishnupada Sarkar & Another v. State of West Bengal8. (B) Incriminating circumstances not put to the accused while recording his statement under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. must be eschewed from consideration. The decisions cited were:
(i) Hate Singh v. State of Madhya Bharat9;
(ii) Sujeet Biswas v. State of Assam10;
(iii) Sharad Birdichand Sharda v. State of Maharashtra11;
(iv) Samsul Haque v. State of Assam12; and
(v) Maheshwar Tigga v. State of Rajasthan13.
Submissions on behalf of the State
13. On behalf of the State (NCT of Delhi) it was submitted that, as per the evidence, after the altercation, Babu Ram left the place with the appellants while extending threats that they shall teach a lesson to the other side and their supporters. Soon thereafter, they all appeared at the roof top and the appellants were noticed exhorting Babu Ram to attack the other side and their supporters. Gunshots were fired in furtherance thereof, causing death of two persons and injuries to 26 others. In such circumstances, all the accused exhibited common intention to cause such bodily injury to persons which they knew it is likely to cause death of the person to whom it is caused. Further, multiple gunshots were fired. Therefore, it is a clear case that the appellants who exhorted the assailant had shared common intention with him.
14. Regarding the incriminating circumstance of exhortation being not put to the accused appellants while recording their statements under
7 (2011) 15 SCC 218
8 (2012) 11 SCC 597
9 AIR 1953 SC 468
10 (2013) 12 SCC 406
11 (1984) 4 SCC 116
12 (2019) 18 SCC 161
13 (2020) 10 SCC 108
Section 313 CrPC, it was submitted that even if it was not put to them, they suffered no prejudice, which is clear from the following circumstances: (a) the appellants were throughout represented by their counsel; (b) the statement of witnesses was recorded in presence of the appellants/their counsel;
(c) their counsel specifically cross-examined the witnesses in respect of their statement qua exhortation by the appellants; and (d) the FIR of the incident, which disclosed their role as that of an instigator, was put to them. It could, therefore, be taken that they were fully aware of the incriminating circumstances appearing against them in the prosecution evidence. Yet, they took no plea before the trial court or the High Court of any kind of prejudice caused to them. Thus, this plea, raised for the first time before this Court, ought not be entertained.
15. In support of his submissions, the learned counsel for the State cited decisions on two broad propositions, namely,
(a) Conviction with the aid of Section 34 of the I.P.C can be recorded for the role of exhortation. The decisions cited were:
(i) Gulab v. State of Uttar Pradesh14; and
(ii) Sandeep v. State of Haryana15
(b) Unless prejudice is shown to have been caused to the accused, failure to put any incriminating circumstance, by itself, would not vitiate the trial. The decisions cited were:
(i) Nar Singh v. State of Haryana16;
(ii) Alister Anthony Pareira v. State of Maharashtra17; and
(iii) Satyavir Singh Rathi, ACP & Others v. State18.
Discussion and Analysis
16. We have considered the rival submissions and have perused the record carefully. Before we deal with the submissions, it would be useful
14 (2022) 12 SCC 677
15 2021 SCC Online SC 642
16 (2015) 1 SCC 496
17 (2012) 2 SCC 648
18 (2011) 6 SCC 1
SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 396 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
to recapitulate facts which have been found proved, and regarding which there is no serious dispute, namely,
(a) The incident had its genesis in an altercation between two families i.e, Sri Krishan’s family on one side and Satpal’s family on the other. The reason for the altercation was one family accusing the other of their girls being teased by other family’s boys.
(b) All gunshots which caused injuries to the two deceased as well as to twenty-six others, were fired by Babu Ram (non-appellant) who has been convicted and sentenced under Section 302 of the I.P.C.
(c) The gun which Babu Ram used to fire shots was licensed to him.
(d) Babu Ram was present at the time when altercation between the two sides took place.
(e) Babu Ram is brother-in-law of Shri Krishan.
(f) Babu Ram’s house opens on Street No. 400 whereas Satpal’s house opens on Street No.300. Though exact location of Shri Krishan’s house is not disclosed in the site plan prepared in connection with the case, however, from his address, which is disclosed as D-291, Jahangir Puri, Delhi, it appears that his house is near Satpal’s house (which is D-294), and on same Street No.300.
17. The place where the incident took place is a congested colony. The location of the two Streets i.e., Nos. 300 and 400 and the houses in between them has been described in detail in paragraph 11 of the High Court’s judgment, the correctness of which has not been seriously challenged. Thus, to have a clear picture of the spot, we deem it appropriate to extract paragraph 11 of the impugned judgment below:
“11. As per the two site plans, street No.400 and street No.300 in D Block Jahangir Puri, run parallel to each other along the west-eastern directions. Street No.400 is towards the north and street No.300 is towards the south. The width of street No.400 is 16‟.6”. The width of street No.300 is 15‟.10”. The distance between the two streets is 47‟.8”. This distance between the two streets is not an empty space but consists of a row of houses having a depth of 23‟.10”. To make it clear, one row of houses being House No.361 to 368 have a depth of 23‟.10” and these houses abut street No.400. Back to back to these houses are a row of houses bearing No.353 to 359 with each house having a depth of 23‟.10”. These houses open towards street No.300. Opposite to the row of houses bearing No.353 to 359 on street No.300 are house Nos.298 to 293. It is apparent that the doors of house No.353 to 359 open in the southern direction on to street No.300 and the doors of house Nos.298 to 293 open towards the northern direction on to street No.300. On the site plan, the spots where Anil and Vijay were shot at have been marked 1 and 2. They are at a distance of 3‟.6” and 3‟ respectively from the boundary wall of house No.295 and house No.294. Spot where Mangat Ram was shot at is shown at point No.3 which is also at a distance of about 3‟ from the boundary wall of house No.297. The spot wherefrom Babu Ram is stated to have fired is shown as spot No.4 and is on the roof of house No.354 belonging to Mangat Ram. The site plan shows that house No.366 of Babu Ram is back to back with house No.355 of Ramesh Chand and house No.354 of Mangat Ram is adjacent to the house of Ramesh Chand towards the west of house of Ramesh Chand. … ”.
18. From the observations of the High Court extracted above, what transpires is that in between Street Nos.300 and 400 there are two rows of houses, back to back. One row of houses have their opening towards north on Street No.400, whereas the other have their opening towards south on Street No.300. The third row of houses, south of Street No. 300, have their opening towards north on Street No.300. Satpal’s house is in that row, whereas Babu Ram’s house is towards north, opening on Street No.400.
19. As per the evidence, altercation preceding the incident of firing took place on Street No.300. After the altercation, Babu Ram left that place, went to his house on Street No.400, fetched his gun and fired shots at the public present on Street No.300 from roof of one of the row houses, which, according to the prosecution, is house of Mangat Ram. A close scrutiny of the site plan would suggest that the place where gunshot injuries were suffered could not have been targeted if gunshots had been fired from the roof top of Babu Ram’s house. Therefore, both the courts below disbelieved SUNIL v. STATE OF NCT OF DELHI [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 398 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.
Babu Ram’s plea that he fired gunshots in self-defence to disburse the crowd which had surrounded his house.
Role of the Appellants
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.