Harilal Etc. v. State of Madhya Pradesh (Now Chhattisgarh)
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 801; [2023] 12 S.C.R. 138
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice However, Justice Neither of Them Lodged the Fir, Justice Rather, Justice A Named Fir Lodged Next Day By the Village Chowkidar of Neighbouring Village, Justice Even Though She Was Not An Eye Witness –
- Decided
- 5 Sept 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2216/2011
- Sections
- 302, 161, 300, 304
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
CASE DETAILS
HARILAL ETC.
v.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH (NOW CHHATTISGARH)
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 2216-2217 of 2011)
SEPTEMBER 05, 2023
[J. B. PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the High Court was justified in upholding the order of the Sessions Judge convicting and sentencing the appellants to imprisonment for life u/s 302 IPC.
Penal Code, 1860 – s. 302 – Murder – Conviction of the accused u/s. 302 and sentenced to imprisonment for life by the courts below – Ocular account of two prosecution witness that the assault on the deceased took place at night, however, neither of them lodged the FIR, rather, a named FIR lodged next day by the village chowkidar of neighbouring village, even though she was not an eye witness – Correctness:
Held: Trial court as well as the High Court while appreciating the evidence did not properly address various aspects – Neither the trial court nor the High Court carefully considered the deposition of the village chowkidar who lodged a named FIR – Two eye witness were chance witness – Testimony of one inconsistent with his previous statement – His statement inconclusive as regards the assault being cause of death, thus cannot be relied upon to convict the accused for offence of murder – Testimony of the other one not such that it may on its own form the basis of conviction of the accused for the offence of murder – More so, it leaves many gaps in the prosecution story – Furthermore, the seizure of lathi and clothes from the accused cannot be considered as a clinching circumstance warranting conviction – In view thereof, prosecution not able to convincingly prove the genesis of the crime as also the manner in which the murder took place and by whom, inasmuch as the evidence led by the prosecution gives rise to a strong probability of the killing being a consequence of mob action on [2023] 12 S.C.R. 138 : 2023 INSC 801 the deceased for his alleged involvement with a lady of the village – Thus, taking into account the various circumstances, the accused entitled to benefit of doubt – Judgment and order of the courts below set aside. [Paras 14, 16, 18 and 19-26] Delay/laches – FIR – Delay in lodging FIR – Absence of proper explanation – Duty of the court:
Held: Courts must be on guard and test the evidence meticulously to rule out possibility of embellishments in the prosecution story – Delay gives opportunity for deliberation and guess work especially when there is high probability of no one witnessed the incident at night in an open place or a public street. [Para 19]
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
2216-2217 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 17.02.2010 of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur in CRLA Nos.864 and 865 of 1991 Appearances:
D. N. Goburdhun, Sr. Adv., Aakarsh Kamra, Ms. Gauri Goburdhun, Advs. for the Appellants.
Mrs. Prachi Mishra, AAG, Mahesh Kumar, Amanpreet Singh Rahi, Nikhilesh Kumar, Ms. Devika Khanna, Mrs. V D Khanna, M/s. Vmz Chambers, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. These two appeals are directed against a common judgment and order of the High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur (in short, “the High Court”), dated 17.02.2010, passed in Criminal Appeal Nos. 864 and 865 of 1991, whereby the appeals of Harilal and Parasram @ Rangnath (the appellants herein) were dismissed and the order of the third Additional HARILAL ETC. v. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
(NOW CHHATTISGARH)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.140 Sessions Judge, Bilaspur, dated 13.07.1991, passed in S.T. No.153 of 1990, convicting and sentencing the appellants to imprisonment for life under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short, “I.P.C.”) was affirmed. Introductory Facts
2. Three accused, namely, Anshram, Parasram alias Rangnath and Harilal, were tried for committing murder of Ellahabadiya alias Vijay (the deceased) on 25.08.1989 at about 8.00 pm. Based on information received, a first information report (Ex.P-7) (in short, “the FIR”) naming the aforesaid three accused was lodged by Smt. Jugmatibai (PW-9) at P.S. Hirri, District Bilaspur (M.P.) on the next day of the incident i.e. on 26.08.1989 at about 10 am. On 26.08.1989 itself, the inquest was conducted and the police collected blood-stained earth/plain earth from the spot and also seized a lathi, which was lying near the body of deceased. On the same day, the police showed discovery of lathi, Baniyan, Lungi (loin-cloth) at the instance Anshram from his house. Similarly, discovery of lathi and clothes at the instance of Parasram was disclosed from his house. The third accused, namely, Harilal, was arrested on 27.08.1989 and on the same day, a lathi and clothes were allegedly discovered at his instance from his house. The dead body of the deceased was sent for autopsy, which was conducted by Dr. S. K. Dutta (PW- 8) on 27.08.1989 at 12.30 pm. PW-8 noticed that rigor mortis was present in lower limbs; decomposition had started; the eyes were forced out of the sockets; tongue was protruding between the teeth; lips were swollen and everted; abdomen was distended; penis and scrotum were swollen; multiple skin blisters containing reddish fluid on the face and front of the trunk were seen and faecal matter had escaped. PW-8 observations in respect of the cadaver were as follows: - Ante-mortem External Injuries: -
(i) Lacerated wound 3.5cm x 2.5cm x 0.5cm on left temporal region;
(ii) Lacerated wound 2.5cm x 1 cm dividing the centre of the pinna of the left ear. Both the injuries were black and were surrounded by black clotted blood.
(iii) Three contusions on one third upper portion of the left thigh in the side portion:
25cm x 1 cm;
12 cm x 1 cm; and 7cm x 1cm.
Colour of which had blackened Internal Examination: - Brain - Extradural haemorrhage on the left temporal region in the form of localised clot which had compressed and flattened the underlying brain. Chest - Fractures on 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th and 8th ribs on both sides. Lungs - Contusion of both lungs on the anterior surface. Pleural cavity contained black clotted blood.
Heart - Both the chambers of heart were empty.
Cause of death - Shock due to injuries in the brain and lungs. Duration: Time since death is 24 to 48 hours.
3. The prosecution examined as many as 15 witnesses. They were broadly categorized by the trial court into three categories: - (i) eye-witnesses of the incident; (ii) witnesses who reached the spot on getting information about the incident; and (iii) witnesses who proved proceedings relating to investigation, medical examination, inquest, seizure memos, preparation of site plan, etc.
4. The first category of witnesses were: PW-1 (Kanhaiya Lal); PW-2 (Sitaram); PW-3 (Mohanlal); and PW-6 (Ganesh). Another witness, namely, PW-4 (Ramanand), who was set up as a person who arrived at the spot on receipt of information of the incident, during his deposition, portrayed himself as an eye-witness of the incident.
5. Amongst the aforesaid category of witnesses, PW-1 was declared hostile. When he was confronted with his previous statement recorded under section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short, “the Code”) he stated that the police had forcibly taken his statement though he had not witnessed the incident. Consequently, the trial court found his testimony of no benefit to the prosecution. PW-3 was discarded by the trial court as unreliable because he was found inconsistent with his statement made during HARILAL ETC. v. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH (NOW CHHATTISGARH) [MANOJ MISRA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.142 the course of investigation. PW-4, who for the first time during examination in Court professed himself to be an eye-witness, was also found not reliable as he too was inconsistent with his previous statement recorded during the course of investigation. Thus, only two eyewitnesses of the incident, namely, PW-2 and PW-6, were discussed in some detail by the trial court.
6. The trial court noticed that though PW-2 (Sitaram) supported the prosecution case as against accused Harilal but he did not name the other two accused, namely, Anshram and Parasram. However, PW-6 who inculpated all the three accused was found wholly reliable by the trial court. Therefore, by placing reliance on his testimony, the trial court convicted all the three accused. While doing so, the trial court found the testimony of PW-6 duly corroborated by medical evidence as also by the circumstance of discovery of blood-stained lathi and clothes at the instance of the accused.
7. Aggrieved by their conviction, three separate appeals were filed by each of the three accused. Criminal Appeal No. 866 of 1991, which was preferred by Anshram, stood abated consequent to his death during pendency of the appeal. Whereas, the other two appeals, namely, Criminal Appeal Nos. 864 of 1991 and 865 of 1991, filed by the present set of appellants were dismissed by the High Court by the impugned judgment and order.
8. We have heard Shri D.N. Goburdhun, learned senior counsel, for the appellants; and Ms. Prachi Mishra, Additional Advocate General, for the State of Chhattisgarh.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS
9. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the incident is of late evening/night whereas the FIR was lodged next day at 10 am, which is suggestive of the fact that no one witnessed the incident and FIR was lodged after deliberation and the prosecution story developed thereafter; otherwise also, testimony of PW-2 and PW-6 is unreliable for the following reasons:
(i) PW-2 is a resident of village Khapri, whereas the incident occurred in village Kohroda. According to PW-2, he had visited Kohroda in the evening to watch television. There he witnessed the incident. After which, he left the village and in the evening itself he informed Smt. Jugmatibai (PW-9), a Kotwarin (village chowkidar) of village about the incident. However, PW-9 stated that she was not informed by any person who might have witnessed the incident. This, according to the appellants’ counsel, seriously dents the credibility of PW-2. That apart, PW-2 only disclosed the name of Harilal. Further, PW-2 does not state that the deceased was assaulted to such an extent that he would have expired, or had expired, on account of injuries sustained by him.
(ii) PW-6 is not consistent with his previous statement made during the course of investigation, inasmuch as during investigation he disclosed that the accused assaulted the deceased with sticks (danda) but in his deposition in Court he stated that the accused had assaulted the deceased with lathi. A lathi is much thicker and heavier than a danda. That apart, PW-6 was not consistent in respect of the reason as to why he came out of his house to witness the incident. In his deposition in Court he had stated that,- he was in his house at the time of the incident; he came out on alarm raised by mother of accused Parasram that Ellahabadiya alias Vijay (i.e., the deceased) was beating her son Parasram, which was inconsistent with his previous statement made during investigation wherein he had stated that he came out on hearing loud noises of a fight in the Gali (alley). Moreover, PW-6 disclosed that the incident occurred in front of the house of Anshram whereas the body of the deceased was found near a temple which was at a considerable distance from the house of Anshram. Otherwise also, PW-6 made no effort to lodge a report, or inform persons of the village. This conduct of his does not inspire confidence in his testimony.
10. In the alternative, it was submitted that from the testimony of prosecution witnesses it appears to be a case where there was a street fight. The cause and motive for such street fight is not clear except that there existed some dispute with regard to a lady. Therefore, considering the nature of the weapons used, it would be a case falling under one of the Exceptions of Section 300 I.P.C. Hence conviction under Section 304 Part-I I.P.C. would serve the ends of justice and their sentences might be reduced to the period of sentence already undergone as both the surviving accused HARILAL ETC. v. STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH (NOW CHHATTISGARH) [MANOJ MISRA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 12 S.C.R.144 (appellants herein) have served over 10 years of sentence during the course of the trial / appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.