Irfan @ Naka v. The State of Uttar Pradesh
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 758; [2023] 11 S.C.R. 789
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice 436 and 326-A, Justice Ipc and Sentenced to Death, Justice All of Whom, Justice As Per the Prosecution
- Decided
- 23 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 825/2022
- Sections
- 8, 302, 436, 326, 366, 313, 161, 32, 32(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
CASE DETAILS
IRFAN @ NAKA v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH
(Criminal Appeal Nos. 825-826 of 2022)
AUGUST 23, 2023
[B.R. GAVAI, J.B. PARDIWALA AND PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Whether the prosecution could be said to have proved its case beyond reasonable doubt against the appellant who was convicted for offence punishable u/ss.302, 436 and 326-A, IPC and sentenced to death, for allegedly setting his son and his real brothers on fire, solely on the basis of dying declarations.
Evidence – Dying declarations – Sole basis of conviction – When not justified – Appellant had strained relationship with his son (victimdeceased) from his first marriage and his two brothers (victimsdeceased), all of whom, as per the prosecution, were opposed to his second marriage – He is said to have locked the door of the room from outside in which the victims were sleeping, poured kerosene in the room and set it on fire – Dying declarations of two of the deceased persons relied upon – Legality:
Held: Courts are first required to satisfy themselves that the dying declaration in question is reliable and truthful before placing any reliance upon it – Dying declaration while carrying a presumption of being true must be wholly reliable and inspire confidence – Where there is any suspicion over the veracity of the same or the evidence on record shows that the dying declaration is not true it will only be considered as a piece of evidence but cannot be the basis for conviction alone – In the instant case, neither the two dying declarations nor the oral evidence of PW-2 and PW-4 inspire any confidence – Both these witnesses do not figure in the two dying declarations [2023] 11 S.C.R. 789 : 2023 INSC 758 790 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
– The two dying declarations are not consistent or rather contradictory to the oral evidence on record – Although, the appellant was named in the two dying declarations as a person who set the room on fire yet the surrounding circumstances render such statement very doubtful – Difficult to rest the conviction solely based on the two dying declarations – Prosecution has not proved its case against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt – Appellant acquitted. [Paras 47, 61, 64, 67-69] Criminal Law – Charge against accused – Duty of prosecution to establish beyond reasonable doubt:
Held: It is the duty of the prosecution to establish the charge against the accused beyond reasonable doubt – The benefit of doubt must always go in favour of the accused – Dying declaration is a substantive piece of evidence to be relied on provided it is proved that it was voluntary and truthful and the victim was in a fit state of mind – It is just not enough for the court to say that the dying declaration is reliable as the accused is named in the dying declaration as the assailant – Evidence – Dying declaration. [Para 63] Evidence – Dying declaration – Acceptability – Theory:
Held: The juristic theory regarding the acceptability of a dying declaration is that such declaration is made in extremity, when the party is at the point of death and when every hope of this world is gone, when every motive to falsehood is silenced, and the man is induced by the most powerful consideration to speak only the truth – Notwithstanding the same, great caution must be exercised in considering the weight to be given to it on account of the existence of many circumstances which may affect their truth – The situation in which a man is on the deathbed is so solemn and serene, is the reason in law to accept the veracity of his statement – It is for this reason, the requirements of oath and cross-examination are dispensed with – Since, the accused has no power of cross-examination, the courts insist that the dying declaration should be of such a nature as to inspire full confidence of the court in its truthfulness and correctness – However, the court should always be on guard to see that the statement of the deceased was not as a result of either tutoring or prompting or a product of imagination. [Para 43] 791IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH Evidence – Dying declaration – Reliance upon – Factors to be considered – Duty of the Court:
Held: Despite a general consensus of presuming that the dying declaration is true, they have not been stricto-sensu accepted, rather the general course of action has been that judge decides whether the essentials of a dying declaration are met and if it can be admissible, once done, it is upon the duty of the court to see the extent to which the dying declaration is entitled to credit – Thus, there is no hard and fast rule for determining when a dying declaration should be accepted – Duty of the Court is to decide this question in the facts and surrounding circumstances of the case and be fully convinced of the truthfulness of the same – Factors to be considered, enumerated. [Paras 60 and 62] Evidence Act, 1872 – s.8 – Conduct:
The conduct of the accused may be unnatural because he was residing in the very same house, however, the conduct which may be a relevant fact u/s.8, by itself may not be sufficient to hold a person guilty of the offence of murder – Penal Code, 1860 – s.302. [Para 46] Evidence – Dying declaration – Sanctity/presumption attached to – Justification for:
The justification for the sanctity/presumption attached to a dying declaration is two fold- (i) ethically and religiously it is presumed that a person while at the brink of death will not lie, whereas (ii) from a public policy perspective it is to tackle a situation where the only witness to the crime is not available. [Para 64] Evidence – Dying declaration – Suspicion as regards correctness of – Duty of Court:
It is unsafe to record the conviction on the basis of a dying declaration alone in the cases where suspicion, like the case on hand is raised, as regards the correctness of the dying declaration – In such cases, the Court may have to look for some corroborative evidence by treating the dying declaration only as a piece of evidence – The evidence and material available on record must be properly weighed in each case to arrive at an appropriate conclusion. [Para 48] 792 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Practice and Procedure – Criminal appeals filed against concurrent findings – Jurisdiction of Supreme Court – Discussed.
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Mst. Dalbir Kaur and Others v. State of Punjab (1976) 4 SCC 158 : [1977] 1 SCR 280; Laxman v. State of Maharashtra (2002) 6 SCC 710; Muthu Kutty & Anr. v. State by Inspector of Police, T.N. (2005) 9 SCC 113 : [2004] 6 Suppl. SCR 222; Nallapati Sivaiah v. Sub-Divisional Officer, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh (2007) 15 SCC 465 : [2007] 10 SCR 347; Bhajju alias Karan Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2012) 4 SCC 327 : [2012] 5 SCR 37; Sujit Biswas v. State of Assam (2013) 12 SCC 406 : [2013] 3 SCR 830; Dharm Das Wadhwani v. State of Uttar Pradesh (1974) 4 SCC 267: [1974] 3 SCR 607 – relied on.
King v. William Woodcock (1789) 1 Leach 500 : 168 ER 352; Neville Nembhard v. The Queen (1982) 1 AII ER 183 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal Nos.
825-826 of 2022.
From the Judgment and Order dated 25.04.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CCN No.4669 of 2017 in RN No.11 of 2017. Appearances:
Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Sr. Adv., Ms. Adeeba Mujahid, Adv. for the Appellant.
Ardhendumauli Kumar Prashad, AAG, Adarsh Upadhyay, Ms.
Pallavi Kumari, Ms. Ananya Sahu, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
J. B. PARDIWALA, J.
1. These appeals by special leave are at the instance of a convictaccused and is directed against the judgment and order dated 25.04.2018, passed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in Capital Case No. 4669 of 2017 connected with Reference No. 11 of 2017 by which, the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the convict-accused and thereby affirmed the judgment and order of conviction and sentence of death passed by the Additional Sessions Judge Court No. 6, Bijnore for the offence punishable under Sections 302, 436 and 326-A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short, ‘the IPC’) respectively.
2. The convict was awarded death penalty with fine of Rs. 20,000/- by the trial court for the offence punishable under Section 302 IPC. For the offence punishable under Section 436 IPC, the convict was awarded life imprisonment with fine of Rs. 10,000/- and for the offence punishable under Section 326-A IPC, the appellant came to be sentenced for life imprisonment with fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in default of payment of fines, further six months of rigorous imprisonment.
3. While the criminal reference was submitted by the trial court under Section 366 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short, ‘the CrPC’) for confirmation of capital punishment awarded to the appellant- convict, the appellant-convict preferred an appeal by way of Capital Case No. 4669 of 2017, putting in issue his conviction and sentence. The High Court dismissed the case filed by the appellant-convict thereby confirming the death reference under Section 366 of the CrPC.
CASE OF THE PROSECUTION
4. FAMILY CHART
IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH 794 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
5. The appellant-convict was married twice. The first marriage was with a lady by name Ishrat, who was the daughter of his uncle Mohammad Yunus (PW-1). His second marriage was solemnised with a lady named Afsana. One son by name Islamuddin (deceased) was born in wedlock with Ishrat. The convict had two brothers, namely, Irshad (deceased) and Naushad (deceased), who lived along with him and his sister Soni (PW-4). Another brother by name Shanu alias Shahnawaz (PW-2) of the convict lived in the neighbourhood.
6. It is the case of the prosecution that the three deceased persons more particularly Islamuddin (convict’s son) was highly opposed to the second marriage of his father, i.e., the appellant-convict. Islamuddin (deceased) was even once beaten by the appellant-convict as he had offered lot of opposition to the second marriage of his father. Islamuddin was also threatened by the appellant-convict that he would be thrown out of the house. Deceased Naushad (appellant-convict’s brother) was in Saudi Arabia. He had just returned to Bijnore from Saudi Arabia on 04.08.2014.
7. Few days before the date of the incident, the appellant-convict had beaten his son (deceased Islamuddin) and at that point of time, Naushad and Irshad (deceased persons) had intervened to save Islamuddin. On 05.08.2014, at around 05.30 pm, PW-2 Shanu (convict’s brother) went to see deceased Naushad and had dinner with PW-4 (convict’s sister), Islamuddin and Irshad. The PW-2 also invited the appellant-convict 795IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] for dinner. The appellant-convict lived in the same house as PW-4 and Naushad, but on a different floor.
8. On 05.08.2014, at around 10.00 pm, after the dinner was over, PW- 4 asked the PW-2 to stay overnight as it was too late. Naushad and Islamuddin slept in one room. As Irshad wanted to sleep on the roof, the appellant-convict advised him to sleep inside the room, as the weather was bad. Thus, all the three deceased persons ended up sleeping in one room.
9. PW-2 claims that the door of the room in which, the three deceased were sleeping, was open. However, according to the PW-4, it was locked from inside. The PW-2 lived at a distance of 200 metres from the place of the incident. It is pertinent to note that the High Court disbelieved the presence of the PW-2 at the place of occurrence, i.e., the house.
10. On 06.08.2014, at around 12.30 am, the PW-2 is said to have woken up to see flames and smoke coming from the room, where the deceased persons were sleeping. The PW-2 and his sister Soni (PW-4) claim to have seen the appellant-convict setting the room on fire and thereafter, fastening the door latch from outside and running away.
11. It is the case of the prosecution that the PW-2 and PW-4 opened the door and at that point of time, saw the appellant-convict running from the roof towards the stairs. According to the case of the prosecution, Amzad and one another person by name Shafiq (both not examined) also saw the appellant-convict running away.
12. The PW-1 (Original first informant- uncle of the appellant-convict) was sleeping in his room in his own house at the time of the incident. The uncle’s house is at the distance of about 200 metres from the place of the occurrence.
13. The relatives first took Islamuddin, Irshad and Naushad to one Pooja Hospital situated at Najibabad in a vehicle. The Hospital declined to admit them. All the three injured were thereafter, taken to the hospitals at Bijnore and Meerut and finally were admitted to the Dr. Ram Manohar Lohiya Hospital, Delhi (RML Hospital).
14. On 06.08.2014, early in the morning at around 6.10 am all the three injured were brought to the casualty ward of the RML Hospital by 796 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Shafiq Ahmad (not examined). At 9.00 am, PW-1 (first informant) lodged a First Information Report with the Najibabad Police Station. In the FIR, the first informant alleged that it was the appellant-convict, who set his own son and two real brothers on fire, while they were sleeping on account of personal animosity.
15. The dying declaration of deceased Irshad was recorded on 07.08.2014 by the A.S.I. at the RML Hospital. Irshad passed away on 09.08.2014. In the same way, the dying declaration of Islamuddin was recorded on 07.08.2014. Islamuddin passed away on 18.08.2014. It appears that the dying declaration of Naushad could not be recorded. Naushad also passed away on 18.08.2014. The two dying declarations were video- graphed in the mobile of the A.S.I.
16. On the strength of the FIR, the investigation was undertaken and on conclusion, the chargesheet came to be filed in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bijnore, for the offences enumerated above, who in turn committed the case to the Court of Sessions.
17. On 06.01.2015, the Additional District and Sessions Judge framed charge against the accused for the offences punishable under Sections 436, 302 and 326-A respectively of the IPC. The accused did not admit the charge and claimed to be tried.
18. In the course of the trial, the prosecution adduced the following oral evidence in support of its case:
S. No. Oral Evidences Witnesses
1. Mohd. Yunus, Uncle and Fatherin-Law PW-1
2. Shanu @ Shahnawaz, Younger Brother PW-2
3. Mohd. Imran, D ownstairs Neighbour, (examined to prove recovery memo)
PW-3
4. Soni, Sister PW-4
5. ASI, Narender Singh Rawat, Police Post, RML Hospital PW-5
6. Dr Saurav, RML H ospital PW-6
7. Dr Rahul Band, Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi PW-7
8. D r K u l d e e p P a n c h a l , L a d y H a r d i n g e M e d i c a l C o l l e g e , N e w D e l h i PW-8
9. Vishnu Gopal Upadhyaya, SI PW-9
10. R.P. Yadav, Inspector (Retd) PW-10
11. Dr Arvind Kumar, Associate Prof., Forensic Medicine, L a d y H a r d i n g e M e d i c a l C o l l e g e , N e w D e l h i PW-11
12. Dr Charanjeet Kaur, RMLHospital PW-12
13. R i y a z - u d - d i n K h a n , C o n s t a b l e C l e r k 1 1 8 4 PW-13
19. The prosecution also adduced the following documentary evidence: S.No. Particulars Number and Name of with witness Exhibit Nos.
1. Original complaint dated 06.08.14 PW-1, M o h a m m a d Yunus Exhibit Ka-1
2. F o r e n s i c S c i e n c e Laboratory Report, Agra dated 08.12.14 Exhibited by Court vide order dated 19.03.15 Exhibit Ka-2
3. S t a t e m e n t o f t h e deceased Irshad dated 07.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-2
4. Request form of autopsy of the deceased Irshad dated 10.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-3
5. R e q u e s t f o r m o f autopsy of the deceased Naushad dated 18.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-4 IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 798 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
6. Copy of the statement of deceased Islamuddin dated 07.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-5
7. S t a t e m e n t o f t h e deceased Islamuddin dated 07.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-5A
8. R e q u e s t f o r m o f autopsy of the deceased I s l a m u d d i n d a t e d 19.08.14 PW-5, A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-6
9. Receipt of dead body of Islamuddin 19.08.14 PW-5 A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-7
10. S t a t e m e n t f o r identification of dead PW-5 A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-8
11. Receipt of dead body of Irshad dated 10.08.14 PW-5 A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat Exhibit Ka-9
12. Medico Legal Case Sheet of the deceased Irshad dated 06.08.14 PW-6 Dr. Sourav Exhibit Ka-10
13. Medico Legal C a s e Sheet of the deceased Naushad dated 06.08.14 PW-6 Dr. Sourav Exhibit Ka-11
14. Medico Legal Case Sheet of the deceased I s l a m u d d i n d a t e d 6.08.14 PW-6 Dr. Sourav Exhibit Ka-12
15. Medico Legal Post Mortem report of the deceased Islamuddin dated 19.08.14 PW-7 Dr. Rahul Band Exhibit Ka-10 A
16. Medico Legal Post Mortem report of the deceased Irshad dated 10.08.14 PW-7 Dr. Rahul Band Exhibit Ka-11 A
17. Medico Legal Post Mortem Report of the d e c ea s ed N a u s h a d dated 18.08.14 PW-8 D r . K u l d e e p Panchal Exhibit Ka-12 A
18. Site Plan dated 06.08.14 PW-9 S.I. Vishnu Gopal Upadhyay Exhibit Ka-13
19. Recovery Memo dated 06.08.14 PW-9 S.I. Vishnu Gopal Upadhyay Exhibit Ka-14
20. Charge Sheet d a t e d 28.09.14 PW-10 Inspector R.P.
Yadav (Retd.)
E x h i b i t Ka14-A
21. Death report of the deceased Islamuddin dated 18.08.14 PW-12 Dr. Charanjeet Kaur Exhibit Ka-15
22. PW-9 S.I. Vishnu Gopal Upadhyay PW-9 S.I. Vishnu Gopal Upadhyay Exhibit Ka-16
23. Chick FIR d a t e d 06.08.14 PW-13 Constable Clerk Riyazudeen Khan Exhibit Ka-17
24. Carbon copy G.D. PW-13 R i y a z u d e e n Khan Exhibit Ka-18
20. Upon completion of the oral as well as documentary evidence, the statement of the accused was recorded under Section 313 of the CrPC in which, the accused stated that he was innocent and had been falsely implicated in the alleged crime.
21. The trial court upon appreciation of the oral as well as the documentary evidence on record, arrived at the finding that the prosecution had been successful in establishing its case against the appellant-convict beyond reasonable doubt. Accordingly, the trial court held the appellantconvict guilty of the offence enumerated above and sentenced him to death.
22. The appellant-convict being dissatisfied with the judgment and order passed by the trial court, challenged the same before the High Court. The High Court dismissed the appeal of the appellant-convict and confirmed the death sentence imposed by the trial court.
23. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant-convict is here before this Court with the present appeals.
IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 800 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
24. Mr. Gopal Sankaranarayanan, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant-convict vehemently submitted that:
a. The courts below committed a serious error in recording a finding that the prosecution has been able to establish its case against the convict beyond reasonable doubt.
b. The entire case hinges on circumstantial evidence and none of the circumstances, relied upon by the courts below to hold the appellant- convict guilty of the charges, could be termed as incriminating circumstances. c. The two dying declarations; one of Irshad and the other of Islamuddin could not have been relied upon, as they do not inspire any confidence and are in conflict with the ocular version of the two eye- witnesses. d. The manner in which, the dying declarations came to be recorded, speaks for itself. He would submit that the dying declaration should ordinarily be recorded in a question-answer form. The Investigating Officer did not even deem fit to call the Executive Magistrate to record the dying declarations. It was also argued that there is nothing to indicate as regards the condition of the injured persons, while they are said to have made the dying declarations before the Investigating Officer. To put it in other words, whether Irshad and Islamuddin were in a fit condition to speak so as to give dying declarations? It was pointed out by the learned Senior counsel that all the three Medico Legal Case (MLC) reports, which were prepared noted “No BP readable”. Irshad and Naushad had suffered 95 % burns, whereas, Islamuddin had suffered 80-90 % burns.
e. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned Senior Counsel prayed that there being merit in his appeals, the same may be allowed and the judgment of the High Court and that of the trial court be set aside and the appellant-convict be acquitted of all the charges.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE
25. On the other hand, these appeals were vehemently opposed by Mr. Ardhendumauli Kumar Prashad, the learned AAG, appearing for the State. He submitted thus:
a. No error much less an error of law could be said to have been committed by the courts below in holding the appellant-convict guilty of the offences with which he was charged.
b. There was a strong motive for the appellant-convict to commit the crime. The second marriage of the appellant-convict was opposed by his son Islamuddin. As the appellant- convict wanted to disown his son, the same was opposed by his two brothers Naushad and Irshad. That is the reason why the appellant-convict was at inimical terms with his own son Islamuddin and his two real brothers Naushad and Irshad.
c. There is no good reason to discard the oral evidence of the PW-2 Shanu alias Shahnawaz and PW-4 Soni.
d. The courts below rightly believed the two dying declarations to be true and trustworthy.
e. To conclude, the learned counsel pointed out that the appellantconvict is a history-sheeter and has tendency to repeatedly indulge in serious crimes.
f. In such circumstances referred to above, the learned counsel prayed that there being no merit in the present appeals, the same may be dismissed and the death sentence awarded may be upheld.
ORAL EVIDENCE ON RECORD
26. Mohammad Yunus (PW-1) is the first informant. He has deposed that the appellant-convict is his real nephew and also happens to be his son- in-law. In the intervening night of 05/06.08.2014 at about 12.30 am in the night, the appellant set his real brothers, Naushad and Irshad on fire including his son Islamuddin by pouring highly inflammable substance on them, while they were sleeping in the room. He has deposed that after setting the deceased persons on fire, the appellant shut the door from outside. On hearing the cries and shouts of Islamuddin, Naushad and Irshad, his brother Amzad and others including Shafiq and Shanu came running from the neighbourhood and broke upon the door. The injured were thereafter, taken to the Hospital at Najibabad.
27. Shanu alias Shahnawaz was examined as PW-2. Shanu is the younger brother of the appellant-convict. He has deposed that on 05.08.2014, IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 802 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
late in the evening, he had gone to his old house to meet his brother Naushad. Naushad had returned from Saudi Arabia after a long time. His younger sister Soni (PW-4) had cooked food for them and they all had dinner together. His elder brother (convict) had also come down from his place of living to the ground floor. The convict had hatred towards Naushad and Irshad. The convict had solemnised his second marriage at Jaspura town, after his release from jail. After arrival of his second wife, the convict wanted to separate his son Islamuddin. The convict had also assaulted Islamuddin two days before the incident, which was settled by Irshad and Naushad. On 05.08.2014, the second wife of the convict had gone to her parents’ house at Jaspura. Being the elder brother, he asked the convict to take meal along with them. It was around 11.00 in the night. His sister Soni asked the PW-2 to stay back as it was late in the night. Naushad slept in one room. Islamuddin slept in the room on the floor on a mattress. When Irshad went to sleep outside the room on the roof, the convict asked Irshad to sleep inside the room as the weather outside was bad. Irshad also slept by the side of Islamuddin in the room. Islamuddin, Irshad and Naushad slept together in one room. The door of that room was open. PW- 2 and his sister Soni slept in the adjoining room. At about 12.30 in the night, they saw smoke and flames coming out from the room, in which all the three deceased were sleeping. Then, he saw that the convict had poured some highly inflammable substance in the room in which Islamuddin, Irshad and Naushad were sleeping and set it on fire. The convict ran away after closing the door of the room from outside. All the three were severely burnt. All the three injured died at the RML Hospital. When the convict had solemnised second marriage, the same was opposed by Islamuddin. The convict at that point of time had beaten Islamuddin and had threatened that he would expel him from the house.
28. Soni (PW-4) was examined as an eye-witness to the incident. She deposed that the convict was her real brother. She was present at her house on 05.08.2014. She herself had prepared the meal in the evening on that day. Her brothers, the convict, Naushad and Irshad and her nephew Islamuddin were present on the second floor of her house. All of them had meal together. After taking meal, Naushad and Islamuddin went to sleep in the adjoining room and Irshad was sleeping on a cot outside the room. The convict asked Irshad to sleep inside the room, as the weather outside was bad. Irshad also slept by the side of Islamuddin in the room. They shut the door of the room from inside. The convict shut the door of the room from outside. Then cries “bachao-bachao” came from the room and flames of fire were seen inside the room. When she opened the room, she saw that the convict was running towards the stairs. Amzad and Shafiq saw the convict while he was running away. They all saw the burning room. After opening the door, they evacuated Naushad, Irshad and Islamuddin. All three were severely burnt. The skin of their legs got stuck on the floor. They took all the three injured to Pooja hospital in a vehicle. On refusal to admit, they were taken to Bijnore, thereafter to Meerut and from Meerut to the RML Hospital. During travel, her brothers and nephew were talking. Her brothers and nephew said that the convict set fire in the room after pouring petrol on account of which, all of them got burnt. All the three died at the RML Hospital, Delhi. The convict had solemnised second marriage after coming out from jail. Her brothers Irshad, Naushad and nephew Islamuddin had objected to it. The convict wanted to oust Islamuddin from their house. Her brothers Irshad, Naushad took the side of Islamuddin. For this reason, the convict burnt all of them by pouring petrol, setting them on fire and shutting the room from outside in order to kill them.
29. In her cross-examination, she stated that to the best of her knowledge, Islamuddin and Naushad had bolted the room from inside. The room in which, she was sleeping, was not bolted from outside. No other room was bolted from outside, except the room in which Islamuddin and Naushad were sleeping.
30. A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat was examined as PW-5. He was examined to prove the dying declarations of Irshad (Ex. Ka.2) and Islamuddin (Ex. Ka.5A) recorded by him. He has deposed that on 19.08.2014, he was posted at the Police Out-post of RML Hospital, New Delhi. Irshad, Naushad and Islamuddin were admitted on 06.08.2014, in the RML Hospital. He recorded statement of Irshad on 07.08.2014, who told that they lived with the entire family. He ran a mobile phone shop. On 05/06.08.2014, while he and his elder brother Naushad and nephew Islamuddin were sleeping in his house, at about 12.30 in the night, his brother Irfan/convict closed the door from outside and set the room on fire from inside with some inflammable substance. Due to which, they suffered severe burn injuries. The neighbours evacuated them from the room after a long time, and admitted them in IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 804 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
the Pooja Hospital, Najibabad. They were referred to the RML Hospital from there for treatment. This statement was given by the deceased Irshad. Paper No. 13, filed in the case, was in his handwriting and signature. He had obtained thumb marks of Irshad, which was identified by him. It was marked as Ex. Ka-2. Irshad died on 09.08.2014 at 07.30 pm. The dead body was sent to the Lady Hardinge Hospital for postmortem on 10.08.2014. After the postmortem, the body was handed over to his relatives Sadaqat and Shahnawaz after proper identification. The deceased Naushad died on 18.08.2014 at 08.40 am. His postmortem was conducted on the same day and dead body was handed over to his relative. He had also recorded the statement of the deceased Islamuddin. He had stated that the convict had closed the door from outside and set the room on fire from inside with some inflammable substance, due to which, he, his uncles Irshad and Naushad got burnt. The neighbours saved them on hearing their cries. PW-5 recorded the statement of the deceased on 07.08.2014, which was filed in case file and under his handwriting and signature. The same was marked as Ex. Ka-5. Islamuddin died on 18.08.2014 at 09.15 pm. His postmortem was conducted on 19.08.2014. Dead bodies of all the three were handed over to Shahnawaz and Sadaqat, after postmortem.
31. In his cross-examination he stated that he had not investigated this case. Neither any officer of Delhi Police nor U.P. Police deputed him to investigate this case. He had recorded the statements of the deceased Irshad and Islamuddin on 07.08.2014. He had recorded the statements of both in the emergency ward of the hospital. No one else was present at the time of recording the statement except him and the deceased persons. Both of them were in a fit condition when he recorded their statements. Exhibit Ka-2 and Exhibit Ka-5, the statement of Islamuddin does not bear the thumb impression or signature of anybody else except his own and the deceased. Exhibit Ka-2 and Ex. Ka-5 do not bear any certificate from the doctor with regard to fitness of both the deceased. Ex. Ka-2 and Ex. Ka-5 do not bear his endorsement with regard to fitness of the deceased at the time of recording the statements. There was a time gap of 15 – 20 minutes in recording of the two dying declarations. Both were written on the same day and at the same place. PW-5 had written only two statements. Different pens were used in recording the statements, but to obtain thumb impressions of the deceased, one ink pad was used.
32. A.S.I. Narender Singh Rawat PW-5 was recalled for the purpose of re-examination on 28.04.2017 in compliance of the order dated 15.04.2017. That on 07.08.2014, he was posted at the RML Hospital. On that day he had recorded the statement of Islamuddin aged about 16 years, son of the convict, resident of mohalla Muglooshah, Najibabad, District Bijnore. Islamuddin was in a fit condition to give a statement. He had recorded his statement word by word as stated by him. His thumb impression was taken on the statement. The thumb impression was identified by him. He had also put his signature on the statement. His statement has been recorded earlier in the court.
33. The appellant-convict examined himself as a defence witness. He deposed that his parents had five children. He was the eldest, his brothers were, namely, Shanu, Irshad and Naushad and one sister Soni. Islamuddin was born from his first wife Ishrat. His first wife had left his house as his brothers used to quarrel with her in respect of property. At the time, when his first wife left the house, Islamuddin was aged about 10 years. His brothers and sister were taking undue advantage of the tender age of Islamuddin and his mother deserting them. Taking advantage, they sent him to jail, in a false case. He came out from jail three years before the incident. During these three years, he did not quarrel with any neighbours or any person from the mohalla. He married another woman, one and half years prior to this incident. His sister also used to quarrel with his second wife frequently for the property due to which she left her house. He has deposed that his brothers, deceased Irshad and Naushad and his son Islamuddin used to consider him to be a weak person and with a view to grab the property, they all colluded to get my brothers and son killed. It was not known through whom, they got them killed. They falsely implicated him in the case. He ran away from the place of occurrence due to fear as he was released from jail in the recent past.
DYING DECLARATIONS:
34. We shall now look into the two dying declarations.
35. The deceased Irshad in his dying declaration recorded on 07.08.2014 stated thus:
IRFAN @ NAKA v. THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] 806 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
“Statement of Irshad, s/o-Mo. Ayub, r/o Mohalla- Muglushah, P.S. Nazivabad, Distrinct-Bijnor, U.P., age- 20 years.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.