Konkan Railway Corporation Limited v. Chenab Bridge Project Undertaking
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 742; [2023] 11 S.C.R. 215
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice J.B. Pardiwala Headnotes Issue for Consideration : in the Instant Appeal, Justice Is Challenged. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, Justice 1996 – Ss. 34 and 37 – Arbitral Award – Concurrent Interpretations
- Decided
- 17 Aug 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2903/2023
- Sections
- 37, 34, 34(2), 5
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 11 S.C.R. 215 : 2023 INSC 742
CASE DETAILS
KONKAN RAILWAY CORPORATION LIMITED
v.
CHENAB BRIDGE PROJECT UNDERTAKING
(Civil Appeal No. 2903 of 2023)
AUGUST 17, 2023
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI,
PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA AND
J. B. PARDIWALA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration : In the instant appeal, the legality of the order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court in an appeal u/s. 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by which the concurrent findings of the arbitral tribunal and that of the Single Judge of the High Court u/s. 34 of the Act rejecting all claims were set aside and certain claims were allowed, is challenged. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – ss. 34 and 37 – Arbitral award – Concurrent interpretations of the contractual clause pertaining to the disputes, by the arbitral tribunal and the Single Judge of the High Court u/s. 34 – Interference with, by the Division Bench in an appeal u/s. 37 – Justification:
Held : Principle of interpretation of contracts adopted by the Division Bench of the High Court that when two constructions are possible, then courts must prefer the one which gives effect and voice to all clauses, does not have absolute application – Said interpretation is subject to the jurisdiction which a court is called upon to exercise – While exercising jurisdiction u/s. 37, the Court is concerned about the jurisdiction that the s. 34 Court exercised while considering the challenge to the Arbitral Award – Jurisdiction u/s. 34 is exercised only to see if the arbitral tribunal’s view is perverse or manifestly arbitrary – Reinterpretation of the contract on an alternative view does not arise – Division Bench exercising jurisdiction u/s. 37 cannot reverse an Award, much less the decision of a Single Judge – On facts, the Division Bench of the High Court erred in re-interpreting a contractual clause while exercising jurisdiction u/s. 37 216 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
and setting aside the concurrent findings of the arbitral tribunal and the Single Judge of the High Court – Award of the arbitral tribunal and the decision of the Single Judge of the High Court u/s. 34 cannot be termed as perverse or patently illegal – Decision of the arbitral tribunal is a plausible view, and the Single Judge refrained from interfering with it u/s. 34 – Division Bench should not have interfered with these orders – Thus, the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court is set aside and that of the Single Judge is restored. [Paras 20, 22, 24 and 25] Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – ss. 34 and 37 – Scope of jurisdiction under :
Held : Jurisdiction of the court u/s. 37 is akin to the jurisdiction of the court u/s. 34 – Scope of interference by a court in an appeal u/s. 37, in examining an order, setting aside or refusing to set aside an award, is restricted and subject to the same grounds as the challenge u/s. 34 – Thus, the scope of jurisdiction u/s. 34 and s.37 is not akin to normal appellate jurisdiction – Courts ought not to interfere with the arbitral award in a casual and cavalier manner – Mere possibility of an alternative view on facts or interpretation of the contract does not entitle courts to reverse the findings of the arbitral tribunal. [Paras 14 and 15]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Radha Sundar Dutta v. Mohd Jahadur Rahim & Ors AIR 1959 SC 24 : [1959] SCR 1309; UHL Power Company Limited v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2022) 4 SCC 116; South East Asia Marine Engineering and Constructions Limited v. Oil India Limited (2020) 5 SCC 164 : [2020] 4 SCR 254; Adani Power (Mudra) Limited v.
Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission and Ors. (2019) 19 SCC 9; Satyanarayana Construction Company v. Union of India and Ors. (2011) 15 SCC 101; Delhi Development Authority v. R.S. Sharma and Company, New Delhi (2008) 13 SCC 80 : [2008] 12 SCR 785; MMTC Ltd. v. Vedanta Ltd. (2019) 4 SCC 163 : [2019] 3 SCR 1023; UHL Power Company Ltd. v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2022) 2 SCC (Civ) 401; Dyna Technologies Pvt Ltd v. Crompton Greaves Limited (2019) 20 SCC 1; Ssangyong Engineering. & Construction Company Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) (2019) 15 SCC 131 : [2019] 7 SCR 522; Parsa Kente Collieries Ltd. v. Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Ltd., (2019) 7 SCC 236 : [2019] 8 SCR 728; Patel Engineering 217KONKAN RAILWAY CORP. LTD v. CHENAB BRIDGE PROJECT
UNDERTAKING
Limited v. North Eastern Electric Power Corporation Limited (2020) 7 SCC 167 : [2020] 4 SCR 156; Vidya Drolia and Ors. v. Durga Trading Corporation (2021) 2 SCC 1 : [2020] 11 SCR 1001; Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority (2015) 3 SCC 49 : [2014] 13 SCR 895 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.2903 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 23.09.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in AN No.458 of 2019.
Appearances:
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Amlaan Kumar, Ms. Musharaf Shaikh, Ms.
Rukhmini Bobde, Ms. Soumya Priyadarshinee, Ankit Ambasta, Amit Kumar Shrivastava, Vishal Prasad, Advs. for the Appellant.
Darius Khambata, Sr. Adv., Aveak Ganguly, Manu Seshadri, Ms. Pallavi Anand, Abhijit Lal, Mithu Jain, Ms. Soumya, Advs. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT/ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA, J.
1. This appeal arises out of the decision of the Division Bench of the High Court of Bombay under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996,1 by which the concurrent findings of the Arbitral Tribunal and that of the Single Judge of the High Court under Section 34 of the Act rejecting all claims were set aside and certain claims were allowed. This appeal by Konkan Railway Corporation Limited challenges the legality of the order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court while exercising jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Act.
2. The short facts relevant for the purpose of this appeal are as follows: The Respondent’s tender for construction of a bridge at KM 50/800, on the 1 Hereinafter ‘the Act’.
218 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
Katra-Laole section of Udhampur-Srinagar-Baramulla rail link, said to be the highest railway bridge in the world, was accepted by the Appellant, leading to the execution of the contract on 24.11.2004.
3. While the contract was in execution, disputes arose between the parties and through an agreement dated 28.02.2012, a Standing Arbitral Tribunal was constituted for resolution of disputes. The respondent raised 35 claims which were clubbed and classified as twelve disputes. The present proceedings arise out of the decision of the Arbitral Tribunal deciding three disputes, being Dispute I (relating to Claim 9), Dispute III (relating to Claims 12, 22 and 28), and Dispute IV (relating to Claims 13, 23 and 29).
4. The Arbitral Tribunal by its award dated 15.11.2014 considered the three disputes and rejected all the claims. The Respondent challenged the award under Section 34 of the Act. The Single Judge of the High Court confirmed the Award and proceeded to dismiss the challenge under Section 34 of the Act. The decision of the Single Judge of the High Court was appealed by the Respondent under Section 37 of the Act, and the Division Bench of the High Court, by the order impugned herein, partly allowed the appeal in the following manner. The Division Bench, while dismissing the appeal with respect to Dispute I, allowed the appeal with respect to the remaining two disputes (Disputes III and IV), and thereby set aside the concurrent findings as regards these disputes. As there is no controversy with respect to Dispute I, we are called upon to examine the legality of the order with respect to Disputes III and IV.
5. The facts relevant for Dispute III are as follows: The contract in favour of the Respondent was entered into on 24.11.2004. At that time the Notification of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir dated 19.12.2003 exempted Entry Tax on earth-moving instruments. However, during the execution of the contract, on 25.01.2008, the Government of Jammu and Kashmir withdrew the exemption notification. Consequently, the Respondent raised claims for reimbursement of Rs. 1,32,29,771/- incurred on account of payment of Entry Tax.
6. In so far as Dispute IV is concerned, it relates to reimbursement of Toll Tax on machinery and materials. As per the extant policy in Jammu and Kashmir, the Toll Tax as applicable on the date of the submission of tender, that is 31.05.2004, was Rs. 400/- per MT. However, through four subsequent notifications issued under Jammu and Kashmir Levy of Toll Tax Act, 1998, 219KONKAN RAILWAY CORP. LTD v. CHENAB BRIDGE PROJECT UNDERTAKING [PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA, J.] the taxes were progressively increased to Rs. 650/- per MT. Consequently, the Respondent raised a claim of Rs. 5,23,279/-, incurred on account of increase in toll tax during the subsistence of the contract.
7. Claims under Dispute III as well as Dispute IV were to be considered in terms of the relevant clauses of the contract, which are Clauses 5.1.2, 7.1.1, 7.1.2, and 11.7. These clauses are extracted hereinbelow for ready reference. Relevant part of Clause 5 of Chapter 5, titled ‘Sales Tax, Turn Over Tax/Local Tax, Duties etc’, is as under: “Clause 5.1 Sales Tax/Turn Over Tax/Local Tax, Duties Etc.
...
Clause 5.1.2 Sales Tax including turn over tax on works contract, octroi, royalty, toll tax, Duties/Levies as well as services and any other tax levied by central govt., state govt. or local bodies, as applicable 15 days prior to the date of opening of tender shall be considered to be included in the percentage rates quoted by tenderer/s in the Schedule of Items, Rates & Quantities. In case of any increase/ decrease in the taxes during the period from 15 days prior to the date of opening of tender to the completion of the work, the net increase/ decrease for the balance portion of the work shall be borne/recovered by the Corporation.
The prevailing rate of Works Contract Tax (WCT) in J & K states to be deducted at source is 4.2% for the registered firms with state taxation department from firms not having the registration, the rate is 8.2%.
Clause 5.1.3 Corporation shall deduct the sales tax/Turn Over Tax or any other tax from the Contractor’s bill at the rate as applicable as per rules framed by concerned Govt./Local bodies from time to time and remit it to concerned department and shall issue a certificate regarding Tax/levies so deducted on demand by the contractor.”
7.1. Clauses 7.1.1 and 7.1.2 from Chapter 7, titled ‘Price Variation’, are as under:
“Clause 7.1.1 The rates quoted by tenderer and accepted by the Corporation shall hold good till the completion of the work and 220 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
no additional, individual claim shall be admissible on account of fluctuation in market rates, increase in taxes/any other levies/tolls etc. except the payment/recovery for overall market situation shall be made as per price variation clause given below.
Clause 7.1.2 No cognizance shall be given for any sort of fluctuations in taxes and other market conditions etc. for any individual item for the purpose of making adjustments in payments. The contract shall, however, be governed by the general price variation clause as under.”
7.2. Clause 11.7, in Chapter 11, titled ‘Schedule of Items, Rates & Quantities - Bill of Quantities’, is as follows:
“Clause 11.7 The rates and prices tendered in the priced Bill of Quantities, shall except in so far as it is otherwise provided under the contract, include all construction plant, labour, supervision, materials, all temporary works, false works, all leads and lifts, erection, specified finishes, maintenance, establishment and overhead charges, insurance, profits, foreign taxation and levies, taxes, royalties and duties together with all general risks, liabilities and obligations set out or implied in the contract and including remedy of any defects during the Defects Liability Period.”
8. The Decision of the Arbitral Tribunal: The Arbitral Tribunal interpreted the contract and construed Clause 5.1.2 of the contract as limited to taxes that could be raised by the Respondent-Contractor directly on the Appellant, as opposed to taxes that formed part of the materials quoted in the ‘Schedule of Items of Rates - Bill of Quantities’. For this, the Arbitral Tribunal also relied on Clause 11.7 of the Contract. The Arbitral Tribunal was of the view that Entry Taxes on earth-moving equipment formed part of the cost of the works quoted in the Bill of Quantities. For this reason, the Arbitral Tribunal came to the conclusion that the increased liability on account of imposition of Entry Tax could not be reimbursed under Clause 5.1.2, as recoupment for the same could only be governed by the Price Variation clauses (clause 7.1.1 and 7.1.2 in Chapter 7).
8.1 Interpreting the Price Variation clauses, the Arbitral Tribunal noted that the contract only provided for generic price variation based on a standardised formula. It also found that Clause 7.1.2 specifically barred cognizance of “any sort of fluctuations in taxes and other market conditions for any individual item for the purpose of making adjustments in payments”. Accordingly, the Arbitral Tribunal held that the claim for recouping increased tax liability for individual or specific items, in this case, the imposition of entry tax, could not be reimbursed under Clauses 7.1.1 and 7.1.2. 8.2 The Tribunal reasoned that the contractor was aware of these conditions at the time when the prices were quoted, and therefore, the claim could not succeed under Price Variation clauses.
8.3 As regards the claim for Toll Tax which formed part of Dispute IV, the Tribunal adopted the same interpretation of the contractual clauses and rejected the claim.
9. Decision of the High Court under Section 34 of the Act: The Respondent’s challenge to the Arbitral Award under Section 34 of the Act was considered and dismissed by the Single Judge of the High Court by its order dated 17.01.2019. The High Court concluded that there were two possible views with respect to the construction of relevant clauses of the contract. However, as the Arbitral Tribunal adopted one interpretation and since it was a reasonable interpretation, the Single Judge of the High Court held that there was no justification for exercising jurisdiction under Section 34 of the Act to interfere with the findings of the Arbitral Tribunal.
10. Decision of the Division Bench under Section 37 of the Act: The Division Bench of the High Court, while considering the appeal under Section 37 of the Act, proceeded to reinterpret the contractual clauses and arrived at a distinct conclusion. The Division Bench rejected the Arbitral Tribunal’s and the Single Judge’s interpretation of Clause 5.1.2 of the contract and came to the conclusion that the said clause will also include indirect taxes such as service tax, GST, Works Contract Tax, etc. While doing so, the Division Bench applied the principle of ejusdem generis to include even Entry Tax in Clause 5.1.2. The Division Bench of the High Court reversed the conclusion of the Arbitral Tribunal and the Single Judge of the High Court on the ground that they had simply assumed that the tax liability of items forming part of the Bill of Quantities was ‘inbuilt’ in the quoted costs and that no evidence was supplied to substantiate the same. The Division Bench also noted that reimbursement on account of increase KONKAN RAILWAY CORP. LTD v. CHENAB BRIDGE PROJECT UNDERTAKING [PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA, J.] 222 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 11 S.C.R.
in ‘toll taxes’ was specifically provided for in Clause 5.1.2 of the contract, and hence, claim for the same could not be rejected. In view of its conclusion, the Division Bench did not find it necessary to refer to Clauses 7.1.1 and 7.1.2 relating to price variation clauses, as the claims were justified under Clause 5.1.2 itself. Finally, relying on Radha Sundar Dutta v. Mohd Jahadur Rahim & Ors,2 the High Court came to the conclusion that it is a “well-settled principle that if there are two constructions possible of a contract, then the one that gives effect and voice to all clauses will be preferred over the other that renders one of them otiose or nugatory”. Adopting this approach, the Division Bench of the High Court proceeded to hold that the Arbitral Tribunal failed to interpret the contractual clauses harmoniously and holistically. It finally concluded that the approach adopted by the Arbitral Tribunal would amount to perversity, and therefore, found it necessary to set aside the Award, and allow claims covered under Disputes III and IV.
11. This judgment of the Division Bench of the Hight Court led to the present civil appeal before us.
12. Submissions on behalf of the Appellant: Mr Shyam Divan, Senior Advocate, along with Mr Amlaan Kumar, Mr Musharaf Shaikh, Ms Rukhmini Bobde, Ms Soumya Priyadarshinee, Mr Ankit Ambasta, Mr Amit Kumar Shrivastava, Advocates, and Mr Vishal Prasad, AOR appeared on behalf of the Appellants. They submitted that the Division Bench of the High Court exceeded its limited jurisdiction under Section 37 of the Act by reinterpreting the contract and substituting its view for the Arbitral Tribunal’s, assuming the role of a court of appeal. They relied on UHL Power Company Limited v. State of Himachal Pradesh3 and South East Asia Marine Engineering and Constructions Limited v. Oil India Limited4 for this purpose.
12.1 Next, they submitted that the parties agreed to a lump-sum contract price payable to the Respondent-Contractor. The Contractor split the agreed prices into several components and indicated the division in the ‘Schedule of Items and Rates - Bill of Quantities’, which inhered the cost and effort involved in execution of the items mentioned therein. There is no indication that the amount incurred in the execution of the entries therein would be separately reimbursed. They added that Clause 11.7 of the contract expressly indicates
2 AIR 1959 SC 24.
3 (2022) 4 SCC 116.
4 (2020) 5 SCC 164.
that the prices mentioned in the Bill of Quantities are inclusive of all costs that are liable to be incurred in the execution of the contract. 12.2 Further, they also submitted that the Arbitral Tribunal holistically interpreted Clauses 5.1.2, 7.1.1 and 7.1.2 of the contract to opine that individual tax claims would not be reimbursed by the Appellant-Corporation. The Arbitral Tribunal held that Clause 5.1.2 operates in a separate field, i.e., it operates in the field of taxes directly payable by the Corporation to the Contractor. They further added that the mention of toll tax and octroi in Clause 5.1.2 is only incidental, and does not render the recovery of taxes by the Contractor implicit. On the other hand, the fluctuations in price of entries in the Bill of Quantities (or for mobilisation of construction material and machinery) was recoverable only as per the scheme of Price Variation in Clauses 7.1.1 and 7.1.2, which expressly exclude cognizance of fluctuations in price of individual items.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.