Central Bureau of Investigation v. Shyam Bihari & Others
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 623; [2023] 10 S.C.R. 464
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice B.V. Nagarathna, Justice 2023 [b. V. Nagarathna and Manoj Misra, Justice Jj. ] Penal Code, Justice Acquittal By the Trial Court – Appeal Thereagainst, Justice U/S. 378(3)
- Decided
- 17 Jul 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 413/2013
- Sections
- 302, 378(3), 378, 34, 32, 313
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 464 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
v.
SHYAM BIHARI & OTHERS
(Criminal Appeal No. 413 of 2013)
JULY 17, 2023
[B. V. NAGARATHNA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ. ] Penal Code,1860 – ss. 302 and 34 – Murder case – Acquittal of three policeman – Correctness of – Prosecution case that prosecution witnesses traveling with the victim, though on a separate scooter, at night in the light of the scooter saw three policemen on the road armed with weapons – Policemen fired at them, hitting the victim who succumbed to the injuries and the prosecution witnesses managed to escape – Policemen charged of murder while patrolling u/s. 302/34 – However, acquittal by the trial court – Appeal thereagainst, u/s. 378(3) – Dismissed by the High Court – On appeal, held: Though judgment of the High Court is a cryptic one but that by itself need not be a ground to set aside the order – There are relevant record to assess the merit of the prosecution case – Incident arose in the year 1987 and the appeal remained pending – Neither of the prosecution witness could identify any of the three accused – They did not depose that the three policemen involved in the crime were those who were facing trial – Trial court justified in discarding the testimony of the eye-witness – Also no reliable evidence that the exchange of fire was with a view to kill – Moreover, the victim died from a .12 bore gunshot which could not be ascribed to rifles issued to the policemen – Circumstances ought to have formed a chain so far complete as to indicate that in all human probability it were the persons facing trial and none else who committed the crime – However, the circumstances found proved do not constitute a complete chain – Thus, not a fit case to interfere with the order passed by the High Court – Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 378(3).
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973: s. 378(3) – Appeal against acquittal – Power of the appellate court – Explained.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 No doubt the judgment and order of the High Court appears a bit cryptic but that by itself need not be a ground [2023] 10 S.C.R. 464 : 2023 INSC 623 A B C D E F G H to set aside the order and remit the matter to the High Court, particularly, when there are relevant record to assess the merit of the prosecution case. More so, because the incident is of the year 1987 and the appeal has remained pending since more than a decade. In such circumstances, if the matter is remitted to the High Court only to rewrite the judgment, it would be travesty of justice. Consequently, as the trial court has dealt with the matter at great length and has discussed each and every piece of evidence on which the prosecution seeks to rely, it would be apposite to assess whether, by not granting leave to appeal against the judgment of the trial court, there has been a miscarriage of justice. [Para 26][474-H; 475-A-C] 1.2 In an appeal against acquittal, the power of the appellate court to re-appreciate evidence and come to its own conclusion is not circumscribed by any limitation. But it is equally settled that the appellate court must not interfere with an order of acquittal merely because a contrary view is permissible, particularly, where the view taken by the trial court is a plausible view based on proper appreciation of evidence and is not vitiated by ignorance/ misreading of relevant evidence on record. [Para 27][475-C-D] 1.3 In the instant case, the prosecution case rested on ocular account as well as on certain circumstances. The ocular account is provided by PW-3, PW-6 and PW-15. PW-3 and PW-6 were traveling with the deceased, though on a separate scooter. They, therefore, had the opportunity to witness the incident. According to them, while they were traveling on their respective scooters, torch light was flashed at them by men in police uniform. As a result, deceased’s scooter skidded. Thereafter, when gun shots were fired they escaped and came to the village. On information, a large number of persons from the village arrived at the spot. Neither PW3 nor PW6 could identify any of the three accused. They did not depose that the three policemen involved in the crime were those who were facing trial. Thus, there is no infirmity, much less perversity, in the view taken by the trial court that the testimony of PW-3 and PW-6 is not of much help to the prosecution qua the three accused facing trial. [Para 28][475-E-G] 1.4 With regard to the testimony of PW-15, detailed reasons have been recorded by the trial court to hold him unreliable and CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. SHYAM BIHARI
& OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 466 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
unworthy of credit. Moreover, PW15’s presence is not confirmed by PW3 and PW6. Otherwise also, PW15’s conduct of remaining silent for over a week creates a lingering doubt in the mind as to whether he is a witness set up on advise, particularly, when it is noticed that his first statement was not to the investigating agency but made on an affidavit prepared by a lawyer, who simultaneously prepared three affidavits identically worded. The trial court noticed all these facts as also that PW-15 was lying when he stated that he went alone to get the affidavit prepared. The trial court also noticed that all the three affidavits were prepared on stamp papers, consecutively numbered, bought from the same vendor and the affidavits were sworn in quick succession giving rise to a definite conclusion that they were prepared by an advocate. The trial court also noticed that the conduct of PW15 was a bit unusual in the sense that he made no disclosure to anyone including the father of the deceased yet, he straightaway went to swear and dispatch an affidavit by post to a higher officer of the police even though, by that time, the investigation had been transferred to the CB-CID from the local police and, therefore, there was no threat from the local police. In these circumstances, if the trial court discarded the testimony of PW-15, the same was justified. [Para 29][475-H; 476-A-D] 1.5 Adverting to the proven circumstances, what transpires is that the witnesses are consistent that there was a police action on that fateful night. Assuming that it is true that in the night there was an exchange of fire between men in uniform and members of the public, but there is no reliable evidence that the exchange of fire was with a view to kill. Moreover, the deceased did not die of a rifle bullet injury. Rather, he died from a .12 bore gunshot which could not be ascribed to rifles issued to the accused persons. Therefore, even if empties of rifle cartridges relatable to service rifles issued to the accused were found at the spot, culpability of the accused persons in causing death of the deceased is not inferable. Further, there is no recovery of a .12 bore gun from any of the accused persons facing trial. Notably, after the incident, villagers congregated at the scene of crime. The police arrived at the spot and took the injured to the hospital. According to the prosecution evidence, the accused persons were present at the spot during this period. Therefore, if they were really A B C D E F G H involved they could have been identified by either PW3 or PW6, but there was no such event. Further, the continued presence of the accused at the spot is a circumstance which goes in favour of the accused, being a conduct that belies a guilty mind. Another circumstance which goes in favour of the accused is that, according to the prosecution’s own case, the accused persons, three in number, had a rifle each with 50 rounds. Admittedly, some of the empty cartridges found at the spot, as per the ballistic expert report, were not fired from the rifle issued to the accused. This is indicative of presence of some other rifle also. Whose rifle it was, the prosecution evidence is silent. Moreover, if the accused were to use their rifle to fire shots why would they use a country made pistol to inflict injury to the deceased. [Para 30 & 31][476- E-H; 477-A-B] 1.6 The circumstance that the accused persons were required to patrol that area and had left the police station for that end on that fateful night is a circumstance which is not conclusive as to turn the tables on the accused, inasmuch as the patrolling area covered two villages. It may be possible that the accused arrived at the spot late, when the incident had already taken place, and to chase away the miscreants, fired shots from their service rifles. Be that as it may, once the ocular account of PW-15 stood discarded, to clinch a conviction on the basis of circumstances, the circumstances ought to have formed a chain so far complete as to indicate that in all human probability it were the persons facing trial and none else who committed the crime. Here the circumstances found proved do not constitute a chain so far complete as to indicate that in all human probability it were the accused persons and no one else who committed the crime. In such a situation, there was no option for the trial court but to extend the benefit of doubt to the accused. It has not been pointed out that the trial court ignored or misread any relevant evidence. [Para 32, 33][477-C-E] 1.7 It is not a fit case to interfere with the order passed by the High Court and remit the matter only for the High Court to rewrite the judgment as the same, would be an exercise in futility. [Para 34][477-F] CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. SHYAM BIHARI
& OTHERS
A B C D E F G H 468 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.413 of 2013.
From the Judgment and Order dated 26.07.2012 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in GA No.4 of 2012.
Vikramjit Banerjee, ASG, Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Shubhendu Anand, Tathagat Sharma, Nring Chamwibo Zeliang, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
Anil K. Sharma, Sanjeev Kumar, Praveen Chaturvedi, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. This appeal assails the judgment and order of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital (in short, “the High Court”), dated 26.07.2012, in Government Appeal No.4 of 2022. By the said order, though the delay in preferring the appeal against the judgment and order of acquittal dated 13.12.2011 passed by the third Additional District & Sessions Judge/ Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act), C.B.I., Dehradun (for short “the trial court”) in C. No. RC-5/87-SIU.II was condoned, the application seeking leave to appeal under section 378 (3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short, “the Code”) was rejected and in consequence the Government Appeal was dismissed.
Introductory Facts
2. In the night/late evening of 24.06.1987, one Raj Kumar Baliyan (in short, “the deceased”) was killed. A first information report (FIR) was lodged by Pramod Kumar Tyagi (PW-6) alleging, inter-alia, that while he and Sudeep (PW-3), on one Scooter, and Raj Kumar Balyan (the deceased) on another Scooter, were travelling from Muzaffarnagar to Meerapur to attend a marriage, near Bhatoda turn, at about 9.30 pm, in the light of the Scooter, they saw three policemen standing on the road. One of them had a Danda (stick) whereas the other two were carrying rifles. The person who had the Danda flashed a torch light on them. As a result, they lost control of their respective scooters, which skidded and fell. One of the policemen exhorted to shoot to kill. In consequence, shots were fired hitting the deceased, who collapsed at the spot. PW-3 and PW-6, however, managed to escape to the village. On information, villagers arrived at the scene of crime and so did the A B C D E F G H police. In the presence of police the deceased was rushed to the hospital but he succumbed to his injuries on the way. Thereafter, the dead body was taken to the hospital and after leaving the body there, PW-6 lodged the FIR, which was registered as Case Crime No.48/87 at P.S. Sikhera.
3. Another version of the incident was lodged at the instance of one Mahindra Singh on 25.06.1987, which gave rise to Case Crime No.48A/87. There it was alleged, inter-alia, that on 26.05.1987 a robbery took place in the village wherein one person died. As criminals were regularly visiting the village since then, a constant vigil was maintained by the villagers as well as the police which had been patrolling the area. It was alleged therein that while three police constables were patrolling the village and people of the village were keeping a watch in the night of 24.06.1987, at about 9.00 pm, a man came and raised an alarm that 5-6 criminals were about to come to the village on motorcycles and scooters. On receiving this information, the villagers and the policemen became alert. At about 9.30 pm, a motorcycle came and stopped a little ahead of Bhatoda turn. Thereafter, two scooters came at a fast speed. When torch lights were flashed and the scooters were signalled to stop, the rider fired a shot with a view to kill the villagers and the policemen. However, one of the scooters skidded and the other stopped. The criminals however started running away while firing shots. As a result, there was retaliatory fire by the police and the villagers. One of the criminals was chased and nabbed by the villagers. He was also beaten by them. At that time, from P.S. Sikhera, an Inspector arrived in an Ambassador Car. He interrogated the criminal. Later, several villagers arrived and informed that the person caught is Raj Kumar, Advocate. Thereafter, Raj Kumar was taken to the hospital. At the same time, the spot was searched and two empty shells of cartridges were recovered from the spot.
4. The investigation of the aforesaid two cases was assigned to CB-CID and later, for further investigation, to Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) upon which, CBI registered a case No.RC-5/87- SIU.II. After investigation, CBI submitted a charge-sheet against the accused persons (the respondents herein) under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short, “I.P.C.”) After taking cognizance on the police report, the Court of First Additional Sessions Judge, Dehradun charged Anil Kumar, Shyam Bihari and Arshad Ali (the respondents herein) for committing offence punishable under CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION v. SHYAM BIHARI & OTHERS [MANOJ MISRA, J.] A B C D E F G H 470 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
Section 302 read with Section 32 I.P.C. The accused pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
5. During the trial, the prosecution examined 33 witnesses and produced various documentary evidences with regard to GD entries, seizure memos, site plan, forensic reports, autopsy report, etc. Various material exhibits such as articles seized during investigation were produced and exhibited during trial.
6. After closure of prosecution evidence, the incriminating circumstances appearing in the prosecution evidence were put to the accused for recording their statement under section 313 of the Code. In their statement, under section 313 of the Code, the accused denied the incriminating circumstances appearing against them and claimed that they have been falsely implicated and made scapegoat.
Nature of the Prosecution Evidence
7. The prosecution sought to bring home the charge against the aforesaid three accused by leading evidence to the following effect: -
(i) On the date, time and place of the incident, the three accused were on a picket duty as reflected by the GD Entries made at the police station concerned;
(ii) The GD Entries reflected that they had departed from the police station with a rifle and 50 cartridges each;
(iii) The ballistic expert report confirmed that some of the empty rifle cartridges recovered from the spot were fired from the service rifles of the accused thereby confirming their presence at the spot;
(iv) PW-3 and PW-6 narrated that the shots were fired by policemen who flashed torch light at the scooter riders;
(v) PW-15 (Shyam Singh) confirmed participation of the three accused in the crime and proved that on exhortation by the other two accused, Anil Kumar took out a country made pistol and had fired a shot at the deceased;
(vi) The villagers who had arrived at the spot after the incident had noticed that the three accused along with others were present at the spot;
A B C D E F G H
(vii) Police set up a false cross version of the incident, namely, Case Crime No. 48A/87, which indicated that there was a deliberate attempt on the part of the police to save themselves from the clutches of law.
Trial Court Findings
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.