The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1088; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 703
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari
- Decided
- 9 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11461/2025
- Sections
- 11A, 11
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 703 : 2025 INSC 1088 The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v.
Ganganarasimhaiah (Civil Appeal No. 11461 of 2025)
09 September 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari and Vijay Bishnoi,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the Division Bench of the High Court was justified in affirming the award passed by the Industrial Tribunal by setting aside the punishment of compulsory retirement imposed upon the respondent-workman and directing his reinstatement into the original post with continuity of service without back wages. Headnotes† Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 – s.11A – Powers of the labour court, tribunals – Allegations against the respondent-dufterycum-cash posted in the Bank that he benefitted on account of misconduct/irregular loan sanction – In the preliminary enquiry respondent admitted that certain loans were availed by coercing the manager and without obtaining any sanction from the Controlling Officer and accepted making unauthorized entries in the bank accounts, thereby tampering with the official records – Charges stood proved in the enquiry, by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate authority and punishment of compulsory retirement imposed upon the respondent – Industrial tribunal found that the enquiry was fair, however in the final award directed the appellant to reinstate the respondent without back wages – Final award upheld by the High Court – Sustainability:
Held: Order passed by the tribunal as well as the High Court not sustainable – Tribunal as well as the High Court failed to take into consideration the settled principal of law in respect of judicial review in disciplinary matters – High Court while adding its irrelevant reasons, confirmed the order passed by the Tribunal acted in a manner as if it was hearing an appeal against the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority, it failed to take into account * Author 704 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that in the departmental proceedings strict rules of evidence, as applicable in the judicial proceedings, cannot be applied and a charge of misconduct is to be proved only on preponderance of probabilities – Enquiry Officer as well as the Disciplinary Authority took into consideration the evidence available on record and had come to the conclusion that the respondent was found guilty on the charges levelled against him – Appellate Authority had also revisited the evidence and concurred with the Disciplinary Authority – After careful scrutiny of their order, it cannot be said that the orders were based on no evidence or are perverse in the absence of cogent and reliable evidence – Tribunal acted as an Appellate Authority and despite concluding that it is highly possible that the irregularities as alleged in the chargesheet were committed by the manager at the insistence of the Respondent, and he was the direct beneficiary of the irregular loan sanction, had illegally interfered with the punishment order passed by the Disciplinary Authority – Compulsory retirement of an employee from the services does not mean that the employee is not entitled to retirement benefits, which can only be denied in a case of dismissal from service – Impugned order passed by the tribunal as well as the High Court set aside – However, as punishment of compulsory retirement is imposed upon the respondent, he is entitled for gratuity and other pensionary benefits in accordance with law. [Paras 30, 34, 39-41] Case Law Cited Deputy General Manager (Appellate Authority) and Others v. Ajai Kumar Srivastava [2021] 1 SCR 51 : (2021) 2 SCC 612; Standard Chartered Bank v. R.C. Srivastava (2021) 19 SCC 281; Indian Overseas Bank and Others v. Om Prakash Lal Srivastava [2022] 1 SCR 246 : (2022) 3 SCC 803; B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India and Others [1995] Supp. 4 SCR 644 : (1995) 6 SCC 749; State of Rajasthan and Others v. Heem Singh [2020] 13 SCR 951 : (2021) 12 SCC 569; State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur v. Nemi Chand Nalwaya [2011] 3 SCR 589 : (2011) 4 SCC 584 – referred to. List of Acts Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
List of Keywords Compulsory retirement; Reinstatement; Serious irregularities; Unauthorized entries in the bank accounts; Tampering with [2025] 9 S.C.R. 705The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah the official records; Coercing the manager; Judicial review in disciplinary matters; Disciplinary enquiry; Rule of natural justice; Enquiry held by competent authority; Disciplinary Authority; Strict rules of evidence; Departmental proceedings; Preponderance of probabilities; Retirement benefits; Dismissal from service; Pensionary benefits; Continuity of service without back wages; Suspension.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11461 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 12.08.2022 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in WP No. 1857 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Deepanjal Choudhary, Dinesh Sharma, Ms. Likivi Jakhalu.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Saju Jakob, Teerthgowda N.M., Preyoshi Bhattacharjee, Senthil Kumar, Chand Qureshi.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vijay Bishnoi, J.
Leave granted.
2. This appeal has been preferred by the Appellant challenging the Judgment dated 12.08.2022 passed in Writ Petition No. 1857 of 2020 (L-RES) by the High Court of Karnataka. The Division Bench of the High Court, thereby affirmed the Award passed by the Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Labour Court (hereinafter referred to as “Tribunal”) in C.R. No. 138/2007 dated 25.09.2019, by setting aside the punishment of compulsory retirement imposed upon the Respondent and directed his reinstatement into the original post with continuity of service without back wages.
706 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
BRIEF FACTS
3. The facts, in brief, are that the Respondent joined the service of the Appellant-Bank as a daily wage Sub-Staff on 17.10.1990. Subsequently, his service was confirmed as Duftery-cum-Cash Peon as Sub-Staff Leader on 18.07.1992. The Respondent was thereafter posted at V.G. Doddi branch from 11.11.1997 till 01.08.2004. Thereafter, he was posted at Bommasandra branch on 02.08.2004.
4. The then manager, Shri H.N. Ramesh of V.G. Doddi branch submitted an investigation report on 06.08.2004 alleging serious irregularities at the branch office, V.G. Doddi branch when the Respondent and other staff members were posted there.
5. A preliminary enquiry was conducted into the said irregularities and the Respondent, in the said enquiry, on 24.07.2004 admitted that certain loans were advanced to his wife which were availed by coercing the manager and without obtaining any sanction from the Controlling Officer. The Respondent also accepted that he made unauthorized entries in the bank accounts of one Shri Ramakrishnaiah and his father, Shri Kambaiah, thereby tampering with the official records.
6. The Respondent was then put under suspension on 19.08.2004 because of contemplation to initiate the disciplinary proceeding, and thereafter a chargesheet dated 28.04.2005 was issued to the Respondent in respect of the charges. The chargesheet is reproduced herein below for easy reference:- “… CHARGE You were working at our V.G. Doddi branch from 11.11.1997 to 01.00.2004 prior to your joining Bommasandra Branch on 02.08.2004 and you were placed under suspension on 19.08.2004.
Serious discrepancies in the Advances Portfolio of our V.G. Doddi branch was observed and an investigation conducted into the matter has brought to fore the following irregularities/ fraudulent acts on your part;
FGC 1/2000 for Rs. 25000/- for Rs. 25,000/- to Shri Kambaiah on 03.04.2000;
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 707The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah On 03.04.2000 FGC 1/2000 for Rs. 25,000 has been granted to Shri. Kambaiah S/o Shri Rangaiah, Nayakanapalya, Magadi Taluk who is your father.
On 01.03.2000, Shri R. R. Hoover , the then Manager had allowed a TOD for Rs. 10000/- in the SB Account No. 519 of Shri. Kambaiah. Again on 24.03.2000, you had requested for a further finance of Rs. 25,000/- in your father’s account informing the Mnagaer that your father would be visiting the branch for executing the loan papers. At your behest Shri. R. R. Hoover had prepared the debit and credit slips far by debiting FGC account and crediting SB account No. 519 of Shri. Kambaiah. The slips for granting FGC loan was prepared without even preparing the loan papers as Shri. Kambaiah had not personally visited the branch for executing loan papers.
You have posted the credit slips in SB 519 of Shri. Kambaiah and withdrawn Rs. 15000/- from his SB account on the same day i.e. on 24.03.2000. In order to set right the unauthorised debit in FGC loan of your father, you have on the next day i.e. on 25.03.2000 unauthorisedly debited SB account 1550 of Shri. Ramakrishnaiah without the knowledge of the Manager and without, preparing any slips for debiting the account and without showing any corresponding. Credit. You have debited the amount in the 1edger sheet only and not made any entry in the subsidiary sheet.
You have brought this unauthorised, transaction to Manager’s knowledge only on 31.03.2000. Subsequently Shri R. R. Hoover passed the slips on that day by debiting SB 1550 of Shri Ramakrishnaiah. M and crediting FGC subsidiary, without slips. By doing so, the entry pertaining to FGC loan granted in the absence of Shri Kambaiah on 24.03.2000 was reversed and the unauthorised debit in SB 1550 of Shri Rsmakrishnaiah remained outstanding. Subsequently to set right the transaction of unauthorized debit in SB 1550 and crediting FGC head, Shri R. R. Hoover had hurriedly sanctioned a loan FGC 1/2000 for Rs.25000/to Shri Kambaiah on 03.04.2000 by duly obtaining loan 708 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports papers and crediting the proceeds to SB 1550 of Shri Ramakrishnaiah thus re-crediting the unauthorised debit. You have posted the debit slip pertaining to the transaction. You have knowingly made the unauthorised entries in your father’s and Shri. Ramakrishnaiah’s accounts for your personal gains.
Shri. Chennavenkataiah, P.T.E. of the branch had extracted the balancings of Rs. 3,00,196/- before the debit of Rs.25,000/- on 25.03.2000 i9n the SB balancing book. You have deliberately made alterations in the balancing book and altered the amount of Rs, 2,75,196/- to tally the balancing book. You have also made alterations in SB Control Register and the closing balance in the ledger subsidiary to tally the books which amounts to tempering and falsification of Bank’s records.
To conceal this unauthorizid debit in SB 1550 of Shri. Ramakrishnaiah you have deliberately left out the debit and credit entry while updating his pass book. You have admitted having deliberately left out these entries in the pass book.
Shri. Ramakrishnaiah had nothing to do with this transaction and Manager has granted the loan for accommodation purpose at your instance and as you had pressurized him in granting the said loan.
Shri. R. R. Hoover, Manager had allowed TODs in SB Account 2450 of Smt. Suvarmamma who is your wife, on 8 occasions during the period from 16.4.99 to 23.5.2000 totalling to Rs. 55,857/-. Apart from this, she was granted with DPN RT 22/09 for Rs. 20000/-, DPN RT 31/99 for Rs. 25,000/-, ALS 15/03 for Rs. 25000/-. Further loans have been granted to Shri. Kambaiah, your father, under ALS 10/02 for Rs. 25000/- and ALGL 98/03 for Rs. 25000/- for which concurrence of controlling office were not been taken. You have unauthorissdiy made debits in the SB Account 1550 for raising funds for personal gain. You have coerced the Manager for sanctioning loans to your family members for personal gains. You have tempered the Bank records [2025] 9 S.C.R. 709The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah by making alterations in the balancing book, key register and SB subsidiary sheets to keep the books tallied by fraudulent means on account of unauthorized debits. Our Staff Section (Officers), Circle Office, Bangalore, vide their letter No- BLC/SSO/7023/EP dated 04.10.2004, has called for your explanation into, the matter. The reply submitted by you vide your letter dated 02.11.2004 is neither convincing nor satisfactory.
You have by your above actions failed to discharge your duties with utmost integrity, honesty, devotion and diligence and thus cant ravened the provisions of Chapter XI, Regulation 2(A), (i) of Canara Bank Service Code and committed a “Gross Misconduct”….”
7. On 07.06.2005, the Disciplinary Authority appointed an Enquiry Officer and a Presenting Officer. The Enquiry Officer after conclusion of the enquiry submitted a report on 09.01.2006, concluding that all the charges levelled against the Respondent stands proved.
8. The copy of the Enquiry Report was supplied and in response to that the Respondent submitted his submissions alleging that the enquiry was not fair as two relevant witnesses were not examined.
9. The Disciplinary Authority issued “Show Cause Notice” dated 10.03.2006 to the Respondent proposing the punishment of compulsory retirement. The Respondent was also afforded personal hearing by the Disciplinary Authority. Finally on 15.03.2006, while agreeing with the findings of the Enquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority imposed the punishment of compulsory retirement upon the Respondent.
10. Being aggrieved, the Respondent preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority which rejected the appeal preferred by the Respondent vide Order dated 22.11.2006.
11. Further, pursuant to the dispute raised by the Respondent before the Central Government, the Central Government made a reference to the Tribunal, the terms of the reference read as follows: “Whether the punishment of the compulsory retirement imposed on Shri Ganganarasimahaiah by the management of Canara Bank is legal and justified? If not, to what relief the workmen is entitled?”
710 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
12. The Tribunal framed a preliminary issue as to whether the domestic enquiry held against the Respondent is fair and proper or not? On behalf of the Respondent, following contentions were raised: ● Some key witnesses have not been examined and certain relevant documents were not furnished to him;
● Sufficient opportunity was not provided to examine the departmental witnesses; and ● The enquiry proceedings were not conducted in the Kannada language but in English language which was inconvenient to the Respondent and his defence representative to effectively put forward the defence.
The Tribunal after dealing with the above contentions of the Respondent and also considering the stand of the Appellant-Bank vide Order dated 17.05.2013 had concluded that the enquiry was fair. The operative portion of the order dated 17.05.2013, passed by the Tribunal is reproduced herein under:- “....Thus, I find no to say that fair and proper opportunity was denied to the CSE or his defence Representative to put forward their case. In the result while arriving at conclusion of answering this issue in the affirmative holding that the Domestic Enquiry held against the I Party by the II party is fair and proper, I pass the following Order:
ORDER
The Preliminary issue is answered in the Affirmative holding that the Domestic Enquiry held against the I Party by the II party is fair and proper…”
It is to be noticed that the said order passed by the Tribunal dated 17.05.2013 has not been challenged by the Respondent and has thus, attained finality.
13. The Tribunal vide order dated 25.09.2019, had passed the Final Award and answered the reference in favour of the Respondent and directed the Appellant to reinstate the workman into his original post with continuity of service without back wages.
14. The Appellant thereafter preferred the impugned Writ Petition No. 1857 of 2020 (L-RES) before the High Court challenging the Final Award dated 25.09.2019 passed by the Tribunal.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 711The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah
15. The High Court vide the impugned Order dated 12.08.2022 dismissed the Writ Petition and upheld the Award passed by the Tribunal.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
16. The learned counsel for the Appellant argued that the Tribunal while exercising jurisdiction under Section 11A of the Industrial Disputes Act had exceeded its jurisdiction and acted as a Court of Appeal. It is contented that, though, the Tribunal vide order dated 17.05.2013 had held that the Disciplinary Enquiry against the Respondent was fair and proper, had re-appreciated the evidence and had interfered with the punishment order illegally.
17. The learned counsel has argued that the finding of the Tribunal, to the effect that the management did not produce any evidentiary material to prove the charges against the Respondent is perverse and bad in law. It is contended that as many as 19 documents were produced during the course of enquiry and the Enquiry Officer as well as the Disciplinary Authority has dealt extensively with those documents despite the fact that during the preliminary enquiry, the Respondent had admitted his guilt. Learned Counsel has further argued that the copies of the documents relied upon by the Appellant were supplied to the Respondent and he was granted sufficient opportunity to crossexamine the witnesses. In such circumstances, the Tribunal had grossly erred in interfering with the punishment order passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the High Court had also erred in affirming the order passed by the Tribunal. Learned Counsel has further argued that the Tribunal as well as the High Court were impressed only by the fact that the Appellant had failed to prove that the Respondent was the author of the entries whereby some irregular/illegal transactions were carried out in the bank/loan accounts of one Shri Ramakrishnaiah, the father of the Respondent, Shri Kambaiah and other customers of the banks. It is further contended that the Tribunal despite observing that it is highly possible that at the instance of the Respondent, the manager committed the irregularities as alleged in the chargesheet and also observing that the Respondent was the beneficiary of the misconduct/loan sanction has illegally interfered with the punishment order. It is argued that it is a settled position of law that strict rules of evidence do not apply to the disciplinary proceedings and the findings of the Disciplinary Authority are to be tested on the principle of preponderance of probabilities.
712 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
18. Learned counsel for the Appellant has further argued that the Tribunal has erred in observing that the punishment of compulsory retirement on the Respondent is too harsh and disproportionate, despite holding that he was benefitted on account of misconduct/ irregular loan sanction. The Tribunal has also wrongly observed that if the Respondent is reinstated into service, then only he will get the retiral benefits. It is contended that the Respondent being compulsorily retired from this service would otherwise also be entitled to retiral benefits because it is not a case of dismissal from the service. It is further submitted that the other staff working at the relevant time in the V.G. Doddi branch, namely, Shri R.R. Hoover and Shri N. Govinda Raju were also subjected to disciplinary proceedings and since the charges have been proved against them, punishment of compulsory retirement had also been imposed upon them. Their challenge to the punishment was rejected by the Appellate and Reviewing Authority and thereafter, they have not made any further challenge before any of the Authority and therefore, the punishment inflicted upon them became final.
19. Learned Counsel for the Appellant has further argued that the customers put their trust in the banks and deposit their money with the belief that their money would be safe in the banks. In such a condition, if an employee of the bank indulges in malpractices or irregularities in maintaining the accounts of the customers, then the faith of the general public would erode in the banking system. It is contended that the Respondent was found indulged in making unauthorized transactions in the bank account of strangers and was also involved in making irregular transactions in the accounts of his father and his wife and therefore, it is not desirable that such employee would remain in the banking system. The irregularities committed by the Respondent resulted in loss of confidence of the employer and in such circumstances the Respondent had rightly been compulsorily retired.
20. In support of the above submissions, the learned counsel for the Appellant has relied upon the judgements passed by this Court in Deputy General Manager (Appellate Authority) And Others vs. Ajai Kumar Srivastava reported in (2021) 2 SCC 612, Standard Chartered Bank vs. R.C. Srivastava reported in (2021) 19 SCC 281 and Indian Overseas Bank and Others vs. Om Prakash Lal Srivastava reported in (2022) 3 SCC 803.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 713The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah
21. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the Respondent has opposed the appeal and has argued that the High Court had not committed any illegality in passing the impugned order because the Appellant did not produce any evidence to prove that the unauthorized entries and tampering of the records were done by the Respondent. The learned counsel for the Respondent further argued that the Enquiry Officer also failed to examine two material witnesses, namely Shri Ramakrishnaiah and Shri R.R. Hoover and the Enquiry Officer did not obtain an expert opinion to verify whether the disputed entries were made in the handwriting of the Respondent.
22. The learned counsel for the Respondent also contends that the statement of admission of guilt by the Respondent, that are relied upon by the Appellant, were involuntary as they were taken under threat and coercion. It is asserted that the Respondent has only studied till 7 th standard and it is difficult to comprehend that he, not being an educated person, had made the entries in the bank accounts of his father or that of any other customers. It is contended that as a matter of fact, the whole irregularities in the loan/bank accounts of father of the Respondent and the other customers were done by the then manager of the bank and the Respondent has been falsely implicated.
23. It is further contended that the Appellant-bank has failed to produce any evidence which suggests that the Respondent was directly involved in the alleged misconduct, therefore, the Tribunal has rightly held that the punishment of compulsory retirement imposed upon the Respondent is too harsh and disproportionate.
24. We have heard the arguments advanced by both the parties and pursued the material on record.
ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION
25. The allegation against the Respondent is that when he was posted as Sub-staff at the V.G. Doddi branch of the Appellant-bank, he had committed certain irregularities. Pursuant to the same, the Respondent was suspended on 19.08.2004 and thereafter a charge sheet was served upon him on 28.04.2005. The Enquiry Officer submitted his report concluding that the charges levelled against the Respondent had been proved and as such he is guilty of misconduct. The copy of the enquiry report was supplied to the Respondent, and his 714 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports explanation was sought wherein he had furnished his explanation. The Disciplinary Authority after providing an opportunity of personal hearing and considering his defence had concurred with the enquiry report and vide Order dated 15.03.2006 had imposed the penalty of compulsory retirement upon the Respondent. The order passed by the Disciplinary Authority imposing the punishment of compulsory retirement is reproduced hereunder:
“I have perused the Chargesheet, the Enquiry Proceedings, relevant documents, findings of the Enquiring Officer and submissions of the CSE.
Sri Ganganarasimhaih was working at our V.G. Doddi Branch from 11.11.97 to 01.08.2004 prior to his joining Bommasandra branch on 02.08.04 and he was placed under suspension with effect from 19.08.04.
Serious discrepancies in the Advances Portfolio of V.G. Doddi Branch was observed and an Investigation conduced in the matter brought to the more certain irregularities/ fraudulent activities on his part.
The charges are morefully enumerated in the above referred Chargesheot which shall be read as part and parcel of this order.
Upon an enquiry, Sri Ganganarasimhaiah was found ‘guilty’ of the charges in the EO’s findings which was served upon him and the CSE vide his letter dated 28.01.06 has made his submissions.
On perusal of the records, I observe the following: During the course of the enquiry 19 documents were introduced as Management Exhibits and two witnesses were examined. On behalf of the defence/ CSE one document was introduced and no witnesses were produced. Sri H N Ramesh, Manager and the Investigating Officer was examined as MW-1. He has identified documents MEx - 1 to MEx - 16. MEx - 1, the contents of which were confirmed by MW1 reveals as follows:
On 03.05.2000, FGC Rs.25,000/- was granted to Sri Kambaiah, father of the Chargesheeted Employee. The [2025] 9 S.C.R. 715The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah debit slip was prepared for FGC 1/2000 and credit slip was prepared for SB 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah. In SB 1550, ledgersheet, there is a debit of Rs.25,000/- to FGC 1/2000 on 25.03.2000 and a credit of Rs.25,000/- is made on 03.04.2000 by FGC. These ledger entries are in the handwriting of CSE. There are no “corresponding debit and credit slips in the slip bundle of 25.03.2000. In the slip bundle of 31.03.2000, there is a debit slip for Rs.25,000/- debiting SB 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah with the narration towards FGC 1/2000 and a Credit Slip for the equal amount for the credit of FGC 1/2000. The debit slip bears the ledger folio no 78.12 with initials of CSE and the slip was released by Sri Robert R. Hoover, Manager. The balancing of SB ledger was extracted by Sri Channavenkataiah, PTE. The total balancing has been altered to Rs.275196/- and the balancing tallied. The alterations in the SB balancing book are admittedly in the handwriting of CSE. The SB key register is also in the handwriting of the CSE. The final total is altered by using white fluid and initialled by CSE. The CSE has admitted debiting the account of Sri Ramakrishnaiah without Manager’s knowledge On 31.03.2000. Sri Robert R. Hoover, Manager, came to know of the debit to SB account No 1550 on 25.03.2000 for Rs.25,000/-and alteration in SB key register and in SB Balancing book. CSE pleaded for mercy and as such the Manager had not written to CO. Sri Robert R. Hoover to set right the above transaction made transfer slips on 31.03.2000 debiting SB 1550 and crediting FGC head. The CSE has written passbook of SB 1550 deliberately omitting the above two entries and CSE has admitted this in writing.
[Emphasis Supplied] The CSE admitted in his statement dt 24.07.2004 that he got SB 2450 opened in the name of Smt Suvarnamma, wife of CSE on 19.12.1997. She is not working and not doing any busyness but she goes to tailoring training class. He had taken the TODs in this account and repaid the same. The CSE has posted the relevant slips in his own handwriting.
[Emphasis Supplied] 716 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The CSE has admitted having availed DPNRT 22/98 for Rs.20,000/-, DPNRT 31/99 for Rs.25,000/-and ALS 15/2003 for Rs.25,000/-in his wife’s name. The CSE has admitted for having posted the slips of FGC 1/2000 in SB ledger sheet of SB 519 & SB 1550. That there is no relationship between SB 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah and FGC 1/2000 of his father. The fact of debiting SB 1550 with Rs.25,000/- was not informed to Sri Ramakrishnaiah. The CSE also admitted that Sri Ramakrishnaiah is deprived of his own amount from 25.03.20010 & 03.04.2000. The CSE in his statement dated 28.07.2004 has admitted for having entered the pass book No 1550 deliberately leaving out the details pertaining to FGC 1/2000. The CSE has admitted having made entries in SB ledger sheet No 549518 of SB 2959 which pertains to Mr George Joseph.
It is brought on record through MEx-4 that Sri Robert R. Hoover, at the instance of CSE allowed TOD of Rs.10,000/in the account of Sri Kambaiah SB 519. To clear TOD he has prepared debit slip of FGC 1/2000. However CSE debited SB account 1550. Sri Robert R. Hoover also informed that CSE altered the figures in SB Balancing and SB control register.
[Emphasis Supplied] It is brought on record through MEx -7, 8, 13 and MEx -15 that debit entry of Rs.25,000/- made on 25.03.2000 in SB 1550 ledger sheet is not appearing in SB subsidiary sheet of the day. SB pass book No 1550 does not show the debit entry of Rs.25,000/-of 25.03.2000 and credit entry of Rs.25000/- of 03.04.2000 which were made In the ledger sheet of SB 1550. SB daily control register of 31.03.2000 debit entry pertaining to ledger no 2 is altered from Rs.68/to 25068/- and the number of slips from 1 to 2. But the total number of slip is retained as 8 even though it comes to 9. The closing balance for the ledger no 2 and the grand total is also altered. The CSE in his statement dated 24.07.2004 has admitted for having made the alterations.
It is also brought on record though the deposition of MW 1 basing on MEx 16 that TODs were allowed in the SB [2025] 9 S.C.R. 717The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah account No 2450 of Smt Suvamamma, W/o Chargesheeted Employee on 16.04.99, 05.10.99, 11.10.99, 23.10.99, 08.11.99, 01.03.2000 and 03.04.2000.
MW 2 Sri Channavenkataiah PTE had extracted the balancing in SB Ledger No as at 31.03.2000, he has confirmed that the balance extracted by him in SB 1550 was Rs.300196/- where as the altered figure was Rs.275196/the balancing was not tailed and the alterations in the balance was not made by him and he had only extracted the grand total in a rough 3heet since it was not tallied. There were no operations in the SB A/c No 519 during 1998 and 1999. A TOD was allowed on 01.03.2000 to an inoperative account, which is not a routine action of the Branch Manager. Sri Kambaiah is the father of CSE and hence, tho TOD allowed can be Justified for no other purpose than the coersion of the CSE. TOD was outstanding for more than 15 days and was adjusted by posting an entry of Rs.25,000/- on 24.03.2000, as narration “FGC 1/2000”. The entry Wall posted by CSE, though the entry was illegible by the Manager. The FGC 1/2000 was granted on 03.04.2000, and the CSE who posted the slips on 24.03.2000, cannot claim ignorance and the CSE had sufficient know 1 edge and knowingly he had posted the slips with the connivance of the Manager.
MW 1 stated that the CSE has approached the Manageron 01.03.2000 and pressurized him for a TOD of Rs. 10,000/in his father’s account, which acoount, which he had permitted to be cleared within 7 days. On 24.03.2000, the CSE has again approached the Manager for a further finance of Rs.25,000/-and coerced him to prepare the debit & credit slip for Rs.25,000/- each to FGC and SB account stating that his father would come to the branch on that day for executing the loan papers. Sri Kambaiah did not turn up and the amount was withdrawn and subsequently on 25.03.2000 debited Rs.25,000/- to SB account 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah, without the knowledge of the Manager. There is no corresponding debit or credit slip in the slip bundles. On 31.03.2000, there is a debit slip 718 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports for Rs.25,000/- to SB 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah which bears the ledger folio no 7812, with initials of the CSE. It is on record that the TOD dt 01.03.2000, was allowed by the Manager at the coercion of the CSE, and the debit entries dated 25.03.2000 and 31.03.2000, were made by the Chargesheeted Employee fraudulently and the defence argument that the entries have been authenticated is not true. On the other and the previous Manager advantage of Manager and benef it hand all evidences show that both the CSE colluded and the CSE had taken undue made fraudulent entries to gain pecuniary.
The Submission of the defence that TOD dt 01.03.2000 and granting FGC 1/2000 on 03.04.2000 are made under normal course of business, is not true. The evidences, show involvement of the CSE and Sri Robert R. Hoover, had obliged the Chargesheeted Employee on account of coercion. Further as per MEx- 1, and MEx -13 & 14, the SB control dt 24.03.2000, 25.03.2000 & 31.03.2000 are in the handwritings of CSE. As per MEx - 8, the CSE had debited Rs.25,000/-to SB 1550 on 25.03.2000 in the ledger account only and not made entry in the Subsidiary (MEx- 14) and SB control register (MEx-13). If the entry in MEx -8 was authenticated as claimed by Defence Representative the 3ame should have reflected in MEx- 13 and 14.
The debit entry dt 31.03.2000, of Rs.25,000/- was made by the CSE in the SB Ledger 2 Subsidiary, i.e., MEx- 14, In his own handwriting and no entry was made in the SB 1550 Ledger sheet.
After taking the balancing by MW 2, the balance in the SB control register, MEx 13 was altered in the handwriting of the CSE, which is visible to the naked eye and also the balancing extract. DEx-1 was also altered in the handwriting of the CSE and by putting the initial by the CSE.
[Emphasis Supplied] As per deposition of MW 1 there more two initials in MEx -13 and DEx -1 and one could be of the Supervisor. [2025] 9 S.C.R. 719The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah But it is true that, one initial is of the CSE and another initial is of the Manager who has colluded with the CSE and had admitted during Investigation that all-these entries were madeat the request of the CSE to accommodate him with funds.
The charge of unauthorised debits in SB 1550 & the alteration in SB control register and SB Balancing bookis not disproved / rebutted by the defence. Though entries of closing balance on 31.03.2000 and balancing on 31.03.2000 appears to be authenticated, the earlier entries of 24.03.2000, 25.03.2000 & 31.03.2000 and the FGC 1/2000 sanction on 03.04.2000 are all indicating that the alterations on 31.03.2.000 were made to coverup all the unauthorisded entries made by the CSE, for his, personal gains.
It is brought 25.03.2000 and Ledger sheet 1550. During branch on 28 03.04.2000, are on record that the debit entry of Rs.25,000/- on credit entry ofRs.25,000/- on 03.04.2000, made in SB of SB 1550, are not shown in the pass book of SB. It is brought on record that the debit entry of Rs. 25,000/- on 25.03.2000 and credit entry of Rs. 25,000/- on 03.04.2000, made in SB ledger sheet of SB 1550, are not shown in the pass book of SB 1550. During Investigation, Sri Ramakrishnaiah, was called at the branch on 28.07.2004 & who reported that the entries of 25.03.2000 & not belonging to him. MWl in his Investigation report has stated that the CSE had written the pass book in his own handwriting. The CSE had admitted during the Investigation for having written the pass book of SB 1550 of Sri Ramakrishnaiah by deliberately omitting the above two entries. Sri Ramakrishnaiah has stated vide MEx -9 that he had not demanded any FGC Loan either on 25.03.2000 or on 03.04.2000 and he never availed any loans from the Bank.
[Emphasis Supplied] It is brought on record that the debit and credit entry of Rs.26,000/-on 13.10.99, were not made in the pass book i.e., MEx -.15. But as can be seen that, the branch 720 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports had debited Rs.100/-on 31.03.2000 towards processing charges in respect of GL 168/99 sanctioned on 13.10.99. However in the case of debit entry dt 25.03.2000;- the same war. not entered in the SB Subsidiary on 25.03.2000, and in the case of credit entry dt 03.04.2000, the loan FGC 1/00 was not sanctioned in the name of Sri Ramakrishnaiah. As the CSE was knowing tho substantial credit of Rs.298937/to the SB account 1550, on 24.03.2000 and hence he had debited Rs.25,000/- to the account without the knowledge of the Manager. The defence has tried to bring on record that the entries dt 13.10.99 was not reflected in the pass book & accordingly, the entries dt 25.03.2000 L 03.04.2000 were also not reflected in the pass book and the defence tried to bring that the action of the CSE was not deliberate. However, as analysed above, the omitting of entries dt 25.03.2000 & 03.04.2000 are deliberate and the account holder i.e., Sri Ramakrishnaiah, had never made any objection/ complaint about the entries dt 13.10.99, 31.03.00 in respect of GL 168/99 vide MEx- 9, and Sri Ramakrishnaiah had nothing to do with the transactions dt 25.03.2000 and 03.04.2000.
[Emphasis Supplied] The CSE in his statement dt 24.07.04 had admitted that, he has got opened SB account 2450 in the name of his wife Smt Suvarnamma, who is neither working any where nor doing any business, but she was attending tailoring training class. On “8” occasions TODs were taken by him in the said account & repaid. The CSE had also admitted for having availed loan DPN(RT) 22/98 for Rs. 20,000/- DPN (RT) 31/99 for for Rs.25,000/- and ALS 15/2003 for Rs. 72570007- in the name of his wife. It is charged that, the concurrence of the controlling office was not taken for the above TODs/Loans. [Emphasis Supplied] The defence has argued that the CSE is not responsible for non obtention of concurrence from Circle Office. The guidelines issued by the Bank with regard to obtention of concurrence from controlling office for the loans/ advances granted to close relatives of the employees are applicable to [2025] 9 S.C.R. 721The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah all the employees of the bank. Though it is the responsibility of the Branch Manager to obtain concurrence the from the controlling office, before granting loans to close relatives of the employees, the concerned employee has also to take interest /initiative in this regard and to see that the Manager has obtained the concurrence or not, for the best interest of himself.
In this case, the defence has made an allegation that the management has made right allegation on a wrong employee. The defence ha3 not produced any evidence to show that, the CSE had also took initiative to remind the manager to obtain concurrence as a responsible employee of the Bank. When the CSE had took initiative in availing various facilities in the name of his wife, he should have shown the same interest to get the concurrence from the controlling office.
The evidence on record show that the CSE has unauthorised1y made debits in the SB account 1550, for raising funds for persona) gain. He had has coerced the Manager for sanctioning of loana to his family members for personal gains. He has tampered the Bank records, by making alterations in the SB control register, SB subsidiary sheets and SB Balancing book to keep the book tallied by fraudulent means on account of unauthorised debits. The CSE had availed loans/ TODs in tho-name of his wife, for which he has not initiated any steps for obtaining concurrence from controlling off ice.
I observe that all the contention of the CSE are covered by the Enquiring Officer in his findings dated 09.01.2006 and the CSE hats not brought any valid grounds for review of the findings of the EO - which merit consideration. Hence, while agreeing with the findings of the Enquiring Officer and for the reasons stated above. I hold the CSE guilty of the charges as enumerated in this order and I order accordingly.
A copy of this order shall be communicated to Sri Gangrasimhaiah Place: CO, Bangalore 722 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Date: 15.03.2006 Sd/-
DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY
“CANARA BANK Ref: BLC:DAC:4421:E-37:2006
DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY
CIRCLE OFFICE BANGALORE
PROCEEDINGS OF THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
Sub: In the natter of alleged misconduct on the part of Sri Gangrasimhaiah (61633), Sub-Staff(U/s), Canara Bank, Bomnasandra Branch.
Ref: 1. Chargesheet No. BLC:DAC:3038:E-37:CH-25/2005 dated 28.04.2005.
2 . S u s p e n s i o n P r o c e e d i n g s N o . BLC:SSW:10813:EP:E.37:2004 dated 18.08.2004.
WHEREAS, departmental proceedings were initiated against the subject employee by serving on him the above referred Chargesheat;
WHEREAS, an Enquiring Officer was appointed by the Disciplinary Authority to conduct an enquiry into the- above referred Chargesheet;
WHEREAS, the Enquiring Officer after conducting an enquiry submitted his findings holding the employee “Guilty” of the charges levelled against him as enumerated in his findings;
WHEREAS, a copy of the findings was forwarded to the Chargesheeted Employee vide letter No. BLCs -DACs 31:2006 dated 09.01.2006 and the Chargesheeted Employee has made his submissions on the findings vide his letter dated 28.01.2006;
WHEREAS, after analyzing the findings of the Enquiring Officer, the submissions made by the chargesheeted employee on the findings of Enquiring Officer and other [2025] 9 S.C.R. 723The General Manager (P) Canara Bank v. Ganganarasimhaiah connected records, the Disciplinary Authority concurred with the findings of the Enquiring Officer;
WHEREAS, after taking into consideration the gravity of misconduct, circumstances of the case, the punishment of “Compulsory Retirement” Was proposed to be imposed on the Chargesheeted Employee and a personal hearing in this -regard was given by the Disciplinary Authority on 15.03 .2006;
REF: NO. BLC:DAC:4421:E-37:2005 DATED 15.05.2006
NOW THEREFORE, taking into consideration the submissions made by the Chargesheeted Employee during the personal hearing, the gravity of the misconduct, connected records, the circumstances of the case, agreeing with the findings of the Enquiring Officer and holding the Chargesheeted Employee “guilty’ of the charges as enumerated in the orders of the Disciplinary Authority, the punishment of “COMPULSORY RETIREMENT”
as envisaged under Chapter XI, Regulation 4, Clause (b) of Canara Bank Service Code is hereby imposed on the subject employee.
The period of suspension shall not be reckoned for any purpose whatsoever and also the increment for the period of suspension shall not be released.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.