Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1184; [2025] 10 S.C.R. 263
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.M. Sundresh, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 6 Oct 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 715/2018
- Sections
- 302, 377, 201, 120, 11
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 263 : 2025 INSC 1184 Nazim & Ors.
v.
The State of Uttarakhand (Criminal Appeal No. 715 of 2018)
06 October 2025 [M.M. Sundresh and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the prosecution has succeeded in establishing, beyond a reasonable doubt, a complete chain of circumstances leading only to the conclusion of guilt of the Appellants, or whether the circumstances leave room for reasonable doubt warranting acquittal. Headnotes† Circumstantial Evidence – Penal Code, 1860 – ss.302, 201, 120-B – Conviction of the appellants u/ss.302, 201, 120-B, IPC rested largely on the testimony of three prosecution witnesses, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 – Interference with:
Held: 1.1 Prosecution failed to establish a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances – Evidence on record does not complete the chain of circumstances pointing to the guilt of the accused persons – There are substantial gaps in the case of the prosecution. [Paras 56, 29] 1.2 The first and most glaring circumstance is the omission of the names of the two of the three Appellants in the FIR – PW-1, the complainant and the father of the deceased, expressly named six persons with whom he admittedly had long-standing enmity, yet he did not attribute any role to the present Appellants, ‘N’ and ‘A’ – Both PW-1 and PW-2 were admittedly familiar with them – Despite this, their names were not mentioned in the FIR, nor was any contemporaneous explanation offered for their absence – This significant omission strikes at the root of the prosecution narrative, undermines its credibility, and constitutes a material fact that must weigh heavily in favour of the accused. [Para 29] 1.3 Further, there are improbabilities in PW-2’s testimony, coupled with his unexplained silence at crucial stages – The prosecution then relied on testimonies of PW-3 and PW-4 to establish * Author 264 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports last-seen circumstance – However, there are serious infirmities in their accounts making their evidence less reliable – The prosecution’s reliance on PW-3 and PW-4 falters on two counts: firstly, the absence of TIP renders their identification unreliable and secondly, even if their testimony is accepted, ‘last-seen’ theory alone is insufficient to sustain the conviction in the circumstances of the present case. [Paras 33, 34, 48] 1.4 The prosecution’s reliance on the last seen theory is misplaced – The interval between the alleged sightings and the discovery of the corpse is too wide to exclude the possibility of intervention by others – The last seen theory applies only when the time gap is so narrow that the hypothesis of another’s involvement is eliminated – That condition is absent here – Last-seen theory alone is weak evidence and requires corroboration, which is absent in this case. [Paras 45, 46] 1.5 Furthermore, though the medical evidence proves the fact of homicidal death but does not implicate the Appellants – The forensic report is neutral, the recovery is procedurally suspect – When the only scientific evidence available neither supports the prosecution’s narrative nor connects the accused to the crime, it is impermissible to uphold a conviction solely on doubtful eyewitness testimony. [Para 53] 1.6 The case of the prosecution with respect to motive is also tenuous – The motive alleged by the prosecution is only that the Appellants sought revenge for an insult to their sister – However, no concrete evidence of animus was led – There is no evidence that the Appellants bore any grudge against a ten-year-old child – Circumstances on record are not consistent with the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused and fail to exclude every other reasonable hypothesis, including their innocence – Suspicion, however strong, cannot take the place of proof – Appellants entitled to the benefit of the doubt – Impugned Judgment set aside – Appellants acquitted. [Paras 54, 56] Circumstantial Evidence – Conviction based on circumstantial evidence – When can be sustained – Conditions enumerated in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda, stated. [Para 28] Circumstantial Evidence – Omission in naming accused persons in FIR – Effect:
Held: In a case based solely on circumstantial evidence, every circumstance must withstand rigorous scrutiny – The failure to name [2025] 10 S.C.R. 265Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand two of the three Appellants in the FIR, despite the complainant’s familiarity with them, casts a serious shadow on the subsequent attempt to implicate them – It raises a legitimate inference that their names were introduced at a later stage, thereby suggesting the possibility of false implication. [Para 30] Last seen theory – Evidentiary value:
Held: The ‘last seen’ theory is itself a weak link unless the prosecution establishes a narrow time gap between when the accused and the deceased were seen together and the recovery of the body, such that the possibility of intervention by a third person is excluded – It would be unsafe to base conviction solely on this circumstance unless it is corroborated by some other strong and clinching material. [Para 44] Evidence – Dock identification without a prior TIP:
Held: Has little evidentiary value where the witness had no prior familiarity with the accused and courts must exercise extreme caution in accepting such identification. [Para 41, 42] Circumstantial Evidence – Scientific evidence:
Held: Where scientific evidence is neutral or exculpatory, courts must give it due weight – To convict on doubtful testimony while ignoring scientific tests is to substitute suspicion for proof – Despite the inconclusive forensic report, the High Court dismissed the absence of DNA evidence as inconsequential and affirmed the conviction solely on ocular testimony – Such an approach is untenable in a case based entirely on circumstantial evidence. [Para 51] Case Law Cited Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra [1985] 1 SCR 88 : (1984) 4 SCC 116; Ram Kumar Pandey v. State of Madhya Pradesh [1975] 3 SCR 519 : (1975) 3 SCC 815; P.
Sasikumar v. State [2024] 7 SCR 87 : (2024) 8 SCC 600; State of U.P. v. Satish [2005] 1 SCR 1132 : (2005) 3 SCC 114; Chattar Singh & Anr. v. State of Haryana [2008] 12 SCR 765 : (2008) 14 SCC 667; Krishan Kumar & Anr. v. State of Haryana [2023] 11 SCR 861 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1180; Hatti Singh v. State 266 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of Haryana [2007] 5 SCR 221 : (2007) 12 SCC 471; Padman Bibhar v. State of Odisha, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1190; Kali Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh [1974] 1 SCR 722 : (1973) 2 SCC 808 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Rules, 2007; Evidence Act, 1872.
List of Keywords Circumstantial Evidence; Conviction based solely on circumstantial evidence; Conviction solely on ocular testimony; Last seen theory; Chain of circumstances; Chain of circumstances not complete; Beyond reasonable doubt; Omission of the names in FIR; Complete and unbroken chain of circumstances not established; False implication; Dock identification without prior TIP; No TIP conducted; Suspicion cannot take place of proof; Benefit of the doubt; Acquittal. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
715 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 15.11.2017 of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CRLA No. 122 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
K.K.Tyagi, Iftekhar Ahmad, Rajeev Kumar Bansal, Ms. Garima Tyagi, Sarvam Ritam Khare.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Akshat Kumar, Ms. Anubha Dhulia.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
1. The present case has its genesis in the tragic and unnatural death of a young boy, Muntiyaz Ali, aged merely ten years. On the [2025] 10 S.C.R. 267Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand morning of 5 th June 2007, he went to the family’s mango orchard near Kishanpur to stand guard, but he did not return home. By late evening, his prolonged absence caused alarm and his father, Nanhe Khan (PW-1), organised a search with family members and co-villagers. Their efforts proved fruitless. At first light on 6 th June 2007, PW-1 resumed the search and discovered Muntiyaz’s lifeless body beneath a mulberry tree near a pit on the family’s land. A rope was found tightened around his neck, his hands tied behind his back with a rope, and an axe drenched in blood lying close by.
2. PW-1 immediately lodged a written complaint at Police Station Jaspur. In his complaint, he expressed suspicion against six covillagers with whom he had a long-standing enmity, namely Wahid, Muslim, Arman, Jahangir, Zahid and Babu. Notably, two of the three present Appellants, namely Nazim and Aftab, were not named in the initial First Information Report (hereinafter referred as “FIR”). The police registered FIR No. 966 of 2007 under Section 302 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred as “IPC”) on 06.06.2007 at about 10 in the morning. Subsequently, during the investigation, Nazim and Aftab were also implicated, and a charge-sheet was filed against all the accused persons under Sections 302, 201, 377 and 120-B IPC.
3. The case was committed for trial before the Court of the Ld. Additional Sessions Judge, Kashipur, District Udham Singh Nagar (hereinafter referred as “Trial Court”) where it was registered as Sessions Trial Nos. 40 of 2008 and 40A of 2008. After a full-fledged trial, the Ld. Trial Court vide its judgment dated 05.04.2014, acquitted five of the accused, namely Wahid, Muslim, Jahangir, Zahid and Babu of all charges. The present Appellants namely, Nazim, Aftab and Arman Ali, were convicted under Sections 302, 201 and 120-B IPC and acquitted under Section 377 of IPC. The Ld. Trial Court sentenced each of them to undergo life imprisonment under Section 302 of IPC, along with a fine of Rs. 5,000/- each and in default thereof, to further undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year. For the offence under Section 201 of IPC, they were sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of seven years and a fine of Rs.3,000/each and in default thereof, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 6 months. Additionally, they were also convicted for the commission of an offence under Section 120(B) of IPC read with Section 302 of IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment and fine of Rs.5,000/- each and in default thereof, to further undergo rigorous 268 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports imprisonment for one year. The Ld. Trial Court directed that all the sentences were to run concurrently.
4. The conviction rested largely on the testimony of three prosecution witnesses. PW-2, the scribe of the FIR, who claimed that on the night of 04.06.2007, he had overheard the accused persons conspiring to avenge an affront to their family’s honour. PW-3, Om Prakash, was presented as a ‘last seen’ witness who claimed to have seen the deceased in the company of the Appellants Nazim and Aftab shortly before the incident. PW-4, Mohammed Rafi, was relied upon for corroborating these circumstances. The Ld. Trial Court placed reliance on these testimonies and concluded that the Appellants, in furtherance of a conspiracy, had committed the murder of the young boy.
5. Aggrieved by the order, the Appellants preferred Criminal Appeal No. 122 of 2014, while the Complainant filed Criminal Appeal No. 129 of 2014, before the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital (hereinafter referred as “High Court”). By its judgment dated 15.11.2017, the High Court dismissed the appeals (hereinafter referred as “Impugned Judgement”). The High Court observed that the Trial Court had correctly analysed the evidence on record and found no infirmity in its findings. It affirmed that the testimonies of PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 were credible and that the chain of circumstances was sufficient to bring home the guilt of the Appellants. The present appeal assails the said Impugned Judgment dated 15.11.2017.
IMPUGNED JUDGMENT
6. While upholding the conviction of the Appellants, the High Court appreciated the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses and acknowledged that the case is based on circumstantial evidence. After examining the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses, the High Court accepted the testimonies of PW-2, PW-3 and PW-4 as credible and summarised what it considered to be a complete chain of circumstantial evidence. It observed:
“18. What emerges from the statements of witnesses, as discussed hereinabove, is that PW-1 Nanhe Khan’s son Muntiyaz Ali was missing on 05.06.2007. He had gone to look after the mango orchard. He did not come back till late night. The dead body was recovered on 06.06.2007.
It was the case of strangulation. The axe was also seen [2025] 10 S.C.R. 269Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand by PW-1 Nanhe Khan near the dead body. It was soaked with blood. PW2 Tauhid Ali is the important witness. He has heard Appellants being told by Wahid, Jahid, Hussain, Jahangir, Muslim and Babu to take revenge from the family of Nanhe Khan, since his nephew has teased their sister. He has heard their conversation on 04.06.2007.
Nanhe Khan’s son went missing on 05.06.2007. He has also signed the recovery memo of rope as well as of axe. The Appellants - Nazim and Aftab were seen by PW3 Om Prakash Singh on 05.06.2007. PW4 Mohd. Rafi has seen Nazim, Arman and Aftab together in the evening of 05.06.2007. It is the case of the circumstantial evidence. In order to prove the case based on circumstantial evidence, it is necessary to complete the chain. All the circumstances must exclusively point towards the guilt of the accused. In the present case, the prosecution has completed the chain, as far as the Appellants are concerned. They were seen on the date of occurrence by PW3 Om Prakash Singh and PW4 Mohd. Rafi. The conversation was heard by PW2 Tauhid Ali, whereby the co-accused exhorted the Appellants to take revenge from the family of Shamshad, who was the relative of Nanhe Khan. The cause of death, as per the statement of PW8 Dr. T.K. Pant was strangulation and injury no. 1 could be caused with an axe. The rope was recovered at the instance of Arman Ali.”
7. The High Court thereafter adverted to certain medical and investigative aspects, noting that:
“19. It has come in the statement of PW8 Dr. T.K. Pant that some blunt object was inserted in the anus of the deceased.
20. Learned counsel for the Appellantsaccused has argued that the axe was not sent for FSL examination. It is a case of defective investigation. However, there is overwhelming evidence that the cause of death of deceased was due to strangulation and injury from axe.”
8. On a careful perusal of the Impugned Judgment, it could be seen that the High Court has heavily relied upon the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses – PW-1 and PW-2. Therefore, with regards to 270 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the submission that upon overhearing the conspiracy, PW2 should have informed PW-1, the High Court reasoned as under:
“21. Learned Senior Advocate for the Appellants in CRLA No. 122 of 2014 has argued that if PW2 Tauhid Ali has heard the conversation, he should have told it to Nanhe Khan. The fact of the matter is that he has overheard the conversation. The coaccused were exhorting the Appellants to take revenge from the family of Shamshad. Shamshad happens to be the relative of Nanhe Khan. It has come in the statement of PW2 Tauhid Ali that he did not take the issue very seriously, since there was enmity between the family of the accused and Nanhe Khan. He was under the impression that it was of loose talk. The statement of PW2 Tauhid Ali does inspire confidence. He has no animosity with the accused.”
9. The Court next dealt with the defence contention that the feast at which the conspiracy was allegedly hatched had occurred on 3rd June 2007 rather than 4th June 2007. It observed:
“23. DW1 Shafiq Ahmad has deposed that the feast was on 03.06.2007. He has admitted that all the accused were called in the feast by him. The statement of DW2 Shamim Ahmad does not inspire confidence, since he has not produced the original receipt and register. The fact of the matter is that the feast was thrown by DW1 Shafiq Ahmad on 04.06.2007. The accused namely Arman, Nazim and Aftab were recognised by PW3 Om Prakash and PW4 Mohd. Rafi. PW3 Om Prakash and PW4 Mohd.
Rafi are also natural witnesses. Their statements inspire confidence.”
10. Finally, the High Court endorsed the findings of the Trial Court and dismissed the appeal in the following terms:
“24. Learned Trial Court has correctly appreciated the evidence, whereby the Appellants have been convicted and sentenced, as noticed hereinabove. There is no evidence against the other coaccused, who have rightly been acquitted by learned Trial Court. The prosecution has failed to prove that the unnatural offence has been committed by the Appellants and co-accused.”
[2025] 10 S.C.R. 271Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand
THE CHALLENGE
11. Taking exception to the Impugned Judgement, Ld. Counsel on behalf of the Appellants submitted that the High Court did not examine the grounds taken by the Appellants and has assailed the concurrent findings of the courts below on multiple grounds. It is submitted that the prosecution’s case is founded solely on circumstantial evidence and has failed to establish an unbroken chain of circumstances pointing only towards the guilt of the Appellants. In his submission, several vital links necessary to establish their guilt are missing.
12. First and foremost, it is contentiously submitted that the Appellants, namely Nazim and Aftab, were not named in the FIR. PW1, who lodged the report, suspected six other villagers with whom he had long-standing enmity, but did not mention the names of the present Appellants. Counsel contended that this omission in the earliest version of events raises serious doubt about subsequent attempts to implicate the present Appellants.
13. Ld. Counsel for the Appellants assailed the credibility of PW2, Tauhid Ali, the scribe of the FIR, who later claimed to have overheard a conspiracy meeting on the night of 04.06.2007. Counsel submitted that his testimony cannot be relied upon for several reasons. First, although PW-2 scribed the FIR at the dictation of PW-1, he did not mention any conspiracy in that document, nor did he inform PW-1 about such an incident when they met. Instead, PW2 surfaced with this allegation for the first time before the Court during trial. Secondly, when questioned, PW-2 explained that he had treated the conversation as “loose talk” and therefore refrained from disclosing it earlier. Counsel submitted that such an explanation is implausible. PW-2 himself admitted that he did not treat the matter seriously because of the pre-existing enmity between the families. Thirdly, conspiracies are not ordinarily conducted loudly in social gatherings so as to be overheard by passers-by. The claim that the accused would openly plot murder during a feast, within earshot of others seems improbable. Fourthly, the defence highlighted that DW-1 Shafiq Ahmad, in whose house the alleged meeting occurred, categorically denied that any feast took place on 04.06.2007, stating instead that his son’s marriage was solemnised on 03.06.2007.
14. The next limb of submission relates to the ‘last seen’ theory. PW3, Om Prakash, claimed to have seen the deceased with the Appellants, namely Nazim and Aftab, on 05.06.2007. Learned counsel submitted 272 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that PW3 admitted in cross-examination that he did not know the Appellants earlier. Despite this, no test identification parade (hereinafter referred as “TIP”) was conducted. Counsel submitted that when a witness is a stranger to the accused, a TIP becomes essential to test the capacity of the witness to identify the accused. Identification for the first time in court, without the safeguard of a prior TIP, carries little probative value and cannot be treated as reliable evidence of identity. Counsel further pointed out that PW-3’s wife, Mithilesh, and his son, Pintu, were allegedly present with him at the time of the sighting. Yet, the prosecution chose not to examine them, though they were the most natural witnesses to corroborate PW-3’s account. Their non-examination, according to counsel, strikes at the root of the prosecution’s case and creates a serious lacuna in the evidence.
15. Similarly, PW-4, Mohd. Rafi, claimed to have seen the Appellants together on the evening of 05.06.2007. However, his statement finds no mention in the FIR and, upon scrutiny, suffers from internal contradictions. Counsel submitted that this omission in the earliest version, coupled with inconsistencies in his deposition, undermines his credibility.
16. On these grounds, the Counsel contended that the High Court’s assertion that PW3 and PW4 were “natural witnesses” and their statements “inspire confidence” ignores these deficiencies.
17. Ld. Counsel for the Appellants also challenged the evidentiary value of the rope and axe. He pointed out that the recovery was at the instance of the co-accused Arman Ali. It was only during the pendency of the appeal before the High Court, and at its direction, that the rope, axe, and clothes were forwarded to the Forensic Science Laboratory for examination. The FSL categorically reported that no complete DNA profile could be generated from the exhibits and, therefore, no match with the Appellants could be established. Counsel stressed that this was the only scientific evidence available in the case and, far from supporting the prosecution, it failed to implicate the Appellants in any manner. He submitted that both the Trial Court and the High Court ignored this crucial finding, even though it directly undercut the prosecution’s case. By treating the inconclusive DNA report as insignificant, the courts below overlooked the settled principle that when scientific evidence tilts in favour of the accused, it cannot be brushed aside. Counsel further underscored that the axe was not [2025] 10 S.C.R. 273Nazim & Ors. v. The State of Uttarakhand initially sent for forensic examination at all. This lapse, according to him, revealed a serious flaw in the investigation. He submitted that the failure to subject a key alleged weapon of offence to scientific analysis at the appropriate stage amounted to defective investigation and deprived the prosecution’s case of the corroborative support it ought to have provided.
18. Counsel also referred to the testimony of PW8, Dr. T.K. Pant, who conducted the postmortem. The doctor opined that the cause of death was strangulation and that the injury could have been caused by an axe. However, he also noted that a blunt object had been inserted in the anus. The Appellants were acquitted of the unnatural offence, and counsel argued that the medical evidence does not, by itself, link the Appellants to the murder. He contended that the alleged motive, i.e. revenge for an insult to the sister of one of the coaccused is vague and unproven. In a case involving circumstantial evidence, the absence of motive weighs in favour of the accused.
19. It was further submitted that both the Appellants, Nazim and Aftab were juveniles on the date of the incident, as evidenced by their school records and the report of a medical board. The Juvenile Justice Board rejected this claim based on an electoral roll. Appellants submit that this contravenes Rule 12 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Rules, 2007 (hereinafter referred as “JJ Act”).
20. Even apart from juvenility, Counsel submitted that the High Court failed to re-appreciate the evidence independently, as it merely echoed the Trial Court’s reasoning and dismissed the appeal without addressing the serious deficiencies pointed out by the defence. He emphasized that the chain of circumstances is incomplete and that the Appellants are entitled to acquittal.
21. Opposing the appeal, Ld. Counsel for the State supported the concurrent findings of the courts below. He submitted that the testimonies of PW-2, PW-3, and PW-4 are cogent, trustworthy, and mutually corroborative, and that together they establish a complete chain of circumstances pointing only to the Appellants’ guilt. Counsel emphasised that the case rests on circumstantial evidence and submits that prosecution has successfully proved unbroken chain of circumstances pointing only towards the guilt of the Appellants. He pointed out that PW-2 overheard the co-accused exhorting the Appellants to take revenge, PW-3 saw the deceased in the company of Nazim and Aftab on the evening of 05.06.2007, and PW-4 also 274 [2025] 10 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports identified the Appellants later that evening. According to the State, these witnesses were natural witnesses, situated at the relevant time and place, and their testimonies inspire confidence.
22. Counsel for the State further highlighted that the rope and axe were recovered from the spot itself, and the post-mortem report established that the cause of death was strangulation and that one of the injuries could have been inflicted by an axe. He argued that these facts provide corroborative support to the ocular testimony.
23. Addressing the inconclusive DNA findings, Counsel submitted that failure to obtain a complete profile does not absolve the Appellants. He explained that forensic results often turn inconclusive due to the degradation of biological samples over time. Therefore, such reports cannot automatically exonerate an accused when other evidence firmly establishes guilt.
24. On the issue of non-mention of the Appellants’ names in the FIR, Counsel submitted that PW-1 initially suspected other villagers due to prior enmity. But subsequent investigation revealed the involvement of Nazim and Aftab. In his submission, the omission is not fatal when credible witnesses later identified the Appellants and linked them to the occurrence.
25. Lastly, Counsel contended that the plea of juvenility was rightly rejected by the Juvenile Justice Board and the High Court. He further submitted that the absence of motive is not decisive when the prosecution has otherwise succeeded in proving a consistent chain of circumstances sufficient to sustain a conviction.
DISCUSSION
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.