Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1065; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 383
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice K. Vinod Chandran
- Decided
- 2 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6377/2023
- Sections
- 399, 286, 397, 406, 108, 242, 193, 155, 111A, 402, 210
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 383 : 2025 INSC 1065 Mrs. Shailja Krishna v.
Satori Global Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 6377-6378 of 2023)
02 September 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the company petition decided in favour of the Appellant by the NCLT was maintainable u/ss.397 and 398, Companies Act, 1956 Act; assuming that the company petition was maintainable, whether the NCLT had jurisdiction to decide whether the gift deed is valid or not; if the answer to the aforesaid question is in the affirmative, were the facts on record and the law such so as to support the finding of the NCLT that the gift deed is invalid; whether the Appellant was able to prove that she has been a victim of mismanagement and oppression by the Directors of the Company. Headnotes† Companies Act, 1956 Act – ss.397-399 – NCLT decided the company petition in favour of the Appellant – Order set aside by NCLAT – Whether the company petition u/ss.397 and 398 was maintainable in view of the bar created by s.399:
Held: The company petition was maintainable – Findings returned by the NCLT and more particularly having noticed the allegations of fraud and coercion as well as fabrication of documents, which were proved to its satisfaction by the Appellant, the reasons assigned are concurred with. [Para 24] Companies Act, 1956 Act – ss.397, 398, 286 – Company petition filed by Appellant was decided by NCLT in her favour whereby inter alia she was restored as an Executive Director of the first respondent-Company; Board resolutions dtd.15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010 were set aside; the gift deed in question was held invalid and the subsequent share transfer in favour of the fourth respondent-her mother-in-law was declared null and void – Order set aside by NCLAT holding that NCLT erred in declaring the Gift Deed invalid when serious allegations of * Author 384 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports fraud, coercion, and forgery were raised – Whether the NCLT had jurisdiction to decide whether the gift deed is valid or not; if yes, whether the finding of the NCLT that the gift deed is invalid is supported by the facts on record and the law and; whether the Appellant was able to prove that she was a victim of mismanagement and oppression by the Directors of the Company:
Held: The NCLT/CLB possess a wide jurisdiction to decide all such matters that are incidental and/or integral to the complaint alleging oppression and mismanagement – Tribunal ought to bring an end to the complaints of oppression and mismanagement and must also provide a solution to the problems – In the instant case, admittedly, the determination of whether the gift deed is valid or not is central to the decision herein and, therefore, the NCLT did have full jurisdiction to decide whether the gift deed is valid or not, or whether it is against the provisions of the 1956 Act and/or internal regulations of the Company, including but not limited to the AoA and the MoA – If a member who holds the majority of shares in a company is reduced to the position of minority shareholder in the company by an act of the company or by its Board of Directors in a mala fide manner, the said act must ordinarily be considered to be an act of oppression against the said member – Appellant was the victim of oppression and mismanagement because the circumstances surrounding the gift deed and the subsequent transfer of shares are seriously questionable and are invalid and; the board meetings were conducted in a mala fide manner and against both the statutory requirements of the 1956 Act and the internal regulations of the Company – Gift deed and share transfer forms were invalid – Share transfer set aside – The Board Meetings held on 15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010 were also invalidly conducted and the resolutions purportedly passed therein, including the acceptance of the Appellant’s alleged resignation, do not warrant any validation by this Court – Interference by NCLAT with the judgment and order of the NCLT was unnecessary – Order of NCLAT set aside and that of the NCLT is restored – Companies Act, 2013. [Paras 29-31, 39, 42, 53, 55] Companies Act, 1956 Act – s.286 – Board meetings dtd.15.12.2010 or 17.12.2010, if were invalid:
Held: Yes – Clauses 30 and 61 of the AoA r/w s.286 mandate that notice of every board meeting must be served on all Directors – [2025] 9 S.C.R. 385Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors. Appellant, who continued as a Director during the relevant period, was never served with notice of either of the meetings dtd.15.12.2010 or 17.12.2010 – Moreover, such notices and/or proof of service of such notices were never produced before the NCLT, even the minutes of the meetings were also not produced – Hence, the requirement of notice being mandatory, non-service thereof renders the meetings invalid – Furthermore, on the issue of quorum, clause 53 of the AoA mandates that every Board Meeting of the Company must have a quorum of at least two validly appointed Directors – Admittedly, on 15.12.2010, the Appellant was a Director holding 98% shareholding in the Company and the only other Director was the third respondent – Hence, in the absence of the Appellant, the meeting did not have the requisite quorum – Further, since the alleged induction of the fifth respondent as an Additional Director in the meeting of 15.12.2010 was itself illegal, he could not be deemed to be a validly appointed Director, and his presence in the subsequent meeting dtd.17.12.2010 could not have cured the defect of quorum – Thus, both meetings were vitiated for want of proper quorum – Board Meetings held on 15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010 were invalid. [Paras 48, 51-53] Words and Phrases – Oppression – Meaning, discussed.
Case Law Cited Radharamanan v. Chandrasekara Raja [2008] 5 SCR 182 : (2008) 6 SCC 750; Kamal Kumar Dutta v. Ruby General Hospital Ltd. [2006] Supp. 4 SCR 462 : (2006) 7 SCC 613; Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. v. Cyrus Investments (P) Ltd. [2021] 12 SCR 903 : (2021) 9 SCC 449; Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd [1965] 2 SCR 720 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 15; Needle Industries (India) Ltd. v. Needle Industries Newey (India) Holding Ltd. [1981] 3 SCR 698 : (1981) 3 SCC 333; Hind Overseas (P) Ltd. v. Raghunath Prasad Jhunjhunwalla [1976] 2 SCR 226 : (1976) 3 SCC 259; Dale & Carrington Invt. (P) Ltd. v. P.K. Prathapan [2004] Supp. 4 SCR 334 : (2005) 1 SCC 212; Sangramsinh P. Gaekwad v. Shantadevi P. Gaekwad [2005] 1 SCR 624 : (2005) 11 SCC 314; V.S. Krishnan v. Westfort Hi-Tech Hospital Ltd. [2008] 3 SCR 184 : (2008) 3 SCC 363; Sri Parmeshwari Prasad Gupta v. Union of India [1974] 1 SCR 304 : (1973) 2 SCC 543 – relied on. V.B. Rangaraj v. V.B. Gopalakrishnan & Ors. [1991] Supp. 3 SCR 1 : (1992) 1 SCC 160 – referred to.
386 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Scottish Co-Operative Wholesale Society Ltd. Appellant v. Meyer (1958) 3 All ER 66 (HL); Elder v. Elder and Watson (1952) Scottish Cases 49; In re H. R. Harmer Ltd. [1959] 1 WLR 62 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited A. Ramaiya, Guide to the Companies Act, 2013, vol. 3, at 4020 (18th ed. LexisNexis 2015).
List of Acts Companies Act, 1956; Companies Act, 2013; Domestic Violence Act, 2006; Specific Relief Act, 1963.
List of Keywords Section 397 and 398, Companies Act, 1956 Act; Mismanagement and oppression; Fraud; Company petition maintainable; NCLT/ Company Law Board (CLB) possess wide jurisdiction; Gift deed invalid; Gift deed against AoA; Jurisdiction of NCLT; NCLT has jurisdiction to decide whether the gift deed is valid or not; Victim of mismanagement and oppression; Complaint alleging oppression and mismanagement; Share transfer in favour of mother-in-law not allowed in AOA; Out of love and affection; Share transfer forms suspect; Share transfer set aside; Ousted as Director without due process; Fraud; Coercion; Forgery; Satori Global Limited; Share transfer form; Gift deed and share transfer forms invalid; Board Meetings invalid; Restored as Executive Director of the Company; Extra-Ordinary General Meeting (EOGM); Form 7C; Extension of validity by RoC; Induction as Additional Director illegal; Not a validly appointed Director; Internal regulations of the Company; Board meetings vitiated for want of proper quorum; Board meeting did not have the requisite quorum; Defect of quorum not cured. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 6377-6378 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 02.06.2023 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal at Delhi in CAAT Nos. 379 and 395 of 2018 [2025] 9 S.C.R. 387Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors. Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv., Ankur Mittal, Bimal Bhabhda, Ms. Muskan Jain, Keith Varghese, Ms. Jutirani Talukdar.
Advs. for the Respondents:
S Niranjan Reddy, Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Sr. Adv., Ashutosh Jha, Ashutosh Gupta, Gaurav Rana, Oleander D Singh, Shivam Tomar, Ms. Sansriti Pathak, Ms. Meha Aggarwal, Aman Prasad, Shourya Dasgupta, Ms. Trisha Chandran.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
The A ppeAls
1. National Company Law Tribunal, Allahabad Bench 1 allowed a company petition 2 filed by Mrs. Shailaja Krishna 3 under Sections 397 & 398 of the Companies Act, 1956 4 by its judgment and order dated 04.09.2018. In appeals thereagainst 5 , the National Company Appellate Tribunal, Principal Bench at New Delhi 6 vide its common judgment and order dated 2nd June, 2023 set aside the said judgment and order of the N clt and allowed two sets of appeals of the respondents. These civil appeals assail the said appellate judgment and order of the N clat.
B rief fAcTs
2. The first respondent - “Satori Global Limited” 7 - a private limited company was earlier known as Sargam Exim Private Limited. The 1 N clt 2 CP. IB No. 107/ND/2013 3 Appellant 4 1956 Act 5 Company Appeal (AT) No. 379/2018 6 N clat 7 Company 388 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports compaNy, incorporated on 13.04.2006, primarily engaged in trading of paper. Sargam Exim Private Limited’s transition to Satori Global Limited will unfold as we proceed to narrate the facts.
3. At the time of incorporation in 2006, the authorized share capital of the compaNy was Rs. 2 crores divided in to 20,00,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each. The subscribed and paid-up capital of the compaNy initially was Rs. 3 lac divided into 30,000 equity shares of Rs. 10 each.
4. The Appellant and the second respondent – Mr. Ved Krishna – the Appellant’s husband were the original promoters of the compaNy. The Appellant initially subscribed to 5,000 equity shares, while the second respondent subscribed to the remaining 25,000 shares. In December 2006, the second respondent transferred 24,500 shares to the Appellant, thereby increasing her shareholding to 29,500 shares. The remaining 500 shares of the second respondent were transferred to the third respondent-Mr. Nirupam Mishra.
5. Subsequently, an additional 10,000 shares were issued to the Appellant. By the end of financial year 2006-2007, she held 39,500 shares of the compaNy out of a total of 40,000 equity shares of the issued and paid-up share capital, representing more than 98% of the compaNy’s shareholding.
6. On 01.02.2007, the second respondent resigned from the directorship of the compaNy. His resignation was accepted at the board meeting and the third respondent was inducted as Director of the compaNy in his place.
7. In the same year, the company made a long-term investment in M/s Yash Papers Ltd. (now known as Pakka Limited) by acquiring 10 lakh equity shares of the said company of Rs 10 each including 30 lakh equity warrants of Rs 11 each of which Rs 1.10 per warrant was paid. The balance sheet for the year 2007 reflected a holding of approximately 33,34,500 shares in M/s Yash Papers Ltd., representing around 14% of its shareholding.
8. On 15.12.2010, the fifth respondent was inducted as an additional director in the compaNy. Subsequently, on 17.12.2010, the Appellant is stated to have resigned from the compaNy. Her resignation was accepted at a board meeting attended by the third respondent and the fifth respondent.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 389Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors.
9. On the same day, that is, on 17.12.2010, a gift deed was executed in Faizabad through which the Appellant purportedly transferred her entire shareholding in the compaNy to the fourth respondent – Mrs. Manjula Jhunjhunwala – her mother-in-law out of love and affection.
10. The Appellant’s entire shareholding was transferred to fourth respondent vide Share Transfer Form dated 01.10.2010 and the validity of which was allegedly extended up to 12.11.2011.
11. Around 2009-2010, the Appellant and the second respondent drifted apart resulting in a strained marital relationship.
12. On 05.02.2011 and then again on 25.03.2011, the Appellant lodged police complaints alleging that she had been coerced into signing some blank documents. On or about 15.06.2011, the second respondent left India for the USA, where he instituted divorce proceedings against the Appellant.
13. In the meantime, a meeting of the Board of Directors was convened wherein notice was issued for an Extraordinary General Meeting (“EoGM”) to be held on 20.06.2011. The second respondent was re-appointed as Director of the compaNy and, at the said EoGM, the compaNy was converted into a public limited company under the name Satori Global Limited.
14. Appellant thereafter lodged her third police complaint on the same lines as the first two. She also addressed communications to the Registrar of Companies 8 and the Ministry of Corporate Affairs 9 , informing them of the circumstances. On 18.11.2011, the alleged transfer forms were utilised to effect transfer of her shares in favour of the fourth respondent.
15. Appellant also filed a petition under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2006 against the second and the fourth respondent. Later that year, she came to know that her name has been removed from the list of shareholders and instead, the fourth respondent was shown to have acquired her shareholdings. This led to filing of another complaint by the appellant, which resulted in registration of FIR No. 105/2013 against the second to fifth 8 RoC 9 MoCA 390 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports respondents under Sections 406, 419 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 10 .
16. Subsequently, the fourth respondent also filed an FIR against the appellant under Section 406, IPC alleging breach of trust with regard to the family jewellery belonging to the fourth respondent wherein she claimed that on 17.12.2010, the appellant changed her bank locker from a joint locker that she held with the second respondent to a locker singly held by her.
17. Amidst these circumstances, the appellant filed a company petition11 before the Company Law Board, New Delhi 12 which was ultimately allowed with costs by the N clt, vide its judgment and order dated 04.09.2018. The Board resolutions dated 15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010 were set aside. N clt restored the appellant as an Executive Director of the compaNy and declared her as the lawful owner of 39,500 equity shares, holding the share transfer dated 18.11.2011 in favour of the fourth respondent null and void. The compaNy was directed to reinstate the appellant as Director, and the fourth respondent ordered to return the share certificates within 15 days. N clt found overwriting and manipulation in the share transfer form, and noted that it was executed after its validity had expired. RoC was found to be lacking the power under Section 108(1-D) of the 1956 Act to extend its validity in such circumstances. N clt also found Form 7C to be incomplete and the extension of validity by RoC doubtful, warranting inquiry by the MoCA.
18. Aggrieved thereby, two separate appeals were carried to the N clat – one by the compaNy and the fifth respondent 13 and the other by the fourth respondent 14 . N clat , as noted at the beginning of this judgment, allowed the appeals and held the company petition to be not maintainable.
impugned J udgmenT
19. Nclat set aside the judgment and order of the Nclt on the ground that it did not have jurisdiction to decide issues of fraud, manipulation and
10 IPC
11 Company Petition No 107/ND/2013
12 CLB
13 Company Appeal (AT) No. 379 of 2018 14 Company Appeal (AT) no. 395 of 2018 [2025] 9 S.C.R. 391Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors. coercion; more so, in the exercise of its summary jurisdiction when examination of elaborate evidence is required. Hence, the appropriate course of action available to the Appellant was to approach the civil court under Sections 31 and 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 15 for cancellation of the disputed gift deed.
A rgumenTs suBmissions of The A ppellAnT
20. Learned senior Counsel for the Appellant, Mr. Dhruv Mehta advanced extensive arguments in support of his contention that the impugned judgment and order of the N clat is unsustainable in law and hence, liable to be set aside; and prayed that the judgment and order of the N clt be restored. A brief synopsis of his argument is as follows: a. The Companies Act, 2013, particularly Section 242 thereof, empowers the N clt to look into acts of oppression and mismanagement even when they involve fraudulent transfer of shares.
b. N clat travelled beyond its jurisdiction by re-appreciating factual findings, particularly on issues of fraud, coercion, and oppression, which squarely fell within the province of the N clt. c. The bar under Section 399 of the 1956 Act which, inter alia, provides for the requirement of 10% of the shareholding for a member to initiate an action under this said section does not stand in the way, since the Appellant was a member of the compaNy at all material times and the impugned Gift Deed being vitiated by fraud could not divest her of her membership. In addition to this, Section 399 of the 1956 Act has consistently been interpreted liberally, to ensure that minority shareholders are not rendered remediless.
d. The affairs of the compaNy were being conducted in a manner which was oppressive to the Appellant and prejudicial to public interest. Appellant had been excluded from participation in management and her name was wrongly removed from the register of members, resulting in her ouster as Director without following due process.
15 1963 Act 392 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports e. Gift Deed dated 17.12.2010 is invalid:
i. in view of Clause 16 read with Clause 2(c) of the Articles of Association 16 . Clause 16 of AoA of the compaNy allows the transfer of shares of a member by way of a gift to a specific category of persons only, namely, ‘Members, Wife, Husband, Son, Daughter-in-law, Son-in-law, Father, Mother, Brother, Sister, Uncle, Nephew, Niece or Cousin’. Clause 2(c) of the AoA lays down that the right to transfer the shares of the compaNy shall be and is restricted in a manner and to the extent provided in the AoA. Hence, Clause 16 of AoA must be read in the context of and along with clause 2(c) and cannot be read in isolation. This way the transfer in favour of the mother-in-law by way of ‘gift’ is not permitted under the AoA of the compaNy.
ii. because it was obtained under fraud, coercion, and undue influence. The second respondent had obtained the signatures of the Appellant on blank papers and later forged it, as the Appellant was not in the city of Faizabad on the relevant date.
f. Board meetings dated 15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010 are invalid: i. because they were conducted in clear violation of the AoA of the compaNy and the provisions of the 1956 Act.
ii. clause 53 of the AoA stipulates that every board meeting should have a quorum of at least 2 members. However, in the present factual milieu, on the date of the board meeting dated 15.12.2010 the quorum was not complete as the Appellant never attended this meeting. The compaNy at that point of time had only two directors, the Appellant and the third respondent.
iii. quorum was also not met in the meeting dated 17.12.2010 as inclusion of the fifth respondent as a director via the board meeting dated 15.12.2010 has no legal sanction.
iv. clauses 30 and 61 of the AoA mandate that the notice of a meeting must be served on the members either personally 16 AoA [2025] 9 S.C.R. 393Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors. or by sending a registered post on the registered address. This position is also supplemented by Section 286 of the 1956 Act. Even though the Appellant was a director of the compaNy throughout the duration of these meetings, she never received any notices for the board meetings held on both 15.12.2010 and 17.12.2010, nor was any proof of service of notices on her produced before the N clt. v. no minutes of the meeting have been produced regarding these meetings, which violate Section 193 of the 1956 Act. g. Share Transfer Forms were fraudulently prepared:
i. share Transfer Form was issued on 01.10.2010 and was only valid for 2 months, i.e., till 01.12.2010 as per Section 108 (1A) of the 1956 Act, whereas share transfer form was allegedly signed by the Appellant on 17.12.2010, when the form had already expired. Moreover, the Appellant was not even there on the said date.
ii. form 20B of 2012 itself shows that the shares were transferred only on 18.11.2011, whereas the Share Transfer Form stipulated that the extended period for transfer was only up to 12.11.2011. Realizing that the transfer on 18.11.2011 was beyond the permissible period, the respondents tampered with and overwrote the Share Certificates, altering the date from 18.11.2011 to 10.11.2011 solely to bring it within the extended period, thereby fabricating the very basis of the alleged transfer and rendering the transaction illegal, null and void ab initio, and incapable of conferring any rights upon the respondents. iii. in any event, the extension granted by the RoC up to 12.11.2011 cannot cure or validate the Share Transfer Form, as the execution/signature of the Appellant thereon had already expired on 01.12.2010, thereby rendering the alleged transfer wholly illegal and void.
iv. extension of validity of the Share Transfer Form under Section 108(1D) of the 1956 Act through Form No. 7C, is fraught with serious inconsistencies and illegalities, inasmuch as the said Form does not even bear a date, the particulars of payment are conspicuously absent in 394 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Column No. 10, and the reason for seeking extension has been vaguely stated as “misplaced”, which by no stretch of interpretation can fall within the statutory purview of Section 108(1D) that restricts extension only to “avoid hardship”. v. further, the second respondent is shown to have attended and signed the documents relating to the AGM dated 24.09.2011; however, this is demonstrably false for the simple reason that as per the second respondent’s own sworn affidavit filed before the District Court of Idaho, USA, he had left India on or about 15.06.2011 and was continuously residing in the USA until 31.10.2011, during which period he had also initiated divorce proceedings there. Consequently, he could not have been physically present in India or attended the AGM on 24.09.2011, and the documents purporting to bear his signature on that date are fabricated and unreliable.
vi. moreover, the Form is not even signed by the mother-inlaw, who was the transferee, but instead by some other person, thereby rendering the entire process of extension invalid, non-est and incapable of conferring any legal sanctity to the alleged transfer.
h. The compaNy was purportedly converted from a Private Limited Company into a Public Limited Company and its name was changed to Satori Global Limited through an alleged Extraordinary General Meeting (EOGM). However, no notice of such meeting was ever issued to or served upon the Appellant. Through this EOGM, 5 (five) new shareholders were added to the register and no notice was served on the Appellant. suBmissions of The respondenTs
21. Mr. Niranjan Reddy, learned senior counsel representing the compaNy sought to defend the impugned judgment and order by submitting that: a. N clt fell into manifest error in proceeding to declare the Gift Deed invalid, particularly when serious allegations of fraud, coercion, and forgery were raised. Such questions involve adjudication of complex factual controversies which necessarily require a full-fledged trial involving oral evidence - examination of witnesses and cross-examination – a feature wholly absent [2025] 9 S.C.R. 395Mrs. Shailja Krishna v. Satori Global Limited & Ors. from proceedings before the N clt under Section 155 of the 2013 Act, which grants it power only to rectify the register of members. The only competent forum to adjudicate upon the validity of the Gift Deed would be a civil court exercising jurisdiction under Sections 31 and 34 of the 1963 Act. b. Moreover, the Appellant had no locus standi to institute the company petition under Sections 397 and 398 of the 1956 Act. c. NCLT exceeded its jurisdiction:
i. first, regarding the finding that the RoC did not have power to extend the validity of the Share Transfer Form, the transfer forms were initially presented to the RoC on 01.10.2010 and executed on 17.12.2010. Since the same were not submitted to the compaNy within the statutory two-month period, an application was made under Section 108(1D) of the 1956 Act whereupon an extension was duly granted up to 12.11.2011. The transfer deed was thereafter submitted to the compaNy on 10.11.2011, well within the extended time, thereby ensuring full compliance with the statutory framework. The finding of the N clt , to the contrary, is unsustainable.
ii. second, with respect to the finding on the validity of the Gift Deed, the N clat has correctly held that the N clt lacked jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the same.
iii. even otherwise, assuming arguendo that the Gift Deed was not validly executed and notarised, the N clt erred in holding it forged without following due process. The notary was never examined, no oral evidence was recorded, and no opportunity of cross-examination was afforded to the parties. In the absence thereof, N clt could not have returned findings on such disputed and complex issues. iv. N clt’s order dated 04.09.2018 reinstating the Appellant as Executive Director and directing rectification of the register of members was manifestly beyond jurisdiction. Rectification of register of members is governed by Section 111A of the 1956 Act. Appellant, however, did not invoke that provision, and in its absence, no relief as granted could have been granted. N clt’s direction, therefore, was 396 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports without jurisdiction, contrary to statute, and rightly interfered with by the N clat.
d. Resignation letter submitted by the appellant on 17.12.2010 was valid and effective. Under the 1956 Act, once a director submits a resignation, it takes effect immediately without requiring acceptance by the Board or service of acknowledgment upon the resigning director. The resignation was duly recorded in Form 32 filed with the RoC on 30.12.2010, and the same became a matter of public record. Appellant ceased to draw salary from the compaNy after December 2010, unequivocally confirming her cessation of office.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.