Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1050; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2368
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 20 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11339/2018
- Sections
- 138C(4), 65B, 108, 138B, 130E, 138C, 138C(2), 9D(1), 138, 65, 4, 65B(4)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 2368 : 2025 INSC 1050 Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v.
Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 11339-11342 of 2018)
20 August 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala and K.V. Viswanathan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the CESTAT erred in passing the impugned order setting aside the penalty imposed upon the respondents-assessees. Headnotes† Customs Act, 1962 – ss.138C(4), 108 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.65B – Compliance of s.138C(4) – Admissibility of micro films, facsimile copies of documents and computer print outs as documents and as evidence – Admissibility of electronic records – Case of the Revenue that the respondents (engaged in the business of importing branded food items) were declaring lower RSP/MRP of the imported goods, resulting in evasion of duties – Show cause notice issued – Confirmed by Adjudicating Authority, demand raised with interest and penalty – Penalty set aside by CESTAT (Tribunal) holding that the documents relied upon by the department for proceeding against the respondents were collected from their electronic devices and were not admissible in evidence in view of noncompliance of s.138C(4) – Challenge to:
Held: There was due compliance of s.138C(4) in the present case – Record of Proceedings were duly signed by the respondents, including the various statements of the respondents recorded u/s.108 – Due compliance does not mean that a particular certificate stricto senso in accordance with s.138C(4) must necessarily be on record – The various documents on record in the form of record of proceedings and the statements recorded u/s.108 could be said to be due compliance of s.138C(4) – A certificate not given in the prescribed format per se will not make it invalid, especially when the authenticity of the marked documents is not in dispute – At no point of time the statements recorded u/s.108 were retracted – [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2369Additional D irector G eneral Adjudication, D irectorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh K umar and Co. Impex P vt. L td. & O rs. Even while giving reply to the show cause notice, the contents of such statements recorded u/s.108 were not disputed – However, this would be relevant only for determining whether there has been due compliance of s.138C(4) – The evidentiary value of such s.108 statements in any other proceedings, if any would have to be considered in accordance with law, including the compliance of s.138B – Order passed by Tribunal set aside – Appeals filed by the assessees before the Tribunal restored – Impotentia excusat legem – Lex non cogit ad impossibilia. [Paras 43-46, 48] Case Law Cited Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and Others [2020] 7 SCR 180 : (2020) 7 SCC 1; Kum. Shubha @ Shubhashankar v. State of Karnataka and Another, 2025 SSC online SC 1426 – relied on.
In Re Presidential Poll [1975] 1 SCR 504 : (1974) 2 SCC 33 – referred to.
List of Acts Customs Act, 1962; Evidence Act, 1872; Information Technology Act.
List of Keywords Section 138C(4) of Customs Act, 1962; Compliance of Section 138C(4) of Customs Act, 1962; Section 65B of Evidence Act, 1872; Admissibility of electronic records; Certificate under Section 138C(4) of Customs Act, 1962; Record of Proceedings; Record of Proceedings duly signed; Statements recorded under Section 108 of Customs Act, 1962; Section 108 of Customs Act, 1962 statements; Certificate; Business of importing branded food items; Lower RSP/MRP declared; Actual RSP/MRP; Evasion of duties; Penalty; Documents collected from electronic devices; Laptop; Computer; I-pad; I-Phone; Desktop; Computer print outs; Impotentia excusat legem; Lex non cogit ad impossibilia; Certifying Authority; Certificate not in prescribed format; Electronic signature; Electronic Signature Certificate; Electronic form; Electronic records; Information; Secure electronic record, Secure digital signature; Subscriber; Directorate of Revenue Intelligence; Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT).
2370 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 11339- 11342 of 2018 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.04.2018 of the Custom Excise Service Tax Appelate Tribunal in CUSTA No. 50095 of 2018, CUSTA Nos. 51918, 51919, and 51920 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Vikramjeet Banerjee, ASG, Nachiketa Joshi, Ms. Nisha Bagchi, Sr. Advs., Digvijay Dam, Amit Sharma B., Shaurya R Rai, Gurmeet Singh Makker.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ashish Batra, Amit K. Nain, Wattan Sharma, Kartik Yadav. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Permission for amendment of appeal(s) is granted.
2. These statutory appeals under Section 130E of the Customs Act, 1962 (for short “the Act, 1962”) are at the instance of the Revenue and are directed against the judgment and order passed by the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short “the CESTAT”), New Delhi dated 17.04.2018, by which the appeals filed by the respondents-assessees herein came to be allowed and thereby the order in original dated 17.07.2017 passed by the Additional Director General (Adjudication), Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, New Delhi imposing penalty upon the respondents herein came to be set aside.
3. It appears from the materials on record that the respondents herein were engaged in the business of importing branded food items from various countries.
4. After the import of the branded food items, they were being sold in Delhi and Mumbai, respectively. Acting upon the information, the business as well as the residential premises of the respondents were raided, and an extensive search was undertaken by the officials of the department. In the course of various searches, the department [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2371Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. was able to procure evidence which prima facie established that the respondents had short paid the duty on the import of the goods in question. The investigation revealed that while filing the Bills of Entry for the imported goods, there was a failure to declare the actual RSP/MRP at which the goods were being sold to the ultimate consumers.
5. Thus, it is the case of the revenue that the importers were thereby declaring lower RSP/MRP, which resulted in evasion of duties.
6. In such circumstances, referred to above, a show cause notice dated 06.06.2016 came to be issued to the respondents, calling upon them to show cause as to why the demand for differential duties of (a) Rs.9,24,50,644/- be recovered from the respondent no.1 and
(b) Rs.9,83,614/- be recovered from the respondent no.2, respectively. The show cause notice also called upon the respondents to show cause as to why interest and penalty should not be imposed and the imported goods be confiscated.
7. The show cause notice was adjudicated by the Adjudicating Authority and vide the Order in original dated 17.07.2017, the Commissioner confirmed the show cause notice and thereby raised a demand with interest and penalty. The order in original passed by the Adjudicating Authority came to be challenged before the CESTAT by filing appeals.
8. It appears on plain reading of the entire impugned order that the CESTAT reached the conclusion that the documents relied upon by the department for the purpose of proceeding against the respondents herein could not have been made admissible in evidence, in view of non-compliance of the provision of Section 138C(4)of the Act, 1962. According to the Tribunal, all these documents relied upon by the department were collected from the electronic devices of the respondents and in such circumstances, it was expected of the officials to strictly comply with the provisions of Section 138C(4) of the Act, 1962.
9. The Tribunal, while allowing the appeals filed by the respondents herein, clarified that an argument was canvassed before it on behalf of the respondents herein as assessees as regards Section 138B of the Act, 1962, however, since the Tribunal was inclined to allow the appeals only on the ground of non-compliance of Section 138C(4) of the Act, 1962, it did not deem fit to go into any other issues. 2372 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
10. Thus, the appeals filed by the respondents before the Tribunal came to be allowed.
11. The Tribunal, while allowing the appeals, made the following observations:- “11. Upon perusal of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Anvar P.V.(supra), we note that the Apex Court has categorically laid down the law that unless the requirement of Section 65B of the Evidence Act is satisfied, such evidence cannot be admitted. In any proceeding. We note that the Section 138C of the Customs Act is pari materia to Section 65B of the Evidence Act. Consequently, the evidence in the form of computer printouts etc. recovered during the course of investigation can be admitted as in the present proceedings only subject to the satisfaction of the sub-section (2) of Section 138C. This refers to the certificate from a responsible person in relation to the operation of the relevant lap-top/computer. After perusing the record of the case, we note that in respect of the electronic documents in the form of computer print-outs from the seized lap-tops and other electronic devices have not been accompanied by a certificate as required by the Section 138C(2) as above. In the absence of such certificate, in view of the unambiguous language in the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court (supra), the said electronic documents cannot be relied upon by the Revenue for confirmation of differential duty on the appellant. In the present case, the main evidence on which, Revenue has sought to establish the case of under-valuation and mis-declaration of the imported goods is in the form of the computer printouts taken out from the laptops and other electronic devices seized from the residential premises of Shri Nikhil Asrani, Director in respect of which the requirement of Section 138C(2) has not been satisfied. On this ground, the impugned order suffers from uncurable error and hence, is liable to be set aside.
12. The ld. AR for Revenue relied upon the decision of the Tribunal in the case of M/s. Laxmi Enterprises (supra) in which the Tribunal upheld the charge of under-valuation and [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2373Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. demand for differential duty. In the said decision, Tribunal overruled the objection of the appellant in connection with Section 138C, by holding that the documents printed out from lap-top will be admissible as evidence in view of the fact that the truth of such documents stand admitted by the proprietor in his statement.
We have gone through the said decision of the Tribunal and we note that the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Anvar P.V. (supra) has not been cited and was never brought to the notice of the Bench. Consequently, we are of the view that the decision in the case of Laxmi Enterprises is not applicable to the facts of the present case.
13. It is submitted by the ld. Counsel for the appellant that the adjudicating authority had not examined the witnesses, as per the provisions of Section 138B of the Act, 1962. He has relied upon the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High Court, in the case of J&K Cigaratte - Vs. - Collector of Customs - 2009 (242) ELT (Del.). In that case, the Hon’ble High Court, while dealing with Section 9D(1) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, (Pari materia to Section 138B of the Customs Act, 1962) have held that the procedure as prescribed in the statute is required to be followed for proving the truth of the statement. The said decision of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has also been relied upon by the Hon’ble Punjab & Haryana High Court, in the case of G-Tech Industries - Vs. - Union of India-2016 (339) ELT 209 (P&H). We find force in the submissions of the ld. Counsel for the appellant that the adjudicating authority had not followed the procedures prescribed under Section 138B of the Act, 1962. We have already observed that the demand of duty cannot be sustained, as the evidences as available for the alleged under valuation cannot be accepted under the law, as per the mandates of Section 138 C of the Act. Hence, there is no need to discuss the said issues, as raised by the appellants regarding consideration of the Provisions of Section 138B ibid.
14. In view of the above discussions and analysis, we do not find any merits in the Impugned order, In confirming 2374 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the adjudged demands against the appellants. Therefore, the impugned order is set-aside and the appeals filed by the appellants are allowed.”
12. In such circumstances, referred to above, the revenue is here before this Court with the present appeals.
13. We heard Ms. Nisha Bagchi, the learned senior counsel appearing for the revenue and Mr. Ashish Batra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
14. The learned counsel appearing for the revenue would vehemently submit that the Tribunal committed a serious error in allowing the appeals filed by the assessee on the ground of non-compliance of Section 138C(4) of the Act, 1962. She would submit that there is cogent and sufficient evidence on record to indicate compliance of Section 138C(4) of the Act, 1962 in substance.
15. She would further submit that the documents collected from the electronic devices owned by the assessees at the time of search have been duly acknowledged by the assessees in their statements recorded under Section 108 of the Act, 1962.
16. With a view to fortify her submissions noted aforesaid, she placed strong reliance on the decision of this Court in the case of Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal and Others reported in (2020) 7 SSC 1, more particularly, the observations made by the Court in Paras 51 and 52, respectively.
17. The paras 51 and 52 respectively read thus:- “51. On an application of the aforesaid maxims to the present case, it is clear that though Section 65-B(4) is mandatory, yet, on the facts of this case, the respondents, having done everything possible to obtain the necessary certificate, which was to be given by a third party over whom the respondents had no control, must be relieved of the mandatory obligation contained in the said subsection.
52. We may hasten to add that Section 65-B does not speak of the stage at which such certificate must be furnished to the Court. In Anvar P.V. [Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2375Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. SCC 473 : (2015) 1 SCC (Civ) 27 : (2015) 1 SCC (Cri) 24 : (2015) 1 SCC (L&S) 108] , this Court did observe that such certificate must accompany the electronic record when the same is produced in evidence. We may only add that this is so in cases where such certificate could be procured by the person seeking to rely upon an electronic record. However, in cases where either a defective certificate is given, or in cases where such certificate has been demanded and is not given by the person concerned, the Judge conducting the trial must summon the person/persons referred to in Section 65-B(4) of the Evidence Act, and require that such certificate be given by such person/persons. This, the trial Judge ought to do when the electronic record is produced in evidence before him without the requisite certificate in the circumstances aforementioned. This is, of course, subject to discretion being exercised in civil cases in accordance with law, and in accordance with the requirements of justice on the facts of each case. When it comes to criminal trials, it is important to keep in mind the general principle that the accused must be supplied all documents that the prosecution seeks to rely upon before commencement of the trial, under the relevant sections of the CrPC.”
18. In the course of the hearing of these appeals, the learned counsel appearing for the revenue provided us with a compilation consisting of documents in the form of Record of Proceedings dated 06.07.2015, 21.07.2015 and 21.04.2016 respectively.
19. The Record of Proceeding dated 06.07.2015 reads thus:- “In connection with the investigations in respect of imports made by M/s Suresh Kumar & Co. (Impex) Pvt. Ltd. (SKCO) A-17, Sonu Tower, IInd Floor, Dr. Mukherjee Nagar Commercial Complex, Delhi - 110 009, the officers of Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (Hqrs.), 7th floor, I.P. Bhawan, I..P. Estate, New Delhi (herein after referred to as the DRI) vide Panchnama dated 16.06.2015 drawn at office-cum-godown Building No.1092, Bhalswa Village, Near Azadpur Bypass, Delhi - 110 033, had resumed certain documents, Lenovo Make desktop and one laptops from the abovementioned office-cum- godown premises. 2376 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. In today’s proceeding, it was proposed to take the printouts of documents from the external Hard Disk of make WD Elements, bearing S/N WXE1A255RF18, which was copied under Records of Proceeding dated 19.06.2015 and 23.06.2015. Shri Sanjay Gupta, Senior Accountant of M/s SKCO and Shri Sushil Kumar, Assistant Accountant of M/s SKCO presented themselves at DRI (Hqrs.) office to witness the proceedings. One Envelope was produced before Shri Sanjay Gupta and Shri Sushil Kumar which was sealed with a paper slip containing dated signature of Shri Sanjay Gupta, Forensic Expert and DRI Officer. The paper seals on the said envelops was checked by Shri Sanjay Gupta and Shri Sushil Kumar, which was found intact.
3. Shri Sanjay Gupta removed the paper seal of the said envelop and took out one external Hard Disk of make WD Elements, bearing S/N WXE1A255RF18. The said external hard disk was connected to a computer installed in DRI (Hqrs.) office and certain printouts were taken from the said hard disk. The printouts were serially numbered from 1 to 103. Shri Sanjay Gupta and Shri Sushil Kumar put their dated signatures on all the said pages (s. no. 1 to 103) as a token of their authenticity and their presence during the course of printing of these documents from the said external hard disk.
4. Thereafter, the said external Hard Disk of make WD Elements, bearing S/N WXE1A255RF18 was put in an envelop and the said envelop was sealed with a paper slip bearing dated signatures of Shri Sanjay Gupta, Shri Sushil Kumar and the DRI Officer.
5. The proceedings started at 1200 hrs on 06.07.2015 and concluded at 2010 hrs on same day i.e. 06.07.2015. Shri Sanjay Gupta and Shri Sushil Kumar on being enquired by the DRI officers informed that they are fully agree to the contents of Records of Proceedings dated 06.07.2015 and that the contents were recorded as per the actual Proceedings”
20. The record of Proceeding dated 21.07.2015 reads thus:- [2025] 8 S.C.R. 2377Additional Director General Adjudication, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence v. Suresh Kumar and Co. Impex Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. “In connection with the investigations in respect of imports made by M/s Suresh Kumar & Co. (Impex) Pvt. Ltd. (SKCO A-17. Sonu Tower. IInd Floor. Dr. Mukherjee Nagar Commercial Complex. Delhi - 110 009. the officers of Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (Hqrs.). 7th floor. I.P. Bhawan. I.P. Estate, New Delhi (herein after referred to as the DRI) vide Panchnama dated 16.06.2015 drawn at office-cum-godown Building No.1092. Bhalswa Village. Near Azadpur Bypass. Delhi - 110 033 had resumed certain documents. Lenovo Make desktop and one laptops from the abovementioned office-cum-godown premises and resumed two laptops (one Sony make and one Asus make). one I-pad and one I-Phone from the residential premises vide Panchnama dated 16.06.2015 drawn at residential premises at B-111/303. 19. Rajpur Road. Delhi - 110 054. Another laptop of Sony make was submitted in DRI office by Shri Nikhil Asrani, Director of M/s Suresh Kumar & Co. (Impex) Pvt. Ltd. On 16.06.2015.
2. In today’s proceeding. It was proposed to take the printouts of e mail / documents from the external Hard Disk of make WD Elements, bearing S/N WX4 IA45DUD6E, which was copied under Records of Proceeding dated 29.06.2015. Shri Nikhil Asrani, Director of M/s SKCO presented himself at DRI (Hqrs.) office to witness the proceedings. One envelope was produced before Shri Nikhil Asrani which was sealed with a paper slip containing dated signature of Shri Sanjay Gupta and DRI Officer. The paper seals on the said envelops was checked by Shri Nikhil Asrani. which was found intact.
3. Shri Nikhil Asrani removed the paper seal of the said envelop and took out one external Hard Disk of make WD Elements, bearing S/N WX41 A45DUD6E. The said external hard disk was connected to a computer installed in DRI (Hqrs.) office and certain e mail data was extracted in Microsoft Outlook and certain printouts were taken from the said data. The printouts were serially numbered from l to 237. Shri Nikhil Asrani put his dated signatures on all the said pages (s. no. I to 237) as a token of their authenticity and his presence during the course of printing of these documents from the said external hard disk.
2378 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.