Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1020; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1444
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Cji and Augustine George Masih, Justice * J.]
- Decided
- 20 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3646/2025
- Sections
- 340, 362, 482, 4, 397, 195(1), 403, 2, 4(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1444 : 2025 INSC 1020 Vikram Bakshi and Others v.
R.P. Khosla and Another (Criminal Appeal No. 3646 of 2025)
20 August 2025 [B.R. Gavai, CJI and Augustine George Masih,* J.] Issue for Consideration Whether a review or recall of an order passed in a criminal proceeding initiated under section 340 of CrPC is permissible or not. Headnotes† Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.362 – Bar under – Scope and applicability – High Court recalled its earlier order disposing of the petition filed u/s.340 against the appellants for prosecution of offences of perjury and directed that the said application be listed for hearing:
Held: As envisaged under the CrPC, criminal courts are barred from altering or review their own judgments except for the exceptions explicitly provided by the statute, viz., correction of a clerical or an arithmetical error that might have been committed or the said power is provided under any other law for the time being in force – As the courts become functus officio the very moment a judgment or an order is signed, the bar of s.362 becomes applicable, this, despite the powers provided u/s.482 which, this veil cannot allow the courts to step beyond or circumvent an explicit bar – Bar u/s.362 is to be applied stricto sensu – It is only in situations wherein an application for recall of an order or judgment seeking a “procedural review” that the bar would not apply and not a “substantive review” where the bar as contained in s.362 is attracted – Neither the impugned order falls within the ambit of “procedural review” to not attract the bar of s.362 CrPC, nor is it the case of the ‘KG’ that they were either denied a hearing before the High Court or were not given an opportunity to inform the court of the said development – Furthermore, an act to undermine the finality of the judicial proceedings cannot be permitted especially in situations of deliberate omissions or * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1445Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another misrepresentation on the part of the parties before the court and thereafter attempting to defend themselves and obtaining the verboten order (Impugned Order) substantially reviewing and recalling the Judgment dated 13.08.2020, under the garb of “procedural review” which is impermissible – Impugned Order set aside. [Paras 34, 43-45] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.362 – Bar under – Exceptional circumstances wherein a criminal court is empowered to alter or review its own judgment or a final order u/s.362, enumerated – Exercise of, when:
Held: All these exceptions are only exercisable for seeking a recall or review of an order or judgment, if a ground that is raised was not available or existent at the time of original proceedings before the Court – Mere fact that the said ground, although available, was not raised or pressed during the concerned proceedings, does not provide for an exemption to the parties to assert it as a ground – Moreover, the said power cannot be invoked as a means to circumvent the finality of the judicial process or mistakes and/or errors in the decision which are attributable to a conscious omission by the parties. [Para 34] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.4, 2(g), 340 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Review Petition u/Or.XLVII – Maintainability:
Held: A proceeding under section 340 of CrPC is in the nature of criminal proceeding and governed by the provisions of the CrPC, as a consequence, thereof, all the procedural safeguards, consequences, and effects thereto associated with a criminal proceeding under CrPC are also attracted to it – The proceedings initiated u/s.340 of CrPC are of criminal nature and governed by the provisions of CrPC which is a self-contained Code, and includes entire procedure within itself to deal with the proceedings initiated under its provisions, there is no scope for application of provisions of any other procedural law until specifically provided under such law – In the present case, the review application was filed by ‘KG’ u/Order XLVII of CPC 1908 before High Court – The CPC 1908 does not expressly provide for a provision wherein a review can be filed in the proceedings of criminal nature initiated 1446 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports under CrPC – Thus, the said petition filed by ‘KG’ under provisions of CPC 1908 could not have been entertained by the High Court being not maintainable. [Paras 38-40] Case Law Cited Sanjeev Kapoor v. Chandana Kapoor and Others [2020] 1 SCR 663 : (2020) 13 SCC 172; Ganesh Patel v. Umakant Rajoria, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 2050; Grindlays Bank Ltd. v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal and Others [1981] 2 SCR 341 : (1980) Supp. SCC 420; State of Kerala v. M.M. Manikantan Nair [2001] 3 SCR 203 : (2001) 4 SCC 752; Hari Singh Mann v. Harbhajan Singh Bajwa and Others [2000] Supp. 4 SCR 313 : (2001) 1 SCC 169; Budhia Swain and Others v. Gopinath Deb and Others [1999] 2 SCR 1189 : (1999) 4 SCC 396 – referred to.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. List of Keywords Section 340 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Section 362 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Review or recall of an order passed in a criminal proceeding; Bar under Section 362 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Criminal courts barred from altering or review their own judgments; Perjury; Proceedings initiated under section 340 of CrPC are criminal; Functus officio; Procedural review; Not a substantive review; Review Petition under Order XLVII, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Company Law Board; Company Petition. Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
3646 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.05.2021 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in COA No. 579 of 2020 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Jay Savla, Sr. Adv., Anand Mohan Mishra, Jasdeep Singh Dhillon, Prabhat Chaurasia, Anirudh Jamwal, Yugantar Singh Chauhan, Deepak Khosla, Arpit Shukla, Shibu Devasia Olickal, Rahul Gupta. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1447Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another Advs. for the Respondents:
Jay Savla, Sr. Adv., Anand Mohan Mishra, Jasdeep Singh Dhillon, Prabhat Chaurasia, Anirudh Jamwal, Arpit Shukla, Deepak Khosla, M/s. Equity Lex Associates.
Petitioner-in-person.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Augustine George Masih, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The instant Criminal Appeal assails the Judgment and Order dated 05.05.2021 (hereinafter “Impugned Order”) passed by the High Court of Delhi (hereinafter, “High Court”), whereby it recalled its earlier Judgment dated 13.08.2020 which had disposed of Criminal Miscellaneous (Co.) No. 4 of 2019 filed under Section 340 Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (hereinafter, “CrPC”) against the Appellants for prosecution of offences of perjury and directed that the said application be listed for hearing. In the Judgment dated 13.08.2020, the High Court declined to interfere in the matter in view of the directions of this Court in Judgment dated 08.05.2014 passed in SLP (Criminal) No. 6873 of 2010 whereby dispute between the parties in relation to their Company Petition No.114 of 2007 (hereinafter “CP 114 of 2007”) and other related matters arising out of it was to be decided by Company Law Board (hereinafter, “CLB”).
3. The Appellants before us are Mr. Vikram Bakshi, Mr. Vinod Surha and Mr. Wadia Prakash while Mr. R.P. Khosla is the Contesting Respondent No.1 and Mr. Anand Mohan Mishra is Proforma Respondent No.2.
4. Briefly, the facts relevant for adjudication of the case in hand is that two groups, namely, the Khosla Group (comprising of Mr. R.P. Khosla, Mr. Deepak Khosla - son of R.P. Khosla and Ms. Sonia Khosla wife of Mr. Deepak Khosla) and the Bakshi Group (comprising of Mr. Vikram Bakshi, Mr. Vinod Surha and Mr. Wadia Prakash) came together in relation to development of a resort at Kasauli in the State of Himachal Pradesh on the land owned by the Khosla Group where the Bakshi Group was to finance and manage the entire project. 1448 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. The undisputed facts as presented and extracted from material on record are that a Memorandum of Understanding dated 21.12.2005 (hereinafter “MoU”) was entered between Mr. Deepak Khosla (representing Khosla Group), Mr. R.P. Khosla, Mr. Vikram Bakshi and Montreaux Resorts Private Limited (hereinafter “MRPL”) for development of the project.
6. The MRPL was a Special Purpose Vehicle incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 for execution of the said project. As the terms of MoU required transferring of shareholding in MRPL by Khosla Group to Mr. Vikram Bakshi subject to fulfilment of certain conditions, an Agreement dated 31.03.2006 was executed between Ms. Sonia Khosla, Mr. R.P. Khosla, Mr. Vikram Bakshi and MRPL, transferring 51% shareholding in MRPL to Mr. Vikram Bakshi. Pursuant to that, Mr. Vinod Surha and Mr. Wadia Prakash (of Bakshi Group) were appointed as Additional Directors in the MRPL.
7. Owing to subsequent disagreements, Ms. Sonia Khosla in her capacity as minority shareholder of MRPL, filed CP 114 of 2007 under section 397/398 of Companies Act, 1956 on 13.08.2007 before CLB alleging oppression and mismanagement by the Bakshi Group, inter alia, contending that her shareholding in MRPL had been illegally reduced from 49% to 36% and sought removal of the Directors representing the Bakshi Group from the Board of Directors.
8. An application, C.A. No. 572/2007, in CP 114 of 2007 was filed by the Khosla Group praying to restrain the Bakshi Group from holding a meeting between themselves regarding the affairs of MRPL scheduled on 26.12.2007 claiming that the appointment of Directors belonging to the Bakshi Group was not confirmed as per the Minutes of Annual General Meeting (hereinafter “AGM”) dated 30.09.2006 of MRPL, implying that they had ceased to be Directors and therefore cannot hold meeting of MRPL. CLB accepted the request and vide Order dated 24.12.2007 directed deferment of the aforesaid meeting scheduled for 26.12.2007.
9. Thereafter, while dealing with the CP 114 of 2007, the CLB vide Order dated 31.01.2008 directed maintenance of status quo with respect to the shareholding and composition of the Board of Directors in MRPL as existed on the date of the filing of said Company Petition by Ms. Sonia Khosla.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1449Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another
10. Aggrieved by the Order dated 31.01.2008, Mr. R.P. Khosla moved the High Court by filing Company Appeal (SB) No. 7 of 2008, which came to be disposed of as not pressed by the Appellant therein vide Order dated 11.04.2008 as the High Court was informed that the parties have agreed that CP 114 of 2007 shall be withdrawn by Ms. Sonia Khosla and the dispute has already been referred to arbitration as per the terms of Agreement dated 31.03.2006. Furthermore, the parties had agreed to maintain status quo with respect to their shareholding in MRPL as it stood at the time of filing of CP 114 of 2007.
11. It needs mention here that Ms. Sonia Khosla had also assailed the same Order dated 31.01.2008 passed by the CLB in Company Appeal (SB) No. 6 of 2008 in which the High Court relying extensively upon the Order dated 11.04.2008 passed in Company Appeal (SB) No. 7 of 2008 dismissed the said appeal vide Order dated 22.04.2008 noting that agreement in terms of maintaining of status quo in shareholding and Board of Directors of MRPL has been achieved between parties.
12. In an attempt to prolong the litigation and not to be confined to 36% shareholding in MRPL, Mr. R.P. Khosla and Ms. Sonia Khosla had filed review petitions against Order dated 11.04.2008 in Company Appeal (SB) No. 7 of 2008 and Order dated 22.04.2008 in Company Appeal (SB) No. 6 of 2008 respectively before the High Court, these came to be dismissed on 06.05.2008.
13. In the interregnum, Bakshi Group filed an application being C.A. No. 1 of 2008 in CP 114 of 2007 before CLB seeking vacation of its Order dated 24.12.2007 leading to deferment of the meeting of MRPL scheduled on 26.12.2007. It was asserted in the said application that Mr. Vinod Surha and Mr. Wadia Prakash were confirmed as Directors of the MRPL as per the minutes of AGM held on 30.09.2006. It is at this stage, the litigation between the parties took a different turn altogether.
14. Alleging the Minutes of AGM of the MRPL dated 30.09.2006 as filed by Bakshi Group in C.A. No. 1 of 2008 are forged, Ms. Sonia Khosla filed an application under Section 340 of CrPC before the CLB seeking their prosecution for perjury.
15. However, citing inaction on the part of CLB, Ms. Sonia Khosla moved the High Court by filing Criminal Miscellaneous (Co.) No. 3 of 2008 seeking same relief of initiation of prosecution against Bakshi group 1450 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports under section 195(1)(b) and 195(4) read with section 340 (1) of CrPC for forgery and perjury with reference to claim made in C.A. 1 of 2008 and concerned affidavits filed by the Bakshi Group in CP 114 of 2007 before CLB.
16. Herein, the High Court, vide an interim Order dated 15.02.2010 directed the Registrar (Vigilance) of the High Court to hold a preliminary inquiry into the genuineness of the minutes of AGM dated 30.09.2006. This order dated 15.02.2010 was challenged by the Bakshi Group in SLP (Criminal) No. 6873 of 2010 contending that the Criminal Miscellaneous (Co.) No. 3 of 2008 filed by Ms. Sonia Khosla under section 340 of CrPC before the High Court was not maintainable.
17. This Court, vide Judgment dated 08.05.2014 in SLP (Criminal) No. 6873 of 2010, passed a consent order recording the submission of the parties that once the Company Petition i.e., CP 114 of 2007 itself is decided, the issue relating to the genuineness of the minutes of AGM dated 30.09.2006, as raised in the application under Section 340 of CrPC before the CLB, would also be addressed by the CLB. This Court accordingly directed the CLB to decide CP 114 of 2007 filed by Ms. Sonia Khosla within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a copy of the order. It was further directed that the High Court ought not proceed further with the application moved by Ms. Sonia Khosla under Section 340 of CrPC.
18. The relevant part of the Judgment dated 08.05.2014 passed by this Court is produced herein:
“21. In fact, though the learned Senior Counsel for the parties had argued the matters before us at length on the previous occasions, at the stage of conclusions of the arguments, the learned Senior Counsel Mr. Cama appearing for Khosla Group suggested for an early decision of the Company Petition before the CLB as a better alternative so that at least main dispute between the parties is adjudicated upon at an early date. He was candid in his submission that the issues which are subject matter of these two Special Leave Petitions and arise out of the proceedings in the High Court, have their origin in the orders dated 31.1.2008, which is an interim order passed by the CLB. He thus, pointed out that once the Company [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1451Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another Petition itself is decided, the issues involved therein namely whether Board meeting dated 14.12.2007 was illegal or whether Board meeting dated 30.9.2006 was barred in law would also get decided. In the process the CLB would also be in a position to decide as to whether minutes of AGM of the Company allegedly held on 30.9.2006 are forged or not and on that basis application under Section 340 Cr. PC which is filed before the Company Law Boared [sic] Board would also be taken care of by the CLB itself. Learned Senior Counsels appearing for the Bakshi Group immediately agreed with the aforesaid course of action suggested by Mr. Cama. We are happy that at least there is an agreement between both the parties on the procedural course of action, to give quietus to the matters before us as well. In view of the aforesaid consensus, about the course of action to be adopted in deciding the disputes between the parties, we direct the Company Law Board to decide Company Petition No. 114 of 2007 filed before it by Ms. Sonia Khosla within a period of six months from the date of receiving a copy of this order. Since, it is the CLB which will be deciding the application under Section 340 Cr PC filed by Ms. Sonia Khosla in the CLB, High Court need not proceed further with the Criminal Misc.
(Co.). No. 3 of 2008. Likewise the question whether Mr. R.K. Garg was validly inducted as a Director or not would be gone into by the CLB, the proceedings in Co. Appeal No. (SB) 23 of 2009 filed by Mr. R.K. Garg in the High Court, also become otiose.
22. The only aspect on which some directions need to be given are, as to what should be the interim arrangement. The Bakshi Group wants orders dated 31.1.2008 passed by CLB to continue the interregnum. The Khosla Group on the other hand refers to orders dated 11.4.2008 as it is their submission that this was a consent order passed by the High Court after the orders of the CLB and, therefore, this order should govern the field in the meantime.
23. After considering the matter, we are of the opinion that it is not necessary to either enforce orders dated 31.1.2008 passed by the CLB or orders dated 11.4.2008 passed by the 1452 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports High Court. Fact remains that there has been a complete deadlock, as far as affairs of the Company are concerned. The project has not taken off. It is almost dead at present. Unless the parties re-concile, there is no chance for a joint venture i.e. to develop the resort, as per the MOU dated 21.12.2005. It is only after the decision of CLB, whereby the respective rights of the parties are crystallised, it would be possible to know about the future of this project. Even the Company in question is also defunct at present as it has no other business activity or venture. In a situation like this, we are of the opinion that more appropriate orders would be to direct the parties to maintain status quo in the meantime, during the pendency of the aforesaid company petition before the CLB. However, we make it clear that if any exigency arises necessitating some interim orders, it would be open to the parties to approach the CLB for appropriate directions.
24. Both these petitions are disposed of in the aforesaid terms. All other pending I.As including criminal contempt petitions and petitions filed under Section 340 Cr. PC are also disposed of as in the facts of this case, we are not inclined to entertain such application. No costs.”
19. The Criminal Miscellaneous (Co.) No. 3 of 2008 came to be dismissed vide Order dated 03.12.2018 of the High Court in consonance with Judgment dated 08.05.2014 passed in SLP (Criminal) No. 6873 of 2010 by this Court.
20. Reverting to the High Court’s Orders dated 11.04.2008 and 22.04.2008 in Company Appeal (SB) No. 7 of 2008 and Company Appeal (SB) No. 6 of 2008 respectively, a Contempt Petition being C.C.P. (Co.) No. 1 of 2009, was filed by the Khosla Group before the High Court alleging wilful disobedience of abovesaid Orders dated 11.04.2008 and 22.04.2008, this petition came to be withdrawn with liberty to file afresh with a proper array of parties.
21. Thereafter, the Khosla Group filed another application being Criminal Miscellaneous (Co) No. 4 of 2019 under Section 340 CrPC before the High Court alleging that the Bakshi Group had filed a counter-affidavit dated 24.02.2010 in C.C.P. (Co.) No. 1 of 2009 which contained false and contradictory statements. This application was disposed of [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1453Vikram Bakshi and Others v. R.P. Khosla and Another by the High Court vide Judgment dated 13.08.2020, observing that the CLB (which has now been replaced by National Company Law Tribunal, hereinafter “NCLT”) was seized of the matter as submitted by the Khosla Group that the CP 114 of 2007 was pending before NCLT, further taking note of the Judgment dated 08.05.2014 passed in SLP (Criminal) No. 6873 of 2010 by this Court that the CP 114 of 2007 and application under section 340 of CrPC was to be decided by the CLB/NCLT, the High Court decided not to interfere in the issue. Relevant portion of the Judgment dated 13.08.2020 passed by the High Court reads as follows:- “20. Broadly understood, the claim of the Petitioner is that if the claim of the Respondents in C.A.
No.1/2008 is that they were elected in the AGM held on 30.09.2006, then no EGM took place on 28.06.2006 and they were not elected in the said EGM. As a corollary if they had been elected in the EGM then a claim of having been elected in the AGM held on 30.09.2006 is false and the Minutes are forged, making the Respondents liable to punishment for perjury.
21. In my view the allegations in the present petition, directly or indirectly touch upon the Minutes of the AGM of 30.09.2006, which is the subject matter of adjudication before NCLT. While Mr. Khosla urges that this petition can be independently decided as it relates to the alleged EGM and certain other issues raised therein, but on a holistic reading of the petition, this Court is of the opinion that any decision in the present petition will have a bearing on the genuineness of AGM dated 30.09.2006 and other aspects sub-judice before NCLT, as the controversies are intrinsically linked.
22. It is apparent from the order passed by the Supreme Court, which was a consent order, that the parties chartered a course of action for further litigation and the path chosen was to have the entire dispute decided before the then CLB (now NCLT). In fact, it was the Petitioner Group which had put forth before 1454 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the Supreme Court that once the Company Petition is decided, the connected issues of the alleged illegalities in the various Board Meetings would be taken care of, including allegations qua AGM held on 30.09.2006. In this light Supreme Court directed the CLB to decide the Co. Pet. No. 114/2007 as also the Application under Section 340 Cr.PC. Apposite would it be to emphasize that the Supreme Court categorically directed the High Court not to proceed with Crl. Misc. (Co.) No. 3/2008 and the said petition has been dismissed by this Court, in the light of the observation of the Supreme Court.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.