Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1139; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1273
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 1 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3810/2025
- Sections
- 302, 374(2), 34, 313, 161, 3, 165, 168, 311, 348
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1273 : 2025 INSC 1139 Tarun Sharma v.
State of Haryana (Criminal Appeal No. 3810 of 2025)
01 September 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Conviction of the appellant u/s.302, IPC based on the statement/ dying declaration (Exh. P-34) of the deceased, if ought to be set aside.
Headnotes† Evidence – Dying declaration – When cannot be relied upon – Penal Code, 1860 – s.302 – FIR u/ss.323, 324, 506 r/w 34, IPC was registered on the basis of injured victim’s statement (Exh.P 34) – Victim died, s.302 was added to the case – Appellant along with co-accused persons was arrested – Trial court acquitted the co-accused persons however, the appellant was convicted u/s.302 – Conviction affirmed by High Court – Interference with:
Held: 1.1 Prosecution could neither prove the faithful recording of the statement/dying declaration nor they could prove it to be an unimpeachable document – Such a doubtful piece of evidence cannot be made the foundation of conviction of the appellant. [Para 64] 1.2 There are material infirmities in the case of prosecution – It was categorically stated by PW-1 (brother of the deceased) and corroborated by the Doctors (PW-9 and PW-10) who treated the deceased, that the deceased remained unconscious almost fully from the time of the assault on until his death, and was never in a condition to speak – Hence the fitness certificate becomes doubtful. [Paras 63] 1.3 Prosecution failed to identify or examine the doctor who had issued the fitness certificate, which creates grave doubt about the * Author 1274 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports authenticity of the fitness certificate – Furthermore, non-examination of the said doctor, deprived the defence an opportunity to discredit the fitness certificate. [Paras 63] 1.4 No contemporaneous medical record relating to the treatment of the deceased at the hospital was produced nor proved during trial, leaving the Court without corroborative material to assess the fitness of the injured to make a statement. [Para 63] 1.5 The statement/dying declaration itself suffers from serious infirmities as it bears no time of recording, and the recording officer, SI (PW-17), failed to record his own satisfaction that the injured was fit to make such statement. [Para 63] 1.6 Even the prosecution and trial Court did not fully accept the version set out in the statement/dying declaration, inasmuch as one of the named assailants, was not charge sheeted, and another, (accused No. 3), was acquitted by the trial Court. [Para 63] 1.7 PW-1, who was present with the deceased at the time of the incident, categorically deposed that the accused present in Court had not caused any injuries to the deceased and further stated that the assailants could not be identified due to darkness, thereby significantly contradicting the version set out in the statement/dying declaration. [Para 63] 1.8 Prosecution miserably failed to establish the complicity of the appellant for the commission of the crime – There are serious lapses surrounding the recording of the statement/dying declaration coupled with the material contradictions between its contents and the ocular testimony as well as the inconsequential recovery of the knife (purportedly used for causing injuries to the deceased) which is discredited for want of scientific corroboration – Impugned judgments set aside – Appellant acquitted. [Para 66] Judicial Deprecation – Adjudication of criminal appeal – Constitution of India – Art.21 – Right to fair trial – In the present case, High Court proceeded to take up the main appeal itself for hearing on merits when the matter was listed only for consideration of an application regarding renewal of the registration certificate of the Alto car seized during investigation – Since the counsel engaged by the appellantaccused was not available, the Court appointed an amicus [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1275Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
curiae and, without granting a reasonable opportunity to prepare the matter, it heard the appeal on merits and reserved judgment on the very same day:
Held: Approach adopted by the High Court is short of standards of fairness and is particularly more disturbing and unjustified as the accused was sentenced to life imprisonment – Deprecated – The hearing in a criminal trial or appeal must be an effective hearing – This necessarily presupposes not only the presence of counsel but also the grant of adequate time and opportunity for such counsel, whether engaged by the accused or appointed as an amicus curiae, to properly prepare and present the case – To appoint an amicus and proceed to hear the matter on the very same day, without affording sufficient time for preparation or consultation, renders the safeguard of effective legal representation to an empty formality and undermines the very essence of the right to fair trial enshrined under Art.21 – Word of caution to Courts – In criminal trials and appeals, especially those involving punishment of life imprisonment or capital sentence, the concerned Courts must not treat the appointment of an amicus curiae as an empty formality – Such counsel must be afforded sufficient time to peruse the record, meet the accused, and prepare the defence effectively – The principles of fair trial and effective representation are not procedural gimmicks but foundational guarantees of criminal justice system, which cannot be compromised or breached. [Paras 33, 38, 39] Evidence – Recovery – Of knife – No scientific corroboration – Evidentiary value – Conviction of the appellant u/s.302, IPC – Apart from the statement/dying declaration (Exh. P-34), Trial Court and the High Court also relied on the recovery of the knife made in furtherance of the disclosure statement (Exh. P-24) of the accused-appellant:
Held: The evidentiary value of this recovery is undermined by the fact that the FSL report (Exh. P-1) did not indicate any blood group on the said weapon, nor was any serological report produced to establish that the blood allegedly found on the knife matched with that of the deceased – In the absence of such scientific corroboration linking the recovered knife with the deceased, the recovery remains inconsequential – Otherwise also mere recovery of a weapon, even if stained by the same blood group as that of 1276 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the deceased cannot by itself establish the guilt of an accused, particularly where the prosecution’s primary evidence, namely the statement/dying declaration (Exh. P-34) suffers from serious infirmities. [Para 65] Evidence of hostile witness – Admissibility/reliability – Principles governing, discussed. [Paras 45-48] Case Law Cited Chaluvegowda v. State (2012) 13 SCC 538; Mohd. Sukur Ali v. State of Assam [2011] 3 SCR 209 : (2011) 4 SCC 729; Anokhilal v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2019] 18 SCR 1196 : (2019) 20 SCC 196; C. Muniappan v. State of T.N [2010] 10 SCR 262 : (2010) 9 SCC 567; K.P. Tamilmaran v. State, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 958; Laxman v. State of Maharashtra [2002] Supp. 1 SCR 697 : (2002) 6 SCC 710; Atbir v. Govt. (NCT of Delhi) [2010] 9 SCR 993 : (2010) 9 SCC 1; Raja Naykar v. State of Chhattisgarh (2024) 3 SCC 481 – relied on.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Constitution of India; Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
List of Keywords Dying declaration; Serious lapses surrounding the recording of the statement/dying declaration; Deceased remained unconscious; Not in a condition to speak; Fitness certificate; Fitness certificate doubted/doubtful; Doctor who issued fitness certificate not examined; Disclosure statement; Recovery; Inconsequential recovery of the knife; No scientific corroboration; Approach adopted by the High Court in dealing with the criminal appeal; Grant of adequate time and opportunity to counsel; Principles of fair trial; Right to fair trial; Effective hearing; Effective representation; Amicus curiae; Not affording sufficient time for preparation or consultation; Punishment of life imprisonment or capital sentence; Recovery inconsequential; Eye-witnesses turned hostile; Testimony of hostile witnesses; Evidentiary value of recovery.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1277Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No.
3810 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.09.2024 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRAD No. 1161 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ajay Tewari, Sr. Adv., Abhimanyu Tewari, Siddhant Saroha, Sidhant Awasthy, Aniket Kumar Parcha.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Lokesh Sinhal, Sr. A.A.G., Akshay Amritanshu, Nikunj Gupta, Ms. Ishika Gupta, Ms. Drishti Rawal, Ms. Drishti Saraf, Sarthak Srivastava, Mayur Goyal, Ms. Aakanksha, Ms. Seema Sindhu, Ms. Kirti, Sarthak Arya.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. This appeal by special leave takes exception to the judgment dated 24th September, 2024 passed by the Division Bench of High Court of Punjab and Haryana 1 in CRA-D-1161-DB-2013 whereby the appeal preferred by the appellant under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 2 was dismissed and the judgment and order dated 26 th August, 2013 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Ambala 3 in Sessions Case No. 11-SC of 2012 was affirmed.
4. By the aforesaid judgment, the trial Court convicted the accusedappellant for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the 1 Hereinafter being referred to as the “High Court”.
2 For short, “CrPC”.
3 Hereinafter being referred to as the “trial Court”.
1278 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Indian Penal Code, 1860 4 and sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and to pay a fine of Rs.5000/-, in default, to further undergo simple imprisonment for three months.
Brief Facts: -
5. Succinctly stated, the case of the prosecution is that on 1st April, 2012, an information was received at the police station Mullana at around 05:30 PM regarding admission of one Munish Kumar into GMCH Sector 32, Chandigarh in an injured condition. On receipt of this information, Sub-Inspector, Somnath (PW-17), along with Head Constable, Dharam Pal (PW-11) proceeded to the said hospital where they were apprised that injured Munish Kumar had been shifted to the PGI, Chandigarh for treatment. Accordingly, the police officials proceeded to the PGI, Chandigarh and filed an application (Exh. P-32) before the concerned Medical Officer seeking opinion regarding the fitness of Munish Kumar to give a statement. It is stated that the Medical Officer recorded his opinion (Exh. P-33) declaring the injured Munish Kumar to be fit for making a statement. Thereupon, the Sub- Inspector, Somnath (PW-17), proceeded to record the statement of the injured Munish Kumar (Exh. P-34) wherein he alleged inter alia as below: - “He was a resident of Village Jahangirpur, P.S. Mullana and was doing a private job. On 31 st March, 2012, at about 10:00 PM, he and his brother Amit were returning to their village from Ambala by car. When they reached near Mullana, they were intercepted by a Scorpio car and an Alto car. Three persons alighted from one of the vehicles, two of whom were alleged to be Bittoo and Sanjay and the other person was connected to Krishna Transport who went by the name of Tarun Sharma. He did not know the identity of the other man. These persons broke into his car and launched an attack on him. Tarun Sharma inflicted a knife blow on the right side of his stomach whereas Sanjay inflicted a knife blow on his head. Bittoo and the other bearded person held him down. The assailants beat him up mercilessly. Amit was kept confined in the car. 4 For short, “IPC”.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1279Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
The assailants took away his mobile and the purse. Amit called his friends who got Munish admitted at the CHC, Mullana from where he was shifted to the Government Hospital, Ambala Cantt and then to General Hospital, Ambala City. Subsequently, he was referred to GMCH, Sector-32, Chandigarh and thereafter was referred to PGI Chandigarh.”
6. The aforesaid statement of the injured Munish Kumar was treated to be the first information report of the incident and based thereupon, an FIR No. 58 dated 1st April, 2012 came to be registered at P.S. Mullana for the offences punishable under Sections 323, 324, 506 read with Section 34 of the IPC.
7. The investigation was undertaken by Sub-Inspector, Somnath (PW- 17). Munish Kumar expired on 14 th April, 2012, upon which offence punishable under Section 302 IPC was added to the case. Inquest panchnama was drawn and thereafter, postmortem was carried out on the dead body of the deceased and statements of witnesses were recorded. The accused Tarun Sharma (accused No.1/appellant herein), Sandeep Sharma (accused No. 2), Balwinder Singh (accused No. 3) and Deepak Bhardwaj (accused No. 4) were arrested. It is alleged that, acting in furtherance of information/disclosure statement (Exh. P-24) dated 11 th April, 2012, the accused-appellant proceeded to point out the knife purportedly used for causing injuries to Munish Kumar. The said knife was recovered and seized vide seizure memo (Exh. P-6).
8. It is relevant to mention that, at a later stage of investigation, the prosecution tried to claim that Ashok Kumar (PW-2) was also present in the same vehicle in which the deceased Munish Kumar was travelling.
9. Upon conclusion of investigation, Sub-Inspector, Randhir Singh (PW-25), found Sanjay to be innocent and hence he was not charge sheeted in the case.
10. Chargesheet was filed against Tarun Sharma (accused No. 1/ appellant herein), Sandeep Sharma (accused No. 2), Balwinder Singh (accused No. 3) and Deepak Bhardwaj (accused No. 4) for the offences punishable under Sections 323, 324, 302, 506 read with Section 34 of the IPC.
1280 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11. The case was committed and made over to the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge, Ambala for trial. Charges were framed against the accused persons for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC who pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
12. The prosecution examined 25 witnesses (as per table below) and exhibited certain documents to prove its case.
PW-1 Amit Bakshi (Brother of deceased Munish Kumar)
PW-2 Ashok Kumar PW-3 Ved Prakash PW-4 Om Prakash PW-5 Narinder Singh PW-6 Head Constable Ram Saran PW-7 Sub-Inspector Yameen PW-8 Shashi Sharma PW-9 Dr. Vijay Vivek PW-10 Dr. Nand Kumar Jha PW-11 Head Constable Dharam Pal PW-12 Head Constable Dharamveer PW-13 Additional Sub-Inspector Baldev Singh PW-14 Additional Sub-Inspector Girdhari Lal PW-15 Head Constable Bahadur Singh PW-16 Head Constable Amit Kumar PW-17 Sub-Inspector Somnath [Recording officer of Dying Declaration (Exh. P34)] PW-18 Dr. Amandeep Singh PW-19 Constable Gurmeet Singh PW-20 Sub-Inspector Balwant Singh PW-21 Kuldeep Singh PW-22 Additional Sub-Inspector Rajinder Singh PW-23 Head Constable Dhoom Singh PW-24 Sub-Inspector Rishi Kumar PW-25 Inspector Randhir Singh [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1281Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
13. The accused were questioned under Section 313 CrPC and upon being confronted with the circumstances appearing against them in the prosecution evidence, they denied the same and claimed to be innocent. However, no evidence was led in defence.
14. It may be stated here that the star prosecution witnesses Amit Bakshi (PW-1), brother of the deceased Munish Kumar, and Ashok Kumar (PW-2), did not support the prosecution case and were declared hostile.
15. Likewise, Ved Prakash (PW-3), Om Parkash (PW-4) and Narinder Singh (PW-5) who were also projected as eye-witnesses did not support the prosecution case.
16. Dr. Vijay Vivek (PW-9) deposed that on 31 st March, 2012, he was serving as a Medical Officer at the Community Health Centre, Mullana. At about 10:05 PM, injured Munish Kumar was brought to the emergency ward by his relative with the complaint of having been assaulted on Devi Mandir Road. On examination, the injured Munish Kumar was found to be drowsy due to probable alcohol consumption, and smell of alcohol was also present in his breath. The condition of the patient was serious, and he was complaining of darkness before his eyes. His blood pressure was found to be low. The doctor noticed two clean lacerated wounds, one measuring 4 cm on the right lateral side of the chest, and the other measuring 3 cm on the lower lip, placed obliquely on the left lateral side. Considering the serious condition of the patient, he was referred to the General Hospital, Ambala City for expert opinion and further management.
17. Dr. Nand Kumar Jha (PW-10) deposed that on 1 st April, 2012 at about 01:15 AM, injured Munish Kumar was brought to the emergency ward by his father, Sardari Lal, and was admitted in the casualty ward of the Trauma Centre at the General Hospital, Ambala City. He examined Munish Kumar and found a stab wound 4 cm x 2 cm, obliquely placed on posterior axillary line on the lower lateral side of right chest, with oozing of blood. Two more injuries were observed: one on the lower jaw, and another on the posterior part of the parietal region, both with oozing of blood. Munish Kumar was referred to GMCH, Sector-32, Chandigarh for ultrasonography and further management.
1282 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
18. Head Constable Dharam Pal (PW-11) deposed about the disclosure statement made by the accused-appellant (Exh. P-24) leading to the recovery of a knife seized vide seizure memo (Exh. P-6). Likewise, the witness (PW-11) also stated about the recovery of a Danda and other weapons at the instance of Sandeep Sharma (accused No.2).
19. ASI Baldev Singh (PW-13) deposed about the disclosure statements made by the accused-appellant and the recoveries made in pursuance thereof.
20. We may note at this stage that though the Investigating Officer claims to have effected recoveries of weapons at the instance of the accused, the fact remains that the prosecution did not place on record or prove any serological report for connecting the recovered weapons with the deceased based on blood group matching.
21. Since the eye-witnesses Amit Bakshi (PW-1) and Ashok Kumar (PW- 2) turned hostile, the substratum of the prosecution case hinges on the statement/dying declaration (Exh. P-34) of deceased Munish Kumar purportedly recorded by Sub-Inspector, Somnath (PW-17).
22. In this backdrop, the evidence of Sub-Inspector, Somnath (PW-17), is considered most relevant for disposal of the appeal and hence, the relevant portion of the same are extracted hereinbelow: - “That on 31.3.2012, I was posted as SI Police Station Mullana. On that day, I received rukka from PGI Sector- 32, Chandigarh regarding admission of injured Munish Kumar. On this information I along with HC Dharampal reached in PGI, Chandigarh. I moved an application Ex P32 seeking opinion of the doctor as to whether the injured was fit to make statement or not and who vide his opinion Ex P33 declared injured fit to make statement. Amit Kumar brother of injured Munish Kumar was also present near Munish Kumar. In his presence Injured Munish Kumar volunteerly got recorded his statement which is Ex P34 (Objected to). He signed this statement at point A. Thereafter, I made endorsement under neath his statement which is Ex P35 (objected to) and send the rukka through HC Dharampal to the police station for registration of the case. On the basis of which formal FIR E P36 was recorded [2025] 9 S.C.R. 1283Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
by ASI Rishi Kumar. I identify his signature as I have seen him writing and signing during my official duties. He also made his endorsement Ex 237 on the rukka.
On 11.4.2012, I arrested accused Tarun Kumar present in the court today. On my interrogation accused Tarun Kumar suffered a disclosure statement Ex P24 to the effect that the knife with which he had caused injuries to Munish Kumar, had been kept concealed by him in the drawer of the table lying in his shop and he could get the same recovered after demarcation. This disclosure statement was signed by accused as well as by HC Dharam Pal.
Accused Tarun Sharma led the police party to his shop and after demarcation got recovered one knife (Chhuri) the sketch of the same Ex P7 was prepared and it was converted into a parcel and sealed with the seal of SN and it was taken into possession vide memo Ex P6. The sketch and recovered memo was attested by accused, Ved Parkash and HC Dharampal.”
(Emphasis supplied)
23. In cross-examination the witness (PW-17) stated as below: - “I had received Telephonic Message from police post of GMCH, Sector-32, Chandigarh on 31.3.2012 at about 1.30 PM. Prior to it no information was received from either CHC Mullana or Civil Hospital, Ambala. I had received these rukkas from the doctors of CHC Mullana and Civil Hospital Ambala again said only from CHC Mullana. I had never visited Civil Hospital, Ambala I did not receive or collect any medical report of deceased from Civil Hospital Ambala city. Information which was received in the night from GMCH, Chandigarh was recorded in DDR of Police Station, Mullana. I cannot produce DD entry which was recorded in this regarded I have seen court file the same is not available there also. It was not made Spart of charge sheet of the case.
It has come to my notice that Injured was referred to Civil Hospital, Ambala by the medical officer of CHC Muliana. 1284 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports I cannot tell at what time, by whom deceased was referred GMCH, Sector 32, Chandigarh and what time he reached there. I had received the police information with regard to this case from CH Ambala City during the course of investigation on 1.4.2012 I had received this rukka 10.00/11.00 am from Police Post Civil Hospital Ambala City. I am not sure if I collected this rukka from Police Post Sector -7, Ambala City. Despite the information from GMCH, Sector-32 Chandigarh at 11.30 AM on 31.3.2012 I did not proceed to that Hospital.
None from the family of the deceased or any of his friend or relative met me till the time I proceeded to Chandigarh on 1.4.2012. From the information which was received by me on 31:3.2012 at 11.30 PM. I came to know the name of injured, place of resident and also name of the person who had taken into hospital. Despite this fact I did not visit to the house of injured which is situated in village Jhahangirpur. Village Jhahangirpur falls within the jurisdiction of police Station Mullana.
I remained associated the investigation of this case for a period about one month. I have seen Ex.P4 which is the statement of Shri Ashok Bakshi. Statement of Ashok Bakshi was recorded on 22.6.2012. Ashok Bakshi was never brought or appear before me to make statement. This fact was not brought before me and Ashok Bakshi was in the car of Munish Baxshi. I cannot say Sh. Ashok Bakshi had stated in statement u/s 161 Cr.P.C. that he was with Munish Bakshi in his car on 31.3.2012 and he had not stated that Amit Bakshi was with him/ them. I have seen hand written statement of Ashok Bakshi in the police file which is original statement and Ex P4 is the computerized copy of the same. Name of any of other accused except the name mentioned in the FIR was given to me by Amit Bakshi or Ashok Bakshi or any of the family members of Munish Bakshi. The involvement of Deepak or Balwinder Singh was not disclosed to me by any of the witness.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1285Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
24. As is discernible from the above statement, the witness (PW-17) was responsible for moving the application (Exh. P-32) seeking opinion of the Medical Jurist regarding the fitness of the injured Munish Kumar to make a statement. Important it is to note that neither the witness (PW-17) disclosed the name of the doctor who issued the fitness certificate (Exh. P-33) nor did he himself record his own satisfaction regarding the fitness of the injured Munish Kumar before recording the statement/dying declaration (Exh. P-34).
25. Dr. Amandeep Singh (PW-18), along with Dr. Kulbir Singh Bal and Dr. Sanjay, conducted post-mortem examination on the body of deceased Munish Kumar on 15 th April, 2012 and issued the post mortem report (Exh. P-43). On external examination, a tracheotomy wound was found on the front of the neck. There were also surgical wounds corresponding to laparotomy, drainage, and chest tube insertion. The doctors noted a stitched wound admeasuring 5 cm in length with 5 stitches, located on the right side of the chest, about 28 cm below the axilla and 29 cm to the right of the midline, placed obliquely. On dissection, the track of the wound was found to extend medially, cutting through the underlying subcutaneous tissues and muscles, passing through the intercostal space between the 8 th and 9 th ribs, piercing the pleura, cutting through the diaphragm, and ultimately injuring the right lobe of the liver on its superolateral aspect. The doctors opined the cause of death to be result of stab injury to the liver and its consequences (haemorrhagic and septicaemic shock).
26. The other witnesses examined by the prosecution were more or less formal and their testimony does not have any bearing on the outcome of the case and thus, we need not refer to their evidence.
27. The trial Court held that the statement/dying declaration of the injured Munish Kumar (Exh. P-34) was recorded after due compliance of the procedural protocol. The concerned Medical Officer recorded his satisfaction (Exh. P-33) to the effect that injured Munish Kumar was in a fit condition to make the statement/dying declaration (Exh. P-34).
28. The trial Court found no plausible evidence against Sandeep Sharma (accused No.2), Balwinder @ Bittoo (accused No.3) and Deepak Bhardwaj (accused No. 4), thereby acquitting them of the charges, however, the appellant herein was held guilty for the offence punishable under Section 302 of the IPC vide judgment dated 26 th 1286 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports August, 2013, and was sentenced to imprisonment for life vide order of sentencing of the even date.
29. The accused-appellant preferred an appeal before the High Court. The matter was listed on 18 th September, 2024, for passing an order on an application seeking release of the registration certificate of the seized Maruti Alto car for the purpose of renewal. However, the High Court insisted for hearing the appeal on that very date. Since the engaged counsel was unavailable, the Division Bench proceeded to appoint an amicus curiae to represent the accused-appellant in the criminal appeal and concluded the hearing and reserved the judgment on 18th September, 2024 itself.
30. The appointed amicus was neither furnished with the case records from the lower Court nor afforded reasonable time to prepare the matter or consult with the accused-appellant. The appeal was finally dismissed by the impugned judgment dated 24 th September, 2024, which is the subject matter of challenge in the present appeal. Findings and Conclusion: -
31. We have heard and considered the submissions advanced by learned senior counsel Shri Ajay Tewari representing the accused-appellant and Shri Lokesh Sinhal, Sr. AAG appearing for the State of Haryana and have gone through the impugned judgments and the materials placed on record.
32. Before dealing with the merits of this case, we are compelled to address a matter of serious concern regarding the approach adopted by the High Court in dealing with the criminal appeal.
33. On 18 th September, 2024, when the matter was listed only for consideration of an application regarding renewal of the registration certificate of the Alto car seized during investigation, the High Court on the very same day proceeded to take up the main appeal itself for hearing on merits. Since the counsel engaged by the accusedappellant was not available, the Division Bench appointed an amicus curiae and, without granting a reasonable opportunity to prepare the matter, it proceeded to hear the appeal on merits and reserved judgment on the very same day. This approach of the High Court is particularly more disturbing and unjustified in the present case where the accused had been sentenced to life imprisonment.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 1287Tarun Sharma v. State of Haryana.
34. At the very outset, we must hold that the course adopted by the High Court fell short of the standards of fairness expected in the adjudication of a criminal appeal. In the circumstances noted above, the High Court ought to have acted pragmatically and adjourned the matter to another date so as to secure the presence of the accused-appellant’s counsel, or, at the very least, it should have afforded the newly appointed amicus a reasonable opportunity to inspect the record, study the relevant documents, and consult with the accused-appellant so as to prepare the case effectively.
35. In Chaluvegowda v. State 5, a similar situation arose wherein the amicus appointed by the High Court on an earlier date was not available on date fixed for hearing, Therefore, the Court appointed a new amicus and on the very same day heard the appeal and reserved the judgment. This Court set aside the judgment and remitted the matter back to the High Court for fresh hearing with the following observations:
“19. The right to be represented by a lawyer must not be an empty formality. It must not be a sham or an eyewash. The appointment of an amicus curiae for the defence of an accused person must be in true letter and spirit, with due regard to the effective opportunity of hearing that is to be afforded to every accused person before being condemned. The due process of law incorporated in our constitutional system demands that a person not only be given an opportunity of being heard before being condemned, but also that such opportunity be fair, just and reasonable.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.