Gurdeep Singh v. The State of Punjab
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 957; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 690
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 11 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 705/2024
- Sections
- 25, 319, 120B, 307, 225, 186, 332, 353, 120, 161, 319(1), 193
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 690 : 2025 INSC 957 Gurdeep Singh v.
The State of Punjab (Criminal Appeal No. 705 of 2024)
11 August 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and R. Mahadevan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the order of conviction and sentence of the appellant for the offences u/ss.307, 353, 332, 225, 186, and 120B IPC and s.25 of the Arms Act, 1959 by the courts below was legally sustainable.
Headnotes† Penal Code, 1860 – ss.307, 353, 332, 225, 186, and 120B – Arms Act, 1959 – Criminal conspiracy – Prosecution case that Head Constables-PW 1 and PW 2 escorted undertrial prisoner from one place to another for the court proceedings – Appellant- Jail official accompanied them, and after court, suggested the constables to return in a private vehicle driven by PW 10, who was known to him – They all sat in the vehicle along with the two unidentified youths who occupied the rear seat and when the vehicle stopped, the youths threw red chilli powder at the constables, stabbed them, and attempted to help the undertrial to escape, however he failed as was handcuffed – Alarm raised, the appellant and the two youths fled and the prisoner was caught – Trial court convicted and sentenced all accused, including the appellant who was summoned later u/s.319 CrPC, for the offences u/ss.307, 353, 332, 225, 186, and 120B and s.25 of the 1959 Act – High Court upheld the said order – Interference with:
Held: Conviction and sentence imposed commensurate with the appellant’s culpability and call for neither reduction nor interference – Findings recorded by the courts below based on cogent reasoning and unimpeachable evidence – Considering the nature and gravity of the offence committed by the appellant, and more so, keeping in view his position as Assistant Superintendent * Author [2025] 8 S.C.R. 691Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab of Jail, a role that demands the highest standards of integrity, responsibility and adherence to the rule of law, thus, no mitigating factor to warrant any leniency in sentence – Detailed, consistent, and credible testimony of the head constable-injured escort officer, clearly implicates the appellant – In light of this direct and incriminating evidence, the trial court rightly exercised its jurisdiction u/s.319 Cr.P.C to summon the appellant – Prosecution convincingly established the existence of a prior concert of action between the appellant and the assailants – All incidents form a continuous chain of incriminating circumstances that point toward his complicity in the conspiracy – Appellant’s conduct was not peripheral but integral to the execution of the plan to facilitate the escape of the undertrial – His behaviour before, during, and after the incident establishes his culpability u/s.120B, thus, his conviction for the substantive offences with the aid of s.120B legally sustainable – Partial hostility of PW 1 regarding the identification of the accused, does not undermine the testimony of PW 2 who remained firm, consistent, and unshaken on all material particulars – His account of the events further corroborated by medical evidence and the surrounding circumstances – His status as injured witness further enhances the reliability of his version – In the absence of any evidence of prior enmity or other animus, and the appellant being PW.2’s superior officer, theory of false implication appears inherently implausible – Prosecution evidence clearly demonstrates that the attack on the police escort team was not a spontaneous occurrence, but a carefully orchestrated plan – Appellant’s conduct during and after the incident wholly inconsistent with that of a law-abiding officer, rather, reveals the mindset of a conspirator attempting to evade accountability – Prosecution rightly characterized entire episode as premeditated conspiracy, in which appellant played a key role. [Paras 16.1, 16.2, 17.4, 18.7, 18.8, 19-21] Police – Police /Jail Officials – Accountability – Elucidation – When public functionaries betray the institutional trust, the consequences are profound and far-reaching – In a constitutional democracy governed by the rule of law, custodial officers must be held to the highest standards of integrity – Role of the police/jail official demands the highest standards of integrity, responsibility and adherence to the rule of law – Any deviation amounts not only to legal delinquency, but to a grave institutional and moral breach. [Para 20] 692 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Hardeep Singh v. State of Punjab [2014] 2 SCR 1 : (2014) 3 SCC 92; State (NCT of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 79 : (2005) 11 SC 600; Ajay Aggarwal v. Union of India [1993] 3 SCR 543 : (1993) 3 SCC 609; Sudhir Shantilal Mehta v. CBI [2009] 12 SCR 682 : (2009) 8 SCC 1; Paulmeli v. State of Tamil Nadu [2014] 6 SCR 420 : (2014) 13 SCC 90; Rajesh Yadav v. State of UP [2022] 16 SCR 967 : (2022) 12 SCC 200; Goverdhan v. State of Chhattisgarh [2025] 1 SCR 657 : (2025) 3 SCC 378; Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras [1957] 1 SCR 981 : AIR 1957 SC 614 : 1957 Cri LJ 1000; Chittar Lal v. State of Rajasthan [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 633 : (2003) 6 SCC 397; Kuna v. State of Odisha [2017] 11 SCR 179 : (2018) 1 SCC 296 – referred to.
List of Acts Penal Code, 1860; Arms Act, 1959; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. List of Keywords Criminal conspiracy; Undertrial prisoner; Court proceedings; Constables; Unidentified youths Handcuffed; Summon; Testimony; Preliminary investigation; Continuous chain of incriminating circumstances; Identification of the accused; Medical evidence; Injured witness; Rule of law; Custody of prisoners; Assistant Superintendent of Jail; Jail officials; Institutional trust; Constitutional democracy; Custodial officers; Highest standards of integrity; Legal delinquency; Grave institutional and moral breach.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 705 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 04.05.2023 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRAS No. 4900 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
A K Walia, Divyadeep Walia, Ms. Debjani Das Purkayastha, Rajiv Kataria, M/S. Delhi Law Chambers.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Karan Sharma, Mohit Siwach.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 693Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment R. Mahadevan, J.
1. This criminal appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 04.05.2023 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh1 in CRA-S-4900-SB-2014, whereby the High Court upheld the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 31.10.2014 rendered by the Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Bathinda2 , in S.C. No. 55 of 10.09.2011, against the appellant / accused. The particulars of the conviction and sentence are as under: Offence for which convicted Sentence awarded Section 307 r/w Section
120B IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs.2,000/-, in default to undergo further RI for two months Section 225 r/w Section
120B IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment for one year and a fine of Rs.500/-, in default to undergo further RI for two weeks Section 186 r/w Section
120B IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment for two months and a fine of Rs.200/-, in default to undergo further RI for one week Section 332 r/w Section
120B IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment for two years and a fine of Rs.1,500/-, in default to undergo further RI for one and half months Section 353 r/w Section
120B IPC
Rigorous Imprisonment for one and half years and a fine of Rs.1,000/-, in default to undergo further RI for one month Section 120B IPC Rigorous Imprisonment for three years and a fine of Rs.2,000/-, in default to undergo further RI for two months All the sentences were ordered to run concurrently. 1 Hereinafter referred to as “the High Court”
2 For short, “the Sessions Court”
694 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2. The case of the prosecution is that on 30.11.2010, the Station House Officer, Police Station City Rampura, received information that Head Constables Harjit Singh (PW.2) and Hardial Singh (PW.1) had been admitted to Civil Hospital, Rampura, in an injured condition. Upon reaching the hospital and obtaining medical opinion, regarding their fitness to give a statement, the Station House Officer recorded the statement of Head Constable Harjit Singh.
2.1. According to Head Constable Harjit Singh, on that day, he, along with Head Constable Hardial Singh, was escorting undertrial prisoner Kuldeep Singh @ Deepi from Ludhiana to Talwandi Sabo for court proceedings in connection with FIR No. 59 dated 31.05.2008 by bus. The appellant, Gurdeep Singh, Assistant Superintendent of Central Jail, Ludhiana, also accompanied them. After attending court, while they were waiting at the main gate of the court complex, the appellant suggested that they travel back in a Tata Qualis bearing Registration No. PB-19L-8750 which was parked outside and allegedly belonged to persons known to him from Barnala. Despite initial hesitation, the Head Constables agreed based on his assurance. The appellant sat in the front seat with the driver; the two Head Constables and accused Kuldeep Singh sat in the middle row, while two young men (aged around 20 - 25 years) occupied the rear seat. On reaching near village Kutiwal, the appellant asked the driver to stop for a while to answer the call of nature. When the driver slowed down the vehicle, the two men in the back, threw red chilli powder into the eyes of the Head Constables. One of them then stabbed Head Constable Hardial Singh in the shoulder with a knife, while the other picked up a kirpan and struck Harjit Singh on the head. Harjit Singh attempted to defend himself with his carbine, but was still injured. The assailants attempted to help the accused Kuldeep Singh escape; however, he failed, as he was handcuffed and chained to the complainant’s belt. On raising an alarm, members of the public gathered, causing the two assailants and the appellant to flee. The injured were then taken to Civil Hospital, Rampura, by the driver of the vehicle, Balwinder Singh (PW.10). Accordingly, the crime was alleged to have been committed by Kuldeep Singh, in connivance [2025] 8 S.C.R. 695Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab with the appellant and the two unknown assailants, with the intention to facilitate escape from custody and to eliminate the escorting officers.
3. Based on the statement given by Head Constable Harjit Singh, FIR No. 65 of 2010 was registered for the offences under sections 307, 353, 332, 225, 186, and 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 3 and Section 25 of the Arms Act, 1959. Accused Maan Singh @ Mana was declared a proclaimed offender on 22.04.2011. At the stage of preliminary investigation, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Circle Maur, in his enquiry report dated 03.01.2011, declared the appellant innocent. Subsequently, the case against the accused Kuldeep Singh and Baldev Singh, was committed to the Sessions Court, vide order dated 27.08.2011. After committal, charges were framed against the accused for the offences under Sections 307, 186, 332, 353, 225 and 120B IPC, to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried.
4. During trial, on an application moved by the prosecution under Section 319 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 19734 the appellant was summoned as an additional accused, as per order dated 06.07.2012, and his case was committed to the Sessions Court on 26.03.2014. He also pleaded innocence and alleged false implication.
5. The prosecution examined as many as 15 witnesses and marked exhibits and material objects collected during the course of investigation. On the side of the defence, DW1 to DW3 witnesses were examined and Exs.D1 to D4 documents were marked. After trial, the Sessions Court by judgment dated 31.10.2014, convicted all the accused and sentenced them for the offences as referred to above.
6. Challenging the aforesaid judgment, the appellant filed Criminal Appeal No. S-4900-SB-2014 which was dismissed by the High Court, along with the appeal preferred by the accused Baldev Singh @ Dev, by the judgment dated 04.05.2023. Feeling aggrieved, the appellant is before this Court by way of the present appeal. 3 For short, “IPC”
4 For short, “Cr.P.C”
696 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. The learned counsel for the appellant assailed the concurrent findings of conviction recorded by both the Sessions Court and the High Court as being legally unsustainable and factually erroneous. It was contended that the appellant has been falsely implicated without any cogent or reliable evidence connecting him either to the alleged occurrence or to the alleged conspiracy with the co-accused.
7.1. It was submitted that the entire prosecution case rested solely on the testimony of PW.2, the complainant, who was admittedly an interested witness. In his cross-examination, PW.2 admitted that as per police rules, he was not permitted to escort an undertrial prisoner in a private vehicle, and that disciplinary action was liable to be taken against him for this lapse. Therefore, in an attempt to shield himself, he allegedly twisted the version and shifted the blame onto the appellant by claiming that it was on the appellant’s suggestion that they boarded the said vehicle.
7.1.1. Furthermore, the other two material witnesses – PW.1 (Hardial Singh), the escorting officer, and PW.10 (Balwinder Singh), the vehicle driver – were declared hostile and did not support the prosecution’s case. In particular, PW.10 who was present throughout the alleged occurrence, completely resiled from his earlier statement, thereby casting serious doubt on the prosecution version.
7.2. The learned counsel emphasized that no overt act was attributed to the appellant. The sole allegation was that he had suggested to use a particular vehicle for convenience. There was no evidence to show that the appellant had either facilitated the presence of the assailants in the vehicle or had participated in any act of violence. No injury was attributed to him. His mere presence at the scene, without any criminal conduct or prior meeting of minds with the assailants, cannot sustain a charge of conspiracy under Section 120B IPC.
7.3. It was further submitted that there was no reliable, sufficient, or legal evidence to support the charge of criminal conspiracy against the appellant. The case was based purely on conjecture and surmise, rather than proof beyond reasonable doubt. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 697Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab Consequently, the conviction under section 120 B IPC is liable to be set aside and the conviction for other offences based solely on the application of Section 120B IPC is also unsustainable.
7.4. The learned counsel also submitted that the charge under Section 307 IPC was wholly untenable, particularly in the absence of any injury being declared grievous or dangerous to life. The theory of red chilli powder being thrown into the eyes of the complainant was neither supported by forensic or medial evidence, nor corroborated by PW.3 (Doctor), the medical witness. No traces of chilli powder were found in the vehicle or on the clothes of the complainant or other witnesses. Moreover, the prosecution case, at its core, is one of an attempted escape from custody by the undertrial prisoner, not an attempt to murder. These aspects were ignored by the Courts below, resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
7.5. It was further submitted that DW.3 (Gurmeet Singh), Deputy Superintendent of Police, Maur, who conducted a detailed preliminary enquiry, had categorically ruled out the involvement of the appellant in any criminal conspiracy and found him to be innocent. The appellant was not named in the original charge sheet, and was subsequently summoned under Section 319 Cr.P.C on the basis of vague allegations and without any fresh or additional incriminating material, having emerged during trial. The summoning order dated 05.07.2012, was passed mechanically and without due application of mind. The High Court also erred in failing to examine the legality and correctness of this summoning order, while disposing of the appeal.
7.6. It was further pointed out that both courts below erroneously referred to the appellant as a police officer and as a supervisory official of the complainant, whereas he was an official of the Jail Department, deputed for a distinct purpose. This factual mischaracterization has led to manifest injustice and vitiated the approach adopted by the courts below.
7.7. Lastly, it was submitted that the appellant is a government servant with 35 years of unblemished service, and the conviction has resulted in harsh consequences including the forfeiture of his pensionary benefits.
698 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7.8. In view of the foregoing, the learned counsel submitted that the concurrent judgement of conviction passed against the appellant, are perverse and deserve to be set aside.
8. The learned counsel for the State / respondent opposed the appeal and submitted that the conviction of the appellant is well-founded and supported by sufficient oral and circumstantial evidence. It was contended that the appellant, though an official of the Jail Department, played an active role in facilitating the commission of the offence by deliberately selecting a vehicle that enabled the assailants to launch an assault on the complainant and attempt to free the undertrial prisoner.
8.1. It was further contended that the appellant persuaded the victims to board a vehicle in which two persons were already present along with the driver – all of whom were known to the appellant. Acting upon the appellant’s instructions, the vehicle was stopped at a pre-designated location, whereupon the assailants carried out the attack. Notably, no injury was inflicted upon the appellant, suggesting his collusion. Despite hearing the cries for help, the appellant neither intervened nor made any effort to assist the victims. Rather, he absconded from the scene along with the accused persons and subsequently failed to report back or accompany the injured to the civil hospital, Rampura. Furthermore, he did not make any statement before the police, nor he examine or cite any independent witness from the vicinity who could support his version of events.
8.2. The learned counsel submitted that the overall conduct of the appellant including his failure to act during the violent assault, which involved the use of deadly weapons and red chilli powder, reveals his conscious participation in the criminal conspiracy. His behaviour was inconsistent with that expected of a government officer, and instead indicated deliberate alignment with the assailants’ objective.
8.3. It was also emphasized that there existed no motive or reason for the complainant or the injured eyewitnesses – who were police officials themselves – to falsely implicate the appellant. The testimony of PW.1 Hardial Singh, an injured eyewitness, stood corroborated by the version set out in the FIR and by the deposition of PW.2 Harjit Singh, the complainant and another [2025] 8 S.C.R. 699Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab injured eyewitness. Their consistent narratives, coupled with the testimony of PW.7 Sukhchain Singh, the investigating officer, established the integrity of the prosecution case.
8.4. With respect to the charge under Section 307 IPC, it was submitted that the nature of the assault, the weapons used, and the intent to incapacitate the complainant, even if injuries were not ultimately grievous, attracted the ingredients of an attempt to commit murder. The use of red chilli powder in the eyes of the victims, especially in the context of a custodial escort operation, clearly demonstrated intent to commit a serious and premeditated offence.
8.5. The learned counsel further argued that the appellant’s summoning under Section 319 Cr.P.C., was lawful and based on the clear and incriminating testimony of the complainant during the course of trial, which revealed the appellant’s active participation in the offence. The mere exoneration of the appellant during the police investigation did not preclude the trial Court from invoking its power under Section 319 Cr.P.C., as the court is not bound by the opinion of the Investigating Officer and is competent to summon any person against whom evidence emerges during the course of trial.
8.6. In view of the above, it was urged that the findings of guilt recorded by the trial Court, as affirmed by the High Court, were based on a proper appreciation of the evidence on record and do not warrant any interference by this Court.
8.7. Therefore, the learned counsel submitted that the appeal is devoid of merit and deserves to be dismissed.
9. We have considered the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record.
10. It is not in dispute that originally, the appellant was not named in the FIR and that the preliminary investigation conducted by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Maur, had opined that he was not involved in the offence. However, during the course of trial, based on the evidence that emerged, the prosecution filed an application under Section 319 Cr.P.C., pursuant to which the appellant was summoned as an accused.
700 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
11. To establish the guilt of the accused persons, the prosecution examined fifteen witnesses and also exhibited various documents, including the First Information Report, statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., medical reports, and seizure memos, as well as material objects collected during the course of investigation through the witnesses. In defence, the appellant examined three witnesses as DW.1 to DW.3, and relied upon four documents, marked as Exhibits D1 to D4.
12. At the outset, it would be appropriate to briefly survey the material evidence led by both sides.
12.1. PW.1 Hardial Singh deposed that on 30.11.2010, he, along with Head Constable Harjit Singh was assigned the duty of escorting undertrial accused Kuldeep Singh for production before the Court of Sh. L.K.Singla, SDJM, Talwandi Sabo. The accused was taken to Court by bus and the appellant also accompanied them in the same bus. At about 2.30 pm, after conclusion of the court proceedings, PW.1 and Head Constable Harjit Singh were standing at the main gate of the court complex. At that time, the appellant informed them that a Qualis vehicle was parked nearby, and he personally knew the persons sitting inside it, who were travelling to Barnala. The appellant suggested PW.1 and Harjit Singh to travel in that vehicle up to Barnala. On the appellant’s assurance, they agreed and boarded the vehicle. According to PW.1, the appellant was sitting in the front passenger seat; PW.1, Head Constable Harjit Singh, and accused Kuldeep Singh sat on the middle seat, while two other persons were seated at the rear. When the vehicle reached near village Dhadda on the main highway, the appellant asked the driver to stop the vehicle, stating that he wanted to attend a nature call. As soon as the vehicle stopped, accused Kuldeep Singh and the two persons seated in the rear seat attacked PW.1 and Harjit Singh. Red Chilli powder was thrown into their eyes; one of the rear occupants assaulted PW.1 with a knife on his back, and the other struck Harjit Singh below the head with a kirpan. Upon raising alarm, some people gathered at the scene, at which point the appellant, and the other two assailants fled from the spot. But, accused Kuldeep Singh was unable to [2025] 8 S.C.R. 701Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab escape, as he was handcuffed and tied with a belt of Head Constable Harjit Singh. Thereafter, PW.1 and Harjit Singh were taken to Civil Hospital, Rampura by the vehicle driver. PW.1 further stated that PW.7 Sukhchain Singh the Investigating officer, recorded his and Harjit Singh’s statements. He stated that the incident was the result of a conspiracy hatched by Kuldeep Singh and others. However, in his deposition, PW.1 identified only accused Kuldeep Singh and did not identify the other assailants. To this extent, he was treated as a hostile witness and he was subjected to cross-examination by the prosecution. During cross-examination, PW.1 admitted that Kuldeep Singh had referred to one of the two other assailants as Mana Singh during their conversation.
12.2. PW.2 Harjit Singh, Head Constable, deposed that on 30.11.2010, he along with Head Constable Hardial Singh (PW.1) had brought undertrial accused Kuldeep Singh @ Deepi to be produced before the Court of Sh. L.K.Singla, SDJM, Talwandi Sabo in connection with FIR No. 59 dated 31.05.2008 under sections 341, 323, 148 and 149 IPC. The journey to Talwandi Sabo was undertaken by bus. After production in Court, around 2.30 pm., as they reached the main gate of the court complex, the appellant met them and suggested that they return to Barnala in a Qualis vehicle bearing Regn. No. PB 19C 8750. The appellant informed them that the persons seated in the said vehicle were known to him and that, it was headed towards Barnala. Although PW.2 initially expressed a preference to return by the same bus, the appellant insisted, claiming that he had accompanied them earlier in the same bus. Thereafter, the appellant took the front passenger seat beside the driver, while PW.2, PW.1, and accused Kuldeep Singh occupied the middle seat. Two unknown persons were seated on the rear side of the vehicle. PW.2 further deposed that during the journey, accused Kuldeep Singh and the appellant conversed and referred to one of the rear occupants as ‘Manna’. After they passed village Kutianwali, the appellant asked the driver to stop the vehicle that he wanted to attend a call of nature. As soon as the vehicle stopped, the two rear seat occupants threw red 702 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports chilli powder into the eyes of PW.1 and PW.2. One of them inflicted a knife blow to the shoulder of PW.1, and the other attacked PW.2 with a small sword (Kirpan). PW.2 managed to partially shield himself with his carbine, which deflected the blow, but caused injury to his forehead. Upon raising an alarm, the appellant and the two assailants fled the scene. The attackers also attempted to help accused Kuldeep Singh escape. Whileso, Kuldeep Singh scuffled with the escorting officers in an attempt to flee custody, but ended in vain. Ultimately, PW.1 and PW.2 were taken to the Civil Hospital, Rampura, in the same Qualis vehicle, and accused Kuldeep Singh remained with them at that time.
12.2.1. PW.2 categorically stated that the incident was a result of a conspiracy between accused Kuldeep Singh and the appellant to facilitate the former’s escape from lawful custody. His statement was recorded by the Police as Ex. PW2/A. In his supplementary statement, PW. 2 named the two other accused as Maan Singh and Baldev Singh, and during trial, he identified both accused Kuldeep Singh and Baldev Singh.
PW.2 also stated that on the day of the occurrence, when they saw Kuldeep Singh in the Central Jail, Ludhiana, he was in the company of the appellant, and all of them including appellant came to Talwandi Sabo by bus, although the appellant had no official connection with their duty. He admitted that as per police regulations, the custody of the undertrial was their sole responsibility, and it was improper to travel with the inmate in a private vehicle accompanies by strangers. He further admitted that they did not inform any senior officer about their decision to travel with the appellant, nor did they question the appellant about his presence in Talwandi Sabo. PW.2 further admitted that he could not identify the specific person who threw the red chilli powder into their eyes. However, he denied the defence suggestion that the incident occurred due to a quarrel following excessive consumption of liquor or that there was any collusion between him, [2025] 8 S.C.R. 703Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab PW.1 and the appellant to orchestrate the escape of Kuldeep Singh. He stoutly denied having made any false statement before the police.
12.3. PW.3 Dr. R.P. Singh, Medical Officer at Civil Hospital, Rampura, deposed that on 30.11.2010, he medically examined Head Constable Hardial Singh (PW.1) and found the following injuries:
(1) Incised wound measuring 1 ½ cm x ½ cm on the back, just below the neck; margins were clean cut with fresh bleeding present
(2) Redness of both eyes.
According to the doctor, both injuries were simple in nature and of probable duration within 12 hours. He opined that injury no.1 was caused by a sharp-edged weapon, whereas injury no.2 could have been caused by a blunt object.
12.3.1. On the same day, PW.3 also examined Head Constable Harjit Singh (PW.2) and recorded the following injuries:
(1) Incised wound measuring 1 cm x ½ cm on the forehead, located just below the hairline, with clean-cut margins and fresh bleeding.
(2) Abrasion on the back of the left elbow joint, reddish in colour
(3) Redness of both eyes.
He opined that all three injuries 1,2 and 3 were simple and of probable duration within 12 hours. Injury no.1 was caused by a sharp weapon, while injuries 2 and 3 were caused by blunt force.
PW.3 further deposed that upon an application moved by Sub Inspector Sukhchain Singh regarding the fitness of the victims for making statements, he certified that both were fit to make statements.
During cross examination, PW.3 stated that redness of eyes could be due to multiple causes, including excessive alcohol consumption, and he did not detect 704 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports any specific contents of chilli powder in the victims’ eyes. He acknowledged that all injuries were simple and none was dangerous to life.
12.4. PW.5 Ravinder Sharm, Junior Assistant in the office of the District Transport Office, deposed that he produced the official record pertaining to the Qualis vehicle bearing Regn. No. PB 19C 8750. As per the said record, on 29.01.2009, the Registration Certificate of the said vehicle was transferred in the name of Karamjit Kaur W/o. Kuldeep Singh, residence of Ward No.16, Barnala.
12.5. PW.7 Sukhchain Singh, who was serving as the Station House Officer, Police Station Balianwali during the relevant time, deposed that upon receipt of information regarding the incident on 30.11.2010, he, along with police party, proceeded to the Civil Hospital, Rampura. After obtaining medical opinion regarding the fitness of the injured persons, he recorded the statements of PW.1 Hardial Singh and PW.2 Harjit Singh. Based on their statements, the FIR (Ex.PW7/ C) was registered. He further deposed that he took into possession a blood-stained woolen shirt and a vest from Head Constable Hardial Singh. He also described the subsequent steps of investigation, including the arrest of accused Kuldeep Singh @ Deepi, the recovery of the Qualis vehicle, and the preparation of a rough sketch of the scene of occurrence. He also deposed regarding the arrest of accused Baldev Singh on 23.02.2011, and other follow-up procedures undertaken in the course of investigation. Additionally, he stated that on the same day i.e., 30.11.2020, Head Constable Harjit Singh produced one carbine along with 35 cartridges, one handcuff, and the custody warrant pertaining to accused Kuldeep Singh @ Deepi.
12.6. PW.10 Balwinder Singh deposed that he was the driver of the Qualis vehicle bearing Regn. No. PB19 C 8750 which was owned by Dial Singh @ Daya Singh. He stated that he used to regularly park the said vehicle at the taxi stand near Court Chowk, Barnala. According to his testimony, on 30.11.2010 at about 11.30 am, two Sikh men, hired his vehicle for travel to Talwandi Sabo. He specifically stated that those [2025] 8 S.C.R. 705Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab individuals were not police officials, and further deposed that he had no personal knowledge regarding the incident. In view of the apparent contradiction between his version and the prosecution case, the prosecution sought to declare him a hostile witness, alleging that he was suppressing the truth, and obtained permission to cross-examine him. However, even during cross-examination, PW.10 denied all material suggestions and did not support the prosecution case.
12.7. DW.1 Balbir Singh, employed as a Fitter in the Record Room of the Central Jail, Ludhiana, deposed that he was conversant with the official records maintained in the jail. He produced in evidence the notice issued to Superintendent, Central Jail, Ludhiana, by the Court of Sub Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Talwandi Sabo, requiring the production of the accused Kuldeep Singh on 30.11.2010. The said notice was marked as Ex. D1.
12.8. DW.2 Hardev Singh, who was working as Naib Reader, produced the enquiry report dated 03.01.2011 prepared by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Maur, which was exhibited as Ex.DW2 /A. He admitted during cross examination that he was not posted in the office of the DSP at the relevant point and had no personal knowledge of the facts of the case. His deposition was based solely on the contents of the record available with him.
12.9. DW.3 Gurmeet Singh, the Deputy Superintendent of Police, deposed that he had conducted an enquiry into the incident and had recorded the statements of the appellant as well as the driver of the vehicle. Based on the facts verified during the enquiry, he concluded that the appellant was innocent. According to his findings, the appellant neither attacked the policy party nor had any connection with the accused persons. He further stated that the appellant’s presence at Talwandi Sabo on the date of the incident was pursuant to a notice issued by the Court to the Superintendent, Central Jail, Ludhiana, and that, the Superintendent deputed the appellant to attend court proceedings on 30.11.2010. During cross-examination, DW.3 admitted that he could not recall the date and time when he visited the spot of the occurrence. 706 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
12.10. Ex. D2 (dated 27.11.2010) - reply to notice and Ex. D3 (dated 29.11.2010) - letter are issued by the Superintendent, Central Jail, Ludhiana, addressed to the Divisional Judicial Magistrate, Talwandi Sabo, regarding the non-production of accused Kuldeep Singh @ Deepi before the Court on earlier dates.
13. In light of the oral testimonies and the documentary evidence brought on record, we shall now proceed to examine whether the judgment of conviction and sentence rendered by the Sessions Court, as affirmed by the High Court, is legally sustainable and warrants interference insofar as the appellant is concerned.
14. As already indicated, the prosecution examined as many as 15 witnesses, of whom, the principal witnesses are PW.1 (Hardial Singh), P.W.2 (Harjit Singh) and PW.10 (Balwinder Singh). PW.1, a member of the escort party, narrated the sequence of events relating to the assault and attempted escape of undertrial prisoner Kuldeep Singh. However, he turned hostile to the extent of not identifying any of the accused, including the appellant, except Kuldeep Singh. PW.10, the driver of the vehicle and an alleged eyewitness, also turned hostile and denied any knowledge of the incident. As a result, the prosecution case primarily hinges on the testimony of PW.2, the complainant and injured escort officer, on whose statement the FIR was registered by PW. 7, the Investigating Officer.
15. The contentions of the learned counsel for the appellant are threefold: Firstly, the appellant had been declared innocent by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Maur, during the preliminary inquiry, and therefore, his subsequent summoning under Section 319 Cr.P.C was unjustified; Secondly, there was no overt act attributed to the appellant nor was there any reliable, sufficient, or legally admissible evidence to establish his involvement in a criminal conspiracy under Section 120B IPC. It was contended that in the absence of concrete proof of conspiracy or any direct role in the assault or escape attempt, the conviction under Section 120B as well as for the substantive offences alleged to have been committed pursuant to the conspiracy is liable to be set aside. Thirdly, the prosecution’s case rests solely on the testimony of PW.2, an allegedly interested witness, whereas other key witnesses either turned hostile, or failed to identify the appellant, thereby rendering the evidence insufficient to sustain conviction.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 707Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab
16. The first contention – that the appellant was declared innocent during the preliminary investigation – cannot be sustained in law. In Hardeep Singh v. State of Punjab5, the Constitution Bench of this Court authoritatively interpreted the scope and ambit of Section 319 Cr.P.C., holding that even a person not named in the FIR or chargesheet can be summoned to face trial if evidence recorded during the course of trial indicates his involvement in the offence. The Court emphasized that the opinion of the investigating agency is merely tentative and cannot override the Court’s independent judicial assessment based on trial evidence. It further underscored that the power under Section 319 Cr.P.C is judicial in nature, independent of the police’s conclusions. For better appreciation, the relevant portion of the judgment is extracted below:
“117. We accordingly sum up our conclusions as follows: Questions (i) and (iii)
– what is the stage at which power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. can be exercised?
AND
– Whether the word “evidence” used in Section 319(1) Cr.P.C. has been used in a comprehensive sense and includes the evidence collected during investigation or the word “evidence” is limited to the evidence recorded during trial?
Answer
117.1. In Dharam Pal case, the Constitution Bench has already held that after committal, cognizance of an offence can be taken against a person not named as an accused but against whom materials are available from the papers filed by the police after completion of investigation. Such cognizance can be taken under Section 193 Cr.P.C. and the Sessions Judge need not wait till ‘evidence’ under Section 319 Cr.P.C. becomes available for summoning an additional accused.
5 (2014) 3 SCC 92
708 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
117.2. Section 319 Cr.P.C., significantly, uses two expressions that have to be taken note of i.e., (1) Inquiry (2) Trial. As a trial commences after framing of charge, an inquiry can only be understood to be a pre-trial inquiry. Inquiries under Sections 200, 201, 202 Cr.P.C, and under Section 398 Cr.P.C. are species of the inquiry contemplated by Section 319 Cr.P.C. Materials coming before the Court in course of such enquiries can be used for corroboration of the evidence recorded in the court after the trial commences, for the exercise of power under Section 319 Cr.P.C., and also to add an accused whose name has been shown in Column 2 of the chargesheet.
117.3. In view of the above position the word ‘evidence’ in Section 319 Cr.P.C. has to be broadly understood and not literally i.e. as evidence brought during a trial. Question (ii) – Whether the word “evidence” used in Section 319(1) Cr.P.C. could only mean evidence tested by cross-examination or the court can exercise the power under the said provision even on the basis of the statement made in the examination-in-chief of the witness concerned?
Answer
117.4. Considering the fact that under Section 319 Cr.P.C. a person against whom material is disclosed is only summoned to face the trial and in such an event under Section 319(4) Cr.P.C. the proceeding against such person is to commence from the stage of taking of cognizance, the Court need not wait for the evidence against the accused proposed to be summoned to be tested by cross-examination.
Question (iv) – What is the nature of the satisfaction required to invoke the power under Section 319 Cr.P.C. to arraign an accused? Whether the power under Section 319(1) Cr.P.C. can be exercised only if the court is satisfied that the accused summoned will in all likelihood be convicted?
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 709Gurdeep Singh v. T he State of Punjab Answer
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.