Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 971; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1695
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.M. Sundresh, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 12 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10542/2025
- Sections
- 60, 55, 47A, 34, 54, 47, 13, 16, 17, 27, 4
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1695 : 2025 INSC 971 Paradip Port Authority v.
Paradeep Phosphates Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 10542 of 2025)
12 August 2025 [M.M. Sundresh and Rajesh Bindal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The issue pertains to fixation of tariff by the Paradip Port Authority (Earlier Paradip Port Trust). Whether it would be appropriate if an expert appellate body is constituted to hear appeals against the orders passed by the adjudicatory board/Tariff Authority for Major Ports (TAMP).
Headnotes† Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 – Major Port Authorities Act, 2021 – In C.A. No.10542 of 2025, an agreement was executed between the parties, namely appellant-Paradip Port Trust and respondent-Paradeep Phosphates Ltd on 03.08.1985 for use of ‘captive berth’ in terms of the conditions laid down in the Agreement – Appellant revised scale of rates for use of various facilities at the Ports – Respondent sought waiver of interest for delayed payment of certain dues from October 1993 to January 1996 – Proposal rejected by the appellant – Dispute arose between the parties – Arbitral award was passed – The Arbitrator held the appellant liable to refund the enhanced amount of port services from October 1993 till 31.03.1999 – As the period of dispute for determination for the Arbitrator was from October 1993 till 31.10.2001, for the period from 01.04.1999 till 31.10.2001, the parties were given option to approach the TAMP for resolution of their dispute – Appellate Authority upheld the arbitral award – The award and appellate order were subject matter of challenge in the Writ Petition – The High Court dismissed the petition, upholding the impugned award and the appellate order – Correctness: Held: The issues required to be considered for revision of rates applicable to the respondent for use of various facilities, have * Author 1696 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not been considered in the manner these were required to be considered – The TAMP being an independent authority consisting of experts, will be the right authority for resolution of dispute between the parties, which is pending for more than two decades – The Award of the Arbitrator, the order of the Appellate Authority and also the order passed by the High Court are set aside – Matter remitted to TAMP for adjudication of the dispute regarding revision of tariff applicable to the respondent for the period from October 1993 till 31.03.1999. [Paras 33 and 34] Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 – Major Port Authorities Act, 2021 – In C.A. No. 10543 of 2025, the order dated 11.01.2023 passed by the High Court is under challenge – Before the High Court, an order passed by TAMP on 22.11.2011 was the subject matter of challenge – Vide aforesaid order, tariff proposal for the financial year 1999-2000 to 2009-10 was determined: Held: Further, once this Court set aside the award of the Arbitrator, order of the Appellate Court and also of the High Court pertaining to the revision of the tariff for the period from October 1993 to 31.03.1999, and remitted the matter to be decided by TAMP, in opinion of this Court, even the order pertaining to the period in question also deserves to be set aside as the base for revision of tariff for subsequent periods is yet to be determined – The impugned order passed by the TAMP and also the High Court are set aside – The matter is remitted to the TAMP for decision afresh along with the matter for the period prior thereto. [Paras 46, 47] Major Port Authorities Act, 2021 – Constitution of Appellate Authority:
Held: The process for fixation of tariff presently by the TAMP or the adjudicatory board, as constituted and provided for under the 2021 Act, is the job of experts in the field – Direct appeals have been provided against the order passed by the TAMP or the adjudicatory board to this Court – Section 60 of the 2021 Act provides for remedy of appeal against the order passed by the adjudicatory board to this Court – Meaning thereby, first appeal against the order passed by the adjudicatory board and at present in its absence the TAMP, would lie to this Court – It cannot be denied that fixation of tariff would involve consideration of various factual aspects, especially figures involved – This Court may [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1697Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. not have the expertise to examine the accounts in detail for the purpose of fixation of tariff – While deciding appeal against an order of an expert body, all issues of law and fact are required to be considered – There are other similar expert bodies which are headed by technically qualified persons along with persons with knowledge of accounting and economics – Therefore, it would be appropriate if an expert appellate body is constituted to hear appeals against the orders passed by the adjudicatory board/ TAMP. [Paras 48, 52, 54, 58, 60] Case Law Cited Patiala Central Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. Patiala Central Cooperative Bank Employees’ Union, 1996 INSC 1056 : [1996] Supp. 6 SCR 347 : (1996) 11 SCC 202; W.B. Electricity Regulatory Commission v. CESC Ltd. (2002) 8 SCC 715; Rojer Mathew v. South Indian Bank Limited, 2019 INSC 1236 : [2019] 16 SCR 1 : (2020) 6 SCC 1 – referred to.
List of Acts Major Port Trusts Act, 1963; Major Port Authorities Act, 2021. List of Keywords Fixation of tariff; Expert appellate body; Constitution of Appellate Authority; Revision of rates applicable; Revision of tariff. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 10542 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.01.2023 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in WP(C) No. 11 of 2010 With Civil Appeal No. 10543 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv., Dipak Kumar Jena, Pramod Kumar, Ms. Smita Kumari, Pradeep Kumar Verma, Raj Shekhar Jena, Sandip Munian, Ashutosh Singhdeo.
1698 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Advs. for the Respondent:
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Sanjeev K.kapoor, Ms. Anushka Sharda, Ms. Raveena Rai, Arpith Jacob Varaprasad, Yajas Achal, M/s. Khaitan & Co..
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Rajesh Bindal, J.
Table of Contents* S. No. Heading Paras Page I. Preliminary 1-3 2-3 II. C.A. No.____ of 2025 arising out of S.L.P.(C) No.9751 of 2023
1. Factual Aspects 4-16 3-9
2. Arguments for the Appellant 17 9-13
3. Arguments for the Respondent 18 13-17
4. Discussion 19-33 17-28
5. Conclusion 34 28-29 III. C.A. No.____ of 2025 arising out of S.L.P.(C) No.9870 of 2023
1. Factual Aspects 35 29-30
2. Arguments for the Appellant 36-38 30-32
3. Arguments for the Respondent 39 32
4. Discussion 40-46 33-35
5. Conclusion 47 35-36 IV. Constitution of Appellate Authority 48-58 36-47 V. Relief 61-62 47-48
1. Leave granted.
2. This order will dispose of two appeals.
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1699Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd.
3. The issue pertains to fixation of tariff by the Paradip Port Authority1 . There were two Writ Petitions 2 decided by the High Court by a common order3 . Both were filed by the appellant herein. Though the period involved is different, the High Court had decided both the writ petitions by a common order. For this reason, both the appeals are being taken up and decided together.
C.A. NO. ____ OF 2025
ARISING OUT OF S.L.P.(C) NO.9751 OF 2023
FACTUAL ASPECTS
4. The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant (formerly Paradip Port Trust) challenging the common order of the High Court dated 11.01.2023 disposing of WP (C) No.11 of 2010.
5. The aforesaid petition was filed against order dated 19.10.2009 passed by the Appellate Authority in appeal 4 , which upheld the arbitral award 5 dated 27.12.2002. The Appellant was ordered to refund the additional amount charged till 31.03.1999 along with interest, holding the same to be unilaterally enhanced. As far as refund from 01.04.1999 and interest is concerned, both the parties were directed to file petition before Tariff Authority for Major Ports (hereinafter referred to as the TAMP). The award and appellate order were subject matter of challenge in the Writ Petition.
6. The High Court dismissed the petition, upholding the impugned award and the appellate order.
7. The appellant is a major port authority, governed by the provisions of the 1963 Act 6 , which is now renamed as Paradip Port Authority (PPA) under the 2021 Act7 . The 1963 Act was replaced by the 2021 Act. 1 Earlier Paradip Port Trust 2 WP (C) No.732 of 2012 and WP (C) No.11 of 2010 3 Dated 11.01.2023 4 Appeal No.5/L.S/2003 5 Case No.MA/NCJ/12/2001dated 27.12.2002 6 Major Port Trusts Act, 1963 7 Major Port Authorities Act, 2021 1700 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
8. The respondent herein was a public sector unit when it entered into a bilateral agreement with the appellant/Authority on 03.08.1985. The idea thereof, as is evident from the agreement, was that the appellant/ Authority agreed for construction of berth at Paradip Port, to be known as Fertilizer Berth, to provide berthing facilities exclusively to the respondent. The tariff to be paid by the respondent was prescribed in the Agreement. The rates could be suitably enhanced at such intervals as would be mutually agreed upon by the parties from time to time. It was the responsibility of the respondent to make such construction and install such equipments exclusively at their cost to ensure smooth handling of its cargo. It was responsible for its maintenance as well. Clause 19 of the Agreement provided that the respondent shall be subjected to application of all relevant laws, rules and regulations of the Paradip Port Trust, as may be applicable from time to time.
9. In exercise of power conferred under Sections 48 to 52 of the 1963 Act, Traffic Department of Paradip Port Trust issued Notification 8 dated 05.10.1993 for revision of scale of rates for use of various facilities at the Ports. It was conveyed to the respondent. The payments were made by respondent to the Authority at revised rates.
10. Vide letter dated 11.05.2000, the Appellant/authority while rejecting request made by the Respondent for waiver of interest on account of delayed payment of revised port charges, offered the facility of payment thereof in 3-4 installments. This was replied to by the respondent vide its letter dated 18.05.2000 seeking waiver of interest on account of financial condition of the respondent. The appellant/ Authority responded to the same vide letter dated 31.05.2000 again requesting for deposit of interest by 30.06.2000, failing which services to respondent’s incoming vessels would be stopped. The respondent filed Civil Suit 9 before the Civil Judge (Junior Division) praying for declaration that appellant/Authority had no right to amend terms and conditions of bilateral agreement dated 03.08.1985. Further, the respondent prayed for injunction against appellant from giving effect to the terms and conditions contained in the scale of rates published on 05.10.1993, claiming that the same do not form part of the bilateral agreement.
8 Notification No.1344 9 Original Suit No.115 of 2000 [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1701Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd.
11. As the respondent on 15.09.2000 was still a public sector unit, the Trial Court on that day directed the respondent to obtain clearance certificate for litigation from the high power committee.
12. The Respondent being a public sector unit as on that date, a supplementary agreement was signed between the parties on 10.08.2001 providing for resolution of dispute by arbitration. From a reading of aforesaid supplementary agreement, it is evident that the same was an informal mechanism for resolution of dispute as the provisions of the Arbitration Act were strictly made inapplicable. It may be relevant to add here that there was already a clause for arbitration in the agreement signed between parties. The same was not invoked.
13. The arbitrator was appointed. During the process of aforesaid proceedings, by way of a share purchase agreement dated 28.02.2002, executed between the President of India and Zuari Maroc Phosphates Private Limited, 76% shareholding of the Respondent Company was transferred. As a result thereof, from 28.02.2002 onwards, the Respondent Company was a private sector entity.
14. The Arbitrator framed the following issues and answered them: S. No. ISSUE ANSWER I What was the scope and ambit of the agreement entered into between the parties?
Clause 19 of the agreement shall be applicable only for the other port charges and cannot provide any help to unilaterally change the terms of the agreement.
II Whether the tariff as provided in the contract can be revised u n i l a t e r a l l y w i t h o u t t h e consent of the other party?
No III Whether the rates revised were reasonable and the respondent in the given circumstances was justified to enhance the rates?
No 1702 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports IV Whether the interest claimed by the Port authorities for d e l a y e d p a y m e n t w a s permissible under the contract or under the statutory rules and regulations, etc.?
Yes V Whether the claims and counter claims filed by both the parties are tenable in law and on merit?
Port Authorities should refund the amount charged by them on the basis of unilateral enhancement from the initial dated till 31.03.1999.
As far as the refund and interest from 1.04.1999 to till date is concerned, both the parties should make a petition to the TAMP.
Finally, vide award dated 27.12.2002, the Arbitrator held the appellant liable to refund the enhanced amount of port services from October 1993 till 31.03.1999. As the period of dispute for determination for the Arbitrator was from October 1993 till 31.10.2001, for the period from 01.04.1999 till 31.10.2001, the parties were given option to approach the TAMP for resolution of their dispute.
15. As per the procedure agreed upon by the parties, the appellant/ Authority preferred an appeal against the aforesaid Award. After filing of the appeal, there was lot of litigation between the parties, which is not relevant for the purpose of the issues raised in the present appeal, except that on 30.05.2009, resolution was passed by the Appellant-Authority to withdraw easementary rights given to the Respondent. A proposal to recover a sum of ₹40.36 Crores from the Respondent was also approved as arrears towards revision of tariff in line with IFFCO tariff for the period from March 2002 till January 2009.
15.1 On 02.06.2009, the aforesaid resolution was communicated to Respondent invoking clause 21 of the agreement dated 03.08.1985.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1703Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. 15.2 Challenging the aforesaid communication dated 02.06.2009, the Respondent filed Writ Petition 10 in the High Court. Noticing the fact that on the same issue, a Civil Suit No.55/2009 was pending in court of Civil Judge Junior Division Kujang, which the Respondent offered to withdraw, and noticing the fact that proceedings were also pending before TAMP for fixation of tariff for the earlier periods, matter was left open to be decided by TAMP.
15.3 Vide order dated 19.10.2009, the Appellate Authority rejected the appeal filed by the Appellant against the award of Arbitrator dated 27.12.2002.
15.4 Aggrieved against the order passed by the Appellate Authority, the Appellant/Authority preferred Writ Petition 11 before the High Court which was dismissed
16. In the Writ Petition filed by Appellant/Authority, the award of the arbitrator and Appellate Authority was upheld. The order of High Court is under challenged in this Appeal.
ARGUMENTS FOR THE APPELLANT
17. Mr. Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant/ Authority, submitted that Clause 1 of the Agreement provides that the captive berth shall be exclusively used by the respondent, subject to payment of tariff as mentioned in the Schedule annexed to the Agreement. The rate was subject to enhancement at such intervals as would be mutually agreed upon by the parties. Clause 19 of the Agreement clearly provides that the respondent shall be subjected to the application of all relevant laws, rules and regulations of the Authority as may be enforced from time to time. In the case in hand, certain tariff was fixed when the Agreement was entered into between the parties on 03.08.1985. That cannot be said to be an Agreement providing for the tariff fixed for all times to come. That is the reason why an enabling provision was provided for revision of tariff. The Agreement clearly envisages application of laws, rules and regulations to the respondent. In case the parties failed to agree to mutually settled terms for revision of tariff, the law will take its own course 10 WP (C) No. 86509 of 2009 11 Writ Petition (C) No.11 of 2010 1704 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 17.1 Learned senior counsel also referred to the pleadings by the respondent in the civil suit filed. It is the admitted case of the respondent therein that in the year 1993-94 a proposal was made by the appellant/Authority for revision of tariff, to which the respondent objected vide letter dated 16.03.1993. Still, the appellant/Authority forcibly enhanced the tariff unilaterally from October 1993. The aforesaid admitted fact in the suit filed by the respondent clearly establishes that initially an effort was made for revision of tariff by mutual consent, however, respondent having not agreed to the same, the Appellant/Authority did not have any other option but to proceed in terms of provisions of Sections 48 to 52 of the 1963 Act. A notification was issued on 05.10.1993. After issuance of the aforesaid notification, the respondent continued to pay the revised tariff without any objection till the time the aforesaid civil suit dated 30.06.2000 was filed. The same being cleverly drafted, had only sought the relief of declaration and permanent injunction. The relief being that the appellant/Authority could not amend the terms of the Agreement dated 03.08.1985; the appellant/Authority could not give effect to the revised rates as published in the year 1993 and permanently injuncting the appellant/Authority from giving effect to 1993 Notification. No relief was claimed for any refund of the amount already deposited by the respondent in terms of rates revised vide Notification dated 05.10.1993. 17.2 It was further submitted that the aforesaid arguments were specifically raised before the Arbitrator, in appeal against the Award and in the Writ Petition before the High Court, however, the same were not considered. The same goes to the root of the case and needs examination by this Court. The arbitration could be in terms of the claim made by the respondent in the civil suit and not beyond that. In fact, from the conduct of the respondent, it did not have right to challenge the revised tariff as notified on 05.10.1993 as without any objection the same was paid till the filing of the suit dated 30.06.2000. Referring to Section 55 of the 1963 Act, it was submitted that though no claim for refund of any amount was made in the civil suit on the basis of which the arbitration proceedings were conducted, any claim of refund could be filed within six months only. In the case in hand, the refund was never claimed by the respondent. [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1705Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. It was further argued that there is basic error in the Award of the Arbitrator because refund was claimed for the period from October 1993 till 31.03.1999. The issue for revision of tariff was not considered any further either in appeal or in writ petition. It was held that the provisions of the Act will not apply even if there was failure on the part of the parties to agree upon for revised tariff. Whereas, for the period from 01.04.1999, the finding given is that TAMP constituted under Section 47A of the 1963 Act will have jurisdiction to determine the tariff. In the Award of the Arbitrator the period so mentioned was from 01.04.1999 to 31.10.2001. In addition to the aforesaid period vide an order passed by the High Court on 08.07.2009 in Writ Petition No.8509 of 2009, a direction was given for consideration of such an issue by TAMP even for the period subsequent thereto.
17.3 Further argument was raised that even otherwise, the claim made by the respondent, even though it may be considered admissible for the argument’s sake, shall be time-barred as the suit for raising an issue regarding tariff from October 1993 onwards was filed in June/July 2000.
ARGUMENTS FOR THE RESPONDENT
18. On the other hand, Mr. Shyam Divan, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents, submitted that the case in hand does not call for any interference by this Court. The issue has already been examined at three different levels, namely, Arbitrator, the Appellate Authority and thereafter in a Writ Petition by the High Court. There are concurrent findings of fact. Hence, the scope of interference by this Court is minimal unless there is grave error, and the views expressed by the authorities or the court are not plausible. 18.1 The disputed period from the year 1993 to 1999, has been dealt with in the Award of the Arbitrator. There is no issue after 01.04.1999 as TAMP has been constituted. Even otherwise, in the factual matrix, specially which are to be dealt with by the Expert Bodies, the courts adopt a hands-off approach. Referring to the provisions of the Agreement entered between the parties on 03.08.1985, the submission is that Clause I thereof in fact is a primary clause. The tariff rates have been 1706 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports agreed upon. It further provides that the increase, if any, in future can only be with mutual agreement. In case the parties failed to mutually agree upon revision of tariff, the issue may have to be resolved by an independent third party. It can be by way of arbitration or may be by any other remedy. Schedule attached to the agreement was referred to. It was highlighted from there that some of the rates as agreed upon were fixed minimum charges whereas some were variable. Clause II of the Schedule is also relevant in that context which deals with additional charges payable by respondent, namely, tug hire, pilotage and port dues only as per the scale of rates and no other charges like berth hire, warping, mooring or immuring charges are payable.
18.2 Further, reference was made to Clause 20 of the agreement which specifies that if there is any dispute arising out of and in relation to clauses of Agreement or for interpretation of any terms of the Agreement, the matter shall be referred to arbitration. Clause 2 of the Agreement clearly specifies that the entire construction had to be raised by the Respondent. Once rates have clearly been defined in the agreement as agreed upon between the parties, there is no need for invocation of Clause 19 of the Agreement. The rates which have been agreed upon between the parties are not the normal rates which may be applicable for any other importer. In the business world, such types of agreement are entered into which are for mutual benefit with an idea to promote business.
18.3 In response to the arguments raised by Mr. Jaideep Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant that the respondents had paid the revised charges from 1993 to 1999 without raising any objection, reference was made to various correspondence between the parties starting from 16.03.1993. It was at the stage when there was proposal for revision of rates as was notified on 05.10.1993. The suit had to be filed in June 2000 when Respondent was requested to deposit the net outstanding interest amounting to ₹38,58,718/- latest by 30.06.2000, failing which Appellant would have stopped services to the incoming vessels. It was during the pendency of the suit that on agreed terms the matter was referred to arbitration on 10.08.2001. It was during the pendency of the [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1707Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. arbitration proceedings that Respondent, which was a public sector unit, was sold off to a private player on 28.02.2002. 18.4 To buttress the argument that the Award of the Arbitrator, which was upheld by the Appellate Authority and thereafter by the High Court, has dealt with all the issue threadbare, it was submitted that firstly, the Arbitrator framed issues with the consent of both the parties. Insofar as the main issue is concerned regarding justification of revision of rates, despite opportunity granted to the respondents no material was placed before the Arbitrator which could justify revision of rates as sought by the Appellant/Authority. As far as the enabling provision in the Agreement regarding revision of the rates by mutual agreement is concerned, the finding recorded by the Arbitrator was not disputed.
18.5 Reference was made to the order passed by the Appellate Authority which again examined the Award of the Arbitrator and has recorded categoric finding that there was no error therein. The issue was thereafter considered by the High Court which also upheld the same. There are limited grounds on which an award of the Arbitrator can be interfered with.
18.6. He further argued that reliance on the revision of rates by the Wage Board in 1994, could not be the basis for revision of tariff in 1993.
DISCUSSION
19. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the relevant referred record.
20. The facts of the case are not in dispute that an agreement was executed between the parties, namely Paradip Port Trust and Paradeep Phosphates Ltd on 03.08.1985 for use of ‘captive berth’ in terms of the conditions laid down in the Agreement. At the time when the aforesaid agreement was executed, the respondent/Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. was a public sector unit. Clause 1 and 19 of the Agreement which are relevant for consideration of the issues in question are extracted below:
“1. That the said Captive berth shall be exclusively provided for use of the Paradeep Phosphates Ltd., subject 1708 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to payment of the Rate mentioned in the schedule of rates; annexed to the agreement and will become payable one calendar month after the berthing of the Ist vessel at this berth. The rates now charged can be suitably enhanced at such intervals as would be mutually agreed upon by the parties from time to time.
x x x x
19. That the Paradip Phosphates, shall be subjected to the application of all relevant laws, rules and regulations of the Paradip Port Trust that are for the time being in force and that would be framed and enforced from time to time.”
20.1. Along with the Agreement a Schedule was annexed which provided for tariff for different facilities to be used by the respondent. Part of the same were fixed whereas other charges namely tug hire, pilotage and port dues were to be paid as per the scale of rates.
20.2. A perusal of Clause 1 of the Agreement shows that the facilities could be used subject to payment of the rate mentioned in the schedule of rates, and the rates charged can be suitably enhanced at such intervals as would be mutually agreed upon between the parties from time to time.
20.3. Clause 19 provides that the respondent shall be subjected to the application of all relevant laws, rules and regulations of the Paradip Port Trust.
21. Merely because an Agreement was entered into between the parties, the same cannot override the provisions of law. The terms of the Agreement only provides for creation of facilities and certain tariff to be charged from the respondent, which could be revised from time to time as agreed. In case the parties do not agree with the revision of tariff the same will not remain in abeyance as some authority has to resolve this issue. Even the counsel for the respondent did not dispute this fact. After the aforesaid Agreement was executed, as cost and overheads on many aspects had increased, vide communication dated 08.04.1993, the appellant had written to the respondent mentioning that ever since the agreement was entered into, the port charges had increased by 50% during 1989, whereas [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1709Paradip Port Authority v. Paradeep Phosphates Ltd. no revision of tariff was made for the respondent. Though, as per the proposed rates, the increase in tariff for others may be in the range of 40 to 50%, whereas for the respondent the additional tariff will be only 25%. Option was given to the respondent in case any discussion was required. From the record before this Court there was nothing to show that any reply was given by the respondent to the aforesaid communication.
21.1. Vide Notification dated 05.10.1993, in exercise of power conferred with the competent authority under Sections 48 to 52 of the 1963 Act, new scale of rates were notified for use of port facilities. The aforesaid notification in Clause 3.1.1 provided for separate rates for the respondent, as compared to the normal rates for other users of the port facilities. The respondent continued paying the revised rates without any objection.
21.2. A communication dated 11.05.2000 from the appellant to the respondent has been referred to, which talks about rejection of the proposal of the respondent for waiver of interest for delayed payment of certain dues from October 1993 to January 1996 and request for payment of the outstanding amount of interest. Opportunity was given to pay the arrears in 3-4 installments. In response to the aforesaid communication, the respondent vide letter dated 18.05.2000, on the subject of waiver of interest for belated payment, submitted that the respondent had been requesting for revision of existing agreement in the present day context. To dispute payment of interest, it was submitted that there was no provision in the Agreement for the purpose. Request for waiver of interest was rejected by the appellant vide communication dated 31.05.2000. Time was granted up to 30.06.2000 for payment of the outstanding interest, failing which the appellant may be constrained to stop the facilities provided for.
22. The respondent filed a civil suit praying for the following reliefs: “a) To declare that the Defendants and their agents have no right to amend the terms and conditions of the bilateral agreement dated 3.8.1985, unilaterally.
1710 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports b) To declare that the defendant and their agents have no right to give effect to the terms and conditions contained in the Scale of Rates published by them in the year 1993 which do not form part of the bilateral agreement dated 3.8.1985.
c) To permanently injunct the defendants their agents and officers from giving effect to the terms and conditions contained in the scale of Rates published by the Defendants in the year 1993. To allow any other relief(s) as it may deem proper in the facts and circumstances of the case. And for which act of kindness the Plaintiff shall ever pray as in duty bound.”
23. Interim stay was granted on 30.06.2000. Vide order dated 15.09.2000, the Trial Court in the aforesaid suit directed the respondent/plaintiff in the civil suit to obtain clearance from the High Power Committee as two public sector units were party to the litigation.
24. It may be out of place if not mentioned here that in the Agreement signed between the parties, Clause 20 provided for reference of any dispute, arising out of or in relation to any of the clause of the agreement, to arbitration. The parties agreed for resolution of disputes by adopting an informal mechanism and an agreement was signed on 10.08.2000 in that regard. It provided for the reference of dispute to the Arbitrator as mentioned in the clause, and in case any of the parties was aggrieved of the award, the remedy of appeal was also provided. The clause specifically mentioned that the Arbitration Act shall not be applicable to the arbitration under this clause. The terms agreed on 10.08.2000 are extracted below:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.