Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1015; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1193
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 22 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11014/2025
- Sections
- 13, 3D, 14, 3C(1), 4, 14(1), 3C, 3, 2, 11(1), 12, 13(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1193 : 2025 INSC 1015 Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed)
v.
The State of Maharashtra and Others (Civil Appeal No. 11014 of 2025)
22 August 2025 [Surya Kant* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the owner of the land in a Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area) has any preferential right to redevelop it under Chapter I-A of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; whether such preferential right, if any, entails that the owner be specially notified and invited to redevelop the SR Area before the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) takes a decision u/s.13 r/w s.3D(b)(iii), Slums Act; whether the power of the State Government to acquire land u/s.14 r/w s.3D(c)(i), Slums Act is subject to the preferential right, if any, of the owner; whether, in the facts of the instant case, the acquisition of the Subject Land by the State Government has rightly been set aside by the High Court.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Chapter I-A – By way of the impugned judgement, High Court held that the scheme of Chapter I-A of the Slums Act creates a preferential right in favour of the owner of an SR Area to redevelop it – Whether the owner of the land in a SR Area has any preferential right to redevelop it under Chapter I-A:
Held: A landowner has the first right among stakeholders to undertake redevelopment under an SR Scheme – Owner’s right to develop an SR Area, holds preference over that of the SRA within Chapter I-A of the Slums Act – ss.3B(4)(e) and 13(1) make it clear that the SRA’s power to undertake redevelopment can only be invoked if the owner extinguishes its right to redevelop – s.13 has its own measure to balance the rights of slum dwellers, by imposing the restriction of ‘reasonable time’ on the owner’s right * Author 1194 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to redevelop – The SRA cannot undertake development of the SR Area unless the owner fails to come forward with a scheme within a reasonable time – SRA has recognised the legislative preference granted to the owner or landlord in Circular No. 144-A dated 09.11.2015, which stipulates that “the first right to file the Slum Rehabilitation scheme is of the owner of the land” – By relaxing the requirement of consent of seventy percent of the slum occupants, it depicts a clear intention on behalf of the SRA that the occupants cannot override the owner’s proposal for an SR Scheme – Impugned judgement upheld. [Paras 51, 53, 61, 63, 107] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Whether the preferential right of the owner, if any, entails that the owner be specially notified and invited to redevelop the SR Area before the SRA takes a decision u/s.13 r/w s.3D(b)(iii), Slums Act:
Held: Though, the Gazette notification or a public notice in newspapers shall be deemed to have informed an owner regarding the s.3C(1) Declaration however, it will be far-fetched and preposterous to further assume that such owner is also obligated to submit a redevelopment scheme when the said notification does not invite the owner to submit any proposal – Mere declaration of an area as an SR Area does not amount to inviting the landowner to redevelop the land, and the publication of the former cannot attract the consequences attributable to the latter – Mere declaration of an area as an SR Area does not amount to inviting the landowner to redevelop the land, and the publication of the former cannot attract the consequences attributable to the latter – Considering the dire consequences potentially suffered by the owner upon inadvertent failure to exercise its preferential right and the SRA’s previous notices, the requirement for a specific notice inviting the owner to submit an SR Scheme, as prescribed in the Impugned Judgement, must be read as mandatory. [Paras 69, 75] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – s.14 vis-à-vis s.13 – Power of State Government to acquire land – Power of Competent Authority to redevelop clearance area – Whether the power of the State Government to acquire land u/s.14 r/w s.3D(c)(i), Slums Act is subject to the preferential right, if any, of the owner: [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1195Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others Held: The owner has a preferential right over other stakeholders to develop an SR Area – If the owner then chooses to exercise this right by submitting and implementing a valid SR Scheme, issues involving rights over the property would not arise – It is, thus, not fathomable that when the landowner is implementing an SR Scheme on its own, a necessity to acquire the land could arise – Rather, any process to acquire the land shall have to be kept in abeyance till such time as the owner’s preferential right to develop it stands extinguished – Since it is open to the owner to file its own SR Scheme within a reasonable time and the proposal of the owner, if valid and complete, would take primacy, it cannot be said that there is any legal necessity to acquire the land – If acquisition is allowed to take place at this stage, it will jeopardise the preferential right of the landowner – It is only when the owner declines to undertake development or to support any third-party development, thereby foregoing its preferential right, that such a necessity would actually arise – Thus, as long as the owner is willing to undertake development in exercise of its preferential right, the acquisition cannot proceed – This can also be harmoniously read in conjunction with the requirement for a notice-cum-invitation to the owner in s.13 – When an SR Area has been notified u/s.3C(1) of Chapter I-A and its development through an SR Scheme is conceptualised, where-under there is an inbuilt preferential right of an owner to carry out redevelopment, the power of acquisition u/s.14 would not operate in an independent silo; rather, it must derive meaning and effect from the principles prevailing throughout the legislative scheme of Chapter I-A – The owner possesses a preferential right to redevelop the SR Area – SRA is duty-bound to invite the owner to submit an SR Scheme and acquisition is not warranted until such right stands extinguished. [Paras 83, 84, 87, 88] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Chapter I-A – Validity of the acquisition of land – Indian Cork Mills Private Limited (ICM) was the owner of the subject land, over time, it was encroached upon by hutment dwellers, and a portion of it was declared as a ‘Slum Area’ u/s.4 – The slum expanded and its dwellers formed the co-operative housing societyappellant – Thereafter, entire subject land was declared as SR area through a s.3C(1) Declaration – Appellant requested Additional Collector for acquiring the Subject Land coupled with a proposal to redevelop the same– Originally, proceedings 1196 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports were initiated before the Additional Collector in the absence of ICM – Fresh notice was issued to the ICM and it responded that as owner, it would like to develop the property itself, under an SR Scheme – Eventually, the CEO submitted report proposing to acquire the subject land recommending that the acquisition be undertaken u/s.14 and that though, while ICM had relayed its willingness to redevelop the Subject Land, it had not filed any SR Scheme – Notification issued by State u/s.14(1) for the acquisition of the Subject Land – ICM filed writ petition, High Court set aside the acquisition inter alia holding that a landowner has a preferential right to develop the Subject Land u/ss. 3B(4) and 13(1); SRA was directed to consider ICM’s proposal expeditiously – Whether, in the facts of the case, the acquisition of the Subject Land by the State Government was rightly set aside by the High Court:
Held: Impugned judgement upheld – The SRA never issued a notice to Indian Cork Mills Private Limited-ICM (owner of the subject land), thereby inviting it to submit an SR Scheme, and does not appear to have explored the opportunity for the owner to develop the Subject Land – As such, ICM’s preferential right to develop the land was not extinguished – On facts, it cannot be concluded that ICM failed to submit its scheme within the stipulated time –ICM was, at all times, willing to prepare and submit an SR Scheme, but neither the appellant-housing society nor the SRA extended the necessary cooperation – Where the circumstances and the conduct of the SRA and the Society themselves impeded the owner from submitting the SR Scheme, it cannot be said that the owner failed to do so within a reasonable period – The SRA and the State exceeded their power, apparently to pre-empt the owner from undertaking redevelopment – The acquisition of land, in such circumstances, being a colourable exercise of power is unsustainable – The conduct and bona fides of both the SRA and the appellant are seriously doubtful – The SRA’s entire initiative to undertake Slum Rehabilitation on the Subject Land was driven at the behest of the appellant – To permit the acquisition to stand, despite the dubious motives of the appellant and its developer and the deeply suspect conduct of the SRA, would catalyse a travesty of justice – Directions issued. [Paras 92-95, 106, 107] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Scheme of the Act – Chapters I-A; IV, V – Original Framework for Slum Redevelopment (1971) vis-à-vis New Framework for Slum Rehabilitation [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1197Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others (Between 1995 and 2018) – 2018 Amendment – Subordinate Legislation/Circulars – Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 1991 – Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Policy in Greater Mumbai, 1997 – General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for Greater Mumbai, 1998 – SRA Circular Nos. 144 and 144-A – Enumerated. [Paras 3-38] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Chapter I-A – Scope – Discussed. Case Law Cited Murlidhar Teckchand Gandhi and Others v. State of Maharashtra and Others, Supreme Court of India, Civil Appeal No. 11077 of 2017, judgement dated 29.08.2017 – distinguished.
Atesham Ahmed Khan v. Lakadawala Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2011 SCC OnLine Bom 239; Awdesh Vasistha Tiwari v. Chief Executive Officer, Slum Rehabilitation Authority, 2006 SCC OnLine Bom 481 – referred to.
List of Acts Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966; Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 1991; Development Control and Promotion Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 2034; Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Policy in Greater Mumbai, 1997; General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for Greater Mumbai, 1998.
List of Keywords Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area); Preferential right of the landowner to redevelop Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area); Preferential right to redevelop; Landowner be specially notified and invited to redevelop the SR Area; Slum Rehabilitation Scheme (SR Scheme); Acquisition of land; Validity of the acquisition of land; Slum dwellers; Village Tungwa, Taluka Kurla, Mumbai; Greater Mumbai; Hutment dwellers; Encroachment of land; Slum area; Slum Rehabilitation Area; Slum Rehabilitation Scheme; Housing society of slum dwellers; Owner’s preferential right; Owner’s right to develop an SR Area; Chapters I-A; IV and V of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1198 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1971; Redevelopment; Failure to exercise preferential right; Landowners; Owner’s preferential right to develop; Sections 13, 14 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Framework for Slum Rehabilitation poorly structured; Power of State Government to acquire land; Power of Competent Authority to redevelop clearance area; Section 3C, Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area; Section 3C(1) Declaration; Pre-empt the owner from undertaking redevelopment; Colourable exercise of power; Proposal for redevelopment; Acquisition for redevelopment; Land acquisition proposal; Willingness to develop the Subject Land; Scheme for redevelopment; Landholders; Occupants; Peremptory right of redevelopment; Marginalised section of urban society; Third-party developers; Manipulating inhabitants; Reasonable time; Issuance of notice-cum-invite to landowner.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11014 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.06.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WP No. 658 of 2017 With Civil Appeal No(s). 11015 and 11016 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Sudhanshu S. Choudhari, Sr. Adv., Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, Ms. Gautami Yadav, Ms. Damini Vishwakarma, Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Arpit Rai, Sudipto Sircar, Aviral Kashyap.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Sudhanshu S. Choudhari, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Amar Dave, Shyam Mehta, Sr. Advs., Amol Nirmalkumar Suryawanshi, Ms. Gautami Yadav, Ms. Srishty Pandey, Sunil Kumar Verma, Aman Raj Gandhi, Ms. Jasmine Seth, Aryan Srivastava, Parthasarathy Bose, Ms. Panchi Agarwal, Pranaya Goyal, Ms. Sonali Jaitley Bakhshi, Jaiyesh Bakhshi, Ravi Tyagi, Mayank Mishra, Ms. Manmilan Sidhu, Ankit Tyagi, Ms. Sudiksha Saina, Ms. Bhumika Bhatnagar, Shikhar Misra, P. V. Yogeswaran, Varad Kilor, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1199Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others Aaditya Aniruddha Pande, Sachin Patil, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Abhikalp Pratap Singh, Utkarsh Kumar, Ms. Shubhangi Agarwal, Aditya Krishna, Arpit Rai, Sudipto Sircar, Aviral Kashyap. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. The dispute which falls for consideration in these Civil Appeals pertains to the validity of the acquisition of land bearing CTS Nos. 119 I and 119 I/1-83 in Village Tungwa, Taluka Kurla, Mumbai, admeasuring 9,054 sq. m. (Subject Land), under the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 (Slums Act). The High Court of Judicature at Bombay (High Court), vide the Impugned Judgements dated 13.06.2018 and 09.07.2018, has:
(i) allowed the writ petition filed by the landowner; (ii) held the acquisition to be void; and (iii) directed the State of Maharashtra and the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) to invite the landowner and consider its proposal for redevelopment. The instant appeals have, thus, been preferred by the proposed housing society of slum dwellers, the State of Maharashtra, and the SRA.
A. LEGISLATIVE SCHEME
3. Before delving into the facts of this case, it may be prudent to first consider the legislative scheme of the Slums Act.
4. The Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 was originally enacted by the Maharashtra State Legislature as “[an] Act to make better provision for the improvement and clearance of slum areas in the State and their redevelopment.”
A.1 Original Framework for Slum Redevelopment (1971)
5. In its original form, the Slums Act provided a procedure for appointment of a Competent Authority (Section 3); declaration by the Competent Authority of certain slums as ‘Slum Areas’ (Chapter II); improvements to be conducted in such Slum Areas by the landowner or the Competent Authority (Chapter III); clearing and redevelopment of 1200 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the Slum Areas (Chapter IV); and the acquisition of land for such redevelopment (Chapter V).
6. Given the background of the instant appeals, it seems to us that, besides the definitions contained in Section 2 of the Slums Act, Chapters IV and V thereof also merit a more detailed consideration.
7. Section 2 contains the definitions of various terms and phrases used in the Slums Act:
“2. Definitions.– In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires –– [xxxx]
(d) “land” includes building and also benefits to arise out of land, things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to anything attached to the earth;
(e) “occupier” includes,—
(i) any person who for the time being is paying or is liable to pay to the owner the rent or any portion of the rent of the land or building in respect of which such rent is paid or is payable;
(ii) an owner in occupation of, or otherwise using, his land or building;
(iii) a rent-free tenant of any land or building;
(iv) a licensee in occupation of any land or building; and
(v) any person who is liable to pay to the owner damages for the use and occupation of any land or building;
(f) “owner”, when used with reference to any building or land, means the person who receives or is entitled to receive the rent of the building or land, if the building or land were let, and includes,—
(i) an agent or trustee who receives such rent on account of the owner;
(ii) an agent or trustee who receives the rent of, or is entrusted with, or concerned for, any [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1201Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others building or land devoted to religious or charitable purpose;
(iii) a receiver, sequestrator or manager appointed by a court of competent jurisdiction to have the charge of or to exercise the rights of owner of the said building or land; and
(iv) a mortgagee-in-possession;
but does not include, a slumlord;
[xxxx]
(h) “slum clearance” means the clearance of any slum area by the demolition and removal of buildings therefrom;
[xxxx] ”
8. It may be noted that although the term ‘landholder’ is not expressly defined within the legislation, it is taken to mean all the persons who hold any interest in the land in question. This would, of course, include the owner(s) of the land, but it also covers other interest holders, such as mortgagees or assignees.
9. Chapter IV lays down the process whereby the Competent Authority can decide to clear a declared Slum Area, execute such a decision, and initiate the redevelopment of the area.
10. Section 11(1) allows the Competent Authority to declare a Slum Area as a Clearance Area, if it is satisfied “that the most satisfactory method of dealing with the conditions in the area is the demolition of all the buildings in the area.”
11. Following the declaration, Section 12 stipulates how the buildings and structures on the land would be cleared. A Clearance Order is to be issued by the Competent Authority, whereafter the occupants are given a specified time to vacate the buildings. An appeal against the Clearance Order lies before a Tribunal. Once the Clearance Order becomes operative, the landowner must demolish the buildings on its land within six weeks, at its own cost.
12. Within this scheme, sub-section (10) of Section 12 further allows the owner to redevelop the land after the execution of the Clearance Order, subject to any laws governing town planning, erection of buildings, and 1202 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports approval of plans as well as any restrictions placed by the Competent Authority. For reference, we shall quote the following portion of Section 12:
“12. Clearance Order.– [xxxx]
(10) Subject to the provisions of this Act, and of any other law for the time being in force in relation to town-planning and to the regulation of the erection of buildings, where a clearance order has become operative, the owner of the land to which the clearance order applies, may redevelop the land in accordance with the plans approved by the Competent Authority, and subject to such restrictions and conditions (including a condition with regard to the time within which the redevelopment shall be completed), if any as that Authority may think fit to impose:
Provided that, an owner who is aggrieved by a restriction or condition so imposed on the user of his land, or by a subsequent refusal of the Competent Authority to cancel or modify any such restriction or condition may, within such time as may be prescribed, appeal to the Tribunal and its decision shall be final.
(11) No person shall commence or cause to be commenced any work in contravention of a plan approved or a restriction or condition imposed under sub-section (10).”
[Emphasis supplied]
13. Finally, the Competent Authority is also permitted to redevelop the Clearance Area at its own cost under Section 13(1). The only requirements to exercise this power are that the owner must not have commenced redevelopment work and the Competent Authority ought to be satisfied that such an action would be necessary in public interest. Section 13 is reproduced hereinbelow:
“13. Power of Competent Authority to redevelop clearance area.– (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) of section 12, the Competent Authority may, at any time after the land has been cleared of buildings in [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1203Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others accordance with a clearance order, but before the work of redevelopment of that land has been commenced by the owner, by order, determine to redevelop the land at its own cost, if that Authority is satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest to do so.
(2) Where land has been cleared of the buildings in accordance with a clearance order, the Competent Authority, if it is satisfied that the land has been, or is being, redeveloped by the owner thereof in contravention of plans duly approved, or any restrictions or conditions imposed under sub-section (10) of section 12, or has not been redeveloped within the time, if any, specified under such conditions, may, by order, determine to redevelop the land at its own cost:
Provided that, before passing such order, the owner shall be given a reasonable opportunity of showing cause why the order should not be passed.”
14. To complement the above-mentioned ability of the Competent Authority to redevelop the Clearance Area, Chapter V introduces a procedure for the acquisition of land under the Slums Act. While Section 14 gives power to the State Government to acquire land, subsequent Sections provide for concomitant processes to take over possession of the land as well as for computation, apportionment, and payment or deposit of compensation for the acquisition.
15. For reference, Section 14 is reproduced below:
“14. Power of State Government to acquire land.– (1)
Where on any representation from the Competent Authority it appears to the State Government that, in order to enable the Authority to execute any work of improvement or to redevelop any slum area or any structure in such area, it is necessary that such area, or any land within adjoining or surrounded by any such area should be acquired, the State Government may acquire the land by publishing in the Official Gazette, a notice to the effect that the State Government has decided to acquire the land in pursuance of this section:
Provided that, before publishing such notice, the State Government, or as the case may be, the Competent 1204 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Authority may call upon by notice the owner of, or any other person who, in its or his opinion may be interested in, such land to show cause in writing why the land should not be acquired with reasons therefor, to the Competent Authority within the period specified in the notice; and the Competent Authority shall, with all reasonable despatch, forward any objections so submitted together with his report in respect thereof to the State Government and on considering the report and the objections, if any, the State Government may pass such order as it deems fit.
(1A) The acquisition of land for any purpose mentioned in sub-section (1) shall be deemed to be a public purpose.
(2) When a notice as aforesaid is published in the Official Gazette, the land shall, on and from the date on which the notice is so published, vest absolutely in the State Government free from all encumbrances.”
16. This above system, holistically, constitutes the original framework for initiating the redevelopment of slums under the Slums Act, beginning with declaration of a Slum Area and concluding with either the owner developing it or the SRA taking over the redevelopment. A.2 New Framework for Slum Rehabilitation (Between 1995 and 2018)
17. In 1995, the Maharashtra State Legislature amended the Slums Act to introduce a new framework for Slum Rehabilitation through Chapter I-A. According to the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Amendment, the intention was to establish an authority responsible for overseeing each aspect of the slum rehabilitation process, including situations where slum dwellers were not participating. The phrase ‘Slum Rehabilitation Work’ has since been defined within Section 2(h-e) of the Slums Act as “the work relating to demolition of any structure or any part thereof in slum area or Slum Rehabilitation Area, and construction of a new building thereon.” This amendment, however, did not tinker with the original legislative policy existing prior to 1995. Instead, Chapter I-A was incorporated to act as a separate procedure, applicable to certain areas.
18. Section 3A provides for the appointment of the Slum Rehabilitation Authority for certain areas to facilitate and regulate the redevelopment [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1205Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others process. For this purpose, each SRA has a Chief Executive Officer (CEO). In the context of the area concerned in the instant case, the SRA for Greater Mumbai has been in place since 1995.
19. Section 3B stipulates the power and duty of the SRA to prepare the General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme (General SR Scheme) for the area covered by the SRA. Sub-section (4), which lists the matters which the General SR Scheme would provide for, is reproduced for reference:
“3B. Slum Rehabilitation Schemes.– [xxxx]
(4) The Slum Rehabilitation Scheme so notified under sub-section (3) shall, generally lay down the parameters for declaration of any land as the Slum Rehabilitation Area and indicate the manner in which rehabilitation of the area declared as Slum Rehabilitation Area shall be carried out. In particular, it shall provide for all or any of the following matters, that is to say,-
(a) the parameters or guidelines for declaration of an area as the slum rehabilitation area;
(b) basic and essential parameters of development of slum rehabilitation area under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme;
(c) provision for obligatory participation of the landholders and occupants of the area declared as the slum rehabilitation area under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in the implementation of the Scheme;
(d) provision relating to transit accommodation pending development of the slum rehabilitation area and allotment of tenements on development to the occupants of such area, free of cost.
(e) scheme for development of the Slum Rehabilitation Areas under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme by the landholders and occupants by themselves or through a developer and the terms and conditions of such development; and the option 1206 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports available to the Slum Rehabilitation Authority for taking up such development in the event of non-participation of the landholders or occupants;
(f) provision regarding sanction of Floor Space Index and transfer of development rights, if any, to be made available to the developer for development of the slum rehabilitation area under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme;
(g) provision regarding non-transferable nature of tenements for a certain period, etc.
[xxxx] ”
[Emphasis supplied]
20. Section 3C, reproduced hereinafter, provides for the declaration of an area as a Slum Rehabilitation Area (SR Area). After the publication of the General SR Scheme, the CEO can declare any area as an SR Area, if it meets the criteria specified in the said Scheme. Such a declaration (Section 3C(1) Declaration) would be published in the Official Gazette, and an appeal against it lies before the Special Tribunal.
“3C. Declaration of a slum rehabilitation area.–
(1) As soon as may be, after the publication of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the Chief Executive Officer on being satisfied circumstances in respect of any area, justifying its declaration as slum rehabilitation area under the said scheme, may by an order published in the Official Gazette, declare such area to be a “slum rehabilitation area”. The order declaring slum rehabilitation area (hereinafter referred to as “the slum rehabilitation order”) shall also be given wide publicity in such manner as may be specified by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority.
(2) Any person aggrieved by the slum rehabilitation order may, within four weeks of the publication of such order prefer an appeal to the Special Tribunal; and the decision of the Special Tribunal shall be final.
(3) On the completion of the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, the Slum Rehabilitation Area shall cease to be such area.” [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1207Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
21. Section 3D contains the provisions for the application of other Chapters of the Slums Act to an area declared as an SR Area. Section 3D(a) stipulates that Chapters II (regarding declaration of Slum Areas) and III (regarding improvements in Slum Areas) would not apply to an SR Area.
22. Section 3D(b) clarifies that Chapter IV (regarding clearance and redevelopment) applies to SR Areas. As per sub-clause (i), Section 11 (regarding declaration as Clearance Area) is not applicable to an SR Area. As such, once an area is declared to be an SR Area, it cannot then be declared as a Clearance Area.
23. Section 3D(b)(ii) provides that Section 12 of the Slums Act is applicable with certain modifications. Effectively, the CEO is empowered to issue a Clearance Order under Section 12 in respect of SR Areas. It is pertinent that the modification virtually retains sub-section (10), wherein, as already elucidated, the private owner of the SR Area has the right to redevelop it after the Clearance Order comes into force.1
24. Section 3D(b)(iii), then, effectively substitutes Section 13 and introduces a new framework which replaces the original scheme. Under this new provision, the SRA can decide to undertake rehabilitation of the slum itself after the area is declared an SR Area.
25. Section 3D(c) deals with the applicability of Chapter V (regarding the acquisition of land). Generally, the acquisition powers under Chapter V are made applicable to SR Areas with certain modifications. These modifications place the CEO as a substitute for the Competent Authority. Specifically, a modification is also made to the first part of Section 14 to clarify when the acquisition can be undertaken.
26. The remaining provisions in Section 3D address other aspects of implementing the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme (SR Scheme) and ensuring the rehabilitation of slum dwellers.
27. At this juncture, it is essential to reproduce the relevant portions of Section 3D:
“3D. Application of other Chapters of this Act to slum Rehabilitation Area with modification.– On publication of the slum Rehabilitation Scheme under sub-section (1) of Section 3B, the provisions of other Chapters of this Act 1 Reproduced in Paragraph 12.
1208 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports shall apply to any area declared as the slum rehabilitation area, subject to the following modifications, namely:- [xxxx]
(b) in Chapter IV,- [xxxx]
(ii) in Section 12,- [xxxx] (H) in sub-section (10),-
(a) for the words “Competent Authority”, the words “Slum Rehabilitation Authority” shall be substituted;
(b) in the proviso,-
(i) for the words “Competent Authority”, the words “Chief Executive Officer” shall be substituted;
(ii) for the words “Tribunal”, the words “Special Tribunal” shall be substituted;
(iii) for Section 13, the following Section shall be substituted, namely:- “13. Power of Slum Rehabilitation Authority to develop Slum Rehabilitation Area.– (1)
Notwithstanding anything contained in subsection (10) of section 12, the Slum Rehabilitation authority may, after any area is declared as the Slum Rehabilitation Area, if the landholders or occupants of such area do not come forward within a reasonable time, with a scheme for redevelopment of such land, by order, determine to redevelop such land by entrusting it to any agency for the purpose.
(2) Where on declaration of any area as a Slum Rehabilitation Area the Slum Rehabilitation [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1209Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others Authority , is satisfied that the land in the Slum Rehabilitation Area has been or is being developed by the owner in contravention of the plan duly approved, or any restrictions of conditions imposed under sub-section (10) of section 12, or has not been developed within the time, if any, specified under such conditions it may, by order, determine to develop the land by entrusting it to any agency for the purpose:
Provided that, before passing such the owner shall be given a reasonable opportunity of cause why such order should not be passed.”;
(c) in Chapter V,-
(i) in Section 14, in sub-section (1),- (A) for the portion beginning with the words “Where on any representation” and ending with the words “clearance area”
the following portion shall be substituted, namely:- “Where on any representation from the Chief Executive Officer it appears to the State Government that, in order to enable the Slum Rehabilitation Authority to carry out development under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in any Slum Rehabilitation Area”
(B) after the proviso, the following proviso shall be added, namely:- “Provided further that, the State Government may delegate its powers under this sub-section to any officer not below the rank of Commissioner.”
[xxxx] ”
28. The text of Section 14, as contained in Chapter V in the original legislative scheme, has already been reproduced in Paragraph 15 above. However, as previously noticed, for the purpose of giving effect 1210 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to the new scheme envisaged in Chapter I-A, the said Section 14, especially sub-section (1) thereof, has been partially amended through Section 3D and reads as follows:
“14. Power of State Government to acquire land.– (1)
Where on any representation from the Chief Executive Officer it appears to the State Government that, in order to enable the Slum Rehabilitation Authority to carry out development under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in any Slum Rehabilitation Area it is necessary that such area, or any land within adjoining or surrounded by any such area should be acquired, the State Government may acquire the land by publishing in the Official Gazette, a notice to the effect that the State Government has decided to acquire the land in pursuance of this section:
Provided that, before publishing such notice, the State Government, or as the case may be, the Competent Authority may call upon by notice the owner of, or any other person who, in its or his opinion may be interested in, such land to show cause in writing why the land should not be acquired with reasons therefor, to the Competent Authority within the period specified in the notice; and the Competent Authority shall, with all reasonable despatch, forward any objections so submitted together with his report in respect thereof to the State Government and on considering the report and the objections, if any, the State Government may pass such order as it deems fit.
Provided further that, the State Government may delegate its powers under this sub-section to any officer not below the rank of Commissioner.
[xxxx] ”
[Emphasis supplied]
29. The subsequent provisions of Chapter I-A lay down the administrative aspects of the SRA’s functioning.
30. Since the instant case pertains to an SR Area under Chapter I-A, it is clarified that wherever the provisions of Chapters IV and V are referred to, the reference remains to the modified provisions as they are now encapsulated in Section 3D. However, wherever need be, [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1211Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others the original provisions of Chapters IV and V will be referred to with the phrase ‘original framework’.
A.3 The 2018 Amendment
31. The Slums Act was further amended in 2018, with substantial changes made to the expressions and language of certain provisions, reflecting the revised legislative policy.
32. However, considering that the actions impugned before the High Court took place before the amended Act came into force on 26.04.2018, there is no gainsaying that the instant case would have to be adjudicated in accordance with the law as it stood when the acquisition was initiated.
33. We are pained to observe that the Slums Act, especially the framework for Slum Rehabilitation, is poorly structured. There appears to be no cogent reason as to why, instead of enacting a self-contained code within Section I-A, the drafters of this legislation chose to incorporate an entirely distinct slum rehabilitation mechanism by amending the existing legislation through Section 3D. This approach to drafting inevitably blurs the boundaries between the two frameworks, creating confusion in the mind of a reader. In this backdrop, dealing with the 2018 Amendment at this stage would only exacerbate the perplexity. We thus do not deem it necessary to refer to or reproduce the 2018 Amendment.
A.4 Subordinate Legislation and other Circulars
34. It is also imperative to note that the Slums Act is supplemented by critical subordinate legislation/circulars to enable its proper implementation. Keeping in view the discussion above, consideration would be limited to the subordinate legislation/circulars applicable at the time of initiation of the acquisition. The same are noticed herein below.
A.4.1 Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai,
35. The development of urban areas in Maharashtra is governed by the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966. Under this Act, the State Government notified the Development Control Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 1991 (DCR 1991). It creates a regulatory framework for any development work to be carried out within 1212 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Greater Mumbai. Regulation 33(10) was introduced to cover plans to redevelop slums. This Regulation predates the new framework under Chapter I-A of the Slums Act and is thus applicable in cases of development of Slum Areas as well as SR Areas. It provides a comprehensive scheme of requirements and approvals, along with development incentives, such as additional transferable Floor Space Index (FSI). Although the DCR 1991 has been replaced in 2020 by the Development Control and Promotion Regulations for Greater Mumbai, 2034 (DCPR 2034), Regulation 33(10) retains its position and remains substantially unchanged.
A.4.2 Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Policy in Greater Mumbai, 1997
36. The SRA issued the Guidelines for the Implementation of Slum Rehabilitation Policy in Greater Mumbai, 1997 (1997 Guidelines), to clarify the procedure for slum rehabilitation. Clause IV of the 1997 Guidelines outlines the procedure for submitting, processing, and approving SR Schemes. In Paragraph 8 thereof, it is provided that redevelopment plans are to be prepared in accordance with Regulation 33(10) of the DCR 1991. Furthermore, it lays out the various Annexures which are to be duly filled and submitted along with the proposal. They require details such as the ownership of the land, the existing structures on the land, a list of dwellers, and their approval for the proposed redevelopment scheme, as well as the financial details showing the promoter’s capacity to undertake and complete the redevelopment. The 1997 Guidelines subsequently outline the further steps to be taken by the SRA to process any proposal submitted in the specified format.
A.4.3 General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for Greater Mumbai,
37. The SRA has also notified the General Slum Rehabilitation Scheme for Greater Mumbai, 1998 (1998 General Scheme) under Section 3B of the Slums Act. It covers the parameters based on which the rehabilitation of the slum would be undertaken by the SRA. A.4.4 SRA Circular Nos. 144 and 144-A
38. The SRA has issued various circulars to clarify and lay down the procedures of its functioning. Specifically, Circular No. 144, issued [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1213Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others on 31.08.2013, provides the procedure for submission, scrutiny, and consideration of an SR Scheme. Inter alia, it requires that the proposal be submitted as per Regulation 33(10) of DCR 1991, and all the relevant Annexures be included with the proposal. It also makes various clarifications and suggestions to streamline the scrutiny process. Importantly, it lays down that the SR Schemes must be strictly in conformity with the laid down format. The SRA has also issued Circular No. 144-A on 09.11.2015, whereunder, it recognises that landowners have the first right to file SR Schemes and has relaxed the requirement of obtaining the consent of 70% of slum dwellers if the landowner(s) themselves file the SR Scheme.
B. FACTS
39. Having illustratively captured the statutory scheme, we now advert to the facts of this case, which are delineated below in detail.
39.1. Indian Cork Mills Private Limited (ICM) has been the owner of the Subject Land since 1970. The said land seems to have been encroached upon by hutment dwellers, and thereupon, a portion of it admeasuring 3,045.03 sq. m. was declared as a ‘Slum Area’ under Section 4 of the Slums Act on 18.09.1979.
39.2. Over time, the slum expanded, and its dwellers formed the Tarabai Nagar Co-operative Housing Society (Proposed)
(Tarabai Society) on 28.02.2002.
39.3. Tarabai Society moved letters and applications in 2006-2008 before the Competent Authority under the Slums Act, seeking a survey of the slum, declaration of the remainder of the Subject Land as a Slum Area, and its acquisition for redevelopment. Accordingly, surveys were conducted, and vide notification dated 11.03.2011, the SRA declared the entire Subject Land as an SR Area through a Section 3C(1) Declaration.
39.4. As a consequence, Tarabai Society reiterated its request to the Additional Collector (Encroachment/Clearance), Eastern Suburban, Mumbai, for acquiring the Subject Land under Section 14,2 through letters dated 28.02.2012, 15.03.2012, and 05.05.2012, coupled with a proposal to redevelop the same. 2 Reproduced in Paragraph 28.
1214 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
39.5. In pursuance of the above proposal, the State of Maharashtra, through the Additional Collector, issued a public notice dated 17.05.2012 under the first proviso to Section 14(1), 3 calling upon ICM, as landowner, and other interested parties to show cause as to why Tarabai Society’s proposal should not be forwarded for approval. As per ICM, this notice was not served upon it.
39.6. As things stood thus, proceedings in this regard were originally initiated before the Additional Collector in the absence of ICM. Although some third parties had raised objections, the Additional Collector rejected them as these were in respect of adjoining parcels of land, not the Subject Land. As such, the Additional Collector recommended that the Subject Land be acquired and forwarded a report dated 04.08.2012 to the Housing Department, Government of Maharashtra.
39.7. Upon consideration of the report, the Ward Officer, Housing Department, sought the remarks of the CEO on the land acquisition proposal. The CEO, vide letter dated 29.11.2012, informed the State that no SR Scheme had been received in respect of the subject property, and there was no objection to the acquisition. However, the State was not satisfied with the response and sought clarification from the CEO as to whether the landowners had been heard or any opportunity had been given to them.
39.8. Accordingly, a fresh notice was issued to ICM on 08.08.2013 regarding the land acquisition proposal. It responded to the notice on 23.08.2013, stating, inter alia, that, as the owner, it would like to develop the property itself, under an SR Scheme, without any third-party involvement. ICM further reiterated this objection during the hearings dated 26.08.2013 and 16.09.2013, whereafter the CEO reserved its order on the matter.
39.9. Meanwhile, ICM relayed a communication dated 12.09.2013 to the Deputy Collector, SRA, highlighting its intention to redevelop the Subject Land without any interference from third-party builders and developers.
3 Reproduced in Paragraph 28.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1215Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
39.10. ICM also addressed a letter dated 08.10.2013 to Tarabai Society, confirming its willingness to redevelop the Subject Land by implementing an SR Scheme. However, the Tarabai Society does not appear to have responded to the said letter. On the other hand, a different society, namely, the Tara Nagar Welfare Society, approached ICM regarding rehabilitation, but no substantive communication proceeded with this society.
39.11. Finally, the CEO submitted its report dated 21.12.2013 to the State Government, proposing to acquire the Subject Land. It was recommended that the acquisition be undertaken under Section 14,4 and that while ICM had relayed its willingness to redevelop the Subject Land, it had not filed any SR Scheme. The CEO also conveyed a formal request for acquisition, vide letter dated 09.01.2014.
39.12. Subsequently, the SRA, acting on the directions of the State Government, conducted inspections and surveys on the Subject Land to determine its feasibility for implementing an SR Scheme. It was reported that rehabilitation is feasible, and if the land were to be acquired, the SRA would be able to approve an SR Scheme. The Housing Department, thereafter on 09.01.2015, directed that the matter be placed for consideration before the Minister for Housing, Government of Maharashtra, for appropriate orders.
39.13. In this backdrop, ICM sent a letter dated 25.02.2015 to the Minister for Housing, reiterating its intention to develop the Subject Land and not to grant rights in this regard to any third party. This letter was then forwarded to the CEO, requesting that it reply to ICM and mark a copy to the Government.
39.14. ICM communicated another letter, dated 06.05.2015, to the CEO, reiterating its willingness to develop the Subject Land in accordance with the stipulations prescribed under Regulation 33(10) of the DCR 1991. For this purpose, ICM sought directions from the SRA to enable it to carry out a survey and demarcation so as to submit a proposal for redevelopment.
4 Reproduced in Paragraph 28.
1216 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
39.15. Considering the above correspondence, the CEO, on 15.05.2015, recommended to the State that, in conformity with the notion that the landlord ought to be afforded the first right to develop the land, an opportunity ought to be given to ICM to submit an SR Scheme. Still further, the State, in its response dated 12.10.2015, recorded that the entire matter ought to be reconsidered, either at the level of the SRA or, if necessary, at the level of the High-Powered Committee constituted by the High Court.5
39.16. The CEO, however, in what can be construed as a volte face, forwarded a report dated 12.09.2016 to the State Government, reaffirming its previous reasoning that ICM has not submitted any SR Scheme and that it would thus not be proper to provide another opportunity to ICM. As such, it was recommended that the acquisition of the Subject Land be initiated by the State Government.
39.17. In this vein, the State Government issued a notification dated 22.12.2016 under Section 14(1) 6 for the acquisition of the Subject Land.
39.18. Additionally, the SRA sent a communication dated 07.01.2017 to ICM, seeking details of the Subject Land required for the acquisition. This included the number of hutments, the approximate rent of each hut, and the total rent recovered over the last 5 years. ICM was also informed to be present before the Deputy Collector, SRA, for a hearing scheduled on 19.01.2017.
39.19. Aggrieved, ICM filed Writ Petition No. 658 of 2017 before the High Court, challenging the notification dated 22.12.2016 and the notice dated 07.01.2017.
39.20. The High Court, vide an interim order dated 27.01.2017, directed that status quo be maintained in respect of the acquisition of the property.
5 High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Writ Petition No. 1326 of 2007, judgement dated 01.11.2007; High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Notice of Motion No. 126 of 2008 in Writ Petition No. 1326 of 2007, judgement dated 18.12.2008.
6 Reproduced in Paragraph 28 [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1217Tarabai Nagar Co-Op. Hog. Society (Proposed) v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
39.21. The High Court on 13.06.2018 passed the Impugned Judgement, allowing the Writ Petition. As already iterated, the High Court held that (i) a landowner has a preferential right to develop the Subject Land, which is enshrined in Sections 3B(4) and 13(1) of the Slums Act;7 (ii) the SRA was under a duty to issue a notice to invite the owner to submit an SR Scheme once private land is declared to be an SR Area; and (iii) the power of the State to acquire land under Section 14 read with Section 3D(c)(i) 8 was subject to the owner’s preferential right. The Court, therefore, concluded that if an owner had not been invited to submit an SR Scheme, such acquisition would be without foundation and consequently fail. Keeping these postulates in mind, the High Court observed that the State and the SRA had conducted the acquisition in the absence of any proper opportunity afforded to ICM to submit its SR Scheme. Thus, the High Court set aside the acquisition and directed the SRA to consider ICM’s proposal expeditiously.
39.22. Vide a clarificatory order dated 09.07.2018, the High Court corrected a typographical error in the judgement dated 13.06.2018.
39.23. Aggrieved by the decision of the High Court, Tarabai Society, the State of Maharashtra, and the SRA have filed independent appeals against the Impugned Judgements dated 13.06.2018 and 09.07.2018.
C. CONTENTIONS
40. Mr. Shyam Divan, learned Senior Counsel, appearing on behalf of Tarabai Society, vehemently contended that neither the legislative scheme of the Slums Act nor the facts and circumstances of this case warrant that ICM be allowed to interfere in the redevelopment of the Subject Land. In this regard, he adduced the following submissions:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.