Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd. (Now Known As Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1004; [2025] 8 S.C.R. 1053
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.M. Sundresh, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 19 Aug 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10882/2025
- Sections
- 16(3), 10, 164, 16, 16(4), 16(5), 7, 15, 51, 10(6)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1053 : 2025 INSC 1004 Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd.
(Now Known as Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.)
v.
Vinod and Ors. Etc.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 10882-10888 of 2025)
19 August 2025 [M.M. Sundresh and Rajesh Bindal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the landowners seeking further enhancement of compensation on account of damages suffered by erection of transmission lines and towers, whereas the Contractor challenging the amount of compensation awarded; and whether there should be some remedy of appeal against order passed by the District Judge.
Headnotes† Telegraph Act, 1885 – s.16(3), (4) – Disputes as to compensation – Assessment of compensation for the Tower Base Area (land beneath four legs of the tower) and the Right of Way-ROW Corridor – Utilization of land owned by the landowners for erection of tower or drawing power lines in four districts, however ownership of the land not transferred – Damages suffered by the landowners – Petition u/s.16(3) before the District Judge by the landowners – Award of compensation by District Judge of Sonepat and Jhajjar respectively – High Court decided bunch of petitions, and awarded uniform compensation to the landowners @ 85% of the collector rate beneath the tower area, determined at ₹1.50 crores per acre, and for diminishing the value of land across the width of ROW, 15% of the value of land, on account of imposition of restrictions on utilization thereof – High Court assessed the compensation in all cases on basis of the facts pertaining to land in district Sonepat only, without touching the facts pertaining to district Jhajjar – Sustainability:
Held: Order passed by the High Court cannot be legally sustained – High Court failed to appreciate the fundamental fact that land * Author 1054 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports pertaining to different villages falling in different districts, which may be the subject matter of consideration for assessment of compensation, would have been assessed differently by the Collector based on their respective locations and characteristics – Facts only pertaining to district Sonepat have been discussed – Applying a uniform rate for the entire transmission corridor would not be a proper methodology for assessing fair compensation to which the landowners are entitled to – Thus, the manner adopted by the High Court for assessment of compensation not approved – Some parties invoked Art. 226, whereas others filed petitions invoking Art. 227 challenging the judgments of the trial court, which were delivered on appreciation of evidence – This is solely because no proper appellate remedy has been provided against the order passed by the District Judge – There are other gaps as well in the statutory scheme-limited determination of compensation, no timelines regarding payment of compensation to the affected parties after the right u/s.10(d) is exercised by the competent authority – This being an Act of Parliament, its application has to be uniform throughout the country – In the absence of defined parameters, it will depend on different courts, how they interpret the provisions – Unless statutory remedy of appeal is provided where all issues of law and facts can be re-examined, any other remedy may be illusionary – Remedies availed by different parties were different – Reappriciation of evidence in those proceedings may be an issue – Anomalies with reference to various timelines as well, the matter to be examined – Issues to be examined by the Law Commission of India and the Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India, to determine whether a statutory remedy of appeal should be provided against judgments/orders passed u/s.16(3) and 16(4), the Petroleum Act or any other similar statute – In district Sonepat, application for dispute related to compensation was registered and numbered as a Civil Suit where a judgment and decree was passed, whereas in district Jhajjar, the same was registered as a Civil Miscellaneous Application and only judgment was passed – Need to bring uniformity in the nomenclature to be assigned to these kind of proceedings, which may come to the court under the 1885 Act and also the proceedings under the Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962 – Order passed by the High Court set aside – Matters remitted back to the High Court for fresh consideration – Electricity Act, 2003.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1055Kalpataru P ower T ransmission Ltd. (Now Known as Kalpataru P rojects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc. Case Law Cited Janardhan Reddy and Others v. State, 1950 INSC 37 : [1950] 1 SCR 940 : AIR 1951 SC 124; The Kerala State Electricity Board, Trivandrum v. T.P. Kunhaliumma, 1976 INSC 272 : [1977] 1 SCR 996 : AIR 1977 SC 282; Suhas H. Pophale v. Oriental Insurance Company Limited and Its Estate Officer, 2014 INSC 92 : [2014] 2 SCR 480 : AIR 2014 SC 1509; State of Haryana and Another v. Pala Ram and Others, 2012 SCC Online P&H 24551; Kerala SEB v. Livisha, 2007 INSC 638 : [2007] 7 SCR 356 : (2007) 6 SCC 792; M.L. Jaggi v. Mahanagar Telephones Nigam Ltd. and Ors., 1996 INSC 6 : [1996] 1 SCR 25 : (1996) 3 SCC 119 – referred to. List of Acts Telegraph Act, 1885; Electricity Act, 2003; Land Acquisition Act, 1894; Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013; Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immovable Property Act, 1952; Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996; National Highways Act, 1956; Railways Act, 1989; Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957; Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962.
List of Keywords Landowners; Enhancement of compensation; Damages suffered by erection of transmission lines and towers; Remedy of appeal; District Judge; Tower Base Area (land beneath four legs of the tower) and the Right of Way corridor; Collector rate beneath the tower area; District of Sonepat; District of Jhajjar; Land pertaining to different villages falling in different districts; Uniform rate for the entire transmission corridor; Methodology for assessing fair compensation; Anomalies with reference to various timelines; Law Commission of India; Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India; Uniformity in the nomenclature.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s).
10882-10888 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.02.2023 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CWP No(s). 21878, 1056 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 26406, 9495, and 28540 of 2017 in CR No(s). 3502, 3503 and 3830 of 2017 With Civil Appeal No(s).10889-10890 and 10891-10892 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Nidhesh Gupta, Sr. Adv., Arvind Gupta, Mahesh Agarwal, Rishi Agrawala, Manu Krishnan, Sunil Mittal, Ms. Madhavi Agarwal, Amit Sagar, Amit Kumar, Jimut Mohapatra, E. C. Agrawala.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Lokesh Sinhal, Sr. A.A.G., Mahabir Singh, Sr. Adv, Rakesh Dahiya, Karan Singh, Akshat Jain, Praveen Kumar, Rn Mahlawat, Rajeev Sharma, Arvind Gupta, Samar Vijay Singh, Nikunj Gupta, Ms. Akanksha, Ms. Sabarni Som, Fateh Singh, Aman Dev Sharma, Ms. Ishika Gupta, Sarthak Arya, Vaibhav Saini.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Rajesh Bindal, J.
Table of Contents* S.
No.
Particulars Paras Page
1. Factual background 2 – 7 2 – 7 Civil Appeal No(s). 10882-10888 of 2025 [@SLP (C) No(s). 14936-14942/2023] 5 – 5.1 4 – 5 Civil Appeal No(s).10891-10892 of 2025 [@SLP (C) No(s).18246-18247 of 2025] 6 – 6.1 6 Civil Appeal No(s). 10889-10890 of 2025 [@SLP (C) No(s). 14926-14927/2023] 7 – 7.1 6 – 7
2. Regarding ‘Impugned Order’ 8 8 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1057Kalpataru P ower T ransmission Ltd. (Now Known as Kalpataru P rojects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc.
3. Arguments of the contractor 9 – 9.3 8 – 10
4. Arguments of the landowners 9.4 – 10 11
5. Discussion 11 – 20 11 – 20
6. Re-right of appeal 21 – 35 21 – 32
7. Need for uniformity in nomenclature of cases 36 32
8. Relief on merits 37 – 37.1 32 – 33
9. Directions 38 – 39 33
1. Leave granted.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2. The present judgment shall dispose of a batch of appeals arising out of a common judgment dated 24.02.2023 passed by the High Court 1 whereby a bunch of nine matters2 were decided. The landowners before this Court are seeking further enhancement of compensation on account of damages suffered by erection of transmission lines and towers, whereas the Contractor is before this Court, challenging the amount of compensation awarded.
3. Briefly, basic facts of the case as are evident from the record are that Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited (hereinafter, “HVPNL”), a public company owned by the State Government initiated a power transmission project, titled “400 KV Jhajjar Power Transmission System-PPP-1,” by issuing a Request for Quotation (RFQ) on 13.01.2009. Jhajjar KT Transco Private Limited (hereinafter, “JKTPL”) was selected as the lowest bidder for the transmission project and was awarded the project under an Agreement dated 28.05.2010. Subsequently, JKTPL entered into a sub-contract for erection, commissioning & other services with Kalpataru Power 1 High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh.
2 CWP No. 21878 of 2017; CWP No. 26406 of 2017; CR-3502-2017; CR-3503-2017; CR-1280-2020; CR-2873-2021; CWP No. 9495 of 2017; CR-3830-2017; CWP No. 28570 of 2017. 1058 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Transmission Ltd. on 29.10.2010, the present appellant in some of the appeals.
3.1 As is evident from the aforesaid contract executed between the JKTPL and Kalpataru Power Transmission Ltd., total length of transmission line is 100 km. The details thereof are as under: • Jharli (Jhajjar) - Kabulpur (Rohtak) 400 KV D/C line (Length: 35 km).
• Kabulpur (Rohtak) - Dipalpur (Sonepat) 400 KV D/C line (Length: 64 km).
• Loop-in-Loop-out (LILO) of one circuit of Abdallapur - Bawana 400 KV D/C line at Dipalpur (Sonipat)
(Length: 1 km).
3.2 The transmission line has passed through 4 districts in different villages as is mentioned in the public notice dated 12.07.2010.3 The districts are Bhiwani, Jhajjar, Rohtak and Sonepat. The issue arose regarding compensation to which the landowners may be entitled to for the damages suffered on account of erection of towers and drawing the power lines. The fact remains that ownership of land is not transferred.
4. As there are certain glaring errors in the judgment of the High Court deciding bunch of petitions pertaining to land falling in different districts, to put the record straight we wish to narrate brief facts of all the appeals.
Civil Appeal No(s).10882-10888 of 2025 (@SLP (C) No(s). 14936- 14942/2023)
5. These appeals arise out of common judgment of the High Court wherein challenge was made to different judgments and decrees passed by the Ld. Additional District Judge, Sonepat in 3 different applications filed by landowners under Section 16(3) of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885.4 These three applications were registered as Civil Suits bearing CIS No. CS/5/2016, titled as “Tara Chand and Ors. versus Kalpa-Taru and Ors.”, CIS No. CS/6/2016 titled as “Vinod 3 Available in the record of the Trial Court in CS No. 6 of 2017 at page 267. 4 Hereinafter referred to as “the 1885 Act”.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1059Kalpataru P ower T ransmission Ltd. (Now Known as Kalpataru P rojects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc. and Another versus Kalpa-Taru and Ors.” and CIS No. CS/7/2016 titled as “Pramod Kumar etc. versus Ministry of Power etc.”. The Ld. Additional District Judge, Sonepat awarded compensation @ 85% of collector rate i.e., ₹85,00,000/- per acre along with interest @ 8%, for the tower base area (land beneath the four legs of the tower). 5.1 Both the parties being aggrieved by the judgment and decree of the Trial Court, challenged the same before the High Court. Two Civil Writ Petitions were filed by the landowners under Article 226 of the Constitution of India (CWP-9495-2017 and CWP-21878-2017) seeking enhancement of compensation.
Whereas the contractor filed three Civil Revision Petitions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India (CR-3502-2017, CR-3503-2017 and CR-3830-2017). Two Civil Writ Petitions (CWP-26406-2017 and CWP-28570-2017) were filed by HVPNL, Panipat challenging the quantum of compensation awarded.
Civil Appeal No(s). 10891-10892 of 2025 (SLP (C) No.18246- 18247 of 2025)
6. The aforesaid appeals have been filed against the judgment of the High Court in CWP-21878-2017 and CWP-9495-2017 and the same judgment is under challenged in Civil Appeals arising out of S.L.P.(C) No.14936/2023 and 14940/2023 (@ S.L.P.(C) Nos.14936-14942 of 2023) seeking further enhancement of the compensation awarded. The land pertains to the District Sonepat.
6.1 Since the parties in the aforesaid appeals are common and are being represented, we do not consider it appropriate to issue formal notice in these appeals and the same are being disposed of along with the bunch of appeals.
Civil Appeal No(s).10889-10890 of 2025 (@SLP (C) No. 14926- 14927/2023)
7. Challenge in present appeals is also to the same common judgment of the High Court dated 24.02.2023. Land involved forms part of district Jhajjar. Before the High Court, two Civil Revision Petitions bearing CR-1280-2020 and CR-2873-2021 were filed by the contractor and the landowner, respectively. The issue again pertained to assessment of fair compensation on account of utilization of land owned by 1060 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the landowners for erection of tower or drawing power lines. An application was filed by the landowner under Section 16(3) of the 1885 Act bearing CM No. 516 of 2013 titled “Rati Ram versus State of Haryana and Ors.” before the Additional District Judge, Jhajjar. The Trial Court initially vide order dated 07.11.2016 awarded total compensation of ₹30,00,000/- under various heads. The aforesaid order was challenged by the contractor before the High Court by filing CR No. 3420 of 2017. The High Court vide order dated 19.08.2019 set aside the order of the Trial Court and remanded the case back for determination of compensation afresh. On remand, the Trial Court vide order dated 20.12.2019 assessed the total compensation at ₹26,12,000/- to be paid along with interest @ 18% per annum from April 2011 till realization. The compensation was awarded under various heads.
7.1 The order passed by the Trial Court in CM No. 516 of 2013 seems to be erroneous on the face of it. In paragraph 6 of the order, documentary evidence led by the landowners has been referred to. There are five exhibits and three documents which have been marked. In paragraph 18 of the order passed by the Trial Court, reference has been made to Exhibits P-5 to P-8 as sale deeds, which are not mentioned in paragraph 6 as such. Further Exhibit P-5 is stated to be an attested copy of the Notice dated 07.12.2011 of HVPNL. Further, the manner in which the compensation has been assessed cannot be made out. The High Court has failed to notice this aspect of the matter.
REGARDING IMPUGNED ORDER
8. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgments/orders of the Trial Court, at Sonepat and Jhajjar both parties filed petitions before the High Court. While deciding the bunch of petitions, the High Court noticed the facts pertaining to land in district Sonepat only and assessed the compensation in all cases. The facts pertaining to district Jhajjar were not even touched. May be counsels did not argue. A uniform compensation @ 85% of the collector rate beneath the tower area, which was determined at ₹1.50 crores per acre was awarded to the landowners. Besides this, for diminishing the value of land across the width of Right of Way (ROW), 15% of the value of land was awarded as compensation. It was on account of imposition of restrictions on utilization thereof.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1061Kalpataru P ower T ransmission Ltd. (Now Known as Kalpataru P rojects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc.
ARGUMENTS OF THE CONTRACTOR
9. Mr. Nidhesh Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the Contractor challenged the judgment of the High Court, whereby the damages payable to the landowners were further enhanced. He submitted that there was no basis for assessment of huge compensation on account of use of the land for erection of towers and drawing of the power lines. The area beneath the transmission lines could be utilized by the landowners, however, subject to certain restrictions. The ownership of the land is not transferred. Section 10 of the 1885 Act authorizes the authority concerned to erect towers and draw power lines, for which only right to use is acquired, warranting compensation to that extent only. The assessment of compensation by the Additional District Judge, Sonepat, which was further enhanced by the High Court, was totally on erroneous grounds and without any basis. Some studies related to effects of electromagnetic waves on the yield of crops, which may be available on internet, have been relied upon by the Additional District Judge, Sonepat, which in fact, have no basis and was not even confronted to any of the parties, before the same were relied upon. It was not even the case of the landowners as the same was not part of the evidence led. 9.1 It was further argued that the towers were erected and the power lines were drawn, running into about 100 kms falling in Jhajjar, Sonipat and other districts. In the case in hand, the value of land was equivalized for the stretch of the land passing under the transmission lines falling in different districts, regardless of the fact whether the towers and lines were situated close to some National Highway or State Highways or running through agricultural areas having no road connectivity as such. Thus, the assessment of compensation at uniform rate for the entire land cannot be legally justified.
9.2 Reliance on the guidelines issued by the Ministry of Power, Government of India bearing No.3/7/2015-Trans (“MOP Guidelines”) dated 15.10.2015 is totally misplaced in these cases for the reason that these were issued much after the transmission line in question had already been drawn and further these were required to be adopted by the concerned State/UTs. It is the case of State of Haryana, that the aforesaid guidelines had not been adopted, hence, invocation of those 1062 [2025] 8 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports guidelines for the purpose of assessment of compensation was totally uncalled for.
9.3 In support of the argument, reliance was placed upon judgments of this Court in Janardhan Reddy and others vs. State,5 The Kerala State Electricity Board, Trivandrum vs. T.P. Kunhaliumma6 and Suhas H. Pophale vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited and Its Estate Officer. 7
ARGUMENTS OF THE LANDOWNERS
9.4 On the other hand, learned counsel for the landowners submitted that there is no error in the assessment of compensation by the High Court on account of damages suffered by them. Hence, the appeals filed by the contractor deserve to be dismissed. As far as the appeals filed by the landowners are concerned, the compensation awarded by the High Court, deserves to be enhanced further. For the land beneath the legs of the towers, the landowners are entitled to 100% compensation and not @ 85% of the value of the land since such area is rendered completely non-utilizable. Further, even for the land areas falling under the overhead power lines (Right of Way Corridor), lot of restrictions are imposed on the use of land, hence, compensation on that account also deserves to be enhanced.
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the relevant records.
DISCUSSION
11. The facts of the cases in brief have already been referred to in paragraph 3 to 7 of the judgment, hence, are not being repeated. The land was acquired for execution of the project titled, “400 KV Jhajjar Power Transmission System-PPP-1”. Transmission line has the total length of 100 km passing through four districts, namely, Jhajjar, Rohtak, Bhiwani and Sonepat. We have matters before this Court pertaining to portions of the land utilized for the project which fall in districts Sonepat and Jhajjar. The first error committed
5 1950 INSC 37 : AIR 1951 SC 124
6 1976 INSC 272 : AIR 1977 SC 282.
7 2014 INSC 92 : AIR 2014 SC 1509.
[2025] 8 S.C.R. 1063Kalpataru P ower T ransmission Ltd. (Now Known as Kalpataru P rojects International Ltd.) v. Vinod and Ors. Etc. by the High Court, which is apparent on the face of it is that cases pertaining to areas falling in two different districts have been decided by a common judgment while referring to the material with reference to district Sonepat only.
12. Another error committed by the High Court in the impugned judgment is that the matter was dealt with as if it was a writ petition filed on the original side dealing with an issue raised for the first time. Rather, challenge before the High Court in the writ petition filed under Article 226 and some petitions filed under Article 227 was to the judgments of the Trial Court, which were delivered on appreciation of evidence. The High Court, merely on the basis of pleadings in the High Court stating that the same has not been denied, has recorded findings.
13. A perusal of the impugned judgment reveals that the High Court solely and heavily relied on the findings of the Trial Court in the case of district Sonepat. The High Court while quoting paragraph 23 of the Trial Court’s judgment in Sonepat matter, observed that the contractor had installed towers and high-tension wires on the landowners’ land but had not paid any compensation for the land covered under the poles of the towers or for the diminution of value of such land, although some compensation was paid for damage to the crops at the time of erection. The Trial Court had opined that this action of erecting towers and high-tension wires without paying compensation for the land covered or its diminished value was in violation of Articles 21, 39A, and 41 of the Constitution of India.
14. The High Court noticed the location of the land, to be part of the National Capital Region and is stated to be situated merely 6 acres/ killas from the G.T. Road, in an area where land prices had already doubled. While holding that this was not a case of land acquisition stricto senso, but merely the right of way is taken, the High Court proceeded to examine the fair amount of compensation to which the landowners were entitled to. The Court relied on the guidelines issued by the Ministry of Power, Government of India on 15.10.2015. As far as the consent of the State was concerned, it was deemed to have been given since the State had not objected against the guidelines or submitted any representative comments against the same when these were circulated by the Ministry of Power to all the States/UTs.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.